On Al Jazeera: Arundhati Roy on her novel, capitalism, Gandhi, Mandela

  Рет қаралды 105,864

Radical Conversations

Radical Conversations

Күн бұрын

Discussion on her booker-prize-winning novel 'The God of small things' www.goodreads....
Her latest book 'Capitalism a Ghost Story' www.goodreads....
Her introduction to Ambedkar's classic talking about the debates between Gandhi and Ambedkar
www.goodreads....

Пікірлер: 216
@hemangeebhattacharya9418
@hemangeebhattacharya9418 4 жыл бұрын
I haven't got a single host in arundhati Roy's interviews, who gave her opportunities to speak her heart out..
@techcrazie8014
@techcrazie8014 2 жыл бұрын
Totally disagree in this interview in case u think, she was given any opportunity here especially in the end…see how the interview was abruptly before Arundhati could talk more about her views on Mandela…
@inder19852000
@inder19852000 7 жыл бұрын
Her mother brought equal inheritence rights for catholic women in Kerala
@ashwinprakashe3941
@ashwinprakashe3941 6 ай бұрын
Oh so the Catholics boycotted Uniform Civil Code
@yeshonestly4268
@yeshonestly4268 4 жыл бұрын
She is beautiful, intelligent, emotionally intelligent, knows the power of truth and is not afraid to speak it. A great intellectual thinker who gives the impression that she is well aware of the laws of nature and is ahead of times and want ppl to see and understand what she can see and knows
@hasanshikoh
@hasanshikoh 2 жыл бұрын
Indeed. A very beautiful mind, and woman.
@faheemqadri9723
@faheemqadri9723 6 жыл бұрын
she is not against India she is talk about marginalised section of the country which no one wanna talk about them bcs they are not intellectual n they poor
@nitrand
@nitrand 5 жыл бұрын
I wish there were people like her in Muslim countries, who would speak up for the persecuted Non-Muslims of those countries. But no Muslim has the balls to take a stand and fight for human rights of Non-Muslims.
@rjhaveri8bh
@rjhaveri8bh 5 жыл бұрын
+290 million victims of Islamic terror why she never speaks against muslims, because there is no one paying her to speak against muslims. wake up facebook.com/notes/knowledge-is-power/290-million-victims-of-islamic-terror/416083148469556/
@theonly6359
@theonly6359 5 жыл бұрын
Ra JeSh where is the proof?
@rjhaveri8bh
@rjhaveri8bh 5 жыл бұрын
dont want to waste my time ..you see alll her videos. people can so good for poor without bad mouth your country
@rjhaveri8bh
@rjhaveri8bh 5 жыл бұрын
Sickularism is a disease introduced in the constitution by Indira Gandhi, Ambedkar did not allow Nehru to add this word in the constitution I am am Indian Hindu My Great Great Great Grand Parents were forced to migrate from Sindh to Rajasthan when Yazid hejaj al Yusuf the same person who killed 4 companions of Prophet Mohammed sent his general Mohammed bin Qasim to invade India because a hindu king Raja Dahir gave refuge to Imam Hussain family & companions, Mohammed bin Qassim & his army plundered 80 million hindus & buddhists on the way, Until he was driven back by Bapa Rawal whose name till this date given to a city in Pakistan called Rawalpindi. My Great Great Grand parents were forced to migrate back from jaisalmer to sindh, when Alauddin Khalji a muslim sultanate, in 1303 CE lay siege to the Chittor Fort of Raja Ratan Sen, the Rajput ruler to steal his wife Rani padmavati, who was forced to perform Johur. Meanwhile Our cousins the sikhs were lost thier necks & children trying to protect us. In 1947 once again, My Grand Parents were given no choice, Either leave our ancestral home in sindhi over night & flee to India or be killed or forcefully converted to Islam. This happened as our leaders Nehru & Jinnah were both power hungry & were bribed by British to Partition India & Pakistan. The British gave away the birth place of Hindu & Sikh religion, our mecca & vatican & a 10000 year old Vedic heritage was given away to the muslims. When we arrived in India, we learned Nehru made a constitution that gave muslims & christians right to teach in their respective religion in their convents & Madrassas. But Hindus in a Majority India were not given right to open Gurukuls or even teach Vedas in our schools. We were told the partition happened due to religion & so India will be for hindus & Pakistan for Muslims, this happened because the 90% Muslims voted to create Pakistan. But when we came here to India barely surviving our lives, we found during the partition the population of Muslims was 92 million muslims in Undivided India. The population of muslims who went to Pakistan from India was 5 million and the Population of muslims that went from India to Bangladesh (East Pakistan) was 5 million. So at the time of partition 82 million muslims stayed back in India and only 10 million muslims went to Pakistan and Bangladesh (East Pakistan). This despite the fact that 90% of the muslim population had voted to create Pakistan. So East and West Pakistan took 10% of the muslim population but took 35% of the land and resources. We were told Nehru & Gandhi allowed Muslims to stay in India. But hindus who stayed back could not survive the 29% who stayed back in Pakistan were killed, raped & focefully converted. Soon after we were barely recovering our lives in refugee camps in India, lost our all our property our loved one, we were told Nehru created Hindu code bill which means Hindu cannot marry multiple wifes, but muslims can marry. This allowed the muslim population to multiple by the hindu population was controlled. We noted our temples were controlled by government IAS officers, but churches & mosques were handled by christian & muslim trusts. In 1990 our brothers faced forced exodus from Kashmir. We barely survived the 75 years of fake Independence & anti Hindu rule of congress party of India. During this time we were scared to stop the Muslims from cutting cow in front of Hindu temples. Muslims posted Beef party videos on the youtube to belittle the hindus. We were being falsely branded as Saffron terrorists, one by one our religious leaders were sent to Jails in false cases. We were scared to be hindu, branded at sanghi. Fed up of this persecution & lies, We voted in large majority to bring Modi as PM, after 65 years of atrocities. The congress bribed News channels, Biased Journalists & English news papers lied non-stop to defame & scare the hindus. We were scared to even implement the beef ban mentioned in the directive principle of the constitution, which congress party never implemented for 65 years. In 1984 we seen the sikh riots killings by congress party goons. Today 2019 we are so scared that congress party may come back & restart the Persecution of Hindus, the congress party may revive fake saffron terrorism/ Intolerance of India is a imaginary term marketed with the help of Amir Khan & Naseruddin shah. I am hindu scared to be hindu in hindu majority India
@narumughai4803
@narumughai4803 5 жыл бұрын
Arundhati nailed it! Why wouldnt the host let Arundati finish talking??
