One Night at Flumpty's 2 | A Retrospective

[@Vodotix]

Fun fact, in the first game, there is a lack of green, and in the second game, there is a lack of blue. This was an intentional choice by Jonochrome to compliment the visuals by creating a challenge.

[@Piquacho]

This game was always so interesting yet horrifying

[@starvingvulture876]

B

[@Nvmmmmmm1102]

and funny in its own weird way

[@CD-Puter]

1000th liker.

[@Trip_Toon]

Shoutout to Sagan for being the only person to ever notice the string connecting the vents.

[@GlaceonStudios]

I noticed.

[@fonejunky6306]

@@GlaceonStudios Me too LOL

[@cactocrotone2645]

*in 4 year old voice* Bu- buh i did!

[@acrazedgunman3388]

I've never noticed that string for 6 years until I heard him point it out

[@SingingToast652]

Honestly thought the string was a wierd screen effect

[@Newtid]

"Today, as voted on by my Patrons, we're talking about Doki Doki Literature Club. It is not as innocent as it seems." Thanks description, very cool

[@dirk1592]

off topic but i love ur pfp

[@saltytomato5568]

Sir this is Onaf 2

[@Newtid]

If anyone needs context, the original description was accidentally put as the ddlc one!

[@Newtid]

@@dirk1592 Thankyou!! it was made by Jaytail ( they have a channel! )

[@dirk1592]

@@Newtid subbing now!!

[@justinecourtneysgavel89]

Man oh man, can't wait to hear about my favorite DDLC character Flumpty Dumpty.

[@Berribearboo]

Just Flumpty…

[@notinghere2190]

@@aldwinmagno THICC

[@justsomeguywithaquestionab3175]

@@aldwinmagno Flumpty Bumpty on one tit, Golden Flumpty on the other tit.

[@SmumplytheF2P]

Honestly, with how unique Flumpty's is, playing this without the context of the original game it's based on, you'll basically think it it's own game. The characters are as memorable as the real deal, and the mix between goofy the humor and horror is really fun.

[@CalvinoBambino]

With Whinnie the Pooh going into public domain as of 2022, the original piglet asset should now technically be free to be reinstated into the game!

[@cako666]

Oh it was last year only, that's why we got that awful Whinnie the Pooh horror movie 😂

[@revkun]

Flumptys always reminded me of Scream. its a parody of exactly what it is but its less poking fun and shittalking but its more out of love for the franchise and community and is still serious and even spooky.

[@MrKing_MC]

Watching ONAF gameplay again makes me Nostalgic.

[@logicalwren8061]

Flumpty was probably the most scary DDLC character tbh

[@Lh0000]

He was immune to the plot!

[@haka-katyt7439]

@@Lh0000 and he can transcend time and space meaning he CAN be in DDLC

[@Lh0000]

@@haka-katyt7439 that really only applies to a single universe, IE transcending space time isn’t multiversal travel unfortunately.

[@TheRunawayOx]

@@Lh0000 but he's also immune to the plot so...

[@darkninjafirefox]

So glad to hear CoryxKenshin's let's plays getting the appreciation deserved

[@zOOpygOOpert]

I laughed so hard my veins hurt

[@Glory2Snowstar]

Ooh, yes! The best FNAF fangame ever! As a user of GameMaker I loved seeing that such a beautiful, entertaining piece of art could be crafted through its powers. I should perhaps take a gander at the internals of the game to see how all the artsy stuff works because it's a delight. Thank you Johnochrome for making my childhood fun with many of your creations, but most of all this.

[@Sugarizer-i2h]

Wait, how can you be here as well???

[@toxic_shr00m]

As a very unskilled GameMaker user, the One Night at Flumpty's games are a huge inspiration for me. (A few months ago, I programmed a functional keypad, lol)

[@ReminiscentIndustries]

This was one of the few OG fan games (JoC, FNaC, and all of those) that I never beat on any mode. It was very difficult, and I may try again, just by watching this.

