Man Shot on New York City Subway Train / Brooklyn NYC 3.14.24

Need a Real Estate or Wedding Videographer in NYC? Contact Adam at [e-mail]
3.14.24 / Video by Usman
A dispute on a Brooklyn subway train escalated into violence when a 36-year-old man confronted a 32-year-old man, leading to the 36-year-old pulling out a gun. The 32-year-old managed to gain control of the gun and struck the other man, resulting in shots being fired. Chaos ensued as passengers scrambled for safety. The incident occurred at the Nostrand Avenue station, and the train eventually stopped at the Hoyt-Schermerhorn station where police responded to the scene. The 36-year-old was taken to the hospital in critical condition. Charges are pending against the 32-year-old, and an investigation is ongoing.
Follow Adam's New Video Production Brand / @a79films
linktr.ee/loudlabsnyc
Watch Season 2 of Midnight Tour bit.ly/3N5hA2k
Watch Season 1 of Midnight Tour bit.ly/3sjGi4D
Join YT Membership to chat on livestreams bit.ly/2UXbs2A
Help support this channel, Paypal bit.ly/3eG04k6
Merch bit.ly/3hdVlaF
Subscribe to Devins Channel www.youtube.com/@DevinLLNNYC/...
Subscribe to Usmans Channel / @queensnewsjunkie
To license video contact [e-mail]
loudlabsnyc
/ loudlabsnewsnyc
Facebook.com/loudlabsnewsnyc
Twitter.com/loudlabsnyc
www.lln.live

[@johnquincy9715]

The Governor and Mayor still insist the trains are safe. Stop lying!!!

[@preciousjacob6108]

I know. They pop up on camera riding the train for four seconds and then jump in their private limo to their private jet, to make a press conference about climate change.

[@MAN_MAN730]

These people care nothing about you. Grow up!

[@MAN_MAN730]

​@@preciousjacob6108remember they are surrounded guns.

[@austinpowers1999]

Bruh, the was a mostly peaceful fight to the death. Don’t believe me? Ask any liberal media outlet.

[@workoutwarrior3118]

I grew up in Jersey, rode the path trains up and down New York as well as all the other NY Transit lines to other boroughs, never encountered any issues other than people asking for money or the trains being crowded…. I left after 9/11, It’s a shame to see this happening now

[@tia_pinkbuttaflyy]

I don't agree with harassment towards anyone. That guy was minding his business and dude kept taunting him.

[@Jdee8989]

Exactly!

[@Will_Moffett]

Well the only video I've seen starts the taunting guy very agitated but doesn't show the genesis. Why do you assume he got that angry without provocation? Although he seems extremely sensitive to disrespect, real or perceived, he doesn't seem to be completely insane. The other guy probably did or said something. It might not have been "fighting words" but we don't know what happened. We should assume the target of the angry guy committed some offense in the angry guy's mind.

[@jgoods4510]

We dont know that to be true we didn't see this from the BEGINNING

[@tomcatt998]

faafo

[@wholesomenic0186]

" Dude"

[@YouTube_deletes_my_comments]

Dude got stabbed and then shot with his own gun…. Bad day to be a menace…

[@elizandropedraza1286]

😆😁😂👍.🍺🇮🇹

[@francheskavega7251]

​@@elizandropedraza1286🙌🙌🙌🙌

[@StayFractalesque]

..too bad we can only leave it to our imagination.. all these crime channels with clickbait thumbnails, then blur everything, and the rest filler with "survivors" crying on social media how "scary" it was and "thank god i am okay" .. yah, u the main character, boo, yah..

[@bellaa2217]

That man was harassing the other guy for no reason. How you tell someone the minute he moves he will get beat up? That’s crazy

[@worldaroundyounearyou]

Some Africans Americans when they see advantage on u they gonna try to scale

[@relife_me3645]

​@@worldaroundyounearyou African instincts

[@eyre73]

was he, we didnt see the start of the confrontation

[@criSOME1]

Wewuzkamgs didn’t seee the start? Oh then it’s justified. Chump

[@SuperMarlene333]

He kept threatening and the man kept quiet tried to avoid confrontation until he couldnt take it anymore. The big man thought he got the advantage, bigger, taller with the gun and the other man was quick and was able to grab the gun from him and man got shot with his own gun.

[@Alex-tx2je]

Exactly

[@seantaylor6565]

If it happened like that smaller dude won’t face any charges …. I said this in NYC there is no self defense but if u take a person’s weapon off them to defend yourself from the attacker everything’s a goo … u cld empty the clip on mf n all u gotta do wen ask yy u didn’t stop is I’m not trained I blick till It clicked

[@cheflouevangelism5889]

Facts. Plus the women stabbed the bigger guy in his back. He could have avoided all this but now hes in a hospital eating some humble pie

[@OregonCrow]

yea thanks we watched the video.

[@DD-pt9qw]

Self defense as far as I’m concerned.

[@demetriadavis7083]

that gun was exactly why he was talking s*** from the start , smfh !

