Nier: Automata Review | The Masterpiece You (Probably) Won't Play

Nier: Automata- I can't recall ever being so captivated by a game. At least not in the last decade. I think maybe I'm going a little crazy. Regardless, I haven't been able to string a single non-Nier related thought together this week as this review has all but consumed me. Even now, I am still deeply unhappy with it as I feel it does not do the game justice. But I know I wouldn't be happy with anything I produce at this point, so my hope is that you enjoy this review more than I did, and if you hadn't thought to purchase and play Nier, that you might revisit that decision.
This cannot continue...
Check out this week’s videos:
Destiny 2 Release Date Revealed!
• Destiny 2 | Release Da...
Mass Effect Andromeda Multiplayer Beginner’s Guide
• Video
Mass Effect Andromeda: The Review
• Mass Effect Andromeda ...
If you’d like to donate to support me going full time on KZbin, you can do so here:
strexm.tv/user/skill_up_gg
Don’t forget to like and subscribe :)
====
Follow me on Twitter: @skillupYT
Check out Skill-Up on Facebook over at skillupgg
Follow me on Twitch over at: / skill_up_gg
If you'd like to Donate to show support, you can do so at: strexm.tv/user/skill_up_gg
My monitor, courtesy of ViewSonic:
www.viewsonic.com.au/products/...

[@MrJackstar123]

Do you guys remember when PUBG was nominated for game of the year over this game? Well I'm still upset about it.

[@meblijebli2152]

People have no taste

[@hittman1412]

most western games are trash money grabs now with near zero innovation/imagination.

[@rinpls2451]

Bob Ross weeb

[@hittman1412]

Rin Pls profile pic lmao

[@rinpls2451]

Bob Ross lol

[@butmunch19121993]

The worst thing about this game is never being able to play it for the first time again.

[@mynameisozymandias7150]

And that it finishes (great ending, thought).

[@benjaminbyham7839]

i mean, as long as you beat it once you can...

[@PenguinsAreColdish]

i'm replaying it again after like a year after forgetting a lot of the details. it's still great

[@Dukefazon]

Right! I had many awe moments I won't be able to re-experience. But I can deepen my knowledge on the subject and keep finding new stuff to awe about. Check out Clemps's videos on the series for example :)

[@Nightsaberban]

Lol

[@Rakka5]

"And Nier is the caliber of masterpiece that's true value can only be discerened many years after it has arrived" 5 years later, and these words came completely true.

[@cloudshines812]

6 years today :)

[@eva-vv4db]

Game is so fresh till this day

[@colwellalec]

Yeah he was very on point with that comment

[@nightfears3005]

Then you are LOST! This is a teenybopper, emo, angst joke of a game!

[@smgb4087]

​@@nightfears3005corny comment, go get some bread and hoes

[@vjat65akvj]

From the bottom of my heart, thank you Skillup for reintroducing this masterpiece to me. I had given up at ending A but you made me go back and play it all the way to ending E. Thank you, This was one of the most memorable and amazing gaming experiences I've ever had.

[@MemeLordCrusader]

Can you tell me what was special about endings c thru e I was kinda left with a feeling of HUH

[@vjat65akvj]

If I were to explain, I'd probably end up writing an essay here.

[@MaxiChannel16]

@@MemeLordCrusader Have you not played them? A is basically the prologue of the story. B is a quick replay through the story through the perspective of 9S, this is the weakest point f the game but there are many things still to learn. C however, is the whole second half of the game, and what makes it truly special. D is an alternate ending to C (without spoiling anything, you can quickly select the final mission after what ever ending you get and make the other choice). And E is the ACTUAL ending, is is quite possibly the most memorable and best executed video game ending. PLEASE. If you had any interest while playing A, do yourself a favor and go back. Look up a guide for some of the 9S specific B run side missions, otherwise blast through the main story and get to route C :)

[@MemeLordCrusader]

@MaxiChannel16 I've played ending e everyone dies, but they get repaired after bullshitily difficult end credits because I didn't have an online subscription

[@MaxiChannel16]

@@MemeLordCrusader lmao, each to their own I guess

[@illusionarywallahead1184]

You see a weird Japanese hack and slash starring a French maid dominatrix and say hell yeah

[@hotdog5927]

pixelated? bruh that ass is 4K HIGH RES MASTER CLASS SCULPTED BY THE GODS

[@JackgarPrime]

+Yuki Takeda "Jokingly"

[@ivxwiv6692]

Illusionary wall ahead japanese are the one who created hack and slash

[@viceanterra3]

WaifuBeater Aren't we all?

[@FimbongBass]

bruh that ass is so perfect, it actually jiggles

[@froztbytesyoutubealt3201]

Bought it. Played it.(cried, questioned my existence, cried again) Worth it.

[@hansross7417]

On pc? Thinkin of buying it, but alot ssy its buggy

[@eval_is_evil]

Ok that's too much dude

[@jesseh9125]

Hans Ross the game was made for the PS4, so if you have one, definitely go that route. And yeah, the pc version gets pretty buggy

[@teeman7137]

MJPJAH the community fix it with a mod

[@jesseh9125]

Teeman for real? That’s awesome!

[@down2earth485]

SO so SO many songs in this game sent shivers down my spine, and the mood it sets for the scenes make them go down like medicine into your psyche

[@Autumnblueskies1]

I totally agree- the soundtrack gives me goosebumps and brings back so many memories..

[@arzosahsothy]

The live concert is incredible. look it up If you haven't seen it.

[@heysiri3327]

BECOME AS GODS

[@dv8574]

@@heysiri3327KAMI NI NARU

[@snbrmn9015]

It’s a top 3 video game sound track EASILY. My favorite of all time.

[@piano1350]

This game is still a masterpiece, 5 year later. Edit: Now 7 years. Hopefully we get a remaster in upcoming years

[@mahmoodhassansyed]

Giga Chad

[@user-uu5hc9gj1l]

That ' hobots screwing hobots ' scene tho 😂 🎉 🥳

[@monarchlaciel3057]

"You look at the cover image and see a weird japanese hack n slash starring some kinky french maid dominatrix and you say 'No thanks'" You misspelt "Yes Please"

[@catburglar82]

Exactly. What crazy, uncultured weirdo says no to that. Everyone who says no thanks to 2B is dead to me.

[@Silent.Watcher]

@@catburglar82 Preach, brothers!

[@Thesupremeone34]

I literally spent 3 years doing odd jobs and saving money to build a pc just to play this game because I saw a weird Japanese hack n slash starring some kinky french maid dominatrix and said "oh *fuuuuck* yes"

[@xanmanskaggs216]

He missaid yes please

[@mahoobarc1439]

UNDERRATED COMMENT

[@TheRealGuywithoutaMustache]

Not only is the story an actual masterpiece, but the soundtracks are transcendental.

[@sherdil3717]

Sup bro

[@sloth9721]

Easily my favorite soundtrack ever. I was enchanted when I first went to the amusement park

[@shawnalexandernoticemesenpai]

I got gamers thumb so im down a few weeks, using the time to get familiar with the ost and oh boy, it's amazing 😍

[@Fil007kk]

We meet again

[@braixendon5496]

Im glad i found you here, i never took you for one of being that of culture

[@leekyonion]

All these years later and this game lives in my head rent free and I cry every time I think about it. This game has aged like fine wine even though I haven't touched it in years. I love it that much.

[@adrammelech6323]

I still regularly search for people going through ending E on youtube. It's a masterpiece.

[@ausar567]

Time to see if the Anime will do the same

[@fractalfae5418]

It's a truly haunting experience. Even after all this time, even just hearing a clip of the music can evoke fresh tears. This and Life Is Strange completely changed how I saw 'gaming'.

[@fractalfae5418]

@@ausar567 Yoko Taro is on board as screenwriter and early reviews of Ep 1 are positive, so prospects look good.

[@linkszxx]

Doing my first playthrough right now

[@WilliumBobCole]

In this game FILLED with truly profound moments, none moved me more than during the true credits sequence, (SPOILERS AHEAD) with the insanely difficult bullet hell survival, and messages from other players accumulating every time I died offering words of encouragement, and the offer of a helping hand. I tried so hard to listen to the ones who said I could do it alone, but in the end I accepted the help, and holy FUCK when all the chorus voices join in the soundtrack, moved me to actual tears! Then when I finally beat that section, I was asked to give a message to other players, so naturally I offered myself as help to them, only to be told that if I wanted to help, it would require deleting my save data. I had spent so much time gathering and levelling my items and weapons, I thought I would just go back to chapter select and get 100%, but the game *insisted* it was not kidding around. I hesitated, I could have gone back and changed my message to one of encouraging a solo win, but I felt so inspired by my experience that, even though my individual contribution to someones game will have very little weight, it meant a lot to me, in a pay-it-forward kind of way, that I was willing to make that sacrifice. Right up until checking the main menu, I had some doubt that it would REALLY go that far, but my GOD do i respect the balls to LEGITIMATELY make you give up something of such personal value, for this almost invisible selfless act. I *mourned* my data, but I wasn't mad. I was a lot of emotions, but all of the kind to where I now hold videogames as a medium to a vastly greater standard.

