Muslims, Christian, and Rabbi Tovia Singer Debate Sin and Atonement!

[@AdaraBalabusta]

We continue to pray for your dear father, Rabbi. May he be healed. Thank you so much for sharing the truth of Hasham to all who have the wisdom to hear.

[@gokhan_duran]

Thank you Rabbi. Shabbat shalom.

[@ToviaSinger1]

Thank you

[@Reconsiderate]

love seeing the Rav engage in these inter-faith discussions 🥰 he's so ready!

[@GlennMalabo]

Thanks!

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Thank you, Glenn. As someone who receives a great deal of benefit from this channel, I appreciate your supporting it. ✡️❤️

[@nob8503]

Shalom/Salam Rabbi Singer Peace and love from a Muslim, May the Almighty guide us all ❤

[@lesaheliorahavramsonkarapo4211]

Thank you everyone. Astounding what things were relayed!

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Yes, I have listened twice and plan to listen again next week. ✡️❤️

[@anggaboyss]

Hi Rabbi, I'm Muslim from Indonesia ❤

[@Shaunieboy51369]

I am an ex Christian turned Noahide. This wonderful man is the reason. Thank you Rabbi Singer. ❤

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Baruch HaShem! ✡️❤️

[@onejohn2.26.]

You could have and should have maintained your belief in Yeshua as the Messiah and still kept the Torah

[@AdaraBalabusta]

@@onejohn2.26. The Torah is only for Jewish people. Jesus/Yeshua is not a messiah, let alone the ultimate messiah. If you worship Jesus as a deity, please repent of idolatry. If your mother is a Gentile, you are a Noahide and are subject to the seven Noahide laws.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

@eminikol3014 The general rule is that it is obligatory for a Gentile to learn the seven commandments that he is commanded to do, and he should learn them very well, to know what is permitted and prohibited for him. He is permitted to learn them even in a way of "delving into them," meaning deeply learning to understand the reasons and the details within the Noahide Code.

[@sub7se7en]

Your next step is Islam inshaAllah.

[@Lv-1rb]

As a Muslim, I love listening to Rabbi Singer. You can tell that he is a man who loves God. Thank you for teaching and reminding people about the kindness and mercy of God.

[@heezyhines2209]

🤲🤲🤲☝️🕋

[@heezyhines2209]

@@Dru517 Yea & he also has no problem with us believing Jesus (pbuh) & Muhammad (pbuh) are messengers & that we pray to the same God & to them we are Noahides who don't worship Idolatry, Now I wish we was guided & accepted him but I enjoy the channel because I still like seeing people's points of views on things even if I'm not in full and or any agreement .. It also proves more & more that Christianity is by no means I agreement with Tenahk & me & my friend's/fam of different faiths have these discussions

[@nob8503]

@@heezyhines2209real religious Jews respect Islam, maybe not politically but religiously we are in agreement and respect . Fake secular Zionists or laymen Jews falsely attribute lies to Islam to please/manipulate hateful christians. RabbiTovia regardless of his politics (which he is hardly ever) is a man of God . Truly fearful and devoted to God. He lived in Indonesia for over a decade so he was able to learn Islam well. You have my respect rabbi all love and guidance from Allah

[@Scalpaxos]

@@nob8503 What lies?

[@ElijahEnochYHWH]

Thank you for showing me the errors of my ways. I will no longer use the term “Old Testament.” Also I loved your dialog about being so welcomed by Muslims in Indonesia. So much love.

[@TekkenLegacy-gamex]

I’am really happy not Many channels are like yours! I’am muslim yet some Jewish group are rare but yeah you adress the issues throw all these scriptures in Bible, That’s why I’am still subscribed to your channel ❤☺️ // greetings from Sweden and my background is Pakistani baloch.

[@heezyhines2209]

As salaamu alaikum wa rahman tu Allahi wa barakatu 🤲🤲🤲☝️🕋

[@darrelsabadera3395]

Thanks Rabbi Tovia for the words of enlightenment,Hashem barak you and keep you safe.

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Amen! ✡️❤️

[@Days6281]

A smile slowly appears on my face every time a video of Rabbi Tovia comes up in my feed. As a muslim I love your work Rabbi.

[@GerardoMagnano]

What are you waiting to embrace the G’d of Israel?

[@What2make2day]

​@@GerardoMagnanoBecause we don't beleive that God was exculsively the God of Israel (the prophet, not the T-state), but he was the God of all humankind. Which makes Islam a more logical, humanitarian and ethnically inclusive faith. I beleive that Mr Tovia is what the Jews should aspire to be.

[@GerardoMagnano]

@@What2make2day where do you get that from? G’d is the G’d of all Creation. Jews and non-Jews. Islam is idolatry based that they neglect the Torah, which is the word of Hashem. Embrace the Seven Laws of Noach.

[@Aurora_Angelique]

@@GerardoMagnano Which Torah? The corrupted one today?