[@zg-mzga]

this

[@dancollins8296]

No doubt about it. Thought he was invincible. He thought wrong

[@junglekutz5625]

Exactly! These types live a fantasized life. Which is why they move in ways that they do.

[@NigelNguyen_]

🎯

[@sonyx5332]

Dudes like him always like to start talking crap with a gun or without a gun.

[@astacioofficial6598]

I dont condone violance but im glad spanish dude was able to protect himself and the young lady with him God is great ❤👏🏼

[@oscardean6351]

God should’ve stopped it before it began then he wouldn’t have to save anyone now. God is stupid.👍☺️

[@niraku321]

Wow you're a waste of space - expect everyone to do everything for you your whole life.

[@Jakub680]

Ain’t no Spanish dude in New York 😂

[@SlantedKW]

arabic dude actually

[@misstee9842]

Trying to be cute while filming a horrible situation

[@joechiodi5529]

And then running and screaming like a banshee when shit hits the fan.

[@Nightwolf3536]

Typical people with phones these days smh.

[@D-Sin5]

See what being a bully gets you?

[@TheTreyTvChannel]

we don't know what happened prior to this

[@luckylove5021]

​@@TheTreyTvChannelDidn't you hear the other guy tell him he didn't do nothing to him?

[@nizzotheartist]

When you pull out a gun you dont have to get that close there is no need to. Now he didn't bring out the gun till the scarey guy had to use a knife

[@dionyrodriguez2269]

@@TheTreyTvChannel 🤦🏻‍♂️ yes we do

[@luckylove5021]

@@nizzotheartist The scary guy didn't want to fight him. The guy with the gun said he was gonna punch him and jumped in his face.

[@manuelsosa6483]

Justice was served this time. Don’t press charges on the man that DEFENDED himself.

[@bhigdaddymark]

Don't forget Manuel, that's an ultra liberal blue city & state where you're not allowed to defend yourself and by law, the NYPD will arrest BOTH parties involved first, then sort things out. Lots of mentally ill people in NYC.

[@msjuicycouture22]

Ur name says it all

[@num1Jaysta]

They probably going to jail so justice is served all around then

[@tanyaholly3307]

Thank you!

[@Samira_m84]

True but the girl needs to get charged. She possibly escalated the situation by stabbing him

[@davidbenitez2835]

The truth is, these trains should have cameras in the cars.

[@anthonyescalante5011]

Nah idk about cameras bruh it's already bad enough in NYC especially there's surveillance EVERYWHERE.... We don't need more of it.... But what we DO NEED are charger outlets either on or under the seats so we can charge our phones

[@Robcoll_]

Да уж, я не думал что в Нью-Йорке так плохо с общественным транспортом, вот в Москве на метро в каждом сиденье есть зарядка. И безопасно.

[@Engineer9736]

@@anthonyescalante5011 So you prefer getting shot over having an empty phone battery 🤦‍♂

[@JayTubeYTThirdChannel]

Plus the R46's are too old to get new features.

[@ej0077]

Dude died all talk first gets stabbed then shot with his own gun.

[@ChannelZero1031]

Oh shit he died?

[@LisaBowers]

The video's description says the man is in critical condition. Did he die?

[@laduralamayimba]

@@LisaBowers they said he went on surgery, so i suppose he survived.

[@majormediaproductions]

😮He died?

[@user-zq1xf3lz8y]

@@laduralamayimba I hope he didn't, we have too many criminals.

[@nycny1090]

We shouldn't have to live like this! Welcome to the open air zoo.

[@jtkaldk6832]

🗽🗽🗽🗽🗽

[@krystingrant6292]

Exactly barely struggling to financially handle living in NYC have to deal with this shi

[@Spaceface3]

Some one turn on New York by Alicia Keys 🗽💩

[@rawestinrino-liverawstreet5333]

@@jozefk.7720Nah they actually doubled cops in the subways and this is still happening proving cops don’t do shit

[@NigelNguyen_]

@@Spaceface3 nah that song is literally bottom 5 songs of all time i cover my ears not to hear that garbage.

[@NelsonLovell]

Never seen a NYC train take that long to get to the next station traveling full speed 😂 it's like the Devil was the conductor

[@nataliecruz316]

😅😅😅

[@jennifermcgoldrick6323]

It’s an express train that goes from nostrand Ave to Hoyt shermerhorn without any stops between, so it’s a long distance between the two stops.

[@simplyshanbrown3684]

​@jennifermcgoldrick6323 Exactly 🙄🙄

[@novascotiagrown6138]

Nobody's coming to save us, we have to save ourselves.

[@rosej5029]

And we might get arrested for doing it which is f****d up if the cops don't see it as self defense!

[@brickflipper5273]

And New York City prefers you to take subway instead of driving when it's not safe for the citizens. This is why majority is driving to work or working from home

[@user-xg3uy6hq9g]

majority are taking public transportation, where do you think they all could park?

[@haloichigo1]

I used to live in New York and would rather risk a shooting or two on the subway than actually try to find parking.

