NEW ColourPop Garden Variety Collection | Swatches, Comparisons + Review

[@squirrel_of_mistri8565]

Things you never hear people say: "I really like this matte shadow, but I wish there was glitter in it." "I can't wait for the glitter in this matte shadow to fall into my eyes and all over my face!!" "Is there a way to make matte shadows less matte without making them satin?" I mean, I get it...it makes the mattes look more interesting in the pans. But how many people actually want glittery mattes?

[@Squirrely1]

Now this is what the Wild Nothing pallete shoulda looked like.

[@SchwallySells]

STOP this is the cutest packaging and I am obsessed with these colors - I just bought the wild nothings palette but THIS is what I wanted.

[@MakeupJustForFun]

I think this one would work well with Wild Nothing since that one needed a little more depth for me 😄

[@Dragonflyathena]

Lol same! 😍

[@mykaelrenee9546]

Same!! I love this!!

[@elizabethgibson929]

It is a great companion palette to add some neutrals and a lighter green to go with this green.

[@alixlola2167]

I hope Colourpop makes an empty palette with this eyeshadow palette design -- I'd buy it!

[@lauriedomino3559]

Yes! I’d love this package! All I have are my old DIY magnetic palettes from when colourpop provides free palettes with singles. You know, the white ones that you could rip out the foam? I’d love this as an upgrade!

[@rebeccaude4412]

Laurie Domino & @Alix Lola - OMG, I was actually looking to see if someone made this comment so I didn’t repeat it, lol! I don’t even know what the BYOP palettes look like right now🤷🏼‍♀️. IMO, the last ones were.... extremely unattractive (the peachy-orange w/gold palm trees:👎🏼. No offense AT ALL to everyone who liked them: having different tastes makes us unique & shows our personalities 🥰)! Anyway, those were on sale/clearance a couple of weeks ago, has anyone seen what the new pattern is? I REALLY wish that they would hire Angela who is @doodlesbythebunny on IG make a collection of palette designs (if you haven’t seen her work, seriously RUN to her page)! At the least, @colourpopcosmestics should have a poll on IG or their website so customers could vote on what magnetic palettes we would like to be able to purchase (& not only for BYOP). In the meantime, I love the ShopMissA palettes, but not the long shipping time! Have a great day!

[@nicolebrowne1433]

I agree about the green! I need a sage, seafoam and olive palette! Mint, teal and other classic greens have been done by Colourpop and I want to see some more interesting variations

[@ilovecheesecake1214]

THIS is what the Wild Nothing palette should have been!

[@yeyiisz]

While I’m absolutely in love with Colourpop and will continue to purchase from them I’ve realized that their prices are creeping up. That becomes an issue for me when they continue to release some of the same color stories over and over. You have become my GO TO reviewer with Colourpop for your thorough review, your comparisons alone remind me that I have these colors ten times over in my collection! Thank you for all your effort, my pocket continues to appreciate it! I’m still hoping Colourpop comes out with an emerald eyeshadow palette ☺️

[@brianaschino4903]

I noticed the price thing too 😭

[@emilynotaro1745]

Wild Nothing didn’t grab my attention, but this collection has!!! Ooohhhhh.

[@renee_12420]

Same here maybe I will buy the Eyeshadow palette and one of the sets on launch today

[@PozzaPoe]

Yesssss

[@angiebartelme]

Honestly not super impressed with the collection, I’m just over here trying to convince myself I don’t need a palette just because it has cute succulents on the front 😂🤦🏻‍♀️

[@brianaschino4903]

I feel ya!

[@katodie5471]

Hard same

[@elizabethgibson929]

I am so addicted to eyeshadow palettes. It's so hard to turn down such beautiful colors and packaging. I need to just enjoy what I have, but it's always "just one more won't hurt." Then the next day I look at my collection and tell my husband to "remind me to look at my palettes before I but it.... 😍

[@christahodges]

I'm here for the NO PRESSED GLITTERS!!🙌🙌 Thank you Colourpop!!

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Yessss!

[@whitneyalger6386]

Saw the post on Trendmood and immediately opened KZbin because I knew you'd have a video! Yay!

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Yay! Thank you!

[@kristyparlor7849]

Colourpop is back at the weekly new realeases! I love it!

