Metal Musician Reacts: The Rose (더 로즈) - She's In The Rain (Live) REACTION

[@alex-od6vh]

someone said woosung sings in cursive and i can't stop thinking about it

[@WBFNBS8809]

Alejandra Wilde 🤯 that sounds perfect

[@teedub878]

I love that analogy! Perfect👍

[@uncertainsubscriber4815]

Woah... Great description!

[@jennab4772]

holy shit they’re right

[@ssgoktas]

Perfect!

[@frozensea3945]

“ it’s better to be held than holding on” Is like... ah. This song makes me shiver all the times

[@teedub878]

That is my favourite line in this song. Beautiful words that are so very true.♥️

[@kiannagriffin6631]

My favorite line in the song! I was absent mindedly listening to it one day and for whatever reason my ears suddenly picked up listening at that part. It was like I was meant to hear it at that moment

[@bts.potatorsp8532]

this single sentence hits me really deep, because i know people, including myself, that can relate to this. I want to be this someone to another, and i have people like this that will be here for me.

[@tamara7301]

Same

[@trinityphar2428]

i tear up everytime i hear that

[@beenwandering]

I agree, Sammy is one of the best vocalists I've ever heard.

[@alex-od6vh]

the rose are SO underrated!! this song is one of my favorite of them, it's so beautiful and emotional. dojoon and woosung vocalist of the century!

[@Julia-qi6ep]

SKSJSKKS BASICALLY THE ROSE ARE THE SUPPORTER ACT FOR HALSEY IN SEOUL AND IM SO DAMN HAPPY

[@tamara7301]

100% agreed

[@kateBeirne]

It's funny you say that they're like Coldplay because they've said before that Coldplay is one of their biggest inspirations

[@lupitafigueroa1311]

Idk if you've noticed, but listen to "Like We Used To" then "Yellow" right after.

[@lupitafigueroa1311]

You will be shook once you hear the one detail.

[@flyushkifly]

Here's my experience with this song: I had been sending my sister BTS songs I thought she might like to introduce her to them and Korean contemporary in general. Her reaction was "hmmm I think we have different taste in music. I like Lord Huron and more rock". OK, I had just listened to my first song from this new band and it had definite indie rock flavor, so I sent her She's in the Rain - happily sure she would like it. She called me sobbing. She had been standing outside, it was raining, and she listened without reading lyrics. She said "It's about Lindsay." Lindsay was her daughter who had been murdered 2 years previously. I freaked out. "No! It's a breakup song!" "No, it's a grief song!" I apologized for upsetting her but she thanked me. We eventually hung up. I listened to the song again with lyrics and broke down. There's a point "You wanna hurt yourself I'll stay with you; you wanna make yourself go through the pain; it's better to be held than holding on; no woah; we're in the rain" where I could suddenly hear the voice switch from my sister to my niece, gently telling her mom to let go. Then in the last lines it goes back to my sister - more at peace with the grief. I don't know if she has ever read the English lyrics, but she has played this at least once a day for the last year. I'm sorry if this was tedious, I wrote it fast.

[@TheChampOfMedium]

Amazing

[@amrutha1883]

"he's literally the most talented singers I've heard in my entire life" fKN YASSSSSSS. so glad Woosung's talent is being recognized and appreciated. He deserves all the Love!!!

[@ashleylaframboise963]

it’s very rare for an artist to sound better live then they do on a record, woosung is one of those very few artists whose voice is magic like that. dojoon is the rhythm guitar/keyboardist. i love his voice as well, it’s a bit rougher then woosungs but it compliments the lead vocal so well that once woosung takes over it feels like a breath of fresh air. jaehyeong is the bassist who can also sing, he has a sweet voice. hajoon is the drummer. Please react to Take me Down or Sorry! 💖💖

[@reneeistyping...]