[@Mefistofy]

I felt the same. I'm glad I chose this ending and that the end really was final. Gives the story gravitas I have rarely experienced otherwise.

[@blarblablarblar]

I literally only bought this game because it had an anime aesthetic and people were recommending it. I then went on to have an existential crisis and then possibly a spiritual experience.

[@shirori2004]

Right

[@Myphor2003]

Lmao same but I’m gonna get it now

[@justinwolf148]

Literally me.

[@zaqareemalcolm]

*existential robot butts*

[@GrillerGT]

@@zaqareemalcolm Heck, that's also part of the spiritual experience xD

[@dxBIGBOSSxb]

Yoko Taro sent me here from one of his tweets. You got YOKO TARO TO ACKNOWLEDGE YOU! Damn fine review!

[@FlattyMchesterson]

Big Boss he did!? I wanna see

[@dxBIGBOSSxb]

Fan XD Square Enix Look up Yoko Taro's twitter. Its one of his few current tweets in english.

[@ACE_dll]

Found it: twitter.com/yokotaro/status/849523282193920000

[@FlattyMchesterson]

ACE Video kinda late but ty ^^

[@ACE_dll]

Your welcome ;)

[@James-rc1tw]

I don't know if you read these, particularly not on a 5 year old video, but, you made a big point in this video about wanting to encourage one person to play this game. I picked it up a long time ago, played it a little and gave up. I had the same opinion as you, "anime ass, meh, not for me." Later I came across your review and it convinced me to try it again. I can't thank you enough for it, it was an experience I'll never forget. The past week with all this SadFuntago content resparked that excitement, which again I wouldn't have had without this review. This may well be the most beautifully constructed and well reasoned review you, or anyone else I've ever seen, has created. It more than does the game justice. So thank you, again, for convincing me to take a chance on some anime dominatrix maid.

[@Heinrick192]

I went in completely blind, and it made my experience one that challenged my future expectations for all narrative-driven video games, and film, for that matter. It is a stunning achievement in medium, and absolutely shatters the notion that video games cannot be considered as enlightened or inspired as "proper art". I would go further, and say it easily surpasses well-known fiction in artistic mediums more commonly utilized for this type of story, like film, an anime, manga, or novel. Thousands of commenters over the course of six years are not wrong. If you are finding this review, and haven't played Automata, get on board. Bring tissues.

[@younusimam-thesalamproject6340]

Absolutely a triumph.

[@Aisatsana1971]

Meh, it wasn’t for me.

[@minescape1309]

@@Aisatsana1971 and that's fine! video games aren't created equally, what you may like may someone else not like, and vice versa. That is the beauty of video games: they don't HAVE to cater to every person.

[@Aisatsana1971]

@@minescape1309 i mean i *wanted* to like it…i’m under the impression that this sort of game is for anime fans if anything.

[@minescape1309]

@@Aisatsana1971 well, I may not be an anime fan, but I still found this game to be fun to play, not for the artstyle, but due to the combat mechanics being a hack'n'slash (aside from the flying sections). The story, although good, the entire "play through the game 5 times to experience it in its entirety" thing got really tiring after like the 3rd playthrough, so it may be good, but tedious to get through.

[@MrJackstar123]

It's criminal that this game wasnt even nominated for game of the year.

[@tiphotisted]

Zylph It did win a few, just not from very reputable sites. Most of those better known sites like IGN and Gamespot caved in to the Zelda nostalgia

[@coletrainhetrick]

Zylph at least we got pubg... Because it made a ton of money... Right?

[@damntrain639]

Because it doesn't deserved

[@nutmalone5527]

Damn Train amazing grammar

[@damntrain639]

so what english is not my mother tongue

[@TbagCentral]

I knew this was an amazing game when a stamp collection side quest in the amesument park ended with 6 robots performing a twisted, hilarious version of Romeo and Juliet and murdering each other

[@CorryWith2rs]

I just Made A Video Called, 2B IS A ROBOT KILLING MECHINE! [NieR Automata] #1 IF you Have Time Can You Check It Out

[@fkoda4194]

Is this game on PS4 too?

[@MarkusNapp]

@@fkoda4194 yes

[@OEpistimon]

Fr that stuff was mad "Romeo, I'll punch the shit out of thee!" "Pisseth off!!"

[@breakmanradio2530]

Sounds great. Which is why I'm not gonna watch this stupid anime that isn't a prequel or a sequel to the video games story. It's just a weak ass summary of the video games story. Why would u spoil that people who haven't played the game? And why would people who played the game want to see the exact same story retold to them when they lived in it the video game? Lazy ass anims studio. Be creative. Its literally your only goddamn job.

[@design-flux]

This video is what inspired me to buy my PS4 and NieR: Automata 4 years ago. I find myself returning to your video occasionally, and each time I do, I do another play through of the game. As a gamer for roughly thirty-five years, It's hands down one of my favorite titles of all-time. Without your video I would've missed out on this, and I'm ever so thankful.

[@mooseot]

I know we're over half a decade since you made this, I bounced off Nier when it first came out, played a couple hours, died the first time and never went back. I always avoided spoilers cause I knew it was a story heavy game, but then about 2 weeks ago I saw your video in my feed. I felt almost personally attacked by the title of your video, so I went back and played it over the course of the last 10 days, and wow were you right. So glad I caught a glimpse of your thumbnail, and now I'm back to watch the vid. :)

[@Zaszol0]

I know this will get buried, but this review convinced me to buy Nier - Automata. I finished the final ending less than an hour ago. I don't think I will ever forget this experience as long as I live. Thank you for this video, Skill Up. Thank you, Platinum Games and Yoko Taro and every single soul who poured their heart into this masterpiece. If you are the gamer that looks for art in games, this is for you. Even if you aren't, this experience is worth your time. 10/10, probably my favorite game I've ever played. This is my second comment on youtube ever. That's how important this game is.

[@jasondp3546]

Zaszol0 is this game that good man to beat it 5 times for real ending

[@eamonnjoyce6690]

Jason dp it is but really after u get the first ending u play through the first part as your partner 9S and once u get to where u got ending A and get ending B the second half of the game comes into play as u will get the choice to play as 9S or A2 and by completing their segments do u gain access to the finale where u can get the final three endings P.S of u are interested in the endings and want to know how to get them fairly spoiler free go to the nier automata fextralife wiki it's really good for help in the game

[@jasondp3546]

Eamonn Joyce so it's worth it ty gonna c what it's all about

[@andrefrazier8653]

this and another review convinced me to buy this game two days ago. waiting for it to arrive. Im a bit skeptical.. and my standards are kinda high just coming off of Horizon Zero Dawn and currently playing the ever creative Dishonored 2. this seems very interesting... looking forward to this... hopefully im not let down like Dragon Age Inq let me down lolll

[@Jonathon_woods]

if its anything like the first nier you are in for one hell of a ride my friend

[@snowcatss1]

Hey man, 2 years late but this review finally convinced me to buy the game. 45 hours later, got all endings, and it's genuinely one of the best games I've ever played. Thank you

[@UnknownUser-uk2gx]

I only got it because of Game Pass, and I could never have imagined how much I would have loved it. I put 30 hours into my first 3 days of having the game, and got all endings and achievements after 55 hours. It was a hell of a rollercoaster

[@Bobandy902]

I just erased all 48 hours of gameplay and one redoing the whole thing again and 100% it

[@boxerheadninja4281]

I'm going to pick this game up and give it a try however I ain't the type to replay a game multiple times, I always move on the the next game once I beat it, the only time I keep a game is when dlc is announced for it which is why I still have doom eternal, I mean yo can't blame me, I gotta play ghost of Tsushima then last of us 2 and before all that I still gotta play dmc5, I seriously don't have time to keep playing one game, the only time I replay a game is if it's that good, but that's very rare for me to want to replay a game, there is only 2 games in the world I replayed a lot, and that was Uncharted 2 and Borderlands 2

[@snowcatss1]

@@boxerheadninja4281If you enjoy the game, it's really worth replaying. Each play-through is completely unique, with different characters, and story elements each time, so it isn't repetitive at all. You won't get anywhere near the full story from one play-through. But yeah, I understand, especially if you've got all of that to finish

[@boxerheadninja4281]

@@snowcatss1 I'm not saying I won't replay it multiple times but Im sure as hell ain't getting all 27 endings, like i said I gotta keep moving forward, I would need to quit my job if I want to be playing non stop lol

[@canisdivinus6218]

I still come back and watch this every once in a while. Marvelous work shill up this is so good

[@WizzlyBearW0rms]

Is the combat hood though

[@James-gj8rn]

I'm so glad someone gave this fantastic soundtrack the praise it deserves and yes it is absolutely the best video game soundtrack of all time (the Amusement Park music is the best from it because it has the build up when you first enter, it stays quite simple but as you go deeper in, more gets added until the fantastic vocals kick in, my jaw hit's the floor and i get chills from it, man i love this soundtrack so much)

[@LouLikestowatch]

Nier wasn't just a game, it was an experience. One of my most treasured games. Music that brought me to tears, especially that last credit roll

[@TheKnightDrag0n]

That game left me feeling empty inside.

