Minimum Support Price MSP Explained | Do all farmers benefit? Affect on Indian Economy

[@KrishnachandraPanigrahi]

Now it's very clear why the major protest is from Punjab and Haryana. Thanks Amit Sir

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@aviksaha2746]

Was there at any point of time when MSP was even mentioned in any bill from 1947-2020 ?

[@yuvraj1971]

That's why new farm law remove middle man

[@harshjain3122]

@@charanjeet5804 that was a good one

[@AdityaRaj-cd5yp]

@@charanjeet5804 we already have 9.6% budget deficit, except of farmer there are others things need to be considered.

[@manikmondal2370]

Every lecture always gives vibes like 9.0 IMDB rating.

[@tanveeransari2537]

I think in KZbin videos should also be have the rating system in which we can determine the quality of content. Like and dislike ratio doesn't do the justice. As i think!

[@manikmondal2370]

@@tanveeransari2537 agreed . Rating for each video would be a very constructive idea. And subscription to rating wise videos will create a good timeline for newsfeed in KZbin. Nonetheless we are getting access to Amit Sengupta's lecture in free. Thanks to KZbin for that.

[@gingergranttech]

It's useless for you .ur jobless anyways 😂🤣😂🖕

[@manikmondal2370]

@@gingergranttech focus on your study bro.

[@ambreshkumarmj6224]

Bade movie lover lagthey ho

[@prasadkulkarni3343]

Within 7 minutes every angle covered , nothing found anywhere best work sir

[@SHK8553]

Sir I found ur channel when I am searching through one of my colleagues phone,,, It's true that those who are destined to know, will surely know each other....

[@mahesh702121]

Only some states are getting rich..come to Maharashtra and Telangana states especially... suicide death rates very high ..Msp benefiting only to some extent.

[@swapnapathakoti7996]

360 degree cover of the topic in less time in simplified and understandable manner . Thank you so much sir We are lucky to have u and get your channel

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@samuelsp204]

He is real gem. Thank you sirji. Although I secured UPSC.Its become ritual to me to watch sir's video.

[@h.mighty9225]

Woow bhaiya which services you are alloted and what was strategy...??

[@GokulKrishnaKM-cx7px]

Wow ! Congratulations. Can you give tips on consistency of prep ? Help us.

[@j.ramanandnayak4571]

That's great bro... 👏Congratulations

[@sukamaldash3599]

I'm getting goosebumps while listening to the explanation!

[@tusharbisht4632]

Goosebumps ? 🧸 I am feeling exhilarated After listening Him Can easily grasp what he is saying At 2X speed also

[@sukamaldash3599]

@@tusharbisht4632 yupp buddy. Goosebumps! All these troubles of past few months, I've been trying to grasp the concept as well as connect dots in an understandable manner. I did it though, but obviously not on this level. That's why goosebumps.

[@sumitpanchal9585]

Explained very well. Without any political opinion. Loved it, shared already.

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@karanguleria95]

Now it makes sense why farmers viz rich landlords are protesting heavily especially Haryana and Punjab,you just cleared my doubt. I support farm laws , they represents the soul of directive principles of state policy and very idea of federalism.

[@nikhilgr]

The above explaination is flawed in terms of the solution. MSP is unsustainable but so are the new laws. The real problem is the high cost of cultivation

[@hwdareu5848]

Anything that Modi policies brings is a disaster for the common people. Remember we used to get LPG Cylinder by Rs460 before BJP came into power? Now we are paying more than Rs1000 per cylinder. What else do you think this government will bring for the jobless youths and common people but privatising the public sectors and selling it to few selected individuals. Mukesh Ambani, Adani wealth will not improve the living conditions of the poor though it might look good in paper in terms of GDPm

[@ervivekchoubey]

Lol

[@हनुमानगुप्ताएकरामभक्त]

