Moscow Murders: One Year Later

[@maryqc8418]

You can't help feel broken hearted for Maddie's dad. Such a beautiful young daughter..can't even imagine.

[@abz9850]

Maddie's dad is an angel himself, no wonder he had such a wonderful daughter ❤

[@AcoLC15]

The honesty and pain in his voice and eyes is heart breaking.

[@ariesfire2690]

So glad to hear Ethan's dad speak, glad he was given the opportunity to speak more. He seems like a gentle kind man. So heartbreaking for the families. I can't begin to imagine their pain.. No parent should ever have to experience such great loss. Life just feels so unfair sometimes. Justice for Ethan, Xana Maddie and Kaylee ❤Rest peacefully Beautiful souls.

[@paulgarrison1141]

I wish I could just sit and listen to Mr. Chapin. Whenever I see his face, I can see how sad and broken-hearted he is. All of the surviving parents have so much to deal with, from the time they wake till the time they close their eyes to sleep. If they can sleep.

[@kaseycarpenter9670]

One of the scariest and most heartbreaking cases of all time, imo, especially since it appears to be semi-random or stalking-based. These kids would all be SO proud of these parents. They are absolute warriors. The love they have for these kids is palpable yet immeasurable.

[@JaredLand]

*Justice for Maddie, Kaylee, Xana, Ethan!*

[@ThinMint501]

😭😭😭😭 me trying to pull myself back together. Maddie's daddy breakkks my heart!!

[@angelaa.c.1370]

I’m so sorry for the families. It was good to hear from Madison’s dad. It made me really emotional. I wish we could hear from her mom and also Xana’s dad. Ethan’s mom book it’s touching. ❤

[@teamcougars]

This case is so tragic and senseless it reverberated across the entire country 😢😢

[@codreaming9304]

14:24 ~ I feel you, Stacy. My eyes are welling up with tears because I would give ANYTHING to hug my forever 18 year old son. I still try to smell his scent in his clothes. The pain is excruciating 💔 and never goes away. Time does NOT heal ❤️‍🩹 it….you just learn how to navigate through life while carrying the pain…trying to distract your mind 10,000 times a day. Everything is a trigger. I am so incredibly sorry for/to these kids, their families, and all that loved them 🙏🏻.

[@codreaming9304]

P.S. My son would have turned 21 yrs old on 11/8. I was a wreck for several weeks leading up to it and I could barely get out of bed the day of. He would have been so tickled and so proud to turn 21. I envisioned him grinning while being carded at a restaurant (that we would have been at with him) after ordering an alcoholic beverage. Just knowing that he could would have made him smile. The day/evening was awful. I just wanted to sleep and wake up when it was over….kind of like the holidays. I wish I could blink and it would be January 2nd. Happy Birthday to your sweet TRIO 🩵💖🩵.

[@LaPlaztique]

I’m so sincerely sorry to hear that you lost your son. I have a 22 year old daughter and I couldn’t fathom losing her. Love, light and peace from one mother to another mother. ❤

[@codreaming9304]

@@LaPlaztique Thank you 🙏🏻

[@Violet-s3v7m]

​@@codreaming9304 God bless you. I know that loss where getting out of bed is impossible.❤

[@DeedeesJourney]

Ethans parents seem to be coping the best. I hope this trial brings some peace of mind or closure to the others as well.

[@paulashipley5992]

You never have closure when one of your children die you’re in that until you die and meet them in heaven you never be the same original such thing as closure closure is at the end of your life

[@blahblahblah1579]

There is no “best” way to cope! They’re all coping the best they can and given the way they are shut out of the case!

[@alejandromolinac]

Stop being the cliche retardo to “corrects” EVERYTHING…. The guy’s folks are the one’s who don’t seem to be enjoying being of camera….

[@melissajurado2328]

Maddie’s dad manages to get me to cry every time 😢 he has such a pure heart & the pain im his eyes weighs so deep in me

[@bwaygal4905]

Heartbreaking. A beautiful tribute to all four innocent, beautiful young souls. This is incomprehensible. It is absolutely beyond imagination. I appreciate that this entire video focused on these young people and their families and not one word uttered about the person accused. Not saying his name even once. This was beautiful and also just devastating. I am so impressed with the courage and strength of these parents and families. All my love and compassion goes out to them.

