A typical child on Piaget's conservation tasks

[@aquileslame6897]

Damn they could use this cup magic to give water to the whole world.

[@fonzie2098]

They already use that cup magic at Starbucks

[@migdonalds]

but it's blue water so everyone will turn blue

[@kilbo1860]

pepeMods

[@VisnitchiRaul]

Or make fat people eat less.

[@youngnutt130]

cypekpl cat I’m blue if I was green I would die

[@mikelim7514]

Woman: *POURS GLASS INTO DIFFERENT SHAPED GLASS* Kid: What kind of black magic did i just witness

[@Xosidhe]

Kid, remember this trick she pulled on you when you go to bars & restaurants later in life

[@thechunge]

We did it boys, world thirst is no more.

[@TiazaLynn]

You mean non-Caucasian magic.

[@pcadamtaylor4262]

Kid: Take my money

[@thelord8190]

no need to scream man

[@lukastaylor9544]

Can’t believe how much I congratulated myself for knowing more than a toddler

[@YamenNazer]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@hellodumplings8564]

Lol

[@jung.o.2080]

At least you're not dumber than a fifth grader

[@virwinsinstruments2209]

ahh look at that dumb ass doesn’t know that the water is the same

[@1Reevee]

Reading this comment be like “I know I’m not the only one”

[@sammyvc2672]

Id like to imagine when the kid turned 6, he was like, "Man, i was such an idiot"

[@nami141]

He'd be about 17 by now. I wonder if he has seen it.

[@thuanhtran2228]

he actually needs to turn 8 to pass this stage, I dont remember the stage's name but its one of 4 stages of Jean Piaget theory

[@sylviaelse5086]

I was struck by the child's apparent complete lack of surprise when the counting showed that the coin rows were the same.

[@ASHERUISE]

I do wonder how much is not understanding conservation of matter and how much is not having fully developed language skills.

[@uk-xc1ol]

Yeah I'm pretty sure he knew they were the same amount but due to the woman having more authority and her changing it right in front of him I think he answered what she wanted him to answer just like at the end he changed his answer of it being fair when she asked again thinking he didn't answer as she wanted

[@barrupa]

information persistence also plays a huge role, children don't have much short term memory

[@bounidadada4057]

I believe the kid hasn't any issue identifying the two rows as having the same number of coins. I believe the issue is his comprehension of the concept of "more". I don't really know much about kids cognition but he must be at an age when you are appropriating some concepts that are very well assimilated by adults, and so he bases his understanding of these concepts on the reaction of adults towards them, and especially since kids are used to be in an educative context these days. So the kid must be like "if she does that and asks me that, thus she means to point out this".

[@twinmasterpro]

Kids generally don't mind being corrected as much as adults do.

[@mochiandjams8761]

And this ladies and gents, is how to trick your kid or younger sibling into thinking they are eating the same amount of snacks than you.

[@coryellis1877]

Mochi and Jams My brother is 17 now, don't think it'll work anymore 😂

[@janruudschutrups9382]

*same AS you.

[@desertdweller9003]

ikr, for sure going to try to remember this for when I have children

[@ohreally331]

And this ladies and gents is how the Democratic party works. Republican and Democrat politicians are both filthy rich but the Democrats claim only the Republicans have more.

[@clown7309]

Oh Really dont bring politics into this buster, its snack time

[@BenRangel]

I love how he just spells out his logical mistakes but doesn’t reflect on it. ”That stick is longer” why? ”Because you moved it” so now it’s longer? ”Yeah”

[@Phoenix.14]

I couldn’t stop laughing lol

[@EscargoTouChaud]

it's LONGAUWH!

[@animationspace8550]

I think the problem here is just that he hasn't been taught to associate the word 'more' with the quantity of things in a set, but rather the quality of being larger sized in general. Hence why some kids would say "This is 'more' bigger". They associate it wrong due to them not understanding the full functions of the word. Also longer to the kid could mean which sticks out further. It's what the words mean to him based off his amount of context, he gets it fully, just not the word.

[@yifyhgksupernintendo]

@@animationspace8550 that’s what I kept thinking too. I wondered how his answers might change if the word “more” was explained in each scenario (like as quantity, in the coin example). I feel like it could be a misunderstanding in language.

[@user-ee9tu1kh5i]

I am very interested in this this topic.

[@quirked504]

When I was a kid in daycare at the YMCA, I held a dollar up to one of the teens who watched the kids and said, “I have a dollar!” She took it out of my hands, tore it in two, and handed it back to me, and said, “Now you have two dollars.” I walked off feeling so pleased.

[@illdie314]

I dont know whether that story is cute or cruel lol

[@lettus143]

​@@illdie314it's cruel, what a bitch lol

[@feather314]

That's so mean of her 😭😭

[@SasafrasYT]

i remember when i was a kid my dad would say "heads i win, tails you lose" when flipping a coin, got me every time.

[@rabidmuffinn]

Sasafras i learned that from scooby doo

[@foreskinmcfat-nutsjr]

Lol

[@sammack1890]

I didn't get the joke for like 5 seconds

[@manwithlongdong]

I might be a retar

[@EpicGamer99]

Yikes

[@modest_mind2526]

I like how he put his hand out to measure the cup's eveness.

[@bryanmejia3998]

me too because i still use my hand to measure my cup vs. my boy's cups of water.

[@Donovaan]

He's gonna become a structural engineer or something. :D

[@Boofedit]

a future engineer or craftsman

[@jennatale]

Eveness💀

[@ashnaasharaph5524]

He most probably grew up with siblings.

[@tripptank]

This is who you're arguing with in the comment section.

[@MushisCow]

For real.. I don't want ro engage in this shitfest of youtube scientists 😂

[@ccgb92]

@@MushisCow should probably do us all a favor then..

[@nyankers]

this is who I'm arguing with?

[@snail2426]

I hate pennies then >:(

[@salvadorramirez4114]

Reverse psychology got us all holding hands(almost) 🤣🤣🤣

[@alanstringer.]

It's amazing to think that your level of mental development can influence your perceptions so much. I will forevermore be much more patient with others after watching this... after all, they may just have the awareness of a 4 year old.

[@anfelboukli9019]

I can totally confirm that My teachers behave the same way he does

[@benthomas4544]

Having a 4.5 year olds of my own, I'm mostly impressed at the child's ability to sit patiently through it all.

[@pablosrf3881]

It's because it's an old video. These days every kid is ADHD.

[@pakan357]

@@pablosrf3881 It's PFAS/microplastics, I'm calling that.

[@connor7296]

​@@pablosrf3881 it's just because everyone's being raised wrong. And then some idiot made adhd a diagnosis and so now everyone thinks it's just something wrong with them medically and that they can't get over it. When if fact they can. It just takes effort, something none of them were raised to put forth. Literally everyone would have adhd if they wanted to. It's stupid.

