MOAB's Season 16 Reviews: Ep 16 Whiff's Wish

[@BriceInkling138]

GOOD QUALITIES: - Whiff gets the lead role. - *Moral:* You don't have to be grand to be useful or helpful. - The introductory started the episode off well. - Thomas hasn't got the lead role. - Emily and Edward's old personas for this episode. - I like how some other engines have break vans in the end of their trains. - Really good scenery shots. BAD QUALITIES: - Plot hole: Percy was never late with the mail. - Percy could shunt those trucks himself, it's not like his bufferbeam is broken or anything. - The alliteration and rhyming. - Couldn't Emily or Edward at least help Whiff along? And couldn't Whiff ask another engine to do his garbage car work for him? *OVERALL RATING:* 8.5/10 [PRETTY GOOD].

[@REBProductions]

2:49

[@Trainboy17]

7:31 Gordon: Oh the catchphrase i say that’s going to be a T-Shirt Someday

[@Shunteration]

Aaaaaand the inevitable budget cut hit the railway where no one expects: in the suspensions.

[@trainboy7]

since, the newer Thomas CGI series barely has nothing to do with the original, they minus well rename it idiot trains =P

[@NewController01]

Tbh, they should've got the original voice actor for Warrior from TUGS to do the voice of Whiff

[@otakumarcus]

Do a review on wayword Winston you'll love it

[@MichaelS1995]

Only S16 episode I "like", isn't as annoying as let's say Sodor Surprise Day or the Christmas Tree Express

[@otakumarcus]

Got trackmaster whiff and scruff

[@CrisisOnACanoe]

I died at 2:49.

[@WTT_321]

Sparkle sparkle sparkle!!! XD Eh, I can see why he thought the movie was bad, but he missed so many things to make it even more hilarious (like adding George Carlin and/or Ringo Starr into a joke, but whatever...) Wait til you get to the episode on the narrow gauge engines (heh the ONLY episode on the narrow gauge engines), utter disappointment to me (thus why I will never think of it as their official return into the series cause....you get the idea)

[@octivenote]

And if he wants a BAD Thomas movie he should look at Calling All Engines if he wants a BAD Thomas movie!

[@octivenote]

I will not shut up about the critics review, I love his stuff from the Bum to TGWTG and of course his reviews. But he took a movie that was a part of my child hood and SPAT ON IT! Thats not just me mind you. I realize that Walker is just playing the "Critic" as his alter ego, but he should have done more research on TTT before his reviews. And I will admit this now, I do love his "FUCK YEAH SPARKLE SPARKLE SPARKLE" joke. But he could have done some more research on TTT before his review.

[@thetrainmaster968]

I AGREE! WORST NOSTALGIA CRITIC REVIEW OF ALL TIME! -1000/10!!!!!!!

[@billa107]

The feeling is mutual on Nostalgia Critic's review. It's a damn shame you're sitting through this garbage.