@@hwdareu5848 Have u gone senile same I can say in 2008 we used to purchase LPG at rate of 270 but in 2014 it became 490 almost double my father says they used to purchase mustard oil at 30/litre in 1999 but in 2007 it became 70/litres

[@khems_bi9491]

@@hwdareu5848 I'm used to buy an Atlas book in 2007 at a cost of 65 for an Oxford Atlas 10th edition, now am paying 300 for an Oxford Atlas 36th edition ..With d tym everything is upgrading u can't hold same price 4 same thing after 10 yrs

[@lokeshkondala8945]

Me to the Google: Is there any other channel like Amit Sengupta ..... Google: Error 404

[@sumantiwary535]

😆 very much true

[@sukamaldash3599]

I literally searched this around 2 months ago! Got the no result. But later realised my network got interrupted. Deja vu! 😂

[@SHK8553]

Really truth👍👍👍👍😂😂😂

[@manikmondal2370]

Nobody knows the correct recipies of making video like Amit Sengupta.

[@sumantiwary535]

@@manikmondal2370 Just Like KFCs food items 😆😆

[@rajeshbg2942]

Thank you for your wonderful, crisp, clear explanation. Hats off to Modi Government to help the farmers, it is the middle men and political parties who are at a loss... sincerely wish the Farm laws are brought into the governance.

[@kumarsatyambivans6849]

Rkzbin.info-R0atOUKwxA?feature=share

[@homijbhabha8860]

We as a country has to come off this whole freebie culture, free diesel, free petrol,free housing,interest free loans- nothing is truly free in a country, money keeps moving,collecting interest, in investments etc.

[@smileysmile4937]

To end the freebies, salary should increase. But the country like india where labour availablity is such a cheap factor..private sectors don't increase the salary instead they hire the labour who is ready to work at cheapest salary. So, in that case freebies means a lot for public.

[@holapola4125]

@@smileysmile4937 with too much of freedom you cant do it.

[@abhishekpawar5126]

Free petrol diesel ? 😂 We Indians pay the highest amount of tax on fuel

[@homijbhabha8860]

@@abhishekpawar5126 I mean for farmers with tractors and many government employees

[@nachannachle2706]

Wah! Perfectly summarised with a pragmatic perspective. Yes, Farm bills need to be amended rather than scrapped, if every farmer in Indian is to benefit from Agricultural laws. Otherwise, the system will remain entirely under the control of PB and HR and decimate other major farming states like UP, AP, BR, TN and WB. Bahut shukria, Amit-ji.

[@firephoenix8966]

Reforms in terms of farm laws and upgrading the agricultural sector is very important for long term benefits

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@venketashwarimartin6037]

Tones of thanks Amit! At last my request is accepted! I suppose, thats is why the farmers of north are protesting! Isn't it? Hats off to you, for very clearly explaining about MSP, I have started recommending the students to watch your videos for better understanding of the lesson, thanks to online classes otherwise I would not have known you, never been to this digital world of KZbin! God bless! 👍

[@lakshyakashyap1490]

I may answer this, as Commission for Agriculture Costs and Prices has recommended MSP on 23 items, out of which Wheat and Paddy are the most procured crops. Now in FCI reports (I will give the link for it), you will find that a large chunk of Wheat and Paddy are procured from Punjab and a Huge chunk of Wheat from Haryana. you will find them at no 1& 2 places in FCI procurement. Now FCI procurement means that these items are purchased at MSP. Actually, govt itself procures disproportionately crop-wise and purchases wheat and paddy in very large quantities as compared to other products. Why? cos they want to feed the population by PDS and more importantly these crops can be stored easily and fulfill energy needs of poor and lower middle class. Well, usually it is possible because Punjab and Haryana are the biggest producers of such commodities, next is APMC model is highly successful due to the good infrastructure in these states at least better than other states. What happens in other states, Usually Rich farmers are able to use such an opportunity very well, the success of this model is such that the usual market rate of crops is much higher in Punjab as compared toBihar. Many times it is seen that traders from other state are selling in Punjab markets. Their whole economic model is based on MSP and APMC that's why they fear that the removal of MSP will lead to their systems collapse. Usually, Punjab and Haryana are getting the maximum benefit of APMC systems which other states are not able to. link for FCI procurement fci.gov.in/procurements.php?view=87

