NEW Supergoop! Protec(TINT) vs CIELE Tint & Protect

[@themiiiche]

As spring approaches, would love to see an updated skin tint comparison

[@lilnitemakeup]

The Supergoop also has chemical sunscreen ingredients (Zinc Oxide 13.58%, Homosalate 7.0%, Octisalate 5.0%) - I like that Ciele is just mineral.

[@TG-jp3tc]

Zinc oxide _is_ a mineral sunscreen ingredient, but I appreciate you posting the info. Zinc oxide on darker skin gives all kinds of ashy. I can't even wear sunscreen without looking like the tin man.p.

[@lilnitemakeup]

@@TG-jp3tc I know, I just listed the full list of sunscreen ingredients to be accurate. ☺

[@ginarussell5077]

The Supergoop Protec(Tint) is a sunscreen. Rather than trying it on like a skin tint, could you apply it like a sunscreen and see what kind of coverage it gives and how it behaves over a full day? I don’t think it makes the best sense to try it out like it’s a skin tint.

[@glossmenagerie]

I appreciate the vine reference for Sail staying consistent so much 😅

[@vadal4043]

IMO, one of your primary strengths over other beauty influence channels is the comparison element. For most of us, there's a bottom to the bucket on spending. I don't buy a lot at the drug store because of formula and shade limitations, so I really want to know how the $$$ products from higher end brands perform against one another, as there is not alot of value for me in simply watch someone put a product on their face and ooh and ahhh over it. Thanks for bringing us this value and for your consistent honesty in sometimes having to say ~ skip it it's not worth it. I think alot of them are afraid if they say that, they'll get no more PR. Maybe. Don't know. But I come here for the comparisons. Keep it up, kiddo.

[@amymccall5263]

You have to use more of the supergoop because it’s a sunscreen not a foundation and again for people with deeper skin tones products like this (especially in the US where our filters are decades behind the rest of the world) are much needed.

[@neggieyaghooti]

The big difference between the Ciele and Supergoop is exactly the amount of coverage, which in terms of sunscreen products (if you were to use it as a main sunscreen step) would be a benefit for the lower coverage one (supergoop). I can’t imagine using the amount of ciele you need for spf coverage, but you actually could use the quarter teaspoon of the super goop on your face for proper spf coverage and not look crazy.

[@neggieyaghooti]

But yes overall wasn’t impressed with the supergroup. Really reminds me of the Avene tinted spf in terms of feel.

[@ginarussell5077]

I wore the Supergoop today as a sunscreen on my combo oily skin and it looked beautiful. It evened my skin tone and stayed mattified without being too dry or dewy.

[@lesleyc2704]

⁠@@ginarussell5077this is helpful. I have been wearing the Supergoop Glowscreen on my ‘no make up’ days with a Merit Flush balm, mascara and lip balm. I would be looking at the Protec(tint) as an alternative to the Glowscreen. So something less glowy and a higher SPF.

[@lindsyehagens1373]

Definitley here for the entertainment. I was so happy for another Kackie video today! Side note I cannot stop using your blush Au Lait! I’m obsessed and so sad it will run out someday. Best color and texture ever.

[@kackie]

We will eventually release the hex codes. It's not intentional withholding. It's a UI/UX thing.

[@lindsyehagens1373]

@@kackie Oh I remember you saying that, I was just being overly dramatic for effect. Lol In fact I’ll probably be proud if I hit pan because I rarely use things up. Thanks for being so amazing with color theory!

[@emilywells131]

Tan Kackie is gorgeous!🥰 Can confirm that June is beautiful on olive skin but fades quickly! The skin tint though…never disappoints!

[@ryrify]

I don’t know about the efficacy of applying sunscreen with a sponge? I usually goop on the supergoop play then follow with a skin tint and it’s the perfect combo for my dry skin. I don’t know about relying on a skin tint for anything but a cute little skin enhancing. Definitely into the ciele!

[@fyern]

The use of Awolnation's "Sail" makes me so happy!

[@starrypunk20]

Thank you for saving me $44 lol. I have the Ciele and it continues to win over everything, like it just cant be beat.

