NEW Tatcha Liquid Silk Canvas VS Original Silk Canvas

[@danahoover1216]

Just can't beleive you are gone. But I am going to binge watch u forever. So talented.

[@Bramsgirl201]

Tatcha is so smart. Putting the product in a pump will make you go through it faster and spend more $$. Gotta give it them they are smart.

[@melthompson2856]

Bramsgirl201 I’m not sure, but I think I’m going to test it. Use the liquid on one side and the balm on the other to see how they compare

[@iryna3891]

Bramsgirl201 or they want to protect the product, and not have the air come into the bottle maybe ? 🤔

[@stephaniedrayton1671]

Bramsgirl201 I was thinking the same thing, which one lasts longer....

[@ainsleylevesque8985]

It's also more hygenic for people who freelance

[@sozuruQ2]

The liquid one doesn’t ruin your nails and tedious like balm does tho

[@ElysiumPondue]

I’m definitely interested in this one. The original just didn’t do anything for me. I was so annoyed because everyone loves the Silk Canvas balm!

[@karenzxc100]

For the Australian scrollers this has been released at Mecca already online and in store.

[@neilsmyth7077]

Sold out already

[@AussieChick48]

Ha ha I saw that yesterday x

[@AussieChick48]

@@neilsmyth7077 OMG seriously!

[@Cara-39]

I'm very excited for this, especially when you said it feels more hydrating! This is the only primer that has ever extended the wear of my makeup but the balm occasionally emphasizes dry patches.

[@tianiortiz8529]

Miss and love you so much beauty. I will always go back to your videos and comment to keep your channel alive.

[@MzVicky]

I will definitely buy this as I love the original and I also love the Elf Poreless Putty Primer. I know it doesn’t have the skincare benefits but it’s a great alternative if someone doesn’t want to buy the Tatcha one. Great review Mel.

[@MayFlora]

Agreed. I also find the elf to be more smoothing

[@AndiHesk]

Oh I may look at the elf one, my daughter is thinking of doing an order with them. I normally buy the Tarte Smooth operator, but use make up less frequently now and feel it is a waste to buy that. Xx

[@MzVicky]

Minandi Heski I have only tried the original one. I believe they have 3 different ones now. This is the one called Elf Poreless Putty Primer.

[@hmsims3]

Minandi Heski definitely try the Poreless Putty Primer by elf! It’s amazing and definitely comparable to the tatcha - I’ve tried both!

[@tatchabeauty]

Thank you for such an amazing video, Mel. We love you! 💜

[@VeronicaRussek]

I have been doubting whether to get this one or not... My HG primer is MAC's Natural Radiance, it is the one that works best for me! I'm 50, and although I don't have any wrinkles and still have oily skin, my skin is starting to think it is "mature", so I am getting new concerns. Your video just made me say YES! I will get in line when this is released so I can get it.

[@mimichemiere]

I’m definitely getting it! You sold me! But I wanted to try it anyways because I love the original silk canvas already. Your skin looks so good too! Thanks for your in depth review! 🙏🏾

[@jennessicasanchez4919]

I literally just ordered both I figure I’ll use one for winter and one for summer my skin is super oily in summer but in the winter I’m dry so I think they will work amazing!!! You look gorgeous girl

[@Jbal8924]

The original always seemed slightly heavy for me (probably using too much!), so I’ll definitely pick this up!

[@mistyl184]

I’ve been anti-primer for years, but I purchased the original Silk Canvas, and I LOVE it. Definitely going to pick this one up! I’m 42 with dry skin, the original works so wonderfully for me. I’m no longer anti-primer! Ty for the great review Mel! 💕

[@brittneyfrederick1513]

OMG ONE OF THE VIDEOS IVE BEEN waiting FOR! I love the silk canvas but I think the liquid is going to be so different but better

[@dnews13]

Before you said anything I said I liked your right side better because it had a touch more luminosity. And it turned out to be the liquid side!! Can't wait for the release date. Thanks so much for your review!!

