Gustav Mahler: Symphony No. 2 in C minor with Andrew Manze | NDR Radiophilharmonie

[@cms8989]

00:00:36 1st movement 00:24:40 2nd movement 00:34:50 3rd movement 00:45:25 4th movement / Urlicht 00:50:35 5th movement 01:22:22 The actual finale you came here for

[@NDRKlassik]

Haha, nice! Thank you!

[@cms8989]

@@NDRKlassik It's not that difficult, you should try it some time 😉 especially for these really long symphonies.

[@bartsanders1553]

Finale marked at the right phrase.👍

[@Dylonely_9274]

Thanks.

[@aroyval]

Absolutely boring. This man has no idea what he is doing.He just butchered one of the greatest symphonies ever written.

[@thetygerpulpitwithpastorglenn]

Outstanding presentation of one the greatest works of musical art ever created!

[@NDRKlassik]

Very happy to hear this, thank you!!

[@TdF_101]

Clear and expressive conducting, orchestra sounds amazing. Well done.

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you, much appreciated!

[@olivierbeltrami]

Superlative recording in which one hears all the secondary themes perfectly.

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you very much, we will pass on the compliment to our colleagues!

[@HenningLubbe]

What a performance! Great sound recording and quality.

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you! Much appreciated!

[@rahulradhakrishnan5591]

Great, divine performance of a true masterpiece of a symphony.

[@NDRKlassik]

We are touched by your words. Thank you!

[@leestamm3187]

A fine performance of the challenging Mahler masterwork. Thank for sharing.

[@NDRKlassik]

Happy to share, happy to have you with us! :)

[@rolandonavarro3170]

One of the best Resurrection I've ever heard. Just amazing, Bravo 👏👏🔥

[@NDRKlassik]

So happy to hear this!! Much obliged!

[@enejfuerst09]

Urlicht was particularly beautiful. I'd say the best one I've heard

[@АлександрК-ч8р]

Прекрасная симфония и великолепное исполнение. Благодарю NDR Klassik за предоставленную возможность прослушать этот концерт.

[@NDRKlassik]

Happy to share the joy! Thank you!

[@maryannlibanan3845]

It's a hair raising experience watching these bunch of ultra talented musicians! So lucky to have watched it. Thanks for sharing ❤

[@NDRKlassik]

So happy to read your nice comment! Much appreciated!

[@HenningLubbe]

Outstanding. Thank you for sharing this with us!

[@NDRKlassik]

Our pleasure! Thank you for commenting!

[@olgamorozov8248]

Bravo!!! It's brillant performance of all musicians. Thank you for sharing.

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you, it is a pleasure!

[@Frank_from_Hanover]

This was a really great concert, I had the pleasure to hear and see that live. 🥰 One of the best Mahler 2nd I ever listened to. Congratulations to the wonderful orchestra, the marvellous choruses and great Andrew Manze. 👏👏 Btw: Please correct your description, this was not NDR Landesfunkhaus, but Kuppelsaal instead. 😉

[@NDRKlassik]

So true! Our bad - sorry and thank you!!

[@hsr.babY123]

My favorite symphony performed to my liking. Thank you. A great fitting end to Manze's NDR era.

[@NDRKlassik]

Happy to hear that you enjoyed it!

[@Boratti]

Toller Dirigent

[@gregorymikaelian2760]

Потрясающее исполнение! У Эндрю Манце - только шедевры! Пропускать ничего нельзя! Всё слушать, изучать и удивляться! 🙏❤

[@Bernd-f5s]

Bravo, C. Eschenbach und allen Mitwirkenden ein großes Danke schön!!❤🎉😊

[@charakter-etudenjohannesst8121]

😂😂😂

[@IrvingWaldorf]

#Excellent performance and excellent recording. Thank you for sharing

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you for listening! We're happy you enjoyed it. 😊

[@jimholder6656]

Simply awesome and wonderful! Some of the best musicians anywhere!

