My Top 20 Starkid Singers

~ Everything belongs to Team Starkid or TinCanBros ~
This was so hard to make. Feel free to comment your rankings!
Here are the clips that weren't from a musical:
Brian Rosenthal - Listen To Your Heart: • Video
Joe Walker and Clark Baxtresser - I Was: • Starkid @ Leaky Con Lo...

[@izzyy404]

#1: Dylan Saunders *the duck is pleased*

[@Elv1ra_-]

You spoiled it ☹️

[@stefanieclarezzepenaflorid9902]

@@Elv1ra_- I mean its pretty obvious If dylan wasnt no. 1, then it would be jaime

[@mylahobbit1815]

i really love how we as a fanbase all just collectively go 'look, we can all have own separate opinions on shit, but jaime and dylan are the best singers'

[@catz2701]

it's always Dylan, Jaime, and Robert

[@radxianixe]

that's why i feel so alone when that's not my opinion 😶 i mean, that's just MY opinion haha. i love both of them with all my heart, they're so talented and they have the power to make me smile. no hate to them.

[@omumafu6346]

@@radxianixe lauren, mariah and jaime are the best in my opinion..

[@k0pstl939]

Imo jaime Lauren dylan Robert and jeff( not in that order necessarily)

[@val8869]

So we’re just gonna sleep on Brittney, AJ, and Brosenthal? Smh

[@the_duckislord]

I assume Dylan Saunders is first. Edit: I was correct.

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

Tzz spoilers👀 but who are we kidding, i think dylan as number 1 is a given

[@daniellevanrhijn1822]

I love the fact that it doesn't matter who lists these lists, everybody just knows that jaime is 2 and Dylan 1, and honestly, it shouldn't be any other way

[@queenelizabifandfrenz1951]

D van Daantje and Robert Manion 3rd I mean have you heard him he’s like a deep voiced angel

[@daniellevanrhijn1822]

@@queenelizabifandfrenz1951 I know right! He's freakin amazing. Tgwdlm really did him right

[@tityajack]

Late to this but Mariah joined the chat As 5th

[@screechingbirbs6406]

But Jamie has a lot more versatility and because she has like 3.6-3.9 octaves I personally think that she’s top plus she manages to overcome a lot of the problems that Dylan has and I prefer her voice

[@morgrugyn]

@@queenelizabifandfrenz1951 And lauren as 4th tbh

[@ra_arcade2966]

im so sad that roberts "he fUCKED A TIGERRR" wasn't here

[@beee2034]

Truly a shame

[@aileenrubio56]

But I’m glad his mega swinging hips were

[@calicoCatkind]

@@IwillrememberAchmed you forgot achmed.

[@mitzkonic5024]

I was a bit disappointed with Rachael's ranking. Yes there were a few shaky moments but overall a great singer.

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

yeah i know it kinda broke my heart to give her that ranking.. but there were often like 4-5 people i thought were equally good but i had to rank them somehow :(

[@rebornmomma129]

A random person PEOPLE SLEEP ON HER AND IT MAKES ME MAD

[@emmaoneill3154]

She's really good in Firebringer and Trail to Oregon. In Twisted it sounds like she's pushing a bit.

[@youruethedaycarlyshay]

She carried emotion so well with her voice in tto

[@rebornmomma129]

Twisted was her first show like I get that but in tto she seriously did an amazing job acting in her singing and like you GO girl

[@kkskilletfan66]

In Dylan and Jaime we trust.

[@mourningdove5591]

Jamie getting the recognition she deserves

[@Gymoodmess3486]

I knew that itll be like 1 dylan 2 jaime 3 rob 4 lauren

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

Its the way it has to be

[@monarch2520]

THE FRICK I JUST SAW JEFF PLAYED THE GUY WHO KILLED BATMAN'S PARENTS THIS CHANGES EVERYTHING

[@lilychancey4446]

Brailey Sloan he doesn’t he plays sweet tooth in hmb

[@danienticknap6199]

@@lilychancey4446 if you watch the first like 10 seconds of HMB you can see that Jeff does play the guy that killed them, he's just not Sweettooth at that point

[@monarch2520]

@@lilychancey4446 yep!

[@mollypocrass4562]

Also, he's Aquaman in "Super Friends"

[@monarch2520]

@@mollypocrass4562 Yes, that is correct. He has great raccoon eyeliner as Aquaman.