[@dontbecoward5302]

@@lakshyakashyap1490 hlo can u pls explain what's APMC in layman language and

[@EasyUpsc]

Best KZbin channel for UPSC ASPIRANTS Thank you sir 👍👍👍🚨🚨🚨

[@ashugiri7235]

The lion is back once again with another topic 😸... thanks sir ❤️

[@dharminderpuri8451]

Hello Ashu....

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@AR-eb4yv]

Amazing... Someone finally made absolute sense out of it....

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@ravidhaker7533]

Thoroughly explained as per existing scenarios and Everyone must watch it. 🤘

[@anilb4768]

I am from a farming family from Odisha....and i can assure you that MSP is a "MYTH"...Whatever the MSP(paddy) amount maybe we get only around 1500rs...the persons getting benefit from it are the middlemen🙏

[@nikhilgr]

The above explaination is flawed in terms of the solution. MSP is unsustainable but so are the new laws. The real problem is the high cost of cultivation

[@vivek-rn6en]

Well said🙏. Don't forget that they charge commission and remove some portions as waste and down the price by saying it as a poor quality.

[@anilb4768]

@@vivek-rn6en yes that too is prevalent here...i forgot to mention .

[@surendrabarsode8959]

Govt should declare its targeted purchases of food grains under Food Security Law -wheat, rice, dal etc. at the least 1 year before and announce schedule of quantity and quality of its purchases from different states and mandis along with the start and end dates. MSP is declared before the sowing starts. It should spread its procurement widely and not concentrate only on Punjab, Haryana and UP. It should not purchase food grains beyond minimum buffer stock requirements. This will remove undue benefits farmers from these 3 states are getting. But Central Govt should also remove all subsidies it gives and distribute the amount saved as DBT to all the farmers in the country along with a minimum income support to all farmers and landless workers. This will free farmers to decide what and when and how much to produce and will change the conditions for better.

[@lakshyakashyap1490]

exactly gov't should not use MSP as a reservation for Farmers of Punjab and Haryana only, all the farmers of the nation must have their share in it.

[@VALAR_Morgulis.]

Excellent 👍 FCI should purchase equally from all states Reservation required basis on no of farmers in each state on FCI budget allocation strictly Farmers from Punjab and Hariyana should be that selfish Whole farmers protest in India is from Punjab and Haryana it self

[@bikashmalakar9303]

Hence, Govt must ensure that Private Sector as well as APMC can't purchase corp from farmers below MSP. Made a healthy auction. Set a base price for a corp (that is MSP), then who have the power they will buy from farmers. Thus it will create a open competitive market for buyers and also a fair mechanism for poor farmers. But the glitch is here, Govt don't want to see it as auction with a Base Price as MSP, because the private player will be unhappy and Govt can't let them unhappy.

[@bikashmalakar9303]

@Saurav Singh MSP is calculated on the expenditure incurred by farmers to produce his corp. Yes, MSP is higher than market and that's why market player (APMC) are getting the profit instead of farmers. Considering the welfare of farmers, Govt fixed MSP on slight higher side, but Mandi players compelled farmers to sell their corp in lower price. You are talking about the profit and loss of buyer (Mandi or Private Player) but, I am talking about the price guarantee and profit of farmers, who produce their own corp. Why are you worried about BUYERs? Farmers will SELL their product as per their own wish, and from where they be more benefited. Why farmers will SELL their product in lower than MSP?

[@mukulsanatan5937]

amendments in farm laws are necessary for which govt. has accepted. so it,s duty of farmers to help the govt.

