EPIC PRODUCER BATTLE - 1 Song 2 Producers!

[@forestwhitehead]

This was so awesome dude. Thanks so much for having me. You killed it.

[@RogerTRiche]

you're awesome, Forest!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

You slayed it brother! Round 2!!

[@thecraiginator]

You both TOTALLY nailed this one, Forest!

[@kamazenji9466]

Yeah both are WOW!!! i don't even know where to start... But definitely a round 2 haha i can't wait... Thank you guys for a wonderful production battle... Very inspiring for people like me still thinking about producing hahaha... Not even started yet just thinking...

[@allidaine2380]

That was great! Loved seeing the process and both versions are strong. My vote goes to Forest ❤️

[@jbeatz6189]

I understand now why forest has all the Grammys He totally understands the artists in a commercial way

[@bartekkturski]

This should be a Netflix series

[@melbrown3537]

Yassss!!! @Netflix needs to jump on this guy and get a series going!

[@theimisioluwaTV]

I completely agree.

[@silveramateur571]

True 🙌🏽

[@benjaveragua682]

I completely agree too, I can Imagine, diferents chapters, diferents producers, it would be amazing

[@CarlitoMarrom]

sim

[@dereksimke9117]

Dude! Both were good, but Forest takes the cake! That groove was just absolutely killer! Nathan needs a rematch, and a new sink!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

REMATCH!!!

[@lindanyathi4033]

Lol... The sink neh

[@mausomtamangofficial7280]

@@NathanJamesLarsen yah!!!!!! Please

[@xan6990]

​@@lindanyathi4033 Jesus Christ loves us all Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good. Romans 12:21 NIV

[@m.j.mcintear793]

How do you learn this. I’m not happy with my song

[@evenbass]

I love how they get excited over each other’s versions! This enthusiasm is what music, and music production should be about always! My vote goes to Forrest, for that awsome drum fill :)

[@forestwhitehead]

I wish you would've said the guitars!!! that drum fill was a splice sample! But I'll take it!

[@TheLiquidCanvas]

Music. The OG, and undisputed Heavyweight champion of ALL recreational drugs. Feels.

[@EF-mj9gw]

@@forestwhitehead like i said in my other comment, i like the guitars and violin 😁😁

[@djloop4146]

I really love Forest akustisk version i love it

[@djdeepbhamra]

Forest's version had a very definite maturity. Nathen's version was good on its own. It's only when you compare it with forests you realise what experience does to a track ❤️ Great video.

[@synthfamous]

Sorry but some one has to say it, forests version captures the emotion and feelings the singer had in her voice i can clearly see why forest has Grammys

[@ya_boi_paypay26]

Yeah! The other one sounds like a remix.

[@xan6990]

​@@ya_boi_paypay26 Jesus Christ loves us all Do not be overcome by evil, but overcome evil with good. Romans 12:21 NIV

[@sozeytozey]

Both were completely devoid of emotion. Forest just knows the radio tricks, so it felt more like a polished song you'd actually hear. But nah this was all generic nonsense.

[@ya_boi_paypay26]

@@sozeytozeyI’d much rather have a generic but nice sounding radio bop than a remix.

[@ankitkalavagunta8951]

When I first heard Forest's version I thought there's no way anyone can match this! But Nathan's last chorus is just killer!!! Especially with the horns at the end.

[@NotWithoutMyArmor]

Forest's sounds like the original pop radio mix and Nathan's is the more interesting remix of it. Both were fantastic, great job and I look forward to more of these battles!

[@oddbromden8786]

I was thinkin the same, I can’t do normal pop anyways. Prob why I was more drawn to Nathan’s more

[@torsten1091]

That's it. Forest's version is great and meets very well what we keep on listening in the main stream media. So it meets the the spirit of the current producing and listening conventions. So Nathan's in my opinion is the more creative and surprising one. May be 1 or 2 decades ago I would have stated the opposite. The only thing I have to complain is that both are way to loud. But that's the opinion of a guy who grew up with vinyl and headphones listening to what was called progressive rock. So I'm wondering if someone gives a sh.. on this comment two years after launching the video. 🙂 Thanks to both for the great work!

[@ThomasAlexNorman]

Killed it with this man. Such a great vid!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Thanks dude!! Appreciate it!

