Bad Apple!! 【VOCALOID ver.】

[@unitymask]

i used to think "how do people recognize all those touhou characters?" now i understand

[@creepingd3th]

I recognized all touhou characters and vocaloids,oh no😳

[@carson6188]

sammmee 😭

[@kylqssymph_p7110]

omg idk how i recognized all the vocaloid characters 😟😟😟

[@ruikasasfixer]

@@creepingd3th same-

[@somegirlwhois...1686]

Me, who recognized most of the Touhou characters but only a few of the vocaloids.😁

[@lilliegvmi]

The fact that I could tell who every Vocaloid was just by their shadow says a lot😭😭

[@Sheamuscz]

Well, you're not the only one. :D

[@thatonealexkun6379]

Yes its so cool!

[@miihsan]

Yep

[@wealllovemia]

I guess it’s cuz I simp for all of them and can easily identify them by their shadow

[@Thingumadoodle0518]

The only one I didn't recognize at first was Lily lol, goes to show how good the Vocaloid character designs are!

[@ririwxs]

the way how rin caught the apple with her broom… respect

[@cakeidoskull]

1k like

[@lesbnamedalex]

@@cakeidoskull likes*

[@lesbnamedalex]

@Spamton G. Spamton geez I was just fixing grammar

[@lieutenaMMD]

@@lesbnamedalex yes but why

[@lesbnamedalex]

@@lieutenaMMD no reason

[@daisydaysu]

i have a whole playlist just for bad apple, adding this right to it

[@moshi-moshi1578]

So do I lol

[@Yuki-56]

Me too lol

[@thedotintheletteri]

There’s just so much bad apple content, I can’t blame you

[@queenaremi437]

Same

[@dash3995]

Have you already added bad apple animated in desmos? It's one of my favorites

[@crisjuli544]

0:22 rin on her way to become princess and terrorize her people and having her brother be killed in her place

[@ventilatedarea.2363]

LMAO

[@OnisanHere]

daughter and servant of evil reference

[@jasperwong2970]

With Gakupo as the gardener

[@GoldenEmpyrean]

Lol

[@stxrryfish]

@@jasperwong2970 Is that an evillious reference (to gammon octo)

[@rayscarlet7055]

TODAY ON "DO YOU HAVE FRIENDS" WE HAVE ALL OF THE PEOPLE THAT COULD RECOGNIZE THE VOCALOID JUST BY THE SHADOWS. THE ANSWER IS NO, WE DONT HAVE FRIENDS THANK YOU SEE YOU NEXT WEEK

[@net_lag]

You didn't have to shout all that😅 Also I'm a noob at the vocaloid community and I still don't have friends.

[@ayashegwynngelapaguirigan-29]

@@net_lag idk who needed this information but ok!

[@net_lag]

@@ayashegwynngelapaguirigan-29 DO YOU WANT ME TO ERASE MY COMMENT.. THERE ARE TWO WAYS OF DOING IT.. JUST LET ME KNOW OK?

[@almondcookie994]

im legendary because i have friends and can tell who vocaloid is who 🤩🤩

[@MinoMicha]

But I thought we're friends since we're in the same fandom? :'(

[@rabbittherobot]

Me - "Ooo! Bad Apple but with vocaloids!" Also Me - * patiently waiting for Vflower to make an appearence *

[@Sugarz-qp5re]

Ikr

[@sanariyadilman1114]

me waiting for akari:

[@Sugarz-qp5re]

@@JustDarkest Yes Piko Too

[@stages_of_mania]

Ikr

[@ezekieliese]

Me with fukase

[@irachan3978]

ALL OF THE VOCALOIDS WITH TIME STAMPS! 0:00 Miku 0:15 Rin 0:29 Meiko 0:36 Kaito 0:45 Luka 0:51 Len 0:58 Gakupo 1:04 Gumi 1:12 Luo Tianyi 1:19 Nekomura Iroha 1:25 IA 1:33 Anon and Kanon 1:39 V4 Flower 1:45 Fukase 1:53 Teto (UTAU, the one with drill hair) Haku (long straight hair) and Neru (she has the big ponytail, both are fanloids) 1:59 Meika Hime, Meika Miktoto, and Galaco (in that order) 2:03 Macne Nana 2:06 SF-A2 Miki 2:11 Otomachi Una (she's the spinning girl) 2:14 Kiyoteru Hiyama (tall dude) 2:15 Kai Yuuki (short girl) 2:23 Mayu 2:28 SeeU 2:32 Lily 2:33 SeeU (I think) 2:36 Yuzuki Yukari 2:41 CUL 2:50 Merli (girl holding doll) and Aoki Lapis (the doll) 2:56 Tone Rion 3:03 Oliver 3:11 Utatane Piko 3:20 Miku 3:23 Rin

[@patch5384]

i think 2:32 is actually lily! the description has a list of the models used and it fits the placement

[@irachan3978]

@@patch5384 aaaah ok- ty!