@srinivaspillai4622
@srinivaspillai4622 5 жыл бұрын
A woman, great intellectual with piercing insight, speaks sense, loves her country without a doubt.
@maruthumuthu4526
@maruthumuthu4526 2 жыл бұрын
This woman??? Love her Country?🤣🤣🤣....
@alankarjoey258
@alankarjoey258 6 жыл бұрын
She is the real achievement of India, unafraid to question the powerful and corrupt
@youtubewatch2254
@youtubewatch2254 5 жыл бұрын
But she doesn't provide any practical solutions..
@myfuhrerr
@myfuhrerr 5 жыл бұрын
Lol shes a joke
@ShailendraSINGH-jk2ev
@ShailendraSINGH-jk2ev 5 жыл бұрын
Action speaks louder than books
@arindamghosal7277
@arindamghosal7277 4 жыл бұрын
Not an achievement but a traitor. Throw her a chunk of money and there she goes, she will speak for you.
@sharminiabbasi2511
@sharminiabbasi2511 10 ай бұрын
I love her Not only her unique prowess... Her brutal honesty. Also her shy coy face that 99.9 women' s gaze, face, persona
@ZephyrBreeze01
@ZephyrBreeze01 5 жыл бұрын
I think the anchor felt bad when Arundhati said that she won't deify Mandela. Probably that's why she interrupted & ended the interview.
@ananyapaul9666
@ananyapaul9666 2 жыл бұрын
"Offended " is the word
@TajamalGhumman
@TajamalGhumman 5 жыл бұрын
How can she be so wise to expose capitalist Mafia without guidence from God? She is really a blessed lady. May God bless her more and keep her on right track.
@hitonozhimo4392
@hitonozhimo4392 5 жыл бұрын
God is with her because she is doing nothing fake ,and she is in the right track if you don't know till now. By the way she aint speaking gibberish like you ,all she says ,she does are fact and not her theory.
@ericrobinson7184
@ericrobinson7184 5 жыл бұрын
The interviewer shotguns questions, while AR responds with answers too deep to move from the problem. Maybe I'm miscalculating the issue, but AR could inhabit any physical body, and see the place of brevity of it's truth. A good soul is the smallest mouth eternity would venture to speak. AR is talking the geopolitical physics of life and death, and being insulted by 10 minutes of modernity traveling at the speed of war. Yet, she is wrapped in the armor of a polite smile. Awe inspiring!
@ShailendraSINGH-jk2ev
@ShailendraSINGH-jk2ev 5 жыл бұрын
Arcane Esemplastic Ecstasy drooling tears of marshmallow
@mountainlinx
@mountainlinx 5 жыл бұрын
Did they actually cut out and edit the part where she was talking about Mandela and Ghandi?!?!?
@abhaymamale6730
@abhaymamale6730 4 жыл бұрын
I agree with arundhati Roy thoughts. Thank you for sharing.💐💐
@vivekprana
@vivekprana 5 жыл бұрын
what a silly interviewer !!! i don't think she even understood what roy was saying.
@loyalindian8986
@loyalindian8986 4 жыл бұрын
Roy, mentioned dams are being used car manufacturers or sugar cane farmers 🙈
@loyalindian8986
@loyalindian8986 4 жыл бұрын
Roy was talking bullshit, interviewer quickly realised it, she abruptly concluded it lol.
@pinkpearl1967
@pinkpearl1967 9 жыл бұрын
What is up with this interviewer? She seems surprised that anyone might not think capitalism is so great, which is pretty insane given the problems it has caused. Then she cuts Roy off at the end. Blegh.
@lovequran6957
@lovequran6957 9 жыл бұрын
+pink pearl i know that interviewer chickened out before she could finish
@poonamabbi7448
@poonamabbi7448 6 жыл бұрын
Roy should not even be invited any where... she belongs on the streets with the kind of rant she does...
@fileboy2002
@fileboy2002 5 жыл бұрын
@@poonamabbi7448 Jesus H. Christ, Indian nationalists are the WORST. I thought US uber-patriots were bad. But I've never seen the kind of mindless, unreasoning hatred coming from Indian nationalists. Any criticism, no matter how well-supported, is just unacceptable to them.
@Ratracer_222
@Ratracer_222 5 жыл бұрын
@@poonamabbi7448 well,atleast she is invited...
@sp_liberated
@sp_liberated 4 жыл бұрын
Dennis Fritz Indian Nationalists are lot closer to the Nationalists of 30’s Germany. They haven’t had any learnings from history, whatsoever. What I have seen them do recently is take the American Right’s methods of propaganda and even some of the talking points. Goebbels must be proud.
