Old Internet Creepypasta

listen to my music: sptfy.com/lilacboy
more links: linktr.ee/aztrosist

[@triffintarte6102]

My favorite creepy pasta is that image of spaghetti thats shaped like hot women

[@poweroffriendship2.0]

All hail Flying Spaghetti Monster.

[@munchlax6577]

I’ve never heard of that, details?

[@ColasAlgo]

Classic

[@voidbeyondtaken4257]

AAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!!!1!1!1!!1

[@Josuh]

pretty sure you can do that with every image with an app/website, unless you mean a specific image

[@JoshFloor]

I thought dressing up as Slenderman and T-Posing around the neighborhood was a normal part of growing up

[@Cortov]

what is the difference between dressing up as slenderman and cosplaying as a groom?

[@JoshFloor]

@@Cortov whiteface

[@Cortov]

@@JoshFloor is doing whiteface racist towards slenderman?

[@L0rdOfThePies]

@@Cortov yes

[@Emily_Bondevik_Official]

@@Cortov this conversation is killing me

[@Barkii]

Old internet creepypastas are the closest thing to old ass campfire legends passed down through generations the internet has And despite how hilarious they often end up being they can still linger on in your memory when you were still a kid and first read them terrified reading a creepypasta for the first time in years really makes you think about how much you have changed over time

[@timrosswood4259]

@pp 99%? As someone who reads and watches creepypasta content i can assure that there are lots of good ones.

[@2ms2]

As a kid I was unable to look at the screen for too long when seeing Slenderman gameplays. Yesterday I decided to rewatch one and they're just boring lol

[@mistermoo7602]

I feel like there was a golden period, 2011 - 2014, where there was such a high concentration of awesome stories with consistently fresh ideas to find. Now when I listen to a CreepyPasta channel or read short horror I feel kind of disconnected. :(

[@Slyshibe]

Smile dog used to scare the hell out of me, like I couldn't forget that dog's face. I'd close my eyes at night and he'd be there in the darkness looking at me, laughing

[@zigzagzwag]

I was about to comment the same thing! I had a friend who kept showing me creepypastas as a kid and he somewhat intentionally traumatized me with images of the dog. To make it worse i had a husky dog of my own that died soon before that. Even though it's dumb now, the stories accompanying it were enough to keep me from ever looking it up again. I still don't want to look it up lmao

[@Slyshibe]

@@zigzagzwag bro, I looked it up after making the comment to relive the nostalgia. Dumb ass hell creepypasta but there’s a small part of me that’s still scared of dog.jpeg

[@deligeorgieva8535]

I used to cry over that one image

[@stillchill7710]

That's what's supposed to happen when you read the story, you goober

[@zigzagzwag]

@@stillchill7710 it fuckin worked 😭 too real

[@giserson2]

I think the Ben drowned one is pretty cool, because it was a pretty well told story. It's not like Sonic.exe where everything is replaced with blood and gore. It starts out with what seems like some harmless glitching, then building up to the cursed save files and later on what seems like the writer going full schizo. Sure it's obviously not realistic at all, but it's a pretty spooky story.

[@poweroffriendship2.0]

Ben Drowned and Petscop are the reason why ARGs become popular now.

[@boyo7918]

​@@poweroffriendship2.0 Petscop's not really an ARG though. Plus older series like Everyman Hybrid are arguably more influential, while actually having ARG elements

[@c4kes99]

It was the very first creepypasta I've ever read and it did a pretty good job at scaring me when I was younger because I thought it was all legit. I'd literally go to a majoras mask obsession then because of it. Til this day it's my favorite one just for the nostalgia.

[@gibusspy5544]

Oh look, another person with the same profile!

[@saintsea-hat7891]

@@poweroffriendship2.0 lmao how old are you? ARGs have been around for decades

[@TheJxR]

It's easy to say it's not scary anymore but we all know that shit spooked us to our core way back when.