[@pathoward2940]

I am just a weeping mess watching this "tribute" to their late son. How these families have managed to get through this horror with such dignity and love I will never know. God bless these families who have senselessly lost so much. ❤

[@_rockseeker]

When Ethan's mom was reading the Boy Who Wore Blue, I absolutely broke. I cannot imagine the pain his parents and siblings are dealing with. All of the families of every victim. They did not deserve this tragic event, and I hope justice prevails.

[@WithLoveDenisse]

Wow! This is so devastating! I wish I could give them a hug. If you guys ever come accross these parents please hug them tight !

[@Aangel452]

What a beautiful book about the boy who wore blue, I know Ethan is with you all everyday giving support love and never ending positive energy.

[@whatupquake6790]

My heart cries for these parents. 😢

[@christtyanne1]

I see the pain in Ben Mogen's eyes, he is the father whose pain of loss is most visible. That smile when he remembers Maddie, broke me 😢😢💔

[@GivingPayback]

This made me extremely emotional!!! I feel like we all got to know these kids, and so many of us have followed so closely. It is so sad!!! I wish it was not real, but since it is, I hope they at the very least get real, full justice!!! Prayers for are of their sweet families and friends that are hurting so badly!?! 💖🙏🏼💖🙏🏼💖🙏🏼💖

[@jeannetvanderdeijl3243]

The way Ethan’s parent speak about him….. It seems like people who die young seem to live their life to the fullest , almost like in 6th gear? I experienced this with my brother in law who died at 42. I don’t know whatnot make of this . But it brings me comfort to know they fully took advantage of the time they had.

[@roshebyleveldt2639]

This had me in tears literally, my heart is hurting this is the first time I'm watching Maddies dad talk about her. This breaks my heart so much 😢 I don't think we realize how much our parents really loves us 😢❤

[@LosAngeles-le2bf]

Aww 😢 this is so sad. I feel sad for the families. I’m so sorry to all. My heartfelt condolences to the families. ❤❤❤

[@ChristineJoey-yb4qf]

Wow I just love Ethans parents, so well rounded with such love and loyalty to the2 left, what an amazing couple and phenomenal parents, God bless ❤

[@palletwizard]

❤ to the families and friends.

[@marthamackey6105]

God bless you, Ben. We send loves, prayers & strength. 🙏 ❤ You did a fabulous job, Dad! You enjoy every Father's Day, Live always & always with you now, 24/7.

[@mishellemurphy4043]

Such a shocking loss not just for their families but the world💔. May they always be remembered ♥️

[@DW...]

WoW, I can't stop crying 😢 The book is beautiful💙 They are handling it great ... I would definitely attend that trial if that happened to my child💯 GOD bless those beautiful souls 🙏 💔😔

[@judybrown7601]

Prayers for family and friends

[@karyntownsend]

May their soul's,rest in beautiful peace. 🕊️- Xana -🕊️ 🕊️- Ethan -🕊️ 🕊️- Madison -🕊️ 🕊️- Kaylee -🕊️ Loads of love & light From Denmark ~🕯️• 🕯️• 🕯️• 🕯️~

[@heyitsjujuu]

I watched the video of the coverage recently. So incredibly heartbreaking that these young lives were taken. I always thought about the 2 surviving friends, how it must be daunting to be alive when you could have been killed too.

[@MeTreesndirt]

Survivor guilt. Must be a very spacious home. Hard to miss screams. Earphones on maybe.

[@sandralee6714]

Ethan's father it's hurting bad my condolences I can see the pain in his eyes he misses his son he looks just like his father😢😢😢❤❤

[@NuraCaicedo-xh2ok]

Just looking in his eyes makes me cry and then but he smiles❤

[@daryldrew8563]

Terrible...these poor families

[@GeraldineWilliams-vt4dd]

Forever young R.I.P

[@a.terriedelgado3449]

😢This has been the saddest day (11/13/23-Mon.) for the 1st yr.Anniversary of these young lives lost; so much so that the day was gloomy + the sky drissled with rain on + off...it's 2am here in No.Fl., so I've watched every News feed of the occurence of that dreadful morning + like I said before this is up there worldwide as when we lost the Twin Towers; #Idaho4; You will Never be Forgotten❤❤❤❤😢😢😢😢🎉🎉🎉🎉 Much Love goes to Each + Every1 of You !!! God must-of Needed his Angels(4)!!!🥴🙏😥😩😭😫😥🙏👀😇🙄☹️😔🥺🥺😞

[@Veruska75]

Same here, greetings from Finland. Can’t stop crying.

