Minecraft Bedrock: Easy WITHER SKELETON Farm Tutorial! 13,400+ Items/Hour!

[@silentwisperer]

*UPDATE!* commands have changed! Please check the description for updated commands:)

[@foxgamingz]

I subbed

[@foxgamingz]

@@solicoli ???

[@silentwisperer]

welcome to the silence fox :D

[@mkekmwarner]

I love this farm but what do you think is the best spawn spots? I am having a little trouble.

[@spicygames7694]

You are my favorite and best Minecraft bedrock farm maker and player in general but I really wanna see a video about fast hopper system since I made a good farm and it keeps overflowing in 30min of asking even with 4 hopper minecarts

[@KRO-222]

FINALLY a farm that can accommodate my insatiable need for slightly damaged stone swords!

[@silentwisperer]

IKR! It's taken me long enough 😂

[@xw9420]

i want to beat the wither with an inventory full of those

[@Kobe_Abogutal]

hello another person with a purple K profile pic

[@KRO-222]

@@Kobe_Abogutal 👋

[@matthewbowen8254]

You’ve been in the early game for years now haven’t you

[@MrLinusDaman]

To everyone having issues with very low spawn rates: My issue was resolved by raising the spawn spots to the original level. Digging down like in the video did _not_ work for me, I had to have the spawn spot at the exact same level as they originally were. Once I raised the spawn spot I have great spawn rates :).

[@Tiler__]

Did you raise the glass and wither rose of just the rose? (please reply i'm desperate lol)

[@M_murph19]

@@Tiler__Has to be both because that’s how you stop piglins from spawning

[@Tiler__]

@@M_murph19 I raised both but the zombie pigmen r still spawning lol wtf

[@M_murph19]

@@Tiler__ make sure the glass blocks are on the west, northwest and north blocks as mobs spawn in the northwest corner of the block

[@Tiler__]

@@M_murph19 omfg somehow i placed them on the south southeast and east blocks lol tysm

[@Yoskii132]

I'm glad I saw this.I was just about to start gathering the materials for a different, less efficient farm but then i saw this one and realised that your the most clutch person on earth when it comes to these things

[@Aphrodite7673]

@silentwisperer Fantastic farm per usual! Unfortunately, 1.19.70 has changed command formatting again. To place wool under the wither skeletons, use: execute at @e[type=wither_skeleton] run setblock ~~-1~ cyan_wool * You can change the "cyan" for any other color as long as it's in lowercase. To replace the nether brick fences with air use: /fill ~10 ~10 ~10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air [] replace nether_brick_fence I hope this helps anyone having issues!

[@dylanbrown4039]

Thank u so muchhhhh

[@skylerkesterman7353]

Thank u this is a life saver

[@silentwisperer]

they always be changin stuff for no reason and breaking the old stuff 🥴🥴🥴

[@electric_v0lz137]

What about just bricks

[@Aphrodite7673]

@@electric_v0lz137 It would be /fill ~10 ~10 ~10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air [] replace nether_brick

[@talapantedtoad6461]

For spawn proofing with this farm I highly recommend foxy no tails marker resource pack. This will show you exactly where mobs can spawn so you only have to do what’s absolutely necessary❤

[@氣Pluh]

i can finally get alot of deepslate

[@janelledizoncaro5008]

Oh the sphere for sim4?

[@talapantedtoad6461]

@@janelledizoncaro5008 yep 👍

[@best_clips_football]

⁠@@talapantedtoad6461 green sphere or red sphere?

[@brianwolvers4316]

​@@best_clips_footballall the mobs spawn outside the green sphere but inside the red sphere

[@m4ge372]

Just to confirm, built this in my world as of the new update and works flawlessly. Haven’t even slabbed a third of the surrounding spawns and still have got over 6 stacks of skulls for a few hours afk.

[@freddstid]

I miss the glorious days of strays giving wither heads. Thank you for making this silent. It's crazy how quickly you got this video out considering I was watching you yesterday working on it

[@rooodis456]

It’s still wild to me that they let that bug stay in the game for as long as they did💀

[@RC-Sev]

Idk if it's a bug or not, but as of writing this, you MUST have simulation distance at 4 chunks. When testing this on my 8 sim world, I had to go around 64 blocks away to get spawns. Thought it was just mob cap or smthn so I used fill commands to clear everything from the spawn level up in a 64 block radius, buttons on everything as well, and still needed to be ridiculously far away to get spawns. Set it to 4 chunks and it worked perfectly : ) Edit: In case it's worth mentioning, I had 35 spawn spots marked out so it was NOT a spawn rate problem lol. Once hitting the distance cutoff it went ham but 0 to 100 so yeah

[@jadalolabi8140]

Thank u a lot a had the same problem now it is fixed

[@raydenrachar6657]

What seed and what cords to get 35 spots?

[@owenmunslow2204]

for some reason they stop spawning when im at trhe bottom on 4 chunks any help please?