[@pafoneto1275]

Isn't that the creepypasta aren't creepy now, but the kids grow up. I bet Jeff the killer would scare kids if it were invented now.

[@Dat_Feathered_Boi]

@@pafoneto1275 It still does, surprisingly. Overheard a group of children talking about Slenderman at the summer camp I work at. They talk about such things often. 10 year old creepypastas live on.

[@BM30]

When I was younger, creepypastas like these used to genuinely scare the shit out of me but looking back now, they really are just mediocre and kind of cringe to watch in retrospect. Also keep up the great work man, I’ve been loving your content recently so here’s a little tip of cash. Hope you reach 500K soon.

[@chrxstt]

“Euros”

[@elliemelmoth1378]

I don’t think I even knew they were called creepypastas so like I would literally think they were real and there were nights I would not sleep at all

[@superchroma]

the real creepypasta is the fact that you donated to a youtube creator

[@LuigixD]

@@chrxstt Not even euros, they are British pounds I think

[@cwto_mam]

@@chrxstt we got a brit right here

[@sonofadam484]

I believe, if you read the whole Ted The Caver story, there is some sort of devil or monster on the other side of that tight squeeze. It comes up from a set of stirs carved out of the ground and walks around, but Ted manages to sneak around other stone walls while the monster walks in the opposite direction, giving Ted just enough time to cram his way back into the squeeze and escape in one of the most tense and butthole clenching escape sequences I’ve ever heard. After a while of Ted and his friend being back at home, nightmares about the cave and eventually hallucinations about it torment him into going back to “conquer it”, but he never came back out that time.

[@Indra_Security]

I read that as Ted Bundy story lol

[@Jonas-ej7id]

I kinda miss those old quirky and creative looking websites from the 2000s Every website now looks the exact same Even youtube. Every youtube channel in the early days could be personalised so much.

[@layt187]

if the og herobrine story didn't have the stupid dead brother twist i genuinely believe he could've been something decent, wasted potential tbh

[@robomaster5274]

It's not about the year we're in, it's about our age. Kids are getting scared by Momo and Siren Head, just we were by Slenderman.

[@Mayflower96]

@pp yea momo makes me skin crawl tbh

[@AltKaxREAL]

momo was freaking scary to be fair, sadly the intern kinda ruined siren head after a while, faster than it did with momo for me💀 imagine a giant freaki creature Gangnam style in the middle of the forest like damn

[@poweroffriendship2.0]

"Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark" is the closest thing we ever get to a creepypasta way before it's a thing on the Internet.

[@Shlappz]

That one story where the farmer turns his daughter’s bf into a scarecrow still sticks with me

[@membu]

i can't believe they yassified jeff

[@RedSpade37]

They need to put the pic through Yaas filters, haha

[@lockerbuddy2039]

The internet really loves their scary stuff. First was creepypastas, then SCPs were the next cool thing. Now SCPs are going out of style and all the cool kids talk about the backrooms. It's odd as hell how the internet will repeat itself nonstop. I'm willing to bet there will be one or two more trends and then it'll reset.

[@alphalax7747]

Scps and backrooms are creepypastas too

[@mtoffo2275]

creepy stories have always existed, so yea, the particular format may go out of style but the interest for the unsettling will remain

[@Thomas_Angelo]

@@alphalax7747 not all scps are creepy. Some of the scps are hilarious. Like the door knob scp. Just search it.

[@alphalax7747]

@@Thomas_Angelo i know but scps were created as creepypastas

[@Thomas_Angelo]

@@alphalax7747 well it changed

[@doublekey8931]

Creepypastas have been a huge part of my childhood and they used to scare the living daylights outta me. I still remember, when I was in middle school, we would always talk about Slender Man, Jeff the Killer, etc. and a friend of mine would often say that Slender was hiding in his courtyard. Man, those really were simpler times.

[@miserymachine-ry7618]

A big reason why the caving portion of the Ted the Caver creepypasta is so well made is because the guy who wrote it is the actual caver in the images, he just added the paranormal stuff to his actual journals of his caving. Really cool stuff.