I know this is a bit of an old comment, but Hajoon can sing too! ^^

[@kbubbles321]

I saw them live in a small venue in Manchester England and legit felt like I was punched in the gut when they played this and take me down, it was amazing

[@kekelouuu4178]

THEY WERE IN MANCHESTER?!! AHHH

[@kbubbles321]

@@kekelouuu4178 yeah they were at the acadamy

[@hannahblackrose2212]

OMG I WAS THERE TOO🥺🥺 Woosung said Bi rights and I knew I stanned the right band 🤧

[@monoiralt]

STAN THE ROSE YALL

[@savedbybtseu]

This song made me realize, "It's better to be held than holding on," and I cried. Woosung is one of a kind! THEY are one of a kind and I'm sooooo lucky to have watched them live. Thank you for reacting to them again!!! 😍 🥀🥀🥀 He has an amazing version of ILYSB! I love their song SORRY and I.L.Y. !

[@madhatter66]

I’m not sure if you’ve seen Woosung covering Sign of The Times, but it sounds like opening heaven’s doors

[@BangtanJiminieARMYFanfics]

The Rose does every live, Live. That’s what you call talent. STAN THE ROSE 🌹

[@mitchelleegeonu6312]

"She's in the rain" sounds like the sister of "I need somebody". Both always GET ME IN MY FEELS MAN!!

[@paige4943]

I'm a huge Bts fan and I haven't felt the way I feel with them with any other group but when I started listening to The Rose I just felt that feeling. There so underrated and they deserve so much more recognition. Please react to there cover of ilysb and there song Red!! Woosungs voice is so beautiful and when i heard it for the first time I instantly fell in love.

[@teedub878]

@Your My Borahae. Same here💜👍

[@karinacontreras7597]

Same here, and ILSB is beautiful ❤ Woosung's vocals are mesmerizing

[@lilaccadet4321]

Same here💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@Michelen7]

Same here. I love their song 'Sorry' as well. Woosung's voice is amazing and he's such a natural performer.

[@ismativ5602]

Same here, bts fan and now the rose as well

[@christinequidington4820]

If you are interested in checking out more Korean Bands then new Band Onewe is a pretty good one to check out. Ring on my Ears is a great Rock Ballad💜

[@suchitameow]

Yes they are talented and the world needs to know about them.

[@frontadoelisa037]

La Banda The Rose es la . Mejor Del Mundo 🥰🥰🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️❤️❤

[@jinandtopicvuong6335]

Woosung most definitely has the most amazing voice. No one like him. Unique and mesmerising. He is a truly an artist, lyrically and musically. His solo portfolio and The Rose, love him, them and all their music

[@ddeonushin]

Woosung's voice is like those sweet rare honey on a cold night. that's how i picture his voice, the vulnerability in his voice wows me. I watched them live and I'm telling you, THEY'RE A HUNDRED TIMES BETTER than live videos and studio versions. They're sooo good that when I listened to their songs on my playlist after the concert, it didn't do justice. I missed them. If only I could listen to them live forever...

[@gabyeol]

i’ve just started getting into the rose recently and i’m absolutely in love, all of their songs are incredible and their lyrics are amazing. i also found out that woosung (or sam) has a song called strangers that was the soundtrack to a drama, he also has a solo called face, i think you’d really enjoy those. i’m glad you like them so much.

[@chocolatelover9147]

omg yessssss. strangers was so amazing and the drama was super good too. idk if you know about this but Feel my Heart is another one of their songs included in a soundtrack. That drama is called Catch the Ghost, and oh my god the song AND the drama are so unbelievably beautiful.

[@alexandriamichelle7276]

Strangers is so good 💯👌

[@bianmulyana3567]

in conclusion we stanning harder than before

[@lynx975]

this song gives me goosebumps idk why

[@BlooDMoonFantasy]

Totally agree, Woosung is a unique singer and one of the best vocalists ever. My confession is that 'Sorry' and 'She's in the Rain' are songs that give me goosebumps and I can't help but cry a little every single time I listen to them. The emotional connection is too much. Now there is 'Red' it just makes me smile and feel energized somehow.