[@wolfandwolves]

I have the same problem it won't work for me if I'm in the bottom of the kill chamber and I have it at four simulation chunks they still won't spawn in

[@Fennetic]

If anyone's having problems with the wool not being placed then here's an easy fix! Make the kill command block have a 1 tick delay and make the command block that places the wool as repeat instead of chain. Both set on always active. Or needs redstone if you want an easy way to turn it off

[@celticlion]

Thank you I was getting seriously annoyed lol

[@Fennetic]

@@celticlion gl with the build xD. It was exhausting but worth it in the end! Don't let the challanges get in the way ;>

[@lilmoose7789]

Commands for 1.21 first command block should be pointing in the next one with a lever on top. Set it to repeat, unconditional, needs redstone. /execute at @e[type=wither_skeleton] run setblock ~ ~-1 ~ cyan_wool []. Second command block needs redstone on top. Set it to repeat, unconditional, needs redstone. Command is /kill @e[r=100]. This works for me on 1.21. I don't know how well the farm will work yet

[@TheSkyWhale]

You sir are a hero

[@lilmoose7789]

@@TheSkyWhale not really. I got these commands from a person on reddit

[@youngdagger-ej4si]

This actually worked thankyou

[@ti___ro___]

Bro you are a God You deserve the best raids ever out of your Farm for this comment

[@KazGMD]

First command block is not working for me

[@Gooday2day]

If you are having problems with the command blocks these tips might help. 1. When you place the command blocks make sure the arrows are pointing in the same direction. Mine weren't and the wither skeletons were walking around creating wool, very annoying. 2. The new command for the purple, repeating command block with the lever is: execute at @e[type=wither_skeleton] run setblock ~ ~-1 ~ wool 3 . There is a space before the first squiggly line, between the first set of squiggly lines, after the 1 and the squiggly line, and after the last squiggly line and wool. 3 The new command for the green chain block is: /kill @e[r=100] 4. You enter the commands ''IN'' the command blocks, and not from the chat command screen. 5. Switching the world to peaceful instead of using the kill command in the chat menu to clear the spawns so you can start marking the spawns might be easier and faster.

[@SlothGripper]

It has a syntax error for the 3 after wool, do you know a way to fix that

[@Gooday2day]

@@SlothGripper The command might have changed again. Some of the newer comments have the new command and fixes for you. Good luck.

[@electric_v0lz137]

Thank you

[@thaticecube1988]

Still have a syntax error

[@Gooday2day]

@@thaticecube1988 Its been months since I did this, I tried my best to describe my issues. If it's syntax errors, they might have changed the command. I would look at the newest comments and see if any of them have the new command. The command might still be good, it's finicky. Quadruple check the spacing, I had trouble with it myself. Good luck.

[@Foefii]

your timing is just not from this planet😂 i literally just started to make my way to a fortress for witherskelly skulls and wodered when i‘m going to build a farm for them😂 convinient as always sir!❤

[@rocketbuilder]

Just a heads up to all, commands have changed again in 1.19 The new commands are as followed: /kill @e[r=100] execute at @e[type=wither_skeleton] run setblock ~ ~-1 ~ blue_wool /fill ~10 ~10 ~10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air replace nether_brick /fill ~10 ~10 ~10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air replace nether_brick_fence

[@greysonfloyd8018]

Yo, is that /kill command with execute one single command. UPDATE answered my own question. No. Still struggling to get the wool to turn up though.

[@jamswag]

Do spawn spots that are on the brim circle count?

[@supguy9021]

Absolute life saver, thank you

[@Foefii]

not a single command works 😔

[@matematicacomvaldiney]

Hey. For those who are playing in the latest version, the command has changed. The new one is this: execute at @e [type=wither_skeleton] positioned ~~~ run setblock ~~-1~ wool

[@gavinsdadphil]

I could hug you... Thanks

[@markusverster39]

You sir are the reason ń can sleep at night.

[@markusverster39]

You are truly amazing

[@gavinsdadphil]

@@markusverster39 silent said recently that commands STILL aren't working correctly. I've tried this updated string without success. But I might try again later tonight

[@gavinsdadphil]

FINALLY this command string WORKS. I tested it on PS4 edition (bedrock) and and can confirm it leaves white wool blocks whenever it kills a wither skeletons. Only issue is at the edge of the 100 block perimeter, they can be JUST outside of the kill radius and just spread wool blocks around like a snowman does with snow "carpet". Suggest making the radius 200 or more. Thanks for all your help, now I can continue on this build. 😌😮‍💨😅🤗🙏👍

[@saduriks]

For anyone having skeletons stuck on the edge: move piglin closer to the glass wall and make sure it's centered. Little move can make a big difference.

[@nonamemcnotaspy8654]

I was struggling with this to the point I made a redstone clock that opens and closes 4 trap doors, worked ok..... what ended up working the best for me was the ring of slabs to accommodate the redstone around the opening and they would run right in, no need for the redstone at all 🤣

[@minatonamikaze7086]

@@nonamemcnotaspy8654what do you mean by a ring of slabs around i made one ring of slabs instead of buttons but not working for me

[@il_daze_ll_Gaming]

List of All Working Commands I used. With the Help From The Comment Section! /fill ~10 ~10 ~10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air [] replace nether_brick /fill ~10 ~10 ~10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air [] replace nether_brick_fence /fill ~10 ~10 ~10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air [] replace nether_brick_stairs /fill ~10 ~10 ~10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air [] replace netherrack execute at @e[type=wither_skeleton] run setblock ~~-1~ cyan_wool /kill @e[r=100]

[@rjmichalski7172]

Thanks bro you are a life saver

[@hazellarido9021]

tnx

[@JoaoLucas-hw4db]

Thanks!