[@quenainonchalant9205]

I hate when Ppl thts not Frm NYC or even lived here always got something to say STFUp❗️

[@3l3ments001]

Oh you must think you will be safe in a vehicle. Oh ok. 😩

[@Greatboogersandwich]

Majority are taking the public transportation. It's only dangerous in ghetto stations neighborhoods. Where are you getting your numbers? You obvs aren't from NYC. There is literally no need to drive unless you are going up state, Long island, staten island, or a parent trying to buy groceries in bulk.

[@philipiano001]

This is what happens when criminals are not put in jail. 🤔

[@rodreiquezattakhan1710]

Criminals Like the founding fathers??

[@camelliainzurich1262]

@@rodreiquezattakhan1710 Hardly. Why are you here if you object to the Founding Fathers? You are licking the gravy that they created.

[@countrygirl4422]

​@@rodreiquezattakhan1710 You can leave you're free to go.

[@user-xg3uy6hq9g]

did he have a real record? had he served his time? fare evasion is just a violation that gets fined.

[@diegomontejo4657]

Not the criminals in the subway​@@rodreiquezattakhan1710

[@JackRainfield]

Let's say a prayer for the 32 year old.

[@keilaz7253]

So this animal just did double digits in jail. Somehow got released, got a gun and started trouble on a train with children. He got what was coming to him. Let that man and woman who defended themselves go.

[@judyvondergathen6818]

The left does not believe that e,v7il exists and that He,l;l does not exist. They might want to do some research on the place because that will be their home for eternity .

[@user-cb9ul1ds6y]

Those clumsy democrats are at it again!!!

[@keilaz7253]

@@user-cb9ul1ds6ydon’t even get me started. Pathetic. And this state still votes for the same garbage.

[@Dcorreia1114]

​@@keilaz7253trumpeta

[@sandram8761]

He should not be charged. That demon in human form needed to be stopped.

[@malachirobley123]

They just released a statement saying he won’t be charged

[@bidhrohi12]

There are no demons. Just people. And people can be worse than demons.

[@blacklyfe5543]

He needs to be charged

[@renziny]

blind ​@@bidhrohi12

[@yesandno3640]

@@blacklyfe5543why??

[@carefulconsumer8682]

Mayor Adams could not be reached for comment at his mansion.

[@MAN_MAN730]

He said he was "Disgusted "😮

[@forfuntime2023]

He said he couldn't believe his people did this in the public.

[@ceciliaaznaran3317]

Of course, he doesn't want to show his face.

[@OregonCrow]

Jealous of people who work hard than you? :(

[@Mrsprettyqueenk]

Dam shame

[@tinacollier1447]

New York getting out of control.

[@user-vl2ev7on2j]

I hope the 32 year old dont charge what he does self defense the 36 year old its a racists

[@ulyssesharris6249]

The lady that stabbed him should not be charged!

[@AllThingsIzzyTTV]

All those bag searches didn't do shit

[@Vdub481]

Same shit I said like that’s goin help the situation people carry weapons guns all types of things

[@juanventura5692]

Until they get random and strategic its not going to do anything.

[@jtkaldk6832]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@jtkaldk6832]

They do it certain spots which makes no sense

[@alisalittle817]

Authorities never accost men their size . Either scrawny guys or women. Guessing it’s safer

[@omel7]

Fools always act tough when they’re carrying a gun! 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@intenseninja8241]

But that fool got his gun taken and popped in the head.

[@_Spicymorenita]

@@intenseninja8241that part !!

[@Jerseyan]

I hope they don't ban guns because of him!

[@omel7]

@@intenseninja8241 the older guy who antagonized the situation took the kids knife; then grab the gun out of his jacket pocket! Look at it again!

[@omel7]

@@Jerseyan nobody is taking away anybody’s gun or ban any guns! Ever! But a mental health background should be conducted to those who want to own guns! Don’t you agree?

[@EdGoPlaces]

I don't get it why people are taking sides based on race. It's clear the overly aggressive guy taunted and then started the fight. Some were saying, "Just let them fight". Death can happen with fist fight or gun. Imagine the aggressive dude having your son or husband cornered in a chokehold. Ladies, what are you going to do? Watch your son or husband die? Would you be a Ride-or-Die chick who would stand by your loved one through thick and thin and help out?

[@worldaroundyounearyou]

My bro some Africans Americans bully better stop that shh cause is not gonna get well I'm dominican we represent all Latinos around we don't like bullying like this ya better stop that shh.

[@EdGoPlaces]

@@worldaroundyounearyou I agree with you. Bullying from anyone should not be tolerated. Fact: Dominicans got a whole lot of African DNA. Thanks for reppin both Africans and Latinos.

[@marchazard8042]

@@worldaroundyounearyou NOBODY LIKES BULLIES OR BULLYING. BUT this isn’t a race or nationality thing. when Lesandro Guzman-Feliz got chopped to death by a group of punks in the bronx, the ENTIRE CITY WAS OUTRAGED. ( not just latinos) so let’s keep that in mind. plus this was a MENTAL INSTABILITY situation more than anything else. the guys ex wife threw him out a year ago because he was committing violent acts towards her, and demonstrating highly mentally erratic behavior. crazy doesn’t care about race, nationality, or ethnicity. there are BULLIES in EVERY ethnicity and culture, as well as people who can’t stand bullies in EVERY ethnicity and culture.