[@llaka79]

@@GerardoMagnanoIslam isn’t considered idolatry it’s wrong in other ways but it’s not idolatry

[@jamesfields2249]

Shalom Rabbi Singer ..Great scholarly lecture of basic Torah. The atrocities of Christianity is truly unspeakable. All the murders, lynchings and worldly corruption. I could go on. Keep serving as a light to nations..🕊️

[@mariareyneke9953]

❤ baruch Hashem thank you again for so many revelation.

[@PardesiBabux]

You are loved by all people who worship ONE G-d. I am muslim and admire your "bad" habit of telling the truth as is, often bluntly, in plain English.

[@stoggsherfnik4569]

Because Jewish theology is deep and, lovely, Rabbi Singer never addresses the fact Mohammad added and, took away words & practice of Torah, rejects the Original Testament, and a managed as much if not :more antisemitism compared to the Christian New Testament. This rabbi is gracious not to point it out, allows the obvious (see above) to discovered by the Muslim individual despite the unlikely odds against it due intrinsic intractability within the Koran. His Indonesian experience, brings hope… it’s a different place than Pakistan, - country where Rabbi Singes life would be imperiled. I don’t expect he will bring up the slaughter of Timor Christians, referring them into demographic insignificance.i

[@PardesiBabux]

Very good, our dear Rabi does not bring up East Timur but will you bring up the slaughter of Jews, constant persecutions, deportations and even attempted genocide of past 2000 yeas of Chritian Europe triggered and encouraged by ALL Christian theologians taking their guidance from the "Gospels". All of your so called Church fathers hated Jews. It is very difficult to guage as to who hated Jews more, from Tertulian, to Luther to the Pope during 2nd world war.

[@msa11387]

@@stoggsherfnik4569your opinion with all respect that this response is completely irrelevant and not correct please check the facts of the world as well as history then express the truth!

[@stoggsherfnik4569]

@@msa11387Ok , how? Specifically what do you think i wrote is “irrelevant”?

[@PardesiBabux]

@stoggsherfnik4569 So Rabi did not bring up East Timor, OK. Would you bring up the two thousand years of persecutions, torture, and deportations, and even attempted genocide of Jewish people at the hand of Christian Europe? All Chritian theologians were anitsemites to their core and therefore general public as well as rulers and kings took their guidance ftom their hateful writings and committed all sort of attrocities against Jews just because they refused the Cross and decided to be faithful to ONE God.

[@Yehonatan613]

jeZeus: “Dont suppose that ive come to bring peace..I DID NOT come to bring peace, but a sword!" Mathew10:34 Actual mashiach: "...he will proclaim peace to the nations" Zechariah9:10 "he'll settle disputes for nations..nationd wont lift sword..nor will they learn of war anymore" Isaiah2:4

[@AdaraBalabusta]

You are correct. In the same passage in Matthew, J-dude also says that people will disrespect their parents for his sake! Heaven forbid such a thing should ever occur!

[@elmajraz6019]

Open your heart to the Islamic Isa/Yeshua, not the New Testament Jesus.

[@Tys-k5o]

Very correct dear Jehonatan 🌷 🌷 🇮🇱🇩🇪🇮🇱

[@elmajraz6019]

@Raizel613 no, it's clearly said that the Prophet like Moses (Deut 18:18) shall appear from Paran and bring a new law (Deut 33:1-2). That is clearly not Jesus, it's Muhammad. And what do you mean end of 2nd Temple Period? In 70 AD, after Jesus? That's when it's closed and completed? Not after Malachi?

[@Yehonatan613]

@@elmajraz6019 The masada scrolls and DSS which predate even the birth of jesus by over 100 years, prove that the torah of today is the same as the torah 2 millenia ago, and more than that, in the hadiths, mohamed himself says he believed in the torah of his day, and the hadiths are hasan. But, the koran actually does have diff versions and they contain variances of words and spelling too, not just qira'at, i can show you actual differences in spelling and meaning of words between the warsh version and hafs version. There is only ONE version of the Torah on the entire planet, and its been around way longer than ur koran.

[@peachlilac925]

So Good! I love hearing these discussions please keep doing them!😁 Thank You All!

[@donovanwint-im2ql]

Among the best of Rabbi Singers presentations. G-D'S Blessings.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

When Cain was tempted to sin against his brother, God came to him and said to him, "if you will improve yourself, you will be forgiven ..." As an eternal lesson for all generations, God instructed Cain about the ability to repent, which is in the hands of every person: to repent and return to God at any time one desires and makes the decision to do so, and God will forgive him.

[@jamalatmaca8071]

Then the Lord said to Cain, 'Why are you angry? Why is your face downcast? If you do what is right, will you not be accepted? But if you do not do what is right, sin is crouching at your door; it desires to have you, but you must rule over it. Genesis 4:6-7

[@yyyytttt7]

Much love tobia from a muslim.

