Marantz av8805 vs Emotiva RMC-1 |Which is Best?

[@chadm4976]

I had to check if this was on x2 speed lol

[@TheJoeyPeacock]

You know, a fabulous comparison would be the Emotiva RMC-1 vs Arcam AV40 vs AudioControl Maestro M9 (or M5). Now that's a review that would solve a lot of questions for a *LOT* of folks! *Thanks for considering*

[@dwalker112]

The “second” sounds a lot more dynamic and detailed 👍🏾

[@ChannelBri]

They both sounded just like my system

[@johto]

@@ChannelBri LOL

[@scottyo64]

@@ChannelBri FYI if I play on KZbin a hand held radio and then a 2 channel system I promise you will hear the difference. You can hear the difference even though it won't be what I hear in person

[@colinburger8926]

@@scottyo64 There is so much wrong with what you just said its not even worth the argument.

[@danielseguin913]

I like that clear and honest video. You are not afraid to tell which sounded best to your opinion. Thanks for sharing.

[@rickgarza265]

I go emotiva all the way ... they also have a buy back program that allows you trade in your old unit for an updated or new model . With Marantz, you are stuck with that processor and it lack of flexibility

[@michaelthomas4125]

Thanks for the video. I have a Marantz but have never heard the Emotiva. I'm sure they are both good but I always wanted a Marantz. Also have an Onkyo for a different application. They both do what I need and fit my budget. But I love this stuff and may upgrade at anytime depends on what I think I need at the time lol. Thanks again for the videos. They have been getting much better since I started watching your channel 👍👍👍.

[@keepingupwiththejones2933]

Glad to see you cleaned up the front of the theater. Looks really good.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Heyyy you noticed. Yeah I got a floating shelf custom made for my house. I think it looks good.

[@keepingupwiththejones2933]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude honestly the front has never looked that good. that floating shelf is awesome

[@sj7624]

For the movies, that definitely goes to the Emotiva RMC-1. But for music, that goes to the Marantz AV8805.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

interesting :)

[@jimmy2shoes75]

Usually the other way around, Dirac for music

[@vicvlz]

That's what I'm hearing too. R J was right. I also think the Emotiva's volume is a bit higher than the Marantz that's why you hear a lot more detail on the Emotivas compared to the Marantz.

[@chriswelljack4910]

@@vicvlz its not it sound louder because you hearing more if the details

[@chriswelljack4910]

Wrong the marantz sounds more compressed the emotiva is wide and open

[@joshpeters7392]

Great video! And I really like the sound clips that you included! And at the end of the day, it is all about sound quality - which is why this unit is so tempting. I really, REALLY want to love this product, but my biggest hesitation with Emotiva are the promises that are made for something in the future, that doesn't come to market for years, or ever. The XMC-1 was supposed to be upgradeable to HDMI 2.0, to Atmos, and to DTS:X.... But the HDMI 1.4 to 2.1 upgrade took more than 3 years for them to release after HDMI 2.1 had been standardized. And they had discussed an Atmos option as well, for years, that according to their forums sounds as though it was beta tested, but never released. My hesitation with this product is Dirac will at some point be available. At some point, you can upgrade to more channels. At some point, it might have airplay. And at some point, it will support DTS:X Pro. (This is all very well documented in their forums and discussed by their lead engineer as well as the president.) But until then, you're paying a premium price for a product that 1) doesn't have many of it's promised features available now and 2) until recently, you were essentially beta testing (The RMC-1 has been out for well over a year now) I'm also not an engineer, but have been looking into the differential balanced v. balanced subject a bit. I want to state that I could be wrong here... But I don't understand what the benefit of a fully balanced circuit is, when it's built into the pre/pro, unless the pre/pro is creating internal noise that would have to be canceled out. Especially if it's a digital source. The soundtrack is presented digitally to the processor, which then isolates the soundtrack into discrete channels, which then sends each individual channel signal to the DAC, which then gets output to the speaker via the XLR connection. The only interference in that path would have to come from within the RMC itself. So my question to Emotiva would be does their product create a lot of RF noise or interference where they felt they required a fully balanced circuit, or, is this just more of a marketing ploy? My closing thought is this.... From a sound quality perspective, this product looks like a winner. But it just has too much promised for the future that isn't available yet. I hope that this is considered by many people reviewing the product in hopes that it applies some pressure to Emotiva to get some of these things delivered before they give it a thumbs up to buy now. If it had room correction, if they had expansion modules for it now, I think it could be a winner. But until they deliver at least something they have promised, I just can't justify buying it now. (Others are absolutely welcome to feel different.)

