McLaren 570S vs Porsche 911 Turbo vs Audi R8 V10 | Top Gear

[@deneth3310]

*listens to the 570 sounds* Damn that sounds amazing, for a twin turbo too! *R8 revs* I beg forgiveness for doubting thou master

[@maincharacter2677]

Evil Gummy Bear correct it to 570 quickly.

[@g2stfu]

thy shall nay longer doubt thee

[@yusufchoudry414]

Evil Gummy Bear you are cringy af mate

[@juanvargas3475]

It happened to me as well when I first heard that Mclaren I was like damn that sounds good, and then I heard that r8 and I was like damn never mind!

[@Nash-xh3fi]

Guys, it’s a v8 to a v10

[@adenahmed7376]

This was in the magazine years ago

[@Elias_g1]

Yup !

[@Wuanty]

I can tell lol

[@lotusamg6997]

"One from Top Gear Magazine's archive" it's literally the first line of the description.

[@colinryan9188]

Literally in the description..."One from Top Gear Magazine's archive."

[@bazejwianecki9054]

This video seems to be quite old. I'm wondering why you haven't uploaded it before. 'Forthcoming 540c' That's a novelty... Edit: Yeah, It's not even a 991.2 turbo s in this video...

[@ebigford34]

its says from the archive...

[@mrbossup7143]

It got lost they found it now😂😂

[@kristianolsenlarsen]

Really you only noticed it because of a Porsche? I new when he didn't mention the 720S or the Senna but kept to talk about the 650/75 and P1

[@pingupongoo]

I also noticed this. When the guy was talking about the "ultimate series" of McLaren's, he never even mentioned the Senna. Like ??? How old is this lol

[@secondnumber396]

Błażej Wianecki they don't even talk about the 720s & the senna

[@eduardobatista5651]

The Location is "Serra da Estrela" in Portugal!

[@alexsiermann3491]

Dudu p

[@307skylake7]

Warning this comment needs parental guidance!

[@RenalTarigan]

didn't ask, but yeah

[@eduardobatista5651]

@@RenalTarigan I saw one or two questions about the location, so i Answered in the comments instead of responding to each comment. If you don't care about the info keep scrolling down ;)

[@Daniel-gb9ex]

They have great cheese too !

[@rehan12x72]

Like for Mclaren

[@wolfkung3942]

@@mgn567 Porsche 💩

[@Spaceman2484]

MGN What in the hell do you speak of

[@gerardov.9716]

McDonald's suck ass. Porsche and Audi is the way to go.

[@capicheeno746]

The mclaren doesn’t compare to the r8 or the Porsche, there so far much better engineered than the mclaren. Also the r8’s sound is superb, and the r8 and 911 are much more practical.

[@austin3873]

@@capicheeno746agreed. I honestly think the r8 is the most underrated supercar

[@ProTreeVideos]

Hey random person scrolling down the comments.. May you have a wonderful day :)

[@SpritSlash]

Oh that's nice

[@andrewrichardson7814]

And the same too you and all that see this.

[@Prince-fr2lr]

U 2

[@VeriStrawberi]

I'm not random! I'm me!

[@MrVocalist567]

"German Pagani?" No, sir. That's a whole 'nother level, sir.

[@gluca069just___it9]

He never has seen a Pagani, there is no other reason, that I can write in a public "forum", for making that statement.

[@Spaceman2484]

Gluca069 Just___it Caught me off guard too. Lol always a bigger fish

[@SuperCitygames]

Doesn't the porsche do 0-60 mph in 2.9 seconds? Well thats what porsche says we all know its faster .

[@louisperron4918]

Both the turbo s and r8 have been recorded under 3 seconds

[@AnthroGearhead]

2.7 if lucky

[@zakiry8634]

You can get a 650hp 570s, 0-60 in 2.8

[@LibinTom-Vlogs]

Absolutely Beautiful Filming and such gorgeous Cars. Mclaren Wins all the way.

[@Jenddy]

Verdict: 570s wins in all performance aspects, R8 wins all luxury aspects and has one of the best sounding engines in all supercars and hypercars, and 911 is in the middle with a little but of both luxury and performance.

[@Lewis360]

Put the Audi's engine in the McLaren and you create the perfect car.

[@Bob-nu3xe]

yep

[@grkhunter9265]

Just feel that V10! Audi!😍

[@falconnnn5]

Damn! That R8 V10

[@totalpackagedetailingllc4413]

Love the McLaren performance but personally for me and looking at the overall total picture of everything offered from interior to performance I would take the Audi V10, that sound is unique too!

