M.L. Hill: 'It's about occupation'

Marc Lamont Hill, Peter Beinart and Alan Dershowitz debate tactics Hamas and Israel are employing in latest conflict.

[@Motivationalwave3000]

9 years ago wow

[@yancarpenter545]

My dislike of Dershowitz is growing by the second.

[@CheetaInsaaf]

***** Do what I said.

[@xlr8r2010]

I'm sure he will be devastated to hear that. Oh, Wait...he won't!

[@beachboy13600]

I hope by now its on the same level as mine.

[@jimreilly6933]

Mines could not grow any more !

[@tareknazzal6864]

How did Hamas initiate the war when Israel started this whole thing in 1948? Alan, go home mate. LOL

[@leonlevy468]

ياللهطيف He was referring to that specific war. And 1948 was a war initiated by several Arab countries not Israel يا شاطر. And even if hypothetically Israel did start that war that doesn't justify ANY rocket hamas launches at Israeli civilians with their goal to kill Jews. This like a 4 year old saying "But he started it" after he hits his friend in the face. سلام.

[@nobodyknows8847]

Dude learn some history Israel accepted the partition plan the Palestine side rejected and started a war with more 4 countries lol. Palestine should take responsibility on war they started, they try so hard to blame Israel for winning a war they started on them it just pathetic

[@nickpeacock1896]

@@nobodyknows8847 If I come into YOUR home and tell you I'm moving in and you have to accept MY rules.. If you disagree and I hit you in the head did I start it or did you?

[@nobodyknows8847]

@@nickpeacock1896 dude but learn some basic history Jews were always in the land for almost 4,000 years its actually the Romans, Ottomans and British that forced their rules resulting the almost destruction of the Jewish population in this land every time. If you think Jews just came from out of nowhere to land they don't realated to you are deeply wrong most of the Israelis today about 45% are from families who lived in this land for generations. And second let me remind you, the UN decided in 48 that both Palestinian and Jews have a historically right of a state on this land and decided on the partition plan. The jews accepted it while the Palestinian not only rejected they started a war with more 4 countries aiming to destroy once again the existence of the Jewish population in this land. So now you try to blame the results of the war on the side who accepted peace and won in an unfair war against 4 countries? If you start a war you suppose to be aware of the obvious results: Deaths, losing land, refugees, poverty and much more. Blaming the side you attacked for winning in an unfair war would not help to return time back.

[@nickpeacock1896]

@@nobodyknows8847 Not the same Jews. 4,000 years ago, it was a group of black and brown Jews based on bloodline. These were Russian based Jewish Converts. They never occupied the land and literally FORCED their way into what's now modern day Israel. And now YOURE defending a group of people who not only stole land, but continues to terrorize the original inhabitants who are fighting for whats theirs. That's sick.

[@thegtafanboy]

Apparently. Don Lemon doesn't like it when you say "occupation."

[@MIS315]

I wonder why

[@peterplantcity6099]

So CNN Firerd the guy in the Middle.

[@Mighty-ue7bt]

Good

[@enmn6001]

No that's racism

[@rosekk9101]

Respect for, Marc Lamont Hill! Such an honest, intelligent individual!

[@cheickfall7399]

Disgut at Alan.. Just a blatant liar, liar...

[@dr.ireneruminjo4346]

Another seller out--

[@lilbigbrow]

Can someone shut that old man up? Someone should teach him to shut up when others are talking since they were shut when he was talking..

[@christianpike6649]

You are a fool if you recognize Hamas as anything other than a radical terrorist organization. That man is 'interrupting' because he wants the American people watching to hear some truth from CNN for once

[@gabeg2434]

These are just further excuses. There is no choice but to engage these terrorists and kill them. They hide in areas of civilian populations to ensure civilian casualties and have revealed their strategy several times(look at MEMRI) along with using women and children as human shields. They want to fool people like you to think that they are poor, defenseless and not culpable by sacrificing themselves. This ideology is difficult for us to understand in the West and they(the terrorists like Hamas, Hezbollah) take advantage of this and your sympathy.Why don't you go visit them and tell them you sympathize with their plight and see how kind and defenseless they really are?

[@DeluxeOmaha]

Alan Dershowitz shame on you!

[@Hellblazer311]

Marc Lamont Hill is my new hero

[@300bushelcorn4]

You need to get out more.

[@joecasey7415]

How is it a war when you have one of the most powerful militaries on the planet against a people with no military.

[@JLDJR]

That’s about the only thing I ever heard Marc Hill say truthfully on CNN. And It got him fired🤔

[@monkeyb1820]

... a minumum of 28 Million African were enslaved in the Muslim Middle East. Since, at least, 80 percent of those captured by Muslim slave traders were calculated to have died before reaching the slave market, it is believed that the death toll from 1400 years of Arab and Muslim slave raids into Africa could have been as high as 112 Millions. When added to the number of those sold in the slave markets, the total number of African victims of the trans-Saharan and East African slave trade could be significantly higher than 140 Million people. -- John Allembillah Azumah, author of The Legacy of Arab-Islam in Africa: A Quest for Inter-religious Dialogue buckdance much?