[@Anxmaly666]

That basement level in Joy of Creation story mode was pure anxiety

[@thegoldenwaddledee]

Gonna sound weird but out of this series I liked his commentary over the games the most For the longest time I used them as videos to fall asleep to and I found the way he describes his thought process and the way certain ideas came about super interesting and inspiring

[@toxic_shr00m]

For sure. The commentary videos (which recently were given new thumbnails) have been some of my favorite videos to watch when I need inspiration for anything. Jon's just such a hugely relatable person for me.

[@sammcgarry5822]

@@toxic_shr00m damn it really sucks to see positive comments about him now

[@ki7roy]

@@sammcgarry5822 ?

[@sammcgarry5822]

@@ki7roy he dated a 13 yr old at age 20

[@ki7roy]

@@sammcgarry5822 who?? sagan?

[@SlicesofHistory]

Anyone else remember that DA Games song “Flumpty’s Jam”?

[@thenorthernbard3688]

Dude that song still gets stuck in my head after this long it slaps

[@oxintoma32dev]

Yes i do

[@nathanlevy8612]

Oh, I do! Man that was such a banger!

[@marcoantoniotorres4924]

*JUMP OUT LOUD FOR FLUMPTY'S JAM, SPICK AND SPAM AND GOES WELL WITH HAM*

[@solarboydjango5219]

YES!

[@RobbYarber]

In all the let's plays I've watched I seriously never noticed the string connecting the two vent doors, until now, when you pointed it out, that is such a neat little detail!

[@JollibeenosHasYourCoordinates]

Danort4: _accidentally pledges more money_ "Shoot, I'm gonna need to refund tha-" Sagan: *A blessing from the lord!*

[@sheehan3204]

"SHIT I DIDN'T MEAN TO ADD AN EXTRA 0"

[@NotAGraveRobber]

Somehow I hadn't put together that Jonochrome made Riddle School too, that was my JAM when I was younger

[@TheShinyDude]

This literally couldn’t have been perfectly timed, clickteam just revealed the egg collection (which includes ONAF3)

[@yunghunt2644]

Honestly I think it’s okay to not be too ambitious, especially when what you do choose to create is REALLY solid in its execution.

[@DWN037]

7:28 "A portal opens in your wall which Grunkfuss will appear through after his timer runs out, which you can keep track of conveniently on Cam 2." This is an inaccuracy. In reality, the portal appears on the Constitution of theSE UNITED ST *ATES OF **_AMERICA_*

[@sphynx2691]

Great ddlc retrospective

[@Quicksilvir]

One of my favorite parts about this game is how it handles the camera. I believe FNAF type games have always had an issue balancing the camera and the office. At high levels in FNAF 1 the camera essentially stays locked on Freddy in the hall, and in FNAF 2 the camera will almost always be on the puppet room. FNAF 3 probably uses the camera the most, but then makes the office relatively underpowered and mostly spent rebooting the camera. I can't say Flumpty's 2 does the camera perfect, keeping the lights off as much as possible is probably a bit too powerful. However, I think the need to use it to track Blam/Eyesaur and Grunkfus/Owl puts it a high step above many in the genre. I think one of the great appeals of the FNAF genre are the "oh bleep where did they go" moments and that requires the camera to actually be used.

[@michael120.]

ONAF2 was the very first gamejolt game I downloaded on my moms laptop, I think I got it when I saw coryxkenshin or markiplier play it. I used to think that when you downloaded gamejolt games you had 1 attempt to beat it and if you close the game it goes away, so I kept it on for like a full day because after beating regular mode I got bored and let it sit. Then my brother played it, got bored and closed the game and I got furious at him because I wanted to beat hard-boiled. Turns out my mom just clears her laptop of all those old mario games I played once back in 2012/2013 and I thought that meant closing = auto delete

[@MollyDollyy774]

2:12 He was Animating since the Year I was Born {2004} 5:07 Getting Inspirion from Dreams or Life Experiences, really makes whatever it is, be it a Show, Movie, Music, Game, it makes it for Immersive, which is what I like to do with my OCs, I hope to Finally draw them when I can, taking some Inspiration from Interests, Life Experiences, Dreams, and more, can really make something really Immersive. If you have the creativity to pull it off~ :) 10:37 That catchy jingle that gets stuck in your head really does help with what to do~

[@SportsGaming-ll3ru]

I hope someday he goes over Five nights at Wario’s 3, that is absolutely my favorite fan game

[@scopicaplays]

Did you do the Five Nights at Wario's series yet? I think that franchise has a lot goin' on for it.