[@1111Thatway]

I think these parents are extremly strong and without them I would be having a harder time dealing with this myself. They are helping to heal the world with their strengths bc these kids took a part of me with them a part of millions of us with them. I cry my eyes out and feel like my heart has been shatterd. Then I see these parents and cry harder but I AM SO GRATEFUL TO SEE THEM AND LISTEN TO EVERY WORD. They are all heroes to me as they're kids are to me too. Thank you to Ethan's dad to hear his voice more what a dear sweet man and Stacy she another piller of strength GOD SPEED

[@Zahra-flower]

Painful and sad, my heart cries 😭 for a life full of excitement and love for Ethan, Xena, Maddie, Kaylee. I have lost my children. This sadness has entered the hearts of the whole world.

[@brendaosborne2216]

My heart breaks 😢RIP 🙏❤

[@patriciaflores2776]

I liked what ethan's mom said about every word both parents said ethan looks like the mom ❤ strong parents i finally heard more lovely tribute'the boy who wore blue.thank you Ben for sharing your fondest memories &pic of maddie .💐

[@happy6lady1]

My heart hurts so for these kids/young folks. I remember this like it was yesterday. Prayers 🙏🙏 always

[@EssenceMiles-z8f]

Those innocent lives were taken to soon my heart goes out to there families 🥺🙏

[@EricLussier-no5no]

Know that I draw strength from you both everyday..please know Steve ..I get angry too but we need to focus. On the good memories..and the smiles..that they all shared..❤😊eric

[@nev0116]

God bless 🙏🏾 It’s scary that someone was able to do this in a college town. RIP sweet angels💗

[@sandralee6714]

😢❤❤❤❤rip beautiful youthfulness sadness gone to soon😢

[@lillyshaw9439]

What an amazing tribute? ❤️

[@LucyLennon909]

Perfect presentation 😇😇😇😇

[@carolm7037]

❤️🙏🏻Kaylee ❤️🙏🏻Maddie ❤️🙏🏻Ethan ❤️🙏🏻Xana

[@Aangel452]

To Xana’s family, she has said, though she is angry this happened to her she is in heaven and co joined in unconditional love, safe and happy. She is always visiting you in the home and anywhere you go, giving love, support and hugs.

[@rubyjeanne1667]

clown

[@MollysMomma]

Your posts are completely inappropriate. Whatever attention you're trying to gain, go get it elsewhere. What a creep, you should be ashamed of yourself. Disgusting.

[@Katie-t7u]

The 911 call wasn’t even released

[@Wildhorse-z6n]

God will take care of it believe 🙏

[@mortalclown3812]

Tbh, I'm praying the evidence holds up beyond a reasonable doubt. It's always awful to read comments from those judging and second guessing victims' actions without having any facts. Let justice rain down with a fair trial - no tricks on either side.

[@bwaygal4905]

Well said. I agree, one hundred percent..

[@NewyearsFest]

These poor young people who were just so beautiful and were on their way to a successful happy future and than this, ugh and the parents and families my heart breaks for all of them, so unfair, 💔 and as a parent it physically makes my heart hurt for them, and than for it to be such a world wide tragedy,

[@michellebaker1974]

God bless Xana Kaylee Maddie and Ethan and their families 🌹🌹🌹🌹🙏🙏🙏🙏✨✨✨✨

[@JoniSmith-h6o]

The two roommates know more than they are saying

[@DeanBillyIII]

Ben We Love you Madison mom we love you to her step father we love you. To the entire Goncalves family we love you to xana mom dad & family we love you and to Ethan’s family we love you. Love wins in the end you’ll see your children again . Keep your faith ❤ from Billy

[@dianedominick5142]

💕🌱🌿🍃❣️Let Us Never Forget these Beautiful Four♥️Pray for Peace in our ♥️Hearts after this Loss💕🍃🌱🌿🙏”Blessed Be”💕🌿🌱🍃💕🙏♥️

[@LucyLennon909]

Seems longer than 1 year ago 😟

[@MariaLopez-mi4ol]

Wonder if all of the people who seen the crime scene have PTSD????? After hearing Donna Serephina tell of the horrific murders I knew that this would change lives and hopefully some laws made to prevent this kind of crime again.