[@AW_Cars-z9f]

65' plate on the R8, which means this comparison is already 3 yrs old

[@DylansCarReviews]

After watching this I still can't decide which one I prefer! I'm glad I don't have enough money to worry about it haha!

[@notchipotle]

that V10 sounds amazing, but I'll go with Porsche 🤣

[@nn-hz5cp]

Id take the Porsche

[@nn-hz5cp]

Porsche > McLaren 🤪

[@nn-hz5cp]

At LeMans, setting Nürburgring Records and perfecting German Ingenieuring 😉

[@Bombast-A-Blasta]

n n Damn that was BRUTAL

[@naveenbattula]

@@nn-hz5cp rekt him 😂

[@ashchen2857]

911👍

[@TheBoyJenius]

The good folks in Britain man. They really giving Ferrari and Porsche a run for their money. That 570S is such as good buy. Can’t go wrong with the 911, though. The R8, while I love mine, for some reason, I am attracted to the 1st Gen R8 more. It just a better looking car out the box to me. Maybe I’m weird I guess.

[@caydenthompson126]

I agree with you.

[@mrmarrow8918]

Another great video Ollie. I'd take the 911, partly as it's the least likely to break down.

[@dng992]

noob

[@WarriorsPhoto]

The Audi R8, is still my favorite of modern exotic cars. The V10 sound and experience is amazing. I don't race and/or plan to race, so that's why I would prefer it. Of course those other two cars would be the better choices if you're planing to seriously drive your modern exotic car hard. Good review. Thank you.

[@Spaceman2484]

ricky v Just want to point out that you don’t have to race to appreciate the razor sharp steering and acceleration. R8 is obviously still quite the beast though

[@WarriorsPhoto]

Spaceman24 Appreciate your input here.

[@sbklvr]

911 Turbo /Turbo S.... Best daily road going supercar since 1996.

[@josippongrac3040]

R8 looks best, sounds best. NA V10 for the win

[@SpritSlash]

the porsche looks the best tho, you lied there !

[@josippongrac3040]

@@SpritSlash I love Porsches in general, and this one looks great too, it's just that it isn't as unique as the r8. For me the r8 has one of the best car designs in 21st century, seems like it didn't age at all

[@andytaylor2321]

In the skin, 570 all the way.

[@jaronyuriyh7931]

Tbh that v10 sounds amazing, so does that flat six. Not much a fan of that twin turbo v8 tho

[@zakiry8634]

R8 does not look better than the mcclaren

[@DrummingAli93]

I don’t know why people act surprised when McLaren win group tests. Since the 675LT, the company has been on fire! The carbon tub and chassis are unrivalled, everything else comes as a bonus.... read ya magazines folks!

[@StevenSanchez_95]

Alastair Brown agreed

[@ergonaut940]

But the reliability..

[@DrummingAli93]

@@ergonaut940 & You think the other big guns in their first 10 years didn’t have reliability issues?

[@itreturnscribbles5660]

Sport series-540C,570S AND 600LT SUPER SERIES⚡-650LT,675LT,720S AND 765LT ULTIMATE SERIES🔥☄-P1,P1GTR,SENNA AND THE SPEEDTAIL GT-MCLAREN GT AND THE UPCOMING F1 SUPERGT

[@josedeleon1009]

One word, PORSCHE!

[@philsmucker5316]

three

[@eyesrightout]

Todays McLarens are somehow beyond any competition even Porsche. They are so clever, sublime, clear and fast

[@caydenthompson126]

I guess you didn't see the P1 get smoked by the 918...

[@juanvargas3475]

That screaming Italian v10 sounds amazing!!

[@capicheeno746]

It’s not screaming but it is amazing

[@AlejdiGallubja]

Who is italian

[@Dominikmj]

I’d say it depends what kind of car you would like to have.... I can’t really picture myself crouching out of a carbon tub everyday- have no significant space for luggage (...) etc. The MacLaren in my eyes is rather a second or rather third car for the weekend. The 911 turbo I see rather as everyday super car - while the Audi is definitely “daddies fun car while mummy is driving a more reasonable and practical SUV...

[@sniry123]

Why did you bring along an older generation non S car? The 991.2 turbo S would smash those 2..

[@longtailgt]

This test is actually about 2-3 years old. The 991.2 Turbo didn't exist at that time.

[@Cards8114]

@@longtailgt Turbo S**

[@longtailgt]

@@Cards8114 the Turbo didn't exist. The S is not even in the question.

[@andytaylor2321]

It is the S

[@boi1146]

It would be so close but that McLaren would eat it.

[@chicken4967]

Oh wow the English car won! How surprising!