[@jonathandunn7853]

It’s such an underrated gem for fnaf fan games

[@user-jn1wm3tb8v]

Five Tries at Love

[@pissnips]

Five nights at wario’s is shit

[@scopicaplays]

@@pissnips didn't ask for your review of the series but sure

[@pissnips]

@@scopicaplays Oh my bad, am I to get your permission before I give my opinion? Really, what made you think this isolated comment displaying my own opinion and criticism of a media you had no part in creating was at all directed to you? And even if it was, why would I have to ask you? You gain or lose absolutely nothing by reading my comment, except for a bit of time. However you cannot even use that argument because you took the time to reply to my comment. Tell me, filthy.memes_v1, how did this comment effect you? How does it concern you? Is it that the senseless hollow comedy you have grown to love and adore until you mature and realise it’s fucking retarded is under attack by some random person on the internet? Or is it that you believe every opinion posted on the internet is required to have your permission? I don’t need anyone’s permission to post my opinion. I mean this very sediment of people saying “didn’t ask” to things that don’t require permission to say is not only stupid but also incredibly easy to counter. You realise I could just say “didn’t ask” back to your comment and it would actually carry way more weight because your comment was directed towards me, while mine was not directed towards you? Do you think the universe revolves around you? Is your urge to reply “didn’t ask” to things that never concerned you an egotistical thing? I mean it would make sense with a name like “filthy.memes_v1”. Is it because you are constantly made fun of and entirely alone in real life, and you need to go onto the internet to grasp at ways to make yourself feel in control and superior? Inflate your ego to overcompensate for it being so fragile? And I know what you’re going to reply with, or at least what your first instinct is. “Didn’t ask.” And I’m here to tell you now it ain’t funny, it’s just predictable.

[@WOF000]

I'd love to see a video on people playground, at first it doesnt seem like something you could cover but it can be really creepy at times

[@antisanity_]

Flumpty Lore: He kidnapped you and forces you to play his 'fnaf' inspired game for no reason other than he is bored lmao

[@antipsychotic451]

Love the videos as always, Sagan. I feel you're only one hit video away from really blowing up in popularity.

[@jonathandunn7853]

Could you do retrospectives for FNAC and FNAW. Wario’s just got a HUGE update recently! Also, have you ever played Five Nights at Ronald’s. It’s honestly one of the scariest ones to me, I’ve yet to see someone complete it 😂

[@sleepwalking3345]

Glad to see someone elses opinion of this game. I LOVE gomotions vids on the retrospectives. I would check her out if you havnt!

[@nameske396]

one of my favorite “sit and survive horror” games

[@the_godbodor7026]

I love One Noght at Flumptys and just talking about how it works and explaining the game shows just how well made the game is

[@CD-Puter]

I love this game!

[@Aggressiveflyingpizza]

I found your channel through the FNAF Retrospective and have been bingeing all your videos since

[@archive3967]

One night at flumptys 3 is coming out on halloween and I cant wait :)

[@XgoDuo]

Definitely one of my favriote fnaf fan games. I like one OnAF2 was able to both keep a fnaf feel while still having some stand out game mechanics like the light switch and the clown. Definitely a step up from the first game.

[@bobbybaccalieri9065]

You're incredibly well spoken bro, great vid

[@caramel9154]

you should cover people playground and the secret noises, locations, discord server, etc

[@reluctant_follower9131]

Hell yeah! I've been waiting for this:)))

[@floopydoodle3082]

The FitnessGram™ Pacer Test is a multistage aerobic capacity test that progressively gets more difficult as it continues. The 20 meter pacer test will begin in 30 seconds. Line up at the start. The running speed starts slowly, but gets faster each minute after you hear this signal. [beep] A single lap should be completed each time you hear this sound. [ding] Remember to run in a straight line, and run as long as possible. The second time you fail to complete a lap before the sound, your test is over. The test will begin on the word start. On your mark, get ready, start.