[@teddyturn6712]

Thank you🫡

[@mtb6066]

Do you know why my wither skeletons don't die with the command I am sure I have done everything right

[@loris_099]

As soon I saw the bug fixed in the changelog, I was sure Silent was already on his way to make a good wither skeleton farm 👀

[@yanhenrique5459]

What bug?

[@josecosta5152]

@@yanhenrique5459 the bug of the wither rose

[@ryangraham5033]

The jitter bug

[@timothybrant9120]

Same dude!

[@vlnak3538]

TIP: If the wither skeletons keep stopping on the edge of the ledges, move the piglin boat a bit father back into the glass.

[@AndresSc09]

Thx man

[@seraj7o497]

Yeah bc the mobs detection range is at least 16 blocks radius

[@Toxic_945]

Ya i keep adjusting it problem wont stop

[@ndomako10]

I had constant problems with this until I swapped out the buttons for coral fans around the edges

[@omisami3124]

What is the measurements of the circle in which the wither skeleton are spawning ?

[@goldygojira1407]

This farm is already better than my old one without much spawn proofing yet. Great farm silent!

[@kizlo33]

first time i've taken the advice to build the farm in creative first lol. it took me a little to figure out the commands considering i've never used them before but it definitely saved me a lot of time. for anyone who wants to know, the farm works great for me and i play on xbox. (i'll be attempting to build this in my survival realm soon.) thanks for the video!

[@brokenbones623]

Yo so my farm isn't spawning anything, did u have to change the spawning platform at all and if so what did u do?

[@kizlo33]

@@brokenbones623 you don't have to change the spawning platform other than making your circle. some issues may be that there is a higher platform catching the spawns, the direction of your farm may be incorrect or you just may not have spawn proofed the surrounding area well enough. if my reply is no help to you i don't mind inviting you to my world and you may dissect the farm until you find the issue with yours

[@redpanda8238]

For some reason I'm getting blaze spawn in my farm and also Spawn rates are low even tho I have spawn proofed everything using foxytail pack

[@rooodis456]

Silent you’re amazing for this farm man. I’m sorry for asking this favor in a comment, but have you seen Pixlriff’s copper aging facility thing? I would absolutely love something like that for bedrock but at the moment I don’t know of anyone to do it..but hey if anyone could do it it’d seem like you could. Sorry if this kinda comment is asking for too much, have a great day🫡

[@GlidedSlasher]

Tht would be amazing love the video too

[@OMEGAMAN1300]

I can’t wait for his mangrove farm. This is a way to do it like the other tree farms but it takes quite a few modifications to stop bees and deal with roots.

[@Sebastian-But-Not-That-One]

I've actually had the very same thought! Silent and his friends could definitely make that 😁❤️

[@ebomboms]

yo i'm also watching empires smp

[@ChaoticD3sTroYeR]

I was finally about to make the last wither farm today, Just gathered all of the materials in shulker boxes. Good thing I didn't. 😂 Knew the wither roses spawn fix would change it up a bit. Now no need to be overworld and nether at the same time.

[@joodh1840]

5:20 WTF is wrong with the damned ghast

[@JusTryNc]

Man you are an absolute legend! I had 4 wither skulls in the time it took for me to travel down the stairs to the kill chamber.. Thanks man!!

[@Skibidi-k7k]

If you’re having trouble with the either skeletons going in move the buttons on the glass down 1 block replace the buttons below the glass with trap doors than the buttons across from the glass replace to coral fan

[@Camouflauge9]

I have found with me that the buttons and trapdoors do not work for tricking the Wither skeletons into the hole but I tried coral fan and it works great

[@owais_mc]

me too

[@ajarci1316]

works beautifully, kind of a pain to build in survival with all the other mobs around, but 100% worth it! i got 25 skulls in fraction of the time it’d take to get 3

[@solhilder7368]

i mean you could go peaceful mode

[@PasiFourmyle]

Wow, I doubt I'll ever make this, but just seeing them spawn so fast when it took me like 2 hours last night to get 3 skulls is really crazy. And that's with Looting III btw.

[@nicolasjhoseff2383]

É muito facil

[@nicolasjhoseff2383]

Demore 1 hora e 30

[@nicolasjhoseff2383]

Para construir mas para nerfar 2 dias

[@nicolasjhoseff2383]

Mais fui eu que fui burro mesmo que não construi na fortaleza acima da lava

[@neonninja6117]

took me 20 minutes

[@Crushal812]

Found a way to maximize potential with this farm, and i'm not sure if anyone else is having this problem, or it's just a new spawn mechanic, but the I'm having them spawn in the middle of 4 blocks, and zombified piglins keep spawning. I just kept slabs around the wither roses where they spawn, I revamped the killing chamber with a 3x3 area where there is a 3x3 trident killer at the bottom, and replaced the trap doors where they are supposed to see them as full blocks to fall down, with powdered snow, so now they don't get stuck on the side of the trapdoors. I had also added a turtle egg to the middle of the powdered snow area, so now the zombified piglins will be attracted to the center of the farm along with the wither skeletons. I moved the piglin to a 1x1 glass pane block, 3 blocks above the turtle egg, and placed a trap door under it so the wither skeletons do not have a chance of crushing the turtle egg. Hope this helps anyone with the same problem, I wish I could put a picture here with my comment so you can see what I did, but that's not possible. Great farm man, I appreciate you putting this on KZbin for us! Edits: The turtle egg is placed onto the center powdered snow block, not in the middle. The trap door underneath the piglin still makes the wither skeletons stay on the outside of the powdered snow, so make 4 trapdoors in a surrounding type pattern of the turtle egg and glass pane, one block below the glass pane

[@cycodragon2412]

I think it would be better to build a Neather hub first so transporting supplies is easier with the added bonus of a pre built escape route (or grab an elytra if possible) it's always good to have a pre set escape route in mind, them ghast are quite annoying

[@Tekunno]

Thank you silentwisperer! The farm I built was truly amazing after all the spawn proofing but it was all worth it, please keep it up!