[@SuperStarr817]

The main reason I've held off on so many Colourpop palettes in the last year is strictly because the warm neutrals are so repetitive. I have all my warm neutrals in singles. If I want pops I always get SSS or more singles so I totally agree that they could've gone funner with the jellies.

[@pollychen1735]

I’m 90% here for your personality, 10% for new products. Love your reviews and bloopers.

[@joannawarrens5117]

I think the world makes a little more sense when Colourpop brings out tons of new products!

[@littlemisslipstick2999]

Hahahaha, the Colourpop that we know and love is back! A new release every week 😅

[@everydaylook8546]

Hi Amanda, I love how informative you are especially the eye safety warnings on the palettes. Can you do a video of ALL your COLOURPOP eyeshadow palettes that DO NOT have EYE-SAFETEY-WARNINGS please?

[@annagraf1908]

The packaging is adorable and I love a garden theme but I'm not tempted to break my low buy for this collection. Holding out for a great fall palette!

[@cassbat]

this is my favorite colourpop collection that they have ever released!! i think the color story and packaging are STUNNING, and Im just hoping they release the palette design as an empty magnetic palette bc it is just that beautiful. 😍

[@Dragonflyathena]

Omg yes same- want this as an empty magnet !

[@kaellyilene]

Just saw the colourpop Instagram and I had to hear your thoughts immediately!!!

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Yay! Thank you for watching! 💗

[@luceromanjarrez349]

Same

[@suellen4288]

Same!

[@meganfogarty7698]

Me too!

[@JessSauceyDough]

SAME!

[@magaliolalde2028]

To be fair, I think the best reviews for the CP collections are yours!! The comparisons and everything :)

[@KarenHarrismakeup]

Saw the sneak peak and came to my #1 coulourpoper

[@abigaeld]

As soon as I saw the post from Colourpop I knew you were gonna have a video up for us. Thank you so much! I wish every new release has reviews up before they’re released. Helps with the decision making! Thank you for always being on top of it, Amanda!

[@MakeupJustForFun]

I’m so happy to help! 😘😘

[@itspaigemorgan]

I came as soon as I heard! I’m here for the blushes!

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Thank you for watching! 😄

[@Dragonflyathena]

Same!

[@danicee]

This collection is stunning, I was so let down by the last one because the shadows didn’t perform like I expected but the creme shadows and the blushes were nice. I am a sucker for flower themed items, they make me so happy ☺️

[@lueraiv]

So cute 💜 trying to hold myself back from buying colourpop but this is hard to resist 🥺 wished I could’ve seen the other blushes on you, especially night bloom. Very curious how that would look. Love your colourpop reviews as always (:

[@stacys.7094]

I'm a sucker for packaging too and, yes, I love the sound of a closing compact! That purple eyeshadow is amazing on you! I laughed at your "bloopers" when you kept admiring your eyeshadow. I go around the house and make my kids admire mine : ).

[@robbye01]

My favorite of all time is the Wild nothing collection. I love the lip oils & will use them often but they all show up the same. There is very little to no difference in color. 🥰 The succulent collection is really nice too.

[@amandajollylines]

LOVE this packaging, interested in the Sage Bundle Jelly Much and the purple blush since they're so different. As for the rest, I just feel like Colourpop is kind of stuck in a color rut. Their formula is my fave, so I'm always excited for a release, but the colors are beginning to look the same with new names. If this palette had actually had cooler, dustier greens like the blush packaging, or some more desaturated colors instead of just warm neutrals, that would have added something REALLY new to their collection and mine.

[@juliavanhorn3399]

I agree completely! Like the last few releases have just left me feeling a little meh. Like I feel this one and wild nothing are just too similar

[@CeleryStickz]

Wow colourpop does not fail to impress me on their designs UGH!!! Also I’m usually not super obsessed with your eyelooks but wow I gotta say that purple looks SO gorgeous on you!!!

[@Nikkimichelle]

I love how u show everything so we can see

[@bangfangbang]

I'm so glad they're going back to giving us new collections every couple of weeks. I missed them!

[@gillypiexo]

2:41 this is why i Loves you! I freaking Love the look of purple lip oil, im not sure how i feel about it not having color. Im SO glad people are catching on to the jellymuch shadows, not having to throw them away, thank you for spreading the message !

[@glamgirrrl33]

I so don’t need this but the packaging is amazing!