[@janishart5128]

Thank you for listening to Rabbi Singer's teachings!! May God/Allah bless you!!

[@Cobra-gl7or]

The Quran says Jesus is the Messiah lol

[@AdaraBalabusta]

@@Cobra-gl7or We can agree to disagree on that. The Muslims do not worship J-dude as a deity; that is the important concern.

[@Cobra-gl7or]

@@AdaraBalabusta Allah and Muhammad is not coming back to judge mankind. Jesus will be the one who will come back to judge mankind on earth and only God judges mankind.

[@AdaraBalabusta]

@@Cobra-gl7or No. You have been deceived, along with billions of others.

[@ItsDeepakhere]

It was Amazing to see a Christian agreeing that God can forgive sins when someone asks with grnuine repentance ... At 39:00...Thank you Rabbi Tovia..It it took him 2 to 3 minutes of struggling to say that....And when God can do that then who need Jesus? ...Why mediator between God & His Creation? Christianity started with Paul ...And not with Jesus.

[@76olimpo]

thank you Rabbi

[@LoreneRaeWard]

I ❤ listening and learning from you! Baruch HaShem! Todah Rabah Rabbi Tovia Singer!

[@saidzouhri8524]

Thank you Tovia singer

[@elizabethbooth5446]

Thank you rabbi

[@milkamilosevic9626]

Yom tov rabbi to you and to your entire family,(aspecialy to your dear father)🙌💪💙

[@yhwhreigns]

Thank you Tovia. Really good video.

[@charleslitherbury8600]

Isaiah 45:22 If an angel came to me and said my wife is going to give birth to the messiah, why do they seem so surprised in Mark 3 20-21? 20 Then Jesus entered a house, and again a crowd gathered, so that he and his disciples were not even able to eat. 21 When his family[a] heard about this, they went to take charge of him, for they said, “He is out of his mind.” Did they forget he was born immaculately and that they had spoken with an Angel? Rabbi Singer is a great teacher! God Bless!

[@georgestathe385]

The apostles denied him after he raised Lazarus and Jesus was perfect the rest are not and do not understand his ways since they are not their way.

[@AdaraBalabusta]

@@georgestathe385 That is a fictional story. Obey the Noahide laws.

[@AdaraBalabusta]

The entirety of the “nt” is a fiction.

[@Cobra-gl7or]

@@AdaraBalabusta Do you believe you deserve to be in heaven with God while Jesus is there looking at you?

[@AdaraBalabusta]

@@Cobra-gl7or If Jesus existed, he was a human being just as you and I are human beings. If Jesus existed, he would be sickened that people have deified him. If Jesus existed and if we both merit a place in the World to Come, yes, I would be entirely comfortable being there with him. He might even thank me for telling the truth about him. ✡️❤️

[@seekers-of-righteousness]

Baruch Hashem!! Truly inspiring! Your metaphors are so powerful! You always inspire me to bring your powerful lectures to life through animations 🥹✨

[@mooshei8165]

The New Testament and the Jews Torah (old testament) don’t mix.

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Correct. ✡️❤️

[@Crusader-George]

rabbinic judaism is an absolute mockery of the Old Law, here's the evidence

[@Crusader-George]

Yoma 39b👇 תָּנוּ רַבָּנַן: אַרְבָּעִים שָׁנָה קוֹדֶם חוּרְבַּן הַבַּיִת לֹא הָיָה גּוֹרָל עוֹלֶה בְּיָמִין, וְלֹא הָיָה לָשׁוֹן שֶׁל זְהוֹרִית מַלְבִּין, וְלֹא הָיָה נֵר מַעֲרָבִי דּוֹלֵק. The Sages taught: During the tenure of Shimon HaTzaddik, the lot for God always arose in the High Priest’s right hand; after his death, it occurred only occasionally; but during the *forty years prior to the destruction of the Second Temple, the lot for God did not arise in the High Priest’s right hand at all. So too, the strip of crimson wool that was tied to the head of the goat that was sent to Azazel did not turn white, and the westernmost lamp of the candelabrum did not burn continually.* wow, I wonder, what did the Jews committed 40 years before the 70 ad (the destruction of the temple) that makes God to despise their sacrifice and abolished their sacrifice, through the Romans eventually? rejection of Jesus Christ.

[@Crusader-George]

Yoma 39b👇 תָּנוּ רַבָּנַן: אַרְבָּעִים שָׁנָה קוֹדֶם חוּרְבַּן הַבַּיִת לֹא הָיָה גּוֹרָל עוֹלֶה בְּיָמִין, וְלֹא הָיָה לָשׁוֹן שֶׁל זְהוֹרִית מַלְבִּין, וְלֹא הָיָה נֵר מַעֲרָבִי דּוֹלֵק. The Sages taught: During the tenure of Shimon HaTzaddik, the lot for God always arose in the High Priest’s right hand; after his death, it occurred only occasionally; but during the *forty years prior to the destruction of the Second Temple, the lot for God did not arise in the High Priest’s right hand at all. So too, the strip of crimson wool that was tied to the head of the goat that was sent to Azazel did not turn white, and the westernmost lamp of the candelabrum did not burn continually.* wow, I wonder, what did the Jews committed 40 years before the 70 ad (the destruction of the temple) that makes God to despise their sacrifice and abolished their sacrifice, through the Romans eventually? crucifixion of Jesus Christ

[@Sigurd-r5]

Yes. Let us agree to disagree. No wars needed.

