Vocal Coach/Musician Reacts: LADY GAGA 'Disease' In Depth Analysis!

[@ninaschofield]

What I love about this song is that it feels like a Gaga classic from first listen - like one of those songs you can instantly know and love. Let me know your thoughts below! Watch the extended version of this video which was blocked here on KZbin over on my Patreon as a quaver member or above, click the link to watch a preview: www.patreon.com/posts/lady-gaga-listen-114683137?Link&

[@GoriAkagi]

please react to charlie puth concert live in manila.. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rXTdq5qGqdCterMsi=ynkRWjn3zMu3SK_n

[@liamo7559]

💯 ❤

[@wig84]

I love how dark this song is. The alarm-like aah-aah's, the dying breath gasps, the industrial metallic sound effects; I'm obsessed.

[@heatherb812]

I love so much that the “aaAA” is a direct callback to the “juDA” from Judas 😍

[@flippineck2825]

​@@heatherb812 I think it might even be a sample... from Enigma

[@nickpost7307]

I like this song because it feels like she gave the fans what they wanted but also made a song everybody could feel is new and fresh and interesting.

[@ninaschofield]

Yes well said!

[@musicislyfe1672]

Yesss

[@rrenzee]

i love it when REAL vocal coach and musician make informative reaction videos like this. thank you so much for this Nina :)

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much for watching and commenting!

[@weedle4736]

It’s a very Born This Way Era song. Her Fiancé also co wrote and co produced the song.

[@ninaschofield]

Yesss thank you for extra info - had no idea her fiancé co wrote and co produced this 🩷

[@Thedownwardmineon]

No wonder its worse than usual

[@TheLapari]

He didn't produce it, only writing credits.

[@weedle4736]

@@Thedownwardmineon this is why you’re being attacked by her fans. You’re giving them reason to. stop playing the victim card under Gaga related videos and log out. You’ve stated that you don’t listen to her in one of the comments so who are you to say it’s “worse than usual”. You need attention and you’ll be getting one in a negative way if you continue to do so. :)

[@MrSanserif]

He motivated her to come back to her essence ❤ we have so much to be grateful with him.

[@RingoRoad]

I'm glad you immediately noticed the distorted backing vocals, it adds such a haunting sound

[@huntingswan1174]

You're so educational about chords I love it!

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much!

[@TT-tp9hw]

Love your detailed reaction! Unreal vocals and such a unique, ridiculously unhinged BOP. Gaga is BACK!

[@gregorybroussard2660]

I think in many ways this song is a culmination of every era she’s ever taken us through.

[@MarinaAndTheDevil]

Yess! Very Joanne!

[@gregorybroussard2660]

@@MarinaAndTheDevil I detect your sarcasm. Joanne is probably the exception here. But Joanne is also an exception in her discography. It was such a deviation from everything she’s ever done that I don’t think it can even be factored in properly.

[@MarinaAndTheDevil]

@@gregorybroussard2660 yeah I was just making myself giggle😭

[@Yoopsen213]

Ughhh the song is such a banger. Gonna be bopping to this for weeks to come

[@ricardo-neves]

Your reaction has now made me want to see Lady Gaga perform this song on the piano at an awards ceremony, in the style of the acoustic performances of Bad Romance or Speechless. These chords sound even more dramatic on the piano without all the industrial-inspired production (although I really like this industrial mood).

[@ninaschofield]

That would be so so good!

[@machines1020]

This analysis has made me appreciate the song on a whole different level!