[@vigneshguhan3393]

Much needed one to understand the current scenario 💯

[@muthuvignesh7027]

Superbly explained about current scenario...recently i faced loss cultivating rice same as explained in this video... One furture thing missed in this video... There is link bw pvt players and inflation and soon pvt will become like mandis...in all ways loss is for farmers...

[@v.msypher338]

Such a cool take keeping both sides in mind. Very well done.

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@rifarocks5651]

Every sec video in youtube confused me...when i tried to know all about farmers protest....But Luckily...I got to watch this..👍No wrds...All i Wanted to know, is here in this channel #SimpleNClear 😊...

[@Pankaj_Rathore]

I don't know why but KZbin Only showing 10 comments but here a lot of comment present 🤨

[@sindhuja_verma]

Perfectly explained.

[@ramji24hours]

Amazing amit ji... Tanq.. Clearly understand Wat is MSP and why new farmer bill..after watching this video I support farmers bill...

[@riyabhatia6871]

Sir your lecture was amazing🤩 I loved the way you just simplify everything.

[@kumarsatyambivans6849]

Rkzbin.info-R0atOUKwxA?feature=share

[@ashakonta1032]

SIR ITS LOVELY....HAPPY TO LEARN FROM YOUR CRYSTAL CLEAR EXPLANATION

[@mirnayeem2611]

Highly informative sir ... Keep making such videos ... You are ocean of knowledge sir 🙏🙏🙏

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@aadilashraflone]

I can recall before 7 yrs ,The Sugar was being available on Govt Public distribution Shops ,at Subsidized rates ,Now It is not and we have to buy it from open market.It means that The Sugar producing states entered into private market and Govt did away MSP for sugarcane. My question is ,Are sugarcane grower farmers happy now ? was govt able to manage fiscal deficit by doing away with MSP for Sugarcane ?How a common man suffers because of This Step???

[@nijanthan.s8733]

For sugarcane industry there is "FRP". (Fair and remunerative price (FRP) is the minimum price at which rate sugarcane is to be purchased by sugar mills from farmers.The FRP is based on the recommendation of the Commission of Agricultural Costs & Prices (CACP)...similar to MSP)

[@aadilashraflone]

@@nijanthan.s8733 then Why Sugar is not available on PDS???

[@vccv9785]

Oh you stupid donut. It's available at the FRP and state determined prices. Cane farmers still get all their produce procured. Sugar is still available at fair price shops and is distributed through PDS under NFSA.

[@aadilashraflone]

@@vccv9785 Then enjoy brooke bond Tea 😄😄😄😄

[@vccv9785]

@@aadilashraflone lol acha

[@akshay0249]

Basically Punjabis and Haryanvis are reaping most of the benefits leaving nothing to rest of india. And if these bills stay whole india will benefit and share of those farmers will be lesser hence they are protesting. Understood. Thank you sir 🙏🏻

[@praveenkumarpandey8101]

