Sounds similar to the mentality of Japan during WW2. That proved to be their down-fall.
@francisburns28113 сағат бұрын
I think you’ve let your personal opinions colour any critical reading of this text. It doesn’t say anything meaningful about immigration, it’s a nativist work that’s a companion piece to The Turner Diaries. It isn’t speculative, it’s propaganda and blatantly so. All the antagonists are caricatures of racist stereotypes, the plot exists to perpetuate a reactionary narrative. None of its “predictions” have come true yet, because it’s all fear based nonsense. Was your initial framing, saying any discussion critical of immigration is going to be labelled racist, just an attempt to be able to dismiss any criticism that could label you that way? Of course there’s room for a real debate around immigration, despite people being polarized, but it’s hard to believe a good faith reader could interpret this book as anything other than the hateful junk it is. If you aren’t a closet ethnocentrist, reflect on your own experience in reference to empirical data on the subject of immigration or immigrant experiences other than your own, don’t paint with such an extremely broad brush that just isn’t backed up economically or statistically. If you’re good faith, that is.
@brendasmart55319 сағат бұрын
Great conversation breaker giggle! Denial is their goal to cover all otherbmilitant & so called social goals lol 😂but horribly sad...
@ferdaousselmoussaid8843Күн бұрын
Great points! What book is this?
@StephenHeinerКүн бұрын
It’s linked: Footnotes in Gaza by Joe Sacco
@arvin4837Күн бұрын
they have a inherited narcissistic personality disorder.
@normita510Күн бұрын
Thank you so much. I will definitely buy the book. God bless you, thank you for standing up for the truth.
@StephenHeinerКүн бұрын
You’re welcome
@a.b.2850Күн бұрын
Israel is a petulant tantruming child for whom “La fin justifie [tous] les moyens”. Zionists are terrorists, and racists, but no one’s brave enough yet to call them for what they really are, that deeply bothers me. Exception made for Montréal, on June 9th protest! I personally have footage of them chanting “Les Zionists sont des racistes, les Zionists sont des terrorists”. At first I was flabbergasted by hearing it, but then proud of the respect shown to our right to freely criticize governments out loud, the protest being heavily guarded and protected by cops (police escort). We, citizens of this world, have no chance of ever getting along and live together in peace if for the entire world 2+2=4 except for that 1 fancy-pants country where leaders have decided for their entire nation that it = 10.
@aqil767Күн бұрын
ilan pappe just released a new book , check it out
@StephenHeinerКүн бұрын
He has one coming out July 30th is that the one?
@aqil767Күн бұрын
@@StephenHeiner book launch video kzbin.info/www/bejne/rKmTgoiKqs5pfbs
@a.b.2850Күн бұрын
Thing is, people nitpick parts of the past that suits them and show no interest in hearing, forget about considering, parts that don’t suit their narrative.
@j.cravani4444Күн бұрын
Israel's prestige and usa down the drain
@StephenHeinerКүн бұрын
If any ever existed!
@a.b.2850Күн бұрын
What Israel’s prestige? They decimated a population to have “their” nation by stealing 76y ago, and are NOW doing it all over again. Of course ‘they’ see prestige, somehow, somewhere, they can fool themselves as much as they want but they can’t fool the entire world anymore and they’re just NOW realizing it, as we speak.
@WilliamDollar-yl3eeКүн бұрын
Hamas is a great example of self critiquing their terrorist attack on innocent Jewish men, women, children & babies. Hamas put babies in ovens & made the mothers watch their babies cook. You are enabling the evil of Hamas with your pandering & defense of evil.
@StephenHeinerКүн бұрын
All of these lies have been disproven already. There is simply no evidence of any of these crazy assertions. But there is video evidence of IDF forces murdering women and children in cold blood. Thanks for the QED, by the way. Video is about the inability of Zionists to self-criticize and you respond with deflection. Classic.
@irenesara455Күн бұрын
Thank you so much for sharing
@StephenHeinerКүн бұрын
You are welcome
@arvin48372 күн бұрын
100% agree.
@elvisiscat2 күн бұрын
“We can’t do anything to help the present, if we don’t understand the past.” Thank you deeply, Stephen, for using your platform to painstakingly take viewers back in time in order to help the present.✊☮️❤️🇵🇸
@StephenHeiner2 күн бұрын
Still have so much to cover
@missmissy24902 күн бұрын
Thank you so much.
@brendasmart5532 күн бұрын
Medieval barbarism was in their plan all along! It should NOT be going on in 2024?!! Wheres the humanity?💫☯️
@rwoods38092 күн бұрын
Thanks Stephen for your review of Normans book. I am a fan of Norman Finkelstein I appreciate his work and dedication to the Palestine/israel situation, he is a master second to none. I have bought the book just received it last week. I have an insatiable quest for learning as much as I can about the Palestinian people and their land.