[@mrsm222]

So what I saw was a big bully talking much shit got his own piece taken off him and he got got. Justice was served.

[@biojov]

Self defense against racist bully.

[@markpranck2508]

The a lot of racism on the A train

[@mo777-]

what race was the guy in yellow?

[@jackblack4654]

​@@mo777- latino

[@harlemboy413]

He thought he was a migrant

[@abusednomoresilence]

Damn that was so wrong. 😢

[@solraczevehc3761]

When trying to bully someone goes wrong 😂

[@jbaxa3]

I am so sorry you went through that. I cannot imagine how terrifying that was for everyone there.

[@jediryan9454]

So the dude gets stabbed by his own knife and shot by his own gun.

[@ivanplacido9636]

And this is the B.S. we have to deal with everyday. Let's thank our former politicians, current politicians, and justice system(D.A.s and judges) for their weak decisions disregarding the safety of the citizens that truly care about doing the right thing and follow the law.

[@jtkaldk6832]

Exactly

[@BOND19951]

Most of the politicians in NYC and NYS have the IQ levels of room temperature.

[@arnoldnicholson2165]

​@@BOND19951below room temperature

[@MR-xc3sw]

You forgot the voters. Do you vote for bail reform, open borders and sanctuary status ?

[@MR-xc3sw]

@@arnoldnicholson2165 what does that tell you about the citizens that vote for these politicians

[@cn9630]

Where are all of our MENTAL HEALTH FACILITIES today?

[@tesscot]

This with the national guard in the subways. You are watching the death of a nation.

[@ShakakuKoruna420]

Exactly👍

[@Greatboogersandwich]

National guards are only put in tourist stations. (Penn and port authority/time sq). It's all a political game. You from NYC? You have criitcal thinking skills? lol.

[@GingerCC-he8be]

The country was born dead, please, get real.

[@nycbenefits]

People may hate cops, but then are relieved to see them when shit goes down.

[@cheflouevangelism5889]

FACTS!

[@iamcase1245]

What did cops stop in this situation?

[@user-er3ri6sc3j]

All the preventive measures are possible human rights violations.

[@user-xg3uy6hq9g]

imagine expecting the public servants we pay with our tax dollars to actually be ethical, uphold the law, not abuse but actually serve the people they are paid to serve and protect. pretty unreasonable...? NOT

[@joelrobert4053]

Because cops have…………guns

[@aj.meso26]

This is exactly why I stopped taking the train and working during the weekdays in the city. Heck, now I work close to home and don’t need to commute. Work hours were flexible when driving on the weekends. PLEASE STAY SAFE AND ALERT ON THE MTA TRAINS. This is so sad to see.

[@johannamaynard4232]

Is unbelievable they don’t let the citizens carry a gun to defend their self,but criminals can!!! I’m glad I leave in a state where they allowed us the American to carry and protect our self!!!

[@SANE172]

Exactly 💯

[@johnm5131]

makes you wish that the Marine, Daniel Penny was there. Oh, he's on trial for murder for protecting a subway car full of people..I forgot.

[@FartMansion]

It’s illegal to defend yourself in New York

[@bronxkies]

It’s so sad they charging that man with murder. We can’t even protect ourselves out here anymore.

[@bobbydrake07017]

He choked out a half his weight homeless dude in a rear naked choke not the same thing not by a long shot.

[@teddyches4648]

This is why NYC needs to jail Alvin Bragg and Leticia James... They should be charged with murder.

[@soulknob9991]

He murdered a man who was having a psychotic episode. The man didn't assault anyone on the train. The person who filmed it said that he just saw a man get murdered on the train.

[@marinabreitigam8571]

This was self defense they better not charged that young man

[@eb7027]

what self defense. did you see the video. The guys girl stabbed the guy not him. she needs to go to jail.

[@AlexB-21]

​@eb7027 so its wrong to do the right thing? Justice was served. The bully asked for it from the beginning with his own weapons. No one should tolerate that type of behavior. Enough is enough.

[@TheAs63401]

I think the woman should be charged as well as the man who was shot

[@LoneWolfj11]

He was definitely tryna go back to jail and ended up in a casket. Guy was mental.

[@JohnnyDanger36963]

Remember there's two sides to every story!!☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️

[@AztecArabGoddess94]

​@JohnnyDanger36963 video shows who the aggressor was and who the bully was, and on top of that, it said racial slurs.

[@elizandropedraza1286]

I want see AOC talking about this on her CNN and MSNBC next interview 😂.

[@drizzo4669]

Why ya'll didn't rush him instead of livestreaming and crying? You just gonna let 1 random dude take your life, when theres 50 of you?

[@darthalba3785]

This is what I was thinking the whole time watching this.