[@ninaschofield]

I’m so glad 🙏🏻

[@Kat_blahblahblah]

can we just talk ab yr ability to hear a melody,beat etc and being able to do it on the piano like now thats insane

[@ninaschofield]

Aw thank you 🙏🏻

[@derlis_whatever7033]

Not 1 minute ago. I'm just looking for every reaction lmao

[@user-cz3sh3dx1w]

SAME BWAHAHA

[@MARTPOP]

Same lmao I keep refreshing and watching every vid. But what i'm looking forward the most is Zach's reaction I just know it'll be a historic one 🤣🤣

[@lfilipeliberato]

Omg same ahahaha

[@Moko_27]

mood

[@Youmakesickkkkkk]

⁠@@MARTPOPGIRL IM WAITING FOR ZACH THATS A TRUE LITTLE MONSTER 😂

[@user-ek3pu9yv3m]

Your description at the final cords is soooo on point that is the exact vision on the Official Music Video, where she is being compressed by moving walls and creates this "wall of sounds with distortions" that u said.. BRAVA !!!!

[@Carlos_Spartacus]

🔥🔥🔥

[@jeansnow1116]

I love this song so much since the first listen and at the same time I got so confused "wow her voice sounds so different here"! It reminds me the feelings I got after my first listen of Bad Romance when I had no idea this singer was the same singing Paparazzi or Poker Face and when I learnt it, I was blown away! Now I know her versatility and I'm still amazed by her talent! This song is not only a return of Darkpop Gaga, it's a dark pop much more powerful vocally and stronger in terms of production than back then. Thank you for your analysis, I appreciate it!

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much for watching! And yes totally agree, she is so vocally versatile and has so much to offer tonality wise 🥰

[@TT-tp9hw]

Totally agree! Bad romance just the song alone was so jarring on first listen but it grew on me and with the visuals is the best ever. I think this song has the potential to reach those heights with visuals and is so complex and layered it gets better with repeat listens

[@TrashCherub]

This is a great reaction video! I love how you approach it through a lens of musicianship.

[@ninaschofield]

So glad you enjoyed it!

[@BlondieBisquit93]

This lead single tells me headbangers are involved with this incoming era 🤘🏻🤘🏻

[@ninaschofield]

Ooh yes!

[@Thedownwardmineon]

There will not be one good song from this era since she's never made a good song

[@TheLapari]

@@Thedownwardmineon you must be diseased based on your recent comments here, stop lying and get some help...

[@BlondieBisquit93]

@@Thedownwardmineon ew a bitter hater who thinks their opinion actually matters

[@WackySagittarius]

@@Thedownwardmineon Why are you even here??? Go back to listening to your Jump 5 album.

[@alfredobecerra-lopez4611]

This is best reaction video I’ve ever watched. You going into the chords and little details, wow you’re amazing. Both you and Gaga are amazing!

[@ninaschofield]

What a compliment 🥰 Thank you so much!

[@purplestardust]

I love when you play the song on your piano, makes me want to hear an acoustic piano version of this song from Gaga! 🖤

[@MusiqueFiend]

It’s like a dark pop version of Diamond Heart 😭🖤😭🖤

[@froggiegirlc3455]

This is such a good description! ❤

[@Itsgothgaga]

Thank you for calling the layers of vocals immediately. Such a perfect touch.

[@ninaschofield]

So glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for watching 😊

[@TSUNAMI-MAMI]

AMAZING single wow I cannot wait for this era. Her voice sounds sooooooooooo good

[@DustinKenney-b5k]

It’s giving fame monster era but if Trent Reznor produced it. Very industrial.

[@michaeljenardligan6173]

I love to watch your in depth reaction dissecting each note, thanks Nina 😍

[@ninaschofield]

Thanks so much! 😊

[@gonzalodcs]

BEST reaction so far. Chords and production makes this song so interesting, so seeing you disect it is a pleasure. 🖤💥

[@ninaschofield]

That’s so kind of you, thank you 🥰

[@ilonanylsen]

DarkGa is back!!!🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤

[@IThekingsido]

A Classic Is Born 🖤🔥 love the reaaction 🫶🏻

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much for watching!

[@gilesy55]

Brilliant, so clear and easy to digest! Thank you for this 😊

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much for watching!