[@FURognar]

2 years later. Still no DTS:X-PRO

[@HermesTrismegistes369]

When you popped out with your blue shirt I thought you were gonna go into a chiropractic skit, haha. I'm seriously gonna have to look into emotiva. Great video !

[@josecuervo3351]

Interesting... the sound was noticeably different even coming out of cell phone speaker. On the second demo the glass shatter, gun clicks, and music was clean and crisp. So if we account room correction software (Dirac >> Audessey) capability, then Emotiva win by a significant margin.

[@Bogenvibrato]

At 16.26 and further you can clearly hear that the Marantz has a better resolution. Compared to the finer Marantz the Emotiva sounds a little bit more like a telefon. But I have to admit that the emotiva has more power, dynamics and sparkle on the film-sequences. So I would go for the Marantz because in the end music-quality is what matters for me.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Good reasoning my man :)

[@officialthetubeofyou]

I agree with you marantz did a better job in music, but emotiva took the upper hand in movie. Actually, I would go to 2ch for music at the end of the day. The marantz sounded too clinical in music, but which av amp doesn't sound clinical and flat?

[@FitraHomestead]

Awesome video man, smashed it!! I was really hoping that the second one was marantz as it sounded noticeably better in every aspect. I love marantz for their ease of use and everything just works out of the box, hdmi switching no major bugs etc. I am hoping that they can iron out the issues with the emotiva so it becomes as intuitive and easy to use as the marantz because if they can then I will definitely be getting it. That's not even getting started on audessey vs Dirac with Dirac being a clear winner. One thing I can't live with is a clunky experience, I don't care how good it sounds if it lags, hdmi switching issues and things like that then I am not buying it.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

The Hdmi switching issue has been resolved with the updates. Since this is a software based platform alot of the issues are fixed via usb updates in DAT format

[@josealfredfernandes]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude which is best processor according your opinion? Sound quality, channels, immersive wise, etc

[@tomcat3941]

Finally I have my Emotiva RMC-1 and the corresponding power amplifier, XPA 5 GEN 3. I am simply thrilled with the sound quality. In contrast to my Denon X8500H, Emotiva plays in a completely different league. Too bad that Emotiva is totally unknown in Germany. But luckily we have at least one distribution here in Germany. Keep up the good work and greetings from 🇩🇪. 👍🇺🇸 SFC Papajewski

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Yeah. I was really surprised for their to be such a big difference in sound.

[@scottyo64]

Wow what a difference. I have been using Emotiva gear for my 2 channel setups for a few years but never tried their HT stuff. I am just running a Marantz SR 7012 for my 7.2.2 I do find most people have NO experience with Emotiva gear but like to talk smack about them.

[@vongdong10]

The Emo definitely sounds better. There's more detail, especially in that John Wick scene. You could clearly hear the glass/pottery breaking whereas it sounded muted on the Marantz.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

yeah. I noticed that too.

[@kevonmanuel]

When I tell my friends that I have a home theater, they are like... "what's that?"

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

HAHA. yeah you right. My buds could care less until there is a Game on

[@googoo-gjoob]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude , (couldn't care less)

[@scottnorris9079]

My wife just prefers to watch shows on her phone. 😢

[@googoo-gjoob]

@@scottnorris9079 , good for you!

[@scottnorris9079]

googoo gjoob I suppose it is... never thought of it that way. Thanks!

[@peerguy]

Very good video. Marantz sound was warmer and Emotiva was more open and clear. I liked Emotiva. I have the Marantz 7706, so cannot complain about these two flagship products 😊

[@1LibranRabbit]

Like your videos, you mention doing a full review on the Emotiva RMC-1, when might this happen?