@StephenHeiner2 күн бұрын
Let us know what you learn ;)
@reemo71232 күн бұрын
'على هذه الأرض ما يستحق الحياة' Thank you so much, Stephen
@StephenHeiner2 күн бұрын
Darwish! ;)
@kazearaki8532 күн бұрын
I recall Finkelstein said the book was not intended for casual readers but instead for future historians so that the history of Gaza is not lost to time. He said, he didn't even believe that anyone would buy the book and that he only hope that someday in the future a historian would stumble upon his book collecting dust in a library somewhere.
@StephenHeiner2 күн бұрын
Interesting!
@sumayahaswad6572 күн бұрын
Thank you for reading this book with everyone. I hope we can erase our ignorance and the ignorance of the world to these crimes. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
@hollyexley2 күн бұрын
God. Truly horrendous crimes committed by the IDF.
@hollyexley2 күн бұрын
Or should I say, the IOF. As they are not defence, they are offence.
@StephenHeiner2 күн бұрын
Have to read it to believe it…at least before they started uploading to TikTok and bragging about it!
@brendasmart5533 күн бұрын
Thanks Stephen, keep rolling out truths on all this mess by shining more light 💡on it all.😢💫☯️
@StephenHeiner3 күн бұрын
Trying to!
@brendasmart5533 күн бұрын
@@StephenHeiner you're not trying you are doing it!! Big difference.
@krieg_guardsman95484 күн бұрын
If that qas true oct. 7 wouldn't have been a surprise they would have been ratted out
@rhysed19974 күн бұрын
Yeah great idea but say that about all the other people who have been through this before, Germany, china, japan, russia, syria, afganistan and so many more where the people don't have a choice in what they say at all!
@ok-hd4ir4 күн бұрын
It's horrifying to see the effectiveness of the Zionist propaganda. I see how unread people are venerating Spain, Ireland and Norway for them recognizing the PA as the chief authority over 67 borders and people thinks that's a solution? The terrorism is just a word for questionable non-state retaliation and when the state does acts of questionable retaliation its a "campaign" or "Operation XYZ" Its almost like one side has been longing to become for a state to avoid this pernicious label but VETOd every time. The bullshit is so apparent the ones deciding if you are a state are the same ones deciding if you are terror group. I dont support Hamas but I personally don't consider them a terror the perpetrators of the civilian killings should 110% be trialed and prosecuted.
@StephenHeiner4 күн бұрын
I think we can see from the most recent hostage interviews that they see the PR value of Israelis going back saying they got baked a birthday cake, etc.
@kishagervais87695 күн бұрын
This is sad, but it does get the point across. No child should have to see things like that To their innocence ripped away like that is heartbreaking.
@StephenHeiner5 күн бұрын
It’s a very powerful storytelling medium
@brendasmart5535 күн бұрын
So sad being told not to believe our own eyes & ears regarding reality...
@Daytonadaisy-126 күн бұрын
thank you for your reviews on Palestinian books! i'm sure you have a long reading list already but i recommend the book Minor Detail by Adania Shibli; it's a historical fiction based on true events of 1948. very short but amazing nonetheless. would love a review if you have read it!
@StephenHeiner6 күн бұрын
I added it to my Amazon wishlist. Might be reviewed next year! ;)
@maxcouleurs46686 күн бұрын
Another great clear explanation. Keep up the good work. Humanity needs justice.
@StephenHeiner6 күн бұрын
Thank you
@maxcouleurs46686 күн бұрын
Well said .
@StephenHeiner6 күн бұрын
Thanks
@mirditasadiku13696 күн бұрын
Was hoping for an unbiased commentator. You clearly are anti-Israel.
@StephenHeiner6 күн бұрын
No one can be unbiased who has spent more than five minutes looking at the truth. You then gain a “bias” for the truth against the lies of the Zionists. I am against the Zionist entity, yes. But I am not against Jewish people.
@mirditasadiku13696 күн бұрын
Your comment that is the lakud line…. You claim the that Israel is acting superior. They simply saud they would everything and anything to defend themselves. What about that is acting superior? Not other country has to ask other countries how to defend themselves in time of war.
@StephenHeiner6 күн бұрын
“Everything and anything” includes murdering unarmed women and children. If that’s what a country is based on it should not exist.
@a.b.28506 күн бұрын
Have you ever done a video on Germinal, de Émile Zola? I don’t know why, but this book fascinated me in my teenage years. I must’ve read it 5-6 times in the following years. I had not thought of that book in years, before watching this short. It’s been 20-25y, so I think I’ll read again it this summer!
@StephenHeiner6 күн бұрын
No, Zola is on the Index of Prohibited Books (omnia opera, which means everything he wrote) so as a Catholic I can only read for a serious reason, for example studying his work as part of a French literature course. I did read some Zola when studying in France but not Germinal. What intrigued you about it?
