Mafia Remake vs Mafia 3 Combat Comparison

Comparing the different forms of combat in Mafia Definitive Edition and Mafia 3.

[@DiggyT]

Mafia 3 had some of the most insane execution takedowns, it just boggles my mind there was never upgrades for 2 or even 3 person take down.

[@deniskasperovich8251]

The shooting in Mafia 3 is amazing

[@alkhoaja]

Yea is my favourite game to

[@user-jc2kf9bi6f]

Agreed

[@Killer7-]

Love both games, but Mafia Remake’s combat and weapon melee takedowns seem so… soft? If that makes sense. Like they lack impact or weight.

[@adri.rossio]

I thought the same

[@kyree4695]

I think it’s cause Lincoln was a trained soldier and Tommy is just a average joe

[@fortunateevil2]

Lincoln is a soldier, tommy is a cab driver

[@dominicstclairstudios6324]

​@@kyree4695 exactly

[@TJtheKnight]

Won't lie. Mafia definitive edition has the best graphics. The character models, resolution, detail, etc. It is an amazing game

[@atonix1219]

Rdr 2 beats it a bit

[@nahpimpin398]

​@@atonix1219He is talking in terms of the Mafia series..

[@johananj.j8003]

He is talking in this video's context.​@@atonix1219

[@xSpicySaltx]

For mafia 3 they had an MMA Fighter for the combat / animations

[@americangangster1911]

Yeah Kyle Kingsbury is his name, he talked about it a little bit on the Joe Rogan Experience.

[@irtvlcanicline1904]

Mafia DE - Better hand-to-hand combat with randoms Mafia 3 - Better and more brutal takedowns

[@gadgettherobotstudios6055]

Mafia 3 is probably one of my most favorite games ever, And I aint denying it :)

[@kainholden2001]

I kinda like how between both games you can tell both tommy and Lincoln have different ways of fighting like techniques and such. Tommy is just a regular man, no special training, no background of violence before joining with saleiri(at least none I know about) just a cabbie who joined a family and picked up some skill along the way Lincoln however is a former special forces soldier who fought in Nam, so he knows his way around an opponent. Plus Lincoln is obviously way more muscular than tommy so he is definitely gonna be hitting harder than tommy can

[@Billioncompany786]

It makes sense Lincoln Clay is a Vietnam war Veteran so giving Tommy his combat style would not work because that's style is Lincoln Clay Exclusive only.

[@Jaffet1990]

@3:16 the way he broke his neck with the butt of the gun sheesh

[@tobicrowther]

He didn't tho?

[@johnmarston1227]

Mafia Games Are Great : Detailed Characters , Deep Story telling , Solid Story , Detailed and living environment Just Awesome Can't imagine what Hanger 13 will do if given good engine, Big AAA games like budget and development time by 2k. As they said that game engine they are provided to work with is sh!t . And people out there are like " GTA is best, So much to do blah blah " it is a good game indeed but at least give props to Dev's for trying their best and keeping Mafia series alive. They deserve better than this

[@satrangiman9046]

❤️❤️

[@venomsnake9975]

Finally

[@juanstfu9021]

Well said friend🤘🏽

[@GaganDeep-lm8zr]

Mafia 2>gta sanandreas

[@mohammedyassine9263]

I only wish they do godfather remake from ps2

[@americangangster1911]

Yeah that would be awesome.

[@melxb]

that and true crime needs to return as well

[@markpoland5748]

Now your talking and why has no one picked up on that. Or a proper scarface overhaul as in complete..

[@imembridibuddha]

So enemies DID flinch in Mafia 3, and not in Mafia Remake (or at least much less frequently than in 3) Hangar 13 WTH?!

[@reasonjefferey4644]

I Cazzi di Buddha have you seen Lincoln he is literally built like a 200 pound a super heavy weight MMA fighter. It’s unrealistic to me that enemies don’t just fall out pass out from one punch from him. Tommy is just a normal dude.

[@coments101]

Tommy wasn't a 230 pound Vietnam Vet with a big ass knife he was just an average Joe cab driver with either a pocket knife or a bat. I do feel like the Mafia remake should've been better though.