[@dzemoski45]

The mids are more noticeable and upfront on the RMC-1, that’s why it sounds the way it does. Whereas the Marantz has the AK DACs who are known to produce a very warm sound, but if you play with the EQ you can bring up the mids higher if need be.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

they are the same ak 4490 dacs. the marantz just arent mono

[@claypf4795]

When you go into an A/V shop, they don't usually let you really mess around with the equipment a whole lot. I'd love to see the on-screen menus, if it has options you can assign to each input such as video processing and volume trim, the GUI for speaker calibration, little options like whether you can override the surround codec when your set-top device is playing a 2-channel movie through a 5.1 PCM stream, etc. Nobody seems to touch on these details.

[@chrisharpe7736]

Emotiva processors are very basic looking, although you can rename/assign each input. I have to admit that I like Yamaha's gui interface. Having a visual of the changes is always a nice touch. With Emotiva you get ordinary text. Once you're used to navigating the menus, you'll find that it's pretty intuitive. There have been a few horribly designed menus, from all brands, that are very difficult to figure out. Maybe Emotiva can eventually make a beautiful gui, but it likely won't be available on anything they're going to offer this decade. Btw, I do not own the rmc-1, but do have the xmc-1. I'm very happy with the xmc-1 and will likely move to the xmc-2 when the trade-in option is available. The xmc-2 will offer the same dac that's in the rmc-1, but shared between channels, with the exception of the 3 front channels. These will have mono dacs for increased resolution. "Audiophile quality AKM4490 Verita DACs, operating in fully balanced Mono mode on the left, center, and right channel." From Emotiva's website

[@mariagiordano3902]

emotiva GUI stinks like vaginosis and dont have an app like others , the marantz GUI makes you feel all warm and fuzzy fun to use. Emo is a hassle to use when using and has glitches .hieroglyphics , you can tell a linux computer is running the show cause it does slow down when using the menu it can get sluggish just navigating then you get that annoying click . it does sound good cant take that away from it , best i ever herd but comes at a price and not $$ your aggravation . I dont want to return it but im not totally happy with it . the menu ergonomics are not there . some smart pencil neck programmed it that didn't want to hear anything anyone had rot say and thats how you get the xmc-2. its the year 2022 GUIs are here to stay and they have to be good not sub par..

[@Emperor36]

I love the video and I tell ya it's all about what you want. Gonna be a hard decision when I need to upgrade. Thank you for the great video HTD.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

cool beans ralph

[@Punisher-1]

So which processor of the two did you keep?

[@pascachi]

Obviously the Emotiva is the winner! Never owned a Marantz but a friend has one that will move to Emotiva after listening with my system!

[@38special4ever]

Make sure you do a video on using REW for measuring and auto creating PEQ filters for the Emotiva. Seems like a very nice feature to use while waiting for Dirac Live.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

I can. Historically people do not care for my REW vids so I usually delete them

[@38special4ever]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude I think people would be interested, since there is no Dirac Live available yet? Doesn't have to be super technical.. just point out the possibilities and your impressions of the result.

[@hi-fihaven2257]

Man of many talents! Great work on the video. Thanks much for all the great information. Both of the units sound awesome. I am using a Yamaha AVR as a preamplifier for my 5.2.2 system. I have been looking at pairing it up with the Emotiva BasX A-700. I am currently using multiple Parasound A23's , that are using a lot of electricity. I have a smaller theater room, I think the A-700 has plenty of power for my needs.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

haha yeah. I had to add a 20amp circuit to the house!

[@josealfredfernandes]

​@@ThatHomeTheaterDude Hey. Can I use studio monitors along with Emotiva processor? 15x JBL 308P MKll + 1x JBL 5628 sub

[@derekhoshaw3072]

Thinking of buying rmc-1 now or go with Marantz?

[@johnf517]

Congrats on Chiropractic Career... all the best with Internship... with your personality and communication skills, you will do extremely well....

