Not-So-Sweet 16-Year Relationship | Judge Mathis

The plaintiff and defendant were in a relationship for 16 years. The plaintiff purchased a car but asked the defendant to put it in her name. He claims the defendant took the car for herself, so he’s suing for the cost of the car and insurance. The defendant argues the car was a gift for her. She claims the plaintiff threatened to vandalize the car with a sledgehammer. She’s countersuing for emotional distress
#JudgeMathis #Court #Mathis #RealityTV
Subscribe to our channel below:
/ judgemathis

[@tiendaphillips8738]

Man she got them crazy eyes!! 😂

[@angelawashington6488]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@kimf442]

Right 😂😂😂😂

[@ONABOARDTV]

He was with her 16 years cause every time he looked at her he got hypnotized 😂

[@brodriguez1204]

😮😅😅😅😅

[@Erica-zg7yo]

😂😂😂😂😂 I was thinking this.

[@vonyorker4482]

Her eyes have me screaming Beetle Juice Beetle Jucie Beetle Juice. 😅😅😅😂😂😂😂

[@AngelaMariaSJCafe]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@elee313]

Beetle Juice high lol

[@plbs6]

That’s a thyroid problem smh

[@kingoffarts8352]

He doesn't have to sell his home if he chooses not to. He has a Right to sell or not to..

[@sheilataylor7497]

Thank you. Judge lost me with that comment. 😏🤨

[@huh1989]

He is using her living there as an excuse not to have custody of his children. That’s the point. If he wants custody of his child genuinely he could leave or sell the house.

[@thomashilson4158]

​@@sheilataylor7497The judge shouldn't have lost you. Basically, the judge was telling him the woman was more important than his kid; AND, for the plaintiff to NOT bring him that bullshit.

[@sereneamani1713]

It was suggested as an option.. My question is, why didn't he legally evict her and her children? He had the means to get custody of his child. That's bogus that she and her children were the reason for losing custody of his child.

[@sereneamani1713]

@@thomashilson4158 Makes perfect sense to me

[@dveightdeprave3415]

Man that lady is on that good white girl 😂😂😂

[@mulaaworld.hunidz]

White girl: 👃🏽_______

[@babygroot81]

Booga suga😂😂

[@LeshaFBaby]

On that Britney Spears 😂😂

[@ak24553]

You think so? It’s something but I couldn’t figure it out. I thought maybe she has a thyroid issue

[@dveightdeprave3415]

@@LeshaFBaby 💀💀 shit we talking before she shaved her head or after 🤣🤣🤣

[@Galatians360]

If it's his house she should move why he has to go? Judge is off on this case

[@karendorsey4780]

Their relationship was very toxic ! They don’t need to be together!

[@kimf442]

Right!!!

[@jamescatalao2607]

Indeed it was!

[@NKAB4]

They’re not…

[@Shes_Her92]

I’m not selling my house either

[@classylady4606]

I didn't agree with Judge Mathis on that one. She should've moved.

[@terripratt2807]

Right

[@amberteflon3762]

Omg her eyes 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@ityler6320]

It’s not funny thyroid issues

[@Proverbspsalms]

@@ityler6320🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄here we goooooo. Everyone with bulging eyes doesn’t have a thyroid problem. She just looks crazy. There’s always someone in the comments trying to diagnose someone.

[@ityler6320]

@@Proverbspsalms it’s always someone in the comments being ignorant.. wait proverbs? Psalms oh wow

[@Proverbspsalms]

@@ityler6320 what does that have to do with a name, thinking you’re a doctor, and giving yourself a thumbs up, 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄oh Wowwwwwwww! here we goooooo. Everyone with bulging eyes doesn’t have a thyroid problem. She just looks crazy. There’s always someone in the comments who knows everything!!!!

[@DrinkinCoffeeBih]

SMH 🤦‍♂️ who would sell their house for none sense like this ?… judge off his meds again ya’ll 😂😂

[@wehappyducks8554]

That looks she made at 8:44 🤣🤣

[@kimf442]

Them crazy eyes 😂😂😂

[@webster2086]

She said "🫨"

[@TheBayeauBelle]

She got them Wendy Williams eyes 😂

[@kimberly6200]

😮

[@beverlyhall4578]

She looks cray-cray-crazy

[@israelcamille]

Selling the house wouldn’t be an appropriate response whether she had part ownership of the property or not. Maybe evicting her would have been the route to go if she wasn’t trying to leave on her own..