[@kackie]

Agreed

[@andreak6132]

Very interesting. As an oily/combo gal, I *hated* the Ciele. It accentuated my texture and actually made my skin feel dry and tight. The color also seemed patchy. Returned it so fast. The blush was the same. Broke my heart bc I had such high hopes.

[@ginarussell5077]

As an oily/combo gal, I really enjoyed the Supergoop with a light layer of Huda Beauty powder.

[@xiomarasinnis7549]

Thank you for this, been looking for a review from someone with oily skin !

[@marileen._.]

​@@ginarussell5077 Did you ever try the Ciele tint? If so, how was it?

[@whatifjenny]

Thank you for this video! The odyssey gloss oil is my holy grail, but I was intrigued by the kush, glad I won't be wasting my money on that. And I was so interested in the supergoop, and won't be wasting my money on that either!

[@baileydubs]

I was swatching sail in Sephora yesterday and I was just replaying that clip in my head from when you put it in a previous video 😂

[@kackie]

😂

[@mymagicemily]

Just over here frothing at the mouth for the Guerlain blush breakdown

[@mymagicemily]

Also I feel like the look would be more intuitive for you were it summer. I really like it on you, I think it's really flushed summer vibes, but I would probably react the same way were I to suddenly feel a look going off the rails like this in early March.

[@Sweet_T713]

I agree with the folks saying they enjoy seeing you troubleshoot! A lot of us go through these same issues so I love seeing how you fix things! That pink blush is so pretty and shame it doesn’t stay. The Ciele tint is so pretty definitely trying it. I love that it has spf so it can top off my typical spf I wear!

[@dietcokehead]

Troubleshooting Kackie helped me turn a chaotic situation into something lovely yesterday! I got the new Rituel de Fille concealer in the shade their consultant picked for me (105), and it was soooo light. So everything went off the rails, and I ended up using multiple bronzers and contours and intense quantities of coral blushes. And in the end I finally just looked human and lovely! Wild. So wild. Thank you for being the biblically accurate angel on my shoulder at the vanity 😘

[@beatdizzy]

Ugh. We need to be more Ron Swanson 'i know more than you (because I follow kackie)' I hope you can return or swap it out...

[@dietcokehead]

@@beatdizzy doubt it. This was one of their lab prerelease tester things. But it’ll be totally fine for brightening purposes, and again, I was able to make it work with the Kackie method of bringing back all the shadows and local color!

[@mmlee2213]

Kackie idk what video it was mentioned in, but just today I tried your black coffee/York peppermint patty combo. GAMECHANGER!!

[@kackie]

BRUHHHHH

[@mochilover87]

I LOVE the Ciele skin tint!

[@katieswanson4496]

The sail video gets me every time 😂

[@megwysatta7393]

“This is happening without my consent.”😂😂😂❤

[@erinclarke-dorrell849]

But the component for the Ciele is awful! I’m over droppers for foundation as they just get so messy. I’m almost done with my first bottle and don’t really want to buy it again despite loving the formulation.

[@katodan0611]

I am "of the age" where I finally invested in a laser treatment to fade my hyperpigmentation. Now I must use SPF every day to protect that investment. I have tried a couple of mineral sunscreens (which are a must for me as standard sunscreens break me out) but they have been off the mark. Kackie is so in love with Ciele Tint & Protect that there is no way I am not going to try it. Fingers crossed it will be the one that works for me!

[@marileen._.]

How was the Ciele SPF tint for you? Currently recovering from laser treatment myself

[@notimportant123]

YES. Could we maybe get a comparison of all the popular (mineral) SPF skin tints? These 2 of course, but Live Tinted dropped a new SPF50 skin tint, the Saie slip is SPF35. I love the Ciele one.

[@pinkTonya24]

I bought the Ciele on your rec and i am loving it !

[@alyssabrown9256]

I love using a super cool toned blush to fix weird bronzer colors. Anytime I feel my bronzer is pulling too olive or dark, I slap some blush on all over, and it neutralizes so beautifully. This is coming from someone who is not a blush girly and avoids pink like the plague 😂

[@ellelovescats3]

So happy I finally have enough time to catch up on your videos!!!! I would love to see more "foundation battles", one on each side of your face. Including older ones side by side like Prada vs Chanel Sublimage le teint.