@a.b.28504 күн бұрын
@@StephenHeiner I was not aware of the existence of an index of prohibited books, and why is Zola on that list… because of religion? (I’m catholic too, as catholic as we can be in Québec.. which could prob explain why I’ve never heard of this). I did read it first for French lit class, I was prob ~14yo. I wasn’t much interested in reading books at that time tbh (was competing++, training 24h+/week) it came later for me, but Germinal was the first book I did read completely, and to my own surprise, with interest. [I hope my memory is not failing me here, and I won’t make a fool of myself 🫠😅] What got to me, the sensitive teen that I was (as far as I can remember), were the extremely poor and abusive life and working conditions of the time, this constant darkness floating above their heads (literally and figuratively), the absence of any hope of a better tomorrow, the level of malnutrition, of suffering and the numbers of (preventable) deaths of women, babies and children, how families all lived together by necessity, how they had no power and couldn’t do anything about it, mothers having to send their young children to work knowing they’d be used for the most dangerous jobs in coal mines that would most likely cause their premature death, and overall, how they lived and died in such horrific conditions bc human beings lives meant nothing. It was to me the first realistic representation that really got to me about how dramatic the poverty and life conditions were at the time (understanding literature is hard with ASD 😒.. but paying attention to every detail sure isn’t 😅). It struck me how life was worth absolutely nothing att, how even though the dangers in coal mines were known and occurred regularly, not much was done to prevent their unnecessary deaths. Reading this book shattered my remaining teenager’s innocence. In retrospect, 30y later, I’m not convinced things have changed that much for the better or that life is worth something more than back then. Sure the work we do nowadays is different and has evolved, but has it really changed in how we’re been treated? In the US of A, RN, Kids that should be in school are working full time jobs in slaughterhouses to do the worst, the most dangerous and most disgusting work out there, and of course 13-14-15 y.olds children have died in *totally preventable* work related accidents, but they don’t care bc they’re brown kids “that prob were Mexican illegals anyways”. That’s happening now, in the USA, despite the “worldwide reputable” OSHA. Working 40+hrs/week for 50 weeks might not even cover your rent and bills, even as a professional, and will only get you 10 days off. We’re back to an era where we need more than 1 person working to cover basic living expenses. Today’s abuse of power over workers is just the same. The more I reflect on it, the more I realize the influenced it might have had on me 🤔. I first started as a r.nurse, then became an occupational health and safety manager in heavy industrial production settings, like aerospace, truck mechanic shops, etc. Maybe. (Please note that English is my 2nd language, sorry for any mistakes… talking about French lit in English is a first for me 😅) FYI, I try to drop a (~) pertinent comment on all your vids and shorts I watch to help out with “the algorithm”, because I really believe your content and the truth you bring to light deserve and NEED to be viewed by wayyy more people. Hope it helps, in some ways!
@a.b.28504 күн бұрын
@@StephenHeiner Also, on a personal note, you not only brought back my interest in literature and reading books in general (instead of listening.. that’s too easy), but also I appreciate your suggestions of books in english covering topics I prob wouldn’t have thought reading about. Thank you very much for that! I just picked up in an ‘exchange book box’ “Les anciens Canadiens” by Philippe Aubert de Gaspé (1786-1871). I know you’re interested in Quebec history ;)
@StephenHeiner6 күн бұрын
If you want to learn more about Joe and his thought process in putting this book together, watch this interview: kzbin.info/www/bejne/j2TWeWtteaqsmsk
@elvisiscat2 күн бұрын
Thanks, Stephen. I saw this interview when it first came out, and so appreciate that you posted it with the book review.
@sumayahaswad6577 күн бұрын
Thank you for honestly researching the history that is being buried with people who lived it ❤️ while it's true that wintness testimony is subjective, it carries the humanity and the emotions of these people. When the written laws aren't enough to tell you it's wrong, the squeeze you feel in your heart that leaves you choking on your words is an indicator.
@StephenHeiner7 күн бұрын
Thanks for joining me on this journey. ;)
@estefaniamg7 күн бұрын
Great review Stephen! Thank you! there are so many parallels, a continuation with what is going on right now, an endless Nakba, now with drones and AI...
@StephenHeiner7 күн бұрын
That’s the thing, as Macklemore said in Hind’s Hall, “the Nakba never ended, the colonizer lied.”
@johnstich17657 күн бұрын
It is about time former president Carter's book receives the recognition and respect it is deserving of.
@StephenHeiner7 күн бұрын
Alas if only more people read.
@jerzeyproone52977 күн бұрын
This was the only dystopic story by him! His first novel, and it’s enough cool❕
@StephenHeiner7 күн бұрын
Have you read the Man Who was Thursday?
@jerzeyproone52977 күн бұрын
@@StephenHeiner Yes!🤓 I've read it on the library of my University 40 years ago. Two years later i bought it. I'm Spanish 🇻🇪speaker, 😅by the way!