One Palestine, Complete by Tom Segev (Part 2)

[@jayneyaghmour7320]

Excellent

[@StephenHeiner]

Thank you

[@EgyptNewFascistRev]

Thanks!

[@StephenHeiner]

Thanks for the kind support!

[@mikeboyle5375]

Fascinating content. With regard to Part 3, it seems the author indicates a strong connection between Bolshevism and Judaism. I’ve recently heard historian Mike Duncan of the Revolutions podcast reject this idea categorically calling it in effect untrue and antisemitic. His treatment of the Russian Revolution is an amazing retelling and he seems authoritative. It seems like this is an important claim to clear up even today, and that someone ought to be able to chase it to ground with facts. In any case, thanks for all your good work. I’m learning a ton.

[@StephenHeiner]

The connection is stated by Zionists themselves and is documented in photos and manifestos! More on this in 2025. This year I have to continue to cover many aspects to this issue.

[@StephenHeiner]

Remember that anytime someone wants to shut down investigation or discussion a telltale sign of dishonesty is calling it “antisemitic.” Facts have no ideology. Truth is not afraid of sunshine. If the claims are false they will be proven so. In the meantime the name calling indicates insecurity.

[@hanihani8612]

Thank you, your channel is educational.

[@StephenHeiner]

I appreciate that. Just trying to learn about all this myself!

[@Offa7a]

Great review.

[@StephenHeiner]

Thank you

[@KeithBrighouse-m4g]

Again, fine work in reviewing and presentation.

[@StephenHeiner]

Thank you

[@ramseypietronasser2]

One thing to bear in mind is that selling land is like cashing in on a pension. You buy when you're young. The land goes up in value. You sell when you're old It's the same in Persia but with carpets, for example

[@Lioninthenight]

Excellent book. I'll have to reread it because I forgot a good deal of the granular parts of the book. But because of you, you provided me with a great review and summary of what I have forgotten. Thanks again, Stephen! I find a great amount of use from your fantastic reviews!

[@StephenHeiner]

I’m glad! ;)

[@EgyptNewFascistRev]

Please accept my Super Thanks as a token for my appreciation, have a great day

[@StephenHeiner]

Thanks again.

[@francisheperi4180]

I look upon this conflict in the Holy Land as a curse from God on both their houses until Heaven intervenes, when the hand of God can no longer be restrained.

[@StephenHeiner]

Well the “both their houses” would imply this is some 50/50 thing when the aggression and criminality and lawlessness is 90% on one side.

[@francisheperi4180]

@@StephenHeiner God of the Jews (a cursed race, anyway) versus the God of the Palestinians (who are Muslims)? And yes, the percentages are lopsided and we all know why that is, in this geopolitical landscape.

[@Offa7a]

But Only 5.9% of the land was sold. 50% of that 5.9% was bought from non Palestinian absentee landlords In 1930 selling land was completely discouraged.

[@StephenHeiner]

Yes but unfortunately it still happened, particularly among the wealthy elites.

[@xaviercrain7336]

It was absentee landlords who sold…not Arabs in general

[@StephenHeiner]

It was both. In any case, people are allowed to sell their land.

[@xaviercrain7336]

@ not if they are selling it knowing what is being done…and it shows class prejudice

[@StephenHeiner]

@@xaviercrain7336 this is a silly argument. People are allowed to sell their land to whomever they want to. There are more powerful arguments to be made than "these people prejudicially sold their own land."

[@xaviercrain7336]

@ go and look at the sursok family who sold land…no it is not a silly argument. You still have so much to learn about how Zionism operates. They were not singularly invested households buying.

[@StephenHeiner]

@@xaviercrain7336 I didn't say Zionism wasn't crafty, nor did I say that everyone who bought or sold were virtuous, I'm saying that it's silly to say that people are not allowed to sell their lands. People get tricked about who or how they sell their lands all the time. This is not some new thing in human history. A much stronger argument, regarding the land, is that the British Mandate had no legal basis. That brings into question the 1947 partition resolution and the entire premise from which Israel declared independence. But hey, if you want to pursue this, please feel free.

[@Offa7a]

Thanks!

[@StephenHeiner]

Thank you!