[@jenlauren143]

The Silk canvas is my HG of Primers so yes yes I will be getting the liquid and I love how it looked on you 😍😍😍😍

[@marb6866]

I love using the og silk canvas on my face and eyes.....I don't use anything else! Tatcha has to be one of the best skin care brands there is. I also think the prices are not that bad compared to others that are considered high end. I can not wait to try this!! Been counting down the the days🤗

[@amandasawyer4784]

Hi Mel. I’m so glad I stumbled across your amazing review. I can’t live without the Tatcha Silk Canvas. It has totally transformed my makeup application & being 54 with dry dehydrated skin I can actually wear foundation without my skin feeling dry & tight. After watching this I’m definitely going to try the new one as I think being a dry skin sufferer this may be even better for me. You’re absolutely gorgeous & your makeup looks beautiful. Sending love 💕 from the UK 🇬🇧

[@gen7936]

I bought this the day it released. Omg I have not stopped using it. It is sooooooooo good! I absolutely love it! It a lighter formulas and perfect for my oily combo skin. My makeup stayed put even after a long 16 hour day at work.

[@pennylanemitchell3170]

Omg. Literally just wiped off my eye makeup as i was playing with it in mirror...tried OG silk canvas as eye primer. DID NOT WORK.

[@robind2727]

Hi Mel! Great review. Just wish this wasn’t so expensive. $52 for a liquid ounce is a pretty hefty price tag. That price seemed more worth it with the balm as it lasts forever. Thanks for the review! 💕

[@AlexaStyleBook]

I've not tried any Tatcha products yet, have heard some mixed reviews. But always love your opinions💕💕💕

[@christimoisant1305]

The original never seemed to work that great for me (oily skin). Very interested to try this formula. Great review!

[@aprildesjardins8210]

I love the silk canvas but I prefer liquid primers ! I will definitely be trying this one . Thank-you for the review. I do have the hourglass veil liquid primer as well . Do you have an opinion on which you prefer ?

[@karenzxc100]

April Desjardins I need to know too

[@b1000-t1s]

Saaame!!!

[@nadiadncr]

Mel I was wondering about that. I have the silk canvas based on your recommendation and I love it. I tried yesterday their smoothing primer from a Sephora sample and it's the bomb. I love the pump too and after my silk canvas is done I'll get the new one.

[@emiemi6165]

Dear Mel today I recived my dior holo pink highlighter. Im from Germany and I ordered the last two from turkey. It was so expensive😭. But I bought it because I trust you so much. And you are right... Dior holo pink is the best highlighter !! Thank you❤️

[@Heather_isms]

As I'm still struggling with my skin, I'm curious about the new version, especially since I'm drier than you & older. May have to get a sample. ❤

[@deniseb7370]

I am almost out of my original Silk Canvas, so I will definitely try this! I oddly love the little Silk Canvas disc - I have the mini, but I know the other is easier/more sanitary. Thanks for the review!

[@erininottawa]

Mel, can you please test the new liquid primer on your eyes with wet shadows and report back? I have the same problem with crepey lids when I attempt to foil shadows (especially the beautiful metallics from Juvia’s Place). I’ve been looking for a base that might prevent that from happening. Granted, not all of it is going to be completely prevented as I’m a fair bit older than you, but I’ll take what I can get! Thanks as always and much love from Canada! ❤️😘🇨🇦

[@radiantbritt]

The liquid will go so quickly tho! That’s just a marketing ploy to get repurchase clients even faster. I’ll stick with the original. 💕

[@dabigheadboiz4938]

How about the serum stick? Do you like it for priming? I have the silk canvas balm and love it!

[@amysmithssportsandmakeup1397]

Hey Mel- I wanted to let your viewers know that Sydney Grace love palette just went back in stock so I grabbed it and used your affiliate code! I only buy if it receives the MT approval. I'm excited because I've never tried Sydney Grace!

[@stephRN05]

Still watching this angel 👼

[@mamamegs06]

I just love Tatcha so much! My fav skincare brand!

[@robingoblin]

Ooh! Yeah, once I finish my mini balm, I have to try this new one! Thanks, Mel!

[@LMDinNC]

This type of comparison is so helpful. I hope you will continue doing this kind of review (like the two Armani concealers). Your reviews are so thorough. Our choices can be overwhelming sometimes.

[@carriemroczkowski9409]

I must not of gotten a notification for this. I just started to watch your GRWM/new makeup video and you mentioned that you’ve done a video on it. I’m usually not a big primer person but think that this one is going to make me a believer, lol. I just wish that it came it a mini/travel size because I often go foundation free. Thanks for the info, love🍃🌸

[@Eroyo.]