[@buzwemkosi5346]

Marc Hill has been consistent.

[@BaalDavaR999]

That's gotta be hard to lie that consistently.

[@ngalahansel6066]

@@BaalDavaR999 makes you mad that he keeps telling the truth?

[@BaalDavaR999]

@@ngalahansel6066 what makes you think I'm mad? He can lie all he wants, it's a free country, and sheep like you can continue to believe him.

[@MrYusha]

Good for you CNN, Peter Beinhart and Marc Hill are a breath of fresh air on this issue in US media...

[@Just_logic]

Old man You have to stop interrupting as when you were talking everyone else was listening. That says one thing, you don’t want others the heat the other side of the story.

[@etmstMdg]

This Alan guy is a joke

[@sashafiers6617]

Mark lamont Hill LOVE HIM fear less........speak up

[@adelbelaifa5492]

As long as there is people who are JUST in this world, there won't be really something to worry about! Definetely the truth always prevail.

[@theviper123]

it is fucking funny when the powerful always have a boogey man in the right place to justify their war crimes...

[@choppermfg]

google Norman Finkelstein

[@DeepStateNewZik]

Exactly!

[@peterbuller3572]

choppermfg thanks for that tip. I did and found it very interesting.

[@JohnLemieux]

"Purely defensive war" All wars are defensive, for both sides.

[@clarkgriswold5903]

That is so dope!

[@St-lan]

peace only when Plestinwe has its own state ..

[@habebhussein1765]

Hill for president

[@mahissaad9552]

Alan is lier

[@yaonebenni4747]

Mr Hill, thank you

[@autorog1234]

Why does Dershowitz have air time? I will not watch another vid I know he is on.

[@autorog1234]

fuck u troll

[@autorog1234]

fuck u doesn't make sense? you sir are an idiot.

[@autorog1234]

quit being a fucking troll and go on with your life. ur mom is probably calling u in for dinner

[@autorog1234]

fuk urself.I have a Phd...don't start, just go away.

[@autorog1234]

ask your mother, she will point at you and remind you of the coat hanger scar on your forehead

[@ngalahansel6066]

Watching this in 2023 after both March and Don had long been fired from CNN and I can now understand how passions always run high when it comes to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. For the first time in my life, I understand the contentiousness of the issue and wish that both sides can soon find a common ground

[@kakman4549]

He is soo right this is a heated discussion and they cannot come to agreement. And just this short debate between 3 people. There will be NO peace in the middle east until Messiah comes. Both sides will not agree on a solution

[@peterplantcity6099]

Occupation

[@good-carma]

Where’s the Palestinian in this discussion? You need to include Hanna. Ashrawi or Noura Erakat or Ahmed Aldin or Omar Badder.

[@user-uj3ol8qt4o]

May the LORD give us right understanding, love of fellow humans, peace & progress. Let's avoid bias, sentiments or taking sides and look into roots of issues. Does anyone, races or groups HATE others, attacking, killing and wanting them WIPED OFF the planet? These should be soughted out & addressed, as they are obviously UNHEALTHY for humankind. Let's live & love together.

[@nicholascharles6254]

Don Lemmon hit the nail on the head there with his last comment

[@rosekk9101]

They created Hamas and keep crying Hamas after each of their terrorists acts towards the native Palestinians!

[@antrave]

0:53 dat sound. Imma sample it.

[@waiotahi52]

Bottom Line: This is happening because of the Israelis. Conversely, if NOT for the Israelis, this would not be happening.

[@nayeemrashid6089]

Hill, Respect for You.

[@abdulmaleksayed1485]

Allen is evasive when comes to Israel atrocities in Gaza.

[@jasoncole8607]

This was 9 years ago and not 2023 exactly the same excuses

[@elainewatson9421]

occupation

[@leorollo1895]

This Alan guy is pureeee evil

[@kakman4549]

If what is peter saying is correct they why is hamas firing rockets?

[@randybridges7365]

The protocols of the elders of Zion is the Truth!!!

[@Snapparazzi1]

"The USA must stand by israel to fight those terrorists" LOL what a joke

[@jordansalmond8483]

One must listen to the other! Not talk over them... that has been a human problem since the beginning and in relationship! One must listen to the other point of view! Then we can debate or courtiq it... also it does not make it law... it someone thoughts and then fact check the argument

[@MsCordially]

You guys should do a better job at SIMPLY discussing both sides viewpoints. Seems we never see any reports talking to those living on the edge of both sides, in the streets.

[@robloxkidvideos]

thanks for the laugh i enjoy the clip, talking at once

[@aegystierone8505]

I couldn't figure out what their talking about LOL

[@gerrybannon7394]

Aegys TierOne a

[@lilgarbagedisposal9141]

3:05

[@mpilombuyazi1411]

Western values in the middle east. The audacity of these colonisers.

[@yasinmohamed4708]

I hate CNN. Sick business. How do you sleep at night

[@hurleyOC]

Rockets found in UN schools? but but Palestinians say things like this doesn't happen though.