[@carino3901]

Which one would you select Ciele vs Danessa Myricks Yummy Skin Tint?

[@jessicagoecke2368]

The MILK makeup cream stick is one of the few items that I fully gave to my 6 year old because I can’t figure out when or why I would put it on my face. She, however, looks amazing in it - totally unbridled, unhinged, full-face application…major David Bowie vibes…like, she could probably point her MILK makeup face to the sky and receive signals from space. Worth it.

[@abigailhugh-jones8188]

I am that person that has the Ciele, and loves it, and was thinking about trying the SuperGoop! I won't be buying the latter now, thanks to you 🙏

[@lookitsgrandma]

I'm actually enjoying the Protec(tint). I wish it were more sheer but need the SPF. I get decent spread using my fingers. That said, now you've got me wanting to try the Ciele. Dang it, Kackie!

[@TheClairelikescats]

This is super helpful, as I have been wondering about both of these spf skin tints!

[@taraunger8110]

Thank you for your honesty, not many you tubers do that! I have more to say but that will be at a later date. Not a great day so thanks for making me smile lovely!

[@afmullins592]

Omg! So glad I found this video and your channel! As a skin tine girlie, i have been wondering about Ciele products and this popped up on my recommended and I immediately clicked!

[@Vixs18]

I have a whole graveyard full of lipglosses that are disappointing. I’m waiting for Haute Cocoa to come back. I just ordered my shampoo at Sephora and Makeup by Mario just launched a Master Mattes Neutral (cool) palette. I’m not an impulse buyer but I was trying to talk myself out of buying the Ethereal Eyes palette, (too many celestials. I’m 67 and cool toned.) when I saw the new release I didn’t hesitate to get it. I bet it sells out quicker than Ethereal Eyes. I love the grey color in it. Pleeeease review it. I need your guidance on the colors in it. I’m learning so much from you about what will look good on me ! Thanks. 💕

[@Autumn_Blessings]

I have the Ciele blush in Giselle and mix it with a little concealer and it looks the same as January.

[@jlozo7160]

I don't know how I haven't been subscribed to you, but you are hysterical! Thank you for this showdown as I was torn between these two for the Sephora sale. Def a new subbie who is going to ransack all of your recs. 😂

[@erinriley2059]

I don’t get the point of these spf foundations. You aren’t going to use enough to get any spf protection so like?? I’d rather they come out with better actual tinted spf

[@sophd1991]

The annoying thing is the Ciele costs £47 to get it shipped to the UK. Gaaaah wish they’d sort their shipping!!!

[@reneefisher4192]

I love all this content you’re putting out, giving me my dopamine hits! I’ve been looking at your content from 2+ yrs ago and I’d love watching you playing with colorful eyeshadows. Ngl I miss that Kackie 😉 we gotta evolve somehow though don’t we

[@valariebrown3768]

Lovely look, as usual. I am still copying that peach eye with green liner, but today it was Rare Beauty Nearly Neutral with a blue shadow liner from the Target Morphe 5 pan in the blues. Not as striking as your combo, but still fun and pretty. You inspire! Thank you!

[@jlb1993]

Nudestix nudescreen blushes when? Lol, I'd love to see your opinion and how they compare with the ciele blushes! Nudestix is spf 30.

[@meganweber3125]

I always learn so much when you trouble shoot. Just the other day I had a similar issue as this and I could not for the life of me figure out what to do to fix it.

[@jansenlee3319]

So the fact you need more product could be good. Helps you get the right amount of spf coverage

[@sweetsweetcoffee]

SOOOO im earlier than my period this month

[@kackie]

🤣

[@Vtrains]

How would the ciele skin tint compare to the ilia skin tint with spf?

[@shelleyeatz]

Is anyone else bothered by the way the Ciele blushes smell? January actually looked beautiful on me and stayed well for 6 hours until I took it off, but I couldn’t get myself to use it again because it smelled like puke. Basically if the smell doesn’t bother you it’s a fantastic blush!

