Staff Of Moses And The Akhenaten Theory | Quranic Guidance Surah Taha 17-21 | Mufti Abu Layth

Clip taken from the weekly Wednesday night livestream, Meaning with MALM #36 | Certain Uncertainty - How We Look At Things
Watch the full episode here: kzbin.infocRddGs6v...
Instagram: / muftiabulayth
Patreon: / malm

[@KevinKanthur]

Wow, the mystic explanation is so good. So beautiful. I love when there's so many deep ways to interpret a religious story.

[@capncrunch5729]

Go to a sheikh bro. Islam's not a game where we can just play with "mystic" narratives because they sound cool.

[@boinkdoink31]

you deserve much more views brother

[@tiafatss2001]

Subhanallah!!! The mystic explanation was beautiful!

[@stokedamoor966]

Alhamduillah excellent presentation may Allah swt be pleased with your effort

[@khanG-gq9hc]

The mystic tafsir of the verse at the end 🔥🔥🔥♥️♥️♥️

[@maghmuda]

you are a precious gem, a light. thank you

[@auycharxernaighn7893]

Thank you for this beautiful tafseer❤️

[@fahmidalutfullah361]

Wow, that was beautiful and deep! Thank you so much!!!

[@chegeuvera]

My goodness this was amazing. May Allah bless you.

[@IB7641]

Shaykh, I want to take this opportunity to recommend a book for you: Jan Assmann, Moses the Egyptian. It is one of the most extraordinary books in comparative religious studies ever published, and has very interesting thoughts on Moses, Akhenton, and the origins and meaning of monotheism. I wish I could actually physically force you to read it, since I know it is exactly rhe sort of thing you're into, and you would make many interesting videos discussing it.

[@stevenv6463]

Wow, what a terrible last name

[@muazmahbub5251]

Wow. You are true Legend. Your presentation was amazing.

[@thamimahmed6108]

Beautiful explanation sir....

[@qazimyousf1826]

Wow,, amazing explanation.. ♥️

[@waseemkhaliq7583]

Amazing view points. thank you Mufti saab i like the mystics view of 100% reliance in Allah. we all ways have people practicing magic for control and power, gain and harm people but they dont know all false perishes and is powerless in front of truth.

[@HitherandYarn]

Great story about Akhenaten/Moses

[@KhalidAnsari-th3wf]

I listen to him with playback speed of 2 and it works out perfect because he speaks so slow.

[@akimia6373]

One way to look at the cane story is that Allah was giving Moses pbuh a Tawheed Lesson that all creation and their being is from God And Moses did learn the lesson, as it shows in his Answer to Pharaoh when asked who is his lord. He answered : قَالَ رَبُّنَا ٱلَّذِىٓ أَعْطَىٰ كُلَّ شَىْءٍ خَلْقَهُۥ ثُمَّ هَدَىٰ He said :Our Lord he who gave everything its Form and then guided it.

[@zariftahmid9854]

Can you react on Hassan radwan, bro recently i watched videos of Hassan Radwan now im confused, i need help

[@stevenv6463]

Interestingly I think it was Freud who first tried to make a connection between Moses (as) and Akhenaten.

[@TheOutlookexpress]

You do rely on the worldly means but remember they all have serpents hidden in them that could come out of it any time.

[@hamzaalikhoso6688]

WOW

[@ReedProCreed]

Got that Motown, James Brown hair going. Mufti's got a brand new bag 🎶

[@auycharxernaighn7893]

Mufti Sahab... Why does Allah say in 24:1 the commands in this surah have been made obligatory.. isn't the whole Qur'an obligatory?... Can you shed light on this please...

[@hatimkhan5028]

❤❤❤

[@Javed6129]

Fir'awn has strong internal support to be treated as a proper name and not a title or as a title of royalty. House (āl) is only found with proper names, never with titles. Secondly, Firʿawn nowhere finds itself to be taken as a definite article, eg al Aziz or al Malik. The presentation of the word in the Qur'an lends itself to be his actual name.

[@Mauri7782]

Firawn is a title it means great house in coptic. The house refers to the palace he stayed in. All pharaos had a name including the one in the time of Musa

[@Javed6129]

@@Mauri7782 "king" was the term used most frequently by the ancient Egyptians for their monarchs through the middle of the Eighteenth Dynasty during the New Kingdom. The term "pharaoh" was not used contemporaneously for a ruler until a possible reference to Merneptah, c. 1210 BC during the Nineteenth Dynasty, nor consistently used until the decline and instability that began with the Twenty-Fifth Dynasty - en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharaoh

[@villageboy3316]

The egyptians know their history very well. An egyptian narrating their history is totally different from the falcies by freud, or other roman historians, or muftis that immitate george michael.