[@jmac1698]

Ny soft back in the day the whole train wuda jumped on bro I seen shit like this one time after school Franklin ave train stoop the whole school jump this kid and the train started comin word to god I thought they was gon push him on the tracks but they push him in the train then threw his book bag soon as the door was bout to close

[@ginaj617]

People begged that dude to stop …there were kids on there ….disgrace

[@robflo5473]

FACTS ✅✅✅

[@brandonthomas99]

I agree with u

[@SuperJK-Man]

Big man thought he was tough with all that shit talk.

[@bobmilin]

This is what the people voted for.

[@johnnyryan3017]

Why was he on the train with a loaded gun?? Obviously he wasn't going to *School* or *Work* like this

[@Musicradio77Network]

Loaded weapons are not allowed on the subway, and no fighting. MTA needs to add rules like they used to do with airports including tight security.

[@ManzaMvsa]

Please give a round of applause for Eric Adams, DA Alvin Bragg, Kathy H, Letitia James and all the corrupt politicians that HATE New Yorkers with their deepest passion. The NYC Subway is literally a JUNGLE of WILD ANIMALS

[@jtkaldk6832]

So you blame all those people/politicians ?😂😂😂😂 Sometimes I wonder do people wanna sound informed or sound cool or just talk ?This could be anybody what are you saying they don’t control what the next person does genius. Thanks for the name drops they were pointless ✌🏿

[@biblemademedoit]

How about blaming the people who cause the problems. The reality is people should not have to have laws to protect their every moment in life. They should be able to go about their life in peace and people like that man can go live outside of the US if he dont like living amongst diverse people.

[@domarq]

@@jtkaldk6832 She actually knows the names of the politicians who facilitated this environment. It was NOT on THIS level of insanity, during Giuliani's era (well...the cops were insane, so that was another extreme). Instead of pasting laugh emojis, like a teenager---research your local politicians and actually give a damn about the policies they implement.

[@melstrashbin]

The policies do affect the outcome of situations like this, and the mentality of citizens... grow up and wake up.@@jtkaldk6832

[@johnlewis3891]

​@domarq She doesn't know jack shyt. Letitia James' office doesn't have jurisdiction over crimes like this. Adams has been the most pro 👮‍♂️ mayor and has flooded the stations with 👮‍♂️. As for your statement that there weren't this level of insanity when Giuliani was mayor, there were 649 murders in Giuliani's last year in office compared to 386 last year.

[@Treerootlocks]

Not all Hispanics are migrants. We are born in NYC as well.

[@_Spicymorenita]

💯

[@youtubelicksmytaint7482]

But someone in your family came here illegally so that make you an anchor baby.

[@Treerootlocks]

@@youtubelicksmytaint7482 I'm Native American. My family ancestors were here before yours came in ships illegally.

[@Treerootlocks]

@@youtubelicksmytaint7482 Ships have anchors...so that makes you a anchor baby.

[@L-M-O-1]

@youtubelicksmytaint7482 anchor babies are legal citizens. Stop trying to degrade ppl off the actions of others. That's first off. Secondly, lots of Hispanics came here legally. Third, America has her own Hispanic islands & those Hispanic ppl are Americans by birth.

[@karenmiller553]

I had a friend that always said everyone's a liberal till they get mugged.. I used to visit new york city regularly but I won't be going back.... Sad the average tax paying law abiding New Yorker has to put up with this.

[@Michaelxg95]

This a why it moved ouf of New York. It’s too unsafe.

[@user-cu3xn4xj3i]

Demon spirits getting into people.

[@Kltpzyxm17]

Concur. Prayers help.

[@leewilliams2312]

Correct don't let it get you remember religion is of the devil kids this say no pray on your own

[@johnmcguigan3]

@@leewilliams2312 I almost had a stroke trying to read this sentence.

[@Anonymous-pm7jf]

It's called liberalism

[@KimmieSue.]

​@user-yf3ws7xs1f yep demons go to ppl who allow it. They're already at a low vibration so it's easy for the demon to come to them.

[@nillyk5671]

That woman making things worse, drawing attention to herself by yelling "let me out".

[@krystingrant6292]

Exactly they all want to get out come on now

[@bronxkies]

She was IRRITATING! Screaming let me out while the doors are closed and nobody can get out. Girl, bye.

[@seviregis7441]

@joshuaadams1538that was a different woman.

[@hove785]

@joshuaadams1538it wasntvthe same woman!!

[@KingCourts-sw9fx]

She was scared. Thank God they're all got out safe

[@kfeder76]

America let the third world in now this is what we get. America's best days are long gone.

[@therealness775]

How you get shot by your own gun after talking all that shit??? Bully ran into a real one and paid the price.

[@johnpatrick1588]

Being under the assumption the bigger guy is the 36 year old and the aggressor and armed with a gun and knife. The 32 year old seemed to be avoiding physical contact with the aggressor. The 32 year old apparently wound up defending himself by using the aggressor's gun and succeeded. This is where NYC also sucks at protecting citizens if "charges are pending" against a person defending himself is an accurate statement. Perhaps just an investigation to see if charges are warranted is more accurate I hope.