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Whaaa? I am terrible at communication. Im trying to get better though :)

[@mikoz2682]

Can you please explain what you’re trying to accomplish by showing video and audio clips of both processors on KZbin? Video is pass through, bit for bit, what point does showing it attempt to make? Should I expect to hear a difference on my iPad viewing your recordings from some probably low bit rate source?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

There is a difference in audio. Video, i dont think there is from what i saw. You may not get the full experience online,but it is perceptible. Maybe grab a good set of headphones

[@raymondtaveras9371]

The second sounds better even the dialogue is clearer than the first and it would sound better if I were there

[@robertoromero8305]

Question for you. Which do you think made the most difference with the sound detail on the RMC: mono DACs or fully differential outputs? I'm not an electrical engineer so I'm trying to understand from a technical perspective. Thanks!

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Roberto Romero if I were to guess, it would be a combo of the fully balanced chassis from input to output and the mono dacs.

[@robertoromero8305]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude were you running the RMC with a differential amplifier as well?

[@ratz34]

Regarding the Emotiva UI Yes it's sluggish. This has been an issue sense the XMC-1. For what ever reason Emotiva is not good at the quality of life aspects of their products. HDMI handling is another issue. I hope this has been improved with the newer Panasonic chips. Regarding Dirac Live vs Audyssey Having used Pioneer MCACC, Yamaha YPAO, DENON Audyssey XT32 Pro, and Emotiva Dirac, I can say I do not like using any automatic room correction. Instead I much prefer the Yamaha/Emotiva manual PEQ. If Yamaha had freely adjustable PEQ settings like the XMC-1 then it would be the brand I would recommend for 99% of users out there. Having said that only the Audyssey XT32 actually matched or came very close my manual PEQ settings. The MCACC, YPAO, and Dirac all completely kill any freq below 80 hz and boost everything above 12khz. This creates an uneven response when measuring with Room EQW and my UMIK-1 while independently verifying any adjustments made by these Auto Room Correction programs. So I find I tend to lean towards products with PEQ for manual control, which for some reason is not that many in the sub $4k range. Anyone offering a unit that cost north of $1500 should not have a 9 band EQ as a manual option.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

again, the HDMI issues have been resolved with updates to the software.

[@nyrep1]

really surprised how different they sound ... even over youtube and headphones ...a clear difference

[@cgleisberg3355]

Love more Marantz.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

which do you own?

[@troybrownentertainment2324]

Marantz AV7705 works good for me😂

[@nyrep1]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude me? neither i am a 2 channel guy , planning for a HT

[@kevinschreckengost4148]

Everything sounds good at Best Buy then when you get it home it sounds like shit.

[@patrickjohncarlo]

1st..fan of your videos, im from philippines.

[@johnsmith-qz4bv]

i dont have experince with either one but i think they are both good...anyone could be happy with either prossesor....great video....they both sound great

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Cool beans John

[@michaelharness3258]

My XMC was supposed to be upgradable. Too.

[@m.s.5313]

Well technically there is (or will be when they are all released) an upgrade path to the new crop of Emotiva Pre's with different price points based on your existing XMC-1.

[@markhampton7559]

THTD, great video. Thanks for the side by side. Is the audio going into the processors SPDIF, or using the HDMI connection? Since you are a Texas boy ( just moved to Kansas from Texas), I wanted to suggest a few music demo tracks: Greg Brown -- "Dear Wrinkled Face" and "Tender Hearted Child", Dead Can Dance -- "How Fortunate the Man with None", Muddy Waters -- "My Home is in the Delta", Heart -- "Stairway to Heaven (Live at the Kennedy Center Honors)". Thanks again...

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

HDMI. The tidal app on my laptop is the first layer of "unfolding" the hi-res tracks. The master files are send through the hmdi and i used stereo reference mode to recreate the sound. that is no eq no processing and no bass management. sounds incredible

[@chriswyatt9868]

To me the Marantz sounds better, The Emotiva sounded to bright. But were both of these set to direct or was Audyssey used on the Marantz. They should be tested with no room correction since Emotiva doesn't have Dirac yet. And if Audyssey was used what setting was used, Reference, L/R bypass or Flat. I have the AV8805 and the Reference is warm sounding,Flat is more on the brighter side. For a fair comparison both units need to bypass the eq or use direct mode.