[@melodie-allynbenezra8956]

At 44:14 - It occurs to me that Rabbi Singer and Alex are having two separate conversations. The Rabbi is asking that, if God can forgive all by Himself, what is Jesus needed for. Alex is talking about activating the second covenant, which Rabbi Singer has already explained isn't a New Testament or the like. At this point, they are speaking past each other.

[@ahmedelnagarmd]

Baruch HaShem Le'Olam .. Love from fellow muslim

[@josephgerard5473]

On this subject, I heartily recommend a track I discovered by accident (it appeared in my 'recommended' feed) by a British band called UNIT. The track is A Tribute To The Israeli Defence Force and it is excellent - tuneful and forceful without being bombastic combined with a lovely lyric. I know next to nothing about the group but on investigation I see they've recorded a whole batch of Jewish related tracks such as Pesach, Yom Kippur, Bar Mitzvah, Israel Is Real, The 613 Mitzvot and probably others I don’t know about yet. Some of them feature Rabbi Moshe Bryski which is definitely a recommendation in itself.

[@AhmadWafee-KL]

Salam and good day from 🇲🇾. Thank you

[@heezyhines2209]

Shalom alaikum from a non perfect muslim who enjoys this channel & how u point out the obvious 🤲🤲🤲☝️🕋

[@amy.1622]

Love this, Rabbi!! ❤

[@GilbertGreich]

Todah Rabba!

[@ecomandurban7183]

Baruch Hashem!!💯💯💯💯

[@scallywag325]

It's the Original Testament, not the old Testament as christians call it.

[@startrackertrax6493]

Dear Tovia with respect as a christian how do i know you are right. im only askng as im open to what you say but due to a lifetime in christianity its super hard to just throw it away. G-d bless you

[@bigtomboye]

@startrackertrax6493 Yes it is hard, so hard, to throw it all away. 😢 Im not even a Christian but have read the Gospels and Quran and i bitterly rue and lament the time, and especially lament the years of mysterious confusion 😕 🫤 😶‍🌫️ TBH i feel self pity and deep depression over it🫥⏳️ So i totally hear you and reach out to you as a fellow channel listener, God bless you in this wrestle 🙏

[@armidaainsworth8843]

Keep listening to him. What changed me is the virgin birth story.

[@meempujaronconviolencia]

Hi Rabbi, As Alex I believe the same thing. however, for your question about what do you need Jesus for the sin of forgivenss, I see it in this way. When Jews go to the DOME and entered the thumb they pray to God for the merits of the Patriarch and Matriarchs. I hope this allow you to understand what I believe Alex is trying to convey. In our case we are asking for the merit of Jesus. There are many like him. I myself abandoned Christianity. I am a believer who follow the Hebrew roots of Jesus.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

Gentiles are obligated to follow the 7 Noahide laws.

[@meempujaronconviolencia]

​@@hrvatskinoahid1048 disagree. Gentiles are not obligated. They do it out of love for the Lord. THey can also convert to Judaism if they strongly believe in their hearts that is the right path

[@chanitalevitz4945]

No we do NOT pray in the merit of the patriarchs. Rather Hashem promised them an eternal nation that He has a special relationship.with

[@leongreen5332]

11.24. I would love to know if that Synagogue in Indonesia still exists. What a beacon for Jewish-Muslim coexistence!

[@m.c.rabbit7257]

Yes it still exist

[@ServantoftheInfiniteTruth]

I am putting this comment here so in the future when someone responds to my comment and likes my comment, i am reminded to look back at this video

[@perdue6709]

That’s what I’m also doing right now

[@ServantoftheInfiniteTruth]

@@perdue6709 awesome here is a reminder

[@perdue6709]

@@ServantoftheInfiniteTruth touché sir

[@ServantoftheInfiniteTruth]

@@perdue6709 Don't worry, I didn't forget about you bo bo

[@ingridleeshueling232]

I fully understand what Rabbi Singer is saying and, his question is would God forgive a person if he repents and ask for forgiveness? In my opinion, I do. Then, why do we need the mediator Jesus or any of the saints or even Mary to go to God on our behalf?

[@goldengun9970]

You dont need any of them to go on your behalf.

[@ingridleeshueling232]

Totally agree.

[@stevenmicahnik4403]

Rabbi Singer is a fantastic rebbe.