[@emmafoley8987]

Harvest in DM Groundwork palette also gives the same effect as the Ciele in June: I surprised myself with a tan look the other day when I used it as blush.

[@Ninyth]

Haha i was about to type „kackie must be ill, no eye glitter?!“ but she couldn’t resist anyway 😂

[@TheJoker718]

Thank you for helping me narrow down my skin tint options! Could you do a short comparing the Kosas BB Burst and the Ciele Skin Tint? My Sephora doesn’t carry Ciele in store, and I’m trying to decide which one to get.

[@nikolasincorporated]

THANK YOU FOR USING THE WORD VISCOUS INSTEAD OF LIQUIDY 👏👏👏👏 sorry rant over Also the sail joke will never not be funny to me

[@carriec5376]

oh my god i never thought i’d see anyone else get as irritated about that as i do, thank you both!! i get it, not everyone has a freaking chemistry degree (like i do) so i let a LOT of things slide. but liquidy drives me absolute batshit 😂

[@nikolasincorporated]

@@carriec5376 fun story, i actually failed chemistry my first go around 😆😝 but i did take SOMETHING away from it 👏🧐

[@notimportant123]

Aren't they opposites though? Viscous is thick and liquidy is thin? So nobody who says "liquidy" means to say "viscous".

[@nikolasincorporated]

@@notimportant123 she didnt say that the other product is “more liquidy”, which 99.9% of beauty KZbinrs do

[@notimportant123]

@@nikolasincorporated😂 got you

[@starrhall8160]

Thank you... Have u ever had a pixie cut? I love a bronzed look for u!

[@kackie]

Yes for YEARS!

[@Liz73-pg7pf]

I find the blush lasts longer if I use the YSL blur primer and fix + setting spray at the end. MAC has a stay all day fix + , I m going to try it and see if it is even better

[@user-nb8tm6pv6f]

Do you have the name of the content creator that tested to see how much foundation one would need to provide adequate sun protection? Curious to know, I am very fair and did some anti aging treatments a few years ago. Staying out of the sun is huge for me-Trey

[@kackie]

Yeah it was on the screen. Charlotte Palermino. Charlotte Parker on IG

[@sabrinaa8948]

Hey Kackie, the Ciele website doesn't discuss undertone. I'm stuck between the lightest 3 shades. Do you have a comment on those undertones? (I can't purchase Ciele in Sephora Canada so this is a gamble purchase for me)

[@clothestohomevlog]

Hi! I have seen the 3 lightest shades in person at sephora and I myself have purchased shade 3. I am usually fair-light and neutral-warm leaning. The lightest shade is your true porcelain/very fair. Shade 2 runs more pink and shade 3 is a more neutral-warm. It’s not super neutral but not super warm a good in between in my opinion. For reference I would be somewhere between nc15-nc20 in MAC and Gobi-deuville in NARS (but none of those shades are as good as shade 3 in the ciele skin tint for me) I personally tend to have a hard time finding neutral foundations that don’t pull too pink & most warm foundations pull too yellow for me. Shade 3 is incredible if you fall in that light skin neutral-warm category. I am actually on my second bottle of shade 3. This skin tint is honestly incredible and feels so good on the skin/great ingredients ! 10 out of 10 recommend. Hope this helps!

[@sabrinaa8948]

@@clothestohomevlog Thank you for such a great answer. I am usually a true neutral, maybe a NC10 in the winter. I don't mind a warmer look in the summer. Thank you for all that information!

[@Justgettingthroughtoday]

You do look great when you’re tanned…. SAIL!

[@kackie]

SAIL!

[@Beautyonthebrain_]

I feel like Milk makeup gets their product ideas from free associating with Toddlers. "Lip Gloss" --"Cookie dough"

[@kackie]

🤭

[@reneegrace7965]

Hi Kackie! I also am so sensitive to Octinoxate, I flake and peel after just 1 use. Do you need to use sunscreen under the Ciele?? Are you able to use enough to get the 50 SPF??