[@wesleysteedmusicUK]

Both are great! My vote goes to Forest on this one though. The guitar parts bring so much flavor to it!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Yeah his guitars were so good. SO GOOD

[@BrandiLynnColonMusic]

I can’t “play favorites”, so I’m gonna have to go with Forest on this one (see what I did there? 😉) Man you both killed it though! His I think complimented the vocal stem a bit more, but I love how your versions were both so different! Yours was definitely out of the box and was so unique, which made it really difficult to decide. Because I love originality like that. So for me it just came down to which jived with the vocal stem more! His rhythms that he did to compliment the vocal were sick! Man I LOVED your intro tho and what you did with the vocals in different places and all the different sounds/instruments! And even the way you put this whole video together with the camera shots/zooms going along with the different hits in the song. This whole video was art. Well done 👏🏻 Congrats to both of you on an AMAZING challenge!!!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Thiiiiiisssssss!!!!

[@Cwallace011770]

Both tracks were awesome! But watching you both react to each other’s track was the best part! I have to give this one to forest though. The acoustic guitar complimented the chorus vocal perfectly! Can’t wait to see the rematch!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Yeah his guitars were amazinnnng

[@samjordn]

Kinda crazy hearing the stark contrast of Forest building the production more engulfing the vocals vs Nathan building the vocals more engulfing the production. Kinda gives you the version of POP Indie vibes vs Atmospheric CLUB vibes.

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Yep it is so fascinating! I mean / I was blown away by what Forest did

[@KnoWareMan03]

@@NathanJamesLarsen CHALLENGE!!! 56y/o hobbyist🤝 Nice to meet you Mr. Nathan, I'm Mr. Nathan too😃

[@jennyooh1]

I liked the richness of forests track. You both did a really great job. I especially loved to see your reactions to each other’s songs. This is fun to watch

[@stanwaiyan871]

Forest totally out class! Thank Nathan for bringing amazing content. Please do more things like this with Grammy producers please.

[@rwnash4150]

Both end products were amazing, but if I had to pick one, I'd say Forest you can produce my tracks anytime!

[@syedarmaghanhassan4652]

I just come every now and then to listen to this song

[@wendyhaney692]

OMG!! That was so awesome! You both had me tapping my foot loving the beat of it. But sorry Forest, Nathan's gets my vote.

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Love it ❤️

[@tammylarsen5]

Loved both! Truly! Gotta choose Nathan’s. Love the upbeat movements. (Btw, Nathan, Dad chose yours, too! 😉).

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

I don't know this woman. LOL just kidding - love ya momma :)

[@phoenixsb]

Family ❤😌

[@yardstarz]

I keep coming back to this. Forest's version is so immaculate!

[@thelookingcat]

Yk... I used to think I didn't like pop. This video changed my mind. Thanks, Nathan and Forest!

[@NikolajChristensen]

What a beautiful vocal - and two great productions. The mix of Forest's version had the edge, but both were awesome.

[@timworley8306]

Nathan, thanks so much for this series. I think the greatest takeaway is that there's no "right" way to produce a given song. Not that there aren't some things that work better than others, but seeing just how many directions one can take a song in and still sound great is really freeing!

[@biggareid]

This matchup was EPIC!!! 2 titans collide in a showdown of the century!!😀 I feel that Mr. Forrest won this round for sure.

[@MrFEOH]

Oh dear, not only I had a smile on my face for +15 minutes, I even had a tear of yoy in my eyes! Thank you so much for this, thank you for the music! You are both great producers!

[@quachtinh-r7d]

Forest's mix is ​​so great, it's captivating right from the first note, showing the subtlety of perfectly combining the timbre of each instrument of an experienced and experienced producer. A sweet mix, understand and cherish the singer's voice... Nathan, your mix is ​​also great, it brings novelty, youthful vitality to the song.. Thanks , both are great.. I think so!

[@thesongwritingstudio5783]

This. Is. Epic! Such a blast to watch both of you guys interpret this song with your own signature sound!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Thanks a ton! Super fun to do - as you can imagine!

[@conspiracyclues]

I like the way forest started the song mood, it was a bit present than Nathan's introduction, but Nathan killed that chorus with beautiful ambients sounds and made it so professional...... by the way you both did an incredible job.