[@YachtReport]

Probably because he concluded it was the best car in is opinion.

[@seth6526]

Is he supposed to just lie to keep Germans happy?

[@chicken4967]

@@seth6526 He could've used the 991.2 turbo s which would have been as fast if not faster than the 570s in a straight line not to mention how more desirable the Porsche is... And that Audi is simply the best super car in the bunch due to its engine.

[@seth6526]

@@chicken4967 Porsche being "more desirable" and R8 being "the best of the bunch" are opinions which you have but he clearly doesn't have and this video is old so that Porsche was probably the most up-to-date at the time.

[@FredBTs]

Virtuosiity The Porsche is not more desirable to me.. Don’t get me wrong, a beautifully engineered car but it should be because they’ve been working on basically the same design for the last 50 years. Most people could not tell which was the new 911 if you parked a 2019 next to an immaculate 1997.

[@Tomxxiii]

Looks like a throwback video

[@swanblake]

Felt like a McLaren press release video.

[@JMartinni]

You forgot to mention something, the price...

[@chineseredneck1211]

And the maintenance...

[@WhereverHugo]

Really good camerawork! Very enjoyable to watch!

[@lucca101able]

The McLaren is NOT an every day car.. And how often do you need to Service it? Porsche 911 Turbo S all the way..

[@dng992]

570s 2017 owner UK here. Since 2 months. BEST CAR

[@liambal886]

props to the camera work

[@swright4171]

Good review, but an old one... 991.1 turbo, ‘upcoming 540c’, 659s has been replaced, ultimate series is not the p1 but the Senna and speedtail. Still a comprehensive review👍

[@menger88p]

When was this filmed, two years ago?

[@Duvalin1986]

Amazing car! Great video! 👍🏼

[@vette-air911turbos3]

Hmmm let's see, an English reviewer - reviewing an English car vs the competition; which car will be the winner...anyone care to guess? Has anyone notice that McLaren usually wins all these British based comparisons test? It has gotten downright ridiculous. Then when similar test move across the pond, results are the opposite. Either there is super bias testing, or McLaren are supplying British reviewers with juiced up press cars.

[@jakes5530]

Should have thrown the MB amg GTC coupe in the mix as well. Pretty much as fast, as expensive, and as beautiful as the others.

[@colinryan9188]

Funny how so many people seem to have missed the description of the video.

[@kingomeke]

I could watch top gear all day😊. Who doesnt love fast and super cars? 🙌💯

[@sv4430]

Which season and episode is this one?

[@BreadNZ]

Thumbs up if the r8 sounds better :)

[@juliangst]

McLaren all the way! Audi and Porsche are nice but the design is so much better on the McLaren imo. You often see Porsche or sometimes Audio R8 on the Road but when do you ever see a McLaren, it's just a different league

[@49siao]

Funny how Top Gear journalist could not say Porsche right.

[@johnwhood5791]

Why has this just been posted? It uses an ‘old’ 991.1 and it’s not the S either. He says the 540 is ‘due out’ when in Dec 2018 (now) it’s been out for ages. Come on Top Gear. This is just re-warmed old news.

[@SCoupeAMG]

R8»570S»Turbo

[@jakes5530]

agreed. 911 seems boring in comparison. I'd like to see how the amg gtc coupe stacks up against those 3 as well.

[@rogeritt88]

Not sure the facts are correct in a straight line drag the porsche turbo would destroy the other two not to mention the four wheel drive porsche would also be more than be a match for the others. Porsche tends to underestimate its performance figures.

[@timo3529]

Why did you rewiew the 911 turbo instaed of the turbo s which has better brakes and 30 hp more power.

[@andrewbond7949]

The Audi and Porsche are dinosaurs compared to the McLaren.

[@okaberintaro2411]

*introduces 911 Make sure not to catch fire 😂

[@stristan6302]

Top Gear... always first in cutting edge motoring news.

[@BIG570S]

570S…Dominating in this video and still dominating today!

[@4tasmic]

That road though!

[@alessiopirolo2946]

Where is Chris Harris?

[@TheModManu]

When the heck was this produced? This is the first „new“ TG Videos i have a chance and it’s older than me?!

[@gmb12philly88]

Anyone know where exactly this was filmed??

[@grantgallagher2638]

We all know the 911 turbo is the fastest but I’d honestly still probably go with the McLaren

[@prajeetsen3052]

Comparing an Audi with Pagani ? Are you out of your mind?

[@guestonlyforpleasantpeople5291]

Audi V10 sound like a miracle

[@mikev6046]

Interesting that the 2019 NSX wasn't selected for this as well.