[@LucasF25]

​@@pakan357 they turn the kids Hyper and the fricking frogs gay

[@sameehasamad]

Yup … cause screen time was probably low then

[@JickFincter]

EA: breaks a game in pieces and sells each part separately Gamers: So much content

[@Fabiano_il_Flaco]

So glad someone points it out

[@siegelink9549]

Paradox: "Hello there."

[@oem4444]

Sadly it's not only EA now.

[@FirstnameLastname-my7bz]

Not very good comparison as even without all content that came later Battlefront II 2017 is "more" than Battlefront II 2005 from the fact (edit: alone) how complex and diverse animation, models. Like in old Battlefrint all force users had same handle for lightsaber.

[@JickFincter]

@@FirstnameLastname-my7bz Doesn't apply in the first place since there's no dlc or non cosmetics locked behind a pay wall. But games are moving away from dlc anyway. I just said EA because they're awful

[@maxgarcia6231]

The kid years later: She played me like a damn fiddle!

[@JohnDoe____]

I read that with Sam's voice from Sam and Max and it was great. Thanks

[@sadrat5375]

"Fiddles are actually very hard to play. I played you like the cheap kazoo you are."

[@insch.9547]

Why we're still here..

[@daviclemons6910]

*Wtf is all this memeage*

[@Hacksaw.Jim.Duggan]

@@sadrat5375 "She played me like a damn fiddle", was a reference to the fiddle's sound, not the measure of difficulty playing it.

[@guytorie]

Even at 31, I often use the tall, thin 8 oz cup instead of the short, wide 8 oz cup because it just FEELS like there's more.

[@laurnborne3830]

Kid when he grows up: *Ive been tricked, backstabbed, and quite possible bamboozled*

[@davidlaburn7603]

Nice Red vs Blue reference!

[@RipleySawzen]

>kids proceeds to vote for red or blue political parties

[@vicnie1]

What is bamboozled?

[@johndoh1000]

This is why I have trust issues

[@windwakerplayer64]

@@vicnie1 they are a kind of beans. Hope this helps

[@jebby16]

I'm just amazed the kid sat still and answered all your questions.😳

[@rosyidharyadi7871]

that's what I think too. how do I get this superpower?

[@littlestsnowy8177]

They must have been given something at the end of it

[@shinobiwannabe]

Nah the kid is just engaged and entertained

[@hanskraut2018]

Non adhd pain killing dopamine shots - then again i realize concentration and fidgeting especially as todler is not even remotely diagnostic

[@leesonneville1817]

Yeah seriously. He understood the questions and was engaged. I know a lot of kids that you wouldn't even be able to do this exercise with

[@N1ckelD1me]

Why did youtube recommend me 4 minutes of a kid getting owned?

[@mossycave3865]

Dunno why its recommended, but this is a classic psychological demonstration of Piaget theory

[@subna03xd28]

Hello fellow person with the exacr same picture than mine. I thought that this day would never come. *wears sword*

[@jimmyjigz]

9 year old video too

[@mozartpiano23]

And a adult being stupid

[@subna03xd28]

@@Gabriel.1985. yea- wait what.

[@essel23fly]

Took 12 years for the KZbin algorithm to decide I needed to see this.

[@moxifloxi]

the way she repeats it made me question it too

[@yoda9142]

What are you doing here? Can you please stay away from videos that have kids in it. Thanks.

[@tacocatt6808]

@@yoda9142 why? What did they do? Are they into children or something gross like that?

[@unfortunateness]

@@tacocatt6808 ikr

[@Bob-lx8xu]

@@tacocatt6808 nope typically people, if this guy is associated with something adultery this mean this guy can't go to videos like these.

[@punchingnun3]

No matter how big or small a channel is.... For some reason we are given the same recommend videos. Also, love the work Mox

[@MatthieuDelcourt]

What’s funny is that at the end of every activity, she says “yes” and moves on as if the kid convinced her with his arguments.

[@Fjordzt]

Yeah but if she explains why the kid isn’t right he might get discouraged and not cooperate as well. If she did explain he most likely wouldn’t understand anyways

[@maksimkirandziski9660]

​@@Fjordzt the point is she shouldnt say anything that affirms the kids logic or her own logic, because it might sway the kid into either direction

[@Fjordzt]

@@maksimkirandziski9660 i agree with that but i also don’t think since the kid can’t grasp the concepts there, her affirming him when he is wrong won’t harm him when the time comes that he can actually understand

[@MatthieuDelcourt]

@@maksimkirandziski9660 That's interesting. I see now how saying "right" could reinforce the wrong idea in the kid's head throughout the test. For that one I was like "Come on, explain the kid what's going on!! Haha"

[@MatthieuDelcourt]

@@Fjordzt I'd be curious to know what the protocol says. Maybe the kid deserves an explanation after the test is over?

[@mastershredder2002]

When this kid grows up, he is going to sue that lady for defamation.

[@BladeOfLight16]

No, he is going to sue for his share of the ad revenue.

[@fataturchina5289]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mastershredder2002]

@@BladeOfLight16 Yeah, but then the lady is going to do the trick on him where he gets a tiny scrap of money and breaks it into two and she says "now you have twice as much of the ad revenue". What an evil bitch.

[@BladeOfLight16]

@@mastershredder2002 Won't work on an adult. ;)

[@mastershredder2002]

@@BladeOfLight16 I don't think so, read the comment where the guy says his boss does this to him every week with his wages.

[@erinmalone2669]

I went to Applebee’s once and ordered a large beer. It was in a tall glass, but then it seemed much narrower so I poured it into a regular pint glass, and it was exactly the same. These kids are growing and learning, but Applebees was genuinely trying to rip me off.

[@userofusername4981]

Just don’t eat at apple bees lol

[@xy4489]

Sue for false advertisement. Use profits to buy a lifetime supply of beer.

[@pjm7745]

​@@xy4489Yeah, I mean, Bud Light is going REAL cheap these days!😂😂🤣🤣

[@aocean6135]

lmaooo

[@erinmalone2669]

@@xy4489 if they existed anymore where I live, maybe

[@Landofalcon007]

He's honestly a pretty smart kid for his age. He's able to articulate his reasoning well, even if it's not technically correct.

[@ReverseGuy]

No the child is disabled

[@ReverseGuy]

Stop spreading lies.

[@thedudeamongmengs2051]

​@@ReverseGuywhat makes you think the child is disabled? There are normal adults who would get a few of these tests wrong. You also don't know anything about the kid

[@flickerygems7779]

​@@thedudeamongmengs2051idk about disability but no adult is getting tests like these wrong

[@thedudeamongmengs2051]

@@flickerygems7779 there are adults who look at different shaped glasses of water and can't tell the difference between the volume

[@doubled5659]

This kid s gonna have some troubles understanding whats heavier: kilogramme of steel or kilogramme of feathes.