[@andolini9639]

Either way the big guy met his fate.

[@soulknob9991]

He didn't have a knife. The girl that didn't run away took a knife out of her bag and stabbed him. I'm not defending the A hole but that is part of what happened.

[@aaronraysor8005]

You have to watch the uncensored video...the aggressor was stabbed in the back by the female when the men were fighting. The aggressor then pulled out a gun and threatened to shot her. Some how the gun was taken from the aggressor and he was shot several times. This was not self defense...the aggressor was stabbed and shot.

[@andolini9639]

@@aaronraysor8005 the aggressive man provoked the situation. To my understanding the woman was with the little guy and in a panic mode she was protecting him by stabbing the aggressive man. I would also protect my loved ones by any means necessary, even if it lands me in jail.

[@SparkleInYourEyes2024]

​@@andolini9639We don't know that.

[@mr.sir.]

Excuse me? How did this happen with the national guard apparently at each station checking people?! What a joke

[@michaelalvarado7176]

Those checks waist of time..need to patrol the trains

[@ItsMeSadeNYC]

They're usually on their phones.

[@spirit13the1st6]

They are not at each station, random stations. Gov just threw them in there without a plan. Get your story straight the man who got shot instigated the whole thing the victim took his gun and shot him with it.

[@Heavensxcitement]

Because that is an actual lie being told for social media 🙄

[@asiagrabowska5092]

They protecting critical infrastructure like Pen Station not us.

[@valarieosborne2958]

A horrible place to live!!!! Absolutely awful!!!

[@ps_nyisgone]

or work or go to school or go on vacation

[@JoseGomez-lp2fi]

That guy should be put behind bars for the rest of his natural life for putting so many lives at risk.

[@CarolynMScotti-gr5ut]

It must have been terrorizing for the 32 year old, who got on the train and was terrified by this 36 year old welding a weapon.. This was terrorizing for everyone on the train. This man should not be charged with a crime, he was defending himself.

[@MariaGonzalez-nv3nl]

He had a knife first, , then he beat the guy then shot him. Guy was just holding on t his bag. N t female tried t protect him .

[@lponm]

Your daily reminder that Daniel Penny is still facing murder charges in NYC for only physically defending himself from a criminal very similar to this one.

[@cameojefferson7779]

This is sad the man pulled the gun on him

[@johnlewis3891]

Daniel Perry was not defending himself. Jordan Neely did not assault anyone at the time of the shooting and Daniel Perry came up and attacked Jordan from behind. Furthermore even if Daniel had been acting in self defense, he chose to go beyond what was allowed by continuing to strangke Jordan even when Jordan was unconscious and no longer a threat.

[@Nanovor4444]

Daniel Penny wasn’t defending himself. He inserted himself into the situation and led to killing the man through asphyxiation

[@mannogroneg1248]

Different scenario here, Daniel is a trained soldier. The homeless guy had no weapon. A weapon was pulled on this guy, that was self-defense.

[@9Mountains9]

He belongs in jail he shouldn’t have let his ego make him actually put an entire train of people in danger by trying to prove his masculinity and fight this man. He should’ve ignored him and saved his life and not put others at risk

[@hollywooddre5]

That's why I'm not feeling New York. Too many unstable people out and about on public transportation in a condensed area where people minding their business are spectators and victims.

[@Mateoski97]

As an NY native that lives in North Carolina, you're better off staying away from NY.

[@WarrenSofine-tp7qf]

YOU CAN TELL THE GUY WAS NO MIGRANT SMH I GLAD HE IS NOT CHARGED

[@LargeDude2023]

I was born and raised in NYC. It saddened me to see what the city has become. A lot of violence, thieves, rats, and bums, illegal aliens, etc. I saw on the news that there were several groups protesting the increased law enforcement presence in the stations ... WTF??

[@bruinflight1]

You're kidding right? NYC has been a dump since 1900. Prove me wrong.

[@LargeDude2023]

@@bruinflight1 I moved away in 1984. I'm not disagreeing, but its gotten even worse. At least you used got be able to go into places like CVS without everything being locked up for example.

[@johnw.8782]

NYC is not worse than the 1980's man. Get out of here. The 1980's were the center of the crack epidemic.

[@looneymacmittins]

How old are you?

[@DD-pt9qw]

@@LargeDude2023I was going to ask if you moved away. Otherwise I would feel sorry for you if you didn’t.😢

[@juliepiemonte3268]

If you ban guns, only bad guys will have them. Legal carrying people could have taken care of it quickly. But no, you have to cry about guns, not thugs. The insanity of it all.

[@Jerseyan]

Facts! 💯

[@elisac.3179]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣, el típico comentario estúpido de los enfermos de las armas.

[@queenoftheworld1]

@@elisac.3179it’s not dumb. It’s common sense.

[@asiagrabowska5092]

Democrats

[@elisac.3179]

@@queenoftheworld1: ¿Así? ¿Y dónde están los "chicos buenos con armas" cuando se les necesita? ¡Nunca están!