[@michelleplass5310]

Just saw this on trended and was hoping the video was up and it was!!

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Thank you for watching! 💗

[@whimsydearest]

Love the combo of purple and green and almost wish there were a few more pops of color in this palette.💜💚

[@thesnoopydance645]

Night bloom blush....💜Desert Days jelly much, the palette. 🙂Glad I held out for this.

[@aileenbell6750]

I really want the Saguaro jelly much shadow. Just an FYI from a Tucsonan, Saguaro has a silent “g”...like Sa-Waro. I am going to go back and watch your Jelly much video because they are so lovely. This palette is VERY tempting. 🥰 Thanks for your video!

[@MissCalicoCat_]

Just wanted to say that your makeup looks especially stunning in this video!

[@d-dub2648]

I ordered 2 pallets today (not this new one😩I have a system lol) however I did order the blush in that gorgeous lavender shade. Super happy to see this. I had a shade similar from Bare Minerals (Fav) that I have only a teeny bit left. Saw this and jumped on it. I will get this beautiful pallet next go around. Have to remember I have only 2 eyes and I choose not to spend too much. Damn it......being sensible blows🤣

[@Cynni393]

I'm Sooo buying this collection especially the palette!!! I'm so excited! Also the collection is inclusive!

[@galacticgabs]

omg thank you for those comparisons!! i already have all i see is magic so i can just pair that palette with another green in my collection and i feel like i can recreate most looks from the garden variety 🥰

[@alexaplease]

Hey Amanda! Thanks for the video and for getting it up so quick! That's so awesome. Are you thinking of doing a tutorial? I would love to see the purple and green combo together *heart eyes* lol maybe a 3 looks 1 palette?

[@jessicajstadelman1682]

Such a pretty collection. I want it all. The lip oils smell like black licorice/anise.

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Yay! Thank you! 💗

[@courtneybaeyen]

Yeah I was going to say red licorice is cherry or strawberry flavored. True flavor is the black licorice, which is like black liquor (think Jager). You wouldn't say the red jelly bean taste like licorice you would say cherry, but the black jelly bean tastes like black licorice. Thanks for coming to my Ted Talk! 🙃

[@wonderfallz]

Literally gasped when you revealed the Jelly Much swatches! 💖🧡 I adore mine, I have not even revived my dried out pink and it still applies to my lids and stays put like magic, but I am watching you video on reviving them properly next.

[@strawberreh]

Damn. I've been wanting to go on a no buy, but this collection is to die for! I might have to get a few things 😭

[@LaurenDayMakeup]

I always love your in depth ColourPop reviews! I don't see the point of the different Lip Oils if they are all clear. I would have preferred 4 new lipsticks instead of those!

[@paolafrias]

I want that purpley blush so much! It would definitely be unique to my collection and I absolutely love blush

[@amandacaron8828]

The packaging is 😍

[@marghiel.3847]

I love how varied the colors are

[@michellesutedja2173]

colourpop literally gave me heart attack each week :') another cute collection !!

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Most of their collections are not super limited edition so even if something sells out, they usually restock it when they can. So no rush, save up a list of what will truly make you happy long term!

[@monaelkateb2652]

Wow I did not even see this collection on their ig , you are the best 🤩

[@IwMk]

It's the most stunning packaging they have ever done 😍

[@regisatlas]

THE go to channel for CP reviews

[@hayleypflug7384]

These collections are cute, but the lip oils are a let down. Release one shade and call it a day!

[@LuWho21]

Your reviews on Colourpop’s collections are always so nice and detailed. I love them!! Really helps me decide what to get. I think I’m going to try and get the palette in this collection. I’m glad I didn’t impulse buy the wild nothing palette. They’re similar, but this one gives me a lot more funn colours that I don’t have in a nice formula. Thank you for your review!

[@JackOllie4]

Whoo ... I need that Night Bloom blush. I am c-r-a-z-y for purpley blushes!

[@NatalieYTFoster]

I did just order the whole nine yards. I wish I had ordered the desert rose as well. Love the packaging. The comparisons are so helpful!

[@abbyswanson3890]

I love your videos so much! I definitely call you 'my colourpop gal' 😂😊Whenever there is a new colourpop release, I always go to your review first! I can always count on great swatches and comparisons from you! Plus I relate so much to your excitement over makeup lol! The palette and jelly much shadows are so gorgeous! I like that it is not so peachy because I was getting bored of it and I look like I'm sick in the color😅 Although the slightly peach blush looks very flattering!