[@sageliminal5621]

Ted the Caver was my first creepypasta. I couldn't have been older than 14, and it was near the year it came out. Obviously it wasn't real, but still, I was enthralled. For a creepy pasta, it's truly incredible and a standard all creepypastas should have aspired to, but you have to be willing to give it the patience and settle into it like the multi-media horror novella that it is. It feels like it could have been a very early Mark Z. Danielewski (House of Leaves) work. No creepy pasta has lived up to it since for me. There's also a (fan-made?) movie. It's very amateur and the story is different, but it was a good time if you can suspend your disbelief with the acting/writing.

[@Bossfightin]

Ted the caver was pretty much the first creepypasta

[@porakone9859]

Holy shit siren head asmr is a real thing

[@StraellPlays]

When I was younger, and I don't know why, creepypastas were usually the thing to keep me up at night. I always am so confused as to how I used to slept soundly after watching Paranormal Activity but I couldn't sleep at all after reading a creepypasta, or listening to someone else read one. Something about the ones I read I guess activated some sort of paranoia in me.

[@gremloid]

same! i loved horror movies and would have no issue with them but some creepypastas like slenderman and jeff the killer (the image, not the story itself) scared the shit out of me and i would regularly have nightmares

[@SmokeTheHorsehog]

When I looked up Ted the Caver to read the story myself, I found an article discussing the fiasco about the validity of said story. Turns out, Nick Botic did an interview with Ted himself back in 2020, so Ted is definitely still alive and kicking.

[@debgenerate]

I'm going to be honest, seeing the Jeff the Killer image out of the blue is a bit of a jumpscare

[@fanfan9554]

mfw when he says slenderman images arent scary and goes on to neglect marble hornets, the greatest horror webseries alongside the backrooms

[@bigman1163]

God damn, Ted the caver was written before 9/11? I didn't think anything on the internet could be that old

[@Dabayaba7273]

The internet had existed since 1990

[@thatguy3083]

My worst childhood fear was Slenderman i used to read creepypastas in a sleepover with my friends. The idea that a giant with no face in a suit kills children was too scary for me and also this sound when he catches somebody was too much for me

[@theboiyouddate5722]

When I was younger I liked creepy pastas because they were kinda scary. For Halloween I even dressed up as Jeff the killer bc idk what to dress up as, and I thought he was scary. With that being said, a few girls I knew in middle school were freaks when it came to this shit. They loved creepypastas! They wanted to fuck them, they wanted to be their proxy's, and one of them believed it was real and would try doing weird sexual roleplays with me through kik messages as their oc creepy pasta. I say all this bc It's so nice to hear a take on creepypastas that is nice and kinda wholesome. Makes me remember the goodtimes of creepypastas before they ruined it for me. When I'd watch videos or read stories about them before bed, and how no matter what I'd be spooked by them despite trying not to be. Scariest one was the pokemon red and pokemon silver creepypastas.

[@willevensen7130]

Yikes man sorry you had to go through that

[@theboiyouddate5722]

@@willevensen7130 Yeah it was awful, but at least it was only 6th grade. I'm ok though, thank you for the concern.

[@cocosiano]

they wanted to do what to creepypastas bro?

[@GyroJake]

I love looking back on old creepypastas they are like the foundation of what's considered scary on here.

[@Aubrey198]

Every gmod horror map: WRITE THAT DOWN WRITE THAT DOWN

[@gregjayonnaise8314]

I used to be scared of Jeff The Killer when I was 12. Then I went on Wattpad, and… Let me just say, I wasn’t *scared,* that’s for sure…

[@uhhhscizo6531]

Completely true, I was not alive when the first one was last updated. I don’t even think my parents had married yet. 21 years ago, crazy

[@comixproviderftw_02]

Creepypasta’s in the early 2010’s man. Ya just had to be there.