[@Syle3]

@@TheKnightDrag0n There's gonna be Nier : Replicant in 2021. dw.

[@narukamii1]

@@Syle3 I'm hype

[@jonathanramirez3109]

I’ll never forget the whole experience and specially the credits

[@kobainage]

Which one?

[@duncanthaw6858]

Two years later, the game is virtually forgotten. Not by me, though.

[@amircat1009]

Duncan Thaw great game

[@duncanthaw6858]

@@amircat1009 Great but forgotten. Basically, the Bloodlines of this generation.

[@Mygrandpaspodcast]

Her name was 2B

[@matrinezkevin11492]

How is it forgotten? Its still getting crossovers with other established franchises like Soul Calibur and Final Fantasy on top of basically saving platinum games from bankruptcy and allowing them to continue making games. Hell, bayonetta 3 probably wouldn't even be a thing if not for this game. It might not be on everyone's lips at all times but few games this decade have had as big of an impact as Nier:Automata and im positive its success hasn't been forgotten.

[@duncanthaw6858]

@@matrinezkevin11492 >implying Soul Calibur and FF are relevant any more I don't know about Platinum Games for now, but it sure seems they are shooting themselves in the foot with the completely botched release of the Game of YoRHa Edition a few days back.

[@Razzle-yer-Dazzle]

I started playing it a couple weeks ago and finished Ending E a few hours ago. I did a good amount of side quests and collected about the half the weapons as i usually only play games for the story. However, I can't wait to start it over again and put more focus into it. This game has so much emotion and it had me fucking invested in the story and characters. I even bought Nier: Replicant so i could experience that now as well

[@jordankit1648]

How is Replicant?

[@Razzle-yer-Dazzle]

@@jordankit1648 overall it's pretty good. I've put in 19 hours and i'm not dure how much i have left to go. Be prepared to get a lil annoyed with loading screens to different areas, it's not open world like Automata The story as it's gone on has gotten me pretty intrigued too. I like the characters but it feels like the development/relationship between a couple of them felt a little rushed imo. Just like Automata, the difference between normal and hard mode is a big jump. In Normal, i can slaughter a group of enemies with relative ease. Whereas in Hard mode i couldn't even kill the entire group of the same enemies and i died like 4 times before switching back to normal to kill em. That might just be me being awful though lol. The side quests are very much just kinda getting supplies and running errands for people, but there were a couple so far that made me sit back and really think about the choice i wanted to make. Plus, the side the quests are how you make the money and it is cool cuz it lets you get a better feel of the society. The scenery in some shots is pretty too. Some of the dialogue can be a little cringe but overall it's fine. The music is good too but for me not as great as Automata, but that is a tough soundtrack to beat. The combat play is pretty similar to Automata as well. I'd say the biggest thing for me was at the beginning with the genre change going from a science fiction-style game to one with medieval/fantasy vibes but i'm used it now. I'd recommend it, it's been a fun play so far.

[@jordankit1648]

@@Razzle-yer-Dazzle thanks for that brother. dope review!

[@Razzle-yer-Dazzle]

@@jordankit1648 no problem man!

[@rikuexe9082]

This review single Handedly shaped my 2021. Watched this review early in the year and decided to play it. 1 year later and I’m still in awe of this game, played replicant remaster that came out in the ps4, decided to look more into this lore and lord and behold I bought a ps3 to play drakengard 3. Months later I’m playing NieR Reincarnation. The stories and the way everything is presented has changed my view of gaming. Like many people say, I wish I could experience this story all over again for the first time.

[@eyezonli]

My only complaint about Nier is I can't wipe my own memory to experience it again for the first time. The wonder, the thoughtfulness, the deepness, everything was absolutely perfect.

[@beennot503]

About to experience it for the first time!! Super excited

[@rafaelmarkos4489]

I have nought but this to say - the greatness of a story is not measured in how it affects you the first time, but in its ability to draw you back for the 100th, even when you know exactly what will happen. It's why people come back to Shakespeare, and I hope this stands the test of civilizational time in the same fashion. I know it has stood the test of time for me. I hope you can find enjoyment in having suspense where once there was surprise.

[@intercontinentalballisticben]

agreed

[@birisuandrei1551]

I just started playing it for the first time and its so neat! I don't regret getting this game, absolutely wonderful, the moves of the character are epic and all the details of the game are mind blowing.... Finding my body at the bridge where the boss battle at the start of the game happens surprised me , as i didn't even know you can go back there and get the big sword back, i love how you can combo the two swords together.

[@HuxianXD]

That's how i felt about Subnautica so I might give this game a try.

[@ValiusTrigger]

Consider your 7 days worth while, I'm buying the game just because your review.

[@eduh7950]

ValiusTrigger same here

Same here. I just bought and installed the game and I'll take it for a spin as soon as the kids are asleep!

[@moetezouelhazi5699]

ValiusTrigger hey tbh im still hesitating did u truly think its worth it?

[@ValiusTrigger]

Moetez Ouelhazi Well to be HONEST, i have not played past a short amount. I started trying to level up something and was make things easier. But an issue I have with the game is it heavy reliance on skill and reaction time of the player over it rpg qualities. Don't expect hours of collecting money and upgrading things to show too big of a difference like in a nirmal rpg. Even games like Devil May Cry and God of War make more use of the rpg a qualities. I also found the general gameplay pretty repetitive despite dishing hours of upgrades into completely different weapon types.

[@ValiusTrigger]

Moetez Ouelhazi please don't get me wrong I think that the game is pretty fun it's just not quite as amazing as I had my expectations set. They really missed out on some great couch co-op opportunities too as most games these days.

[@Tohlemiach]

Your comment near the beginning that perhaps it will take a while before people properly appreciate this game in light of what comes after is so spot on. I only just played this game around this time last year, and since that time, I haven't played any other game that has come remotely close to matching the brilliance of this game's story and immersive narrative. Even now thinking back on the last TEN years, even, I still don't think anything comes close. It's as if this game has completely altered my emotional memory, and now I can't even remember what I used to consider "good" before this game came along. I definitely remember really getting emotionally invested in Ghost of Tsushima, God of War, Nier Replicant, Returnal, etc, but for each one of them, there was just something about them that just didn't "click" completely. Returnal didn't have enough of an emotional punch, Ghost of Tsushima felt a little too cheesy with how the uncle was so uptight about not using certain war tactics cuz "we samurai yo", God of War is literally half a story, and Nier Replicant has moments here and there that I thought were a little contrived and took me out of the moment (like Devola and Popola near the end of each route) and having to play through the exact same sequences of events so many times really soured the experience for me more than anything else. Nier Automata, on the other hand, only continues to get better and better in my memories, and with each passing story I continue to encounter after it, it only looks better by comparison. Nothing has made this more clear than the existence of Xenoblade Chronicles 3. I have been a mega fan of the series since Xenogears, which I actually only finished about a year after beating the original Xenoblade Chronicles back in 2012. Xenogears is a story like Nier Automata in my mind, i.e. one that hits literally every spot it possibly could and hits them at light speed. I've been watching through a playthrough of Xenosaga and I desperately want to get back to part 3, but it's been so long that I would need to start over at this point, and I will say I think it has potential to also be an incredible story on the same level as Xenogears, but I can't say yet. Anyways, I love Xenoblade Chronicles, but the story was not nearly as personal nor complex as Xenogears, so as great as the overall experience was, it still didn't eclipse Xenogears for me. Then Xenoblade Chronicles 2 came out, and other than a really cool twist near the very end, it was basically just a shounen/harem rom-com anime story, and it fucking sucks most of the time. I've harbored a grudge against that game for the last 5 years because I was expecting a story at LEAST as good as Xenoblade, but secretly I was hoping that maybe somehow Tetsuya Takahashi could find it in himself to actually make something as good as Xenogears again. That was an unrealistic hope, but man, he didn't need to disappoint THAT hard. Then Xenoblade 3 was announced. This time SURELY, I thought, we can finally get a good Takahashi story for the first time in over 10 years. There's no way the man could really have wasted an entire decade of his life making stories that aren't worth consuming, right? And for a time, I was convinced that Xenoblade 3 was a success. It starts off fantastically with grounded characters that completely avoid cringe anime tropes, no pointless sexualization, just "regular" anime stuff that used to be around before Sword Art Online popularized the adaptation of terrible light novels into mega hit anime. Things were going great, the story had a solid direction, and about 4/5ths of the way through the game we hit an emotional climax that had me crying through about a solid hour of cutscenes. It was brutal, it was effective. I was IN the story. It HAD me. And then the rest of the game happened. What followed was the most boring snow level ever created, a hyped up area called "The Cloudkeep" that was actually just a cube with 3 staircases and a boss fight at the top, a lore dump that amounted to "things sort of just happened and now we're here", a fetch quest throughout the rest of the world you've already explored, and a final dungeon. Throughout all of this, the story evolves thusly: two major story beats are explained in the "things sort of just happened and now we're here" variety, and the rest of the major plot points simply *aren't explained at all.* When the credits started to roll, I think I actually shouted at my TV "You're joking, right?" Another 5 years of Tetsuya Takahashi's mind wasted on a story that he decided not to finish. At least Xenogears' story itself was actually told to completion, even if the second half of the game was mostly unplayable due to production issues. The funny thing is, Xenoblade 3 feels the exact same way, like after the climax hits it feels like there should be another half to the game, and there just isn't. Only unlike Xenogears, they didn't even finish telling their story. All of this then made me think "man, what even was the last game I played where the story actually finished well?" and I immediately thought of Nier: Automata. I thought of it so much, in fact, that I couldn't stop thinking about it. I've now watched at least a dozen reviews in the last several days wondering if I'm going crazy, but no, it seems the rest of the internet agrees that this game has aged so unbelievably well I would serve it at a 5-star restaurant. So, your prediction was correct. In light of what games have come after it, there is still nothing that compares to Nier: Automata. I would put it alongside only 2 other games that I think match its quality in terms of storytelling and affectation: Undertale and Xenogears. These are without a doubt my 3 favorite videogame stories, bar none. The more stories people try to tell in videogames, the more Nier:Automata looks better by comparison. It's truly insane, but it's just that good.