[@FabrizioTheSoundGuy]

Nathan, great club remix approach, but sorry, Forrest really nailed it on that. I loved the instrumental dynamic and the arrangements. But yours kicks well on the layers building and the grow up atmosphere. Really cool to see the different approaches on the same melody

[@ludeksmetana8696]

I love both versions :) If I used the song in a movie, I'd use Forrest's version in the opening credits and Nathan's version in the closing credits :)

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Ohhhhh great way of thinking about it!

[@SamK-Music]

*emotional damage*

[@edwigebokondem.5640]

You Both did an incredible work. but forest's track got my heart.. I love the groove and acoustic guitar matched with the vocal feelings. You are amazing guys...

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Yeah he really captured the vocal so well

[@GotBettaBeats]

You guys both did an amazing job, being a producer for many years, I have to tip my hat to both of you

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

😎😎😎😎😎🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻 thanks!

[@k.remi-eyo6329]

I loved both so much. Nathan's version got me into my feelings. So deep and I had my legs tapping to the beat. Forest on the other hand is just a true definition of genius. Those acoustics are just perfect. That was an award winning track right there. I am having a great time on this channel. ☺

[@luco-games]

I can't stop listening Nathan's version. It is just wow!!

[@rangla8141]

Forest's half time used is epic, and so as nathan dynamic flow of remix over vocal is too good ... Well if I have to choose among the two than I have to go with Forest's..... Great battle 💕👍💕

[@sanjanabanerjee5851]

9:27 - Forest's Track 13:15 - Nathan's track For those who needed it :)

[@JoshuaAmoah]

Both were so 🔥. I'd give Forest's a slight edge simply because of those hits throughout. So good, man. It makes you groove to the music without even noticing you are. With Nathan's, I really love how he builds and creates atmosphere. Simply awesome. The most fun part of the video though is watching you both react to each other's work. ❤️

[@Mikaflyd]

Man, both were really cool, love how you both did that from just the vocal of a song.

[@john-henri]

That was fantastic! I really enjoyed the rhythmic pop and melodic feel of Forest's. But the dynamic range and transitions that you made Nathan were superb! Truly enjoyed your track more. Absolutely LOVED the cinematic bridge!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Thanks John! It's nice neither of us just destroyed the other - more like two sweet takes on the same thing

[@BrandiLynnColonMusic]

Ok so I’ve watched this video multiple times now cuz it’s great 😂 Now I’m almost getting a different interpretation of the lyrics from the way you guys arranged it. Forest’s to me is the feel-good version: the singer is in this love bubble and can literally see/think about no one else but this person. They’re playing favorites, but they can’t help it. Yours feels more like a rebellious/moody version lol like the singer is focusing more on all the haters haha. “I’m playing favorites, and y’all just gotta get over it”😂 So fun how the production can have such an impact on the feel and interpretation!

[@forestwhitehead]

Love this comment because production completely can change the interpretation of a song! Thanks for listening!

[@JoshuaAmoah]

Deep interpretation. Lit

[@Matt_Morgan]

I was so excited to press subscribe on this video, but then I realized I am already! Haha. Great video! Forest won that one IMO. But you’re both at a tie for personality. Love.

[@KSR-Music]

Same lmao. I just saw 1 video yesterday and now i love the content

[@Josephlimmusicofficial]

MORE!!!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Challenge accepted

[@kimbaker719]

Both versions and the vocal itself are terrific. Far as which is my favorite.. well man there's a reason he's got all those awards on his wall back there :P

[@m3muzic312]

Great tracks from both and the battle was an interesting concept. You had great vocals to work with. My vote goes to Forest. I feel his track had more bounce to it and it hit a little harder. Great job and good luck to you both!!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Yes! He nailed it so good

[@dubsbarry9963]

Man Forest's mix sounded so crisp and clean. Love how it was so big, yet had tons of air and not even a hint of anything muddy. These producer battles make for some great videos. Big fan

[@fredoscott2346]

Two completely different versions, but they're both freakin' awesome! I usually hate this kind of music, but these had me from the start :)

[@ryguymcflyguy369]

I loved them both! They both gave me goosebumps, but Forest's wins my vote. The last minute of his track hit my soul.

