MLP THEORY- Why Does Pinkie Pie Become So Normal When Insane?

A theory I came up with regarding Pinkie's 4th Wall Breaking abilities and how she loses them.

[@ashthewierdo4963]

Yeah, she can remember everypony else's birthday. EXEPT HER OWN! It makes no sense whatsoever

[@randomvids8745]

Actually maybe she just has to much in mind so she forgets her birthday day and other stuff and other ponys that's why she made her party cave but that's just a theory of MLP theory

[@systemoverrider4270]

Maybe she has bad experiencies¿¿¿ And is dissassociating from it?

[@randomvids8745]

@@systemoverrider4270 good theory

[@vernyulkisasszony4708]

Maybe she puts others before herself, so she does not find her birthday too important. Or she just forgot what day it was. Sometimes I forget too, and I don't know it's wednesday or friday? August 2 or 3? And she was so focused on Gummy on this episode to think other things.

[@yaasgurl6544]

Because of her friends OMG

[@eevee1583]

Party of one is the most terrifying MLP episode

[@ASillyAuthor]

Lily Mega Eevee I disagree cuz lesson number 0 was way more terrifying this wasn’t even close to terrifying it’s just a little creepy

[@milos_mellow]

It is what 'cupcakes' is based on

[@wolfsani1792]

Party of one or Pinkie isn't scary you should see how Thwillight goes insane...she has such a Creepy Smile when she's "insane"... and she has a "Doll" ...

[@zecondplace]

Catgirl now I wanna look at the the episode, but not really bc its scary apperantLy so thx for that...

[@sadskeleton6112]

Which episode is it?

[@elenapet6446]

Also, I find it kinda symbolic how in party of one, after Pinkie loses her motivation and stuff, Rainbow Dash is the one who comes to fetch her to give her her motivation and happiness back. Rainbow also created the sonic rainboom which gave her it as a child so

[@AshDraws]

Pinkies real name is pinkamina

[@muffinminecraftepicflamgo3817]

No it's Pinkamena Diam Pie

[@ravindeeraj4167]

diane*

[@SaphInfection]

Pinkamena Diane Pie.

[@ruicchiii]

Diane, not Diana.

[@meowewow82]

@@ruicchiii it's different for other people like Mexicans we speak Spanish so for me it's Diana

[@MidnightMuffin]

Conclusion: Pinkie Pie is the REAL god of chaos, not Discord.

[@serentique]

she def inhereted some chaos magic from the finale episodes, which ykno, 4th dimension things, that magic seeped into her entire lifetime

[@headphonesguy5812]

My theory is that pinkie pie have hypomania but when it's combined with bipolar it can have negative effects and I think she suffer too from ADHD and she have psychosis, too. Look at her attitude in the first episode of the new season.According to these symptoms, it would appear that Pinkie Pie suffers from a severe case of bipolar disorder. She very frequently experiences "manic" episodes - wherein she bounces as opposed to walking, is extremely scatterbrained, talks very quickly in a stream-of-consciousness manner, and is able to move anywhere almost instantaneously - sometimes even matching pace with Rainbow Dash

[@JustdrawitIo]

Am I the only one who’s going to say this is really not how much writing I expected?

[@helloworld366]

... She has so much mental disorders, it's INSANE. It makes so much sense for her to be Bi-polar. Usually she's happy and a little chaotic, but if she loses it she becomes insane and hallucinates-

[@headphonesguy5812]

I no longer understand what I typed 2 years ago holy sh-

[@cherryblossomy5850]

.o.

[@sve4mc]

yeah, I watched the same video

[@adamcheck4941]

The way Pinkie so quickly loses trust for her friends along with how she always hallucinates like when she hallucinates about chocolate cake in the mysterious Mare Do Well and Frosting in Princess Twilight Sparkle, leads me to think she suffers from paranoid Scitzofrania.. Because distrust and hallucinating are it's main symptoms.

[@spiritualities]

Hey, in "Monday Blues" the EG music video short, Pinkie's hair went straight and she seemed pretty chill. Looked at Sunset, Twilight, Rarity, and Fluttershy putting her hand up like an 'I'm okay' sort of thing. Then ran over to help Rainbow Dash up when she fell. NOT SKIP.