[@LikeABawsGaming249]

I dont get it

[@alexismandelias]

@@LikeABawsGaming249 a kelegram o steeel or a kelegram o fethes

[@ploppyploppy]

@@alexismandelias Explained here :p kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y5emY6KhmpqAfMk

[@tenbillionfliescantbewrong9238]

obviously the steel is heavier because the steel will sink in water but the feathers will simply float on the top. nice try but you can't fool me.

[@partridgeluke]

@@LikeABawsGaming249 not the sharpest tool in the shed are you

[@hennaoctopus]

The kid using his hand to measure the level of water between the two glasses, so clever!

[@AliceHalley]

I mean, moving them closer would have been so significantly more reliable. Not to mention our hands aren't completely flat and can easily tilt to produce unreliable results. Nothing against the kid, I just don't see why people find this so impressive when we're meant to be the adults 😅

[@isaacpowell1608]

Imagine being this kid and years later realizing he was called “typical”

[@robertsdzanuskans2550]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@julienweems6166]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Josephr2211]

It’s a way of describing a child’s development typical development is the rate at which each child develops the only things that is different is how much time it takes for that child to develop typically. Atypical development is basically a slower rate of development and unlike typical development time isn’t a factor because the rate of which the child develops is slower. For example a typically developed child would be like a 12 month old infant being able to crawl and explore the area around the without much adult intervention. Whereas a atypical developed child would be a 12 month old baby still learning how to roll over from its back to its belly to crawl and it’s a good indicator that there’s something neurologically wrong with the child. So Isaac I assume at some point in your early childhood years you were consider a typical child. The field of early childhood education is a complex one with many different theories and ways to incorporate and express those theories/teachings in a teachers curriculum.

[@fhanum9716]

@@Josephr2211 get rekt

[@simpleinverso8628]

I'd be reassured if I saw a video describing me as a normal child.

[@agentx4315]

Perfect example of a $15 beer vs the $11 beer at the football game. Exact same amount just different cup.

[@buffybuffalo2975]

Phase two of testing: every time he’s wrong, yell “wrong” while slamming your fists onto the table. Then proceed to the next question without explanation while maintaining firm emotionless eye contact. We shall call this test the negative reaction test. Our goal is to see if stress can sharpen a child’s mental capabilities, or completely diminish them.

[@oliverjohanan]

Okay Dwight Schrute, calm down..

[@jonaskebab8090]

WRONG! You baby brained fool! NEXT TEST

[@jalel_z2867]

I actually wanna see this, but something tells me it's unethical

[@willmate5105]

Details are too specific my friend

[@daniloribeiro5372]

And now he's president of USA

[@ulischmidt03]

1:37 i love how he uses his hand to measure the water level

[@kailarobinson1028]

that was so cute

[@darek4488]

That's how most grown-up Americans do it.

[@KonglomeratYT]

@@darek4488 I'd say most human beings, not just Americans, would instinctively (and wisely) use their hands when making a general and insignificant comparison to find out whether or not two identical glasses contain a similar amount of liquid.

[@1616jaime]

Yeah I thought that was pretty smart of the little guy

[@mrheadshot8757]

@@1616jaime well he could just push them together and see more accurately if they are the same amount, but considering how he did in the test. yeah pretty smart

[@MissSchnickfitzel]

Its incredible how theres fully grown people who have the mental capacity of a literal toddler.

[@cmd1zz13]

Cutest thing ever to see how excited he gets when he answers all the questions, like "dude, I am NAILING THIS"

[@renni9813]

"Is this stick longer or is this stick longer or are they the same?" Kid: "well lady, if you triangulate the position of each end of each stick with the light fixture and use integral trigonometry you would actually find that the second stick is 12 nanometers longer than the first stick."

[@snapperyx6573]

Math's teachers be like that

[@bazookaace]

Um, dude, its pronounced salt.

[@renni9813]

@@bazookaace ?

[@ryderpham5464]

Integral trigonometry?

[@renni9813]

@@ryderpham5464 You obviously wouldn't need integral trig when triangulating, but it sounds cooler, and I obviously wasn't being serious.

[@turle8645]

I wanna know what percentage of adults would answer the same way the kid did

[@mitchellverhelle3986]

i asked my mom, what weighs more a pound of bricks or a pound of feathers. turns out this works on grown-ups too

[@RB-mm7ce]

If a pound of feathers is less dense then it will weight less. That's due to the buoyant force of air pushing the feathers up.

[@Renrang]

@@RB-mm7ce I just saw a plane fly, I feel so fat now 😢 Gotta lose more weight.

[@RB-mm7ce]

@@Renrang good luck with that.

[@SanxBile]

@@RB-mm7ce So your pound of feathers doesn't weigh a pound?

[@RB-mm7ce]

@@SanxBile I don't use imperials, but if pound is a unit of mass, then, if you place your pound of feathers on a very, very precise scale it should read that feathers weigh less than a pound.

[@maxmustermann8663]

I think the kid is just polite. The lady changes something and asks again, implying his former answer was wrong.

[@musics4me]

That woman is pretty fair in her tone of voice. I would've been extra shady: "so now it's LONGER???!!!!"

[@munchyfish201]

Arif nonce

[@estebansilva1071]

Lmfaooo (x

[@manelicecream9689]

hahaha

[@robinj.nysveen2105]

Child : OH DON’T SASS ME WOMAN

[@DjSunexx]

In this kind of tests, it is extremely important to keep the voice level and neutral since the kids will pick up any changes a lot quicker. this is also the reason she always asks them the questions with 3 outcomes, option A option B or both being equal. If you'd leave out the third option, in many cases the kid would simply go for one of the other two instead of coming up with the third option on its' own.

[@Carol-pv1gu]

The kid has tons of patience and is well mannered answering all the questions 😍

[@sownheard]

He is not a pet 😔 Well mannered 🐕 Where is all his energy The passion of youth should not be snuffed 😤

[@floraice.]

@@sownheard its not that deep

[@iwishiwaswrongbutimnot517]

Being will mannered will no take up for being constantly wrong tho.

[@iwishiwaswrongbutimnot517]

@@sownheard your right. But animals don't have manners at all. He did get every answer wrong. I would be more concerned with that, rather than pointing out the obvious. Or were u saying he wasn't a pet for yourself?

[@iwishiwaswrongbutimnot517]

@@sownheard your right. But animals don't have manners at all. He did get every answer wrong. I would be more concerned about that. Rather than stating the obvious. Or were u saying he wasn't a pet for your own clarity?

