Monthly Tie-Off Contest--Flagler vs. Rosenbauer tie the Quigley Cripple

The Quigley Cripple, developed by the late Bob Quigley in California, was and is one of the most innovative dry flies ever created. It imitates both a crippled and an emerging mayfly, which is the stage of the insect most vulnerable to trout.
Quigley Cripple
Hook: Orvis Tactical Dry, size 16
Thread: Yellow, 8/0
Shuck and abdomen: Brown marabou or ostrich herl
Rib: Fine gold or copper wire
Thorax: Yellowish orange dubbing
Wing: Fine light shade deer hair
Hackle: Grizzly

[@marshallbaldwin8960]

I really learn lots from this tying challenge. Thank y'all for your entertaining tyi g brilliance

[@ronlee2606]

Great to see Tim Flagler. Fan of his tying videos for a long time. I have learned (and still am learning) a lot from them.

[@greenbuttskunked]

That is one beautiful, defective hackle.

[@articgrayling1300]

Never get to watch these live but - fun/ love these. I would have voted Rosenbauer just cause the deerhair looked to blend with the hackle. Wonder who the fish would choose?

[@bentpolski]

Tom C Tim A!

[@MarcTelesha]

Why do we always reverse wrap the wire and not the body materials???? I have learned that wrapping the wire the same way as the thread works so much better.

[@richardgivens1522]

Rick from Utah