[@Ka0sAssassin]

Many yrs later you convinced me to play this , and I must say has to be one of the greatest games iv ever plays , completing every ending , absolutely amazing story that every one should experience, a game for the ages

[@Vy-if3zd]

I mean... I remember when Yoko Taro did an interview 1 year after the release of the game and he answered the following question “What would you say to the people who still haven’t played this game?” with “It’s been an year since the release, if you still haven’t played this game, i don’t think you absolutely need to do so” The humbleness in this sentence shows how much the mind behind this masterpiece told us very important things through those games

[@plipplop1769]

Could you explain? I have no idea how that statement is that special in any way.

[@lunascomments3024]

@@plipplop1769 exactly. no marketing out of nowhere. if you haven't play it, don't rush to play. you can, to not play it. you don't have to force yourself.

[@plipplop1769]

@@lunascomments3024 I mean it's a normal ass statement. I don't know why people are talking about it like it was some revelation about life "The humbleness in this sentence shows how much the mind behind this masterpiece told us very important things through those games".

[@lunascomments3024]

@@plipplop1769 exactly. it's normal statement. well in my view, you're the same passionate person as the TS, just in different spaces & thinking.

[@plipplop1769]

@@lunascomments3024 What does TS mean?

[@arenkai]

Before playing the game: "Man, yet another one over doing it and spouting this 'masterpiece' word like it's nothing..." After playing the game: "This video doesn't even scratch the surface of how this game is gaming's ultimate masterpiece"

[@azizx2796]

arenkai that's so true. Don't forget you only need 2B's godly body to call this game a masterpiece😏

[@arenkai]

I loved the game so much and feel so deeply about the characters that every time someone brings up how "hot" 2B is, I go full SJW on them (ok, not really, but pretty close) It's like a trigger, I like the character so much that seeing her reduced to "Damn ! She's hot, look at those thicc thighs !" makes me go insane. Is this... what you call love ?...

[@azizx2796]

arenkai yes. You are madly in love.

[@arenkai]

WOMANpukumaru The poor girl deserves better my friend...

[@arenkai]

WOMANpukumaru That's exactly why the game's narrative is so powerful. There's no word I hate more than "overrate" when talking about art. You can't take people's appreciation of a piece of art and completely disregard it by saying that they are wrong to love it this much. That's quite arrogant. This review doesn't even delve to the core of why this game is special: its design. This game is a masterclass in game design and narrative design, no game before it achieved the level of mastery with which it can convey abstract ideas and the narrative itself through gameplay. The narrative itself is a perfect example of how you can use the medium to subvert and reset expectations in order to tell a unique story that could only be told through a video game. Everything in the game's design serves a purpose and enhances the narrative. If anything, the fact that 2B is dressed like a skimpy french maid only made the game's final moments even more powerful. Proving once and for all that video games can make you feel deeply for characters regardless of character design. Her design tells you nothing about her, if anything it conveys ideas about the game that couldn't be further from the truth. That's another example of expectation subversion applied to video games. The people who made this game (and especially Yoko Taro) understand how video games work and how players engage with a game and they use this knowledge to craft an experience that never shies away from completely rebooting its tone and the narrative's stakes in order to surprise and engage the player. Oh, and he happens to like sexy girls. Why should he need other reasons than that to make some if in the end it serves the narrative he crafted ? NieR:Automaya single handedly makes the case for video games as art.

[@LoR0451]

It truly makes me happy to see people still discover this game and watch this review. And now with Replicant out, I really hope more people play it and give it a chance. It takes awhile to get going, but once it does....you won't regret it.

[@cooloobahn112]

Still one of my favorite reviews ever. If you come across this comment all these years later, thank you, Ralph. What an experience the first time through. The music, the combat, the revelations in the story my brain couldn't, all the way, follow because I'm broken, And that sweet sweet pixel ass on 2B. Thanks for recommending this one. I was on the fence because of all the reasons you listed toward the beginning of the review. But this video sold me 100% on the game and I don't regret it at all. Keep on keeping on!

[@richardkluin6124]

"40 hour game." *looks at my steam play time* 200 hours Good video game

[@marcemagge9808]

@Kurisu Makiseare you not sure how to get more endings because I just finished all the endings you just keep playing the save to get other endings I think any ending past E is secret though

[@biancasawbridgeworth1386]

my last save file was 59:59:59 because I think PS4 can't endure a timer bigger than 59 hours.

[@cristopherkurisutofa166]

40 hours game? bruh i have 20 hours already, my stats says i have less than 30% completed

[@cristopherkurisutofa166]

@Kurisu Makise at first less than 5 hours i unlocked Ending T (i removed the OS Chip lol xd) what did you do for the ending A, Christina??

[@cristopherkurisutofa166]

nvm i already got ending A, but at 30hours

[@jaytb6458]

I got Nier at release because of the positive vibe around the game. Ended up being one of the most original and thought provoking games I've ever played, a piece of art really. Fully agreed that this is a masterpiece of gaming media and happy to see you give it the attention it deserves!

[@SkillUp]

So glad I'm not the only one that thinks so! I've felt like a crazy person all week long!

[@jaytb6458]

Skill Up Crazy? I'd call it good taste in games ;) I'm sure many other Nier fans will agree with you too. I was literally in the same boat as you, not all that interested in the individual mechanics after watching many reviews, but mainly went for it to bridge the gap until MEA was released and the positive vibe all over the web. How it went from there is pretty much exactly as stated in your review. This game truly deserves all the attention it can get. I always enjoy your detailed spot-on videos, keep it up SkillUp!

[@iota-09]

yeah, the first nier was re- wait, "this"? oh, how much you don't know... i have the feeling that like over half the people who bought automata have no idea that there was a nier on the ps3.

[@graveyardsoil]

Play Nier on PS3 god damn ittt

[@MrSolLeks]

I had never heard of the older games and had nier on my radar for a while (I am a anime fan, rpg fan but I mainly play counter strike). while board, I started looking into it a bit and discovered the older games and their 'relation' to NA, was like screw it il preorder. I also had never taken a day off work for a game and it seemed like a great excuse. the day before PC release, I had watched a few reviews trying to avoid spoilers as best I could, I then found clemp's videos on drakengard and nier (watched all of them execpt drakengard 3, will probably go back and watch, but was mainly interested in niers backstory) and from the moment I ended that last nier analysis video, watching some 2 to 2.5 hours of his stuff, I knew NA would be amazing. Then friday came about. I had other plans as well (Went to the range with a military friend and his mom, tough his mom how to shoot the guns that they owned but she had never fired before as well as laying out all of mine for them to choose from), I got home and the install was complete and from there I powered through the game, I did quite a few side quests but skipped a lot, the main story just kept pulling me. 40 hours in and I had finished. its been what, 2 weeks since then and I still can't get N:A out of my head, I watched this review because I just love content about N:A and seeing what the press has said and I agree, they describe a masterpiece but give it a 9... very odd. Very great review skill up, subbed because of this video! Hearing the music in the background while you talked gave me chills, you described it perfectly as well! Ever so often over the last few weeks I have done somthing I have never done before, listened to a games soundtrack alone while doing other stuff (theme park is best music IMO). Thanks for the great video, I will probably pass this to a few friends!

[@Ahicksaf]

Playing this game now thanks to this review. So you convinced me, seriously this game is so unique and has an amazing story. People really need to give it more credit

[@Kaohteeko]

Hands down the most in depth and comprehensive review of this game to date. Not only have you gained a subscriber but you have achieved your goal as to convincing me to download the game ASAP. Bravo 👏🏻

[@Lin117]

"Do you still wish to rescue someone - a total stranger - in spite of this?" If you selected yes, you understood the moral of the story.