[@sakiyaki-sashimi]

It’s sad that I knew all of these before I even saw this comment -_-

[@irachan3978]

@@sakiyaki-sashimi lol it's fine!

[@krowsilver8966]

Teto is actually an utauloid!

[@kokoro7996]

The fact that you recreated the entire video in MMD. respect.

[@DuaneMoody990]

I'd be terrified to try it in another animation program

[@versacetae_3580]

I can’t imagine the effort this must’ve taken lol, you’re so talented minnemi

[@Gummible]

meanwhile: vocaloid fans mistaking the original as a vocaloid song

[@annaferns1840]

I absolutely hate when people do that, especially since Bad Apple was written by a doujin (indie) circle, and not a established musician in a record label or anything.

[@sh0ut0]

That was me 6 years ago.

[@Lucifer_Is_Not_Amused]

I hate that 😩

[@aiseya]

Why do people think that?

[@kansas0606]

I almost thought it was a vocaloid song, but I saw the original song that has actual people singing

[@L_VBS]

Alternative title: Guess the vocaloid by their silhouette while they sing bad apple.

[@snoutts]

recognizing the silhouettes but forgetting everyone's names

[@shady8868]

Same

[@bilge5687]

Most of minemi s posts: funny memes Her vocaloid covers: a blessing from internet

[@hoshi-sama8462]

Touhou + Vocaloid + Minnemi = The perfect video

[@jewelminess]

why did i scream "FUKASEEEEE" when i saw him lmao, my cousin is looking at me like i'm insane

[@lemonacepardopartida915]

SAAAAAME AND HIS SILHOUETTE WA SO COOL TOO?? LIKE BRO

[@lilliegvmi]

@@lemonacepardopartida915IKR

[@Leso_Univrs]

Me when i saw Piko

[@Derpo_Nerpo]

real (i did that too)

[@oreo482]

Epic Now we just need a cursed UTAU version

[@ciao8757]

yes.

[@youdroppedsomething4334]

Yes 😫

[@linkingglagoon8254]

I approve of this suggestion

[@mskittygemma]

This is gonna be SO cursed.

[@oreo482]

@@mskittygemma it would be glorious

[@stages_of_mania]

There’s an indescribable sense of satisfaction you get from recognizing one of the more obscure vocaloids and a very familiar sense of disappointment when another obscure vocaloid doesn’t show up

[@skeouspace]

ayyyee even teto’s there- *the utauloids have invaded.*

[@VideoEnglishSubs]

How many more UTAULOIDS?

[@coxinhalover]

I just noticed that you can hear each vocaloid singing in unison with Miku very quietly

[@shiena_scarlet_official]

Fr

[@RedzaMalaysianCrossover]

Damn, this is probably the most impressive thing I've ever seen! (I really like Rin with YYB model here)

[@emiledesbiens4676]

I mean Massive respect for switching every model to actual Vocaloid and not only making a cover of it. This is by far one of my favorite cover too

[@mskittygemma]

The fact that I can almost tell who everyone was by their silhouettes. I am such a nerd.

[@sakura_pop_soda1627]

I SAW MY CHILDHOOD HIYAMA AND KAAI YUKI I CRY-🥺😭💞💖 Seriously Why do you exist to make such beautiful art?

[@sakura_pop_soda1627]

IT'S BEEN A LONG TIME SINCE I LISTEN TO THIS SONG AND IT'S- ALREADY- AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻💞💞💞💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💖💞💞💞💞💞😆👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 GOOD JOB MINNEMI!!!!!!