[@jessicag1431]

I comment on you and tom's channel asking about blurring way too much. Trying to build out a whole new routine centered on blurring thats also airy with a slight dew. My thought was: VB Primer in bronze Sisley blurring powder used as a primer Ciele skint tint (or is another more blurring but leaves a dew finish? I mix nudestix and fenty ATM) Sisley blurring powder to finish in target areas Danessa yummy blush Gucci bronzer If you think there are more optimal blurring options for any of these please let me know!!

[@caseyelizabethan]

Hyaluronic acid in the Supergoop, not for me :( why does this ingredient have to be so trendy!? Even though it basically does nothing and can even dry your face out or, as in my case, cause a reaction. The Ciele works pretty well for me

[@lesleyc2704]

I’m glad you pointed that out because I never check ingredients. My mature dehydrated skin (environment) loves hyaluronic acid but I always apply Bobbi Brown hydrating face tonic before applying products. I will try the Supergoop Protec(tint) as a less glowy higher SPF substitute for my Supergoop Glowscreen on no make up days. I apply with my fingers and I want more product for the higher SPF.

[@lisafalanga8457]

Fantastic Video☀️You, ARE, a cosmetic historian! Perfect Analogy..” Like Kackie says ,”This is how we play the game.” I Really like my Ciele..Per this communities recommendation❣️

[@mariky]

9:22 It’s giving Oliver Twist😂

[@GlowITG]

The Milk Makeup Kush lip oils feel so redundant! Thanks for confirming. I already got the cookie dough one out of curiosity, and I was sort of appalled I paid $36 CAD for it. I don’t like it any better than the Tower 28 clear gloss which was $22 CAD. I really don’t see the point of Milk releasing all those different flavors of lip oil when they look identical on the lips; the product photos on the Sephora website for each color (applied to the lips) seem to be literally the same photo lol. Why not at least make the tint of each one meaningfully differ? You can have a relatively sheer formula that at least has SOME discernible pigment on the lips.

[@victoriarose466]

How does the Ciele compare to Danessa Myricks Yummy Skin Tint?

[@kristiang1870]

I wonder how June looks compared to Dune from Ami Cole 🧐

[@tzoe875]

Which tint would work better in intense summer heat?

[@maryarmstrong2231]

Love everything I have purchased from ciele

[@catherinekripak4767]

Question: Ciele January or WA Petal (color not formula)? Thanks, community!

[@rachaeltaylor2563]

June looks almost exactly like Rare Beauty in Happy

[@beatdizzy]

Ohhh id love to see that swatched

[@AnneOnymaus]

"If you swatch all of your foundations together...": that assumes I've found at least one complexion product that matches me (think Hannah Louise Poston minus the green) ☹️

[@butterlite100]

Can you compare Protectint to Bloom Effects?

[@somacarr7528]

I wish these foundations had no spf in them. Especially if they can’t protect you from the sun, as we can’t use that much to do it.

[@samanthaleigh805]

Which shade did you say the ciele is in?

[@BronwynCook-i6n]

My supergoop will be going on my legs! I look like I'm auditioning for gold finger. Not flattering.😅

[@lisadgingersnaps9843]

TGIF❣️❣️❣️

[@ebombard]

This or that? Ciele vs Ilia skin tints!

[@parissinclair6513]

I've tried both, and they're both great but very different! The Ilia one is the epitome of moisture and glow. It's *quite* shiny, but feels delightfully hydrating on the skin and really soothes my sensitive rosacea skin. The Ciele has a much thinner, more slippy texture, blends in very quickly, and while it offers coverage, it looks like absolutely nothing on the skin and has a very natural finish.

[@Trainfeastfast]

Suppose to use your fingers not sponge. 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@SophieCummings-bu9ty]

I wish you would stop using actives when they seem to irritate your skin so badly 😞💕

[@kackie]

Let me live

[@sarahr9181]

Damn, the Protectint is on its way to me. Sounds like it’ll have to go back 👎🏻

[@cindicleee]

❤❤❤

[@QueerBones]

We swatched the lightest shade supergoop for my partner and the olive shade for me yesterday and both looked kinda grey on us, I assume because of the high amount of zinc oxide

[@erinnswan7063]

❤❤❤