@surrected4526
@surrected4526 8 жыл бұрын
What’s up with the interviewer? And did she run out of time? Why did she cut Roy off?
@ai_bieu
@ai_bieu 8 жыл бұрын
Pretty sure it's the editing.
@nitrand
@nitrand 6 жыл бұрын
I think she just got tired of the bullshit that was coming out of Roy's mouth.
@ambat79
@ambat79 6 жыл бұрын
possibly didnt like what she said about nelson mandela. :)
@theonly6359
@theonly6359 5 жыл бұрын
ambat Exactly! She was very uncomfortable 😂. As a black South African 🇿🇦The truth has to be told about Mandela. He wasn’t perfect
@soundhealer6043
@soundhealer6043 7 жыл бұрын
The interviewer is as genuine as a paper flower, lol.
@utpalbasu7164
@utpalbasu7164 7 жыл бұрын
I support the Lady and her opinions.
@AlokAsthana1954
@AlokAsthana1954 4 жыл бұрын
Oh, what a good woman! Something Indian I’m very proud of.
@asher8273
@asher8273 3 жыл бұрын
Arundhati is an inspiration for all the citizens of my country💕
@myartgallery4458
@myartgallery4458 8 жыл бұрын
Arundhati Roy represents the voice of the sane and reasonable voice of India..raises her voice everywhere against the murder of justice,violation of human rights and oppression by fundamentalist Hindu rule..So inspiring a woman commands lot of respect in the whole world of intellect and wisdom..I love the way she speaks..poetic diction,style and double-edged satire and humor she is blessed with...!!
@veenabedi4252
@veenabedi4252 6 жыл бұрын
Asif Islam, arundati voice of reason really ?????????????
@lucabrazi6801
@lucabrazi6801 6 жыл бұрын
Asif Islam so does taslima nasreen.
@poonamabbi7448
@poonamabbi7448 6 жыл бұрын
Asif Islam : You mean SANE like those who INSIST ON FOLLOWING & EVEN KILLING TO ENFORCE THEIR BELIEF SYSTEM that gives MALES of the human race the DIVINE RIGHT to rape any one... MAN, WOMAN between ages 2 weeks-85 years, or animals... abuse, enslave & even kill the women, & any one who refuses to OBEY YOUR COMMAND. Right?
@hallmonitor7527
@hallmonitor7527 6 жыл бұрын
@@nitrand Couldn't let it go, could you? Your hatred for people who happened to belong to a particular religion is overflowing. Why must you come up with so many presumptions? Have you ever questioned your own hatred towards Islam which echoes so loudly in your use of terms as important as terrorism and sexism? It is telling of your home and your upbringing. Don't bother calling me a Muslim to hide your shame.
@nitrand
@nitrand 6 жыл бұрын
​@@hallmonitor7527 I had a great home and upbringing thank you very much. You need to question your cowardice and hypocrisy, which speaks volumes about what trash your parents must have been. Islam is a cult of violence, terrorism, sexism and homophobia. Islam is like an asshole, no matter how much morons like you try to clean it up, eventually the only thing which will come out of it is shit. You need to be ashamed that you are trying to condone a cult of terrorism and prejudice. You may not be a Muslim, but you are something worse, you are a Dhimmi. People like you need to voluntarily kill themselves, so that the world is a better place.
@AyubKhan-qx2sd
@AyubKhan-qx2sd 5 жыл бұрын
I would like to appreciate her intellectual Opinions, I love the way she talks and speaks all about Indian people political issues and their life style .she is really very smart in her deep expressions . she is a so inspiring and influencing women in our intellectual societies among well educated people and civil society people by her freedom of expressions and freedom of thoughts So inspiring a woman commands lot of respect in the whole world of intellect and the world wisdom.she raises her voice everywhere against the murder of justice,violation of human rights and violation of women fundamental rights , women empowerment , women freedom .. she has got a beautiful voice very naturally .. and i would like to appreciate the way she speaks and talks by her unique stylize .. in a very innocent way . i have deep observation all about her beautiful unique life style ..she has been influencing by her smart life style always in our intellectual society by her beautiful expressions . Best Regards
@rjhaveri8bh
@rjhaveri8bh 5 жыл бұрын
+290 million victims of Islamic terror why she never speaks against muslims, because there is no one paying her to speak against muslims. wake up facebook.com/notes/knowledge-is-power/290-million-victims-of-islamic-terror/416083148469556/
@husainjam
@husainjam 5 жыл бұрын
This looks like a highly edited version of the interview. Interviewer just jumping from 1 question to the other. It just gives u a shallow understanding of what is there in the interviewees mind.
@afg420007
@afg420007 4 жыл бұрын
This woman is an absolute diamond
@loyalindian8986
@loyalindian8986 4 жыл бұрын
I don't know when this interview was taken, she said 80% of India population lives on 20 rupees a day. Oh my God, where did she get those figures from? These people get famous by talking grim situation, which is untrue.
@zaveri1945
@zaveri1945 5 жыл бұрын
Truth has 360 degree purity. Each person views their views half true or false.Some are none
@b-23aryankishore64
@b-23aryankishore64 7 жыл бұрын
yes ban the TATAS and Ambanis and all the company's they own. let's pull down the private sector and bring everyone back to poverty....as in pre 90's India. Bring misery to everyone in the name of Socialism. No wonder Americans hate Socialism and love capitalism.