[@topnotch3112]

Sounds like he chose her over his son and that’s sad

[@jackienewson17]

He should’ve legally evicted her! Bunch of excuses!

[@adrianknight1406]

My condolences go out to those who lost their lives in the school mass shooting in Georgia and their families as well. Hopefully somehow we can put a stop to all the senseless killings one day.

[@bufferover_flo4727]

Better parenting….. been saying that since Columbine

[@kimf442]

Rip🕊️

[@NKAB4]

@@bufferover_flo4727right cus kds don’t come from good homes &nd go out &nd act a fool…

[@osva7807]

Sometimes it sounds soft to say, more loving from parents. More time spent together. Because better parenting , or mental illness is easy. But what is mental illness ? Just give them prescription drugs to make them feel better and act right? Sounds like a mad game.

[@nikkif9873]

@@bufferover_flo4727you can be the best parent your child can still stray and do whatever they want… we all have free will 💯

[@nettejones8276]

They deserve each other. Neither one of them seem like they are the sharpest knives in the drawer😂

[@vonyorker4482]

😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@toniporto8000]

Did you ever think of selling your house? That is the most ridiculous thing I ever heard !!!!! Why should he ???

[@user-ne2df1ro5c]

Seriously.

[@drelex9845]

Coming in this court like he a saint when he had a baby on that woman 😂

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

Right! he tried to roll over that part real quick

[@DaGreatOne1979]

it was wrong but i'm glad it wasn't with her

[@sheilamajor3842]

He never said he was a saint but that witch wrong for taking his car

[@drelex9845]

@@sheilamajor3842 right I agree and wrong for letting her kids disrespect that man

[@drelex9845]

@@DaGreatOne1979 I AGREE SHE OLD AND TOXIC

[@elove4577]

Them eyeballs drove me crazy!!🫨🤦🏾‍♀️😂😂

[@allinme2008]

She scaring me a little bit with them eyes

[@chancest.thomas5160]

"Dated for 16 Years" smh 🚗

[@queenbee3828]

She’s mad cause he’s moved on, and she’s now realized, she can’t manipulate him anymore, so she’s reaching!

[@classylady4606]

That woman's eyes 😳

[@user-ye5ku2ws6s]

Graves disease.

[@Proverbspsalms]

@@user-ye5ku2ws6s 🙄🙄🙄🙄here we goooooo. Everyone with bulging eyes doesn’t have a thyroid problem. She just looks crazy. There’s always someone in the comments trying to diagnose someone.

[@christinerivera8142]

I can't believe the judge isn't criticizing this guy. He had a child with someone else during their relationship. He said he had to get physical with her kids so I guess that means hitting them? Also, the he way he depends on his mother at his age. The whole situation seems like a big mess.

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

l was thinking the same thing😮

[@vivianpatton5692]

I think he's bitter against women now that he & his wife R splitting up.

[@Jedi_Jonson]

Well, with everything that's come to light in the last week concerning Greg mathis and his relationship......I'm not surprised he didn't chastise this dude about having a baby outside of his relationship

[@classylady4606]

​@@vivianpatton5692that's a stretch.

[@kingoffarts8352]

@@Jedi_Jonson I think this was a older one. They were probably married at the time this was taped.

[@TheBsheep]

The defendant over there looking like Suge Avery..."EYES 👀married now💍" lol

[@loribryant884]

Why does he need a car if you don't have a driver's license 🤔

[@G-PAT]

I know it took you 16 years to figure her out but you did dodge a bullet 🚅🚅🚅😂😂😂

[@AllDayFinesse]

She sounds like Mark Walburg’s kind of Boston accent 😂

[@spiritualbae90]

He didn't fight this hard for custody of his son smh😪

[@saturnladee110]

But he definitely put up his hands to fight other people's kids. The boy is better off without him.

[@DaGreatOne1979]

this case is about a car not a kid plus she stayed so

[@RacieRain]

He could have evicted her.

[@Eltown33]

Im surprised drugs was not bought up. Because she looks like it!!