[@darkninjafirefox]

Before the super popular creepypastas there were those chain emails with a scary image/screamer ending with the "send to X number of people or blue Garfield will eat your teeth"

[@mcpeteymcnustard7777]

Dude these old internet videos are great keep up the good work!!

[@neatoshin]

didnt expect a mention of let’s all go to the world’s fair. you never cease to impress me aztro

[@debrisposting4904]

Loving these videos of internet culture and history videos! Hope to see more!

[@ashleyking8851]

And then there's the countless Luna, and assorted mlp games that had some pretty creepy ideas in them, lmao

[@goonglab]

I'm glad I was a weird enough kid do go down rabbit holes and discover creepy pastas even though I only got into the Internet in the 2010s. I think every kid should experience this stuff

[@kristofgriffin384]

I first discovered these creepypastas when I was around 14 years old. I found them more creepy and disturbing than scary. The ones I liked the most were: The Rake, Russian Sleep Experiment, and the Anasi's Goatman Story. I liked the Rake because it preys on our fears of a creepy stranger stalking us during what's supposed to be our safest and most comforting time of the day: sleeping in bed. The Russian Sleep Experiment fascinated me because I always liked stories where men who want to use science and experimentation to play God, only for it to backfire. Plus, I think it's interesting how sleeping is depicted as the key to keeping our inner demons in check. And finally, the Goatman story is legitimately creepy because it taps into that fear of an impostor lurking amongst a group of people who all supposedly know each other. Also, I like horror stores that are set in a forest are some of my favorites.

[@raythunder8619]

The good old days. Got into it in the mid 2000's and early 2010's and got scared out of my mind. Now it's pretty funny that my first story was Jeff the killer. But then everything got ruin because people made it into a cringy Fandom with that 2014 slender man attack. Hasn't been the same sense. Now the only way I can replicate it is 4chan x or paranormal boards because many of those stories are eerie

[@thebroman500]

Not to mention they made several variations of Slenderman with names scarier then the character itself (Sexual Offenderman as an example.)

[@xxepic_swag_gamingxx5238]

Biggest shock for me was exploring the creepypasta # on Tik Tok and finding kids in 2022 making ticcy toby edits. I was almost proud that they’re keeping my childhood alive it if weren’t for the fact that all of it was gay fanfics.

[@Reya66]

10:17 If only you knew about the countless fanfictions on creepypasta characters. People crush on ben drowned and slenderman dawg 😃

[@LuxuriousLenay]

I was crushing on eyeless Jack at one point😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@Reya66]

@@LuxuriousLenay hate to admit it but me too 😂😭

[@Indieindrocan]

It feels like looking into a different world ah Creepypasta you will forever hold a place In our hearts

[@napwack]

I used to be scared of sonic.exe in like 2012 and 2013. Same with the mario game that had luigis face melted off

[@L0rdOfThePies]

Shit wasn't "i hate you" an intentional crappypasta

[@napwack]

@@L0rdOfThePies even it was it scared me back in the day

[@L0rdOfThePies]

@@napwack i mean yeah that image was horrifying to me too, that and the mario cthulu image thing and the mario creepypasta image

[@neuroticgazer176]

I remember the days of browsing on 4chan and finding threads where people would repost images of old text posts with generally creepy/unsettling stories, long before the over saturation of creepypasta characters e.g. "the killer" types and what not. Watching creepypasta devolve into r/nosleep stories has been painful to watch, the campfire story esque charm of creepypastas has been long lost in the steady flood of thirty word titled stories that give away the entire plot. Like if Ted the Caver was wrote in the modern time, the title would be something along the lines of "My Friend and I Are Spelunking in an Undiscovered Cave and We've Found Something Horrifying and We've Never Been Heard From Again'. But I digress, I can go on about the de-evolution of creepypasta.

[@Barb0nius]

Man this shit reminds me of watching videos titled like "tails dies" and shit and they always made me cry

[@gooeygary]

Not enough pasta in this video.