[@treedom5938]

Dude I never noticed it was a string, that’s so cool and adds lore to flumpy making it a “game”

[@theanimator4098]

I also just wanted to mention the onaf1 actually has some small but interesting ideas to it that make it different enough from a fnaf clone. First of all,all the insta-killing enemies are on the right while the camera killing enemies (jam the door and wait for you to go on your camera) are on the left. This means that you could form a strategy where you close the right door as a last attempt to survive. Also the camera doesn’t waste power meaning that cameras are a lot more useful compared to almost every other actual fnaf game. The other 2 are definitely better but the first one has its perks.

[@the_godbodor7026]

Maybe could you take a look at The Joy of Creation? I loved the Story Mode game for its different gameplay and fun challenge (especially the basement cause those not moving when being looked at is one of my greatest fears)

[@ariallen675]

Ok but who killed my man Piglet

[@gratefulcranegames]

Holy crap, it's already been a good 6 years or so? What even is time? Well I'm glad this gem is still remembered

[@notfloweyyt7618]

something about a mostly loreless goofy fnaf fangame is just so fun to play and watch but it gets better when you add great mechanics

[@VultureCulture]

I love the content you create! Thank you so much for all that you do!

[@CheesyRacc]

I just discovered your channel from your petscop video, loving it so much man!

[@nightdog4183]

I always loved this game, definitely an eggcellent one.

[@ukatosp1953]

A retrospective of the rocky developement of the 5 nights at treasure's island games would be awesome!, keep this up man!

[@hasanaturner]

always so excited to see ur videos!!!!!

[@oxintoma32dev]

Nice video! I really liked it! I really want to see more retrospectives for fnaf fan games like The Return to Freddy's, Five Nights at sonic's and others.

[@KittyFAN13]

Sadly, this video didn’t age quite so well after what Jon did.

[@thischanneldoesntexist6132]

I love this And I’ve only watched 1 second

[@littleyoyo8480]

I bet if Phill Eggtree got captured by Flumpty he'd be one of the very few if not the one to win at flumptys game

[@timelessmedley2782]

dude I love your videos so much I always get hyped when you upload. looking forward to that slender vid 😣👌🏽

[@genaropegoraro6552]

Great job, man! What an EGGscellent retrospective! :D

[@JaydensPlace]

How'd you know I just rewatched markiplier play this game?

[@geekleas2073]

That jumpscare with that atmosphere was TERRIFYING

[@vxlley_flower5672]

My notifs were off for you and I was so mad. I love your videos!

[@shadowboss7895]

Love it when youtube says there's 6 views and 10 likes

[@OneroseArts]

Interested to see your thoughts on fnaf vr. As far as I've looked there isn't a video on your channel discussing it yet. so yeah

[@EliasMorals]

Ngl I'm more of a fan of Five Nights at Wario's 3 being the best Fan Game, but pretty much every fnaf fan game is amazing. Good video!

[@Ruannnnnnnn]

Jonochrome *creates riddle school and onaf* Also jonochrome "hey I don't wanna be remembered being the guy who created riddle school and onaf"

[@Namelessstew]

Interesting description

[@njvikesfan0162]

Meanwhile at Five nights at treasure island: I was the first, I have seen everything

[@sirlogan4786]

FNAF and it’s fan games brought 12yo me into a different world, back in 2015

[@KnottyTulip2713]

so to stop the owl, cut the string, then you dont have to deal with it anymore

[@splitreality8712]

I’ve always thought the jumpscares were the best out of any fan game The 2d is great yeah but that’s not what I mean. It’s less of a frantic shaking everything going wooo spooky. It’s a light camera shake with a small animation and some motion blurr. It’s so simple but it’s actually much more jarring and makes you more scared, cause of how still the characters stay your eyes have time to adjust to what you’re actually looking at. Meaning you get both the jump and the “oh god what am I looking at” especially with birthday and red guy. Imo it’s so much more effective than any other fnaf style jumpscares

[@nyroctopia9376]

Personally, I think the remake of Five Nights at Treaure Island is the most disturbing. However, (fangame wise) I think One Night at Flumpty's 2 is the most fun.

[@_deletus_]

Okay, so, I LOVE the intro! But Grunkfuss would _never_ betray you like that!