[@spencerbigum1309]

Interesting - making me wonder about my recent setup with a Denon 4500 9.2 hooked up to an Emotiva XPA5 channel amp to expand it to 11.2. At least I know what to upgrade to one day lol

[@unknownkosmos1822]

Fisrt and second? Which is the first and which is the second??

[@prabhuveleie]

First is which device and second is which device?

[@svenkrause1844]

Who sounds better Rotel 1580 MK II or Marantz 8805 / 8077 ?

[@haknys]

Thanks for your excellent work. Even via headphones (and no dirac!), its easy to spot the differences. Must be an amazing processor, and I hope they iron out the bugs. :)

[@gsmd770]

Thanks great video! I've got my eye on that Marantz! RANGERS Lead The Way!!!!!

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Yeah me too

[@jiriza84641]

All I need is MOTRIN, you know how it works I have M&M's. Good Luck on your journey! ANOTHER GREAT REVIEW, BY THTD . I hear the Emotiva sounded more crisp in sound! Which Fan are you using for the Marantz?

[@thesauce669]

I grew up with Marantz and McIntosh products as my dad was into his gear in the 70s and 80s. Although these products are still great, someone can not convince me that Emotiva and the likes of direct to consumer brands are crap. My whole soundstage is powered by Emotiva an XPA5 and two monoblocks. EMOTIVA dollar for dollar is TOUGH to beat. Plus customer service is top notch.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

right on man

[@lexiewilkinson9703]

wow i dint expected such a difference even on youtube the Rmc1 hit harder much clearer and dynamic very clean.... Maratz sound good with music! i wont be able to got back once i got a rmc1 lol maybe one day!

[@jaycarneygiants]

I actually prefer the Marantz sound to the Emotiva when you were playing the music. I didn't notice a difference during the movie parts. The Marantz had a softer sound to me and the Emotiva seemed bright. It's all in what the individual thinks sounds better I guess. To each his own. Also 1 thing I noticed is that you pointed out the Emotiva upgrade path but did not mention that Marantz will upgrade the AV8805 to HDMI 2.2 when it comes out.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

i mentioned it in the 8805 review. I have no proof that it will happen. I will ask them tomorrow at RMAF

[@jaycarneygiants]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude www.soundandvision.com/content/marantz-unleashes-hdmi-21-upgradeable-flagship

[@gibluap]

AC infinity rocks! Love it as well

[@attilaadam7497]

Hi If I buy emotiva xmc 2 , I need to buy amplifiler to contact in to the speakers ?

[@IamVintage72]

Definitely

[@spiritgeometry8440]

Emotiva seems you dialled in louder and more bass. The Marantz sounded lower bass added. Thanks for the clarity.

[@ruknasty1]

Hey the home theatre dude. I have a fairly specific question. What's the best way to ask and get a quick response?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

travis beich you can ask it here. I’m traveling today so it probably won’t be the fastest response.

[@rajivchauhan3223]

Which was 1 and which was 2 while you placed the demo clips..u did not mentioned the brand name..

[@elipolancojr3219]

Awesome video bro. Keeping it real bro like always sweet. Keep them coming.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

I do keeps it real haha

[@kack7130]

it is true what you said about emotiva, software is buggy, menu is slow but the sound is great

[@bphilbac]

Thanks bro, great commentary and video!

[@michaeldelaney6256]

nah ill go see a real doctor who isnt selling snake oil, but i like your home theater videos...

[@jocyvarkey862]

Did you compare these two using a music DVD?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Paid tidal app on the laptop. they use master quality files that are higher res than cd

[@Punisher-1]

Would it be overkill to get the RMC-1 just for stereo listening and for a 3.1 setup?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

yes. go with the XMC-2 save you 2000 bucks and its fully differential on the front speakers LCR 3.0

[@Punisher-1]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude Thanks

[@lexiconthx1]

Awesome video been waiting for something like this. Looking forward to your full review of the rmc-1. Even through you tube I could tell more was there with the rmc-1. Really impressive. Looks like emotiva made a really nice bang for the buck processor.

[@stevemann3078]

My question is for the best way of hooking up a second amplifier for 2 or 4 channels of more speaker audio on a separate amp not cutting into the power of using all the channels on the main amp. what's the best way to hook this up and which sort of amplifier would you recommend is the secondary amplifier I do currently have the Denon 2400. and it works very well thank you audioholics,

[@gibluap]

Absolutely well said! I have had great EXPERIENCE WITH Emotiva.