[@seth.g-fp6ej]

Marc Lamont hill love you my brother always, Got fired for speaking the truth against a racist ideology keep up the good work when he talks reminds me of brother Malcom x

[@tugreenaway9448]

Western values alright...colonialism

[@Mubisherk]

If you posted this 4 years ago, what makes him Anti Semitic today?

[@AveIvy]

What a mess!

[@kvniyer1]

The same guy is openly and sarcastically condemning the right wing government in india. He knows if he speaks against Israel he will lose his job.

[@user-wt2qc1xi2r]

Marc got fired from cnn. Imagine how bad you have to be.

[@juanvaladez5703]

CNN used to be so much better.

[@TeddiJane111]

God Bless Israel!

[@etmstMdg]

Lol the right to free speech....

[@elainewatson9421]

Blackade

[@videosonpoint]

WHAT A JOKE lol smh. This is why it's hard 4 me to watch Cable News a lot of times. Cuzz u don't get conversation or discussions on issues, u just get a bunch of arguments with ppl yelling over each other. Everybody walks away having gotten nothing from it, lol smh. Pathetic.

[@user-or6le4tu3w]

Oh God , how today resemble yesterday....said arabic idiom !

[@jetermoersdorf1011]

God Bless Israel

[@schowdhury8243]

🖕🇮🇱💩🖕

[@czargallo]

.... ..som

[@2274brian]

The PLO (Palestine Liberation Organization) formed in 1964. What Palestine were they wanting to liberate at that time? Gaza was part of Egypt at that time. The West Bank (including the old city of Jerusalem) was part of Jordan. The "occupation" did not occur until June 1967.

[@cuddifrom6]

Do cockroaches need glasses 👓

[@edwardpayne3967]

The only occupation was when muslims moved onto Israeli Jewish land in the Jewish absence, but it is easy to know it was not their land because they did not love the land ans they never did any improvement to Israel. When Israel returned they came to a desolate land and ruined cities, but the Jewish people rebuilt the cities and replenished the land and today Israel is like a eden. Even where muslims pals. are today they do nothing to improve their own situation, they sit and do nothing.

[@DeepStateNewZik]

Israel has been conducting terrorist false flag operations to establish the state of Israel. Operation Susannah Aka Lavon affair. Israel planted bombs in movie theaters, libraries and educational centers targeting british, egyptian and american civilians. The Egyptian government busted the Mossad terrorists and Lavon resigned as a result from the Israeli Mossad. The false flag operation was covered up for 4 decades and in 2006 the Israeli president publicly honored the mossad terrorists who planted the bombs with certificates of appreciation.

[@lindamandel6900]

Edward Payne high 5

[@YankubaSaidykhan-yf2id]

Alan is just another senseless liar .

[@mookjuice]

I love Dershowitz. He is unafraid and retorts with facts. We need more on the left like him. Marc Lamont hill actually cried in another segment because he knew he couldn't counter anything Dershowitz said.

[@wolflg]

he did counter, the other two made him change is point on occupation, if another state controls your state you are occuppied

[@mookjuice]

Londre Gilkey Semantics. He actually clarified what he meant later in the segment.

[@mattdillahunty7644]

Lol his eyes did water. You think he was crying because the Zionist was smacking him around?

[@mookjuice]

Matt Dillahunty yup.

[@Herb615]

Hill probably cried because seeing the suffering the Palestinian people is heartbreaking for any decent human being.

[@JustinKies]

Alan Dershoshitz

[@katherine101able]

This African American lad is quite pushy

[@enmn6001]

Yep.. that's good .he need to be extra pushy

[@janemueller653]

This didn’t age well for dershoshitz

[@doudoub2005]

the black guy gets so mad and oblivious lmao...he has no valid arguments

[@jamerican347]

db2005 think you mean Alan. Kept interrupting because his points cannot stand on their own.

[@crazycat5958]

Israel has three times offered a peace agreement and three times it was opposed.

[@jamesmorett6184]

You can offer terms that you KNOW will be totally unacceptable but you can strut and brag that you Made an offer and IT WAS TURNED DOWN Imagine that !!

[@FI32690]

Israel is in violation of international law.

[@lucycamo4664]

I'm black too, and as a black man we're not all for the Palestinians or the Democrats I and other true black people who know our history defend Israel and support Republican values...never forget who was first involved in black slavery. The Palestinians are not friends and democrats either My deepest support goes to Israel 🇮🇱 🙏🏽🇨🇩✡️ The only race and nation that has never offended black people And all respect to Abraham Lincoln

[@lrwsf1]

ROFL that you as a Black man are behind Israel. Another reason why you fuckers can’t get any respect

[@ngalahansel6066]

I am Black and I'd rather you speak for yourself.

[@lucycamo4664]

You asked for your personal opinion on the matter 👀

[@seth4954]

Dershowitz more correct than ever

[@FI32690]

Alan Dershowitz is a joke.

[@johnirqui6868]

Alan dershoaitz is a master lier too but that's his job.