@OtisAdonisChad
@OtisAdonisChad 5 жыл бұрын
It shows that you weren't listening. She is for the poor. She hasn't asked to break down capitalism. She is giving an overview of the system. In effect yes she is suggesting a model based on China or similar. Look at Chinese Welfare state and side effects. She is however not suggesting that much of a radical solution even if she does attend communist rallies. You sir have no idea how Modi's campaign is funded and exactly what US-Israel-Saudi appeasement is by Modi to realign with their agendas of military industrial complex and potential wars for exploiting resources and/or capital expensive for war and equipment. If you think the slapping of Balakot is happening without US blessings in advanced you need to go back and check the Nixon- Kissinger and white papers and policies on India. An India that isn't too strong nor weak is the policy of think tank that controls Asian power balance. India is now favoured to counter check China and for naval bases at Gujarat port for US shale, warship refuelling thereby having a much bigger 'ally' to activate to check China.
@ronalddash6520
@ronalddash6520 4 жыл бұрын
You're so utterly ignorant that you don't even know who creates wealth. The ownership class doesn't create wealth, the working class does. The owning class just owns wealth and assets and of course the productive output of workers.
@shaharukhnadaf7084
@shaharukhnadaf7084 3 жыл бұрын
Aryan thats what the problem of Socialist ..they live in their own bubble..😂😂🙏
@techcrazie8014
@techcrazie8014 2 жыл бұрын
How the interview was smartly and abruptly wrapped as Arundhati is to show her perceptional displeasure towards Mandela…may be the anchor heard a voice from her producer in her ear plugs and thanked her even before ms Roy was expecting it
@nomsangwenya9116
@nomsangwenya9116 3 ай бұрын
The interviewer seemed to hurry her up and cut her off before she explained more, why then call her for an interview!
@mohamedalyahudi3865
@mohamedalyahudi3865 6 жыл бұрын
A writer almost always have to be anti capitalist. The majority of her income come from sheer number of people. Same with anyone selling to the masses. You dont have to be right , you just have to appeal to the largest block of the population.
@anthonygeorge9932
@anthonygeorge9932 5 жыл бұрын
So beautiful!
@nazlone
@nazlone 7 жыл бұрын
India should listen to Arundhati and Pakistan to Tareq Fatah.
@bhaskarsharma9207
@bhaskarsharma9207 5 жыл бұрын
I think India should listen to Lokmanya Balgangadhar Tilak......
@hitonozhimo4392
@hitonozhimo4392 5 жыл бұрын
She is a gorgeous lady A gem of india.
@rajenderverma333
@rajenderverma333 Жыл бұрын
Amazing writer, thinker and activist.
@ashishkanna7353
@ashishkanna7353 4 жыл бұрын
In Kerala the family was running School in that school per person fees 3 lacs. it is less fees no. Group guys
@AyubKhan-qx2sd
@AyubKhan-qx2sd 5 жыл бұрын
I would like to appreciate her intellectual Opinions, I love the way she talks and speaks all about Indian people political issues and their life style .she is really very smart in her deep expressions . she is a so inspiring and influencing women in our intellectual societies among well educated people and civil society people by her freedom of expressions and freedom of thoughts So inspiring a woman commands lot of respect in the whole world of intellect and the world wisdom.she raises her voice everywhere against the murder of justice,violation of human rights and violation of women fundamental rights , women empowerment , women freedom ..
@hemangeebhattacharya9418
@hemangeebhattacharya9418 4 жыл бұрын
I wonder at this woman.... She ever deserves superlatives
@rajithasr7537
@rajithasr7537 5 жыл бұрын
Mesmerising face, talk, she is so cool, peace. Great
@426377
@426377 5 жыл бұрын
She is a highly intelligent articulate Indian treasure.
@rjhaveri8bh
@rjhaveri8bh 5 жыл бұрын
we are brothers and sisters, does not matter we are hindus, muslims, sikh, issai, buddhist still we are all Indus wasi and all brothers and sisters, we cannot identify ourselves as hindus cause hindu is a forign word not even mentioned in vedas aur bhagwad geeta, the word hindu was given by our islamic captors and attackers from the west. Irrespective of which religion we want to practice it is a private matter but we are all products of Indus valley. I want you to listen to what I say today with an open mind and digest this and a part of history, just because we had a violent history with a lot of corruption does not mean we need to live in animosity and hatred for the rest of our lives. The people with vested interest have used hatred to poison our minds against each other. We need to be brave to acknowledge facts and not fall into the same trap that our forefathers were exposed to. For this we must first know the real facts and then learn to move forward with universal brotherhood. I say this cause unlike what many of you have told religion was made of universal brotherhood but it was hijacked along the line, due to rich people who wanted to control people and hold on to the power. Irrespective of your religion there are corruptions and you have become a pawn in the hands of few powerful people, nothing more. Hindus should know the fact that we remember ourselves as followers of hindus is enough evidence that there is corruption in our religious facts. Our religion is not hindu but Sanatan Dharma and Sanatan Dharma is not even a religion it is a green practice which explains preservance of earth and our duties (karma) as a human being. The Mughals who ruled India were the exact same people who first attacked and killed Arabs and after conversion to Islam were diverted to hindustan. The rule of the moghals was brutal and no different from the ISIS we know today, the hindus were afraid to teach their own religion to their children for fear that they will be killed, kidnaped or raped. 