[@45potato95]

Surely there are kids out there who wouldn't be tricked by this

[@frazzle657]

Just tried this with my niece who is almost 5 and she was the same however, when you actually elaborate and ask "so the liquid in these is no longer the same" she understands that they are the same but one is higher. I think a lot of it is down to how they interpret English. Maybe they see what we say as phrases more than literally

[@BigLiftsITA]

This is a very good hypothesis

[@jessicali8594]

Under the age of six, cognitive development and perception are often not in sync. Note that child acknowledged that the coin lines were the same after using his finger, not his eyes, to count them.

[@grandmaul9003]

It's not the way you asked but what you asked for, you asked if they were different, they said yes, just because you know what "more" and "same" *can* mean doesn't mean they know what you're asking for

[@AntiKiwieCS]

Grand Maul yeah this is what I think, the fact that he describes that “this one is taller” as a reason for his answer makes it seem to me as if he does not understand what she’s asking for really

[@jessicali8594]

This cognitive development experiment of Jean Piaget has been repeated in universities for at least 70 years. Back then, outside the US, fizzy drinks were a very seldom enjoyed treat. Two boys, well below 6 years old, were shown the amount of fizzy drink poured into two identical glasses and they agreed that the amount of drink was the same. Then, as they watched, one glass was poured into a taller glass with a narrower base. Then the boys were invited to select a glass. They Both wanted the taller glass. The experiment was repeated with boys over 6 years of age who didn't mind which glass they got. Btw: the reason for boys in this part of the experiment is that back then boys were encouraged to be competitive and before the '80s were typically given toy guns and knives as birthday presents.

[@Dalgia111]

“Sorry sir it looks like you’ll need more money to purchase these items” *spreads my dollars further across the checkout counter* “Thank you sir that’s plenty. Would you like your change?”

[@hqppyfeet7513]

lmAO "That will be twenty bucks." **gives 10-dollar bill** "...twenty, not te--." **rips dollar bill** "Oh my bad, thank you, have a good day."

[@whyuactingsopepegasusbro7196]

Thanks for the good laugh hahahaha

[@abundance-lg8zw]

Lmaoooo

[@lunaromance2243]

😐

[@ForeverYoungKickboxer]

Nailed it, great comment, sir

[@fynnfish]

I was first totally baffled by the kid’s way of thinking, till I learned that he doesn’t have a concept of conservation of mass. If something is stretched than mass magically appears, if it’s mushed it magically decreases. But it’s interesting that he doesn’t reflect on his way of thinking after counting the coins.

[@monkii-]

Kid: that's more me, a 19yo: pathetic.

[@abdelal-maraj4675]

@William Shakespeare and you don't understand sarcasm, congratulations

[@monkii-]

@William Shakespeare you are being very pathetic right now, just saying :p

[@monkii-]

@William Shakespeare and i got my attention thanks to you :p

[@epochthekid]

@William Shakespeare Relinquish that account name this instant, you fool.

[@alliemae26]

@William Shakespeare Cry harder

[@Kittiesinclair5]

This kid is aware that the amounts have not changed. His definitions of ‘more’ or ‘larger’ are different than those of the adult working with him. A very interesting demonstration.

[@adi45713]

Laura Hargreaves I agree. His explanations point those differences out.

[@HylianHanzou]

@Cosmic Dissonance if you are referring to the answers the kid is giving as a common phenomenon, it is, children have different perspectives and reasoning (not as good as an adult's), it's not hard to find more videos and experiments similar to this one trying to make the same point.

[@tren380]

Cosmic Dissonance your reply is entirely too long full of ridiculous conclusions.

[@untelmorveux]

hes just stupid asf

[@Mezaph]

He thinks the Graham crackers distribution is fair. Completely debunks your theory.

[@KPpivot]

The child reflects my level of confidence when I bomb a math test.

[@karimzocker]

Nice

[@mayagene6282]

This actually really fascinates me because be was able to realize that the two rows of quarters were the same because he could count them. However, when it came to the things that he couldn’t easily measure, it through him off. It’s interesting how kids connect “more” with physical appearances.

[@xavierpantig1772]

*breaks the kid's single gram cracker in half* Kid: Now THAT'S fair!

[@lewisabraham4359]

😂

[@burntchickennugget8142]

I have the 420 likes power

[@CraftBasti]

@@burntchickennugget8142 thanks for pointing it out, I almost destroyed it

[@allotherlightsgoout]

I am honestly surprised that worked for her.

[@insightfultoaster2965]

are the iPhone same? They are the same *Hikes the price of one* How about now? This one's better

[@vasectomyfail442]

some of my earliest memories are counting my "moneys". i would be so impressed with myself for having 80 shiny pennies and my brother just had one dumb 10 dollar bill.

[@tristenarctician6910]

Yo, are yuh a gighjellianaire?

[@FabioSpelta]

Your nick is wonderful.

[@ellac613]

I used to trick my sister that way, giving her lots of five cents in exchange for fifty cents, which in my country are roughly the same size.

[@pponcelet]

@@ellac613 What kinda weird country is that? Are the fifty's really small or are the five's really big?

[@henriquemeiralins]

HOW TO BE SAVED (How to KNOW you are saved and not just hope you are THE BAD NEWS All men have sinned and are in need of a Savior (Rom 3:23 "For all have sinned, and come short of the glory of God" ; Rev 21:8 "But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all LIARS, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death. No man can come to God by his own good works and righteousness. (Isaiah 64:6 "But we are all as an unclean thing, and all our righteousnesses are as filthy rags;" THE GOOD NEWS 1 Timothy 1:15 tells us "This is a faithful saying, and worthy of all acceptation, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners." How does Jesus save a sinner? From the beginning of the bible to the end, God has only forgiven sins through a BLOOD SACRIFICE, because he is a Holy God he can't forgive sins any other way, Heb 9:22 tells us, "...without shedding of blood is no remission." when Adam sinned, God had to kill a lamb in Adam's place as a substitue, In the Law of Moses, a Blood Sacrifice was demanded for the forgiviness of sins. Jesus came to die for the sins of the whole world, he came to be OUR Blood Sacrifice, OUR substittue, he came to bear OUR sins on the cross, in OUR place. John 1:29 "...Behold the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world." What must you do to be saved? YOU MUST REPENT; You must change from unbelief to belief. admit you are guilty, that you cannot do anything to save or help save yourself, and that you need Jesus Christ as your savior. Titus 3:5 "Not by works of righteousness which we have done. but according to his mercy he saved us," Romans 3:28 "Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law." Romans 4:5 "But to him that worketh not, but believeth on him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness." YOU MUST TRUST; placing your complete faith in what Jesus Christ already did to save you; John 1:12 "But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on his name:." Salvation comes by believing in WHAT Jesus did for you, 1 Cor. 15:1-4 tells us "Moreover, brethren, I declare unto you the GOSPEL which I preached unto you, which also ye have received, and wherein ye stand; 2 By which also ye are SAVED, if ye keep in memory what I preached unto you, unless ye have believed in vain. 3 For I delivered unto you first of all that which I also received, HOW that Christ died for OUR SINS according to the scriptures; 4 And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures:" All you have to do to be saved, and on your way to heaven is place your TRUST in the shed Blood of Jesus Christ and nothing else, as sufficient for your salvation, (Rom 3:25 "Whom God hath set forth to be a PROPITIATION through FAITH IN HIS BLOOD, to declare his righteousness for the remission of sins that are past, through the forbearance of God;") (Propitiation means the act of appeasing wrath, Jesus took your place on the cross.) Will you accept Jesus Christ as your savior by simple faith, simply trusting in his shed Blood for sufficient to save your soul from hell? The last sentence is all you must do to be saved, and that is FAITH, not works, TRUSTING in what someone else did for you is the only thing that is not a work. Please watch Robert Breaker's video titled "HOW TO GET SAVED" If you have received Jesus Christ, by faith in his Blood, you now have eternal life and on your way to heaven! I John 5:11 "And this is the record, that God hath given to us eternal life, and this life is in his Son." John 10:27-28 "My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me: And I give unto them eternal life; and they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand." If you got saved because of this message please let me know! You can copy and send this message to others!