[@bonnieroe7023]

I'm not wired brain wise the same as you I wish I could be but I really still enjoyed watching this and hearing you break down the music in that way, really puts into focus the talent I already knew she had. I would love to see a cover from you with the chord change. Glad I checked out this when watching reactions. Thankyou!

[@ninaschofield]

Aw thank you so much!! Really appreciate it 🥰

[@partyinmyhead]

You really know what you’re talking about and not only that, you’re so enjoyable to listen to! Keep it up I’ve subscribed to you ☺️🙏🏻

[@ninaschofield]

That’s so kind, thank you for commenting and subbing!

[@ryanwoo4347]

Yes, I need technical analysis even tho i cannot follow some theoretical terms. Fantastical video👏

[@ninaschofield]

Thanks so much!

[@flippineck2825]

After the first line of the chorus it BEGSSS for one of them *clap clap* like in The Fame & Telephone. Hopefully on a remix!

[@Stevenspielburger]

Her "Happy Mistake" live performance on Jimmy Kimmel was amazing if you haven't already seen it

[@ninaschofield]

I have it up on Patreon now with early access and it’s coming to my channel soon 😊

[@jhossafatgalan6738]

I LOVE LOVE LOVE When a coach give us additonal technicque information, thank u Nina, this is really a complement for music lovers that aren't necessary experts like u

[@ninaschofield]

I’m so glad you enjoyed it, thank you so much for watching and commenting!

[@WoodlandT]

I love seeing your musical expertise really coming out in this reaction, very impressive. We’re all so excited about our Dark Mother rising again 🖤

[@AlaiahRodriguez-s6f]

I’m not a big fan, but disease is a very very good song, her best lead single since ARTPOP. 🔝💋

[@ninaschofield]

🩷🩷

[@Thedownwardmineon]

Try having her fans tell you that you can't be gay and that you should kill yourself SIMPLY because you state you don't listen to her. There are SO many more talented musicians out there and we give our adoration to the worst. This song and everyone who likes it is fucking garbage.

[@BenGray10]

When I started thinking of reaction videos for this song, your channel was the first one that came to my mind. And it's up super-early!

[@ninaschofield]

Aw thank you for thinking of me!

[@dennisdijk6002]

She listens just like I do, love that.

[@ceciliamackie]

It's impressive how fantastic your content is!

[@nikolamilenkovic2293]

Such a talent you are. I really enjoyed this video

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you! I really appreciate you commenting 🥰

[@emanoelfoicinho8839]

I’m so exited !!!! Just what I needed ❤️❤️

[@ninaschofield]

🩷🩷

[@DanAxl-x9d]

I also love how the chorus is Bm, A, G, E, yet the bass undernearth the A doesnt follow the root note, it goes up to D (so A major over D). In the first half of the chorus anyway.

[@DanAxl-x9d]

Nvm I just got to you saying this lol. The chords are: Bm, A, G, E (all the way through the chorus) But the bass notes are B, D, G, E. That's what gives the second chord that nice edge. Then the bass notes follow the root notes for the second half of the chorus.

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you for this! I confused myself during this reaction 😂 😂

[@TheMrIndividualist]

Lovely video, amazing song

[@v.r.5549]

Beautiful reaction! ❤

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!! 😊

[@mazmac3854]

Thank you for the breakdown ❤❤❤❤

[@TSUNAMI-MAMI]

This is Born This Way with a dash of Art Pop to me. Both some of my top Gaga albums!!!!!

[@shnooksMN]

Great video! Thank you for breaking it down :) I'm getting so many different vibes and messages from this song! It's great!

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much! ☺️

[@olliehutchins]

I love the piano work in the pre chorus! So creeepy

[@patrickjava9966]

Notice how pop gaga and classical gaga are combined in this track, just makes me appreciate this song so much.