[@tappoff]

was about to go to bed, thanks

[@Wafflelywaffles]

Thanks for taking me on that nostalgia trip that is Jonochrome's games. I had forgotten about Riddle School/Transfer but with FNF and this retrospective I've been going back and reliving the experience. Funny enough that I tended to play Riddle School during school. Wish it had taught me how to escape from home schooling. Think I'll support ya on Patron and push for a Newgrounds Retrospective series

[@unearthlyfromage2297]

You should really do a retrospective on the most recent Treasure Island, the 2020 version.

[@monobro141]

jump up loud for flumpty's jam

[@rgultimate8724]

this is probably the most intense fnaf fan game

[@pugsly7453]

I think Onaf 3 is a little more intense

[@TwinkieChief]

I love One Night at Flumpty's, it's a really great game. Also off topic real quick, has anyone noticed the second voice in the Mausoleum Suite from halo 2? It's near the middle section where it sounds like some kind of electric glass sound, really weird description from it I know but it sounds like someone else is speaking in that song. I've not looked in to it deeper but just wanted it out there.

[@TwinkieChief]

I know it's pretty random and off topic, just thought it'd be a great place to put that comment in because there is some weird and creepy stuff out there. Plus it seems out of place for a game about shooting aliens and saving the world to have an eerie message in, and a possible second one. From what I know, no one else has really talked about it.

[@hipsterdolphingrandma3946]

We need a day shift at Freddys retrospective lmao

[@-Centre]

based game choice

[@hipsterdolphingrandma3946]

@@-Centre yeahhh

[@Radi_vvanker]

Yesss new sagan vid and about a great game too

[@baeregard]

WOO i'm so excited, i love ur vids and also this game

[@0rangeEcHO]

Omg he’s doing fan games now

[@Kaika433]

I remember beating hard boiled mode in 2015 this Game was really fun

[@k-c-s2988]

we need some Fnaf Fan made Retrospective videos ! ( Popgoes , , Five nights at candy's , stb..)

[@atanaZion]

What's STB?

[@k-c-s2988]

@@atanaZion im from Hungary and STB means a same thing in a same topic i Like English Teams : Chelsea , Tottenham , Man City , Aston Villa , S T B )

[@aggroash7717]

Who would’ve though that an egg could cause so many nightmares

[@petcrab7026]

I'll never forget my first time playing this and actually shitting my pants. Tip: don't eat taco bell before participating in horror elements

[@the24thcolossusjustchillin39]

How bad was it?

[@petcrab7026]

@@the24thcolossusjustchillin39 it looked like a swamp just piled onto my chair and the floor immediate to it

[@jakman8515]

Riddle school man that's so nostalgic

[@AnOddlyFortune]

The real question is: If Flumpty hatched, what would it be?

[@och1443]

Jonochrome stated that there would be another Flumpty

[@elcuy3544]

A Lovecraftian abomination

[@freakinoutwolf6405]

You know the thing that makes a FNAF Fan Game stand out? Making gameplay different. Flumpty did this perfectly, mechanics we never saw before.

[@fluxcptndavey4378]

2 week later ONAF 3 Trailer has Dropped

[@comedienne_historian]

Stoked for a slender man vid

[@DoodlesOfPoiisøn93]

I really love this game😊👍

[@SpamorammA]

*LOOK OVER THERE ITS THE EGG MAN*

[@Heisx737]

*CAN HE SCARE? YES HE CAN WITH HIS CARTOON GANG*

[@willyaleksanderwiksaas9561]

2:01 omg! Yoo! THIS DUDE MADE THE RIDDLE SCHOOL GAMES?!?😱😨

[@zettaeliza2043]

This art style heavily reminds me of Battleblock Theatre 🤔

[@tinhead_junk]

9 minutes in, One night at Flumpty’s 2 is what Ultimate Night wishes it was.

[@donutdog1937]

hang on i just realised that the pumpkin in the first game is also in spooky's house of jumpscares

[@fricc3824]

Im so excited for OnaF 3, its gonna be great

[@Mrcake0103]

Ah yes, one of the best fnaf fan games ever made.