1000 years of disconnect from own religion is long time for superstitions to be introduced, when the mughal went the British corrupted the vedic scripts using the Germans. Today sanskrit is more studied in Germany then in India. And to the muslims of Indian, Pakistani and Bengali descendants I want to say with sadness you are our brothers and sister who were victims of rapes and forcefully converted by arabs and mongol invaders, some of you infact agreed to convert out of fear and due to rewards. But your faith is least of my worry, so long that you understand the difference between the preachings of prophet Mohammed vs corrutions introduced subsequent to his death. Infact I want to assure there is no conflict between preachings of prophet Mohammed and that of vedic ways of sanatan dharma followers. Infact Prophet Muhammad declared, “There was a prophet of God in Hindustan who is dark in color and his name was Kahan [Krishna]” (History of Hamadan Dailmi Chapter Al-Kaaf). Some critics allege this is not a Sahih (authentic) hadith, and while their assessment could be valid, their conclusion that the hadith should be discarded is invalid. Basic Islamic jurisprudence holds that if a hadith does not contradict the Quran, then it may be accepted as valid. Islamist deny this important hadith which was written 1000s of years ago, which shows unity of all religions, including christianisty and buddhism. People with vested interest want to retain power hence want to deny. I whole heartedly believe that we are all children of one allah also called iswar, prabhu, god, yhwe (pronounced as yahweh), allohem and by many other names. And I will share show corruption started. Those like me who have read the full text of prophet mohammed last sermon will understand prophet Mohammed asked his followers to follow Ahl Bayt, his family members, he asked you to give the same respect you gave to him to Imam Ali his son-in-law. Infact many of you know nowhere islamic hadith or quran can be found that prophet Mohammed nominated the Abu Bakr as the 1st caliph of Islam, so when Abu Bakr forced himself as the 1st caliph with the help of second caliph Omar, they betrayed the wishes of prophet Mohammed. Infact it is also covered in both Sunni and Shia Hadith catagorically Abu Bakr sent sent Umar to Fatima and Ali to ensure they support him as 1st caliph, but Fatima was so angry that she refused to see Abu Bakr face till death and she asked Ali not to even invite Abu Bakr to her funeral. Caliph Umar who had supported Abu Bakr even burned Fatima house and cause miscarriage of Fatima. Everyone knows Ahl Bayt was persecuted in Arabia and had to flee in desperation, without going to much details I want to say even much of what muslims are being told is corruption of the caliphate. Prophet mohammed clearly said not to collect taxes, where as Caliphate Uthman was killed by the Muslims of Alexandria killed him because he placed a non-muslim Ummayad cousins to collect taxes from them. One of the non-muslim Ummayyad cousin - Muawiyah b. Abu Sufyan. Let us not forget Caliph Uthman was also himself a convert muslim from a very rich Ummayyad and rich background. This is the same man caliph Uthman himself said that all the people who knew Quran by heart have died in wars so 110-130 years after prophet Mohammed death asked the Quran to be rewritten. He called upon people to provide their memories of prophet mohammed which were collected in scribes, but these original scribes burned later. We all know prophets family family faced persecution and Imam Ali was killed and then Imam Hussain was forced to secretly send his family and companions to Hindustan, but when he himself was on the way to hindustan he was killed on the way in Karbala. Hussaini Brahmins still exist and they are found leading Muharram for centuries proves connection between Hindus and Imam Hussain. Today I will share few fact which will highlight how foreign vested powers with the help of our so called leaders, cheated both the People of Pakistan and Indian during Partition. Hatred was harnessed as a tool to acheive the desired outcome. But before I come to that I have a lot of things to share with you. During the 1946 Provincial Elections held in India under the British. Muslim League under Jinnah only got about 27% of Muslim Votes. That is right. Yet if you look at the 1937 elections Jinnah could not even win 1 seat, only this time they created reserved provinces where hindus could not vote in reserved muslims provinces hence gauranteeing victory to them. Thanks to British modified election rules, AIML finally managed to augment itself as India’s largest Muslim party. It also did well in two other Muslim majority provinces. It won 113 (out of 230) seats in the Bengal and 27 (out of 60) in Sindh. So, ML could not form a govt in NWFP, and Balochistan was never a province but was annexed by Jinnah from Nawab of Kalat after independence. The only place it had a decisive majority was Bengal which has now seceded as Bangladesh. Except for Punjab which was in favor of creation Pakistan no other state voted for AIML hence this is why major parts of Punjab and Bengal went to Pakistan. Or let us put it this way that British had achieved what they had planned out of the 1947 provisional elections by using the muslim votes in provinces reserved for muslims. Muslim League managed to win all the 30 seats reserved for the Muslims that means Islamist parties got no votes how is this possible unless it was rigged by british. The results of the provincial election held in early 1946 were not different. Congress won most of the non-Muslim seats while Muslim League captured approximately 95 percent of the Muslim seats. Another important point to note 95% muslims voted to create pakistan. If that was the case then why did they stay back in India then after 1947 if they voted their choice. If they stayed back India then why did Nehru make a secular constitution when it was already clear from before the partition was to divide hindustan based on religion, ie Pakistan for Muslims and India for Hindus. What was the pupose of this excercise. In my view nothing more then British design to stop communist Russian advances to connect with India so they created a buffer state which can be managed by British and Americans in the form of Pakistan. Jinnah took money from British after which he changed his strategy to create separate Pakistan. How Jinnah self proclaimed himself as governor general without any electoral process due to faithfulness to British he was obliged. Not only people of Pakistan but also people of India were cheated there many conspiracies, including conspiracy of Nehru. Uneducated masses of Hindustan where ignorant till today they dont know any facts they only believe what they were made to believe. People of both countries have not been told that British created two dominion states which is not same as two independent countries. It is well known fact the congress committee had elected Sardar Patel as the PM of India, yet Gandhi owing to the preasure from British asked Sardar Patel to step down from PM candidature and he oblidged Gandhi giving way to Nehru. In the end Pakistan got a ex-Hindu, pork eating, alcohol drinking Jinnah as governor General and India got a ex-muslim, Beef eater as PM of India both agents of the British, followed British Interest.