[@remygarrisonmusic]

both are killer tracks !! y’all are both so talented !! if I had to pick one to go with it would forest because the guitar in the track is sooo good !!!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Yep. Guitars for the win

[@Rocketdog2522]

Forest your comment about it being the club mix of yours got me and is spot on man. Both are bangers for sure

[@alessandrofontana71]

Man this has been so intimidating hahah :) you both did such an incredible job! Also you have worked with an astonishing vocal performance, she’s a great singer. This was so fun to watch, I prefer “the club version” ;) BRAVO 👏 👏👏 greetings from Panama 🇵🇦

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Yeah the song and vocalist are amazing! Thanks!

[@jasongravely7217]

Loving the sound of Forest’s so far. That sexy acoustic multi genre goodness

[@naomiecelestemusic]

Totally loved watching this competition and the different ideas that came out of this. I'm not certain if I'm bias but I'm gonna pick Forest's version of the song. I like that it was more upbeat and it sounded like something that I'd be jamming in my car drive to work! Both producers are amazing though! I like the creativity that went into the same song.

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Love this! Yeah Forest honestly just nailed it

[@M0S3ST0NE]

you got schooled Nathan... Just found your channel, what an inspiration brother, we used to do this a decade ago on LOOPERMAN! I had my fondest creative learning moments on that platform. So glad to be here, so much to learn, I'm excited.

[@celestxl835]

I'm so early Nathan hasn't even been sent the vocal stem yet

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@o1111br]

Wow. Just discovered your channel. Both versions kept me grinning from ear to ear but Nathan, yours gave me chills. Those chord changes, that half step🔥🔥🔥👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@homestudiohaven]

I love the pre-chorus of Nathan's track, but overall I'd go with Forest's track. Great job by both though. Shout out to the vocalist. She killed it.

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Oh yeah she is amazing! We were both blown away at how good the song is

[@MRYOGI27]

@@NathanJamesLarsen vocalist social media?

[@dennisdavis3414]

Awesome to watch the passion these guys have. Like Forests a bit more- bit more acoustic, cool quick licks, etc.

[@mambo5476]

Who is loving the lady who's singing?

[@xChrisN1975x]

She has a sexy voice!

[@marcelcomello620]

Cool to see/hear how different perspective/insight can lead to such different songs, while still starting from the same source. Also nice to see there are still similarities between them. Nice job guys!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Thanks Marcel! And yes all so true!!

[@owenkorzec]

“There are no rules” * immediately states a rule * lol

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

LOLOLOLOLOL oops

[@philragu5298]

Forrest made a solid pop song from the vocals. Nathan's is like the b=side club mix. I love that I wasn't alone in thinking that when I heard the similarity in the chords at the beginning, thanx Forrest. I'm a Dj so I'm gonna go with the B=side, although I can think of a half dozen ways to remix either track and make them floor stompers as I'm typing out this reply. Bravo guys!

[@kriskorat]

The vocals that Forrest produced make me feel like an actual singer is singing next to me.

[@definfected]

Both songs were super dope!! I enjoyed Forest's a little bit more. So many dynamics in his track. I'd definitely add both songs to my playlist. Congrats to the both of you!! Can't wait to see more like this!!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Thanks duuuuudddeee! Yeah Forest just nailed it

[@subi5701]

Forest version is a song i would listen to

[@MichaelCorleoneLFC]

He smashed you Nath but it's no embarrassment. He's elite levels. Good video guys

[@jacksmith4460]

put it this way, I hate the style of music Forest's track was...but I loved the track, that is how good it was, the guitar arrangement was brilliant and I'm a guitarist lool

[@thearielleeden]

This was super fun to watch, especially the excitement and the reactions. Love both versions. If I had to choose, I prefer Forest’s. As Nathan said, so many simple and effective moments subtly highlighting transitions and the vocal. I’d dance to both any day! Y’all are mad talented! Thanks for sharing this with us!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Love this! Yeah he just had some many amazing moments

[@Chromarecords1]

Nathan I love your introduction..but forest is crazy ...man

[@stevecolley7745]

Wow!!!! I'm blown away with what I'v just watched and listend to!! Soooooo that's what a producer does. Fair play that was bloody epic.

[@raydendaily769]

Both were aweessome.....but my and my family's votes goes to Nathan.....for the effect and punch....soo effective ❤️❤️.....it's sounds much better with headphones.....good job both of you guys 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍.. So that's 5 votes...from my side for Nathan 😀😀

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Ayeee! Thanks Joel (and fam!)