[@charlesoba51]

I became a Noahide because of Tovia Singers' debates and going back to the Tanahk starting from Genesis. Whilst Islam has a true concept of G-d, but the fact they believe in Jesus as the Messiah, you know it's a fake religion. May the Holy One blessed be He bless Tovia Singer for his wonderful work 🙏

[@charlesoba51]

@hassanabdur-rahman1559 If the Christians NT was a stand-alone text saying Jesus is their Messiah, there wouldn't be an issue but because they're claiming prophecies from the Tanach that's how we know you and the Christians are wrong because the Messiah is meant to bring world peace and more hence we know he's not the Messiah which means there's an error in you Quran. In other words, G-d does not make kindergarten mistakes. This is why I believe your text is not Holy.

[@leongreen5332]

I don't think Muslims think Jesus was the Messiah. You're getting it mixed up with the Virgin birth, which they do accept.

[@AL-ss5wq]

Muslims accept Jesus may peace be upon him as the Messiah( chosen/anointed as the last prophet sent to the Jews). We accept it not because it says so in the Bible but because it says so in the Quran and because we have independent evidence that the Quran is the word of GOD and that Mohammed may peace be upon him is his last and final messenger to Humankind. I recommend you look into the Channel of Paul who was in the video: Blogging Theology. I also recommend you look at the Muslim Lantern channel and you will find out why Islam (submission to the will of GOD) is not a fake religion but the only religion that all the prophets since Adam followed including Noah, Abraham, Moses and Jesus may peace be upon them all.

[@charlesoba51]

@AL-ss5wq Messiah means anointed. Who anointed him? Jesus is nowhere in Tanahk, sir, unless I missed him somewhere.

[@AL-ss5wq]

⁠@@charlesoba51I was merely fleshing out the definition of Messiah that Muslims use because if you say to a Christian the word Messiah they will for some reason link divinity to it whereas the word just means chosen or annointed. Cyrus, David… have been called Messiah. So the word itself is not that important. As for where it says Jesus is the Messiah, Muslims don’t rely on the Hebrew Bible or the New Testament. We rely on the Quran, because we have evidence that shows that it is from GOD and it is preserved. You cannot say that the Hebrew bible is preserved nor is the New Testament. Anyway this whole thing about Messiah and Messianic age is not that important in Islam. What’s important is GOD and submitting to GOD. I really advise you to take a look at the Muslim Lantern Channel on KZbin, perhaps you won’t be interested but maybe you’ll understand better what 2 billion people believe.

[@atharbasit9223]

🇵🇰 very 1st passport was given to Leopole Weiss, a polish person who became ☪️, served as pakistan representative at UN, wrote a book " Road to Makkah".

[@ingridleeshueling232]

I'm throughly enjoying the discussion.

[@zdzislawmeglicki2262]

How is it that the Sadducees and the Pharisees would differ so much on religious fundamentals of the first century Judaism, while both worshipped the same Torah?

[@brucheweinberger6863]

The Sadducees rejected the Oral tradition on the written Torah.

[@789truth]

@17:15 How can God's living word disappear when it is forever living? He is The Beginning and The End. Old or New Testaments in The Holy Bible will forever live because it is God's word.

[@JosephMage]

Baruch HaShem 🙏🏽✡️🌈

[@ruslans1570]

Hi Rabbi Singer I love your work. I bought your books and I even consider translating some to posts in Russian. Just one remark. We can't ignore the elephant in the room. In our time. I'd prefer to be targeted for conversion to Christian faith, rather than targeted for beheading. I don't believe that Christian missionaries are an existential threat to Jews and Judaism. Radical Islam, however, is such a threat. It would be interesting to dive into Islamic scripture, maybe along with a moderate Muslim companion, to bring to light moderate interpretations. For instance, if we learn from "akidat Yitzhak" (or Ishmael for Muslims) that Almighty doesn't need us to sacrifice our children in his name, the conclusion should be that you cannot wage a holy war where children are used as human shields. Thank you

[@avrahamshusteris8271]

You mentioned that the Torah rejects vicarious atonement. How do you explain Rebecca's statement to Jacob that he should trick his father Isaac to get the blessing, and she will take the sin upon herself?

[@tatootomy3044]

First: the title is wrong (Muslims, Christians, and a rabbi discuss sin and atonement!) The correct title is (Muslims, Christians, and Jews discuss sin and atonement!). Second: With all due respect to the other debaters, they are poor in their religious knowledge, and you must debate with a scholar to gain the full benefit. The two are not convincing, their talk is illogical, and they defend their religion in a funny way. They should read and learn about the religion they want to discuss before they speak. Third: as a Jew, do you believe that Jewish people follow the Ten Commandments literally? Fourth: of the twelve Jewish tribes, how many are remaining and, which ones do you follow? Fifth: Who are the (Ashkenazi Jews) and where did they come from? Sixth: Among those twelve tribes, which tribe is right in following the teachings of Judaism, the Orthodox Jew (Haredim) or the liberal Jew (the seculars)? Finally, is there a relationship between Zionism and Judaism? Jesus is the KING. Kindest Regards,

[@paulawallace8784]

As Jeremiah prophesied, the Gentiles will come to see that they have inherited only Lies, Emptiness in which there is nothing of any avail! Christianity = Last Beast = no avail

[@heezyhines2209]

How? Respectfully

[@heezyhines2209]

​@@paulawallace8784 Do u believe us as Muslims worship the same God?