[@daviouscram2101]

Bruh there's a shit load of morals in that story. 9S is an under dog who never stopped trying. The good ending is behind the dude who goes completely nuts but for valid reasons (that almost never happens in games). The Strongest heros of the stories are actually victims because they simply accept the injustice and do what they're told. Fear of the unknown controlling and ruling people.

[@undeadman7676]

I only chose no because I did E before getting D, but right after I got D I redid it and said yes. A solid 45 hours of 95%ing the game only to be guilt tripped into doing the right thing. Worth.

[@primedember5249]

i re-downloaded it recently. i'm gonna 100% it and help a fellow android. may my data be useful. wish you luck.

[@elzian4975]

I selected yes, ans didn't understand the moral of the story.

[@bonelesscommunism4031]

I’m sorry but I’m not giving up al 78 hours of grinding

[@Th3Jez]

This is the best video you've made on this channel Ralph. I'll be buying the game immediately upon your recommendation.

[@SkillUp]

Th3Jez Fuck yeah Jez. Can't wait to hear your thoughts on it.

[@FyreBlastkin]

Th3Jez Didn't expect to see you here! Enjoy, it's a treat. 😊

[@12315wojtek]

Oh boi! I'm just about end of the 4th run. Your comment immediately gave me the feeling that at the moment of writing it you wouldn't even imagine how outstanding this game is. I hope you have enjoyed it as much as I do.

[@Telris86]

@@12315wojtek I agree, it's absolutely mind-boggling. I heard so much before I finally played it but nothing really truly conveyed how outstanding it is. I also understand the desire of this review to attempt to convey it as best as possible. In my opinion it is one of the best games ever made and it should be treasured.

[@tylershimek6167]

Same here, I’ve always known about the games but DAMN the review is so good I’m all in!

[@EarhirX]

I loved Pascal's theme and how it evolved for me. The first time I listened to it, I found it creepy and disturbing, but it grew on me and it became my favourite theme from the game. It grew on me as my fondness of Pascal and his village grew. His village became my favourite location on the game and even beyond that my appreciation of the theme changed as Pascal's story ended

[@AC03115]

This game is easily one of my favorites of all time! Nier was an experience I'll never forget thanks for giving it the true love it deserves

[@Rahlivia]

At first I thought this review was annoying as he kept repeating how much of a masterpiece this is; I decided to play it anyway to see for myself. I now no longer think this review is annoying.

[@chupamishuevos303]

Rahl of Rivia I dont get it he only played for 2 day$ n he can review it ??? I been playing it for 4 days n I still havent seen it all.

[@unhomme643]

Rahl of Rivia I disagree. It’s still a display of redundancy.

[@typhoon37351]

kabronplay Have you been playing it nonstop for 4 days?

[@andrefrazier8653]

While this game is great...it's far from being masterful.. whatsoever... I have this game and beat it multiple times A through E or whatever.... and.... it's not masterful... many parts of this game could have been fleshed out so much more.... for one. The level design is somewhat atrocious... a robot utopia world could have been a perfect place to flex creativity and ambiance here.... the level design is desolate and honestly quite frustrating considering the amount of back trekking done... The gameplay itself is masterful... best I've seen in some time... very fun sword play and I love the chip system... Conceptually it's deep. But execution wise isn't masterful.... The music is wonderful... I'll never forget the "THIS CANNOT CONTINUE" scene and the boss fight.. brilliant... Overall the game is a 7.5 to me... while ganeplay and story is great... the level design structure, ridiculously stupid map system and quest system make this average.. The developer Yoko is a great conceptual designer. Not a game designer or director... If LEVEL 5 had this franchise they would make it sing... I'm playing Ni no Kuni 2 right now and I'm way more impressed with the amount of thought and quality gone into the product.... If you're gonna play this game, don't buy it full... buy it bargain bin

[@MultiAFroDuck]

@Andre Frazier thought and quality in Ni no Kuni 2? really? that game sucked! from combat to the the devastatingly horrible army mode, they were tedious and repetitive! what part of that is quality? and dont get me started about the crappy story

[@innerg_92]

when you play just the first 30 minutes, it spans an entire legacy of game genres from the early 90s to more recent years. its insane how well the game captures the feeling of gaming as a whole. A true masterpiece.

[@tektauron]

agreed!!!!

[@satanick9376]

Excuse me what? I've been passing this game for a few years now and nothing has intrigued me like this comment yet lol

[@SparkTFS]

Indeed. While playing some parts of it, I tried to imagine some parts of it as a SNES or PS1 game. The way it fix so many genres together without being overwhelming is incredible! Also, for a modern story-driven game, it makes a lot of effort to remember you're actually playing a game, and not watching a interactive movie. I think the moments that did impact me the most were while I was in control of one character, and these are the majority here.

[@MegaAndyGG]

Yes, this was exactly what I thought too ❤👌 Also the music is superb! 🙌 🖤

[@weaverquest]

That's certainly not true unless your idea of gaming as a whole is limited to hack & slash and schmups.

[@themcmith]

Mate, I just wanted to say thank you for this video. It is 4 AM here, I JUST finished automata and my god I loved it. Thank you for making me enjoy probably some of the best 80 hours of my life. If you’re reading this, and you’re thinking about getting the game: GO FOR IT! It’s incredible. Thanks again Skillup!

[@Kirby-Krios]

This is my fav video on the channel.. back when it was better ^_^ Don't care for the newer style vids/podcasts nowadays and that Austin guy lol.

[@JuiceEternal]

This has aged very well, and with the Stellar Blade stuff happening right now I think was can understand why it wasn't getting those 10/10s. I just bought the game after watching your review and am looking forward to playing after Stellar Blade.

[@spacepenguin3590]

You don't beat the game, the game beats you.

[@Shiribunga]

This is I swear to fucking god the comment that best captures the NieR Automata experience even if it's written as a meme. You need more likes my man

[@reecenaidu6020]

+A Priest Of Kek Like given. And Space Penguin, well said

[@LockCard]

it was hard for me too, but stay calm, im in your corner. [USA]

[@noangles1564]

Amen to that

[@6th_Army]

Funny how the game is constantly bashing the US to the ground but many fail to notice. (This is what he was going to speak of before realizing how long the video is.

[@97ghosts84]

In my 43 years i have never had a gaming experience like Nier: Automata. Masterpiece.

[@purdy9431]

Its a great game for a balance of emotional storyline and nods to classic arcade gaming that does not feel forced or gimmicky.

[@EvolutionIX219]

Just picked this up due to the ffxiv crossover and holy shit I regret sleeping on this game for so long. I havent beat it yet but I'm already in love.

[@TheAbsoluteSir]

God of War?

[@firstname163]

@@TheAbsoluteSir Bloodborne

[@marcozg77]

I'm 42, and same for me. It's a brilliant masterpiece.

[@borjmolina5586]

Five years since this video was uploaded, I wanted to say what an excellent review! I will definitely be getting this one. Was announced that it'll be ported to NSW.

[@jordanhicks347]

6 years later. This game is a true masterpiece.

[@UrsulaDorada]

Here is a testimony from someone who played the game because of this video. Loved it, spreading the video around

[@Arthiem]

I tried my best to play it but after 3 minuets of buttery smooth 60fps the screen goes white for 15 or so seconds, then my PC shuts down with no blue screen.

[@ADCVr]

Arthiem have u try turn down the resolution ??

[@Arthiem]

yeah, and compatibility mode, safe mode, low settings, ultra settings, disabling cores so it isn't trying to run across 16 threads, I was getting close to the refund expiration so I had to just give up and stop trying.

[@ADCVr]

Arthiem sorry to hear that mate. well i guess its your pc problem. maybe your pc cant handle it :/

[@Arthiem]

yeah its an AMD build, water cooled Rizen 1700x and an overclocked RX480 with 8 gigs of video ram, and 16 gigs of DDR4 system ram. which crushes the recommended settings by double, obviusly the game favors Nvidea/intel

[@tboltgames]

You convinced me to play this game and now I've completed every ending, every side quest, every collectible, all DLC challenges, all with 100% completion. This game hits hard right in the feels and I can't stop listening to it's music even after finishing it. Thanks for such a great review of this game. Your time spent for this review was well worth it.

[@MaroLFC]

After about a year from finishing it i still like hearing the soundtrack every day till now

[@jonathanramirez3109]

I was working towards that 100% and oh boy the surprise that awaited me

[@deathboy12345]

Have you finish ending E?

[@tboltgames]

@@deathboy12345 I have finished all endings from A-Z & 1 DLC ending.

[@daffanier]

@@tboltgames Did you cry from the E and C ending?

[@khalimh]

Just finished it this week... Man... it really is a masterpiece. There are so many points in the game where I just paused to absorb what just happened, to reflect if I really made the right decision, ugh that moment with a certain character... So many scenes where I was emotionally affected. There were even times when I was late to realize I was already in tears. All the moments I had on this game, I wish I can forget it so I can experience it again. I will treasure these memories. Thank you very much for this review, Ralph.