[@endoneezer]

would be interested in your take or understanding of the virgin Mary and birth of Eesa in the Qur'an, as we know she had no intimate interaction with men as confirmed in the Qur'an - do you take it word for word or is it metaphorical? as according to science than this is not possible

[@shoaibbhat279]

The question is when The God asked Moses what was in. his right hand , why didn't Moses tell him that it was his sceptre (a remembrance of who he was - as suggested by MALM ) . Instead Moses enumerates the common uses . Why would he use it for daily things

[@bubuurgulla-gurgullu3075]

But mufti, does musa's a.s. staff-snake not negate the magicians witchcraft in a way that they prostrated and submitted to musa and allah? So the spectators would not see magic against magic, but the defeat of pharao. Therefore I think there is a logical error in your argument that the staff being a snake would affirm magic, the fact that it negated magic is the motive here in my understanding.

[@moedot7]

The clue within this Ayah is the words "right hand". Allah is drawing our attention to a specific hand. Focus too far on the staff and you'll lose what Allah is trying to hint to you.

[@obaidulhaque7687]

Agreed

[@runninginsept]

What's the significance of the right hand?

[@moedot7]

@@runninginsept As usual, my comment got removed. Search YT20 and YT29

[@nycnow811]

???

[@moedot7]

@@nycnow811 search yt20 and yt29 by Marvelous Quran

[@thamimahmed6108]

Sir please make a vedio on iblees ..what made him rebel ?? Please make a detailed vedio on IBLEES

[@anvarfou]

Mufti, I have a doubt about riba. Actually what is riba. Is it interest rate by the bank. I am from India, i want to take a saving scheme named "sukanya samrithi yojana"provided by central government, for my below 10 age girls, . But it is a interest based scheme. Is it riba. I am confuced the word riba in Quran is what actually. Pls reply

[@pkmuhammedhisan]

Interest provided by the bank and the definition of Islamic Riba is not the same.

[@dud9926]

Mufti Sahab i seriously doubt historcity of older prophets..only prophet muhammad and Jesus were real... They were just preacher ( prophet) there is nothing more to it.. although i believe in miracles..

[@anvarfou]

@@pkmuhammedhisan is it true? Many scholars prohibited that interest is haraam. Actually I am confuced.

[@aladindelic]

any money growth without trade (goods in between seller and buyer) is ribaa for example: leasing is riba... the proof for this is that in the Qur'an some people say that riba is same as a trade, but Allah allowed trade and forbid riba; so, we can conclude that riba is anything that looks like trade, but it's not trade because there is nothing to trade for/with

[@anvarfou]

@@aladindelic then what about salary

[@GermanBigGuy]

German Support!

[@sarasohaib6765]

staff is leg of Sara

[@aladindelic]

Sigmund Freud and others were wrong about this theory. Akhenaten was the Pharaoh and his foster son known as Tut-ankha-mon was Moses. Akhenaten was a sun-worshipper (sun = knowledge). When he died in Nile all his temples were destroyed by the people, because he was one who exaggerated, infidel ruler.

[@ali09gaming58]

Tutankhamon only lived till her was like 9 or less than 12 years old, how could he be Musa (AS)

[@aladindelic]

@@ali09gaming58 All about so-called tomb of Tutankhamon is a lie, fabricated. They couldn't find it, until some guy Howard Carter brought items from other tombs and set them all inside one for which he claimed it's Tutankhamon's. He became rich and famous. There's no proof that Tutankhamon died at a young age, except that staged deformed corpse. If you believe in a story that 12 yrs old kid was very experienced in battles and got many wounds. What Carter found is an empty (no body) tomb prepared for Tut by his father Akhanaton. But, after all happened, Tut (Musa, Moses) was never buried there. Similarly, no body of Yusuf was found in Dayr al-Bahri, which Hatsepshut made for her and Yusuf, because the Jews took his dead body with them and carried it to "the promised land".

[@-one-4358]

I find these explanations so farfetched. Allah is All Mighty and He can change reality as He wants. Btw, not that we need this to proof anything but his story is also mentioned in the OT/NT, and there also the staff changed into a real snake.