[@adamgillespie3393]

"is this fair" *shakes head* "yes" I get that

[@Gos1234567]

The volume one tricks adults all the time,that’s why pubs use long skinny glasses for a half pint

[@metalvideos1961]

Maybe they fool Americans. But I am not fooled by it. I am a grown up who can see the difference.

[@dadrumma8608]

@@metalvideos1961 Yes I am also a grown up. I wear my big adult pants and go to work and do a business. Then I come home and do grown up things. I can't be tricked by dummie dumbs like all the little kids, because I'm a grown up.

[@minoxiothethird]

@@dadrumma8608 Hahahahahaha Ohhh man, now I've got in my head the small kid on top of some stilts or something from bojack horseman trying to comment on youtube

[@saaah707]

The real reason is it stops you from dumping it all over yourself

[@shanious4804]

Hes right but not totally. The demonstration that the two had the same volume before the transfer is the difference. Generally people perceive taller glasses to be more full.

[@TiLWid]

Alternate Title: How to gaslight a four-year-old.

[@TaxEvasi0n]

Astoundingly, some adults never seem to develop past this stage of learning. I would know, I work with them.

[@onatic8058]

Kid: moves piece of Bread Kid: I have solved world hunger

[@potatos5699]

@llriv me, an Christian: Well no, but actually yes.

[@Alaryk111]

Considering how wasteful the rich countries are with the food this statement is true.

[@stardestroyer8084]

@@Alaryk111 I wonder who is wasteful... fertile countries that cannot organize farming or rich countries that can, but decide to throw things away they don't need (which then ends up in biological waste which again might be used as fertilizer). The question can be answered with a peek to South Africa.

[@unigodspawn]

This comment made me laugh so hard.

[@Chioticfoot]

😂😂

[@YourCapyFrenBigly_3DPipes1999]

This is just so adorable. This baby is 16 or 17 now. I bet he'd get them all right today.

[@niknaython1979]

2:08 I love how he pushes them together to check the heights of the water, so cute

[@riti184]

Yessssss

[@queeniegierza289]

yeep

[@Ema_126]

Nik Naython no need

[@therealb888]

@@Ema_126 no need? What do u mean?!

[@eliasabbas8450]

@@therealb888 No need to be gay dude. Obvious.

[@giol33t]

The funny thing is that these types of "tricks" work on adults too. Like how people are more likely to buy an item for 19.99 rather than 20.00 when they are practically the same price. Or when stores double the value of an item and then sell it at half price (the original price) and people feel like they are getting a great deal.

[@deponensvogel7261]

They never double the price. It‘s just too expensive to begin with, because it is designed to get sold at a discount price. With the .99 trick, certain parts of your brain seem to only register the first two digits.

[@piergiorgio919]

99.99 percent of people will just register 9.99 $ as 10

[@onee]

They don't double the price. They just make a $100 product $135. And give you a discount of 25%. So, you end up paying more ($101.25).

[@visualstudiosproductions]

Those examples are not the "same type of tricks". Buying something at 19.99 instead of 20 or at half price after being jacked up has 0 to do with conservation of matter, there's absolutely no link between this experiment and commercial tricks in any way. The only trick that would be equivalent would be to sell the same product, in the same quantity, in two different packages, and charge more for one of them because it appears "larger". To my knowledge this doesn't happen anywhere at all. (And no, this is not equivalent to buying in bulk at a discount, etc. - it would only apply if you could get two different packages of the same exact product and quantity at different prices. And you never can, because DUH - consumers are not 4 year olds).

[@Rhino1004]

Depends on how the value of that item was doubled. If the upmark always started at $10, then they later sold at $5, then that's buy-low sell-high profits at work. If it started at $5, then said they doubled it to $10 but immediately discounted it to $5, then that's actually illegal.

[@ParentingPlanet]

Watching your child hit milestones is like witnessing tiny miracles. Stay engaged, celebrate progress, and nurture their journey. Here's a thought: How can you turn a daily activity into a chance for them to learn and grow? 🙂

[@urphakeandgey6308]

I'm impressed he had an explanation for all his answers. I bet a lot of kids would struggle to explain it or just be like "it looks like it."

[@OppyOzzborz-sb8oz]

American ones

[@bosstoober8782]

Well I mean, if you showed them outside a conservation task how would you justify which glass has more water?

[@secretname2670]

Not all children are misbehaving gremlins, some parents actually raise their offspring

[@74oshua]

​@@secretname2670Just because a child isn't able to accurately describe their reasoning for a decision doesn't make them a "misbehaving gremlin." They're a child, their brain isn't fully developed, and not every child grows the same parts of their brain at the same rate, even given the same stimulus. It kills me when people blame a child being disobedient on their parents not doing their job, it's such a short-sighted argument. There are plenty of adult reasons to be disobedient, it's not like it's a universally bad thing. It's just occurring at an inappropriate time, because they're still learning how to interact with society.

[@dondavis1180]

NGL, his answers are so "exactly what the researcher wants to hear" that it seems coached. My kid just turned five and while he might be tricked by the spacing out of quarters, I think it would only "trick" him on first appearance. There is no way my kid is going to think that a stick suddenly grew in length because i moved it slightly to the left or right. and also my kid would be doing way more trying to touch stuff. Need to see a few more kids before we say this one is "a typical kid"

[@shahru]

the child basically wants to finish the test asap and thus quickly giving you the answer you want..no bsting around!!!