[@JD-WLKY]

She's nothing but a certified kook! Look up her real name and history! And her daughter wasn't murdered either! She died from an overdose!

[@NorCalParanormal]

Why wasn't the name of the sorority that Kaylee was in mentioned when describing each of the 4 victims??? The other 3 were mentioned, but not Kaylee

[@davecooke7868]

Why is there no trial date set ? Seems odd doesn’t it 😮😮😮😮

[@LaPlaztique]

It’s the prosecution not turning over required information (IGG) that is holding it up.

[@amandawhite9362]

Lock your doors and think it can happen to you

[@MariaLopez-mi4ol]

Yes say it outloud.....our beloved ones energy is with us always.....I had 3 beautiful family members taken in 12 days cause of corona covid....12 -23-21 Sister Liz 59....12-24-21 Mother Mary 79....01-05-22 Best Brother Chris 57....it is all about WHO YOU KNOW WHILE IN THE STORM....AND KNOW THAT HE WILL NEVER LEAVE YOU....not about what you feel.... NEVER STOP PRAYING.

[@DarkSparkIe]

2:07 looks like a disposable yellow painters suit on the ground discarded just laying there and something mation in color a little bit farther away grom the dumpster I wonder if these were picked up for processing

[@victoriariley7490]

First initial call? doesn’t that mean the same thing?

[@sythe5350]

Maddie was so beautiful

[@justynegreenlaw6840]

Idaho?

[@laurahernandez-bd4vr]

What a lovely father Maddie has.

[@БеллатриксОрионовна]

I know, it sounds irrelevant, but I wonder where Maddie's mom is.. RIP 4 beautiful souls❤❤❤❤

[@amyclare5377]

21:07 irritatingly rude the way she says "their dead" shes giving very childish... 2mins of fame on the news type vibes

[@rubyjeanne1667]

well, look at her. ick

[@cathymiddleton1242]

I mean when HIS OWN SISTER suspected him what does that tell you?

[@LaPlaztique]

Has that been officially verified as fact?

[@lindarobinson8827]

Fault information. His Family stood together after his arrest and made the Deepest Condolences to the Victims family and said. Also stated after : they will stand beside their Son and brother from his Attorney in Pennsylvania. His Family remains Silent and refused interview. No interview from them. Just rumors and words and clicks. I'm sure they are hurting too.

[@loribeugnot7895]

Huge cover up. Dig in Moscow the truth is out there!

[@chrislim7615]

Allegedly they said this crime was done with vengeance,yeah soo sad*

[@what-if1111]

I wonder why the sorrority that KG had been in wasnt mentioned, yet the other 3 were. They didn't say that she was a part of a sorority at the time of this incident, nor had previously. That's kinda sus to me.

[@LaPlaztique]

Kaylee was no longer in that sorority, that’s probably why.

[@Wildhorse-z6n]

😭😭😭😭

[@ItisMeMike]

Godspeed to the family's ❤ rip mkex ❤💙💜💖.. 🔥bk

[@Aangel452]

To the Concalves family, I know Kaylee is at home with you always and everyday. She has also said that she loves her half sister too, and will never stop being around you all.

[@rubyjeanne1667]

clown

[@0breezy]

Ethans parents ❤

[@OmarMartinez-le2sc]

R.I.P Juan Martinez Omar 20🪦 R.I.P

[@AnnaNolanOfficial]

maddies dad... shes def looking after you. she does hear you.