[@lucisauctoradvocatus]

I'm surprised to see blogging theology on here

[@lauranell2978]

The people of America!

[@LoboAtwater-o8h]

What decade are we in? The 21st century?! Not the 13th century!?

[@ibrahimelmasry-z3k]

حوار جميل 🌹🌹

[@MESivasYldzeli]

İ have a question about a Quran verses were Moses (pbuh) had a friendship with a mysterious figure..first Moses asked God about is or there was a person with more wisedom and knowledge then him…and God answers Yes and says you wil meet him soon…well is there a same story in Torah or in Midrash teachings ?…

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

Moses is the ultimate and supreme prophet for all time.

[@MESivasYldzeli]

@@hrvatskinoahid1048 it is not about supremacy of a ululazm prophet.. and the mysterious figure that Quran mentioned here is not Munammed (pbuh) if you think so…and yes Muhammed (pbuh) is the final prophet /messenger of God…other prophets with name or not mentioned by name ..are chosen by God and have done their job in guidance…i have no classification tool…what i know Muhammed (pbuh) is His most beloved creation and His beloved messenger…all the praises on him…Amen 🙏🏻

[@MESivasYldzeli]

And on the Others well…with no exception 🙏🏻

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

@@MESivasYldzeli Your hero is a false prophet.

[@abdulkarimahmed6161]

Love u Rabbi Btw I am Muslim❤

[@janishart5128]

Thank you for listening to Rabbi Singer's teachings!! May God/Allah bless you!!

[@Cobra-gl7or]

Allah is the Lord of Saudi Arabia not the God of Israel. Allah is a pagan moon God ☪️ that's why you have the crescent moon symbol above every mosque. With all due respect!

[@PSYKSY_]

​@Cobra-gl7or Allah said in Quran he is the Lord of all worlds but the God of The Torah is a national god also there was no Saudi 14000 years ago

[@PSYKSY_]

The crescent moon represent the month of Ramadan in the lunar calendar in Islam we use the lunar calendar pagan Arabs didn't not worship the moon

[@erasethehate5616]

​​​@@Cobra-gl7oryou're uninformed, ask Rabbi Singer. Look at his videos. He says Muslims & Jews have the same God. Only the Christians have a different concept of God

[@JoelWeingarten-m2x]

It’s amazing that all this smarty's are sitting in front of shelf's of all types of books and Rabbi Singer has all this info in his head.

[@thefnaffan2]

And to think, I went from Atheist to, I'm really not sure. By listening to this channel.

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Baruch HaShem! If you mother is not Jewish, you are Noahide. Welcome home! ❤

[@zack256300]

​@@AdaraBalabustawhat about if only my father is jew..😅

[@janishart5128]

That's GREAT!! May God continue guide and bless you, and give your much courage and strength on your spiritual journey!!

[@janishart5128]

@@zack256300: Then you are not considered Jewish and would have to either convert to Judaism, or follow the Noahide Laws. Jewishness is through the mother and tribal affiliation is through the father. You may also want to research your ancestry.

[@zack256300]

@@janishart5128 Thanks for the info..🙏

[@edsanjenis9416]

If a person wants to understand God, you need to read the whole Old Testament, and by doing so, you get understanding and knowledge. Job 16: 21 I need someone to mediates between God and me, as a person mediates between friends. If Job felt he needed someone to mediates between God and him; just like a lawyer is used when we go before a judge.

[@pisces1821]

I just compared Isiah 2:4 from my Jewish Study Bible to my KJV Bible and NLT study bible and it's the same....trying to understand why Rabbi Singer says this passage never makes it into the christian bible???

[@midwestairway]

Christian's fixation on the JEWISH messiah is mind numbing, jews know who their messiah will be, stop telling them it's Jesus

[@oracleofaltoona]

It is weird.

[@KathleenGuloy]

Where are the Noahide laws in the Bible?

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

It is explained in Tractate Sanhedrin 56b that all of the Noahide Commandments can be exegetically derived from Genesis 2:16, "And the Lord God commanded the man, saying, ...," which was stated to Adam in the Garden of Eden on the day of his creation.

[@lauranell2978]

Maybe they should reconsider !