[@kenekiknie]

For everyone asking why the wither skeletons leaving a trail of wool... check the arrows on the command blocks,they need to point in same direction. So if the wool command block with the lever is on the right and arrow point to te left you need to place the kill command block on the left with his arrow pointing the same way. So like this

[@kenekiknie]

On 7:17 you can see this

[@IINo1goodII]

Yeah gotcha thanks

[@Getshartedon]

For anyone having a problem with them falling into the trident killer. Add 2 glass blocks on each side of the glass. Then build 4x2 glass blocks right across from it. This will pinch them and they will push each other down.

[@saintsm]

Hey the kill command in command block not working

[@marchi_archi]

Version 1.21 is still working perfectly. Thank you so much!

[@nafrullop6804]

I literally planning to build your precious big mind breaking farm but now a new and very easy farm thanks bro ❤️❤️

[@RanjanaSingh-oq4dr]

The command fir placing wool is not working any way to fix it silent

[@LeytonErickson]

For the kill command set tic delay to 5

[@DaftWullie1981]

Well explained as always. Thanks Silent!

[@DaftWullie1981]

I just finished building this on a realm I play on. The fortress I selected wasn't ideal - I could only manage 23 spawn spots in a 15 radius circle. I thought this might hurt the rates. But honestly, I see a near constant stream of skeletons falling into the trident killer. Just one more tip: the positioning of the piglin was a bit problematic: at first I tried to center the chest-boat on the glass pane square, but this meant that the piglin itself was off-centre, and some skeletons would not walk all the way into the drop chute. Make sure to center the piglin, and even push him a little closer to the side with the glass block wall. In any event - make sure to do a check to see that the skeletons don't get stuck, and adjust if necessary.

[@ruizzz7420]

This farm still works in 1.21, for those who cannot enter the code, pay attention to placing the command blocks as in the video and it will work

[@ImagineeringTopic]

14:23 what texture or resource pack is he using for the hopper direction with the green arrow?

[@mythicgt]

Thanks so much! I think we all were waiting for a wither farm :)

[@willhoban1]

I mean he did already make a couple but

[@mythicgt]

@@willhoban1 there mostly broken

[@willhoban1]

@@mythicgt oh

[@firephoenix5915]

When testing for spawn spots, if you want the farm to have the same level of spots, just place blocks above the different y levels to make it flat. Wither skeletons should spawn on the higher placed blocks for the same spawn spots to make it flat (not sure if this is 100% accurate, not much testing)

[@logicactiv]

I originally built one that only used one spawn spot and no wither roses until I found this one. only with around ten minutes I have 13 skulls even without Looting because they just spawn so fast. 32 spots REALLY helped 🔥

[@austinkoiman]

Make sure command blocks are on in settings. Make sure the command block arrows go into each-other. The 2nd command block just do kill @e. No need to add a radius. My wither skeletons weren’t going into the hole so I used coral fans instead of buttons and it worked better.

[@daawesomehotsauceman9797]

Farm is outstanding! Thanks again Silent!

[@RaggPlayz]

hey whisper I just completed the farm but I am getting hit buy the wither skeletons through the Trident killer what should I do? Also the wither skeletons are getting stuck at the top and aren't falling

[@youngdagger-ej4si]

This doesn’t work in 1.20 anymore to anyone wondering, I used this farm before the update perfectly fine but than the update and it doesn’t work, edit it works but only if you put dirt where the wither rose is and the rose on top of that so you move it up by one

[@Super-Wolf-2468]

Legend thank you so much

[@Mobro07]

Not even spawning for me

[@-_--cp3gy]

Ik this comment is a year old and u probably won’t see it but did u move the glass up too or just the rose?

[@youngdagger-ej4si]

@@-_--cp3gy I did recently make the farm on a different world and you don’t need to change anything as it works perfectly fine in the latest update, but the commands have definitely changed

[@-_--cp3gy]

@ ohh that’s weird cuz mine only spawns like 1 every 5 mins I’ve tried the normal way and raising the roses and glass but it’s the same

[@ahmedmahmood3935]

I would recommend changing the thumbnail to make it a little more clickbaity this video deserves more veiws

[@Craxin01]

It's crazy how many farms you can make. Infinite bonemeal, coal, and wither skulls? Sounds like a plan to me.

[@shahriar5570]

if anyone is building this farm, remember that the spawn spots locating will take more time than You're anticipating. do the process 1 time then make a sphere covering the most spawn spots, then spawn proof those spots and go throug the command block process once again... You'll definitely find more spawn spots inside that circle for sure... on first time I got only 11 spawn spots then I did all those for 4 times and now I'm seeing 33 spawn spots inside the circle I made....