[@milissalee]

Woosung has the voice of an angel, The Rose as a group is amazing. I saw them in NY in September and they had technical difficulties but went on to put on an amazing show.

[@LiaLucina]

You should definitely check out their cover of “ILYSB” I love it so much (it’s also a live performance)

[@martynax932]

i was on the rose concert and they are so amazing live, stan the rose guys 😭❤

[@erenscrustytoe6957]

You are so lucky 😿💕

[@mintyclicks]

There's no video or anything but The Rose recently did a song for a show (OST) for Strangers From Hell, the song is called Strangers, I believe. I'm curious what your thoughts would be cause the song gives me Chevelle vibes. It's a COMPLETELY different vibe from their normal stuff, and super refreshing to see them step out and try something new as well.

[@catalinapoblete8421]

That's a really good song! He should totally react to it.

[@pistachio-cookie]

yes please!!

[@marianasantiago3968]

If you like woosung's voice you should listen to his song face from his solo.

[@xximagx5923]

I had the luck to see them live twice... And those concerts were two of the best I ever attended. You could see that all four of them enjoy doing music and performing so much, which makes me appreciate their music even more. And hell yes, Woosung's voice gives me shivers, his vocal color is beautifully unique 😍

[@naty9112008]

🖤🖤🖤🖤 Thanks You for react to The Rose

[@Georgia-w7v]

I so agree with it’s better to pay money and see them live instead of buying the album, and it’s better when it’s a venue rather than a very big concert haul. I saw them live not too long ago (in a venue), and I will admit, it was one of the most beautiful experiences I’ve ever had.

[@mirandaobrien9640]

I love this band. This is one of my favourite songs. All 4 of them can sing. They’re amazing.

[@mehu707]

The Rose getting what it deserves!!!! Completely agree with you... Woosung has the most beautiful voice ever, such good control damn

[@TheCodysbiggestfan]

i want to cry out of happiness because you said woosung is one of the most talented singers ever because he is and it makes me so happy to see/ hear him be recognized as such by someone who is not a stan on that note: stan the rose!!

[@juneseghni]

FT Island , and now The Rose ? Life is good !

[@Amanda-ik1wv]

For The Rose, I really like Strangers (however there is no music video). Side note, you should check out N.Flying's Yoo HweSeung and FT Island's Lee HongGi collaboration "Still Love You" ... if you appreciate vocals you will also like this!!

[@honestlyidk8112]

And the live videos of the collab - insane

[@ellecaledonia348]

I agree! They do make errors, sometimes in the middle of a performance, and they just stop and start over. But that’s live music and I love it! Every performance is also different. Love this band. And to think I just discovered them 2 weeks ago while just randomly perusing various Coachella 2024!performances. I was instantly captivated by The Rose. Been listening to their music exclusively since then.

[@cindyboyce3056]

I’m obsessed with The Rose found them last year and have since seen them live in concert and then at Coachella. Woosung’s vocals are so beautiful and unique and Dojoon has a beautiful voice also. Their music is healing and profound.

[@DulcisAbsentia]

Woosung Is just a fantastic singer. His voice is gold.

[@allinx889]

Woosung is seriously the best singer ever. I wish people would appreciate the Rose more because they are absolutely amazing

[@Maerchenlaenderin]

Yes, Woosung is such an amazing singer, everyone could pick him out of hundreds of voices. :) amazingly talented, that guy ;_;

[@patbw47]

GORGEOUS!! I LOVE everything they sing!!! I think they are special and agree the vocalists have such beautiful voices. Thank you for agreeing!!

[@deerlalu]

Wooosssuunngg yes. He is one of a kind vocalist. Thank you for appreciating him☺️

[@PleiadianDove]

They are so underrated. I hope you get a chance to react to SORRY and I.L.Y. Sammy’s vocals are so unique and they all are incredible vocalists. ❤️

[@kaath5408]

It's funny because when u see them live, u can tell Woosung KNOWS what his voice does to ppl and he gives a little smirk.