[@theroadking547]

He fucked around and found out

[@rochellet1333]

This is so sad. Those poor people. Terrified.

[@subie38x]

No one is coming to save you!!! You have and always will be on your own to protect yourselves. This is just the beginning of whats to unfold on us Americans.

[@jtkaldk6832]

🎯

[@1notgilty]

Exactly right! Imagine the scene in NY City and the other big city cesspools when the SHTF. Anybody within a three day walking distance from a major city is in for a Mad Max situation. The average person will walk 10 miles per day. A good rule of thumb is to estimate 20 miles per day. Thus, if you are within 60 miles of a major metropolitan area when the SHTF you are in BIG trouble.

[@aaronraysor8005]

@@1notgilty You must be from Levittown.

[@Patricia-kh3bg]

Yep… Complete lawlessness.

[@spirit13the1st6]

I believe that. FBI STATS SHOW MURDER EVERY 31 SECONDS IN AMERICA.

[@user-zf6nl4zl9q]

What is really happening to the hearts of mankind,Why is all this fighting and killing all this Anger and bitterness Why not just walk away

[@dcrijo]

Unbelievable man...I'm glad no one else was hurt. For those New Yorkers who have to deal with cramped spaces like a train on a daily basis...I feel for ya man. Wish people would just talk things over or just simply RESPECT one another so everyone can go about their business in a safe manner.

[@ulyssesharris6249]

Self defense all the way around!

[@dumamay283]

I see alot of cops standing near station turnstile at flushing station looking for people using the wrong metrocard or jumping the turnstile to catch them, BUT IRARELY SEE THEM IN THE TRAINS OR UNDER THE STATION looking for criminals...It's all pointless and easy overtime money for cops. All this is a charade, it doesn't help anybody

[@juanventura5692]

Listen i don't blame them, the laws/strategies got flipped and they don't want to be outcasted as the "Agressors".

[@jtkaldk6832]

To be honest idc what’s going on I’m not wit the searching me that’s been a dead issue crime is crime it’s gonna happen whether Times Square,a train ,the suburbs anywhere just never know .Could’ve been a billionaire riding the train stray bullet that’s it or walking down a street .My point is there’s no control on life or should I say what the next person does how would we know search every single person?Stop it

[@asiagrabowska5092]

No cash bail.

[@christianjmj6460]

Incompetent politicians.

[@blade_warrior_blue]

Are the politicians this guy's parents?

[@jtkaldk6832]

@@blade_warrior_blue😂😂😂😂😂

[@Yogurt_Fingers]

Basketball people..

[@aeonsbeyond]

What do politicians have to do with this absolutely nothing . People just talk absolute garbage shit hole nonsense

[@9Mountains9]

This is not a politicians fault this is two stupid egos at fault

[@tyronedavis3435]

This is crazy man…. I’m pretty all of this was really over nothing! The guy that was quiet had the right to defend himself and the other dude had to face the consequences!

[@mariatheresavonhabsburg]

Not crazy but racist.

[@Bauks]

The cameraman forgot she had the plot armor.

[@sasfiremaiden840]

These poor people were trapped with NO way out!!!😢

[@highvibefreqzshow5967]

Let you out?? No, you stay there and finish recording the damn video. Don’t you know the cameraman is immortal?

[@highvibefreqzshow5967]

@@user-yf3ws7xs1f Yeah she must have forgotten the everlasting might of the filmer. 🤷‍♂️ The part where she turns the camera back on herself while screaming in terror to “let me out” said it all. She became part of the scene and now who’s filming who? 🤣🤣

[@DAnimaeee]

🤣🤣🤣

[@jxmai7687]

Was that acting ATM?😂

[@kalikush6286]

Clout is high quality, but when it wears off ,it's crashing out

[@altheadawn2531]

Have you tested this theory out yourself? 🤔

[@lorencast]

This crazy man was fully armed! The 32 year old was defending himself. The 36 year old was bullying the other guy because he looked small. I’m sure he didn’t provoke him, these kind of people get angry if you just look at them! It’s happened to me! Maybe the 32 year old saved people’s lives that day by taking the gun from him!!

[@MARDISTRONG-qv2cx]

That was really hard to watch and listen to, but this is exactly what the government wants people to turn on the new people and create such a chaos and I’m glad you were able to film. Let us know what’s really going on in the street thank you whoever this is.

[@waynewisecarver]

The loud, lazy, vulgar, and violent.

[@silveraire]

and now almost dead

[@rochellemosley9480]

I would have started moving when they first started arguing on that train I would have been at the front😢

[@DAILYDRIVENREVOLUTION]

they always bullying people on the trains

[@JD-mu7qm]

Where is the national guard?? Smh joke

[@jphilbin528]

This is really disturbing. No one should have to live like this, 3rd world country material.

[@madelineharkins5643]

Damn skippy!

[@jc605__]

It's going to get a lot worse.