[@elainepinnock2933]

What is wrong with men from u look into her eyes u should’ve ran

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

At 4:13 his momma's looking like "Oh, son... I don't know if the Judge is goin' to believe thát." 😅 Poor thing. She probably hates cosigning his bullshit. She's tired of this mess and probably prefers to Stay Out Of It. 😢😅😢

[@stanleybowser5853]

😂😂😂

[@isiahwarner3087]

The mom had that look like, "That's not what we rehearsed and wrote in our script!!" ⚖️

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

@@isiahwarner3087 LOL! Ü

[@TheJocha31]

He is selfish because he wanted his car that he purchased back....they thought process is all bad and wrong

[@kayshawnsimmons5585]

why buy a car if you don't have a license? And why he got his momma in this mess. He well pass the age of needing his momma to back him up. It's obvious he's a basement dweller 😒😑

[@angelabyers-boyd4860]

Why she .all bug eyes?

[@user-ye5ku2ws6s]

Thyroid disease/ graves disease.

[@barbarajackson9884]

She is trying to steal a car......crazy eyes...

[@kelseygriffin1571]

She got them eyes like the man from three’s company 😂

[@ms.goshay8713]

Don Knotts RIP and yes she does 👀😂

[@m.r.3674]

Why buy a car you can't drive. Fix your ticket and license and humble your butt and take public transportation

[@carlpotter007]

This guy is trying to act like such a saint. Treated this woman and her children like dirt for 16 years, and then after breaking up with her and talking about her like a dog - he turns around and asks her for a favor. He got what he deserved.

[@gailgrant3209]

They’re both whacked.

[@vivianpatton5692]

Put that car n ur OWN name !

[@ms.goshay8713]

Literally Bette Davis eyes 👀 Baby Jane!

[@NKAB4]

I don’t care how long I’m with a man…won’t be any getting physical with my kds EVER PERIOD…

[@waltonjones5411]

Hope your kids ain't physical with him. Make sure you have a house and keep your kids with you from the jump!

[@NKAB4]

@@waltonjones5411 my kds are grown…bt when little I wasn’t having it…you have women that think that’s ok &nd some men that think they have a right to do it…

[@tmack7563]

y'all really b think y'all flexing when y'all say that goofy shiiit, never gone have a quality dude and your kids gon run right over you, especially sons. single moms got the whole black community fck up cuz can't nobody tell y'all r yo kids nothing, reckoning day is coming when the hood gets turned all the way up and you want b safe in them suburbs either with all y'all slick mouths

[@Lola_Bunnie]

Them crazy a** eyes 😂😂😂

[@mybrotherskeeper9764]

At 5:50 did the mom say “ backins and forfis to work”? 😂😂🤣🤣

[@user-fs2bz9hw2z]

He seems very normal. However, the former girlfriend seems problematic.

[@KrisHoppz]

He got used. His house, his car, everything. She moved her bad kids in there and thought she had the car too

[@jasonr.9863]

First but that’s not important. Salute for all these throwback episodes!

[@BigDaddyDax]

He didn't have to get physical with her children. That's a sorry man's excuse.

[@cynthiafrench4411]

She looks crazy

[@jorgem6689]

Man that look she gave @ 7:29 😂 💀

[@Datpmf112]

So he let his child get adopted cuz he didn’t want to kick that woman out his out ??

[@brilliantlybritt1928]

Ummm why does he have to move and/or sale HIS house?

[@marlonyates3690]

Man she looks surprisingly surprised 😭😭🤣🤣

[@denisethomas109]

Jehovah blessings go out to the families in Georgia. ❤

[@kimberly6200]

Yes his blessings will....thank you❤

[@captaincrunchberries2631]

He’s disgusting suing for a car meanwhile he let his son get put up for adoption smh

[@user-ye5ku2ws6s]

Something tells me that the defendant had something to do with him not getting his child. she has a sketchy background, maybe child abuse or a criminal background, she wouldn't leave the house with her son's. He should've evicted the defendant & her sons.

[@phoenixjnyc]

Very toxic relationship. It's best for them to go their separate ways

[@nottistewart]

SHE MAD MAD HUH😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@theuntouchablegirlkysieisc599]

Protect your Peace!

[@kenyakimbrough7152]

I Know this is an old episode, but I hope she gets checked out. She has a thyroid condition.

[@sheridethdennis3837]

Poo Those Eyes on that lady are So BEAUTIFUL AND BRIGHT.. THE WINDOWS TO HER SOUL.