[@lesleawitter5534]

I just saw this advertised, so I was excited to see your review! The colors in this palette are gorgeous, and the packaging is stunning! I also really like the rosy toned blushes! Love the magnetic closure and beautiful packaging as well! I’m disappointed that the lip oils don’t have any color though. The colors are so pretty, but it’s a bummer that they don’t show up when wearing them.

[@Joy_Aqis]

I found your channel because of Colourpop collections so everytime i see new releases from them i definitely think of you. Still wonder if i could see your entire super shock collection 🙈

[@sandy5791]

Thank you so much for the swatch comparisons! I realized I don’t need the palette but that purple blush is calling my name! 🙌❤️

[@HazelStar12]

Beautiful palette and that orchid blush😍😍

[@sandracox9287]

This and Going Coconut were my first two Colourpop palettes! Love them! I've since purchased Miss Bliss, Taupe and Making Mauve. :)

[@lillianmonet5952]

Please do swatches of all of your colourpop blushes!

[@Sharischreiber451]

I ordered and am waiting for both Wild nothing and garden palettes 🎨. Love colourpop!!!!!!!

[@chersilveira8944]

I trust your opinions on colors, versatility, ease of application etc. IF YOU love it, chances are I will end up loving it too. I am getting THIS one cause it has such great colors and can be used with other palettes to really look pretty and different. I also am getting the Mauve palette at the same time. I LOVE purples and apricot, soft light peach or pinky shades with GREEN. they look so fresh and really pretty. I always wear neutrals so I am LOOKING FORWARD to wearing color again!!!

[@AnetteL.Nielsen]

2 collections within a few weeks... 🤔... 🤔... Colourpop is BACK!! This collection is so pretty and soft but still fun 😍 I really want the palette but I'm too broke. I own the 3 Disney palettes and Sweet Talk, so maybe I can get the same color story that way. 🙄 Great video as usual, Amanda 😊

[@AlyLaughlin]

I almost feel like this is what I wanted the Wild Nothing palette to look like inside...I was looking for reviews and swatches so I’m so happy you uploaded this! Thanks! 🤗💕

[@AlyLaughlin]

Oh I forgot to ask. Do you know if this palette is vegan? Thank you!

[@melaniephillips7825]

Your skin looks extra glowy today

[@2eyelids]

I'm so glad I found this video because it sent me down a rabbit hole. I tried to get the single Colourpop shadow "wishful winking" recently and it was sold out. I didn't know the original palette it was from, so once I saw it was All I See Is Magic, I went to look at the whole palette for grins knowing it was old and no longer exists. I then saw a Temptalia review that showed me wishful winking looks exactly like a shade I already own. TLDR: thank you for that All I See is Magic comparison! :]

[@heatherk6445]

This collection is so cute! I noticed someone already asked on your IG but I'll second the request to see Jelly Much shadow comparisons... definitely want to pick a couple of those up as long as they don't look exactly like the ones I already have :)

[@keleyw]

oh darn! I woulda liked to have seen this palette compared to the Wild Nothing palette too! How would you say they compare?

[@bobbiem]

This is the prettiest palette. Oh my, now I have to buy another palette. 💖

[@orirose9100]

Your Colourpop reviews are always SO helpful! Thank you so much for how thorough and straightforward you are in your product descriptions and recommendations!

[@SophieTheArtist]

New subscriber! I’m kind of obsessed with succulents so it’s like this collection was made for me 😂

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Yay! Thank you for being here! 💗

[@SophieTheArtist]

Makeup.Just.For.Fun Happy to be here too! I was first introduced to you a while back with the Game of Thrones collection. Being a cheapskate college kid who’s still new to makeup, it was my first big purchase so I definitely needed a little help 😂

[@loricox3674]

Oh they like to keep me broke. I’ll pick up whatever I can.....hopefully the palette for sure!

[@carolynmichelejones-kirkla1651]

You need to colab with ColourPop...your ideas and suggestion are spot on....Love you....