Sir, I am huge admirer of your teaching. Being a FCI quality cader, i wanted to inform some corrections: 1. There is no such 'safety net' decided by FCI during procurement of foodgrains. FCI purchases all the arrived stock in mandi from farmers through comission agents. And past two years, FCI strictly ensure every single payment of foodgrains to the concerned farmers by the bank statement of comission agents. This marketing season, FCI have developed mechanism of directly payment to the farmers which brings more transparency. 2. APMC in Punjab are plays main supporting role in procurement by FCI. He does not procure foodgrains from farmers. He only provide space and facilities for procurement. In Punjab and Haryana, APMC are well structured and well governed. Because of this, farmers easily sell their produce to the FCI without any problem (e.g. Unloading, cleaning, bagging and loading of foodgrains). But this system is not so developed in Uttar Pradesh. Thus, farmers faces many procedure and steps to sell their produce to the FCI. But not all the farmers of UP bears this lengthy process and most of them are not even aware of government purchases. So, they sell their produce to private players at very disappointed price. 3. FCI have no cap for procurement limit. But he repeatedly requested to Punjab government to set procurement limit. Because every year production of foodgrains increases which was ultimately resulted in increase fiscal deficit (e.g. Fiscal deficit increase due to reimbursement of FCI loan during current budget). 4. Yes, it is true that Punjab and Haryana are most benefited by MSP system. And most of the farmers who benefitted by MSP are big farmers. But state like Uttar Pradesh where percentage of small and marginal farmers are high, they can not awail this MSP system due to weak structure of APMCs. 4. Sir, i am not well aware of Farm laws. Yes, i believe that MSP may increase food subsidy. But indirect removal of MSP through Farm laws is not in the interest of farmers future. Government did not included MSP in farm laws. He only ensure guaranteed price which is governed by private trader and farmer. And we well aware the farmers were not afford negotiations with such big players. Government says, MSP is administrative matter not a legesative. In my opinion government must ensure MSP to the farmers in written form for safeguarding the interest of farmers. Sir, i am also supporter of Capitalism. But the India is a poor country. We are not developed as Europe and US. Yes we need capitalistic approach. But we also need government backing. So some socialist features must be remain in Indian economy. 🙏🙏🙏

[@Yuvrajsinh6]

Thank you so much sir. ...🙏🏻😊🙏🏻

[@Transformer033]

After 2 years, I understood why only Punjab Haryana farmers were opposing the Farm Bill.

[@Robin-yc9fq]

MSP is not beneficial for farmer because what happens farmers go to mandi then they have given token means they need to come after atleast 15 days and also farmers need transportation and sometimes happens that they need money as soon as possible to give money to labours etc so they sell them at home at low price because they don't have money for transportation.

[@gurchaininsan777]

U r wrong this system is one of the best marketing system. In Punjab we are happy with it. We sell all our produce at MSP. THESE LAW will make farmers of Punjab and Haryana like farmers of other states.

[@bharatkumarreddy294]

@@gurchaininsan777 ek simple baat bolu tum Punjabi logon ke liye reforms nahi rukenge, koi bhi bill vapas nahi hoga likh ke le le

[@gurchaininsan777]

@@bharatkumarreddy294 Let's see only time will tell

[@bharatkumarreddy294]

@@gurchaininsan777 we should dictate our future not just depend on bhagwan barosa time

[@gurchaininsan777]

@@bharatkumarreddy294 ok ji If don't support us then it's ok ji no problem But we will fight for our rights

[@LOFI.MUSICS.99]

Thenkewww sir ji.....u are a genius teacher really 😘😘

[@Girish202]

The most underrated channel.

[@cssanketsrivastava7867]

Well explained about MSP. Though, i don't know, why i can sense some contradictions from your earlier explanation of Farm Bills 4 months ago. For eg. there we understood Rich Farmers will be benefited out of New Farm Bills while here it seems different.

[@yadvendrasingh6849]

Extremely helpful thank you sir

[@jotarokujo5538]

Amazing video Amit sir. So it is the middlemen who stand to lose the most with the new bills. Now i know who orchestrated this whole protest...

[@aayusharora2459]

Yes that's why you are seeing protest only in punjab and few parts of haryana

[@jotarokujo5538]

@@aayusharora2459 evil men. They are the embodiment of when capitalism goes unchecked. Unilateral exploitation of poor.

[@priyayadav4389]

@@jotarokujo5538 hey my interview is scheduled on 2nd March for PSB...if they ask me my opinion about Farmer protest...what diplomatic answer I should give them ?

[@usharaninarra313]

But these laws were already introduced in abroad and proved to be disastrous. These laws also states that no tax needed to be paid for private sector, clearly indicates that it should increase privatisation. If Privatisation is introduced farmers are prone to be fooled by corporate companies whose agenda is only profits. As we know the literacy rate of farmers is comparatively low, they will not be able to understand the company policy and conditions before signing any agreement. In order to protect our farmers I think government should be involved and help farmer’s through the process.