[@Floridamangaming729]

I mean personally the images still unsettle me and are scary. But im not gonna piss my pants over it.

[@RightClickGamers]

And then we got the SCP universe, and your worst fear became existential dread

[@pedrongreen]

I'm from Portugal and your videos make me feel like we had the same childhood literally in different continents

[@Leon_Kennedys_Ftoy]

I still get a little scared when I accidentally close my eyes in the shower or am in a dark room with a mirror and have to constantly remind myself to not accidentally summon bloody marry 😱😱

[@youtubeneedstochange4414]

I didn't know Springtrap was so scared of Bloody Mary.

[@wrestlingwithjay3770]

Flashback in the early 2020's

[@AquaStockYT]

I grew up on MarbleHornets, and the idea that something you learn about taking an unwelcome notice of you simply by nature of you learning it? That shit fucked you up.

[@revkun]

back in the day a lot of this was scary and id say a lot of it dosent hold up but tbh the old ben drown videos are still really eerie.

[@Bossfightin]

Seeing slender man and Jeff in the picture had the nostalgia flooding me,I remember I would watch that type of stuff,And I would have so many nightmares,But like with fnaf,I didn’t care,Because I enjoyed them

[@bigman1163]

Creepypastas are very fun for me to look back on, sure they're bad and not really scary, but damn are they funny. I mean they can kinda get ridiculous, I mean some of the names are so fuckin dumb I can't believe anyone thought of it as scary.

[@smalltok4638]

Literally Carmen Winstead

[@MissingGamer]

AAAAAAUGHH

[@nonamesorry7135]

I sleep so well at night knowing full well I will NEVER go spelunking in my entire life

[@DonathanXVI]

idk what’s going on but i don’t see ur videos in my recommended until like a few days afterwards, even though i’m subscribed

[@FollowerofDuck]

man i miss early 2000s internet

[@lajeonit]

The first dude just preticted the Sadam hussein memes

[@DonutBoxers]

could you pleeease do a video on those early 2000s jumpscare videos, like the car with the bush and the maze, the little girl in the mirror

[@notelliot-lh1mt]

NOT THE WERE GOING TO THE WORLDS FAIR JUMPSCARE😭😭

[@shikonaori]

I guess these aren't particularly old but Anansi's Goatman and Candle Cove both definitely stuck with me as far as creepypasta goes

[@TristanThesicon-fw8bu]

Aw yes creepypasta I remember being terrified of red mist when I was 7 I thought it was a real spongebob episode

[@bighammy93]

I love how it starts out with luigis mansion music

[@theleafeon1]

Mother 3 music followed by Pokemon Colosseum, my two favorite games - now it just needs Twilight Princess lol

[@Dragonfire-rd7sw]

This reminds me alot ab the adult swim thing "the dawn is your enemy" very simple but just imagine your a kid who stayed up all night scared that your parents would find you watching what you shouldn't then the tv just says "THE DAWN IS YOUR ENEMY"

[@daeamiralis]

Smiledog is probably my favorite just because its so ridiculous

[@daeamiralis]

That and it genuinely unnerves one of my friends so its fun to spam

[@Milla4life2]

NoEnd House genuinely terrified me. I couldn't sleep the night I read it. I was like 15

[@spooder1568]

3:46 thats a picture of the dude that got stuck in Sand Cave i think

[@oceanmango]

I was hoping that first creepypasta you talked about would actually be good, as caving is genuinely so dangerous and horrifying in itself lmao,,,while it feels very dated, the photos def did make me feel claustrophobic and made me think of real photos from incidents. Never thought of myself as someone scared of tight spaces but the photos are just a big no from me. But i also don’t know if it’s actually their own photos or not and the graphic design is literally so funny

[@CaptLinkster]

the mother 3 music really fits with this video

[@the2ndcomingoflaynekrusz654]

The distorted noise in squidward's suicide comes from a song called Torn Into Pieces by Genocide Organ.