[@richardlatham3771]

you need to keep this going. it just shows that everyone has there own take on a song or lyric, and thats ok because evryones take is special

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Yes I want to start doing these monthly if possible!

[@josephsam23]

Both Track are Amazing!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

🙏🙌🏻🙌🏻😎🔥

[@djmaup]

It's like Forest said. I think his is the original, yours is the club remix...If I must point out a winner, It's gonna be Forests version because of the build up and the guitars..THE GUITARS are killing it...

[@atrain2020]

Definitely need rematch Nathan, he got you first round. I’m behind you second round though

[@harshalkullu1111]

Dude both of you just stop😂 you guys are blowing my mind. Both of you were too good...hats off to you guys and....I WANT A REMATCH VIDEO!

[@alexanderpetrenko79]

We need a track with just Nathan’s reaction...

[@JoshuaTMagee]

This was really awesome to watch! I love both productions, but man Forest really smoked it. Great job, both of you!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

So happy you loved it! And yeah... there's a reason he's got hit songs

[@benmadi]

producers can be cool, Quincy Jones with Michael jackson, the strings in "Don't Stop 'till u get enough' etc

[@subeeshkumar2821]

Really guys you both killed it can't say which one is better because both are equally good..keep up this good work and please give us more quality content..enjoyed it..thank you

[@scorpionleader1967]

So close. I think Forest edged you out. The clean guitar gave him an extra element of depth.

[@Kimians]

I’ve listened to both versions several times. Each one is a work of art in its own right. All that is left to be said is….that it is down to the listeners individual ( or on downloading mass) that determines which of these versions hit the top. Well done to you both. I do have a fave by the way.

[@jonathanmaes27]

They both sound like they could be on Spotify! 😄

[@aldomajanil]

Both did great, but i loved Forest’s approach. 👏🏾👏🏾

[@vewilli]

I‘d really like to know what happens to this song once! It‘s mind-blowing.

[@sbd668]

FOREST!! FOREST!! My goodness!! You made beat making effortless!! Great job to both of you guys!!

[@summerfazed]

Forrest track = Radio. Nathan track = Live production

[@chima1140]

Both were super dope!!! This was so much fun to watch. All I can say is MORE MORE MORE!

[@cameron8619]

i know everyones saying they liked forests more but I LIKED NATHAN'S!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Ayeeee I got one! Hahahah

[@Swapnomoyyy]

Forest deserves a grammy for his version, and we deserve it on spotify.

[@TheSeeking2know]

This was fun! My favorite was Forests, sorry! 😂

[@AMTRAK020]

This was so much fun to watch! ❤️ 2 Music Lovers going at it in a fabulous way... Both versions are absolutely great for different moments. Looking forward to see more videos that go deeper into the production aspect because I’m working very hard on making music but can always use great tips from guys like you two! Thank again! 🙏

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

❤️❤️❤️❤️ thanks so much! Both of us teach this stuff on our channels. 🔥🔥

[@jodbar1]

Nathan: Forest wiped the floor with you mate. Sorry.

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

Why you sorry? Haha. He nailed it. Very different approaches.

[@michelthibodeau8550]

This is a very original idea ! I'll have to listen to both a couple of times before voting... Incredible production for both congratulations 👏

[@rumar4u]

Well... Both productions sounded very good... I missed additional melody elements in both productions from other Instruments or Sounds (they can be added later) so it sticks in my head (and sing it unconsciously) 😁

[@racheloshaksmusic]

I love this Forest guy! It was so good I could cry. Love the acoustic and romantic vibe it had. I gotta follow this guy!

[@africanhistory]

forest handed your ass to you Michelin style. The difference is epic. It is like one guy did the music without the vocals and then added them, while Forest actually listened to the music and did a composition to enhance the vocals.

[@Monkain08]

You both win!!! Absolutely awesome!! And her vocals had so much passion from the get go so it was great feeling both your passions come out with the production!!

[@tabithakeilholtz5573]

I had my family listen to both tracks without telling them whose track was whose. While both were INCREDIBLE, all six of us chose Nathan’s track. The strings were amazing!!!

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

That is AMAZING! Love you guys!!

[@PastorMoabel]

Hard to decide, both did a great job.