[@10ny10]

I’m confused now 😂 I was going to go from the marantz 7012 to the cinema 50 but if I pivot to The emotiva then I also need an amp for that processor. Running a 7.2.4. Which I’d be looking at closer to 5 or 6 out the door.

[@brucecarter6205]

Good comparison. The volume level is clearly higher on the RMC-1. Easily noticeable imo.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

i normalized them to the same volume. The emotiva did have a pair of speakers on that the marantz didnt have. The extra headroom is probably what you are hearing.

[@brucecarter6205]

That Home Theater Dude, hard to say. That’s just what I hear from the crappy KZbin audio through my iPad Pro speakers. Interesting that they sound so different if everything is level matched.

[@truwarrior22]

@@brucecarter6205 What I find even more interesting is that the glass break scene from the movie thru my headphones sounds just like the Marantz. I suspect DIRAC is making it sound clearer though I think the Marantz maybe more true to source.

[@DTA_Crypto]

great video i was picking the second clip each time and in my head, I was thinking it was the Marantz every time, boy was I wrong. I wonder if its a wash to upgrade from a Denon x4400h to Marantz lated 9.2 channel receiver? anyway great video

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Maybe. I had the denon 4400 for over a year and the marantz sounded really nice on the 6014

[@PAINFOOL13]

Oh wow congrats on being a chiropractor 👍🏻 Listening on my Headphones 🤘🏻🤘🏻 Thanks Dude 👍🏻

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Thanks Brother

[@SteinerSE]

Well, a year and a half later and the Emotiva is still 16 channels as none of the advertised expansion/upgrade cards ever materialized.

[@erniebrown3187]

Home theather dude.... At 8:58 what did you find out about or mean about fully balanced on the Marantz?

[@avtechman77]

I was wondering about that too

[@DustinFrancis]

Marantz 8805 should be available for about $3650 from Greentoe, that’s what it shows “green” at. My 6014 was $1100 shipped to my door from Greentoe.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

whats a greentoe?

[@DustinFrancis]

That Home Theater Dude You don’t know about Greentoe? Greentoe.com is a wonderful site where you make an offer and it will get accepted or not and before hand they have a meter to show you if your offer is likely to be accepted. My 77” C9 was less than $4900 when I got it over a month ago and my 6014 was $1100 shipped to my door and these are with the full US warranties! They have extended warranties you can add on as well. It really is just a smarter way to shop if they carry what you are looking for. I think an offer of $3700 would for sure be accepted for the 8805 for example, but $3650 looks like it would too. These are with shipping and taxes included n the pricing as well :)

[@Quetzalcoatl0]

That Center channel should sound quite a bit better now. It's under foam and not surrounded with stuff to reflect sound from.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

its been on foam for the last year and a half It does sound more distinct now that its open air

[@oatekung]

Hello i use Marantz with MK plan to move to Emotiva because they got more channel. Could you please tell me emotiva is good at music too ?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

two channel yes, mutlichannel no, the bass is lacking

[@ebrahimalmehza2132]

Thanks for the video, may I know if the emotiva can work on 240 volts ac power please ?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

im pretty sure

[@chriswelljack4910]

Yes it can just plug n play

[@mikek.4211]

I use my system mainly for music, then movies. I love the Marantz signature sound, and especially since the Emotiva is 500 bucks more and has a bunch of glitches...no thanks. I currently have the Marantz AV8801 and I want to upgrade to the AV8805 for Atmos. I like Emotiva amps...I have three of them. I guess I will wait and see if Emotiva can get their shit together with this RMC-1. Until then, I will be buying the AV8805. Besides that, it looks soooo much better than the Emotiva.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Have you used the emotiva?

[@mikek.4211]

That Home Theater Dude just pictures. My AV8801 just had the HDMI board crapped out (I think) so I am looking for something with not only video processing, but SUPERB sound. More into music than anything, but want movie processing too. Considering both of these units. Not sure what to do. Does Emotiva have a “trial” period for their processors...as in returns if you don’t like it? Also, I need three HDMI zones Out. Hmmmm. What to do...