[@jesoko6724]

I agree with most of this, but if it were me, I would have switched Rachel and Joe Walker. Joe's not bad but singing is not his strength (he would be high on a top actor list) and Rachel is a much more consistent performer when it comes to singing than him.

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

Yeah I think on acting he would be somewhere around my top 3, but it just fascinates me how much he has improved i wanted to give him some recognition for that

[@danielle-jg3ee]

Totallyyyy agree with the top 5 (BROSENTHAL! 😍) but I wish Tyler, Britney and Corey were a lil higher and Jeff was on the list but I know he’s an...acquired taste lol

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

I was debating whether or not to put jeff on the list but i couldnt let go of anyone i already had on there, soo.. :(

[@fatherterry1017]

i love jeff’s normal, lower register, & it kinda disappoints me when he goes into his falsetto :// also ty for giving aj, my bway boy, the rec he deserves

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

Yeah I'm not into his falsetto, this was the only reason i didnt include him.. I could only choose 20 and i had to decide somehow

[@fatherterry1017]

I will remember Achmed that’s valid

[@WickedAwesomeGardening]

Yeeeeeesss. There are times I can't stand to listen. Which is painful cuz he is so awesome!!!

[@guinealover6674]

We need a list of the best moments of every Starkid singer so that no one has to choose who's the best. XD

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

That's actually a great idea, i might do that someday

[@keirakabar2006]

wait can someone do this?

[@charlotte0236]

I think that the entire Starkid fandom can agree by now that the top singers are definitely Dylan, Jaime, Robert and Lauren Also finally someone who shows how awesome Jamie Burns is, Thank You, sad to miss Jeff Blim though, but oh well

[@cherrypick520]

I mean, how else could it possibly be?

[@user-qx5ft2ik1u]

i feel like if jeff didn’t use his annoying falsetto/mix so often he would be ranked very high. he has a gorgeous normal range. i wholeheartedly agree with this list, though. also, idea: clark baxtresser as orpheus from hadestown

[@beefstroganoff1774]

Omg absolutely.

[@kassidy4701]

Omg... Clark as Orpheus and Mariah as Euridyce ( idk if it’s spelled right but u know what I mean )

[@mags233]

unpopular opinion: i actually like jeff’s falsetto...

[@tonimenard9013]

i feel liek Alex Paul should be on this list, cause she did amazing in Dream a Little Harder

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

Yes she's amazinf in dream a little harder, but i had the same problem as i had with jeff: i just couldnt decide who i should leave out in order to put them on the list

[@joelatkin1214]

I feel like she’d definitely be top ten if she’d been in more shows as well as twisted

[@user-hl7gi8ud2i]

Dylan Saunders at the beginning of HMB is my favorite thing ever

[@Daniel-ed9gn]

Darling you are bold putting Mariah at 7. She’s at least in the top 5 imo.

[@heyimmashark9030]

Me through the whole video *sees the number placement*: what the heck they should def be higher *sees the person who comes next*: oh never mind I get it

[@amypond6740]

Holden, Corey, Bonnie, Tyler, Britney, Clark and Joey all need to be higher! They’re some of the best singers. I know most of them aren’t in as many shows as others but they’re more talented

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

I agree that they're really talented but I didn't know who to put lower instead :(

[@amypond6740]

I will remember Achmed tbf it is difficult to decide who to put lower. I’ve gotta give you credit for actually deciding

[@tuna1564]

5- Rachael 4- Lauren 3- Mariah (my queen) 2- Jaime 1- R O B E R T

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

Valid, but only if dylan is number 6

[@tuna1564]

@@IwillrememberAchmed sounds about right

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

@@tuna1564 very good

[@kenzidevine929]

Mariah shouldn't be on the list cause she's not actually a starkid member and Jeff is so he should be on the list

[@radxianixe]

@@kenzidevine929 ...mariah is a starkid.

[@mylahobbit1815]

personally i wouldve flipped robert manion and meredith stepien but that might just be bc i'm very, very gay

[@lenkagamine1410]

myla hobbit people overrate Robert Manion and I feel bad saying it but it’s true. Showstopping number is a great song but people really be saying he’s better than Dylan and that’s a hate crime

[@tempest2789]

@@lenkagamine1410 I mean, Dylan is an amazing singer, if we judge by technique. But, to me, he always sounds the same. His voice is not particularly versatile. It's always broadway-esque tenor. Similar to Lea Michele, who tried pop but her voice is too Broadway. Robert, in my opinion, has a more versatile, flexible voice.