[@mangalgharami4904]

MSP must be legalized. The government needn't buy. The companies must buy above MSP

[@hrithikmaity2269]

There are different types and qualities of paddy,rice, wheats, pulses and spices.... You cannot make such MSP because low quality rice will more price and high quality might be decreased by bussinessman at end it's a disaster like testing each and every student of the entire school only in a single subject(without variation)......

[@adithyaadi1363]

Thats why we need farm laws .

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@poojakarn]

Crystal clear explanation.🙏🙏🙏

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@cseaspirant1757]

Lovely lecture sir...

[@valarmorghulis8387]

If Agriculture Markets are put open for private players they will exploit the farmers by many way ,not a new thing. i think the solution is govt should open the agricultural produce to open market but fixing a minimum price for every crop, ( for private players)by this way both objectives can b met, ( farmers happy, end of govt's role in agriculture and entry of private players in agriculture)

[@tusharbisht4632]

Coorporate would be penalized And any farmer may File a case against any Fraudlant Activities of Coorporates Unlike Middlemen Who are Loan provider and Take Undue advantage of Farmer's helplessness It's not a Compulsion to sell your Crops to Coorporates It's your Freedom of Choice

[@valarmorghulis8387]

@@tusharbisht4632it's very difficult for the poor and uneducated farmers to file case against the cooperatives, and still if they file case against the cooperatives it will take years to solve the cases and farmers will suffer anyway, n we can ignore the influence of money n muscle power of these cooperatives. Agriculture must b privatised but without hurting the core intrests of farmers.

[@tusharbisht4632]

@@valarmorghulis8387 Dear In a way Farmer Procure farm Related stuffs Or Any thing for his self Consumption from Any Private Player If they didn't Get exploited by them How Can they get exploited now Does it mean He won't procure anything to sustain his livelihood

[@AbhishekGuptat]

Woww what a complete and easy to understand explanation!!

[@don8535]

Always the best quality videos and information on this channel💪💪💪🙏🙏🙏

[@StormBringers-w9b]

Thank You Sir Finally I got it 😊

[@Rachna1]

Superb explanation Sir!! 🙏Thanks a Ton!

[@pradeepchauhan2379]

Maza aa gya sir clarity bahut hai apne

[@Viraj_2305]

Sir, I understood the point that the government can't procure all the food produce from all the farmers across the country but if govt makes a law by which procurement of agricultural produce below MSP by any private party would not be accepted then the storage issue can be sorted out. By doing it inflation will certainly happen but by this, the lowest strata of the economy will get benefit in terms of money. This will be the biggest tool for poverty alleviation. The ruling government should also consider this point.

[@atharvak4312]

Inflation will have chilling effects on poorer section.

[@nikitasingh9516]

When will you upload the part 3 and other parts of budget ? Please do that first 🙏🙏 kind request sir😊

[@jyotikumar1547]

Incredible sir aap best hai..🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@durgeshmishra7313]

That's why only Punjab and Haryana's farmers are protesting.....

[@learner3499]

What you think they are not Farmers? There protest doesn't matter?

[@durgeshmishra7313]

@@learner3499 I didn't say that... I mean they are more beneficial than other states farmers...

[@Nitika-f4i]

Amazing , superrr amazing

[@D.T-r7n]

Thanks for the help

[@CBuzzShorts]

Apart from the lack of storage facility of FCI, Govt can't buy whole crop as the govt has to distribute it to Poor at a very lower rate(effectively free). And who pays the burden of this free distribution? Tax payers.

[@hiteshgujarathi4636]

That's not entirely true. Because many of the stock go waste because the facilities are not up-to-date. Due to rain issue and humidity you'll find this crops are rotting in the warehouse of government. And even many time FCI food corporation of india sell this product to private buyer at much cheaper price and officers of FCI will fill up their pockets along with middleman and local politicians.

[@kavyaachar147]

Sir please post remaining parts of budget analysis as soon as possible.... Waiting for the video.....