[@motogp3478]

Is the RCM 1 worth the extra $1000 over the XCM2 ??

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

the xmc2 is 3000 the rmc1L is 4000 and the rmc-1 is 5000. I have noticed a slight difference in sound of the rmc-1 over the xmc-2. Is it worth 2000 for the improvment? maybe. You get the ability to expand the rmc-1 too

[@adamjj85]

Great comparison! The Emotiva seems to be the clear winner. The question is, did you run any calibration on these before the tests?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

cal and db match was done before each test

[@adamjj85]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDudeGot it, thanks! I can only imagine how much further a lead the Emotiva would take if it had Dirac! Now you've got me doubting my original plan to put a Marantz in my upcoming primary theater build...

[@Punisher-1]

@@adamjj85 I was actually thinking of getting the 8805 but now that I saw this video I'm now considering the Emotiva. Also I will be getting their XPA3-Gen3.

[@kevinschreckengost4148]

You have to remember he is sponsored by Emotiva. Of course the Emotiva is going to win. I can't find any reviews on KZbin except his.

[@oatekung]

@@kevinschreckengost4148 i read all his comment. I think that he described that emotiva is good at 2 ch only.

[@motogp3478]

What's the name of that fan you were talking about ?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

here ya gp buddy amzn.to/2Od5d8A

[@motogp3478]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude in a completely open cabinet design would this still be necessary ? Using with XMC2

[@mitsukid82]

the conclusion shows how emotiva RMC-1 is more clearer and detailed. Right now there is a sale and I am finally getting the emotiva woot woot

[@dr.merakat]

I have a 7.2.4 system with bi-amping my fronts... i read both manuals before hand... and the 8805 had a config in the gui for my exact need... just seemed so much easier(maybe possible with the emotiva also, just didnt see it in the manual.. some preamps have more than enough channel processing but dont allow certain configurations.. they dont allow the channels to be assigned)... plus the 8805A allows me to game at 4k/120 on my xbox series x

[@cuchyto82]

i would like to know your cinema spec?

[@ctweedter]

I definitely hear that the Emotiva has better sound. Clearer and crisp sound.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

You got that right

[@joez7700]

Hi. I've had my RMC -1 now for about 3 weeks. Yes I agree the menu can be a bit slow at times. I pretty much use mine with a logitech harmony elite and that really helps with the user experience. Even with it's quirks it sounds amazing. So much better than the Yamaha cx a 5100 it replaced. The sound is much clearer and dynamic.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

yeah. its a little of a compromise, but Sound is what i am most interested in. if it sounds better i will deal with some stuff to make that a reality.

[@Scarczar]

Thanks so much for this comparison I have been waiting for, now I know I haven’t made the wrong decision returning the Marantz and getting the RMC 1.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Good Deal Chander

[@gibluap]

Does a surge protector /line conditioner suppress powered subs? I have heard so much I'm not sure. I have both of mine hooked to a Panamax m5300

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

you should be fine

[@avtechman77]

That Home Theater Dude.. Do you know if Emotiva will be adding IMAX Enhanced? If they do that, my AV8805 is history

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

they said they will look into adding them if people show interest in them

[@avtechman77]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude They got my vote

[@Gregturner1970]

I have a question for you you know how on your Denon or your Marantz remote control hit the option button and you go to channel level adjustment how do you have your Channel adjusted do you turn your channels all the way up or leave them on zero or the negative thank you

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

That depends on speaker placement, room size and speaker sensitivity. Alot of my levels are negative but some are over 0

[@Gregturner1970]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude ok thanks

[@awakenedsoul2638]

Marantz for Music hands down and Emotiva hands down for movies!

[@dankollars4501]

its so hard deciding what to get. i have a sunfire tgp5 right now but its dated and every time i have a power outage it loses all memory settings and i have to completely go thru it and re-enter settings. it has to go. does anyone have recommendations on an upgrade in sound quality over the sunfire. i have been very happy with the sunfire but its time to upgrade. i am leaning towards emotiva xmc1 because its reasonable priced. but is it an upgrade on sound?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

i run the xmc-2 for my daily driver right now. Functionality issues are minimal and sound is great.