[@mollywhiteman8956]

in my opinion you shouldn’t call a person overrated. it’s just really horrible to say someone gets too much love. you can call everyone else underrated compared to him but saying he’s too loved is just awful.

[@maddy7101]

My Favorite is the best Working boy out there. aNd CHaD. Who did you think I was gonna say?😂 -yeah definitly not Robert Manion😂-

[@mylahobbit1815]

i'm so glad you included tiffany williams!!! she has such a beautiful voice!!!!

[@JJ4EVER9232011]

11:49 that transition 😂😭😍

[@li.theo.4]

we may disagree on some of these ranking but at the same time i am SO thankful for some of them-brosenthal appreciation hell yeah!!

[@mollypocrass4562]

I feel like the entire fandom is Jeff in "Join Us and Die"

[@bluuebye1991]

tbh I’m so glad brosenthal is so high up but I also wish Racheal and Mariah were a bit higher tbh

[@coleatencio2]

Ok but where is Jeff Blim??

[@jessicasanders3505]

In the corner doing a badass saxophone solo and not caring about ranked lists probably

[@AliceNWonderland16]

@@jessicasanders3505 you’re so fucking right

[@aimeerivers8049]

BUT WHAT ABOUT BONNIE Also I feel like Corey could have been a looooooot higher

[@cherrypick520]

Bonnie's at number 15

[@mollywhiteman8956]

Aimee Rivers especially after our doors are open

[@jmeahd1953]

I feel like one of the things that makes people rank Corey lower is that for some reason it seems like his voice doesn't get picked up on mics very well so it can be hard to hear.

[@mylahobbit1815]

JAMIE AND CLARK GETTIN WHAT THEY DESERVE!!!! I'M SO PUMPED!

[@Rude_i_Wredne]

I would rank Brian Holden and Corey Dorris way higher, Lauren and Brosenthal a bit lower. However my biggest complaint is and will be: WHERE THE HELL IS JEFF?!

[@ameliataylor4012]

Rude_i_Wredne ikr

[@inhumanillusory]

Yup Jeff should be at least In the top ten

[@lonelyforestfae]

I feel the exact same way! Except, I would keep Lauren the same because she is a phenomenal singer snd I love her voice.

[@whatisthisbusiness4681]

Yes Meredith!! Honestly she deserves more recognition. Great video, BTW, for me it would be impossible for me to rank them.

[@rileyherbig1537]

brain rosenthals voice is so beautiful im so glad it was ranked so high oh my gosh hes godlike

[@SableChipmunk1]

The “your wagon is on fire” Song gave me chills the first time I saw Trail to Oregon and I loved it so much.

[@mrsrockylunch]

Me when I opened this video: Dylan's gonna be first its just common sense Me when I saw Jamie was second: Who else could possibly be left? Jamie is a god. Me .02 seconds later: Dylan. Dylan is first. I am an idiot.

[@ben2184]

Now you listen here Clark is queen and #1

[@maxaroni2313]

a crystal clod from Hufflepuff Um sorry false information

[@tuna1564]

uM R O B E R T

[@ben2184]

@@tuna1564 ok Robert and Clark can be like Anna and Elsa. But Clark is Elsa 😁

[@ben2184]

@@maxaroni2313 no you have false information

[@adagrey2856]

Honestly, yes!💛💛💛🥰🥰🥰

[@galacticaxolotl3184]

finally. a list where people actually acknowledge joe walkers existence.

[@madeleinetyler9407]

I love joe walker so I’d put him higher. I just need to say that he is beautiful and talented and he doesn’t get enough love

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

Yeh i wish i'd put him higher but i also didnt want to put anyone lower

[@JoshBasit]

Personally I would've put Rachael faryjee up in the list because she belts beautifully but I totally respect your opinion

[@fischybusinesss]

If Jaime isn't in the top 2 I'm rioting EDIT: Ok good she deserves it

[@hotlipsturtlehead6794]

I like how no matter what, Dylan Saunders is always first and Jaime Lynn Beatty is always second. It's the only constant in my life.

[@avitallichtenfeld813]

It makes me so happy that you included Brian Holden because I feel like he doesn’t get enough recognition especially as a singer

[@cerysnicholas6885]

Rosenthal my man YES. quite sad that Rachael is second to last but ah well

[@ash-lynnsarah8626]

Super glad you put Lauren, Jaime and Dylan up there in the top 5. Ive always thought those 3 were amazing singers. I like Joey too. But Jeff definitetly shoulder have been in there somewhere.