[@davidbresnahan5986]

The NSX wasn’t out yet when this video was created, this is from an archive

[@pedro10borja]

Which road is that one?😮

[@kushalraghavendra6836]

The audio quality is still poor considering we are almost done with 2018

[@scotty193]

If you say it quick enough £133 grand for that McLaren is a bargain. I know what the most sensible choice would be out of all these three would be and that is the 911 all day long. However 3 keys on the table I would want drive off in a McLaren they are just special more in my humble opinion. I wouldn't even consider any Audi although a great car but in this company its boring.

[@guydudley9705]

Great video... keep this content coming

[@ibrahimpallikkal5100]

Every McLaren is Brilliant engineered thing,

[@vitaobatera]

1:28 Automatic thumbs down for forgeting about Senna...

[@kaustubh160]

My conclusion ya the mclearn has all the bells and whistles but it lacks the Zen.... And the Porsche is know for steering response research more top gear

[@6indy8]

does someone know where this is filmed? Road and landscape look stunning.

[@GM-ii8gs]

N339, Penhas da Saúde, Cortes do Meio, Portugal.

[@c32amgftw]

Do lap times and 1/4 comparisons. Otherwise your reviews are just prettily shot videos.

[@hellobye9905]

haha noobie

[@Joe-721]

Statistics arent everything

[@gazman9468]

90% of owners never take their car to the track or drag strip

[@c32amgftw]

Gazman do these owners own an accord?

[@gazman9468]

@@c32amgftw ?? I mean 90% of Porsche/McLaren drivers never take their cars to the track.

[@eichler721]

Porsche is the best car for all around use and the one I would get. The Audi R8 sounds amazing, to bad this is an old news video

[@cegolab]

Hey guys, listen the v10 screaming at 3:55 and be happy!

[@junkfoodeater]

No talk about 720, Senna etc you forgot to upload this back in the day? :p

[@yousefva94]

TOP GEAR? I DON'T THINK SO... BUT NICE VID ANYWAY

[@devkichowki86]

Porsche’s are killer R8 is desire but mclaren is both

[@JBsC6]

All great cars yet my favorite of the three is the mclaren. That would be my choice ..ymmv. Great video

[@PaulRicardF3]

McLaren with V10 would be my choice... Porsche looks pretty ordinary compared with both.

[@user-zs4gd2vb9g]

This video is probably quite old, he doesn't even talk about the 720s, the Senna or the 600lt

[@igoor012]

They forgot to mention 720s in super series and Senna in ultimate series...

[@diederikdemot2007]

where does the 720 sit then ?

[@cesarcastillo2405]

German Pagani...really? That’s a little bit overstated

[@HodsBroo]

Would be nice to see an NSX and 488 GTB

[@GaryDownes]

The Audi sounds like a beast, but it looks a little dated to me now. Definitely like the McLaren though

[@winglessang31]

As a subi owner I have to go with the flat engine 911.

[@w-james9277]

I'd take the McLaren because it's more of a drivers car.

[@robcharlton4486]

Roger!

[@thembinkosisamuel9475]

The turbo is a much better of two daily drivers car and practical...

[@kitfisto1145]

I would choose the McLaren anyday

[@손정민-v8k]

Awesome thanks

[@mrod4864]

Cmon now nothing compares to that Pegani interior

[@opshredderytp]

Chris Harris is perhaps not that bad

[@ganuv]

I tested these cars in Germany and the Porsche is definitely the fastest. This guy doesn’t know what he’s talking about

[@carzhuangx1815]

The 911 and the R8 is supposed to be left hand drive

[@milo6468]

“Interior like a German pagani” who is this melt

[@demonwares]

Yes, I'd take the McLaren over any of them, but it is sad that NA engines are being replaced for turbos. The turbo M4 is not as desirable to me as the E34 M3 was for example

[@J0lker]

But there was no E34 M3...that's codename for 5 series.

[@LivingLifeSlower]

No doubt you'll appreciate them all of a sudden when the prices fall even further.

[@shehryarkhan7763]

The new turbo s does it in 2.5 seconds thats just ludicrous

[@steinemannhermann]

just cause its a McLaren you gave it the first spot, cause its made in your country...yeah we get it

[@cookedit]

No. It is because it was a proper new model car when this video was first released (this is an archive video), where as the 911 and R8 were already established models, which the 570S needed to compete with to seem viable. That's how a lot of tests work. Prove you are worth the money and belong in this prestigious club.

[@ox4556]

@@cookedit Exactly The 720 Is a destroyer of Lambos and Ferraris.

[@StevenSanchez_95]

Ox agreed