Magic: The Gathering Except the Rules Keep Changing

[@CardmarketMagic]

Decklists: bit.ly/44j3JO2

[@matteorossi1172]

Magic the gathering, but it's a Magic the Noah google slides game video

[@rumad-_-bro2062]

@@matteorossi1172 Mountain, you.

[@matteorossi1172]

@@rumad-_-bro2062 turn one hallowed fountain, untapped, with only 6 drops in hand, you

[@TheCommandSphere]

with "glare of heresy" The goat token was white so he didn't have to kill his own creature

[@Kristjan0209]

​@@TheCommandSpherehad the same thought

[@matt5g]

The card market boys played with Noah and realized the infinite potential that was in chaos

[@Aaackermann]

Ah, Noah! Pft! THIS is how it is done!!

[@CardmarketMagic]

The vibe of this video is meant to be "MTG Noah minus the Powerpoint"

[@theblakwarior]

@@CardmarketMagic I can see it now. Next video is gonna feature carl just casually rolling in 5 different actual physical wheel of fortunes.

[@matt5g]

@@CardmarketMagic that would make sense

[@moocow17]

@@CardmarketMagic we need more of these. these stupid fun videos. this is mtg but make a stupid deck vs a meta deck and give good stuff to the stupid deck

[@soasertsus]

I almost spat out my drink when Thoralf asked if the punishment goes on the stack 😂

[@jmbw4271]

Without skipping a beat too

[@BaronSengir1008]

It's a valid question...

[@Bobal27]

@@BaronSengir1008You said “It’s.” Do twenty mental pushups.

[@BaronSengir1008]

@@Bobal27 No, because I was not in the duel so the restriction on words doesn't apply to me...

[@Bobal27]

@@BaronSengir1008 How lazy can you be to not imagine 20 push-ups? You can’t say you’ll pass on that.

[@jacobbrj]

Tofer said "not a blue deck" and didn't get his punishment. He said it a little before 4:18.

[@HopfenMalzify]

came here for that.

[@Worm.emergency]

Bluedeck just feels like 1 word at this point

[@lequinow]

Narc.

[@NamelessFacelessWhoa]

They also changed one of the keywords from scared to afraid

[@RoderickEtheria]

From afraid to scared

[@DKforever24]

Jamin forgot Thoralf still had a goat token, which could have been exiled by the Glare of Heresy instead of the Fabled Hero he just got. The game could have ended differently.

[@BaronSengir1008]

Judge! Minotaur Skullcleaver gets the +2/+0, not one of your other creatures!

[@S3iF3]

He also said „deck“ right before the „beat“, but I imagine it’s pretty difficult to keep track of these words😅

[@BaronSengir1008]

@@S3iF3 Yes, but other people have mentioned that...

[@MegaBengland]

That's a game loss

[@goshdarnitthatsalongname5349]

i was about to say...

[@Xavi_Shado]

I absolutely agree, this is the best game of MTG I have ever watched. Can you please do this again?

[@CardmarketMagic]

Glad you enjoyed it! :D and... that top hat was expensive, might as well use it again ;)

[@SpizzyRich]

Next time somebody needs to have cards from an Un-set. Maybe the Mad Hatter add them to the game, maybe the Players have them in their decks. Either way, somebody needs to play the card "Charm School".

[@ButzPuff]

​@@CardmarketMagicIt would be amazing to for a special Commander game with this same set up and enough punishments for 4 players.

[@TehKorwinMikke]

@@SpizzyRich The idea of an un-set is much more interesting than the un-sets are in reality. It's much better to keep to tournament-legal MtG cards, than to look for the incredibly few actually interesting un-cards.

[@apark633]

Thoralf is a comedic genius 1:05 "I should have said hare" 🤣🤣🤣

[@Videodude810]

At 7:06 "Scared" turns into "Afraid" ... just in time for Jamin at 7:40.

[@oafkad]

True chaos

[@CardmarketMagic]

I wrote above the text in the video that I changed it because I make the rules 😎 but really it's because I forgot if I had said scared or afraid in the beginning so I just went with both 🤫

[@Videodude810]

@@CardmarketMagic Yeah...O.o .... I bet Carl.... o.O ... I'm watchin' youuu.... O.O

[@MP_Indy]

@@Videodude810 Scrolled down here to say this cause I actually remembered what was said at the beginning! Sorry, listening to the video while drafting on Arena :)

[@HeartOfStone.]