[@TheBuddsO]

I loved this ranking so much! I'm so glad you showed appreciation for underrated members like Brosenthal, A.J, and Tyler, they all have such beautiful voices! And I'm kind of glad you didn't include Jeff...I think he's a great character actor but he strains his voice so much when he sings lately its hard to listen to. Also Dylan's intro in HMB is so freaking good omg.

[@myrandajo9280]

i’ve been a fan of starkid since avpsy came out and this is the first time i learned the same guy played cedric and lucius 😅

[@katarinarose3379]

Same! I saw this comment right after the part in the video lol

[@soyasauce3626]

Right. I also *found* that very interesting.

[@becca287]

I’d probably switch Robert and Darren but other than that YESSS!!

[@juliaklaassen2247]

(lol a bit late) Yeah Darren is def better!

[@quilespiritu]

And beckons him to sayyyy kick it up a notch

[@toilingtrouble4541]

yo where the hell is that clip of Dylan from the starkid reunion where he holds that "welcome" note for like two straight minutes

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

i already had far too many dylan clips compared to all the others, there's a ton that would have deserved to be shown :(

[@toilingtrouble4541]

haha no worries im just joshin around

[@rosiemartin672]

Brian deserves more 😇

[@annaclaramol]

Mostly agree, but Joey Richter could have been higher

[@dianahernandez8688]

I was worried not seeing Dylan... uff that was close

[@chloebrammer108]

My top 10 1.)lauren 2.)jamie Lynn 3.)rachel 4.)jeff 5.)Robert 6.)joey 7.)corey 8.)mariah 9.)jamie burns 10.)meredith

[@Caitlinmperry]

Totally agree👏👏

[@angelicfajardo4986]

I love your #1!

[@amypond6740]

I’m so happy with 2&1!!!

[@mylahobbit1815]

8:28 ITS!! WHAT HE DESERVES!!!!!

[@ummguy5548]

Finally some appreciation for Clark

[@norqb3s]

I've been watching starkid for so long(although i started watching the different compilations last year because finding gems like this are hard) that i had a hard time making up my list. in my opinion your top 2 are great so I got no problem with that, I'd probably switch lauren and robert(Robert has the voice of an angel but Lauren's ability to have her voice stay in charachter even while singing amazes me, especially the random high notes she pulls out of nowhere amazes me e.g. la dee dah day and inevitable + they're pretty stable, although honestly I'd put them in the same rank) thus for the same reason I'd put joe walker higher, I'd also put rachel, and clark higher but I don't know where basically my ranking is messed up

[@heyoavacado1014]

Oooo... vid ranking people who have only been in like two or three or less shows

[@ellasallie4865]

I’VE NEVER BEEN HAPPIER, BRIAN ROSENTHAL WAS UP SO HIGH, HE DESERVES THE WORLD

[@srutibanerjee7352]

Will jamie Burns be in more starkid shows? Her voice was amazing!

[@queenelizabifandfrenz1951]

If Robert Manion isn’t included I will be mad

[@weltato]

After seeing the end of the show....Torture Tango is emotionally painful!! -To me anyway...-

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

At the end of that song where curt and the deadliest man alive sing their parts at the same time i think it's so incredibly well thought through that the lines "it doesnt even matter if i killed my best friend" and "to show you the horror of staying alive" overlap

[@weltato]

I agree, they like throwing in hints that you never realise until you rewatch the show.

[@jaykennedy8986]

Jeff deserves to be on this list and i will fight for him

[@orls216]

“And inspires him to say........ KICK IT UP A NOTCH!!!!!

[@silentdamfino2918]

I almost cried when I saw Dylan staring in TURN Washington Spies. I swear he is so good and is so underrated!!!! I hope he get so much good coming his way because he really deserves it!

[@bridgetspector6703]

I appreciate these videos because I could never dream of making one

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

I thought so one month ago, you never know whatll happen (even though, if youre refering to the ranking I dont think I'll ever be able to rank their musicals)

[@MadisonHartling]

I’m so happy Tiffany got some recognition

[@cormorantcolors]

Joey’s performance in a CERTAIN song (I’m sure you all know) should’ve made first place alone.