[@teedub878]

Another great song by The Rose.👍 "music that coexists with the beauty of flowers and the sharpness of thorns” . true dat👍 This song is so beautiful and full of emotion. As I mentioned in another comment here, my favourite line in this song is " it's better to be held than holding on" . How powerful are those lyrics. ♥️ And totally agree regarding the "2am" moment. Thankyou for sharing.

[@guadalupemartinez7091]

Watching them live is such a great and beautiful experience specially this song. They’re having a comeback in March!

[@_kemely_4061]

I had the opportunity to see them perform live... It was a m a z i n g they're so freaking talented vocals & instruments... it was perfect instruments live hit different*

[@FandomsLater-]

your reaction was amazing! i was really happy that you pointed out how unique his singing still is, not a lot of people do that. good job!! :)

[@Yino_lemmon]

To me I love seeing bands performing live so much is exactly because they stylized it soo much so you can hear something different and creative You can check out live videos of The Rose, Day6, N.Flying They are all pretty much enjoying theirselves in concerts and you can tell

[@svtluvrr]

Omg yes thank you for reacting to the rose again !!! I love your reactions !!

[@exploring_with_dounia5921]

The fact that you said they remind you of Coldplay made me sooooooo happy because Coldplay is one of their inspirations, and they always describe their sound as British pop rock , so they also get inspired by the Beatles, the script and so on. Thanks for reacting to the rose I'm so happy rn ❤🌹

[@santorum1203]

First i hear him sang, I remember the cranberry sounds "when youre gone", the distinct cranberries sounds on the part he sang cuz im dying in side ... ... ... and rain rain rain love that part! Thats when i fall inlove on his voice.

[@jwehope]

yes, dojoon (other vocalist) switches between keyboard and guitar. woosung is my bias but man, dojoon has incredible energy live. saw them in dallas and he was on 100% the whole night and plays really well with the crowd. very personable and entertaining! idk if you’ve checked out woosung’s solo work but i’d definitely suggest that next. these guys are so great. “sorry” is what first hooked me and then i fell down a rabbit hole watching their busking videos and cover songs. LOOOVE their cover of coldplay’s “yellow.” ugh. right in the feels.

[@yuikim441]

I started to get into The Rose just recently because I had the chance to see them live and it was one of the best choice of my life! I recommend you to check out Woosung solo Face too! This guy is really something else! Also if you're up for somenthing new, give a shot to A.C.E, they're on the rock side and are getting a bit of recognition only now, even tho everything in them screams power!

[@jhingbautista4519]

the fact that you did some research and respected the artist by not reacting to the reuploaded version says a lot. you earned my respect. other people just react without thought. thanks for being thoughtful.

[@annmcconnell2099]

He's really incredible. I absolutely love Woo Sung.

[@thaichilli1]

I agree with everything you said about his voice. It is so rare and new to listen to, it stirs something inside you. The Rose is such a talented band, sad i discovered them so late!

[@AngelaSealana]

I am such a fan of your reactions, bro! I totally respect The Rose. You're right that he sounds like no one else. His sound is not my preference; I wish it was, because The Rose fans seem really great. Anyway, I keep giving them a chance to change my preference, and watching your reaction was another chance to do that and support you.

[@xXJAng3lXxx]

I literally just found these guys yesterday because I saw a clip of them on twitter singing ILYSB live and I had to find the whole video because the clip alone blew me away, they sound so amazing I don't know how anyone could sound so good live.

[@villainsoup]

please watch Sorry by The Rose!! after She’s In The Rain, it’s my favorite The Rose song

[@borar_ose13]

I got obsessed with them cuz of their song “sorry”. I’VE LOOPED IT FOR A MONTH. ITS THAT GOOD!! Plz give it a shot too! Woo sung also participated in a JTBC show called “Superband”, had some really amazing performance there!! 🌹🌹💗

[@melodywang2492]

The rose is a treasure.