[@eden7t]

How big is the circle i counted a 15 block radius. I am asking you as you are the most recent comment i have fpund

[@eden7t]

Doesn't matter i have just found out i needed to build the hoglin 4 blocks high that has solved my problem

[@shahriar5570]

@@eden7t good to know your problem is solved. btw how many spawn spots did you find inside that 15 block radius?

[@barneysteele-smith3942]

Finally. We now have an automatic stone sword farm so we have infinite weapons. We have zombie farms for infinite tools and armour and we have drowned farms for infinite food! Silent is really carrying my survival worlds

[@tomas3300]

Drowned farms for infinite food? Do you eat rotten flesh?

[@barneysteele-smith3942]

@@tomas3300 hehehehe

[@tomas3300]

@@barneysteele-smith3942 oh I'm so stupid 😂

[@ScoRPy22]

Built it in 1.20.60, still works and rates are awesome (30 spawn spots farm).

[@mattboy4582]

Met execute command doesnt work it says faild to execute setblock as [null]

[@ScoRPy22]

@@mattboy4582 Check description. It has the most updated commands. Also make sure your command blocks are facing the correct direction.

[@D_4_N_]

just saw this change in patch notes, crazy how fast you got this video out, gg

[@FanthonEntity]

commands changed again. now is: execute at @a run fill ~20 ~-10 ~20 ~-20 ~ ~ -20 air replace netherrack

[@godfizh]

The wither skeletons won't spawn, I have changed the difficulty to hard and render distances to 5. I destroyed the wither roses and I still don't get any spawns. Is there a certain elevation that the farm doesn't work at?

[@maxdeacy5349]

Same here

[@dahomie6979]

​@maxdeacy5349 after 1.21 spawning changed so these older farms may be broken after that

[@maxdeacy5349]

@@dahomie6979 that’s probs true mate but somehow for some reason my farm just started magically working on its own - thanks though😊😙

[@shitpostmania6061]

You need to be atleast 24 blocks above/away the spawn spots.

[@omisami3124]

What is the measurements of the circle in which the wither skeleton are spawning ?

[@CALC1M]

16 I'm pretty sure

[@benjaminsimpson6254]

Around a year or 2 ago I thought i would try to make my own either skeleton farm with no tutorial and In survival only, I knew the corridors were better and made a good farm from it, i got a load of skulls from it, it wasn't amazing but I was proud of my monster of a farm. I had a lot of time that year

[@silentwisperer]

sounds fun :3

[@benjaminsimpson6254]

@@silentwisperer it was, i got around 10-15 skulls every 5-10 minutes

[@Tom-uf7pr]

Buttons don't seem to work anymore to trick mobs over the edge, but coral fans still work great. Trapdoors work too, but not as well because they do have a hitbox. It's a small hitbox, but some mobs often sill end up standing on it until another mob runs in to push it over the edge.

[@LFlashLI]

Good to see it perfected from the stream!!!! I am the othernamewastaken btw

[@tjpprojects7192]

Question: you said spots near the outside of the circle won't have proper movemeny for the Wither skeletons. However, what about spawning spots DITECTLY on the circle? Will those spots still have proper path finding?

[@nikkiwilliams5752]

i found that they didn't, so i didn't include those :)

[@ScoRPy22]

If the glass blocks of a spawn spot are on the circle or outside then unfortunately they won't path find. But There's something you can do is make a 2 block high wall around the farm(including those spots in) this way they won't wander out of the farm and when they come near the piglin they'll walk towards the chute automatically.

[@gamingholik9242]

Instead of naming the piglin you could just trade 1 gold ingot and it wont despawn

[@chadp8532]

Hi! So been working on this farm and feel followed it exactly. Have spent hours. Haha! So I am using bedrock and on a realm. So wondering if that matters. The only problem I am having is when I lay the rose down the wither skeletons never spawn. Any help would be great. Thanks!

[@johnmcmahon9701]

Same. Any suggestions?

[@chadp8532]

@johnmcmahon9701 So I finally have mine working. What I did is from where the skeltons get killed in the trident killer have your viewing spot 30 to 35 blocks above it no more. So example if the skeltons fall in at 25 have the trident killer 5 spots down. Then have your viewing spot 25 to 30 above the skeltons. This is the only thing that worked for me and I have afk last night and have 7 stacks of wither heads. Hope this helps!

[@johnmcmahon9701]

@@chadp8532 Thanks. Honestly I wasn't done with the farm and kinda jumped the gun. Honestlly now they won't stop spawning.

[@electric_v0lz137]

@@chadp8532 I kinda don’t understand

[@mindful_knight8035]

I was here for the stream. It was great btw

[@田中_田中]

ボートの位置は結構シビアで、置く位置によってはうまくウィザースケルトンか落ちません。落ちなかったらまずボートの位置を少しずらしましょう。多分気持ちガラスの壁寄りにボートを配置するとうまくいきます。 ピグリンはモンスターにカウントされてしまうので、究極の効率を追い求める人は代わりにアイアンゴーレムを使うと良いです

[@cloudzzcloaked2773]

I did the commands exactly but it's not working. Any tips?

[@Wholesome_murder_drone257]

I think it's because the execute command has been updated/changed.