When I saw the liquid version when randomly browsing tatcha on sephora I was excited. I love the original silk canvas and many times I wished it came in a pump. Once it comes out I would still use both since I still have the og. I would use the og for more pore filling around my nose area and the liquid one all over the rest of my face. 😉 Thank you for the comparison video!

[@xgal08]

Look forward to trying this liquid primer! I didn’t see a big difference in the two. Also, I like that you can use it as an eyeshadow primer! Very cool! Thanks for the review!

[@wagnerab1958]

Mel says it's good then I'm buying it! Thank you for another great review. Love love love your channel. I'm looking forward to your review regarding the new Pat Mcgrath concealer, powder and brushes.

[@526mum]

Can't wait to try it! The convenience of the pump has me sold. Although I love the original the packaging is bulky and it is easy to scoop out too much. Being able to put it on like this is a huge bonus - and I need all the hydration I can get with my dry skin.

[@jessicaflores170]

Thank you for this comparison. I have the sample of the liquid one and the full size of the original. I hardly use the original but have been loving the new liquid one. Now I am set on finishing my original one so I can buy the full size of the liquid.

[@TxYelowRose]

I am definitely going to try this. I use the regular Tatcha now so I will most likely like the new one. I’m especially interested in it for the eyes. My eyelids are so dry I think this might be a good answer to that. Thanks so much for your review of this product. I love your enthusiasm and your “simple” eye look Would it be possible for you to show us a tutorial on a couple of your “simple”eye looks? Honestly they are some of my favorites. 💖💖💖

[@JoAnnaTheSoulStringerJohnson]

I'm excited for this!!! I live Tatcha! They are a top notch brand. I've been putting the putty on my lids as a primer to make my shadows pop as well. I just love Tatcha!!! 💖

[@vanessaladescarada165]

I want to see you review the new pat mac graph concealer and pressed powder😜

[@radiantbritt]

vanessa la descarada the powder is so chalky! Try the hourglass Ambient Lighting Powder in Etheral or Diffused Light instead ❤️

[@vanessaladescarada165]

@@radiantbritt hmn i had a bad experience with the hourglass dim light but maybe the others color are better

[@radiantbritt]

vanessa la descarada dim light is the worst, I didn’t like it either! Try the other 2... under the eyes they are unlike anything else I’ve ever tried.

[@blackathena1565]

Kinky Sweat did a review of the PMG powder and concealer. She also compared it to Hourglass and will be doing Armani

[@vanessaladescarada165]

@@blackathena1565 i saw it very good review as usual from kinky.But i would also like to know mel point of view on it

[@suecone2198]

I think the right side did look more hydrated so I will be purchasing. I put a piece of tape on top of my top of the cream one so I can keep track of it. It is so small it is easy to lose that’s for sure. Thanks

[@reneeb9021]

Great review! I’ve wanted to try the balm. Trust your opinion. Your makeup is always perfection. 💕

[@ruthlogan5354]

I'm definitely going to buy some. I've never tried the other formula but I would like the hydration. I just received the new Tatcha lip balm you recommended last week . I love it! It feels so good on my lips. I love your eye look in this video. It's so simple and elegant. Would you consider doing a tutorial doing this look? Thanks for your hard work

[@MoMakeupMoBeauty]

Great Review! 👍🏽 Tatcha putting it in a pump form is amazing! Can’t wait to try it, because I LOVE the original.

[@mortypickles]

So excited to try this! Thanks so much for the comparison - so helpful! I am one of those people who did not have luck with the original Silk Canvas. I just don’t think it was right for my more mature, dry skin. Based on your video, though, I’m definitely going to test out the new liquid.

[@Nerdydiva12]

Couldn't really see a difference. I'm definitely going to try this. Your makeup looked flawless.

[@deboraho6779]

Good Morning Mel 🌞! I think you hit the nail on the head! I think putting this into a pump makes it easier. It also helps with bacteria control, containing it in a pump, which might allow longer shelf life!🤷🏼‍♀️ Plus, I feel I have better control over a pump on how much product I use. Even though there is the little disk to dig out product in the original, sometimes one can grab too much and then there is the cross contamination when putting product back the excess into the pan. Those are just my own thoughts. (No I’m not a germaphobe🤦🏼‍♀️🤣🤣🤣). After watching this, I’d be interested in trying out a small one to see if I like it better than my current favorite primers! Thanks for the info and review! 🤗💗💐💫👍🏼

[@truewants]

thanks for doing this! Also get excited when a product I enjoy gets a different version with an easier application! Now added to my wants list!