[@7346908]

What If it was a device if some kind and Musa Alaisalam didn't know about it. Could be a left over of some advanced race.

[@idris_haris_al-kalima]

El Elyon (ie. God Most High) used Moshe to show he is greater than the so-called Elohe Mitsráyim (ie. the gods of Egypt). "... Against all the Elohe Mitsráyim I will execute judgment: I am Yahweh." Thus Yahweh the King of Israel and the Redeemer of him (ie. Israel) Yahweh Sabaoth say, "I am the first, and I am the last; and beside me no gods exist." Yahweh is name of both Allah and Isa. Isa in Safaitic means the Redeemer, in fact Jewish believers in Yeshua/Jesus forbid saying the name of the Messiah just as they forbid saying the name of El Elyon; because in Early Judaism the Messiah is [the] Malach [of] Yahweh who also bears the Name Yahweh. So to avoid blasphemy some people called him the Redeemer in stead of using is name. This angel is not an el (ie. a god) besides El Elyon, but beneath El Elyon, for this angel is merely an emanation of El Elyon. Christians are excessive in their veneration of this emanation of El Elyon and thus made him into a second most high god besides El Elyon which is blasphemy against Yahweh, but Muslims are insufficient in their veneration of this emanation of El Elyon, thus worthless the works of the Redeemer which is yet again blasphemy against Yahweh. "Shema Yisrael: Yahweh Eloheinu, Yahweh Ehad." That is to say, "Yahweh is our Gods, Yahweh is United." Yahweh is the name of El Elyon and of all His Emanations, so say not, "Three." For our Gods are Ehad/One, and He is our Gods.

[@asifbrettishmaelmakki9]

Hi bro. Lamad-Ayin is EL* Lamas-Alav/Alpha is EL* have u any idea why Lamad-Alpha is not written as AL? in Arabic;AL is The and LA(Lam-Alif)is No. (Them two definitions could be wrong in that, AL and Lam-Alif/Lamad-Alfa is to do with god or God. AL EL UL 👈 all mean god,ithink.something to do with Hallelujah And Karen Armstrong author of a muhammad biography says that Allah has Three Lam's and pagans used two Lam's. ALLLH 👈correct. ALLH👈 Pagan spellings. A Viking ring also states three Lam's.

[@asifbrettishmaelmakki9]

Kufa hadith boss AL Kalil introduced the Lam-Alf symbol.its like a Hebrew Ayin.

[@KORAN-ALONE]

The pharaohs as such never existed. The word "pharaoh" does not exist in the Egyptian language. The name Firaun that appears in the Qur'an is a proper name like Moses. The story of Moses did not take place in what is now the country of Egypt, but in southern Ethiopia and then they crossed into Arabia. What did exist were the kings of a Misr, changed and called later Egypt

[@ArmanAnsari-wi7ng]

Don't let these type of people currupt your aqeeda.. Gain knowledge through real scholars.

[@ahmedtijanitanko2534]

Is time you know how to unlearn and relearn else....ignorance

[@sadofaraji5999]

He has ijaz to teach,if you dont like him dont listen to him.

[@shariquehussainkhan5913]

When I started to watch your videos I admire you specially about The Hadiths of Bukhari, But now I think you are lost, when Allah says "behold it is snake" you say it could me miracle but it may not be. And your previous videos also you have started to denying the miracle of Allah, Allah has power over all things, He can change the very nature of the physical phenomena because He has dominant over all things, Allah can do anything to show his sign to his prophets and righteous believer. Miracle of Allah can't be explained with science, and you have been trying to say nothing can be done against science. I am sorry to say brother but you have broken my trust on scholar like you, May Allah guide us all to Straight Path (Aameen)

[@dud9926]

Mufti Sahab i seriously don't believe in older prophets. Only prophet Muhammad and Jesus were real histocal Preachers....

[@OMAR-REZA-HAMiM-77]

Why is that Bro ?

[@bbilal111]

What would make you say that, dear brother?

[@dud9926]

Too much Reading lead me to this conclusion...

[@bbilal111]

@@dud9926 Elaborate please

[@khagantaka8876]

Then you're not a Muslim as you violate one of the 6 articles of faith. You been reading the wrong stuff haha

[@sarasohaib6765]

Moses is low confident person He cant argue with David in 99 sheep matter