[@mrpenpro6139]

The command block commands dont work so how can i find the spawn spots or how can i build without knowing the spawn spots

[@benjiyes12]

there is a new command in the description that works

[@darienkivenas6949]

Whenever I run the command it doesn’t just change the block they spawn on but also the blocks they start to walk on

[@aaronsrok619]

You need the kill command as a chain so they die right after spawning

[@LegomasterYT830]

Thank you so much! I've been looking for a relevant wither skeleton farm for months! and now I'm finally building one that will work Tysm! :]

[@gokumarper]

Does it still work?

[@jamesspiemc8383]

Can you place all over the circle with dirt and witherroses so you don't have to find the spawn spots?

[@jackdesanta69]

Way better than any bonemeal farm

[@silentwisperer]

for reall, such good rates!

[@Foefii]

@@silentwisperer makes my recently built moss bonemeal farm kinda useless tho😂

[@Adrian_PH647]

3:10 what are the odds lol. bro got a looting 3 hand 😂😂

[@silentwisperer]

ikr 😂

[@Adrian_PH647]

​@silentwisperer i didn't realize its 2 times in a row 3:20

[@tristangnzalez]

guys the commands work, I'm currently on version 1.20.15, you just have to make sure the arrows in the command block are followed

[@xxvequalizer9826]

The farm works as well then right?

[@drwaffles9418]

I can't get the command block to work the one that places wo

[@tristangnzalez]

@@drwaffles9418 i don't know man, now the version is 1.20.62, idk if commands get right

[@nathanieldevries4285]

​@@drwaffles9418I'm currently trying to figure out how to place the wool it's confusing the hell out of me

[@iron2291]

I had no idea that holding a looting sword applied to trident killers. That is amazing.

[@understand1382]

It's crazy to understand but I have to say THANK YOU MOJANG xD

[@maevwat]

it was a bug at first but they made it a feature Looting now applies to all projectiles including arrows if you can switch to a sword fast enough

[@ThePurplePassage]

This and trident killers are the redeeming features of bedrock and are vitally important to compensate for the generally lower mob spawning rates of farms on bedrock

[@Spidey_Knight316]

Hi bro! man, does this farm still work? in the new beta update, where mobs only spawn in the center of a block. can you please make a short video where you talk about the modifications that need to be made to this farm, for it to work again. This farm is a lifesaver, and I really wanna build it in my new world. PLEASE ??

[@flaviopucciarelli]

Idk why but wither skeletons are spawning very rarely like one every 5m, i did everything as you explained then double checked if the coordinates of the wither skeletons' spawns were right and placed slabs on all the fortress but It doesn't work, any idea how to fix? I then noticed that if i get far from the farm and the go back to It 2-3 wither skeletons spawn and then no more of them will spawn Edit: i set the simulation chunk distance from 6 to 4 and know It works

[@MrLinusDaman]

I had a similar issue that was solved by raising the spawn spots to their original Y-level. In the video Silent digs down into the floor to place the rose/glass blocks and that completely ruined spawn rates for me. Once I raised them to their OG Y-level spawn rates are excellent :).

[@flaviopucciarelli]

@@MrLinusDaman Ah, i changed the simulation chunk distance from 6 to 4 and It started working for me, i'll also try to do what u just said to see if It will improve the rates

[@Foefii]

Feedback time :) working almost perfectly as of 26.08.2024. i‘ve built this farm and it‘s absolutely incredible! the rates are great, i have afk‘d for 2 nights and have pretty much enough skulls forever already😂 a few slight flaws i still have though, seems like button spawnproofing has some bugs since i have now seen every single mob, that can spawn in the nether, seen spawning on buttons. it rarely happens so i don‘t care since i‘m safe and sound in my AFK room. second the dirt blocks with wither roses on them and glass blocks around them still rarely spawn pigmen, but they die quickly because of the wither roses. and thirdly and probably most importantly, especially when you fixate on rates, the trident killer and therefore afk spot seems to be a bit too high. i tried many spots using a copy of the world and creative and if i place myself right i have 5-9 wither skeletons spawn at the same times in waves, all pathfind perfectly and fall to their doom. if i stand at my afk spot i only have waves of 1-3. i have 36 spawning spots & before you ask, yes i buttonproofed everything in a 30+ blocks radius around the farm (the 16x16 of the farm included so basically a 46x46+ radius) so might be worth a thought using slabs, glass or leaves (if not too close to lava or if fire spread is off) might be worth looking into them if you plan on using it, expecting rates, for multiple people or on a server/realm😊 edit: If you have troubles with the rates, it might spawn other mobs on the buttons or sometimes it spawns pigmen (if in the nether wastes biome) on the wither roses and if they don‘t get killed fast they will reduce the rates pretty drastically. so i made the entire platform that would be 1 block above the spawning spots to dirt and put wither roses everywhere which kills the pigmen pretty fast now :)

[@danyalali1786]

I’m currently in creative trying to find the spawning spots when I use the commands it’s doesn’t kill everything instantly unless I turn it onto a repeat command block unlike what ur supposed to do in the video and whenever I put repeat on it’s doesn’t spawn the wool underneath the wither skeleton what did you do ?