[@sathyamoorthy1325]

Very much informative sir

[@komalparmar2223]

Please share this , I already shared this with my friends and sir you are awesome 😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@yashbakshi4306]

Awesome, awesome & thoroughly awesome ❤️

[@sv3656]

That's why I am supporting Farm laws and against making laws on MSP.

[@kalebj7001]

Well explained. 👍 The reform looks good in paper, but opening up the market to private players doesn't guarantee and a smooth transaction. The issues of APMC price management can also pop up when big private corps step in. Similarly the misuse in contract farming can also be suppressive to the farmers. The farm laws arnt perfect, however they could have been sent a parliamentary standing committee before being passed hastily without in depth expert inputs.

[@rajx7120]

To avoid misuse only the law was introduced. The law was not introducing contract farming. It is already there. The law provided guidelines to frame contracts in a way that farmer will benefit. For eg: private buyer cannot ealk away from the contract, but farmer can if someone else is paying a higher price.

[@haroonrashid5105]

You should also make complete video on polity lecture

[@Drona9963]

Sir please make a video on LoC and LAC

[@debabratakundu9602]

Excellent lecture. Thank you very much,Respected Sir. Respected Sir, please, upload comprehensive lecture series on "Latest Economic Survey 2020-21" & please, keep on uploading the rest lectures on rest 4 parts of "Union Budget 2021-22" for UPSC CSE 2021 Exam Preparation.

[@travel_1shorts]

Now it's make sense why largely farmers from Punjub and Haryana re protesting, I dont why I am Cursing govt till now

[@shaiphawa4613]

listening to this gave me a whle new perspective on how the whole things works. There is a thin line of balancing the string and make everyone happy, but that seem to be a distant star.

[@gobhikaar2823]

Very clear explanation. Thank you 🙂

[@drbharati3330]

Very very impressive and thoughtful lecture

[@keerthikeeru7]

Thnqqq soo much sir.. for giving valuable information in summerised form.. 👍👍🙏

[@shivah2353]

Helpline

[@shilpi207]

Tnqqqqq so much amit and your channel The way u present the topic..all the doubts gets crystal clear Seriously no one can match u Lots of love to u Keep going ❤️🔥

[@chndrjt]

We must have 42000 mandis but we only have 7000 as of now. Government should work on minimising the effort farmers have to make to sell the produce. They should strengthen the APMC system by linking all of them through e-NAM. Instead of fixing APMC system, they are trying to get out of agriculture.

[@robinparashar]

Right. They are simply running away from their responsibility.

[@vrg1966]

You are right. Increasing the mandis, enforcing the MSP for both mandi traders as well private buyers must be the responsibility of governments which they (both current and previous governments) failed to do. Please remember that MSP is only for 23 essential items and not for all goods. The statement "Farmers are not allowed to sell outside mandis" is not correct. In Mandis, the traders have long term relationship with farmers and support them when they need money. The same will not happen with private/corporate traders. Prices for farmers will go down further whereas for general public it will rise. In any way, only the private players (corporates) will be benefitted. Hence the fear of farmers is very genuine and that is the reason why they are protesting. The assumption that private players will give farmers the fair price (greater than or equal to MSP) will not happen in real life.

[@IndrakalaTayde]

Awesome 1 video clear concept

[@ToppersChoicePhysics]

You are my favourite teacher

[@ramakrish5647]

In my local regional language to appreciate was Nu thopu anna 😉 ..osm sir

[@rounaksinghhoonjan378]

Very right that the benefit of MSP is going only to the rich farmers while the poor farmers are unable to improve their conditions. The new farm reform laws address this concern by allowing the private sector in the agriculture field. The concern that the private sector would exploit the farmers & acquire their land is a conservative one. It is clearly mentioned in the new laws that the private players cannot take farmers' land. The laws are made to protect the farmers' interests while at the same time modernise the agriculture sector with the help of the private sector.