[@OneHatEllie]

I first became interested in playing this game after watching Sterling's glowing review but never got around to it. But after watching this review a couple of weeks ago I decided to bite the bullet and do it, and it is such an amazing game. I've only just started it, really, and can't get enough. It's rare for me to feel that way about this genre of game, which usually isn't my thing. I actually listen to some of the music from this game regularly on Spotify and hadn't even noticed until this video when you pointed it out and the song was so familiar to me.

[@chiffoncakeandtea]

I remember playing this game because, well, 2B looking really good. I didn't expect it to turn into my favorite game of all times.

[@imbadateverygame2920]

“Come for the thighs, stay for the cries” - Some redditor

[@MagisterXII]

I feel most people did the same and neglected the underrated greatness of Nier 1 unfortunately.

[@chiffoncakeandtea]

@@MagisterXII Oh, ohhh you don't even know how much I want to play the original NieR, as well as the Drakengard games.

[@MagisterXII]

@@chiffoncakeandtea Hey, I'd lend them all to you if I could, lol. Love those games. None of them were very popular until Automata unfortunately though. Glad they allowed the creator to make a follow up to the first Nier. I'm hoping for a Drakengard reboot myself. Nier 1 getting a remaster...ish and a mobile game is a good sign though.

[@victuz]

The gameplay certainly isn't my favorite, but the narrative (lore) of Nier series is absolutely incredible.

[@nobodynoone2997]

Hey Dude, it's me, the one person who explicitly played the game because of your video I was here to watch gameplay footage of games I wanted to buy in order to make a decision a couple of weeks ago. NieR wasn't even one of the games I took into consideration - I didn't even know it existed. But somehow I stumbled upon this video. So yes, your seven days of work paid out. You successfully convinced me to get it even though I was here to compare three totally different games on order to figure out which of them I would buy. And now, there is only one thing left to do and say: THANK! YOU! ❤️ This is one of the best games, if not THE best game, I've ever played in over 23 years of console gaming. So seriously.. thank you :D Greetings from Germany and sorry for the probably bad English

[@Ryan-nt4lt]

Apologies for bad English while speaking flawless english lol

[@Himmelsfeger]

"Greetings from Germany" and apologizing for our "bad English" are basically the way we want to greet the rest of the Internet. I have to stop myself from writing it ^^

[@briansouthparkstudio1357]

@Johnny Flannigan and this video conviced me i just baought it myself though i'll have to wait till it actually gets here to play it likely i have a 3 day weekend next week

[@MasDouc]

Convinced me too, and while yeah it's a pretty fantastic game and I'm currently addicted to it, I think this guy was a bit hyperbolic with his review.

[@davidfutterer551]

@@Himmelsfeger Same Problem mate.

[@kvnmcaleer]

I've listened to this review probably like 5 times over the passed couple of years. It's the video I send to people when I talk about thus truly special game!

[@JSMRAP]

Same. But to trrully enjoy it and understand... hardly anyone would do it.

[@craigdorsey1293]

My co-worker was raving about it a couple weeks ago. Just bought it for $16 for Black Friday. Absolutely love it so far

[@sicdedworm09]

When I realized this game is literally a HACK and slash my mind was blown.

[@j.jehml.1446]

omg i cant believe i just read that with my own 2 eyes.....

[@nhutminh9290]

wait all these years now i get it lol ! tks

[@trymenicca8606]

U trippin

[@hassanabbas5926]

@@j.jehml.1446 you will not believe this:i read this with one eye open

[@wanderingpaladin4927]

ba dump ssss

[@EdwardViaTomato]

Totally should've ended the review with an "9". That would've been amusing.

[@zach367]

😂

[@azrazel916]

lmao

[@theresnothinghereatall]

Nine.....z

[@nhutminh9290]

NICES

[@tanaypandey1771]

"Its a solid 9 from my side " LMAO

[@azzymacplaysgames5936]

Thank you for this! I am finally getting around to playing this game (currently downloading) and I'm so excited thanks to this excellent, heartfelt review!

[@paulelliott3056]

Hey Ralph, I know you posted this nearly 5 years ago, but wanted you to know that I am someone who has just played Nier Automata because of your video. You say at the beginning that most people would see this and be like “No thanks”. That was me. You also say that your 7 days of work on prepping this video would be worth it if you convinced a single person to play Nier Automata. Well, you convinced me. And it was mind bendingly awesome, beautiful, and thought-provoking. 10/10 from me. Thank-you!

[@DTYUT]

The masterpiece I probably won’t play? You mean the masterpiece I’ve played and 100%? WHO’S READY FOR REPLICANT “VERSION UP” BOIS?!

[@MasterXIII13]

Damn straight. Can’t get here fast enough.

[@vishy1992]

Finally its coming. Been hyped since last year

[@voidlooksback]

@@haktar11 This is bait

[@DTYUT]

@@haktar11 Garbage? That would be your taste my friend!

[@voidlooksback]

@@DTYUT Don't continue this conversation, it's simply bait. There's no need for them to get attention from you

[@wholesomecomment45]

I ignored Nier Automata for roughly 2 years for reasons I don't know. Till I came across your video and all I could say is i legit regret taking so long to play it. Thank you for convincing me in playing perhaps one of the greatest video games ever.

[@Luxius1509]

me too, I played this game 2 years ago, but I dropped it because it wasn't interesting enough for me. 2 years later I feel bad because I only play this game when I ran out of games to play (GOW, DMC5, Spiderman, Red Dead etc...) This game is a masterpiece

[@comfypumpkin6475]

Well, I bought NieR: Automata near its premiere and waiting to play it for no other reason than putting titles like Horizon Zero Dawn and God of War ahead. I finished NieR just yesterday and I don't know if I regret the waiting. I grew up a little and started the game with no pressure of time or responsibility to do it. I guess, this helped me aprecciate that masterpiece even more.

[@leeturner8023]

ive had it since 2017, I only played a bit of it, got bored, then abandoned it. Maybe I missed out on a masterpiece, IDK

[@coldnoodles2951]

Found this video like 2years ago, watched a bit of the beginning and decided i wanted to play through it before watching it. Been procrastinating for so long, but now here i am, just finished the game, broken and lost, looking for answers........ oh boi am i gonna savour this video.

[@Adam-tz7jb]

Great review and this video is the reason I decided to go ahead and buy it and i've just finished it. I came close to trying this game 3-4 years ago but after seeing the cover I had the same thoughts you mentioned within the first minute of the review about the 'weird japanese hack and slash' so I could totally relate. It was one the best stories i've experienced in a game so thanks

[@bdbgh]

The amusement park introduction actually made me stop and made me actually interested to slowly explore the area, the music is simply bewitching, the robots performing around you, I was gobsmacked. I never had a moment in game where I was so enchanted by an area alone.

[@sesshonuyasha]

yes any excuse to walk that area !!

[@paulashwin247]

One of the best gaming moments. I'm sad it has happened and that moment won't happen again.

[@sesshonuyasha]

@@paulashwin247 Awww don't worry there are plenty of atmospheric games that synergize all the right stuff to give us those moments..........they just are different genres like MGS4 and Nioh

[@iaxacs3801]

It's just that sudden change from desolate apocalyptic wastelands filled with murderous robots to suddenly coming into full view a carnival brimming with joy and your enemies deciding not to hurt you.

[@owenabbiss3443]

gobsmacked is a great word for that section... i fully agree. it's funny because i usually like to run and jump around killing shit as fast as i can but i too had to stop and slowly enjoy the music and performances.......right before i slaughtered them all hehehehehe

[@Messi-rw9ng]

Anyone else come to this comment section just to see how many new players have bought NieR Automata and enjoyed it just as much as we had? I love this community so much.

[@patrickholzer6415]

Got platinum 2 days ago. So yeah, fanbase still growing! Glory to mankind

[@roon568]

Yeah

[@Clarity_Control]

Sure, but another settlement may need our help, mind checking for us?

[@GoldRaven-oe4by]

I bought it a few months ago

[@YolomanrsGaming]

I saw the coverart I'm thinking I don't want to be seen as a perv by the people around even my parents, but I came across some music and few short clips of the gameplay and I considered buying which I did and I don't regret purchasing the game it's fucking amazing the story is good, music is great, art and graphics are on point, and gameplay wise it's just great

[@Probably_Laurence]

6 years later you convinced me with this video, rn downloading Nier

[@samridhiroy8437]

alright, I heard a part of the soundtrack the other day, listened to the full later, and watched your video till 3:49. I can't afford to play the game now, for I have too much work to push aside, but I promise I'll play it as soon as I can put aside two whole weeks and a good device to play it on.

[@dsel307]

Felt like the thumbnail called me out. So I played Nier: Automata and it’s now my favorite game ever.

[@shakibahmed6044]

Finished it last night. And what an experience it was. Had minor bits spoiled for me, but still, after getting [E], I felt both hope and emptiness inside, that's a rare feat. What a game.