[@المرتدالفخور]

Proud ex Muslim turned Noahide

[@saimbhat6243]

You mean murtad!??? But I don't see anything special about it nor any sense to it, why would you then just not convert to be the real deal, to adopt Judaism? Or do you want to keep a basic minimum ethical bounds on you and a basic minimum leash on your carnal desires and yet be assured that you will be among righteous? Have the cake and eat it too? You don't want to tailor make yourself to be among righteous but to tailor make your God to be among righteous!?

[@xepturate]

@@ישוע repent from idolatry and the worship of a man?

[@1sosukeaizen1]

Why do you stick to the title Muslim though😂? If you leave Islam then just forget it

[@avalerie4467]

Welcome. Once you find Torah and the 7 Mitzvot, life becomes so much sweeter. Glad to have you with us💞

[@janishart5128]

@@1sosukeaizen1: The person said "Ex Muslim turned Noahide", so they're not 'sticking to the title Muslim'! They just said "Muslim" as a reference to their past!

[@LoboAtwater-o8h]

Coming out of slavery here in the world created life changing products, services and businesses right here. And we are not in one history book. Blood transfusion, Glory be to Our Creator!? Stoplight, Elevator and we are in American history books as a blacksmith?! That’s a joke, right. All praises to The Most High!?!

[@us.nyc.10011]

Tovia please get some heavyweight debaters (no disrespect to the 3 gentlemen)

[@julianmontoya428]

GOD existed in the past! GOD exists now!, and God will always exist in the future!, may everyone who calls upon the true God, be heard ! May every moment of your life be blessed!

[@m.c.rabbit7257]

Torah is for Jews Gospel is for christian Quran is for muslim No one can have right interpret other scripture if their not in what scripture What has been given

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

Torah has 613 commandments for Jews and the 7 for Gentiles.

[@paulawallace8784]

As Jeremiah prophesied, the Gentiles will come to see that they have inherited only Lies, Emptiness in which there is nothing of any avail!

[@mightymadrid]

why are muslims not considered a sect of Christianity if they also believe him to be a sort of messiah that has a role in the the future of the new Jerusalem.

[@789truth]

It's just fascinating to me that some people cannot grasp the idea that Jesus is "Christ" made in flesh, to be sacrificed to save mankind from sin and gift them with eternal life. That The Father, The Son, and The Holy Spirit is a Tri-filiation, an absolute trinitarian source of ONE innascible-insecable self-existent, omnipotent, omniscient, and omnipresent absolute power of love, life and creation itself. He is God and he can do anything because he is The ONE and only.

[@stans1058]

How does he qualify to be from the house of King David?

[@789truth]

​@@stans1058 Jesus is described as royalty in the Gospel of Luke 1:30 - 33 30 But the angel said to her, “Do not be afraid, Mary; you have found favor with God. 31 You will conceive and give birth to a son, and you are to call him Jesus. 32 He will be great and will be called the Son of the Most High. The Lord God will give him the throne of his father David, 33 and he will reign over Jacob’s descendants forever; his kingdom will never end.”

[@aA-lx6ji]

Off the topic...Rabbi any idea why there wasnt anything written abt Jesus when he was 1 yr old to 33 yrs old....Im sure many would recognised him if he was a "God" during his time.

[@ToviaSinger1]

There is a brief segment at the end of Luke 2 that contains a story about Jesus' supposed visit to the temple when he was 12.

[@JosephMage]

Baruch HaShem w🙏🏽✡️🌈

[@MESivasYldzeli]

My last comment is not being send by KZbin…strange 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@AdaraBalabusta]

There are glitches occasionally. Possibly due to high traffic re the Presidential Debate?

[@MESivasYldzeli]

@@AdaraBalabustaWell not everybody is American …Rabbi Tovia’s message is way important then that circus show…🙂

[@AdaraBalabusta]

@@MESivasYldzeli True that. But lots of people worldwide watched the debate.

[@MESivasYldzeli]

@@AdaraBalabusta 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@mariannarain4870]

Rabbi, I don't think Jesus wanted to die!? And I don't think He wants to pay for anyones sins. It's about OBEDIENCE to our Heavenly Father!!! He came with a mission and He fulfilled it and He will come again!

[@stans1058]

It flys in the face of Ezekiel. How does he comes from the house of King David.

[@LoboAtwater-o8h]

We can visit it.

[@LoboAtwater-o8h]

It has everything you need to know. The messiah has not come. Isreal was the messiah for the whole world. We can pass away?! But His world will not. There is only one Creator and he one more time Does not change.

[@claudioas]

that boy will end up noahide or jewish, i made the same path

[@nicolediamond8273]

Jesus did NOT die for our individual sins. We die for our own individual sins. Jesus did die for our inherited weakness towards sinning. He died to replace the firstborn, Adam who chose to sin, distorting his once perfect image of God. That's why Jesus is called the second Adam. He replaces Adam genetically. This atoned for us and buys us a resurrection. Jesus also suffered and died as men do in order to prove his loyalty to God and to fulfill the requirements of Psalm 82 to inherit God's throne.