[@justahamster]

Woman: Are they the same now? Child: *Always has been*

[@JmastersJ]

💀💀💀

[@НиколайКучерявенко-з1ш]

The most underrated comment on this video

[@justahamster]

Thank you thank you

[@insch.9547]

Lol

[@kroepoek3764]

@@justahamster good one lol

[@chatroom101]

Wow for a grown up, this woman doesn't seem know anything

[@MatheusC1729]

She needs to ask a little Child for every thing

[@apppertplus68]

Kid's trying to take her at her word on leading questions. He thinks she's trying to teach him something, not test him.

[@gatesford7481]

App, yes exactly, and he is not trying to compete, he is just making straight observations...

[@MushisCow]

@@apppertplus68 The test is conducted without leading questions specifically to avoid a faulty outcome. Before you reach conclussions on acknowledged child cognitive development how about you don't conclude based on a three minute video? I study this field and though I had my skeptisism with a lot of theories, when you dive into the theories and what they're based on, other than numerous tests conducted by individuals that tries to break the theory, it yields the same result.

[@foreskinmcfat-nutsjr]

MushisCow right

[@badoman5000]

Hes just using kid logic, I mean it makes sense to him. At least hes being consistent in his line of thinking

[@robertchristii5017]

At 4-5 years old I would have asked this lady if she was stupid immediately after she pushed the stick to the side and asked me which one was longer.

[@generaltsingshitao4368]

Sir this is 10$ you need 10 more for this item. Bob: *tears it in half* Oh, enjoy your purchase

[@tomwanders6022]

As someone who had Latin in school and failed miserably at it I have no idea what you guys just said.

[@AnimeGIFfy]

I haven't seen a more intense interrogation in my life

[@seekhelp]

Really shows how the human brain develops overtime. Have a successful life ahead lil buddy..

[@alvaroprieto2092]

Bruh this kid is like 25 now

[@goodoldmoovies3374]

Assuming the study took place right around when the video was published, he's actually only 13 or 14.

[@alvaroprieto2092]

@@goodoldmoovies3374 True. The video quality looked to me like it was converted from VHS 90s. But considering the ratio the video has your probably right

[@loljptrollergami7325]

This is like when you ask a kid young enough which number is halfway through 1 and 9 they say 3

[@pseudotaco]

@@loljptrollergami7325 I see you have been watching Vsauce?

[@adamschneider868]

What you are seeing is not a child who isn't understanding the world, but being surrounded by adults who understand the world better than them, so they are constantly looking for their own gaps in knowledge and trying to correct them in real time like error correcting code. It's like when we thought elephants couldn't use tools cause they wouldn't use a branch to get fruit. However they wouldn't use a branch to get fruit because they use their trunk as their main sensory organ, it would be like us grabbing a stick with our eyes to knock down a piece of fruit. Give them a box and they will move it and step on it. To get the fruit. The framing of the questions is inherently wrong, she is saying one thing he is interpreting another, he is merely going "I am kid, the adult knows more. Their must be a gap in my knowledge. I must error correct and change my answer"

[@DeuceGenius]

Man this is hard work for the little guy. Give him a snack or something for his dilligent effort.

[@TheIncognitusMe]

The only reason the kid gets the questions wrong is because he’s recognizing a pattern that trumps his understanding of the quantities. The researcher asks a question, changes something, then asks the same question. The pattern is that the answer must change because the items have changed. The kid isn’t focusing on the meaning of “the same amount.” They aren’t the “same” anymore.

[@danielsummers4446]

Guys this kid is not stupid. He’s not at the age where he can answer this stuff correctly. These are actual experiments done on many kids the same age and almost all come up with the same answer. I find it fascinating

[@topdog3080]

Daniel Summers they are kidding lol no one actually thinks the kid is stupid.

[@blaketto]

Why are children so stupid? I could make this shit up when i was their age because it's just logic so why can't they?

[@pijn2370]

Wrong, I wasn't even this dumb when I was 4.

[@Sidnfjdkdndfbd]

Most people are jokeing

[@ixthebest8325]

@@AdrianoCROST So you are saying every kid that has ever done this test always with the same results is stupid? If you weren't stupid you wouldn't feel smarter than a kid because you would know that at his age is totally normal to give those answers.

[@32334694]

3:04 he's fed up gives a look to the camera 🤣🤣

[@cristianpereyra6912]

the sigh lmao

[@Gambit2483]

"I was promised Graham crackers. Where's my Graham crackers?"

[@ryanyaksich4047]

I would like this comment, but it's the magic number. 69.

[@Yetipfote]

"how long will this stupid shit go on? When can I resume building on my time machine at my room?"

[@kainuipenaloza9395]

I think I understand. The child doesn’t understand what exactly the concept of “equal” is, but it does understand “the same”, so it answers a question it doesn’t understand by assuming from the answer. It can tell the sticks, glasses, shapes, are not the same, so its not the same. But they don’t understand the further concept which is that they’re equal despite being different.

[@tokutickler]

Lady: *Moves stick* My Brain: Aight Ima head out

[@BufordT]

I always tell the pizzeria to cut my pizza into 6 slices because there's no way i could eat 8 slices!

[@ratmations8306]

Hah!

[@ItsJustMilkISwear]

This was all just an elaborate trick to scam him out of his graham crackers.

[@TheEMC99]

😂

[@shane8037]

This chick reminds me of my wife...

[@bohemianabyss6419]

🤣🤣

[@Sina_TM]

:))))))

[@coachjohann915]

Technically the sticks are the same that you moved it Forward so it makes it longer trick question

[@chairmankurihara8658]

Woman: Are they the same? Kid: War. War never changes. Woman: What? Kid: What?

[@ForeverYoungKickboxer]

Nice!

[@harrybull3297]

Fallout 4

[@vigi86]

@@harrybull3297 Fallout 1, Fallout 2, Fallout 3, ... ;-*

[@TheOneWhoHasABadName]

and then there’s fallout 76 would probably have been better if there had been actually 75 games made before it

[@abdouippo1793]

😂😂😂😂😂😂 The moment you get universal conscience and then it fades away

[@Cammmmm24]

I think this kids a genius, when she moved thay stick over he was taking its superpositions into account, i couldnt do that when i was 4

[@jackson5116]

2:07 is a restaurant trick where they make you think you're getting more drink when in reality it's just a different glass with the same amount.

[@buschbohne001]

Yep. Starbucks practises that principle to an extend. The actual amount of coffee you get is basically the same regardless of what size you buy.

[@mattrogers5188]

The drinks you buy in stores are the same way. The containers are cleverly designed to make a little look like a lot

[@Aspartem]

Is that allowed where you live? All glasses / bottles that get served in Switzerland have to be marked. You can not sell "undefined" amounts of a drink. Comes with hefty fines. So a 3dl or 5dl is always marked a such - be it glass or bottle.