[@SkillUp]

Edit: Yoko Taro himself tweeted at me about this review! Extremely humbled that he took the time: twitter.com/yokotaro/status/849523282193920000 Hey all- really hope you enjoyed the review. Don't forget that there is a free demo on the PS4 store, and on Steam you can refund it within the first 2 hours of play if you don't like it. I know this one is a bit of a 'long-shot' purchase (it was for me) so if you want to try before you buy, then I'd recommend going down these routes. Hope you love it. It really is amazing :) I also have one REALLY big request for a Japanese speaker with some spare time on their hands. I'd love to have this video translated into Japanese so I can forward this review to the game creator, Yoko Taro. Please message me on twitter @skillupyt if you happen to have the time for something like that. It honestly makes me sad to know that I won't be able to pass on my thanks to Taro in his own language, so I thought I'd make this odd request :) Thanks everyone.

[@joshs7276]

How did you play this game? I have heard the key board and mouse control system on PC can be a bit sub-par at times.

[@SkillUp]

Oh yeah. You CANNOT use keyboard and mouse lol. It's awful. Control on PC all the way.

[@AKSBSU]

+SkillUp Nier: Automata is just as good as you say. I played it almost nonstop for over 80 hours on PS4 Pro, dropping Horizon and Breath of the Wild, as great as they are, completely until I'd completed Nier: Automata A through E. It's easily my favorite game so far this year, and also I'll rate the soundtrack among the best of all-time. It's very likely Nier: Automata also has the best story and animation of 2017, which resulted in a punishing experience for me with Andromeda due to catastrophically unfortunate timing of release dates. Few games have continued to lurk in my thoughts the way Nier: Automata has. I'll be picking it up again for Steam later this year. I'm hoping for a remaster of the original Nier as well. 9.5/10 for me and probably my GotY for 2017.

[@SkillUp]

Well said mate :)

[@darkwyve]

I had checked many of the reviews online for Nier Automata and thought that they either didn't grasp the true depth and value of the game (despite high numbers/ratings) or didn't understand how to reflect that in the grade/number they gave it. Also none of them (in my opinion) delved into the depth of the experience, and the expression of true story telling that exists in Nier. Not a single review has done it the real justice it deserves, until now. Is it weird to say this has made me not only respect you more as a youtuber, but as a person as well? I've told everyone I know about it as well and tried (but feel I have failed) to convey the value and depth of Nier Automata to them. I know for certain it's the best game I've played in the last five (maybe ten years) and will certainly be one of the best games I believe I'll ever play in my life time. The experience resonates on a level deep enough to touch who we are as a person, and how we, as a people might very well be connected on levels we're only beginning to understand. But I digress, I'm getting overly philosophical and wordy. Thanks for vocalizing and expressing so well in a video, what I think many have experienced since playing through Nier Automata. Thanks for a review that does true justice to this masterpiece and labels it for what it is. And lastly, thanks for sharing it on this medium so it can reach the hearts and minds of many who would have lost their chance to experience what we did because they overlooked this gem of a story.

[@matthewdippel5745]

Does it feel good to be validated by time? This game is a true masterpiece.

[@AaaSWE]

Gonna play it some day. It had some technical issues on PC which I think is pretty much fixed now. Maybe next sale I'll pick it up.

[@KevinSmithSB]

I'm not a big gamer, I like to play when I have time and I've never left a comment for a video game review. I was exactly the person that said "no thanks" after seeing the art and trailer. With my spare time limited from owning businesses​ and having kids I have to be selective on game purchases these days....there is just not enough time to play everything that looks interesting. Metal Gear, Dark Souls, etc were all games that I did invest the time in and loved for their creative originality. This review alone convinced me to purchase and give Nier a shot, and I'm glad I did. Thank you for taking the time to craft such a detailed review, your mission was accomplished.

[@SkillUp]

Hope you love it mate :)

[@AnonYMouse-ky4sg]

Kevin Smith I recommend The Last of Us

[@KevinSmithSB]

Anon YMouse That was the last game I finished and it was fantastic. Thanks.

[@businesspro7244]

Kevin Smith well if life ever gives u a break I recommend bloodborne

[@BasedDad35]

Kevin Smith I know it's a big commitment but I highly recommend the Witcher 3!

[@thomasgoodwill]

I'm so happy there are still new comments on this video. Nier is more than a mere game, it's a lifechanging experience. The fact that there are still people who find it for the first time just fills me with joy.

[@MikeTolosa]

I got final E 2 days ago, and you know what I did 😊 It really is a life-changing game. I hope Replicant gets its price lowered soon to insta buy it

[@chocomints909]

I just had the chance to play it until now. at the moment I think is very good but i think I'm a bit far from the best part. but who knows

[@MikeTolosa]

@@chocomints909 the whole experience is good imo, but I think you won’t get disappointed with what will be coming 😊

[@chocomints909]

@@MikeTolosa Yeah i think it's very good. I've been hooked and enjoyed what's going on so far. Just nothing mindblowing (yet)

[@MikeTolosa]

@@chocomints909 Well then, I hope you keep enjoying it and get surprised 👀 😊

[@derekdenekamp18]

It is now 2022 and I've been thinking about playing this game for a full year now. I just downloaded it based off this one review. Ive seen/heard many reviews and still wasn't sure about it. Thank you for this video. Now I must put all my time and effort into the game

[@Sonnymac81]

My advice, stick to the story and don't put the game on the back burner for too long during your 1st playthrough or you'll potentially lose track of some cryptic elements or even where to go sometimes as the map and waypoint system kinda sucks. Other than that, it's a masterpiece. Get your ending "A" and then hit sidequests and exploration on the 2nd "B" playthrough. The game doesn't click until then anyways. It takes three playthroughs with three different characters to truly finish the game in a single way, but there are more endings that are worthwhile if you're feelin the story. I started Nier digging the gameplay, but I ended it savoring the story which is rare af for me, I usually put gameplay above all. I wound up watching Drakengard lore videos...Yoko Taro is a brilliant madman.

[@deathgun2792]

you did it. you first 3 min off the review and a good friend who told me to play the game last year, got me into it. i wasnt so excited cause i played the demo and while it was nice, i didnt inow what to expect and i skipped the game.. so last year, i started your review and asked a friend who is a totally nier freak: is it worth? what makes it so special? and he say only: play it, you will see. i cant spoil anything about this game. so i did and it blow my complete away. and im so thankfull that iam a person who could play this. its not just a game its art. and i personally ranked on the same high as my all time favourite game. i will come back and play it again. and sometimes i just watch your review and can feel instantly my emotions that i had, when playing this game. if i will have kids: i will tell them about this game and how it changed me. thank you for this masterpiece of a review!

[@m3ng252]

Guys, for those who haven’t played this yet, I, as someone who finished the entire game, can confirm that *at least* 95% of this video are straight up *facts,* and you don’t need to doubt anything by the looks of it. Before I played this game, it almost felt like taking a leap of faith when clicking “purchase”, but trust me, there’s something in this game that cannot be experienced through let’s plays, it’s something you have to live for yourself. Before you call us crazy, please, give it a try.

[@Marcusianery]

I been on the fence for so long, then my sibling asked me what I wanted for my birthday, I said Elder Scrolls Summerset (MMO), Vampyr and this. Got all three....First now, 1,5 year almost later, I tried it...what a bloody master piece.

[@brownchair2698]

I did. Though I only finished 2b's storyline and I do not feel the same way as you guys do. I don't know whats up.

[@thecalifoxv2222]

Played the demo but I'm really not all that impressed

[@MudeGun]

@@brownchair2698 that's like a 1/4 of the game

[@brownchair2698]

@@MudeGun I am aware of that. But I mean shouldn't it get it's hooks in me now rather than when it is over? If you know what I mean.

[@ambelitrusiocarzajodelamen193]

My first impression when going through the beginning of the game : "Oh, so this is gonna be a story about these 2 partners that grow closer as they fight for a world where machines and androids can coexist and humans can finally live in peace." Boy was I wrong.

[@fuckyoutubeassfuckyou7751]

Damn was I hilariously naive in thinking similarity as well, game fucking does everything it can to give you a emotional crisis over fucking polygon androids, especially for those paying attention to it's very subtle hints that not everything is what it seems, its nihilistic but at the same time a very hopeful story, cant wait for the NieR remake

[@biancasawbridgeworth1386]

when I was close to the end of A ending, I thought "well, it will be an open ending! humanity is saved and fanfics everywhere!". And now I have an existencial purpose crisis.

[@frozenninja4030]

Not sure why this popped up in my feed today, but I happily rewatched this review. This is one of my favorite games of all time and this is a great excuse to revisit it. Such a unique and amazing journey filled with strong emotion and characters that you cannot help but love. And God, the music! And that final choice! It really cannot be overstated how fantastic Nier: Automata is. I might have to do another run through of this beautiful game soon...