[@jen8778]

Oh I see you Wild Nothing palette, out there with that upgrade 😉 CP had me at succulents...what GORGEOUS packaging! I wish CP would sell a magnetic palette w/ just this packaging, I'd buy it in a heartbeat! Have my eye on the jelly much shadows and the Night Bloom blush. And as an ex-*NSYNC fangirl, I kinda want the Terran Up My Heart blush on namesake alone, lol

[@michellehoang576]

I love the blushes and the eye palette. Will definitely picked those up. The lip colors do look sheer though.

[@juliekruse4060]

I love your Colourpop reviews!

[@MakeupJustForFun]

Oh thank you! 💗💗

[@dazem8]

I usually agree with your suggestions of how a collection could be a bit better. A mint green or a cool toned purple JM shadow would have been more interesting to me too and why not make the lip oils more pigmented? letdown a lil bit but the palette is pretty. 🤷‍♀️

[@kaitlynrudy8238]

Ooooh those jelly much shadows are SO PRETTTTTY!!!!

[@truewants]

thanks for all you do!! This was perfect before the launch!!

[@TanealyaKimBeauty]

The packaging is super cute and I will get the blushes because I love Colourpops blush formula but the color story of the palette are just so uninspiring in MY opinion lol. I honestly wish rather than constantly launching something new they would focus on keeping the products they know people want in stock. I've tried 3 times to get the blushes from The Sailor Moon collection. If they focused on keeping that collection in stock they would have enough to ensure everyone that wanted it was able to get it. If after 3 launches on the website and 2 on Ulta people still can't get the blushes there is no way they are making enough for a restock.

[@violetlune72]

Meanwhile, I’m still trying to get my hands on the Sailormoon collection 🤦🏻‍♀️.....instead of restocking they just keep on coming out with new launches. I can’t keep up 😅

[@JBSouls]

Thank you so much for not neglecting to mention the lip oil scent again... I had hoped so much that it would be different this time but I kinda doubted it (because why would they come out with the product only to change it up like 2 weeks later in a new release) ._. The thought of licorice alone makes me gag so I unfortunately can't try these - very sad but still glad I was warned before ordering some.

[@KateKosmo]

I can't take how cute this collection is. I need the palette and the peachy blush!

[@NerdySweets3]

i need to get this! i love succulents, and i’ve been looking at palettes just like this! 💖🌸💞

[@MakeupJustForFun]

It is SUCH a cute one!! 💗

[@deborahmitchell8025]

Just got this palette and I love it!! 😍💕🙌🙌🙌💕

[@Tjg191]

Love this ❤️ that orchid blush is really pretty!

[@denisem8570]

Another home run collection review from you! This collection is lovely, but I think I have most, if not all, of these colors. I have to stop buying eyeshadows!

[@mariannemilkshines2390]

I am so excited for this palette love the purple blush. Wish they had some new eye liners.

[@brendadawson4912]

IH MY GOSH! I THOUGHT I liked the Wild Nothing Pallette (although I hadn’t purchased yet because I wanted to see what CP came out with next). And I’m SO GLAD I waited!! THIS is me in a pallette! I absolutely LOVE purpled, just like you! And I LOVE my jelly much shadows! Just used one yesterday (Bookay). I haven’t been this excited for a release in a LONG time. I will most likely have to wait because I know it will sell out in no time and I can’t be available to order tomorrow at the time they are releasing. But I will wait. Cuz it’s that good!! Thank you so much for all the swatches and comparisons. The lip oils ARE disappointing that they have no color. That first one you held up, the color was amazing! If only it swatches that color 🥺 YOU ARE THE BEST!! Hugs 💄💄 P.S. we need an emoji of an eyeshadow pallette and other make up!!

[@carolinagirl3219]

Beautiful collection.

[@makeupbysheduly_]

Omg!! This collection looks so good💚💚

[@fullercorp]

weird to have two nature/garden palettes in a row and they each have ONE green. Thank goodness you posted this because i am a completist and would have bought all those lip oils and been pissed they were all clear.

[@sarahoswald9415]

I really really wanted the entire wild nothing collection I hope I am on time to get this collection

[@beccahope]

This eyeshadow palette is going right onto my wishlist! So stinking adorable!

[@nancytipton7602]

I feel that this is what Wild Nothing *should* have been! Living here in the desert Southwest, I can vouch that we do have more color than that one had, this is more like it. Would have loved to have seen that more minty toned green you mentioned, as our cacti oft times have a rich cooler, almost minty color to them.