[@RapidPhantom293]

I wish kids these days could experience what it was like to be a kid while reading these creepypastas and being wide awake at night while being scared of those fake creepypasta sightings. to me, they are more nostalgic than scary.

[@seanpaul93]

can't remember what it was called but i really enjoyed one where the twist was the story was from the family dog's pov. sounds stupid but it was pretty good

[@chrisbeast._.6182]

having flashbacks to when i was in the creepypasta fandom......... truly , truly scaring O_O

[@Moneychode]

The GameCube Pokémon music is sending me. Yr a gem

[@Oscar-qt9ud]

16:51 Great Cleveland from Family Guy impression

[@TsukumoEt]

Ngl like I havent slept or not run away when whenever I switch off the lights thanks to The Squidward"s Suicide/Red Mist and the Pokemon MissingNo.

[@theehalloweenking]

"what's is that in the background? Is that a guy just going ARgHdhHzhr!!!"...that got me 😭

[@cgumby]

Jeff the killer as a story kinda did suck ass but that image was terrifying to me as a kid, hated even having it open in my old windows background computer

[@RedSpade37]

Jeff still weirds me out, but I have to admit the thumbnail edit of him is pretty cool.

[@gjokuu]

Aztrosist comeback season 🔥

[@BNK2442]

Leaving in consideration how much the Ted The Caver protagonist talks about cave exploration, I wouldn't doubt he actually entered in that space.

[@fiendish9474]

The true horror in old school creepypastas is finding the Jeff the killer x Ben Drowned Yaoi fandom

[@elliemelmoth1378]

I love this because i remember not being able to sleep as a kid because of shit on the computer

[@user-su9fh6ct4d]

“It’s all fun and games until you smell the stench of a gay-“ *ad* “-mer.”

[@themadxd1274]

The best creepypasta videos are the ones who don't go on a tangent, desperately tryna seem cool by shiting on old creepypastas

[@mach6247]

I hate the fact that 10 years later, that Jeff the Killer photo still freaks me the fuck out. I can watch horror movies fine, but I’ve somehow never been able to get over that Jeff photo.

[@thebroman500]

Slenderman is definitely my favorite out of all the old creepypastas because he was a really intriguing concept to me but overtime I stopped caring about him because he just wasnt as scary now compared to when I first found out about him, and the 2018 movie was the final nail in the coffin and I just couldnt take him seriously anymore after years of him being used as the poster boy for the thumbnails of clickbait videos over and over again.

[@timrosswood4259]

I also don't find him scary but i still consider myself a fan.

[@2RatsInATrenchCoat]

I recognize that turnip boy commits tax evasion music

[@K1ng_Squ1dZ]

Sure trevor henderson was ruined very early. Had 2-3 years of golden ages and than yt kids butchered it. But creepypasta on the other hand, went on for atleast a decade. And grew and changed rapidly, it died off at some point, but creepypasta's legacy lives on, whether it'd be in our hearts as nostalgic or the highlight of a simple photoshop of a faceless man, forged from a forum and somehow leaking into the mainstream. Creepypasta has come a very long way It will always remain a huge piece of internet history

[@HalfDuck]

I'm spooked

[@fiddler7858]

I rember sawing that image of a werewolf on the stairs and instantly be afraid of any black dog. And I had a black dog

[@SayGexPls]

3:12 goon cave

[@pistachio9152]

no bc i also went as a creepypasta for halloween one year as a kid, except it was jeff the killer. i thought i was so cool

[@otherone4804]

I’m so glad I’m not the only one who went as Slenderman for Halloween

[@endless_sands]

Creepy bill is free vore?!?!??!

[@Zeifos_]

"If i was 8 playing this cartridge , i'm turning it off. im telling my mom-" i laughed harder than i should have

[@KicaVixMG]

STOP you're so funny lmao

[@Luna_V247]

Does anyone remember The Holders and the sequel stories like Jeff is Back? Persuaded also used to be my favorite. Also, the copy pastas like Frown Cat was so stupid lol