[@exaltedb]

From the first few seconds I could tell that this was going to be amazing Both the tuning and the animation are both so incredibly smooth and well done

[@JustDarkest]

0:52 len’s little ponytail is so cute-

[@CrazberriesSoup]

Hatsune Miku - Reimu Hakurei Kagamine Rin - Marisa Kirisame Meiko - Patchouli Knowledge Kaito - Remilia Scarlet Megurine Luka - Sakuya Izayoi Kagamine Len - Flandre Scarlet Yamui Gakupo - Youmu Konpaku Gumi - Yuyuko Saigyouji Luo Tianyi - Komachi Onozuka Nekomura Iroha - Eiki Shiki IA - Fujiwara no Mokou Anon and Kanon - Keine Kamishirasawa V4 Flower - Eirin Yagokoro Fukase - Kaguya Houraisen Teto, Haku and Neru - Prismriver Sisters Merlin Prismriver (Trumpet) Lyrica Prismriver (Piano) Lunasa Prismriver (Violin) Meika Hime, Meika Mikoto, Galaco - Chen, Ran Yakumo, Tewi Inaba Macne Nana - Reisen Udongein Inaba SF-A2 Miki - Sanae Kochiya Otomachi Una - Hina Kagiyama Kaii Yuki - Suwako Moriya MAYU - Yukari Yakumo SeeU - Tenshi Hinanawi Yuzuki Yukari - Aya Shameimaru CUL - Suika Ibuki Merli, Aoki Lapis - Alice Margatroid (and her doll) Tone Rion - Nitori Kawashiro Oliver - Yuuka Kazami Utahans Piko - Elly Kagami Rin and Miku - Reimu and Marisa Comment if i messed up anything

[@HitorinoShizuka]

when both your favorite touhou character and vocaloid share the same part in the music video

[@lvchrpax]

I literally screamed when IA showed up. Good job minnemi Edit: imagine how society would be if i could spell your name correctly

[@youfwalexx]

2:50 I love how merli holds aoki lapis-

[@felipe_sth]

This shows --> how unique every vocaloid character design is --> how talented minnemi is

[@LucidMist.]

I been listening to a vocaloid chorus from back apple none stop *now a gotta add a new one to the list-*

[@ベイブ009]

WTF THIS IS INSANE. I LOVE IT!!! The ending with Miku and Rin is **kiss cheff**

[@glitchedrena]

wow, this video really highlights how unique each and every VOCALOID character's silhouette and design is!!

[@KodokuKyoko]

Nagareteku toki no naka de demo kedarusa ga hora guruguru mawatte Watashi kara hanareru kokoro mo mienai wa sou shiranai Jibun kara ugoku koto mo naku toki no sukima ni nagasare tsuzukete Shiranai wa mawari no koto nado watashi wa watashi sore dake Yume miteru? Nani mo mitenai? Kataru mo muda na jibun no kotoba Kanashimu nante tsukareru dake yo nani mo kanjizu sugoseba ii no Tomadou kotoba ataerarete mo jibun no kokoro tada uwa no sora Moshi watashi kara ugoku no naraba subete kaeru no nara kuro ni suru Konna jibun ni mirai wa aru no? Konna sekai ni watashi wa iru no? Ima setsunai no? Ima kanashii no? Jibun no koto mo wakaranai mama Ayumu koto sae tsukareru dake yo hito no koto nado shiri mo shinaiwa Konna watashi mo kawareru no nara moshi kawareru no nara shiro ni naru? Nagareteku toki no naka de demo kedarusa ga hora guruguru mawatte Watashi kara hanareru kokoro mo mienaiwa sou shiranai Jibun kara ugoku koto mo naku toki no sukima ni nagasare tsuzukete Shiranai wa mawari no koto nado watashi wa watashi sore dake Yume miteru? Nani mo mitenai? Kataru mo muda na jibun no kotoba Kanashimu nante tsukareru dake yo nani mo kanjizu sugoseba ii no Tomadou kotoba ataerarete mo jibun no kokoro tada uwa no sora Moshi watashi kara ugoku no naraba subete kaeru no nara kuro ni suru Ugoku no naraba ugoku no naraba subete kowasu wa subete kowasu wa Kanashimu naraba kanashimu naraba watashi no kokoro shiroku kawareru? Anata no koto mo watashi no koto mo subete no koto mo mada shiranai no Omoi mabuta wo aketa no naraba subete kowasu no nara kuro ni nare!!!