I love whenever someone screws up and says a no-no word, Carl comes in with a crazed face looking like a full on trickster god

[@ajpbrunet]

Turns out Carl has *incredible* trickster god energy on top of impeccable fashion sense

[@SpizzyRich]

All the more messed up that these two are English Second Language players. Mad props to our German boys for stepping up to a vocab challenge.

[@Thorg42]

From the thumbnail, to the intro, to the ominous cuts, wheeling in and out on the chair, eye contact, ALL of it. Thanks. I can only hope you guys got to enjoy this as much as your audience has

[@CardmarketMagic]

I'm thrilled you enjoyed it :) and yes, we have an incredible amount of fun doing these

[@BaronSengir1008]

@@CardmarketMagic If you don't have fun doing your job, are you even doing your job?

[@ylktr]

I laughed out loud every time Carl scooted in on his chair.

[@AAIIYAAA]

This is one of the greatest magic exhibitions I have ever seen. Please turn it into a series!

[@Ryadic]

I'm not even 2 and a half minutes into it and I want more of this content. Carl creating machinations that the others have no clue about.

[@wayanc1880]

PLEASE do more of these. This is PERFECT

[@DerDarkfire1]

One of the best videos I watched this entire year. Such great dynamic, great people and a really fun concept!

[@daemonxblaze]

I would actually like more of this

[@heitortremor]

This channel's videos are always so full of creativity and authenticity!

[@CardmarketMagic]

That's really kind of you to say :D

[@ThankYouForTheVideos]

I want so many more of games like these, I love the chaotic energy! I would also love if you banned EVEN MORE words!!

[@Romashka_Sov]

4:10 Thoralf says "I'm not the blue *deck*"

[@comlitbeta7532]

I see that you're putting in good use what you learned from magic the noa

[@CardmarketMagic]

The whole point of this video was: "Magic the Noah but without PowerPoint"

[@AllTop507]

7:07 scared changes to afraid

[@Buhlaine]

Y'all make the best non-commander magic stuff on KZbin. Love to see it.

[@CardmarketMagic]

That's really kind of you to say :) thank you

[@roynicorn8361]

Well this must become a series, there is so many pre-cons you could do this with. Also I am sure this goes even more insane in Commander with 4 players... ^^

[@_____kb]

This one was really fun. Carl majestically rolling in to deliver a bizarre punishment was hilarious every time.

[@GawdDaeme]

This is so stupid and random and absolutely freakin awesome! Really enjoy the Videos you guys put out, always entertaining

[@CardmarketMagic]

I'm happy you enjoyed it :)

[@kellan-williams]

Carl & Noah really need to do a collab. I NEED THIS IN MY LIFE!!!

[@CardmarketMagic]

We've already been on Noah's channel a few times :) I even asked him permission to do this video because it was so Noah inspired

[@aprofessionalcitizen9030]

I enjoyed this more than any other magic content I've seen in months. I'm sure it was a lot of work prepping all this, but it's not unnoticed! Keep it up mates

[@michelezino7528]

I love you guyz!😂 Met Carl at the Papupergeddon was an honor.. you dude are really kind, a real homie! Keep going with these veeeedeos

[@CardmarketMagic]

Happy you enjoyed the veedeeeo 🥳 I can't tell who you were from your icon just being an M, but it was probably also really cool meeting you at Paupergeddon! That event was so much fun :)

[@cameronp6176]

This is truly incredible. Please do more chaos like this.

[@TheFvsdg]

This is halarious! I love when y'all bring this kind of playful energy.

[@jamesaditya5254]

This absolutely is the best magic I've ever watched. This would also work amazing for livestreams or events with audience participation and maybe gamemaster's veto

[@Narakiomal]

SOMEHOW more chaotic than Crim's 4Player Chaos Commander decks from last time XD

[@GumballMachinery]

That was the most chaotic and wonderful game of Magic I've ever witnessed!! 😂

[@hayden32040]

You guys are so good, and keeping 60 card content alive!

[@nathanielreichley4640]

I was screaming at the screen "Glare of Heresy the Goat!!" Hahahah what a great game

[@CardmarketMagic]

The game was chaotic enough that I think we should forgive Jamin for missing that the goat was white 😅

[@ReederMG]

More of this please! It was great fun. Carl has the best devotion to content

[@bryanbiscoll5519]

This was a blast to watch. A little bit of this every now and again would be a welcome addition to the regular rotation.