[@JAVYxGV]

(low-key, it brings me joy to see you... you made the 2020 pandemic era bearable, so first of all, thank you for that.) [update: of course, i also have to mention i really appreciate how you break down a song, layer by layer, your intuitive grasp of composition and third-eye vision of a song's spirit, you bring into terms melodies, potential sonic easter eggs, nuances i wouldn't otherwise magnify on my own, that i literally rewind your reaction(s) more than a handful of times, which is rare. ugh.] i developed my patience with GAGA over the years, so to hear her in this gritty element feels nostalgic but also i can sense the maturity and confidence she has cultivated in this period of life. she's in love again and i can hear it in the unrushed pace of this production - it's not frenetic or desperate. the lyrics are face-value simple (however upon meditation, and a few shots of tequila, the theme of withdrawal and a menacing, abusive undertone in the character she's embodying in this song, remains to be seen but i feel it [the MV hasn't been released at the time of this stream of consciousness], but alas the depth she brings to the soundscape with her adlibs and layering, (shoutout to the producers), the synths she infused into this song gives it a slow-burn ambience - i was literally shocked at first listen. gagged. anyway - i fear this entire era is going to be the death of the current me - like every era with GAGA, the past 16 years of being a once Little to now fully grown Monster, she's helped me shed layers of myself by summoning the elements of myself that were dormant, and in rare instances, instilling in me gems she found and shared with us through her artistry. paws up 🤘😈🪽 forever

[@ninaschofield]

What a lovely comment! Thanks for your kind words and also for sharing what this new era will mean for you - one thing Gaga is amazing at is creating meaningful powerful pop so I can only imagine what kind of an album we are going to get 🥰🥰

[@kevinp.shogun]

We all love @LadyGaga #LadyGaga

[@simonwarren9855]

You got this out so quick. Great video!

[@ninaschofield]

I was excited to listen 🥰🥰 Thanks for watching and commenting!

[@RomicheSchndr]

I love your reactions, you're such a ray of light!!

[@ninaschofield]

Aw that’s so kind thank you 🙏🏻😊

[@ceciliamackie]

Hey! Continue producing such fantastic content.

[@horsehollerer]

Jarring and pleasing is so accurate 😂 I love it …although I slightly prefer your complicated progression!

[@ninaschofield]

Oh thank you so much! I really liked that chord 🥰

Lady Gaga is BACK

[@wthsamdi1221]

BANGER

[@ceciliamackie]

It’s lovely to meet you!

[@cesargabrielmathieu4528]

I LOVE how you play the song at piano like Gaga shows in the teaser! Musicians recognize each other ❤❤❤

[@ninaschofield]

I’m so glad you enjoy it! I love to work out what’s going on piano wise 🥰

[@cesargabrielmathieu4528]

@@ninaschofield Keep reacting and making such nice videos. Here is a big fan from Argentina. I send you a big hug 🤗

[@jemuelmoisesvillanueva4848]

Love your reaction/ review ❤

[@ninaschofield]

Thanks so much!

[@kaaailu]

Im new here, so excited for a cover in your voice and style

[@JOHN.Z999]

I loveeeed this music!!!

[@_HigherSelf_]

Awesome reaction! Love your expertise 😊

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!! 😁

[@jimmydaves]

You should check out Lady Gaga's live performance of "Happy Mistake" from the Jimmy Kimmel Show. For me, it's the best and most beautiful live vocals I've ever heard.

[@gregoryalbert6020]

Love your reactions! You’re so talented! I love her return to Born This Way Era! Based on the 3 snippets she played (2 in Paris and 1 after the HBO chromatica ball) the album will sound similar to this song

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much! Yesss I really meant to say Born This Way era 😅🥰

[@gothliban]

Nina Schofield doing a reaction-> I click ❤

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you 🙏🏻🥰

[@ceciliamackie]

I’m glad to have met you!

[@auroragazm]

we definitely won't be mad if you back and react to some of Gaga's discography ☺

[@tomasmachado7029]

Omg you’re amazing! Loved the video!!!!