[@user-xg3uy6hq9g]

actually @@jc605__its far better than it was in the 1960s, 70s and 80s

[@stefan.agnello9772]

Sanctuary city!

[@camilabarrera6403]

Well…USA is a 3rd world country, only difference is it has more money 🤷‍♀️

[@MsAmericanthinker]

When seconds count, cops are minutes or hours away.

[@JaydenGeorges]

I been living in nyc for my life and thank god I never witnessed something like this

[@sportluck9167]

New York sucks so much!

[@jtkaldk6832]

Pause I agree tho

[@nikkipost9858]

❤ my city but this ish trash

[@sportluck9167]

@@nikkipost9858 Are you born in New York? I wasn’t born in Manhattan, but my family moved there when I was a little kid.

[@nenaj1]

Nyc u mean

[@AggravatedMan365]

@@nenaj1 Exactly! I see none of this trash up here in Dutchess

[@recordgalaxy]

MTA and the witch Hochul will ban this video , as it will scare away riders , just watch and go ahead with their dumb congestion pricing

[@jtkaldk6832]

Man up busta the show gotta go on .

[@mountaintiger6945]

They better start making Express Busses cause no one (with half a brain) getting on the train anymore.

[@Elevatorelectricgate]

There are express buses?...

[@AggravatedMan365]

Tyrone starting trouble again

[@teastrainer3604]

The media narrative is that segregation was a bad thing and the country is better off now.

[@DfromBoston]

😂😂😂

[@user-er3ri6sc3j]

Which Tyrone?

[@reesebloom8093]

😂😂😂

[@kmc5887]

this is EXACTLY what the people in the city voted for. most of them didn't connect the dots on what city's soft on crime policy would do to them, until now. yet most of them would still vote the same way. I don't directly blame the politicians, I blame the voters. those public offices are not self appointed, they are voted in

[@Puff_Chady]

Words are words, but the 32 year old got up to throw hands when he really didn't have to.

[@raihanjoy5949]

I Never Agree No Harassment Ever Again

[@jamesmontoban1338]

Shorty went from recording to....let me outtttttttttt smh. Found out real quick that everything ain't for the internet 😂

[@simplyshanbrown3684]

But then again, how would there be any proof of what happened? They have cameras on the new trains, not the old ones (the one they were on)

[@zaritaleehetheru4753]

What makes me sad about watching this is how desensitized the passengers are to the whole situation. No one seems to care about the argument. Then when they do realize it is escalating, not one person showed a sign of emotion. There was no fear or worry, everyone seems so robotic. This video is in America, but I feel like this is the state of humanity everywhere.

[@susanschroeder3512]

Did it ever OCCUR to you that they felt vulnerable so they shut down out of pure TERROR?

[@zaritaleehetheru4753]

​ @susanschroeder3512 Hell no! stop playing and learn how to read the room. We have one person (filming) who is laughing, and we have multiple people who are genuinely ignoring the situation. I appreciate that you want to believe these people felt vulnerable, but psychologically the reality vs actions don't make sense. A person who feels vulnerable shys​ "AWAY'. Meaning that you MOVE AWAY. There are people who shut down, but even they will move away. Stop.

[@susanschroeder3512]

@@zaritaleehetheru4753 HELL YES, stop your lack of Empathy and learn how to connect with others. We have one person (filming) who is laughing nervously, soon to 'read' he's whipping a gun out and FIRST to exit and we have multiple people who are genuinely praying go GOD in silence to be spared, not wanting to draw attention to themselves. I appreciate that you appreciate, but psychologically, the shooter is PSYCHO and SILENCE makes sense. A person who feels vulnerable FREEZES. Stop.

[@jillmondt5398]

You Tube, you need to stop censoring.

[@lunhil12]

What needs to change is our American culture of violence.

[@globalautobahn1132]

Well, to be honest, a certain section of society needs to change their culture of violence because if you removed their statistics from the national statistics America suddenly becomes one of the safest countries in the world. Just saying those are statistics and facts that you won’t hear from politicians.

[@spirit13the1st6]

Maybe you guys didnt know this But every 31 seconds someone gets murdered in our wonderful country. FBI STATS

[@user-ym3yw9mh8f]

The problem is primarily one culture.

[@winstonwebb8199]

Now u talking the real thing

[@dancollins8296]

Violence has been a part of humans since humans began walking the earth. No different than other animals.

[@marieabineau]

ny citizens have a bullseye on their back....all thanx to mayor adams and gov. hokel....

[@astronaut8917]

and they will keep voting democrat lol

[@dlovestar]

We need to VOTE THEM OUT. SOCIALISTS!!!!

[@GodBlessTheChild1]

That’s the exact Subway station where Michael Jackson filmed the “Bad” video. Guess they didn’t get the message. “Thank You!” for sharing

[@SANE172]

Really?

[@PowaFuuWOOMAN]

That girl stabbed the dude from behind while they were fighting then says i didn't do nothing 😂

[@PawelR-sj8uw]

absolute ignorance, failed parenting and inability to understand life isnt about gangster rap and dumb thug culture.