[@dasvenson765]

I love that you guys remember it's a game and just do whacky stuff for the fun of it. So many people get so emotionally attached to games.

[@manadorkuk]

This whole video could be called "and in rolled Carl"

[@brokensprites]

Such a silly but chaotic match. Opening the packs to interact was just epic. Great idea, lots of fun.

[@CardmarketMagic]

Glad you enjoyed it! :)

[@namidairo1573]

this was amazing i loved it. hope this becomes slightly more common as it is very fun to watch

[@nickivany2116]

I love cardmarket-magic

[@SeraphArc]

This was actually amazing. Would love to see more like it!

[@galahadpedro6416]

You guys are awesome, trully. I've been watching all your videos while working and have already sent to some magic friends who also liked a lot. Greetings from Brasil, keep the creative and awesome job.

[@jokersjacket3174]

The amount if wholesome chaos in this video is absolutely wonderful. Definitely am asking for more of this!!! Just dont spoil us with it too much lmao

[@toxicbuffalo2269]

I loved this, Carl could definitely use this video to catch them with new words and new punishments. I would love to see more of these

[@deschamos7599]

Great job on the variety of videos. It's impressive how clever these topics are. This variant looks like it'd be pretty fun to play as a party mode style!

[@CardmarketMagic]

Thank you :) that's very kind of you to say!

[@SwedeRacerDC]

This video was entertaining. I could definitely see this happening with other sets. What a goofy way to play! Frog hat and tokens of themselves showing up were some nice little twists

[@z-mashupz8069]

Would love more of these, this was super entertaining.

[@imcreatingthisjusttocomment]

Shoutout to 7:05 when the banned word "Scared" changes to "Afraid" out of nowhere lmao-- I CAUGHT THAT

[@ryanburris8590]

This was amazing do more please! And your chair rolling was fantastic btw

[@umbraloctavia5349]

13:00 He could have targeted the goat token with glare instead of his creature.

[@vhungria6614]

This was an awesome video!! I need more!!!! You guys are great! Love your content. No joke, this and chaos commander were both very entertaining.

[@Verlisify]

He should have missed timing on guessing the card in hand from activating the punishment

[@junebyrd]

I would *love* to see more of these! Maybe duel decks could be used as well? I could see a cruel world where a punishment is swapping to a planeswalker deck.

[@corbenmurphy1807]

This was the best episode ever! I haven't laughed at MTG content in so long, and there was so much genuine joy on everyone's faces throughout the game. I can only imagine how much fun the 3 of you had. Please keep enjoying yourselves while making some of the best MTG content on KZbin and congrats on 100k subs :)

[@CardmarketMagic]

Thank you for noticing our sub milestone :D I'm thrilled that you enjoy our shenanigans

[@Haurent]

This was actually pretty fun to watch. The chaos in this match was beautiful

[@shieldgenerator7]

7:07 sneaky sneaky, silently changing "scared" to "afraid" like that

[@TheCommandSphere]

with "glare of heresy" The goat token was white so he didn't have to kill his own creature

[@naruyashan]

This was amazing! Would love to see more like it.

[@teadeity363]

This is easily the best Magic channel on KZbin imo. I think it'd be really cool to see some Thoralf MTG Arena livestreams

[@bricelory9534]

I really do think this is the spirit in which Magic was created originally - very fun! Thanks for the creative video!

[@jasons9895]

please do this again, it's too funny, I love these types of videos

[@Aikon94]

I don't get how can you come up with so many fun ideas for videos, without a doubt the best mtg channel.

[@alexhayward2415]

I love theros, my first block and set that got me into the game. So many memories and a great start for many players due to the power level

[@austinturgoose]

Congrats on 100k! Been following since around 15k. Easily one of my favorite content creators in the community

[@CardmarketMagic]

Thank you for noticing :D and for being around for so long! It's truly appreciated!

[@killpioo2]

Please do more of these. This was so entertaining

[@prashanttewari]

Banger video as always. Great concept as well. Will definitely see more of these from time to time 👍

[@FranzBeckenboden]

what an absolut fever dream of a match. Great Work!

[@Neoflamme]

I love that the Thoralf Tolken has reach

[@CardmarketMagic]

We all just sat at a restaurant, laughing really hard at this comment

[@Colafarr]

@@CardmarketMagic Did not Seem like thoralf found it funny, can u confirm?

