On the Jewish Question (Karl Marx)

This Lecture talks about On the Jewish Question (Karl Marx).

[@dotEmfour]

Thank you so much for this great presentation.

[@valeri91xx]

I'm SO happy i found this, thank you!

[@asyouwish6108]

Thank you very much, this was really helpful :)

[@AndyKaknes]

Is there a version of Bruno Bauer's essay, "The Jewish Question" available? There only seems to be bits and parts of it included in Karl Marx's rebuttal essay titled: On The Jewish Question.

[@shiulisinha8901]

Thank you ma’am.

[@AndyKaknes]

If Karl Marx was living in India during this time could this essay have been entitled, "On the Hindu Question?" Given that Jews had their own language at one time, Hebrew, that morphed into the Yiddish language that used the Hebrew alphabet, and itself was a mixed languge - were the Jews not considered an ethno-religious group? Bruno Bauer and Karl Marx's essays seem to view Jews only as religious group. This would seem to be an incorrect analogy in of itself.

[@tristanbruns5968]

Anyone coming to this video with a search for knowledge, please disregard the antisemitic comments below. 1. Marx was an atheist, and was not for or against any religion. 2. Antisemitism is a cancer that affected everyone before WW2 in a way that didn’t seem as egregious, so, yeah, this is not Marx’s best work, but it’s not a prelude to Hitler. This is complex stuff and needs context to understand. (I disagree with Marx’s closing statements of this piece, btw, although I am myself an atheist).

[@tristanbruns5968]

@decolonizationisforeveryon1514 so, you’re saying that you are an antisemite and a racist?

[@tristanbruns5968]

@decolonizationisforeveryon1514 Oh, so antisemitism and Jewish Supremacy are the ONLY two options? I do not believe so. Slippery slope argument, that taking action against antisemites leads to Jewish domination. Also, argument from authority, with you being the authority. No, sorry, not convinced. You’re trying to justify your own prejudice.

[@tristanbruns5968]

@decolonizationisforeveryon1514 yes, I understand what you are saying, and I am saying that, no, I don’t believe you, and that you are projecting your own feelings.

[@letsnotbefriendly]

They wanna be victims yet are commiting actual genocide against REAL semetic people .. these people are grifters and liars and they know they are not who they claim to be

[@ganjaericco]

Disregarding the anti-Semitic comments below, how can you seriously say Marx isn't against religion? Especially Judaism after reading this essay? Was it a prelude to Hitler? It definitely played a role, as Hitler was a communist before becoming a fascist (who read Marx). Just like Mussolini was before he created fascism with Gentile.

[@cross8215]

Imagine you were expelled from 109 schools over 1030 times. Would your mom say the teachers are just mean or would she ask what hell did you do?

[@gaurirane7059]

Seems like Hitlar's big inspiration would be Marx

[@AD-yv6gt]

@Gauri Rane-thats my girl!!! Finally someone to understand this cummunist socialists and national socialist were are two sides of the same coin because their father is marx. He hated jews, slavs(im a slav), muslims, mexicans, christians and many others but he hated jews the most and he mostly wrote about jews in all of his most famous books because there were a lot of jews around him and they were all hardworking, educated and therefore prosperous and he was a pathetic little man never accomplished nothing a spoiled bratt milkimg money from his parents his whole life(his parents had good money) so he went to college, kept milking money from parents, got married had kids but never worked except for a very short period in his life and he was still milking money from his parents and from his colleagues writers, artists and other who supported his views and his "cause", he spent money on drinking and f*cking around while 2or3 of his kids died of hunger or diseases related to hunger in times when that wasnt normal especially if you had any money and he did spend a lot of money its just wasnt his money so he didnt appreciate it so yea his kids starving, his wife had to clean for other people and he is traveling and getting drunk so ofc he couldnt stand jews they were everything he could never be, and yes hitlers ideology is marxs ideology. For marx capitalists were jews, money was god of israel so capital is the god of israel, and capitalism is judaism, and he hated capitalism a free system where the rule is how much you put in that much you get in return, marx hated that cause he didnt put in he got nothing in return so to get rid of capitalism=get rid of judaism, to get rid of capitalist-get rid of jews, so yes hitler bassically copied everything he wrote with small changes even more than stallin the difference was stalin concentrated on class not race and he wanted all the world to unite under coummunist socialism and hitler wanted only all germans to unite under national socialism, thats why he killed and banned communists not because they were so different but because their alligeance was to moscow and he didnt care about the rest of the world except for those nations such as slavic nations he wanted to exploit and stallin wanted to exploite the whole world. Same thing.and that is the reason he burned marxs books he admitted he was"influenced"by marx and said he is not hiding it but he wanted to hide he was actually inspired and basically copied marx but than he wouldnt be the great "mastermind" to his people... I dont know about adeucational system i know everyones system is allways based more about areas or events closer to them and i dont know if you care about this subject at all, i do because most of the western leaders oppenly describe marxism as something good?!?! Thank god i dont live in the west i live in eastern europe but we are influenced by west and i dont want this spread to my country and if you don want either heres a great video it is 5 hour long you dont have to watch or listen at once but it will teach you more than 10000documentaries about hitler or stalin. So if you are intersted(and you should be😂) please watch you will thank me later m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/m3TOqop4hcaHeZo

[@muhammadabuzarkhan7450]

Hitler was originally a Communist but after few unpleasant interaction with the Jewish community he felt Marx criticism on Jews weren't hard enough and created his own Socialism.

[@kescowethtys]

Hitler was always violently anti-communist

[@MrZillaman73]

TALMUDICcommunism=KARLmarx

[@indra607]

@Austrian Painter Your username...lmfao!