[@imembridibuddha]

@@coments101 I meant how enemies reacted to bullets, not punches. For the remake, they prioritized hitmarkers over animations as hit feedback, and made enemies more bulletsponge.

[@idekbruh753]

@@imembridibuddha it depends on the difficulty if you play on normal/easy (I think even on hard too) you get all those flinching animations

[@grasshopper0274]

@@imembridibuddha its to save money

[@Joseph-wh5of]

Lincoln is a fucking tank. He hits like a monster truck.

[@samiaberkan3474]

Mafia lll best combat Mafia remeske best graphics

[@ajax3748]

Mafia remake best story and characters as well

[@EduardoSalamanca1960]

@@ajax3748 mafia 2 has the best characters

[@alkhoaja]

Mafia III has the best characters

[@denimschaffer9439]

Mafia remake: best graphics and protagonist ( that might be controversial but don’t get me wrong Vito is a fantastic character but I honestly think Tommy was the better developed character and most relatable) Mafia 2: best story and characters Mafia 3: best gameplay and music

[@epicphantom40]

Both games are good

[@ajax3748]

No mafia 3 is repetitive bullshit

[@el_cucino]

@@ajax3748 true it killed the series

[@SlyCooper1920]

Epic phantom, LIAR!!

[@epicphantom40]

@@SlyCooper1920 nope

[@SlyCooper1920]

@@epicphantom40 don't bullshit me Phantom, Mafia 3's gameplay was repetitive

[@choloturf2923]

Lincoln clay + victor Vance Tommy Angelo + Toni cipriani Gta vcs + mafia 3 Gta lcs + mafia definitive edition

[@H.K.5]

The combat is more or less the same in both games, they just have different moves.

[@alkhoaja]

4:14 how you do that stealth kill in ps4 I need to do that

[@xaedeo6549]

Okay hear me out I think that mafia 3 open world is way more fun to explore both games stories are amazing while mafia 3 does fall back graphically compared to mafia 1 remake ... I think that both games are fun in there own ways .

[@americangangster1911]

Yeah I actually enjoyed taking down all the different types of rackets in Mafia 3. There were a lot of crazy rackets like the underground drug and sex partys, the body disposal labs, the drug factories, the slave trading in the super market, it was fun wiping those places out. I think the racket idea was inspired by the Godfather games but a lot of people complained that it made the game feel non linear. There should have been a separate mode where you could skip them if you wanted.

[@xaedeo6549]

@@americangangster1911 I agree

[@arindammishra2329]

@@americangangster1911 I really love mafia 3 I don't know why people hate mafia 3 I know it has some limitations compared to mafia 2 but still it is a good game

[@americangangster1911]

Yeah it just lacked certain details and probably would have been more well liked if it was just a linear story like Mafia 2. If they would have just focused on the main story missions then they might have had more time to polish the game but I think they really wanted those side missions because it worked for the godfather game.

[@jerelljoshua9185]

The takedown and combat system is the same but has different camera angles and fighting type

[@GreeKurdChannelMilan]

There is a problem with the lightning in Mafia 3, They need to fix it.

[@americangangster1911]

They never will.

[@GreeKurdChannelMilan]

@@americangangster1911 Why is that?

[@americangangster1911]

If they didn't fix it for the Definitive Edition then they never will.

[@GreeKurdChannelMilan]

@@americangangster1911 They could make patch updates

[@americangangster1911]

Yeah they could but there would be no incentive for them to fix it. The window of opportunity has already passed, the game was released in 2016 and then rereleased in 2020 and they didn't fix anything, same with Mafia 2 Definitive edition, they didn't fix any glitches in the 11 years it's been out.

[@hade5v]

Nice video and i like mafia Remake but the problem is the engine of Mafia Remake is same the Mafia 3 engine and physics . So The different thing is the world and the Characters

[@TheACTIONZ]

Yes but mafia remake isnt that buggy

[@grasshopper0274]

its same and reduced at the same time

[@amirabbasmaslehatjoo6898]

They are like 90% similar...but lincoln is bigger 😄

[@alkhoaja]

Lincoln Clay is the best

[@adriancapito8419]

Shooting and combat in Mafia 3 is way better than Mafia remake.