[@CurryWithoutMeat0602]

I can’t describe how much I love this

[@aussiethecat7532]

It took me a while but 0:02 Miku 0:15 Rin 0:32 Meiko 0:37 Kaito 0:45 Luka 0:51 Len 0:59 Gakupo 0:59 Gumi 1:11 Luo Tianyi 1:19 Nekomura Iroha 1:25 IA 1:32 Anon 1:33 Kanon 1:37 VFlower 1:44 Fukase 1:52 Teto, Neru, and Haku 1:59 Hime 2:00 Mikoto 2:02: Galaco 2:04 Macne Nana 2:07 Sf-A2 Miki 2:10 Otomachi Una 2:12 Kiyoteru 2:15 Yuki 2:20 Mayu 2:27 SeeU 2:32 Lily 2:33 SeeU 2:36 Yukari 2:41 CUL 2:49 Merli and Aoki Lapis 2:55 Tone Rion 3:04 Oliver 2:09 Piko 3:20 Miku 3:23 Rin 3:26 Miku and Rin 3:34 Rin 3:36 Miku

[@flutter37]

OK BUT LIKE THE DEDICATIONNNN MINNEMI YOU QUEEN

[@H3lnXi4n]

0:56 this scene was perfect for Len, before watching the video I really wanted him to be on that part! Thanks minnemi!!

[@ddarcky]

2:14 KIYOTERU AND YUUKI 😭💖😭💕😭😭😭💞

[@rekapotato5599]

i feel like it's 2012 all over again and i mean that in the best way possible, this is a blessing

[@sakiyaki-sashimi]

Minnemi: The youtuber that spends months on videos that no one asks for but everyone wants, she truly hasn’t changed

[@chikattochika6540]

Minnemi you're really carry whole fandom, no jokes I thought about bad apple with vocaloids and you did it Queen

[@cigarts331]

Wow! Did you animate this??!! It looks almost identical to the original!

[@kai_roo_ko]

Why is this so good though?? Like the talent, the hard work, the result 🥺

[@WillowIsntHere]

1:39 SHIIIIIIIIIIP

[@Junferno]

Must've been a lot of effort. Good stuff!

[@vaalentin-p8535]

MY GOD MINNEMI, YOU SO EVOLVE!!! THIS IS VERY GOOD!

[@theLPScollector1]

Why is this making me emotional? It's so beautiful!!!

[@soupsshiho-v4]

okay but neru with the trumpet at 1:44 had me dead 😂

[@KAITOgarerian]

好きと好きが混じることは神なんだよなぁ

[@yuritadaki8840]

This is honestly the best bad apple vid I ever seen in my entire life Good job Minnemi :'

[@Tarotan330]

My life is complete, thank you Minnemi PD: thank you for including Merli & Lapis

[@_Marushiki_]

Luka spinning is a double larriat reference!?

[@harukilol727]

i can't believe there are so much vocaloid i used to think in the group of just 10 or 14 tffff

[@andand3570]

every vocaloid i recognised: 0:00 miku 0:14 rin 0:27 wait who?? Wait no thats meiko 0:36 kaito 0:44 luka 0:50 len i was honestly expecting him to come earlier, gumis next 0:58 gakupo, very fitting indeed 1:04 gumi 1:13 oh the chinese one i dont remember her name 1:19 the hello kitty lookin red kid, swear its like iroha or something 1:25 ia 1:35 goodness knows who these are, theyre so generic 1:38 oh theres flower 1:44 fukase, only recognisable by his hat 1:53 teto neru and haku 1:59 the hime girls and some persons idk 2:09 no idea again 2:11 una 2:13 bro whos that dude 2:15 kai yuuki 2:22 that trim looking like mayu 2:27 seeu 2:32 another generic looking girl 2:36 nah bro this dude an npc 2:41 i should probably have gotten this because of the crazy lookin ponytail 2:51 another basic lady and i think shes holding aoki?? 2:55 rana or some other generic child vocaloid idek 3:04 oliver 3:11 piko 3:20 miku again 3:23 rin again

[@kurokawa3766]

Alternative title: Guess the VOCALOIDS by the shadows

[@lunariansoup9635]

i just got off your channel and here you are uploading the good stuff cmon minnemi

[@kagaminenagisa4839]

No one: Vocaloid fans : *naming every characters for each shadow* XD

[@axohno]

came back to enjoy this

[@AriaTheSongKeeper]

If this doesn't get me back into VOCALOID, I don't know what will.

[@rozcos]

one of my favorite songs with one of my favorite youtubers. NICE

[@Autistic_rizz]

1:25 IA: my favorite vocaloid. Fujiwara no Mokou: my favorite character from Touhou. Coincidences? I don't think so.