[@invinible9734]

That isn't the same Pinkie Pie. In fact, there wasn't any indication that Pinkie Pie lost her sanity.

[@chaealmeda18]

Well that is because Pinkie's hair is just wet because of the rain.

[@oliviamia5018]

Her hair was wet

[@sweetpea2604]

0:44 when you had took too much drugs

[@neutralball1099]

Stay off the crack, kids.

[@helloworld366]

Lol.

[@calemlinke773]

Reminds me of being in a white room... You become unhappy, then slowly go insane from the isolation. You lose track of time, you cut off from your senses, eventually you start to hallucinate from solitary confinement. If it's more than three days, you may even die.

[@theponyfiles9097]

Guys, I know her name is Pinkamena Diane Pie. I was just using it in fandom context. Also, thank you so much for 2.9 Thousand views! You guys are amazing! I didn't even like this video that much due to the crappy voice over. But I guess you guys thought otherwise. And I couldn't be more honored.

[@jyawshter]

Ayy its been 2 years and im the only reply But the views are 37k now :D

[@jyawshter]

I'm a subscriber, btw :D

[@heyimhere7048]

@@jyawshter haha *no*

[@jyawshter]

@@heyimhere7048 what?

[@heyimhere7048]

@@jyawshter nvm lol I meant abt the reply lol

[@robertnoxon9246]

To quote an old joke It doesn't DRIVE her crazy. That's no drive, it's a putt! 😅

[@taylorlonewolf8526]

That’s the pinkie pie I love ❤️ she’s my favorite I love her she’s my favorite when she’s depressed I get depressed I just want to just jump through the tv and hug her She’s one of my favorite ponies she’s my favorite she is the one I am at work when my friends are depressed I’ll do everything I’ll do anything to cheer them up Like pinkie

[@AnimeditzV]

I was terrified to know that pinkie is actually a killer on google.

[@jxllobunzzz]

Bro it said she's a killer in the story cupcakes in mlp she's not💀

[@annikablackburn2283]

Nice! Im happy we got some bronies here making these excellent theories on My Little Pony! And, I wouldn't be surprised if Pinkie Pie was a secret god. Normally, the most powerful are the ones unexpected. Pinkie Pie, She'd definitely be unexpected.

[@theponyfiles9097]

aj furever Thanks! It's taking some time, but I've got a few on the way soon enough. Two of which involve Starlight Glimmer. And yeah, if Pinkie was god we'd...be in a lot of trouble to say the least.

[@sav2474]

Is there a connection like this between maud pie and boulder.. Does this make her insane.. And if so how does that affect her?

[@elementalsteve9029]

Now that I think about it she talks to rocks like maud has boulder

[@pxnklxmonade3989]

This is amazing! How do you only have 104 subscribers???

[@theponyfiles9097]

Princess Seashell Thanks! Guess I just need higher quality videos and a more consistent schedule.

[@pxnklxmonade3989]

The Pony Files you’re welcome!

[@AdamThe-Father-Of-Humanity.]

I can relate to Pinkie Pie i actually kinda lose my sanity little by little too it's very depressing if I would have told you

[@flameofthescorpion3623]

For anyone who wants the start Background music:"pinky pie stage theme (fighting is magic)"

[@MorganWenninger]

I like the idea Pinkie Pie has depression

[@mochamanplays257]

There’s a later episode where Pinkie gets sad and her hair goes flat. This theory still hold up in regards to that episode. For some reason, seeing Pinkie Pie all grey with straight hair in the background of that later episode creeped me out.

[@theskullysplaceking8266]

Pinkie pie is my most favorite major character

[@aheony]

in party of one she unleashes her inner fluttershy. because they’re the same voice actor and also she sounds a lot more like her.

[@guysimreallyary1223]

I like pinkamena bc shes the only one who is a KILLER.

[@weeb535]

And that's how cupcakes happened

[@peterhiggins1872]

I think you're wrong. Some people(ponies) have bipolar disorder and don't know it.

[@Skeletty1710]

Having no purpose and no aim in life- that can and will drive everyone insane one day. People with that problem just ignore that fact and tend to use drugs. They get addicted to materialism (more, better, faster, higher...). Some even ruin their health with the abuse of alcohol, nicotine, caffeine or even harder drugs...