[@doberbrat17]

Haha! The reporter called Truth Social, “social”, as if truth is evil! That must be the reason mainstream media doesn’t use truth telling in their reporting any longer! In any case, my heart breaks for these families. I can’t even begin to imagine the heartbreak they’ve endured over losing such precious, beautiful, and talented children. They will forever be in the hearts of Americans! 💜

[@codreaming9304]

12:04 - “…..even one year later” 🤦🏻‍♀️🙄. As if it’s shocking to know that a parent is still mourning/grieving the loss of their child and thinking about them. That has to be one of the most ignorant and insensitive statements I’ve ever heard.

[@Milla768]

Good people Won’t last longer because they expect to everyone be good. Ethan was a very tall man,and even with that he was not able to do anything to this evil person. Rest in peace kids and rest sure that justice will come to light. Who ever do this will como and tell.

[@loril.ferguson549]

🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️🤗🤗

[@NewyearsFest]

These children looked as beautiful as they were nice and very smart, ❤

[@juditube391]

You blame a mans family for what hes done and before he's even found guilty. That says a lot about you. 😢

[@devinw5150]

I just started seriously researching this case and reading everything I can get my hands on and watching every documentary and video I can find. At this point, I’ve seen and heard all the evidence that was released to the public and in my opinion, this is not an open and shut case but there’s a large amount of circumstantial evidence that points to the suspect. Things like 13 different times his phone was pinged very close to the house, his car seen multiple times circling the house multiple times the night of the murders, his dna on the knife case found under the body of Matty, his dark reddit posts, following and liking all the pictures on the girl’s social media accounts, his interactions with police when pulled over on that cross country trip, disposing his trash in his neighbors trash cans wearing rubber gloves at 1 in the morning when he was arrested. What sticks out to me is I’ve never heard the suspect claim he’s innocent or say “I didn’t do it.” All he has said is I look forward to being exonerated. Given his dark background and criminology studies, I think he just wanted to commit murder and try to get away with it. I believe he’s mentally disturbed, a narcissist, and a sociopath who has no regard for human life. Given the large amount of circumstantial evidence that he cannot explain away and his weak alibi of just driving around alone at the time of the murders, I believe they got the right guy and I hope the families get the justice they deserve.

[@loribeugnot7895]

Wow..its a Cartel hit . I cant believe people still dont know? Huge cover up.

[@jeffdragna316]

They have done nothing in court with kolberger

[@patrinajasso5689]

I have such a hard time thinking why the room mate that made eye contact thought that was bormal to see a guy with a ski mask on and lock her door and not think anything about it? I still dont understand why she didnt go up and check on them or call 911 till 2 the next day?. Very strange. I cant imagine what these guys all went through. This guy sis saying he didnt do it. Ok than why was ur d.n.a on that knife seath if u dont know them? I hpe he gets the death penilty cause life in jail for killing 4 people and taking them away from there familys come on.

[@christtyanne1]

@patrinajasso5689 The killer may have squeezed Bryan's hand and his DNA was left on the knife sheath. Or Bryan could have touched this sheath in a store and the DNA would remain for 6 months to 1 year. Or there was no DNA on the sheath. I believe that whoever committed the crimes knew the layout of the house, knew who slept in each room. And the person knew that the bedroom door was open. And how would he enter a house with 6 cars in the garage. Something tells me it was someone from the Brotherhood

[@LucyLennon909]

​@@christtyanne1 possible more than 1 murderer.

[@Manatee4Scale]

We don’t know that they made eye contact just that she saw him. She may have been spooked and just assumed it was a friend of one of her roommates. There is so much we don’t know about what she did/didnt do, what was normal for the house, the state she was in, what she thought, etc. it seems like it makes sense to the police, though, and they do have her whole story!

[@MeTreesndirt]

Why only county jail til then is strange. It Is a miserable sm.cell. Maybe they want him to be miserable is why the trial date is not being set . Whyy do some peepl think harming, killing, those who are innocent is going to ease the pain they have? He says he feels nothing. If there is not deep seated pain of resentment why did he kill these happy ,popular kids? He definitely was hurt by other kids.maybe esp. the girls. Kids, be kind . Try to help the misfits. U may prevent another crime.

[@MeTreesndirt]

​@@Manatee4Scale. We will find out during the trial. Kids are stupid. College kids need supervision. Anyone under 20 still has a childs brain and dd alot of booze and u get alot of stupid.