[@shanekiapaul3229]

Your videos are always the best! Yes! Because of you, I’ll be picking this up. Thank you for the review.

[@mati261000]

We miss you so much sweet Mel.

[@gypsydoll14]

OOOHHH THAT LIP COLOR LOOKS GORGEOUS ON YOU! ❤️

[@vikkki]

I always have a hard time opening the packaging of the original Silk Canvas so I'm so excited for the pump version!

[@stephaniedrayton1671]

Great review! Loved the Natural look during the wear test, just stunning...Thanks for the tip about it being an eye shadow primer...👌🏽❤️

[@sharone7479]

Hi Mel, what’s your impression as to how long each product will last, meaning a month, two months etc.? Thanks for the review. Beautiful look as always. 😊

[@AussieChick48]

Hey @melthompson You can make cream shadows with the original Silk Canvas too. Just a scraping of a powder shadow mixed with a little of the SC and vòila. Cream shadow. Can prime the lips too 💋

[@Scangirl2149]

The extra moisture is great for my drier skin during the winter. I Will have to try it.

[@faithb8723]

How did you do your eyes? Is it powder or sticks? Would love to see a video on how you do it. Great job by the way!

[@heatherjames3693]

Good I couldn’t stand getting in the container and scooping out the original. Love your earrings

[@loralee3232]

Very excited about the liquid Tatcha primer! Thank you for reviewing before it’s even out! I could not see the difference but if you say it’s more moisturizing yahoo!!

[@lianabeth]

i was curious about the difference but decided not to wait. i've just repurchased the original

[@aprillovesjulio]

I will definitely picking this up as soon as I'm done the primer I'm using.

[@tonihicks1779]

I wonder since the new one is a pump if you will use it up sooner. The balm is so easy to control how much I use. Any thoughts?

[@mrs_pinkmist]

can i use the liquid silk canvas to thin my foundation out?

[@lindaliffers9690]

Thanks for comparison! I have the balm and can't wait to try the liquid. Curious if you would have an opinion on how it compares to Hourglass liquid Veil??

[@audreyso1201]

Puffin is back !!!! ha ha, it looks great on you, I love it when you do simple makeup, lots of mascara and lipstick

[@melthompson2856]

audrey so thank you!!! This is one of my favorite looks too... and sooooo easy! Lol

[@leahmiranda8359]

Thank you....I've been wondering about this. Another way I use the original is kind of weird. I'm not a fan of facial mists, so I pat a little of the Silk canvas on my under eye crinkles. It smoothes them out really well, without ruining the powder on the rest of my face. 😂

[@thebeauteatalk]

Yeah when the balm version came out the Tatcha owner did a IG story showin how much more vibrant eyeshadow looks over top of the silk canvas balm vs not!

[@corbitt61]

I'm just curious of whether the container of the balm version would last longer than the liquid. Maybe you could do an empties comparison of how long it takes to go through the balm vs. how long it takes to go through the bottle.

[@melissabaker6810]

So the new one spreads easier? I feel like i need more than recommended to cover my face, maybe I'll feel like I'm actually using enough if the liquid spreads better!

[@nevertooold6498]

I love The Silk Canvas; I was planning on ordering this as soon as it's released. Now I can't wait! Thanks Mel! Take care, Ginny 😘😘😘

[@foxymama2003]

Mel approved! It will be in my cart the day it comes out!

[@AshleyLamora]

I'm glad to know when this comes out. I order all the time and never saw the deluxe sample yet. I'm going to check and order something

[@megdvs21]

Late to the party on this but it seems like they somehow took the same formula and made one for oilier skin AND one for drier skin which I’d love to see more brands do with their primers I just ordered the mini size To do a wear test with it ... looking forward to seeing how I like it 🙂

[@lesleysingletary1493]

Can’t wait to try this! I love your eye look!

[@SoutheastbyMidwestBeauty]

Sephora currently has this as a free sample with a $XYZ purchase (Can't remember if it's $25 or $35) I'm glad that I picked this as my sample to try when I placed my order earlier this morning.