[@Foefii]

@@danyalali1786 there‘s a comment of „Aphrodite7673“ where she mentions that mojang changes the commands. here‘s her comment: Unfortunately, 1.19.70 has changed command formatting again. To place wool under the wither skeletons, use: execute at @e[type=wither_skeleton] run setblock ~~-1~ cyan_wool * You can change the "cyan" for any other color as long as it's in lowercase. To replace the nether brick fences with air use: /fill ~10 ~10 ~ 10 ~-10 ~ ~-10 air [] replace nether_brick_fence I hope this helps anyone having issues!

[@darrylepps3141]

How low did you make your afk spot? I’m having the same issue I think with spawns

[@GunskillsWorld]

36 spawn spots is crazy

[@GunskillsWorld]

Struggling to find 20 lol

[@yuusou_480]

hello i have question for this farm, how big does the circle need to be??

[@AYAZSAYYED000]

Finally The GOAT Has Uploaded 👍🏻

[@AliMohammed-pj6rp]

The command dont work can someone help me

[@blackharlemshake7513]

does this work on bedrock 1.21?

[@duestv5784]

Imma bout to build this ill lyk 🙏

[@duestv5784]

It works

[@michaelhenar]

3:23 2 SKULLS IN A ROW!??

[@ChrisLikesAxolotls]

WHY IS NOONE TALKING ABOUT THIS

[@Hypnostedon]

Dude, I was about to create one. You are a life saver

[@beanswater]

I remember in one of the realms i played at, my base portal runs through a nether fortress before getting to the main nether hub, so i kill wither skellys on the way back and forth and kept the stone swords in the chests that spawned in the fortress. I expanded them when they get full. By the end of the realm, that nether fortress had so many double chests full of stone swords. That was a fun time

[@DaftWullie1981]

Just a note: for those other players slumming it on mobile devices (like me), the syntax for the setblock wool command is a bit different. rather use: execute at @e[type=wither_skeleton] positioned ~~~ run setblock ~ ~-1 ~ wool 3 all the other commands stay the same.

[@loris_099]

Finally completed the farm. I just need to spawn proof a liittle more and add a sorting system, but beyond that the farm works like crazy, already got 2 wither skeleton heads just by testing for a few minutes!

[@randomguy15865]

No that's bad you should get about 26 wither skulls in a few minutes (10 mins) you must of built it wrong

[@anabsolnamednyx899]

The wither skeletos keep running up to the edge of the hole and standing there looking at the piglin, not falling in

[@senseislime9861]

I’m having the same issue. Not sure why they aren’t falling in? I’ve tried trapdoors too and I’m getting the same result

[@edgarthieme4131]

@@senseislime9861put glassblocks around the hole stacked up by two and leave only one entrance

[@stephentorrey8727]

The side that they're getting stuck on means the piglin is too close, push the boat a bit further away from the edges they get stuck on.

[@stephentorrey8727]

​@@senseislime9861the piglin boat just needs to be pushed further away from the edges the skeletons get stuck on, the wither skeletons are sensing that at that point, they are as close to hitting the piglin as they can get. If you push the piglin further back, they will sense that they need to move over the open trapdoor to get closer to him, and fall in.

[@stephentorrey8727]

​​​@@senseislime9861it's a small window of area that the piglin can be for all sides to work, basically as close to directly centered over the middle of the pit as possible.

[@MacElMasMancoDeTodos]

The Chain comand block wont work. Use a repeating /kill one without radius, just a /kill @e with tickspeed 1. Worked for me, the rest of the farm is INSANELY CHEAP AND SIMPLE Thanks, God of Technic Bugrock

[@Katie16682]

So my nearest nether fortress is far from being the ideal candidate for this farm but I decided I would give it a go since I'd be in creative anyway. I went against all advice just to see how useful my useless location would be. Context: my fortress has overlapping biomes (nether wastes, basalt delta, & warped forest), is not over a lava lake, is half buried in netherack, I then built the farm on a crossroads, and a full quarter of the circle in the farm is overhanging a cliff & produces no spawns, I have done very little slabbing in area (just enough to get me safely into the farm). Verdict: still collecting around 20 wither skull heads an hour which is more than enough to keep me happy. The good news is since I'm next to waste lands, I've thrown a few turtle eggs into the mix & now it's a gold farm too 😅 Love this farm, thanks so much for sharing Silent. Edit: 2 1/2 hours in & 49 skulls. (hard mode, Switch, 12 total spawn spots in my farm). Highly recommend this farm 👍

[@nikkiwilliams5752]

I can confirm this farm still works in 1.20 (march 2024 lol). However my rates are not great. I'm getting about 4 stacks of coal and 20 (not stacks) of skulls per hour. I've spawn proofed about 40 blocks from the edge of the platform in each direction on the fortress parts. I dont need a super efficient farm but I'm just wondering why my rates are so low? EDIT: As per the comments below, I changed the boat for a minecart and had it travelling around a 2×4 area with the hole in the middle. No skeletons get stuck now. I also spawn proofed the whole of the nether underneath the farm (where there wasn't lava). At first I had just put slabs on the parts of the fortress within 40 blocks each direction but later on I did the other parts like the floor and land within 40 blocks and my rates are much better. Off the top of my head I'm getting about 45 stacks of coal per hour, and about 6 stacks of skulls per hour. So a massive increase

[@ScoRPy22]

You have to make sure your piglin is exactly in the centre. Your wither skeletons are stuck and they are unable to fall which is hurting your rates.