@Unity108
@Unity108 5 жыл бұрын
Pity the interviewer just popped one question after another, without engaging Arundhati Roy in conversation, to expound on her erudite responses.
@SB-vw1wb
@SB-vw1wb 4 жыл бұрын
The interviewer seems more visionary and a real intellectual than Arundhati rao
@flyingspaghettimonster3791
@flyingspaghettimonster3791 3 жыл бұрын
she is a great intellectual.
@vkj321
@vkj321 5 жыл бұрын
One glory so called literary writer, who couldn't write fiction and so she turned commy, from Kerala, where Commies ruled the roost.
@prithvi770
@prithvi770 5 жыл бұрын
Why did they cut the last part?
@smithasreejith8855
@smithasreejith8855 2 жыл бұрын
See she is definitely beautiful. But why everyone give importance towards her physical beauty more than what she is saying. If you ask me i will say she is a great woman, an intellectual. Thats it.
@ronniet71
@ronniet71 6 жыл бұрын
Beautiful lady.
@yourinterestarea6640
@yourinterestarea6640 4 жыл бұрын
Aren't you ?
@hemantsa1
@hemantsa1 2 жыл бұрын
Arundhiti Roy should research more about Madiba and transition period negotiations thoroughly
@faheemtm1865
@faheemtm1865 2 жыл бұрын
Arundhati and Shashi Tharoor will be a good couple 😀😀
@TheAnkurp09
@TheAnkurp09 7 жыл бұрын
thank god people don't do work like the way she thinks.
@ae00505
@ae00505 5 жыл бұрын
who is the one who is asking questions?
@Shiva-pu8nb
@Shiva-pu8nb 5 жыл бұрын
Less than 20 rs,. ........ is exaggeration .
@laxjs
@laxjs 5 жыл бұрын
No its not
@loyalindian8986
@loyalindian8986 4 жыл бұрын
can anyone please reply what is the interviewer's name?
@jerry-simonmalebana1868
@jerry-simonmalebana1868 3 жыл бұрын
Redi Tlhabi
@matthiaseckerle7764
@matthiaseckerle7764 5 жыл бұрын
The Gandhi myth. Everybody praises his non-violence. Have there not been others? What about Subhas Chandra Bose, Netaji, he was able to create bounds, to Japan, he tried with Germany, but Hitler refused. What was the fight of Netaji about? What was his motivation? If we are not talking about this, it all remained in the fog.
@amartyabhattacharya5016
@amartyabhattacharya5016 3 жыл бұрын
We have to see what?
@mathslearninghub3878
@mathslearninghub3878 6 жыл бұрын
Great arundati
@enochcmc7949
@enochcmc7949 6 жыл бұрын
She was gift of Indian
@sunipmukherjee2130
@sunipmukherjee2130 4 жыл бұрын
It was great until the interviewer interrupted.
@freddesmet259
@freddesmet259 4 жыл бұрын
"What's so funny bout Peace, love and understanding?"
@aefwon3936
@aefwon3936 5 жыл бұрын
Every democracy has highs and lows That can never be resolved with communism Democracy can succeed by only willingness
@khurmiful
@khurmiful 6 жыл бұрын
Great voice of dissidence.
@lovequran6957
@lovequran6957 9 жыл бұрын
SEEING THEY SEE NOT, HEARING THEY HEAR NOT, DEAF DUMB & BLIND will never RETURN TO PATH!!!! What a person, very few SEE, SPEAK and STAND for TRUTH, may your voice be heard and wake people up, GOD BLESS YOU for your courage and may people of knowledge and wisdom realize the issues before its tooooooo laaattttteeeeee and save humanity from this world wide capitalist ORDER!!!
@gowrishankar5714
@gowrishankar5714 7 жыл бұрын
Love QURAN
@ameertarin
@ameertarin 9 жыл бұрын
The most hated person in India is Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi. Prime Minister Modi's drill masters part of various branches of the tree having roots of fascism, bigotry, hatred, extremism, intolerance killed Gandhi in cold blood. Dalits 33% of India's population hate him because, as Arundhati puts it, Gandhi created "politics of guilt" giving Dalits a name to stay with them for all times to come. Arundhati a humanist, philanthropist and an intellectual is hated & hounded by Hindu fascists to silence her.
@sting281
@sting281 8 жыл бұрын
+Ameer Tarin I'd say modern India is more confused about their views on Gandhi. Modi's ministry itself is divided on their views on Gandhi. Modi adores him but some of his associates like Sakshi Maharaj lionize his assassin Godse. They keep giving contradictory signals on Gandhi.
@rajraj987654
@rajraj987654 8 жыл бұрын
Ameer , please shut up if you don't know the reality , Gandhi like any human being may have done wrong things, but he was the leader whom no body can compare to be. Arundhati is not an icon..she portrays herself to be an ICON. Gandhi was killed because of partion of Pakistan which Gandhi approved.
@ziggystardust6418
@ziggystardust6418 7 жыл бұрын
Durka Durka We do not 'give' them democracy. It is their undisputable birthright.
@saravanamg7593
@saravanamg7593 5 жыл бұрын
@@durkadurka9573 hurrey foolish fellow in the name of Hindu law ruined the lives this country for centuries, but out siders came and rescued us and given education to understand u fools, u can't challenge us any more u useless.
@suryadev6780
@suryadev6780 7 жыл бұрын
aljazera has nevr to say good about india...wow...
@poonamabbi7448
@poonamabbi7448 6 жыл бұрын
surya dev surya dev : looks like They have been created for JUST THIS ONE PURPOSE...