[@CardmarketMagic]

@Colafarr Carl here. Thoralf didn't notice the reach thing in the video at the time (neither did I when making it) because we don't talk about his height a lot. Not because it's taboo, just because he's our friend and it's just not an aspect of our friend that comes up very often. It's only weird people on the internet that bring it up, which he provably doesn't see because he doesn't often read comments. But I promise you his height is something he takes rather lightheartedly, and he's the one who usually makes jokes about it :) thoralf has nothing to be bullied about (except for his complete lack of understanding of commander 😅)

[@jaredoxley9693]

This just brings back good memories of playing "magic" with my friends at show choir competitions in high school. Up until another friend of ours was like you are doing it all wrong.

[@CardmarketMagic]

That other friend of yours is the one who was doing it all wrong 🤠

[@highroller5335]

The twists the turns Also everyone is smiling i love it!

[@Obversechaos]

These people are wonderful. I love everything they do.

[@JohnMurphy-zl6nj]

the joy in this video is unreal

[@jessegraves8321]

I'd love to see more matches like this.

[@war2theren227]

This video was fantastic, would love to see it played again with different people. I want to see Carl go through this

[@bchap5429]

That was so fun to watch! Please do this again sometime with a different set. Preferably War of the Spark

[@StijnHommes]

This is hilarious! Would love to see more games like this.

[@TheRealGrimpaw]

This is just next level fun. And the best part of it you guys seem to have a lot of fun which is contageous.

[@CardmarketMagic]

You had fun, we had fun :) what a good day

[@poiri]

Oh god they've been in too many Magic the Noah videos, it's changing them.

[@CardmarketMagic]

My pitch for this was: "What if we did Magic the Noah but in real life". I'm happy people see it :)

[@randomnerd5913]

This feels very Magic the Noah, and I love it. Keep it up, guys!

[@MagicalMasterMind]

Amazing lolll, you guys should do this more often!

[@PhoenixRising200]

PLEASE DO MORE OF THESE OMG SO MUCH FUN

[@ajpbrunet]

I didn't laugh when Carl appeared from under the table at 12:17 and apologetically said "I couldn't find boars...here's pirates instead": I cackled like a goddamn hyena 🤣. This was *so much fun*, please could we see more and also could we get a series of "Carl the mischievous trickster god goes around sowing chaos into people's games", somebody call Wizards I would pay to see that.

[@dimensionswaechter]

That was absolutely hilarious :D You are as always very much on top of the content game. Made my day!

[@CardmarketMagic]

Thank you:) that is really high praise!

[@sunshindo3726]

This truly was the most entertaining magic duel I have seen

[@jozefkeresturi2139]

I really enjoyed this idea. Hope to see more itterations of it.

[@xanbanan2917]

congrats with 100K! waiting for behind the scenes video😉

[@CardmarketMagic]

Thank you for noticing! :D the behind the scenes video will be coming out next Tuesday

[@egoish6762]

Lucky white goat avoiding that removal spell 😂

[@doofdanill3128]

That was so enjoyable to watch! Please do more!

[@MetodoCuboAzul]

One of the most unique MTG channels on KZbin, every episode is a banger, well done! If I lived in Europe, I would buy from Cardmarket!

[@CardmarketMagic]

That's kind of you to say! :D we'd love to expand to other countries, where are you located now if you don't mind me asking?

[@MetodoCuboAzul]

@@CardmarketMagic in Brazil, MTG scene here is pretty big

[@CardmarketMagic]

Yes! And I've heard pauper is a very popular format there! Which I love since it's my favourite format and it's hard to find players for it here in Germany:)

[@pandanometa]

By far the most entertaining video. Everyone was having a blast!

[@badook2001]

the only non commander magic content i watch - u guys are so funny love it :D

[@CardmarketMagic]

That's high praise! :) thank you

[@obsidiansiriusblackheart]

😂 This was so funny. The creativity of all you guys is off the charts! Love this channel ❤

[@CardmarketMagic]

Thank you! That is so kind of you to say! :D

[@DerringerHK]

Carl this was so good lol. I think there are legs left in this, and I know Id definitely love to see you guys do this again

[@recino2]

I love this whimsical game master arc

[@Biblionaut]

that costume shop close to you really paying of haha. i love it.

[@nicodee8282]

Carl is straight up looking like a member of the Sgt. Pepper Lonely Hearts Club Band!