[@ScoRPy22]

Instead of a boat you can place 4 glass block and place rails on them making a loop. Now get that piglin in a minecart and he's gonna move around in a loop bcz of this wither skeletons will move too and they'll easily fall

[@nikkiwilliams5752]

@@ScoRPy22 thank you! That's such a good idea! I'll give it a shot

[@ScoRPy22]

@@nikkiwilliams5752 Yeah, I didn't try this bcz original idea worked for me but someone on Silent's discord suggested this. Though I'm not sure if skeletons would get blocked by glass blocks or not. So you might have to do some tests in creative first.

[@nikkiwilliams5752]

@@ScoRPy22 that's a good shout. I appreciate it :)

[@cianconway2540]

Mobs are still spawning on my slabs in the nether fortress how is this possible lol

[@krisgosney117]

They might be falling down from above I’ve had that problem with a different wither farm before

[@nachoszb]

Common errors/Why my command blocks dont work? 1.Make sure the orentation of the command blocks is correct, the Arrow on the top of the purple command block should be pointing to the Green one, and the Green one should point to its left. 2. The new commands working on 1.20 are the following: Purple Block: execute at @e[wither_skeleton] run setblock ~ ~-1 ~ cyan_wool Green Block: /kill @e[r=100]

[@IgorGamerYT1]

Purple command is wrong

[@bencrystall6822]

This works, but it has to say type=wither_skeleton

[@VoidPlayz_ROBLOX]

I never actually knew how good bedrock farms could be but with enough effort they could actually compete with Java farms pretty closely

[@Jesus_loves8]

Thank u so much for getting this out so FAST🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@ibrahimshahab3766]

Ello silent! I tried to make this farm but I came across an issue with commands... the "execute @a" command does not work for me. I have to run the command "execute at @a run fill ..." And whenever i run the command for placing wool or any block under the wither skeletons, it places nothing. Any solutions??

[@kingbackwards]

First it should be @e not @a, so copy and paste the original command from the description and see if that works. Otherwise you can try the command in this syntax: execute as @e[type=wither_skeleton] at @s run setblock ~ ~-1 ~ wool 3 That should do the same thing.

[@ibrahimshahab3766]

@@kingbackwards thanks my guy

[@samkosch7963]

@@kingbackwards yo this helped me beyond comprehension, thankyou

[@smilleyseyes7185]

Does this farm still work?

[@Mobro07]

No

[@uweird9154]

Does this still work

[@JeanOctavia]

yes

[@Vintage_Bert]

Your Farm videos is what i always watch Becuz they are simple and efficient but i never built one yet but soon ill built one when i need one of ur farms

[@GrouchTheGreat]

Would placing dirt + wither roses inside your old design work similarly/better? I'm having problems sorting all the items when holding a looting sword but I'm planning on cutting the storage system in two to compensate for that (talking about old design but using 2 simple kill chambers for overworld side)

[@silentwisperer]

yea thats fine too

[@bencrystall6822]

For anyone wondering, this works in 1.20 still. Its worth spawn proofing to improve the drops, it helps massively. I spawn proofed an area of 40 blocks and removed all the lava in a 40 block radius to stop striders spawning. Some people have said to raise the spawning platforms by one, you can do it if you want, but it doesn't improve the rates. I tested both versions with 27 spawning spots for 20 minutes, and here were the results: Silents design: 6 stacks and 47 coal, 13 stacks and 32 bones and 19 heads Spawning spots moved up: 6 stacks and 45 coal, 13 stacks and 57 bones, 14 heads The variations in drops can be deduced to luck, nothing more. It seems the rates are the same either way. I tested it without looting 3 just to save on counting, however, testing it with looting 3 would have just increased the rates for both farms, and would have no made a difference when comparing.

[@redpanda8238]

When I built this farm as shown in video I was getting zombie piglin and blaze Spawn which weee decreasing rates alot so I raised spawn platform by one block(alot comments suggested that so) and rates improved and piglin and blazes also stopped spawning but rates are still very low compare to what's shown in video. I have spawn proofed everything in 40 block radius using foxytail pack but I still gets very low rates compare to what is shown in video . I gets around 5 stack coal, 9 stack bones and 24 either skulls after 20 min afk with looting 3.

[@bencrystall6822]

@@redpanda8238 Hmm not sure what your issue could be exactly. You are getting the same rates as me when I didn’t have looting 3. I’d check your render distance and make sure it’s set to the lowest possible. Also I removed all the lava (which was a pain) but it massively improved drops.

[@redpanda8238]

@@bencrystall6822 I play on sim4 and reder distance is also low. Lava ? I thought lava is immune to Spawn so there's no need to spawn proof that ?

[@bencrystall6822]

@@redpanda8238 The striders affect the rates unfortunately, I didn’t lava proof at first, then I noticed rates were low. Made a copy of the world in creative and in spectator mode noticed that as soon as striders spawned the rates lowered. I removed the lava and rates were fast again :)

[@redpanda8238]

@@bencrystall6822 ohhh I didn't know that but how am I suppose to remove like 40x40 lava Ocean 😨 that would take like week to do so.

[@cyrusjohnsigua8429]

Can this farm still work today

[@Hyperslayer12]

yes