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you so much! We feel honored. ☺️

[@Dylonely_9274]

Bravo !

[@zushonosuke318]

Wonderful❤

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you very much. 🤩

[@Dylonely_9274]

Such a great symphony, the best of them all… at least for me.

[@DaestrumManitz]

Wonderful performance.

[@NDRKlassik]

Much obliged!

[@SYcooking]

素晴らしい演奏。録音自体も凄く良い。久しぶりに良いマラ2が聴けました。心から感謝します。

[@NDRKlassik]

Vielen Dank! :)

[@운전꿀전자]

클래식에서 50Frame이라니.. 감동이네요

[@nurhabibi922]

wunderbaaarrrr

[@NDRKlassik]

:))

[@tt-ew7rx]

Imagine going through this piece, entirely standing. If you fancy that, they sometimes do it during the BBC Proms. I'm reliably told it's a very exciting and memorable experience.

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you very much for this kind comment - much appreciated!

[@dejapan]

Please make it into a CD!

[@NDRKlassik]

We will certainly forward your wish! 😊

[@ArionedeWinter]

Inspired!

[@chtidede]

Dès les huit premières mesures, on sait tout de suite que nous sommes en présence d'une des plus grandes versions de la 2. MAGISTRAL HABITÉ. FANTASTIQUE.

[@NDRKlassik]

Merci beaucoup!!

[@r.daillee1034]

❤

[@leonschwichtenberg9329]

Piękne. ❤

[@NDRKlassik]

Dzięki! 🌟

[@sumeetsharma7256]

Why is Manze so enamoured.....why's does he want to proceed to heaven

[@Ukgejap]

👏👏👏

[@marcelouz1]

One of the most spectacular symphonies of all time and which had harsh criticism from the famous Wagnerian conductor, Hans von Bulow and the new French movement of Debussy's French impressionism, which unfortunately with Paul Dukas left the theater after the second movement. Together with the 8th, both of them end with the "redemption of man" but the 2nd goes further with the "resurrection" after the loss of faith, it is Mahler's most conflictive and contradictory symphony, since it is present the day and night, "yin and yang", yes and no, death and resurrection, the contradictory essence of human existence, cannot survive and coexist one to each )other. Impressive performance by the NDR Philharmonic Orchestra and its conductor Andrew Manzel. I have once again revived the interpretations of the late 20th century, especially those of Bernstein versions with LSO and NYPO, I don't know why I don't like the versions of other great conductors of our time, especially the "funeral rites"with exaggeratedly fast tempos. The only criticism I could make, with great respect for the entire perfrmance,, is the slightly loud sound of the offstage brass. Otherwise a powerful and irresistible prerformance from the beginning to end. BRAVISSIMO!

[@thetygerpulpitwithpastorglenn]

I agree with the note on the offstage brass. Other than that, I consider this the best KZbin offering I have heard! Thank you!

[@Frank_from_Hanover]

@@thetygerpulpitwithpastorglenn I agree, too. It's definitely a bit too loud in this recording, but it was really perfect in the concert hall that evening.

[@NDRKlassik]

Thank you so much! Happy to hear (read) this!

[@MartinJunghöfer]

Ja, wunderschön, aber wann schaffen es die Herrschaften an den Mischpulten endlich, den Einsatz vom Chor fast unhörbar runter zu dimmen: ppp (3!)!!!

[@wt6311]