[@oreeeana]

it makes me so happy to see people acknowledging their talent thank you

[@ignacioangelo9849]

Hajoon basically chilling and stanning his three other members at the start of the song because the drums enter after the chorus

[@1jun1]

Woah.. That description box hit me hard 🙃

[@kal3853]

THE ROSE is amazing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@leacazanove1003]

I truly love this song 😭❤️

[@RS-xu6hd]

Ahhhh I recently got into the rose as well and I completely agree that he is one of the best vocalists I have ever heard in my life. Please react to his woosung's solo face as well and more lives of the rose e.g. ILYSB, red. Thanks!!

[@sofiaa.puerta2895]

The Rose covers are amazing! They have more performances from the day of that performance and they’re amazingg. You should react to more N.Flying!! Also, HYUKOH and ONEWE are some other amazing bands!

[@azlianabitriz1]

oh my god.. how can i miss this video reaction? i love this song so much.. the boys vocals sound so great. thank u for this. 💜

[@rawna7920]

Sammy has one of the best voices out there! I love listening to their music and his solo projects. First time I listened to this song I cried so much. So much emotion in their voices ugh

[@emelybalseca750]

Also STAN THE ROSE❤️they deserve so much love

[@chocolatelover9147]

im so glad you could listen to more of The Rose. :) Some of my favorite songs of theirs are “Strangers”, “insomnia”, and “i dont know you”. Itd be super nice if youd listen to them, regardless if you upload a video reacting to them. Woosung appears in a show called Superband, and i really think that youd like it. Theres no subs but you could look at the performances.... some of the videos on youtube got privated/taken down, but Superband has so many talented people in it.

[@WickedEcho]

Yesssss. So glad you're checking out more of The Rose. Also very very glad you tried for a real live performance. There's a lot of their big name live stages with the backing track (as live kpop tends to do even when not necessary) but they aren't nearly as good as the real lives. If you need a go-to, search for "The Rose Culture Warehouse" for most of their songs you're interested in. That series of performances are all real stuff, and they've done a lot there. Sorry and Red are great songs to check out next (although they do have MVs). Thanks for sharing!

[@Lara-wr2kv]

Thanks for reacting to The Rose again!! Woosung really does have such an amazing and special voice. He also brought out a solo mini album with the title track FACE which has a music video. The song is soooooo amazing!!! Would love for you ro react to it at some point😊

[@soobjun-ec6np]

"I cant watch him without freaking out" me too 😭

[@requlus]

thank you! the rose are very influenced by brit rock! also, can you listen to onewe? they are a lot like the rose. i'd recommend "regulus", "reminisce about all" and "0&4"... they're very underrated but i can promise you'll love them!! also if more reaction channels react to them, they might get more audience through you. anyhow, thanks for this second reaction :) sorry for the long comment~

[@magnum_cx8805]

Please react to their songs “sorry” and “Strangers”! The latter is a bit different because it was made for the ost of a psychological thriller show.

[@alexandriamichelle7276]

Yeeeeeees strangers is sooo good! 💯👌

[@mamtz4764]

Yes I’m recently watching the show and it’s so good, when I first heard the opening song I’m like this is has to be the rose, and I was happy that it was them and that they got to do an opening for the show, the theme actually worked really well

[@sleepy830]

They usually play in smaller venues, which to me is a lot more personal and emotional. Woosung, or Sammy, Released his solo debut with "FACE" but has another amazing song that you'd probably enjoy called "Lonely". As for other songs from The Rose, please listen to "Insomnia", "Sorry" or their newest song "RED"!!

[@iambutpaper1172]

she's is the rain is THAT song. it can have its own fandom

[@hollyz24]

woosung's voice is one of the most distinctive in kpop in my opinion, you should rect to his solo called face and also the rose's other songs like sorry and their most recent one, red!