[@Autistic_rizz]

And the fact that i am in my vocaloid and touhou fase since i'm 9/10 doesn't help.

[@simpdevil]

I like the satisfying detail that you put Anon and Kanon as the twins at 1:33

[@Polnaratti]

It would’ve been a bit better if all the vocaloids were singing when they were shown in the video but I can tell you worked hard on it. The cover, the video, I cant even imagine how much time it must’ve took. Its honestly the best thing Ive ever seen in a really long time.

[@Moth_is_a_soullessbeing]

It's incredible how in some way gives the same vibe as the og bad apple. A welcome for the newcomers and a love letter for the old fans. Amazing ♡

[@victoriaacosta9520]

was i the only one that thought bad apple was vocaloid at first? idk y i thought that

[@fgvcosmic6752]

Len doing that smile was everything I ever needed to see

[@mafuuya02]

this just proves that most vocaloids have awesome character design

[@bunnymint3n]

IA is my favorite vocaloid and Fujiwara no Mokou is my favorite touhou character so I love that they are both in the same spot

[@Oliver-rt7op]

Its fun when you can tell who everybody is just by their silhouettes also there was KAITOOOOOO and Ren and Oliverrrrrr and Pikoooooo i would die for all of them but also i saw my queen Hiyama he is the best

[@deadaccount83]

This is brilliant in every way

[@GamerzSeb]

0:51 This part can be fit for the Daughter of Evil A.K.A Riliane Lucifen d'Autriche

[@itsturtlefacemydudes]

I'm very proud of myself for recognizing a solid 85%of the Vocaloids in here, though I did get myself set up for summertime sadness when I thought WOAH LUO!! Are the rest of the VSingers gonna be in here??? Also good on you for the massive variation in the 'loids, when I was going into this I 100% wasn't expecting to see Yuki and her teacher in here!

[@isabelaszm]

Damn, this must have really taken a long time to make, but the final product paid off, huh?👏 Also I love that you can tell who is who just by their silhouettes.

[@TXFlyveon]

YOOOOOO I'M DYING OVER HERE OF HOW COOL IT IS UDVSGSHHS THANK YOU!! I love Vocaloid and Touhou, this is awesome!!!! ;o;

[@jadebayoba7073]

2:24 she looks suspiciously like Yukari...

[@cyan2037]

gumi's barrowing gakupo's fan cute

[@nathankid76]

"VOCALOID ver." *sees teto playing the piano*

[@silly_tako]

I was so happy that you included Yukari. Good job on this cover and video!

[@cinderbunnie]

The fact that the video is exactly 3:39 seconds 😂

[@nyoooom]

noooo you missed the chance to use yukari for yakumo yukari's part

[@unrealisticdiversity6427]

im so happy tone rion is here

[@leonneniccals8769]

Me waiting to see Sachiko: 🤡

[@jimmypoopasin]

1:58 missed opportunity to put the triple baka squad

[@tanukijager7921]

Nice, I like touhou songs

[@miyukiOo]

Vocaloids: exists Bad apple: exists Vocaloid + bad apple =this Lesson: anything that exists can make bad apple

[@claramiegler]

I kinda like how Len got Flandre's part

[@twilight2461]

This song is so nostalgic everytime i listen to it

[@equetix3381]

i’m pretty sure 3:05 is oliver

[@oli-producer]

Same

[@LilianaDaCatLover123]

Wow! That's so cool! I love it! Great job, Minnemi! This must of took a lot of effort.

[@AestheticGhostie]

1:00 *Fangirl scream*

[@lavenderdreamss]

I love this!! 💖 You're so talented!! 💖 *I smiled so hard and almost screamed of happiness when I saw Oliver, lmao, I love him so much, he's adorable!!!*

[@derpedfox]

Project Sekai if it was actually good

[@aosakirey5032]

Bad apple virtual singer ver is good though

[@CNH-]

​@@aosakirey5032 Fr

[@Duskdevatabyss]

Something about Len being flandre and Kaito being flandre's older sibling hits different. I wonder what that implies...

[@queenaremi437]

Who is this? 2:32

[@Carbonarazzz]

SEEU

[@queenaremi437]

@@Carbonarazzz and the one between her?

[@rinchannnn39]

yea i love this song is a boop lol thanks minemi i love you soo much

[@Weronika_Pawlak]

Finally 😍😍😍 I was waiting for it for a few years :')

[@monsteralfie]

The amount of work put into this single video... this deserves at least a million views.