[@laterriasgilbert469]

Why would he suggest he sell his house wth

[@wesleychasady]

Yea sis just went in there and lied. Showed how bitter she was

[@tjneverdefeated4394]

They are too old for this.

[@cantgetbettathanthis]

Backess and forthess to work 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@agchitty]

I bet they know her by the first name at the liquor store 😂

[@chanelhopeful5336]

They both seem off😳😳😳😳😳

[@55thst_rojos]

Well alright

[@wandalawson6857]

I DO AGREE WITH HER👀 CRAZY 😧 I THINK HE NEEDS TO RUN!!😂😅

[@Dshipp25]

Woman be so hurt how you wth someone 16 years an never ment nothin😂😂😂she hurt hurt

[@diwilliams7183]

Lmfao 😂that’s toxic

[@kimberly6200]

She said.............😳

[@topnotch3112]

So he never got his son back? and her eyes screams crazy

[@user-ye5ku2ws6s]

Probably wouldn't place him in the plaintiffs house Because of the defendants criminal background, sounds like her son's were pretty violent too. He should've evicted them & got his son out of Foster Care.

[@undertakerfanz628]

16 years of not liking each other in a relationship😅😅

[@millissentflemmings2216]

The toxicity and torture. 😳

[@blackpowerpuff6155]

Right, it's crazy.

[@CharisToTheWheeler]

@@blackpowerpuff6155I just don’t make sense

[@RobertCooperTheGallery]

What's a caah?!!

[@Proverbspsalms]

Uhhhh you’ve never heard a ny accent?

[@RobertCooperTheGallery]

@@Proverbspsalms ummmmmm of course I have.... I live in upstate, she lives in western NY, that is not a NY accent, that sounds more like Boston....

[@Proverbspsalms]

@@RobertCooperTheGallery I assumed Boston too but because said Niagara Falls that’s where i left it. Either way, it’s an accent. You all sound pretty much the same.

[@coolmoneymitch1046]

I'm so confused the car being in his mother's name but he needed somebody to get him back-and-forth to work but he's buying the car?..I'm so confused.

[@Allthesekisses]

Pretending like he wasn’t gonna be driving dirty.

[@toniadavis2105]

Crazy eyes for sure!!😂😂

[@shyantejones]

Heeeyyyy defendants son 😍 he’s sooo handsome

[@queenavery7400]

Why would he sell his house? Come on judge…🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️🤷🏽‍♀️

[@TalkswithMellow]

Seems like he got tickets in her name, but judge Mathis didn’t let her speak.

[@prettybossy510]

They are both nuts

[@justsobrandi1142]

She's horrible

[@kimberly6200]

Son is handsome❤

[@janellewoodall2326]

The defendants son is kinda… 🫣🤭

[@dmunz7015]

The defendant looks crazy as a MF.

[@dineilbtv]

So you couldn’t just wait a day or two on the car go pay your ticket and get your license reinstated so you can get your own insurance ??🤦🏽‍♂️🤦🏽‍♂️🤦🏽‍♂️🤦🏽‍♂️🤦🏽‍♂️

[@carolinemagee8033]

She took his car because of the new girlfriend 😅

[@queenleorobi8253]

Her eyes 👀 bug 🐛 me.

[@lauralee60]

She's silly and petty

[@mikellbull]

Is she on drugs? Cuz bro 😅😅

[@antoinettetapper2785]

Who remembers the episode with The Parkers with crazy actress who tied up Ms Parker with the crazy 🤪 👀 👁. That's who she reminds me of 😅😅😅

[@lovingmy4kings48]

Well, someone's pantoes are in a bunch

[@sincerelyyourscg8562]

She looks bout crazy lol

[@user-hs1zr6mc5d]

The plaintiffs witness reason made no sense at all. Judge ain't have to embarrass her like that 😩 😂 the defendant is a straight up like. She know that wasn't her car. Turned around next sentence said it was his car 😂

[@saturnladee110]

I'm legit scared

[@chiquitabroxkman231]

Give me that Becky😂😂😂😂

[@humacunra]

What’s wrong with her?

[@pj.talbert9410]

She has wild eyes.

[@nitab7756]

I see why he had to fight her kids look at how she act smh they got it honest just ignorant

[@stevefaulkner2658]

SHE GOT CRAZY EYES YO 😮

[@kimberly6200]

Graves disease 😮..........😳