@SanaullaMohammedNazrulla-zx2my
@SanaullaMohammedNazrulla-zx2my 5 жыл бұрын
surya dev It tries to portray the current affairs! You seem to be bothered facing the truth? Exposed? Feel naked and ashamed?
@ashutoshkumar1960
@ashutoshkumar1960 5 жыл бұрын
@@SanaullaMohammedNazrulla-zx2my yeah...just like Ayesha when she was raped by ur prophet..piss be upon him
@OtisAdonisChad
@OtisAdonisChad 5 жыл бұрын
Al Jazeera is officially anti India propaganda channel running on Saudi money.
@xenimariabarajas2390
@xenimariabarajas2390 6 жыл бұрын
great Arundhati... weird interviewer...
@b-23aryankishore64
@b-23aryankishore64 7 жыл бұрын
I think arundhati Roy needs to take a few lessons on economics.
@narayanabhandary3797
@narayanabhandary3797 3 жыл бұрын
Nice... Has her views, may be with tastes, orientations... Can any individual be able to change system evolved, of various factors of a nation and due to the values valued by world around(?).... Who can fund the changes advocated.... May be dreams... Good to dream... Becoming true, normally an illusion.. There may not be an ideal state on Earth..Pardon🙏
@Ak-pu1yn
@Ak-pu1yn 4 жыл бұрын
Another epitome of Women Empowerment💖I admire & respect Arundhati Roy!btw the interviewer sucks!!
@artistleaf
@artistleaf 5 жыл бұрын
Why you are against Susses ?
@m.ishakziaee9861
@m.ishakziaee9861 9 жыл бұрын
"You worship only symbols/idols/deities instead of God, and thus you invent base lies. Indeed, those (beings whom you deify and make statues of) and whom you worship instead of your true creator, do not even have power to provide sustenance - so seek all your provisions only from Him and be thankful only to Him - for you are/will be being bought back only to Him." (29:17)
@shehlarandirashid856
@shehlarandirashid856 8 жыл бұрын
You follow filthy liar pedophile muhammad.
@shubhashishbehera5225
@shubhashishbehera5225 5 жыл бұрын
Why it should be him and not her
@janakpatel1557
@janakpatel1557 4 жыл бұрын
Roy is not an icon to look up to last person in my opinion
@ashishkanna7353
@ashishkanna7353 4 жыл бұрын
Roy please think positive to the society
@007bhagyaraju
@007bhagyaraju 4 жыл бұрын
What!! 80% of people are living with less than 20rs a day. It is not true. Even according to Tendulkar committee and Rangarajan committee it did not cross 30%. However I believe more will be there when compared to multidimensional poverty
@abhw4001
@abhw4001 4 жыл бұрын
what a liar she is.She is telling ill about country and still people are taking her interview.For all viewers pl visit india and see its prosperity.India is becoming Golden bird and these vultures like Arundhati Roy cannot hamper India becoming potential for entire world.
@JaspreetKaur-jr1up
@JaspreetKaur-jr1up 4 жыл бұрын
Umm where is your golden bird now nd also please tell me whats golden about 122 million people who have lost jobs since March adding to millions others who were already jobless. Lets sit together and blame this on covid,shall we?
@ashishkanna7353
@ashishkanna7353 4 жыл бұрын
Roy's living a rich.she is spoiling many Muslim peoples to that popularity gaining more amount and also popularity
@ashishbagade7601
@ashishbagade7601 7 жыл бұрын
I don't know but what I think is going on in India is something similiar to what happenned in China during den xiaoping's revolution and in Russia during Stalin's regime.....Old cultural world pf peasants and farmers coming to terms with modernity and city life.....But India gets a bad name as always because there is inertia in western thoughts about India...because its always been negative...I am a dalit and my motherland gives me so much that I am proud of it....there are many struggles going on and I am not saying India is perfect....But IT WILL be third largest economy no matter what......I feel racim in western world against Indians more worrying as compared to Casteism against Indians inside India because at least we do have positive discrimination laws to fight against them but in West u just have to bear it....Sad but True :(
@VickySharma-qr8ku
@VickySharma-qr8ku 6 жыл бұрын
just one topiccc... nothing else... , learn something neww
@gagansharda4505
@gagansharda4505 5 жыл бұрын
Tum kya kar rhi ho ban jao Ambani ,ban jao, tata
@captainearth3294
@captainearth3294 6 жыл бұрын
she sould start helping people instead of just writting about writting doesnt help people
@ashishkanna7353
@ashishkanna7353 4 жыл бұрын
She is very very criminal minded please grown up guys Har mind how to spoil religion and also friendship
@skysunny75
@skysunny75 4 жыл бұрын
The interviewer looks like Michelle Obama !!
@isaiahdavid4230
@isaiahdavid4230 7 жыл бұрын
india is a superpower? who thinks that.. This is the first time I was told that
@Juandinggong
@Juandinggong 4 жыл бұрын
God, I swear I have not seen anyone lies so much it is incredible. why she is attacking TATA they are the only company that gives so much back. what she has done is bad mouth India on the international level that certainly doesn't help her "suppose" agenda. what is she saying about people are living in forest and being killed for resources is an insane lie.
@unnamed1993
@unnamed1993 7 жыл бұрын
Her political inexactitude astonishes me....you cannot use the system and work against the system.
@vkj321
@vkj321 5 жыл бұрын
Has she donated anything to poor's cause from over 2 crores she received for her book and from her talks in foreign countries on false crying for so called poor. She criticizes Gandhi and repeats what Hindu hater Ambedkar and his protagonists have been doing for 90 years.