[@AUGSpeed42]

@@Aspartem Yeah, Switzerland is much more big-brained than the US, but we all kind of knew that. The US has free reign (in restaurants only) to sell you indeterminate volume drinks.

[@bloodykon1]

@@Aspartem u.s. is sorta just corporate scammin around every corner

[@GabrielRM]

Some people will overthink what's happening. The kid isn't heavily thinking about each question, he isn't thinking about what volume the cups have, exact amount of coins etc at first. He's simply saying the first thing that goes on his mind after each question. It's like how an adult will say a red car is better for whichever reasons, although we know colour makes no real difference in its functionality. As we grow up we simply learn to use our critical thinking and communicate.

[@frognite02]

I love how the child is never told that he is wrong, they are just playing this little "game" and it's fun to him.

[@imjustsomeguy72]

Exactly. You generally don''t expect a 4 year old to understand the concept of conservation, that typically happens a few years into primary school. Not much point telling him he's wrong, cause it's a difficult concept to grasp. The kid doesn't learn and doesn't have any fun, and the tester just ends up feeling shitty. Better to keep it as a game and keep them having fun learning!

[@viviando1386]

Actually, the entire purpose of a clinical interview is to understand what is going behind a child’s mind. It is for research and not an opportunity to teach them on the spot. (I do hope they do teach him afterwards though!)

[@BrosBrothersLP]

@@viviando1386 yeah i dont get why most comments dont understand that this isnt to check how well he learns specific things regarding volume and numbers and length awareness. But to understand what the "natural" understanding is at that age. And people commenting that she is tricking him by not correcting "false" answeres. Also maybe they should try to get a 3 year old to sit and concentrate for an extended period while you constantly tell them they are wrong

[@viviando1386]

@@BrosBrothersLP yup exactly! Ig people aren't too familiar with this concept. I'm majoring in math education and we recently learned how to conduct clinical interviews with older students. It's pretty cool how much you can understand their reasoning and misconceptions from just a few well-written questions!

[@bbbbbbb51]

@@BrosBrothersLP I mean anyone who knows who Piaget is understands what's going on simply from the title.

[@DingleberryProductions]

It’s so funny for me that for like a year of a child’s life it’s gonna fall for these without fail

[@tommy.h]

There was an experiment by McGarrigle and Donaldson that showed that when an entity such as a "naughty Teddy" was the one moving the items about, the children were fully capable of doing conservation tasks, which could mean that the child is simply giving the responses that it thinks the adult wants in this case but that it does understand conservation.

[@mchikos]

Exactly! He sees her move the stick, and she’s an authority asking questions, so he thinks she wants him to change his answer.

[@andrewcain6518]

Trying to understand children in a lab is like trying to understand killer whales at sea world.

[@InitialPC]

@@andrewcain6518 I think we learned a lot about that killer whales in sea world. Mostly reasons why we shouldn't have them.

[@InitialPC]

yeah, if a kid is asked "what does yellow taste like?" the kid will give an answer because theyll be thinking "well if this grownup is asking me that there must be an answer for it"

[@YonDivi]

I feel like the glass experiment is the only one thats actually a really good experiment. When she moved the stick and asked him if it's a different size it's like, confirmation bias or something. Put yourself in the child's shoes, imagine a big strong, smart, grown up who's asking you questions starts doing something like that. Like at that age it makes no sense for an adult to ask you a question like "which one is bigger" after something has happened like that.

[@masterbaiter9856]

I kinda get it. A toddler sees every question as a trick from a mad god.

[@anshumansingh5698]

woman: "How about now?" child: "now that's fair" video: uploads politicians and corporates: "Shit, our trick just got leaked."

[@tchortaff1750]

I'm 25 and even I'd say the taller glass has more water. I mean, just look at it.

[@raffaelechinotti5244]

Weeeelll yes if i didnt saw the same quantity get transfered from the smaller glass to the taller hahaha id say the same🤣

[@cheva1]

raffaele chinotti your genius cannot be contained

[@vastowen4562]

Same. If she hadn't poured from the smaller glass into the bigger I'd say it's more too. It's because of two things: the shape of the glass (getting narrower then thicker) and the fact that the smaller glass is wide whereas the larger glass is tall. We perceive taller things as having more volume or being bigger than wide things of the same volume because of our vision. We seem much more at once horizontally rather than vertically, if that makes sense. Basically a wide object takes up less space in our vision than a tall object due to the nature of our eyes. Therefore, we perceive two equally volumous objects, one which is wider than it is tall and one which is taller than it is wide, as the tall one being larger than the other. Weird huh?

[@jdavi6241]

@@vastowen4562 this is why huge predators like lions often didn't fuck with early humans unless desperate or extremely confident. we stand upright. they had to look up at us. We were taller, therefore bigger, therefore more dangerous.

[@jdavi6241]

@Green Giantnot so jolly huh? the fuck is up with your vague racism on a children's psychology video?

[@seussdoctor9452]

I feel like the boy's thought process is a mixture of trying to make sense but also trying to make the questioner happy. He is so innocent that he never imagines a trick question, hence the only reasonable answer to the question when repeated after some procedure is the alternative. I expect different results if the series of questions are performed by another child or friend.

[@darksoals]

I do wonder if some of this is a misunderstanding of terminology where the “more” is being substituted in the child’s mind as “larger” or “different”. Because we have to understand that children have not developed the same understanding of terminology. They have enough to get by, but they merge words where possible in order to optimize their language.

[@troywakefield9250]

Soals Young children have underdeveloped brains and find it very difficult to understand abstract concepts that we have no problems with. Death is a very good example of this, as kids under the age of five or six are unable to recognise that someone can just disappear from their body, gone forever. It’s why its so hard to tell young kids that their parent/parents have died, because it is incomprehensible to them.

[@darksoals]

Troy Wakefield abstract concepts sure, but I’m pretty sure that straw one was a fundamental misunderstanding for example. The cup one I believe the child was fooled, same with any of the ones that play with the distribution of space between multiple objects. But there are some of these that I bet have more going on than just “bigger or smaller” but the child has not learned to communicate effectively. We have to remember that the human brain is so extremely complicated, even if not more so the brain of a developing child, that there are many variables that go beyond the scope of what we see in this test. The first and most important one being communication and understanding.

[@troywakefield9250]

Soals It’s a thoughtful opinion and it is true that we don’t fully understand the human brain yet but, for the most part in this case it’s fairly well understood how our brains work at each developmental stage. There have been many studies done (some similar to this one) on how the brain operates in children between the ages of two and five and we now know that at this age children’s cognitive abilities are about the equivalent of a chimpanzee (not including speech as it is unique to humans). What this essentially means is that their brains have not yet developed the ability to comprehend certain abstract ideas as a result of developmental latency in the areas of their brain responsible for complex and intricate thought. After the age of six or so children start to understand these ideas properly.