[@Pitbull0669]

without Dirac and having them ship without all features deal breaker for me.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

PITBULL it has arc. Where did you hear it didn’t?

[@Pitbull0669]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude don't forget I do reviews for AVS forums I have access to a lot of stuff through through the years that most people probably never will. I just think they should have waited 2 put it out when everything was 100% with the product in all honesty if that's the case then I would use the Monoprice monolith version of that less money same features ships with Dirac

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Yeah. Well we cant fix that they released it before it was perfect, but i think they are definitely heading in the right direction. I completely forgot about the AVS reviews. What kind of stuff you get?

[@Pitbull0669]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude just had a full Paradigm set up towers subs, center,bookshelves. Working on supertweeters from Aperion. Had their top towers in too wow they were incredible.

[@andrewmanus5686]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude Maybe the confusion comes from about 7:30-7:40 where you mention it does not come with dirac enabled?

[@chriswelljack4910]

I can only imagine what dirac is gonna do for the emotiva sound if it can sound this good without room correction

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

They sent out my kit. We will know shortly

[@chriswelljack4910]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude yep am waiting for my kit also

[@desuhunachew2805]

Do you think old amplifire like 12 years and more buying from eBay is it safe.i dont be regrate .thank you.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

amps usually last a long time without maintenance

[@myhometheater7029]

Great information! Great video!!!!!!

[@darylRvillaescusa]

How come nobody talk about anthem mrx 1120? I would like to see comparison anthem and emotiva

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

The rep just took over in my region and isnt really in a place to send out review units. Hope he changes his tune soon

[@keepingupwiththejones2933]

Just invite some more people over to your home theater and your subwoofers will take care of giving people back issues and then you can adjust them before they leave. You can call it Bass Adjustments. You look like you lost some weight . Looks good on you. Beard looking tight. Dad life must agree with you.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

PFFT. I lost the weight before the kid. Now Im gaining it back haha. The beard is looking tight :)

[@keepingupwiththejones2933]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude well you still are looking fantastic I wish you the best of luck with your new career

[@geoman2188]

what do you think outlaw 7220?

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

dont know. never tested one. Im sure it sounds great. my model 2200s from outlaw were excellent

[@giovanniiossa3169]

Salve volevo sapere come vanno i finali emotiva?

[@mongoosevsgt]

when i played this through my yamaha cx 5200 they both sounded good. :P LOL

[@amars_handle]

The notable difference in sound between these two is 99% due to differences in EQ setup. If they both were set up properly and equivalently, the difference would be too subtle to hear on a KZbin video. In-person, I would expect the RMC-1 to have a very slight edge over the AV8805. A more fair and meaningful comparison would be to the XMC-2 - with both devices EQ'd exactly the same.

[@brucecarter6205]

Bingo!

[@sebna]

Sure especially that there was no EQ available at that time for Emo...

[@keepingupwiththejones2933]

So the Emotiva isn't like getting attacked by a shark? Emotiva is more like going for a nice jet ski ride in the bay with the sharks waiting nearby in the ocean. Sharks can't catch you on that jet ski. LOL

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

Shark attack phenomenon is when a shark attack happens out of the blue then you hear about 10 more right after. The media focused attention

[@keepingupwiththejones2933]

@@ThatHomeTheaterDude thank you for explaining I did already know that I was trying to make a lame joke. I usually use the analogy that when you buy a new car and then you think there's so many more of those cars being purchased it's just your now noticing them on the road because you bought one

[@MrBlur510]

Can you review something with room perfect. Maybe lyngdorf mp-50? Thanks

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

im pretty sure i heard one of those over the weekend. I could be wrong. right now. i have my contacts. if i make more then maybe more companys will send out more stuff.

[@Quetzalcoatl0]

For me the "second" sounded better. It's sounds to me more clear and there are some effects that i didn't hear in the "first". and the "second" one has a bit more bass.

[@ThatHomeTheaterDude]

You speak directly to my soul. thats exactly what I heard

[@alessioscoda5839]

I agree

[@ImportLenz]

I also agree