[@katarinarose3379]

The fact that friggin Darren Chris who was on GLEE isn't even top five really says something about the goddamn amazing vocals on this cast

[@vaalig]

This is the first authentic and truest ranking I've seen. I love Lauren, and she's my favorite as well as many of others' favorite, however I recognize there are people who do sing better or have a larger vocal range and that's FINE. They are all the best singers I've seen. Many other fan channels rank her first as she is their favorite and that's fine, but Jamie and Dylan do deserve more recognition (no hate just my opinion)

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

it was pretty hard to do it like that, especially ranking Joe Walker so low hahah

[@sadieh487]

I will always regret that Tyler wasn’t in many other starkid musicals he’s such a good singer

[@pellaw8011]

Mariah would have been my #1 or #2, but that might just be because I think Mariah is the best person in general

[@michaelbo2477]

you didnt have to use that clip from show stoppin' number, but you did anyways. and we arent complaining.

[@cherrypick520]

Honestly, I would be personally offended if it wasn't included.

[@emmebiggs1920]

My List: Dylan Saunders Mariah Rose Faith Jamie Lynn Beatty Darren Criss AJ Holmes Robert Manion Lauren Lopez Brian Rosenthal Clark Baxtresser Jamie Burns Tyler Brunsman Joey Ritcher Brian Holden Britney Coleman Corey Dorris Rachael Soglin Tiffany Williams Meredith Stepien Joe Walker Bonnie Gruesen

[@jamieestes3956]

Emme Biggs this is really good. I agree with like all of them but for some reason I want Darren at number 2

[@flaminlo9104]

i absolutely agree with your first place choice but i think a liiiittle bit of bias went into putting lauren above mariah and aj

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

(dont call me out like that)

[@katiej3506]

I'm sorry but Tyler brunsman is like fRiCkInG fAbUlOuS

[@rachelelizamusic7797]

collectively the only answers 1) Dylan 2) Jaime 3) Robert 4) Lauren after that we stop being all on the same page but we all know Dylan and Jaime are freaking top notch

[@emmaoneill3154]

Lovely list, I would've put Rachael, Brian H and Joey higher though. Robert and Brian R are great but they could've been lower. I mean, just listen to Wagon on Fire. Joey is INCREDIBLE!

[@Lauren_Nicks]

1. Jaime 2. Rob 3. Joey 4. Lauren

[@ellagurfinkel4172]

OMG you put there SAF

[@IwillrememberAchmed]

I had to, joe and joey are amazing! And I really like all the other actors and the plot, it's great.

[@Alexhaydan]

I personally don’t agree with 18 but the rear are ok

[@spicy.scribz]

10.You 9.can't 8.rank 7.them 6.they're 5.all 4.so 3.amazing 2.Jaime 1.Dylan

[@violetidk132]

twust is like an ongoing thing it needs to be in black friday lol i know robert accidentally said it during twisted but still

[@heatherduke7361]

Brolden and Rachel tho

[@dorothybowen9797]

I love Dylan's voice to the moon and back, but Jaime is my all time fav singer

[@ramona3840]

10. You 9. Can't 8. Rank 7. Them 6. They 5. Are 4. All 3. Great 2. Singers 1. Dylan Saunders

[@gabrielabravo3731]

20. You 19. Can't 18. Rank 17. Them 16. Because 15. They 14. Are 13. All 12. Great 11. In 10. Their 9. Own 8. Way 7. And 6. All 5. Sing 4. Amazing 3. Darren Criss 2. Jaime Lyn Beatty 1. Dylan Saunders

[@juliaklaassen2247]

I'm very late but YES

[@jamierobertson267]

I think Darren should have been higher than '8' but that's just my opinion.

[@thatoneemokid8215]

A Dylan Saunders and Jaime Lynn Beatty duet would me my heaven

[@Mary-lh9bj]

Dont touch Me they sing a Sami/Harry duet on one of their tours. It’s on KZbin and Spotify! You would love it

[@Mary-lh9bj]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/pZi1i3qOrdKHqs0

[@Elv1ra_-]

First time I've ever seen brolden on a top 20

[@mylahobbit1815]

9:26 ITS WHAT SHE DESERVES!!!!!!!!!

[@melissasanders5627]

I agree soooooo much with Dylan’s Jaime’s place in this

[@Imani88888888]

so happy to see walker on here his voice has grown so much and i just fucking adore him that’s my boy

[@littlecat7128]

Finally someone includes Joe Walker!! ❤️

[@k0pstl939]

But jeff!!!! Where is my boy jeff?

[@solane2148]

Brian Holden should've been higher tbh

[@danienticknap6199]

AGREED

[@kilian-one-l]

I know he's only been in TGWDLM, and only sang at the end, but I feel like Jon Matteson deserves a mention.