[@happysatanproduction8854]

if i am not mistaken, the amusement park is the first area you encounter that the machines are not hostile or poses any threat at all. first time i visited the place i was like what going on? i cant kill these creatures. and defeating the tank made me feel that im in the wrong. even the first time you encounter adam he said that he doesnt want to fight. this game hits real different. truly a masterpiece

[@yoshen433]

Wanted you to know just how convincing I found your analysis. As someone who is often disappointed with a lot of different creative media, it is refreshing to hear someone speak so highly and so convincingly regarding the quality of a product. I want to say, this is not the kind of game I would normally be interesting in playing, additionally I earn minimum wage, I also never buy games on release, as usually £40-£50 can affect my living standards for that month; however, I am choosing to make an exception. It is blindingly obvious that this is one of those works that is not just crafted, it is born, the creators of these kinds of media are concerned with one thing and one thing only, reaching the greatest potential possible; in doing so they give birth to a community dedicated to unravelling its secrets and examining its genius, not only do I hope to be part of this community, but so rarely do I allow myself to be witness to its birth. With the hopes of inspiring a similar mentality in the industry surrounding it, I will be throwing my measly sheckles into the collective hat. Thank you for bringing this game to my attention, by doing so you have fulfilled the greatest role that critics can, in other words, hopefully games like this will raise the standards.

[@juliopinedo9402]

How did it go? If I may inquire

[@casperfghost7267]

Dude... I just played the free demo on PS4PRO... my mouth dropped open. This thing is epic. Buying tomorrow. And I do mean "EPIC".

[@huskytzu7709]

The OSTs alone messed up my life

[@BEINGHUMAN-lm8bs]

huskytzu who u telling smh

[@CostasAn]

You bet it did. This cannot continue!

[@huskytzu7709]

@dimox99 hells yea lol i still listen to them as of 2021 🥲

[@blakeabene4583]

Just played Stellar Blade, liked it but made me really really want to play this again. Just got through the first playthrough and remembered this video...I've been watching you since stumbling on this video and picking up Nier because of it. You rock Ralph (and team now)! Thanks for the years of excellent content!

[@findthestones]

Great review and breakdown. Definitely need to add this to my list!

[@kayjaycee777]

I'm 3 years late but I wanna play this now Update: it's not just a game, it's literally an experience. It's intense and makes you think and gives you emotion and I've just never experienced a game like this. The music, the quest, the endings, everything is just amazing.

[@mikestamp1188]

I just bight it, it’s coming tomorrow and I’m so exited

[@EvanAnderson64]

I have never fallen in love with a game faster than nier. The song that plays through the credits literally always makes me teer up. The games a certified masterpiece. 9/10 can't wait for replicating remaster

[@MegaAndyGG]

I am also playing at the moment. I love it so much!! 🖤🖤❤❤

[@heihei3453]

If you buy this game and die, you can become as gods.

[@VisserZer0]

I've got to say that was about as wrong as a plan can possibly go.

[@DaveLikesPie413]

Nice reference lol

[@headlessmonkeys3106]

yes just yes

[@yunsha9986]

Just finished the game, I can finally understand this lmao

[@colers2366]

Ah, but did you finish it or did you finish finish finish it?

[@victoriajepson4824]

I’ve had this game for a while on switch never even put the cartridge in but now you have convinced me to finally play it xxxx

[@Frezyman]

Just finally played the game and searching internet on ideas how to express myself around my experience. Found this video and you got it spot on!

[@VilleHalonen]

I watched the first few minutes of this review back when it came out, about two years ago, in the middle of a deep depression. I had just gotten PS4, too, my first console ever. Horizon Zero Dawn was one of the first games I bought, and the pictures I saw of Automata looked kind of pale in comparison - and yeah, I didn't much care for the waifu aspect either, or the cute robots. The first few minutes of this video convinced me to give the game a shot. I fell in love, and in the middle of a severe mental illness where nothing much felt like anything at all, this game made me feel and think and appreciate so many things. Two years on, it remains my favorite game ever, and I still marvel at its design, its themes, the interconnectedness of it all. I admire how Route A kinda feels shallow the first time you play it, but once you've finished the game and you play or see someone else play it, you get how much emotion and effort there is. All the silences that made no sense are now full of meaning - and pain. It's a masterpiece, still, and I owe it to you that I ever played it. Who knows how much more, because it might've literally saved my life. So yeah, your seven days was worth it. Thank you.

[@skyiie6790]

It actually makes me so happy reading your comment. I can definitely believe how this game can make one's life change, i changed myself a bit and the way i view the world after finishing this game. Hearing that it probably saved your life made my day, because i have so much love and appreciation for this game.

[@alexvswrld]

Wow, I hope you’re doing great bro. I almost skipped this gen, I only had my Xbox 360 but didn’t play it much at all. Got a PS4 last year in the midst of my depression, I’m 30 years old and never knew what true depression was... but during those agonizing months (being away from drugs and alcohol) I was able to find myself again.

[@akiinmoonlight79]

Reading your comment made me cry

[@VilleHalonen]

@@alexvswrld I'm doing better than ever, thank you!

[@nakedbeekeeper9610]

Depression is not a mental illness you pussy. Schizophrenia is. Try living your life with a warped apprehension of space and time for five minutes and tell me if you still think depression is a mental illness.

[@cipley]

After spending 30+ hours in this game, I promised myself to go see the game's OST orchestra show since the song tracks in this game is absolutely incredible. I'm glad I could fulfill that just before the COVID outbreak. Seriously tremendous experience. And Yoko Taro himself was on stage!

[@cipley]

@Super Mario please pardon the mistake as I typed this at 3AM

[@McSnezzly]

What’s wild is that only one of the orchestra shows had the cast of the game show up and act out what happens after ending E

[@brandonduarte8918]

I'm not ashamed to say I cried at the ending credits. That had to be one of the most powerful sequences I've ever experienced in gaming my entire life

[@verhulstjason]

Join the club bro! I cried twice once in the ending and once on another point...

[@neilfalzon283]

Convinced. Your review is poetic. Thanks!

[@Necreon021]

The review that single handedly created a level of trust between me as a viewer towards you as a reviewer. This review was born after I already finished everything in NieR and after watching this review I just knew if I ever want a reliable reviewer who approaches games the way I do, each differently according to how each is best approached, then I'd come here. Nearly 4 years later I'm rewatching this review and during all these years not once have you delivered anything less than this quality. Bravo, and thank you.

[@liesdamnlies3372]

...yuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuup. For me that was the other way around. I already trusted this guy, and seeing that he called it a masterpiece was enough to push me over the edge and buy it. I was just like he was at the start of the video, with one friend who said "no seriously, it's amazing, SERIOUSLY PLAY IT". Now, I'm that friend.

[@ronniewest87]

Good show

[@frankm6546]

@@liesdamnlies3372 I really don’t get it. It doesn’t look fun….is it that good?

[@liesdamnlies3372]

@@frankm6546 Yes. I didn't think I'd like it either.

[@nrishiee5231]

@@liesdamnlies3372 character development

[@TranceZiggy]

You know, I was on the fence about NieR: Automata when it came out. I was going back and forth over whether it was worth my money or time. Reviews were very favourable, but I've played games with favourable reviews before and found they didn't deliver the kind of experience I was personally looking for. Skyrim comes to mind as a perfect example of this; it was widely hailed as one of the greatest games of the last generation. Naturally, I picked it up, played it and put it back down 10 hours later. Never finished it. Never picked it back up. Anyway, I stumbled across this review. I've never seen any of your videos before, but the title and thumbnail grabbed me. I thought, "Maybe i'll get a 50th opinion from this guy." I didn't get an opinion. I got the single greatest review of a game I have EVER read, or watched. The passion you put into this review is awe-inspiring. It reminds me of my own passion for video games, a passion that seems to have faded in recent years; whether that's due to recent video games not providing the same experience I came to expect over a decade ago, or a progressive change within myself. You said if this review prompts at least one person to buy this game, it will be worth it. I just want to let you know, that's exactly what your review did. Immediately after finishing the entire review, I went out and bought it. The experience was worth much more than the price tag. I no longer doubt that video games deliver the experience I'm looking for. NieR delivered that experience and much, much more. So, thank you for your review. Without it, I may not have experienced one of the greatest games of this generation. You'll be my go-to for quality game reviews from now on. Subscribed.

[@SkillUp]

Chris Sparks really glad you enjoyed the game mate :)

[@acampbel26]

Right there with you man. 80 hours into the game and no sign of slowing down. Haven´t felt this way about a game since Chrono Cross. Simply Inspiring.

[@AnnaCurser]

dont buy games like skyrim only for the reviews. But why only put 10h into it? its more worth than that ...

[@xander4357]

Right there with you. This was the best video game review I have ever seen BY FAR for one of the best video games I have ever seen BY FAR.

[@landrybt]

I️ think I’ll pick it up as well. Wonderful review. Subscribed

[@Alcor72]

I love coming back to this once in a while, thank you again.

[@h.serafin1489]

After seeing your review a couple months ago, i FINALLY get to experience this game since it came out on Switch (somehow???) I'm just a couple hours in and it's already hooked me in a way a video game hasn't since Breath of the Wild. All the subtle details you mentioned and more that i'm finding out myself has got me thinking aliens must have made this game. No disrespect to the creators but I just cannot believe a team of people came together to create such a masterpiece. Their way of thinking is ahead by lightyears.