[@robloxlover1363]

Lincoln might be strong but tommy has the power of hitting 2 guys with one punch 0:42

[@ruggedrider7]

Mafia 3 is better

[@alkhoaja]

Yea

[@Nostalgic_Gaming_]

1:59 they were passing out ass slaps

[@hassanhafeez8]

man i was not able to choose between mafia remake and mafia 3 so i finally baught mafia remake now i regret it

[@americangangster1911]

Yeah I can understand that but on the bright side you still have Mafia 3 to look forward to in the future.

[@kingovhell6]

Mafia remake is a lot better than 3

[@pubgmallus2686]

@@kingovhell6 there is nothing much to do and the open world is empty.. I am kinda disappointed playing this game after mafia 3

[@warriorgt7gr222]

Mafia 3 combat is more visceral

[@Jupiter-vt2kj]

Mafia 3 fight: 🗣️

[@qworuxhjamdhs2199]

0:47 He wait 😁

[@lawrencesantiago8649]

Mafia remake feels like a real mafia game while mafia 3 only feels like a generic crime simulator. The only reason mafia 3 was a "mafia" game is because of vito. Both games are good but the mafia remake is just way better in terms of story and characters.

[@americangangster1911]

Yeah I kind of agree but I'm glad they made Mafia 3, you gotta love the 1960s, the vietnam era weapons, the cars, the music, there was a lot of cool things about that game.

[@nomercy6685]

@@americangangster1911 agree, I feel like Mafia 3 is kinda underappriciated

[@offthatmuscle8214]

Hey you guys making me feel bad 😢 mafia 3 was my first mafia game and I love it 😂

[@nomercy6685]

@@offthatmuscle8214 Mine was Mafia II, but I definetely enjoyed the third one too... Btw I just beat Mafia Definitive Edition few days ago and it was great too, definetely recomend, if u haven't played it yet.

[@ajax3748]

We well actually theres multiple different mafias or mobs. The black mob which is what lincoln was a part of,Italian mob,irish mob,london mob,and many more

[@nickjones4851]

Huge fan of mafia games my favorite mafia defitivine edition best game ever mafia 2 best Game ever mafia 3 not bad game when will be make mafia 4 when coming out mafia 4 realsed date of mafia 4 more videos of this game this days please make more videos of this game this days please answer question news and wishlist information ideas please

[@ashmacole]

do you know what full stops are?

[@onemoreday9453]

@@ashmacole fr lmaoo

[@peas6429]

@@ashmacole 😂😂

[@luca_magna7753]

@@ashmacole I get that English isn't many people's first language but they could at least understand simple things even if they can't spell or something

[@qx4n9e1xp]

The music effects in Mafia 3 are so annoying. I hate it when they make games/movies overly action-y with uneeded effects. Just let the choreography do the work.

[@morgan0__o]

the ones in mafia remake were more annoying

[@adriancapito8419]

no

[@bruh8701]

Mafia remake kinda reminds me of Mafia 2

[@jimmynucklehead3070]

Wait really why

[@samiaberkan3474]

Me too

[@gumaryae]

Naw.. nothing is like Mafia one. Matter of fact there is no open world game with a story even close as Mafia one

[@Rognvaldr]

Mafia remake better.

[@tg.cartier]

@@noelcapito9040 right

[@Firewertyhn6817]

in Mafia 3 exist fighting cages??

[@americangangster1911]

Just in one mission.

[@23babychopppa44]

Mafia 3 better

[@Jupiter-vt2kj]

I call it bug3

[@ajax3748]

Its repetitive bullshit

[@jimmysalome7372]

Mafia 3 ps4 se de labonbe

[@mr.amangeldiyev]

Mafia 3 so bugged and bored

[@alkhoaja]

bruh is so good to but mafia to

[@SirTootsAlot]

So now they've ruined a classic. Ugh

[@americangangster1911]

Nah it still exists

[@talpatv512]

Only if you are a nostalgic fart, sure

[@jackyourmotherisapussyassc8565]

All they have to do is add more stuff to free ride and it will be much better than the original