[@KSS352]

Yes, Doojoon switches between guitar and keyboard! I don't know if you can do reactions to them but Woosung appeared on a show called "Superband" and there are some really great covers on it. And you can really see how much he loves performing and he has so much fun on the show! Also, the sad story behind the MV is very unfortunate. It doesn't sound like the band knew where the pictures were from...but Jonghyun the artist who passed away it seriously (along with Woosung) one of the craziest/best vocals in kpop. He was part of Shinee but also had an extremely successful solo career. I would highly suggest watching him perform "Y, ¿Si Fuera Ella?" It's a live performance and it's insane how well he can perform. Also, "She Is" for fun/unique vocals...I really enjoy the radio performances of this one.

[@september9730]

Yeah Sammy (Woosung) is like... his vocal is like the type that he owns and nobody could do like him. Nobody could ever do it like him. I’m in love with his vocal sooooo so much. Ps. Btw if you want to explore in more of k bands go check OneWE. And ofc more The Rose and Day6 as well. Edit: check out Red and Sorry by The Rose and Woosung solo called Face.

[@koya_joonie]

i saw them live in atl... i literally cried listening to this song

[@dearvernon]

i saw them live a little over a year ago and let me tell you it was one of the best concerts i’ve been to and i’ve been to quite many lol

[@isabnf]

I agree with you about woosung, he one of the best singers in kpop!! The rose is so underrated :(, pleasee react to the rose - ILYSB live! His vocals in this one are great!!!

[@kpoplove2289]

When you said no one can sing like Woosung, I immediately thought of the video where there were a few artists trying to sing like him. It's called Kim Woosung Impersonation Battle.

[@alidatusch2140]

The Rose should really get more attention from the world🙈

[@daedae275]

Yes, I have the same reaction over woosung's vocals every single time.. He's really THAT vocalist. I'm just so happy I found them.

[@melodywang2492]

Woosung has a solo album which features the tiltle song Face. please check it out!

[@faithyang8255]

Just found your channel and love your reaction and how you understand music. I love the rose and been there since the beginning, which is Sorry, so I hope you check that out. But like you said, the lyrics are so we'll written Especially towards the end when he sings "we're in the rain" instead of "she's in the rain" the progress of the song from just sad to hopeful really shows a change of perspective and I'll tell you, I cried when I first listen to it. I love what you said at the end! I love small venue and when I saw them during their last tour at a small venue, it was magical! Thank you for checking them out!

[@juliedbd5566]

first thanks for your reactions, second, I,wish I really wish you could read to his superband performances, they're all... amazing at this point, I swear.

[@angelbrose]

"I'm dying inside I wanna think that it's a lie why why~~" 🎶 Stan Talent, stan The Rose 🌹

[@sumrasheikh1758]

i always cry whenever i listen to this song it’s beautiful. the rose is such a good band. love all their songs

[@HanaNoAi]

If you ever get a chance to go to one of their concerts DO IT!!! They were my best and favorite concert experience!!!

[@exploring_with_dounia5921]

YEEEES this song is so good and it means so much to us black Rose's because the lyrics helped so many of us get through our hard times❤🌹 I'm forever grateful for The Rose I ROSE YOU 🌹

[@nikolaiquack8548]

So happy that you reacted to this. The first time I heard this song I got very emotional as well. I still do, when I hear it. For further listening I recommend their song and mv to 'Like We Used to'. It's imo their most underrated and my favorite song of theirs.

[@ThunderCrey]

If you love Woosung's voice you should check out his solo FACE, I absolutely love it! But also more reactions to live performances from The Rose because they're so freaking great and like you said, I love the lives even more than the studio versions bc they feel more alive. I really like this live they did of Take Me Down, in the same venue as this one I think. It's on the KBS channel :D

[@tutuzillagirl8393]

The Rose is one of my favorite bands. I saw them live in Miami with my husband(plays in a southern gothic band) 😂 he enjoyed them too. They did change it up just for us, it was amazing. I agree 100% on Woosung vocals, no one else comes close to his style! Dojoon does rotate between keys and guitar as well. Thank you for the reaction.