[@troywakefield9250]

Soals I should probably add that every experiment performed with the child in this video revolves around an abstract idea. It may not seem abstract at first glance but these tests are all designed around whether you can correlate the movement or reshaping of an object to its surface area/volume. His brain cannot tell the difference between the two because it cannot interpret the difference. And even if you could explain it to the child properly he still wouldn’t be able to understand because it’s an issue of comprehension not communication.

[@pattmahiney]

That's literally part of what this is testing.

[@andreyromashchenko8967]

He means it “takes up more space” and you mean it’s “more of”. He means “it reaches further” and you mean “longer”.

[@AD-wg8ik]

I just think he doesn’t understand what the word “more” means

[@bronze5158]

also his answers are influenced by the womans gestures and how she uses her voice like "how about NOW" so the kid thinks he need to give a different answer so this test is wrong on so many levels it is not scientific at all

[@bronze5158]

@@HuaweiBoulder Well not a scientist yet but im actually studying physics and also my comment is true, being on youtube doesnt make it false and you have no counter argument other than insulting which also proves that im right.

[@Salatiels]

@@bronze5158 exactly, and the fact that she is answering "yes" to the wrong answers only makes the child think he's getting it right.

[@sirskelletor]

@@bronze5158 Don't consider this to be a perfect experiment, but these results have been replicated countless times. And psychologists are very aware of the ease at which participants can be influenced by the experimenters. Admittedly this would be a difficult study to do double blinded, but every psych 1000 class teaches you about Clever Hans. Just in case you were broadly criticizing these results.

[@spencestep1998]

@@sirskelletor exactly! i learned about this is intro to psych. This particular experiment isnt perfect, but this type of experiment AND the results have backed up by brain scans in relation to how a childs brain develops.

[@A2Ztigers]

Why was this recommended to me? Why does KZbin think I'd be interested in watching this, and why was it correct?

[@shoulders-of-giants]

because you were him once

[@A2Ztigers]

@@shoulders-of-giants and I will be again

[@voxelrush]

Because the AI algorithm is honestly scary kzbin.info/www/bejne/rGqofIloo7iIbtk

[@regularfather4708]

I hate that KZbin seems to know what I want to watch before I do.

[@thejtd21]

Same man....same...

[@kylek4408]

"You fool! You fell for one of the classic blunders!!"

[@_dad_chef_exotics__forksno3381]

"Never argue with a sicielain when death is on the line! " "hahhaha". 😉

[@williamundy4569]

The first being never start a land war in Asia

[@coryellis1877]

William Undy And second never to attack Russia in winter

[@wenaolong]

This seems to be more about the conservation of identity in all dimensions rather than as such. The child's mind seems to be thinking of "more" as more in some dimension, rather than "more as such". They are not thinking about mass.

[@aleksandarsolaja8849]

Problem with this Piaget's test is that children (some children) still don't fully understand, comprehend concepts like; more, bigger, taller, longer...They are having mixed information on what exactly those words mean...When you are not acquainted with exact terminology, you can send a confusing message to the one who is conducting the test, and they can think that the child doesn't understand inner works of conservation, but kids actually don't understand the question. (In saying this, some children do actually present undevelopment in areas where is necessary to grasp the concept of conservation , as well as not showing correctl understanding of the real meaning of the question.)

[@kimberley4383]

Aleksandar Solaja that was the point of his studies. To show how cogantive development happens and at what point can kids understand that the amount of rather doesn't change just because the glass does. Or the playdough is the same amount though it changed shapes. Again that was what he was studing. At what point do we comprehend these concepts.

[@jordanwhirl3958]

That’s the point it’s not a quiz it’s a study

[@Moore-s5p]

No, you guys are wrong and the original commentator is correct. This study is not about language development but spacial development. He is pointing out that the language skews the results because the word the "same" is not clearly defined to the child. It is true the playdough was no longer the "same" after she squashed it.

[@kimberley4383]

Who had child development or psychology classes. The point wasn't about language development but understanding object permanence and the progression of the idea. The child understands same when they look the same. They don't understand that just because the overall shape changes it it's still the same amount. At younger stages a child believes that if an object disappears it's gone which is why peekaboo is so fun for them. The person disappears then comes back. It's along the same path of understanding the world.

[@Moore-s5p]

Kimberley exactly, It wasn't about language development and they didn't factor that element into the study making it flawed. I am sorry that your brain stops work once someone else says they have a degree and therefore you should just agree.

[@cloroxbleach7554]

2:04 Imagine if the kid just pulls out a pen, paper, and a calculator and started solving for the volume of each glass lol.

[@21area21]

Then he'd be dumb af cuz he still using eyes to do measurements. You'd just need to know conservation of mass and say both are still the same. If you wanted to be a smart-ass or "know it all" as they use to call it, you could say that the glass that was poured has less because some liquid is still left in the old glass.

[@ddalgi6673]

no need, the kid is too smart for pens, papers and calculators

[@yourrightimsooosorry884]

Kid: okay Google which one.............

[@windowsxpmemesandstufflol]

But then he forgot to put evaporation into the equation :(

[@meskinYT]

These questions need to be asked of every politician before they are allowed into office.

[@vivvpprof]

3:24 "Did we share the crackers fair?" Yes Why? Cause you're twice my size B-)

[@ryangarces9331]

Try three times even

[@P4rz1va1]

Yeah fair is kind of relative there

[@TheeOK1]

*Mission passed:* *Respect +*

[@wizkid2001]

Honestly, what if he was like, well you bigger and older and you probably paid for the food and so any case that you share the food is unfair to you, but always great for me.

[@vivvpprof]

@@wizkid2001 you mean what if he were a feeder? 😮

[@Gabi-nn6xu]

you can see he thinks he nailed it omg so adorable

[@FireBlade57]

Now imagine that even as adults there are concepts out there that we just can't grasp, but are unaware of it. Yet we walk in this world and use it up, like we know everything for a fact.

[@imaverageatgamesbutimostly3431]

I've learned a long time ago that everybody is an idiot. The only people who aren't idiot are people who realize they are idiots, and actually put in effort to study and exercise their mind.

[@Diya8114]

That is so true

[@peezieforestem5078]

Speak for yourself, I walk in this world with great humility.

[@trickortrump3292]

@@peezieforestem5078 Yes. Your comment reeks of humility.

[@Red-jl1qr]

@@imaverageatgamesbutimostly3431 that's just the dunning Kruger effect

[@kenny2006sp]

People think this video is about the kid answering correctly or how smart he is. This video is just showing a concept.

[@076657]

It is about how kids at that age answer incorrectly

[@Picklemedia]

Well I thought he was pretty clever although he didn't answer all the questions correctly