[@nachannachle2706]

I think the root of the problem is that some farmers simply cannot access MSP due to: - lack of transportation (i.e if you live remote, you have no road/train for delivering your produce) - lack of crop diversification (i.e if you only do 1 produce, you can't win the race against quotas) - lack of awareness about the scheme (i.e if you are not part of a union you have no guidance) This is what needs to be addressed first, because no "private sector" folks are going to invest in INTERSTATE transportation infrastructure, STATE land and irrigation development or REGIONAL farmers union/associations of India. Tl;DR: A coordinated and targeted approach is needed across the board in government administration, not just on paper at the Lok Sabha.

[@rounaksinghhoonjan378]

@@nachannachle2706 How do you do that? By improving farmer's income and by "farmers", I mean the actual cultivators & not those who just pick the produce at the field & with their connections sell it & take farmer's money. And don't you think that it is injustice with the farmers to not allow them to sell outside the Mandis? They should have the freedom to sell anywhere they want.

[@ektachauhan0505]

Clear and crisp lecture🙏 😇

[@A.khan123]

Thank you so much sir 🙏 🙏 🙏 I love your majestic voice always encourage and put focus on main nd important points of every single vedio made by you❤️❤️

[@ManishVerma-hk9vd]

Finally I understood it

[@drShivaR]

Thank you for providing quality information.

[@kumaran4798]

Very good explanation

[@jitendrachandra4169]

Your are really very humble man 👍🏼❤️❤️

[@rajeevtiwari3862]

Excellent explanation by you sir. .

[@antonyraj6582]

Wonderful class thank you

[@jonawangsa6489]

Who are those people giving dislikes 😤

[@tusharbisht4632]

They don't want to Know the Reality Same People who readily rely a Propoganda

[@availablehage]

Great quality content...commenting so that the YT algo pushes the video to more viewers..

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@availablehage]

@@charanjeet5804 they tried it in soviet union..people started getting lazy and broke the economy

[@sydiptos]

Thanks Amit, for this informative video. I do have few questions, and a opinion regarding our policymakers. Procurement of grains at MSP is the only reason for fiscal deficit?? Is there any data on how many FCI godowns are there in our country and what are the present requirements?? Opinion : Government have money to spend on projects like Central Vista at that time fiscal deficit isn't worrisome but building basic warehouses and paying for MSP makes them worried.

[@charanjeet5804]

The question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@harshjain3122]

Central vista is like 1000 crore. That's 3x less than what was lost per day in farmer's protest. Anyway, your so called basic warehouses aren't really basic when they need to be maintained and corruption gets in the way too with each crop having its own requirement. At the end of the day, govt shouldn't do business. It's not the job they were assigned to do in the first place

[@newlook353]

It's actual simple. FCI buys and stores it. But the supply is surplus, demand for these crops don't equal supply. So no point in making warehouses to store more. We don't export in those quantities, because the demand isn't that much. Even if a market were to exist to export to, the price would be quite low. Government would have to export at a loss.

[@aaditijain7100]

FABULOUS

[@VaniSharma-rz2cj]

Thankyou

[@pushprajbhardwaj4820]

0.36 If even half of this price is practically given to our farmers, there will be no farmers suicides. But sadly, its just in papers.

[@glennex0077]

The thing is govt cant do anything to stop these middlemen from adjusting govt msp prices

[@harshjain3122]

@@glennex0077 u have a person in the middle who has basically ntg at risk in the whole supply chain and you give him the power. Why wouldn't he loot you? That should have been obv to our preceding generations

[@gauravsinghtomar359]

Great analysis..💯

[@charanjeet5804]

yes very nicely explained. But the question is can MSP be made a legal right and can 100% crop be procured on MSP? watch this video for clarity on that topic. it has been very elaborately explained. kzbin.info/www/bejne/i2jUapajntqDqM0

[@sandeepdevarars3209]

Tq Amith Sir u give so much knowledge to us tq.......