[@lauranell2978]

We are human !

[@AdaraBalabusta]

Yes, and most of us are Noahides. ✡️❤️

[@mooshei8165]

Not when you’re entitled at work. Saying we are human is pretty bias.

[@mooshei8165]

I shut my Human Resources at work when they say “we’re all human being.” You better say that wisely.

[@janishart5128]

​@@mooshei8165: ??!! What is "entitled at work."??!!

[@mooshei8165]

@@janishart5128 they think I’m suppose to be scared of them when they say, “we’re all just human beings.” I’m I suppose to be scared of you just because you have a title? We’re just human beings?

[@lauranell2978]

Universities and the American school system commercially

[@veteran2x]

❤

[@wildwomanofthewoods]

I reject Paul’s understanding of the original teachings

[@Nudnik1]

They may be considered " Ben Noachides" ? No idolatry avoda zora . תודה רבה שלום

[@AdaraBalabusta]

@@ישוע Anyone whose mother is not Jewish is Noahide and is subject to the seven Noahide laws.

[@hrvatskinoahid1048]

The main doctrine of Islam is not idolatry, since it calls for belief in one God. However, it is forbidden to uphold an innovated religion that people introduced after Mount Sinai.

[@Nudnik1]

@@ישוע "Unitarians... Muslims" " Righteous gentiles" as per Chazzal Sages. No avoda zora no man God idol trinity human sacrifice calvary. We can pray in Mosques and have done so in Morocco and history.

[@LoboAtwater-o8h]

We are waking up right here in America. I have made my choice!? Tora and the Tenak. Peace

[@lauranell2978]

What is school and Hebrew Schul. it means semen, seed of consciousness, where does our consciousness come from, purest thought? Torah!

[@LoboAtwater-o8h]

There is always gonna be Tora and Tenak people. Until the end of time.

[@Samsunga14-pg2du]

Bog Isus Krist 12 only 1 G.d. amen 🙏

[@lauranell2978]

Communities and a nation

[@Ar_tistt]

As a muslim, I am a fan of Paul. Paul Williams of Blogging Theology, of corse. 😊

[@XRay-T50]

Paul Williams the gay Muslim that's apostated from Islam 5x times that guy lol 😆

[@Ar_tistt]

@@XRay-T50 One day you will regret that comment. Make sure that that day is in this current life.

[@XRay-T50]

@@Ar_tistt Regret for stating the truth lol do some investigating.

[@LoboAtwater-o8h]

We expect it. The only ones who knew who we were are the Jewish people. They were there when Rome came down an earlier that that?! I don’t know all the facts, but I talking about changing America back to their Creator from the beginning. Not Rome or Greeks. The Creator.

[@HisMessenger-wf5qd]

Are Jews and Christians two totally different families, or are they a part of the same family?

[@paulawallace8784]

Jews and the Gentiles who are fortunate enough to be instructed by them worship only THE CREATOR, THE ETERNAL ONE, THE ALEPH AND THE TAV, EHYEH ASHER EHYEH/I WILL BE WHAT I WILL BE, to WHOM EVERY KNEE SHALL KNEEL, EVERY TONGUE SHALL SWEAR!

[@paulawallace8784]

The False Teachings of Jesus/Cult of Christianity brought MORE HEATHEN IDOLATRY TO MANKIND, for the Devotees of Jesus have spread and engaged in the Idolatrous worship of Jesus, a carnal idol of flesh made in the Image of Man, a Heathen Trinity of Man made false deities, Jesus' mother, other dead people, Angels, Paintings, Statues of Wood and Stone, a dirty painted sheet, crackers and wooden sticks, all of which are ABOMINATIONS to the CREATOR, WHO Commanded that HE alone is to be worshiped!

[@HisMessenger-wf5qd]

@@paulawallace8784 Are Jews and Christians members of the same family?

[@laanaa26]

What is Gentiles, and who are they because some Christians call themselves Gentiles even though they call Jesus God!? ​@paulawallace8784

[@janishart5128]

@@HisMessenger-wf5qd: Christians would need to check into their ancestries! Some (a LOT, in fact!) are actually Jews who were converted to Christianity, and are unaware of their heritage. This is why Rabbis often advise callers to the show, to check into their ancestries.

[@m.c.rabbit7257]

O israel remember our god Is One(echad) !! Qul huwwallah u ahad "Say (O prophet) he is Allah the One and Indivisible"

[@freedom4all581]

🎉 👏👏👏👏

[@LoboAtwater-o8h]

I will not share my covenant with anyone else?!

[@lauranell2978]

You are dealing with people who only live for pleasure, they will harm the elderly , children and families

[@raydanabe]

Are we not born to please the creator? When a mortal acknowledges that humans are but only mortal and make mistakes but consistently seek ways to please the creator till ones life ends on earth. Is that not living for pleasure in order to please the Creator?