[@fnaffan3078]

I LOVE WHEN SHE BREAKS THE FORTH WALL AND TALK TO THE ODDIOENC I LOVE IT SHE IS SO SILLY

[@dxrk_rxtytbaka6508]

Pinkie pie is my favorite pony and she will always be just like me

[@natyoboi5191]

Goodness this is so sad

[@crimson6031]

In the thumbnail, the normal pinkie looks more evil than the crazy pinkie xD

[@jorjavalentine7094]

Is it just me that thinks Rocky sounds like babs??? 🍎

[@kayleelomas5598]

Twilight also breaks the fourth wall.

[@cdur5091]

once

[@tygical]

wait which episode

[@Fluffypancakes-o7q]

Wait. This is same as rocket to insanity like pinkie rainbow also become insane But it came from a nightmare.

[@muffinminecraftepicflamgo3817]

Her real name is Pinkamena Diam Pie

[@harewhisker5354]

PinkiePieParty Official Her real name is Pinkamena Diane Pie.

[@vannyafton]

PinkiePieParty Official *Diane

[@cutiemations7287]

PinkiePieParty Official yep

[@plutolunaplays]

FlutterShee Yay Dian

[@moc277]

Actually, the show didn't say that her actual name is officially Pinkamena Diane Pie. edit: literally i am so dumb when i made this comment i was like ten

[@plutolunaplays]

Why she listens to the rocks is because they bring her back to her past

[@Kitty-h7u4w]

Ummmmm did anyone notice on the actual vid the mother said: is that u pinkamina pie?!'

[@iraidacharriez2600]

Never thought of that.

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

Creepypasta Version Laughing Jack: UH HUH I knew it *he turns even more monochrome and depressed* LJ: *tearfully* Oh no my friends Jeff Smile Jane Ben and Sally don't like my parties and they don't want to be my friends anymore

[@tygical]

what

[@fuzzywheezledoodlers]

Pinkies like was quarantine before the rainbow and I think Hasbro was hinting us somewhere!

[@rexillaluna]

Anyone has a first name or middle name of Diane/ Dianne cause my middle is Diane the meaning of moon I am happy to be moon in fact my 1st name also mean moon and goddess of the hunt, Woman from Mount Kynthos

[@ellies_wxrld5798]

2:38 well DUH

[@rpcsa8]

Okay wow I have always wondered why her hair does that *Deflate* thingy

[@wolfsani1792]

I can see and hear she has a Mental Illness🥺

[@keiroty7187]

Pinky knows how to make people happy

[@richflyawesome0167]

and thus cupcakes after pinkamena and the grimdark fanfics after that

[@jordonstone9973]

Just to make sure that no one eats a cupcake after this

[@Omikkii]

Idk why but at the same time that Pinkie scares me I feel like she’s like a child cause of how she normally acts ;-;

[@ally7824]

Good theroy! I loved it please make more

[@theponyfiles9097]

ally I'm glad you loved it! Don't worry, I'm working on a few. They're time consuming and I haven't got a good place to record but they're coming soon enough.

[@pointelove3017]

What's that background music? It's very tough to hear. But the closest thing that I can think of is it's from Legend of Zelda Majora's Mask. Stone tower theme? Am I wrong? What's the background music?

[@kimwiklund935]

Where was maud at that time?

[@DamnitJeff]

Why does nobody bring up the fact that pinkie pie was raised in a family that is close to the medias depiction of Amish families?

[@neptuneisscaredofwater2066]

good job

[@pleaseignoremyoldcomments-2170]

I turn into pinkemena because I am depressed

[@afforgoto]

pinkemena diane pie im not sure if i should cringe at this or feel sorry for you tbh

[@BethanieBeck-rm3fn]

Poor pinkie

[@gabrrielbicudo]

Pinkamena Ansiedade

[@caseydreamuslpsandmore2582]

Make that 250

[@MaxKarmaCat]

bpd

[@marcalarts16teen]

Oh I thought she had DID txs for clearing that up

[@mustafasamater7520]

Ok

[@ЮляТанакова-д1ы]

😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