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much!!

[@tuliofelipe315]

AMAZING !! LADY GAGA QUEEN

[@Liam_st95]

A BRILLIANT song and a fab review!

[@ninaschofield]

Thanks so much for watching!

[@captainlevi9778]

no one can pull of darkpop like gaga 🖤

[@W1LDFIRE]

lovee the way u break things down

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!

[@KaMillo538]

born this way vibe

[@devwithsoul]

she gave the what we asked !!

[@avrillukfan2043]

Super quick! Thank you Nina ❤

[@ninaschofield]

Thanks for watching!

[@dominikg8500]

Really enjoyed this song a lot ! It feels like old Gaga is back with an update sound

[@Ramon-fv6be]

born this way instrumentals with chromatica confidence = DISEASE 🦠

[@nicholasbissessar9777]

TO MY NINA, I'VE BEEN HOSPITALIZED AFTER MY LAST DEEP DIVE, EVEN IN THE HOSPITAL I HAD TO FIGHT OFF CRAAAAP. I/M GLAD TO SEE YOUR FACE. I'M ALWAYS WEAKENED BY THAT SMILE OF YOURS MY NINA..

[@instrumentsmrti]

nina schofield, the icon that you are

[@ninaschofield]

🥰🥰

[@xvx6161]

GAGA IS BACK 🔥🚨🔥

[@simonwarren9855]

Damn you got this up quick

[@ninaschofield]

Yes indeed 🥰🥰

[@kuilaat3183]

was waiting for this

[@ninaschofield]

🩷🩷

[@sander4233]

LOVE YOUR REACTION! ❤️

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much!

[@TiagoPereira-ed3jo]

Amazing reaction

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!

[@johnnygil5409]

The music before the "Ahhh" part sounds like it's the intro of Alice.

[@stevencandido8626]

DarkGaga is back 🎶🖤🕷️

[@ohmomoshane]

I desperately need a piano cover of disease from you now 🥹😭💕

[@utheriii4787]

Amazing ear you have

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you!

[@NLeroyP8]

So happy to see you react to disease! You would love happy mistake and I would love to see you dissect it along with the Jimmy Kimmel live performance of it!

[@ninaschofield]

Thanks for watching! Yesss I have that very performance reaction up on Patreon now with early access, coming soon to KZbin. Loved it! 🥰

[@NLeroyP8]

@@ninaschofield glad you enjoyed! Your reviews/analysis are great! 💕

[@LFjordao01]

You just have that cute high school music teacher vibe

[@joeandrews4282]

you're so fantastic

[@musicislyfe1672]

I love ittt

[@TonyMonszhter]

You got the piano notes right, if you go to her channel there is a short video of the song's teaser video and the same notes that you play sound, incredible

[@ninaschofield]

Oh awesome thank you!

[@panosatemlos7386]

Love your reactions and the musical insights ❤

[@ninaschofield]

Thank you so much!

[@tuliofelipe315]

BRAZIL LOVED GAGA

[@keanamiller-wood4101]

I see Old Gag has a new persona.Old Gag is done with Amy Winehouse, Marilyn Manson and David Bowie.Gag has moved on to someone new and young.Old Gag is now Jann.Old Gag has taken over Jann's persona complete.This song Disease sounds like ALL OF JANN'S MUSIC!The lyrics of Disease is very similar to Jann's song Charisma.The pic you showed of Gag at the front of the video looks exactly like Jann's video for his song Gladiator.If you are so impressed by old Gag then listen to the original.I can give you some song names of Jann's music.Listen to Jann's songs : Gladiator, Met the God, Emperor's New Clothes and Charisma.You don't have to look at this old auntie Gag.Jann is beautiful and talented.

[@ChristopherMangili]

Hello nina the beautiful lady i love your songs

[@Roboi86]

Gaga is back!!!❤❤❤