@loyalindian8986
@loyalindian8986 4 жыл бұрын
Roy, mentioned dams are being used car manufacturers or sugar cane farmers 🙈 not sure what is she talking about? Please don't fall for sweet talk.
@ubadtmar7835
@ubadtmar7835 4 жыл бұрын
Roy have written very important books, against imperialism, big dam projects, ..... But her book on "capitalism" is not upto what i expected, it is a repetition of what she said most in of her earlier articles and nonfiction books. Algebra of injustice, listening to the grasshoppers et al
@TheAnkurp09
@TheAnkurp09 7 жыл бұрын
she has no knowledge of anything why is she even writing.????
@mathslearninghub3878
@mathslearninghub3878 6 жыл бұрын
ankur pathak that is Bcz you are so uncomfortable with her words.... Illogical comment😅😅😅
@jerry-simonmalebana1868
@jerry-simonmalebana1868 3 жыл бұрын
Iyoh, this is terrible interview.
@gagansharda4505
@gagansharda4505 5 жыл бұрын
she only show she care of poor people but in the end she is fraud Do something for poor I think she did nothing
@atulduggal1363
@atulduggal1363 9 жыл бұрын
Now this lady is against Gandhi also. She is only publicity hungry Sorry I cannot tolerate this video anymore.
@romaasrani
@romaasrani 9 жыл бұрын
atul duggal she is a booker prize winner, who gave all the prize money to the victims of fascism. Booker prize is enough for her publicity... Well if u r gonna shut people who fight against the mighty by calling the publicity hunger- then wen u really want to question them u might be able to do that.
@romaasrani
@romaasrani 7 жыл бұрын
Darkhorse well if it's that corrupt why not in Darkhorse's ass. Or Maybe in ur mouth. Coz both speak the same language
@arunchattaraj5392
@arunchattaraj5392 4 жыл бұрын
Practice makes writer but not give common sense. Where , when , how and what word will say. It gives common sense. Not possible to get fRom practice. Judge ment may be created from practice.
@georestofair2046
@georestofair2046 9 жыл бұрын
I think she is from Pakistan,,,,Whats her problem with all things in India,,,,,,Try to speak at least some good things,,,,,,,,Problems about Kashmir,Rulers,entrepreneurs, system,police, military,,,,,,,too much supportive to terrorists and some problem making minor communities in Kashmir and all,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,This is the system we are living with at least try to proud with some of the good things...............
@romaasrani
@romaasrani 9 жыл бұрын
geo davis we dont need to... She saying the negative things doesnt mean she doesnt like India or she sees everything negative about India.. She is trying to save the real India from the fascist and Rich forces contaminating the real India.. She s nt supporting Terrorism. She supports the so called Maoists , who were forced to fight against the forces who raped, killed, humiliated them.... U dont need to force yourself to be proud of something when you are being used and looted by fascist forces.. Better fight against them with words... Our lands rivers culture everything s getting spoiled... u wont realise it until the MNC's start selling u dirt and forcing u to eat it,
@VSM101
@VSM101 7 жыл бұрын
Fincher Braandhan Ever Heard about Pakistan? She works for them.
@mithilesh.edavalath2062
@mithilesh.edavalath2062 7 жыл бұрын
Vishal Maraj anyone against the govt is Pak agent isn't it?
@VSM101
@VSM101 7 жыл бұрын
No anyone promoting anti Indian sentiments on a Sudi Arabian fuded station a Sudi Arabia a nation that activaly groups that supports terrorists groups harbored in Pakistan.
@VSM101
@VSM101 7 жыл бұрын
I love how she likes to point out problems in a nation of 7 billion people which are few and far between that are blown way out of proportion but yet when they ask her what is your suggestion of a solution to any of these things happening in india she presents no real suggestion of substance.
Debunking the Gandhi Myth: Arundhati Roy
25:38
Laura Flanders & Friends
Рет қаралды 721 М.
“I Was Wrong About Antisemitism.” Sheryl Sandberg on Waking Up
53:54
啊?就这么水灵灵的穿上了?
00:18
一航1
Рет қаралды 75 МЛН
Когда отец одевает ребёнка @JaySharon
00:16
История одного вокалиста
Рет қаралды 15 МЛН
Wait for the last one 🤣🤣 #shorts #minecraft
00:28
Cosmo Guy
Рет қаралды 10 МЛН
My Daughter's Dumplings Are Filled With Coins #funny #cute #comedy
00:18
Funny daughter's daily life
Рет қаралды 35 МЛН
Arundhati Roy talks about her life and views on the world
30:08
Storytellers' Studio
Рет қаралды 188 М.
Israel-Hamas War: Gabor Mate vs Piers Morgan On Palestine and Gaza | The Full Interview
20:10
Full Extended Interview: Arundhati Roy on Democracy Now!
1:01:53
Democracy Now!
Рет қаралды 59 М.
Author Arundhati Roy on Gandhi and discrimination
7:05
DCP Entertainment
Рет қаралды 1,6 М.
Arundhati Roy with Anthony Arnove, Conversation, 3 May 2017
30:13
Lannan Foundation
Рет қаралды 41 М.
Arundhati Roy Interview: The Characters Visited Me
43:41
Louisiana Channel
Рет қаралды 79 М.
Arundhati Roy with Alice Walker and David Barsamian - Part 1
48:36
Alternative Radio
Рет қаралды 94 М.
Salman Rushdie and Arundhati Roy interview (1997)
29:26
Manufacturing Intellect
Рет қаралды 530 М.
Slavoj Zizek: The Delusion of Green Capitalism
4:06
FORA.tv
Рет қаралды 171 М.
啊?就这么水灵灵的穿上了?
00:18
一航1
Рет қаралды 75 МЛН