[@jaysonakridge]

Just caught you on Wayne's channel and instantly fell in love! Can't wait to dig through your catalog! 🌼🌸🌷

[@melthompson2856]

The Akridges ❤️❤️❤️❤️thank you for stopping by!! 😍

[@kellywolfe5930]

Hopefully they have a mini size like they do with the original tatcha primer 💙💛💟💚💜

[@angiedaniels5357]

I dont wear foundation anymore due to wrinkles, but I'm wondering if Silk Canvas would be good to wear alone. What are your thoughts?

[@LivingCavalier]

I truly can't wait for it to come out. I love the Silk Canvas for my dry skin.

[@akcj1]

I loved my silk canvas at first but I don’t like it at all now. I’m going to try the liquid when it comes out. Hopefully I’ll love it like I loved the balm at first.

[@killerfootsteps]

Queen A why don't you like it anymore? It is such an AMAZING product 😻

[@paofacu]

First review I’ve seen of this one!!! Ekkkkso exciting!!!!

[@mollzz]

I need to repurchase this soon. Now I’m torn on if I should try the other version!

[@jamaica72001]

It would be interesting to see how each of these perform and if there is more of a difference in hot summer weather.

[@irisk934]

First review I've seen for this. I'm definitely interested, thank you Mel!

[@alisamarie3377]

I feel like I'm the only one tatcha Silk canvas doesn't work for. I've tried so many times with different foundations and every time it looks awful.

[@lilb9181]

Alisa Marie it was oily for me, and I’m normal to dry skin.

[@emmawhite3354]

Didn’t work for me either. Really tried hard to like it but nope. It hates me.

[@skylarnorris3575]

It only works for me if I’m just using a tinted moisturizer over it. Then I get a smooth finish that seems to gradually fade throughout the day instead of sliding (which most makeup usually does after a while). But if I use it under a medium or full coverage foundation it’s moving within minutes, even if I only use a tiny bit.

[@kuromiii444]

i bought it after seeing so many people rave about it. I decided to test it out a day I had work and barely a few hours into my shift my coworkers asks me why my face looked so oily! I ran to the breakroom and saw that my makeup looked absolutely horrendous! I knew it was the primer forsure since I didn't change anything else in my routine. Right now the only primer that gives me amazing results is YSL's touche eclat blur primer. I've gone through 2 1/2 containers of them since 2017 and it never fails to make my makeup look flawless and smooth but it keeps it looking that way throughout the day too. I've worn that stuff in the GA pit of a BTS concert and my makeup still looked pretty good after LOL

[@Samzena]

Alisa OMG the first time I bought the first primer I was so confused. It didnt do jack for me and my base was all type of mess. Recently I bought the liquid one and guess what .... it performed the same as the fenty hydrating primer. I did a review on it on my channel.... sooo ya dear u r not the only one. feel u!

[@Shorty52700]

I love my silk canvas so I am definitely interested to try the new version! I love a pump!!!

[@millersunearthed]

Mel, do you have a preference between the Tatcha Gold Spun Balm and the Kissu Lip Mask?

[@JoyeSmith]

Your skin looks amazing...Both sides looked the same to me but Im sure you could feel the difference if one was more hydrated. I have trouble with the silk canvas. I feel like i cn see my pores more when I use it and I have small pores...my foundations don't seem to play well with it...Boo Hoo....maybe the liquid wood work better for me?

[@valerievalois6263]

Mel, are you going to review the Victoria Beckham primer? Thanks for all the great reviews. 😊

[@kennymoore8502]

What is the best primer & full coverage foundation for oily acne prone skin and also is good and benefits the skin?

[@AudreyTrullinger]

I HATE the original silk canvas but I just bought the liquid so I’m really hoping I like it better!!!

[@Tailored_Talons]

I saw no difference. Your skin is just so beautiful! 😭👏🏻

[@DeborahCarlston]

There are several Tatcha products that I love, but the balm primer was a total bust for me. I kept trying to like it. So much so that I missed the return window and ended up throwing it away. So I really hope Sephora offers a deluxe sample of this before I buy, because Tatcha is pricey. Plus I went back to my old Smashbox and it still works best. Also, is it just my iPad? Every time you guys have commercials in the middle of your videos I lose the sound and have to turn the sound off then on to get it back. Had to ask. Thanks for the video. 💚

[@catnip4587]

You are wearing my favorite of your lpsticks❤️ I like the balm but dont like to stick in my fingers in it. Of curse the little disk is lost

[@fraddtastic]

I love the original silk canvas. Can't wait to try this one!!