このオケはブラームスのシンフォニーが伝統的重要演目と聞きますが、このマーラーの2番「復活」は、ここ40年数年間ではこの楽団の得意曲目になっている気も致します。スタートは何と楽団とすぐに合わなくなってしまったクラウス・テンシュテットかな。 それにしてもこの曲でのこのオケは上手いですね。響きも独特な何かを持っている気が致します。 でも、最近の演奏は時代の違いというか、流行でもあるのか、演奏のテンポがだいぶ速くなりました。私はマーラーがもしタイムマシンに乗ってやってきたとしたら、もっとゆっくりのテンポで、しかも結構激しく音楽を動かすのではないかと想像します。それで評論家たちとお客全員が目隠ししていたら、あるいは時代遅れの演奏スタイルの指揮者と言われてしまうことでしょう。でも、感動したという人も続出する予感がします。 ちなみにマーラーがウィーン国立歌劇場でオペラの指揮をすると聴衆はとても感動して拍手喝采するほど、格別に素晴らしかったと言われています。反面、いつもとても厳しく歌手やオケには接するため、次第に演奏者たちからは嫌われていったと聞きます。そして、ついには追い出されてしまいました。何だか、まるでNDRにおけるクラウス・テンシュテットみたいではないでしょうか。私はマーラーはそういう飛び抜けた才能とキチガイじみたほどの感性の持ち主ではなかったかと想像します。そして、演奏の異常性というか、飛び抜けたキチガイじみた激しさと壮大さはやはり、テンシュテットの指揮の特徴でもあり、この指揮者も他の指揮者も彼に比べれば普通にとても良い音楽家です。 それぞれ素晴らしいです。マーラーの持つ飛び抜けた個性を出せるヤバい位の指揮者とではこのオケは長続きしないでしょうけれど、ヴァントのようにオーソドックスな解釈のマーラー版の指揮者たちならば繰り返し演奏していけるし、そうしているうちに得意演目になってきたのだろうと思います。たぶん、オケの人たちはマーラーのこの曲が好きなのではないかと。そして合唱団もたぶんこの曲が大好きなのでしょう。だってすごくいい曲ですし。Urrichtの歌以降は、心が洗われる音楽、そして戦いの音楽、苦しみと死を受け入れて再び立ち上がる(復活)音楽の感動は半端ないです。 でも、いつか再びキチガイ指揮者が現れて、マーラーのこの曲のはち切れんばかりのキチガイ性をも含む真価を再びこのオケと演奏してほしいです。

[@nakayamayasubei]

In 2022, Beethoven's 3rd Symphony was heard in Japan.

[@Cubestreak]

One can only wonder what was going through Mahler’s head while composing this…

[@alexladentin1986]

Was it an electronic Organ? I can't really find any information about any new Organ in the HCC.

[@NDRKlassik]

We don't know exactly what you mean. A smaller organ was played in the concert, as you can see in this picture gallery under photo number seven: www.ndr.de/orchester_chor/radiophilharmonie/konzerte/manze508_backId-manze434.html#content

[@alexladentin1986]

@@NDRKlassik it was a very big Sound in the last movment.

[@erikschlagzeug]

El de la Tuba es un héroe

[@mct8621]

Peter Stadlhofer 👏

[@NDRKlassik]

Exacto!!

[@Happysongkla]

このメンバーでマーラー全集公演お願いします。できれば東京でお願いします。

[@NDRKlassik]

Herzlichen Dank für den Kommentar und die Einladung! Wir leiten Ihren Wunsch gern weiter! :)

[@Dylonely_9274]

16:39

[@jonnieinbangkok]

Where are they hiding the pipe organ 🤔

[@hendrikf3670]

Das ist der Kuppelsaal und nicht das Funkhaus

[@NDRKlassik]

Sehr wahr - das war ein Fehler unsererseits, Entschuldigung. Ist bereits korrigiert!

[@ВладимирБарабаш-к4ш]

Арестович- президент - это действительно смешно, после всего-то…

[@Dylonely_9274]

1:06:15

[@melaniamonicacraciun9900]

Let only music rule the world fans & let it sound just this good, Mahler is a bit ...hallucinating, he had alcohol and narcotics problems but then, fans in the audience need a bit of . .. something shocking to wake them up. If anyone can use this composition as movie soundtrack...did you see John Williams playing with sharks and Jaws? It works like that...😂😂😅😅have fun guys 🎉❤🎉

[@TheStockwell]

Mahler did NOT have alcohol or narcotics problems. Where you came up with that idea is hard to imagine. 🧐 Best wishes from Vermont 🍁