[@MarkTurner-wu1bs]

If i was accused of this and was innocent. Id be pleading with the parents id be making a scene. I wouldn't be acting like this guy at all. I also think he had help. This guy stinks of guilt

[@claudiasimpson9606]

Numerology was at play: House address, 1122 =6, Date 11,13th =6, Year =2022 =6.Add the Numbers up = 666 ...The Beast . This wasn't a Coincidence !!!. Rest in peace, Moscow 4 !!!.

[@glendahartwick9252]

That house has something attached to it that was there way before these murders happened...

[@Lizespin001]

And they were 6! Something went wrong with the killer ( lucky ) sparing the other 2 life’s..,what a tragedy! Hope the families will find peace and justice be served to all 😅involved in this horrible crime😢

[@LaPlaztique]

@@Lizespin001The fact that Dylan Mortensen only reported what she did is bizarre. If the person she saw was the perpetrator and the entire attack only took 8/9 minutes, he would have most definitely breathing heavy plus she reported him only walking toward her and then out through the kitchen sliding door. No heavy panting out of breath or walking fast/running. Quite bizarre!

[@lindarobinson8827]

Facts all the bedrooms doors have codes locked ?!? Don't they automatically lock after you shut your bedroom doors ?!? One of the Victim Father opened stated. He went and fixed his daughter's bedroom door locked. PCA said bedroom doors were closed?!?

[@nicolekear3911]

​@lindarobinson8827 No you're wrong. They were talking about the front door.

[@jojoyoung2803]

🙏🏽💙💝💝💝

[@Casperette]

The four murder victims lived together in Idaho. They have the RIGHT Monster behind bars. I hope that the monster get the Death Penalty. 🙏♥️

[@LaPlaztique]

Ethan didn’t live there. Also, you have already deemed BK guilty when the trial hasn’t even happened yet? I guess you are the court of public opinion which doesn’t count, respectfully.

[@Casperette]

@@LaPlaztique unlike you I'm very educated and have followed this case since the very beginning. He was not only SEEN inside of the home by another roommate but his DNA was found at the crime scene...psst, knife in the sheet.

[@LaPlaztique]

@@CasperetteObviously, you’re a troll and not educated at all if you are saying “knife in the sheet”. Sit down and be quiet.

[@LucyLennon909]

​@@Casperette When does defendant plea?

[@cathymiddleton1242]

His family......who cares. Only The VICTIMS AND THEIR FAMILIES MATTER.

[@Aangel452]

Ben, Maddie has told a psychic that she is at home with you everyday and loves you so much!

[@rubyjeanne1667]

You know NOTHING. Crock.

[@DM-sx3ge]

You said this abt xana too, stfu and gtf bored clown

[@ashnew7113]

🖤🥺🥹😩🙏🙏🙏🙏💚

[@luisaugustoscosslopes8143]

God bless all the families... These happy and pretty children are in Heaven now!

[@chrislim7615]

Can u imagine if:BK's innocent,does that mean the murderers r still at large??!!Wht abt the:3Dna,a glove outside trash?!!App it's neighbors trash that the:LE*RIP 2all the victims

[@marilynfielding2760]

I certainly feel so sorry for the families of the murdered people BUT something is very strange about the 2 survivors it seems that one person alone could commit such a horrific crime DUH

[@doygazgar]

Maddies parents split when she was young. My guess was Ben's drug addiction was the cause of it 😮 she called her stepfather DAD?

[@smallies7154]

oleksandr usyk

[@roseg.4354]

The same narrative as always wow what a waste of time listening to the press.

[@arness2426]

🙏🏿

[@rubyjeanne1667]

Looks like Maddies parents were drug users.

[@Cocostacey]

Wow absolutely so rude. Maybe you’ve never lost anyone but stress and grief can make you appear that way it’s called depression

[@rubyjeanne1667]

@@Cocostacey Well, it is actually a fact. Her parents were/are druggies and her mother was/is in jail.

[@DM-sx3ge]

@@rubyjeanne1667what does that have to do with anything?

[@rubyjeanne1667]

@@DM-sx3ge Probably nothing...maybe something.

[@DM-sx3ge]

@@rubyjeanne1667 nothing at all…bored ass clown