ONE VOICE (SHINee 샤이니 '네가 남겨둔 말 (Our Page)' MV Reaction)

[@leeminhyung167]

When I was reading the comments for Our page one comment said: “The music video is 5 minutes and 10 seconds long. Because they have 5 members and 10 years together”

[@Nadia-xr1wk]

if you listen to closely at the end, you'll hear onew say "수고했어" (you did well/you've worked hard) which was a phrase very frequently used towards Jonghyun after his passing, and it also references his song "end of a day" where the final lyrics is something similar. it's both heartbreaking and heartwarming when you hear him say that to his precious Jonghyun💛

[@yeahyen]

And also Jonghyun's lyrics in Lee Hi's Breathe ends with the same phrase.

[@estellev795]

That was what he wanted to hear the most. That he did well.

[@fave525]

also he just wanted people to tell him that he worked hard and did well and he did, damn, what a MAN!

[@parkchimminiee6294]

And can do a time stamp please? I can’t seem to find it🥺

[@wendy-1017]

@@parkchimminiee6294 6:55 13:10 in a really low voice

[@alexajaaay]

read the our page lyrics without crying challenge: failed

[@susanmarie9513]

Ben, I think the next one needs to be our national anthem, Ring Ding Dong

[@doradominguez5709]

YES

[@nicoleguanio9240]

Susan Marie DEFINITELY

[@kundans9265]

yassss

[@akaliahri8442]

Jonghyun - End Of A Day

[@ezmanasir2626]

Upppp!! Arghh pleasee😭

[@teefoo3334]

With lyrics 🤝

[@sunrise420]

idk if he's seen rdd before but if he has i hope he picks this. or if he does rdd tomorrow i'll upvote end of a day for the next one

[@nirupama5644]

PLEASE THIS. Red is so fun but I think deacs will Love this one.

[@roserossm9027]

When you say s**t, i felt it

[@susanmarie9513]

They wrote it about Jonghyun, this song is....there really are no words

[@Adelina-on8nl]

Thank you, Ben for this and for reacting to SHINee🤍🤍🤍 just a little story about the song/mv (writing this before watching) SHINee wrote this song for Jonghyun, it was their way to send him off. The video shows how they were left living their lives after What happened because they took a break from activitaties and from the public when it happened. Minho was filming a movie when it happened and had a few weeks off, Then went straight back to it, Key was dancing because they were supposed to get ready for their Tokyo dome concerts in february that were scheduled to Take place, Onew was writing and producing. Taemin went to the gym because him and Jjong often would work out together. Time was passing by and people were moving on, But they just couldn’t move on.When it happened they weren’t sure if they wanted to keep going as a group or not, But in the end they realized that walking down that path as 5 and standing together was the best decision Both for them and for their beloved SHINee World. The pearl aqua lights that light up around them represent us, their fans that are there for them and guide them back to their passion. And obviously the fifth mic represents Jonghyun. At the end of the song, while they were harmonizing together, Onew says “You did Well”

[@daulfinlover8534]

Perfect summary of this song!!

[@snehamusiclover1]

They were way ahead of time. No hate to anyone but couldn't help saying it Shinee faced something so huge and even after that they came back very strongly The kpop industry scenario might have changed or the criteria of everything might have changed but im proud of them for always trying to come back and always staying away from trashy race I respect them so much for being the same legendary shinee And yes i feel bad that they don't get the recognition and success they deserve but no matter what I will always be a shawol and I will always wish for their happiness and success

[@iousung]

if yall dont ask for ring ding dong next, shawols get zero rights

[@MyvIsLove2]

okay but name one shawol liking rdd

[@onewsfalsetto9439]

@@MyvIsLove2 um, me

[@arenit1]

@@MyvIsLove2 me

[@susanmarie9513]

@@MyvIsLove2 me

[@DiliniOshadhi]

Me

[@linaa2526]

“excuse me miss” but the shinee world 5 version and dw people have reacted to it on yt so it’s safe

[@kundans9265]

yassssss

[@clau6023]

YES

[@blossominapril20]

It's shinee world 4 isn't it?

[@Calvine]

Good evening is such a special song as well. Especially lyrically.

[@fayedorabella]

Yessshhh Good Evening dance practice!

[@Pearlysky25]

YESS Especially the dance practice too! It is just so artistic and the choreography is all laden with meanings. SO BEAUTIFUL. Feels like a contemporary dance art.

[@nicoleguanio9240]

Yeessss with all the symbols for Jjong

[@nykihanis9825]

All 3 titles song for jjong actually. Miss them

[@Ree-js9lc]

“1 of 1” is one of my favorite retro sounds of SHINee, it puts you in a great mood instantly you’re left with a huge smile after watching it i guarantee!

[@aura5572]

At the end Onew says something, he says it live too and looks up the sky, I think it means "you did well". And this blue light they look at in MV is shawol color and we believe blue moon is Jonghyun. When he passed away, this type of moon was seen and Jonghyun loved moon and space with all his heart.

[@SkyeMueller]

I still remember the blue moon and was like whoa that's so cool then I found out about jonghyun and felt so horrible.. 😭

[@ateeztoffu2351]

I can't listen to this song wothout crying like a baby.......

[@losdesafiados]

Key - one of those nights

[@Intervenire]

yes please!!

[@pandakholin]

SHINee - GET THE TREASURE (It’s uploaded by SMTOWN and there are more reactions on KZbin so it should be safe)

[@leeminhyung167]

Please react to Good Evening. I love that songgggg

[@ynjordanc]

Yesss good evening !!!

[@taeyonarahitori]

DREAM GIRLLLLLLLLLL

[@roshinir8384]

Watch jonghyun's end of the day mv...it's really comforting..

[@mahaesuperior]

I'd like to recommend Jonghyun's Before Our Spring, it was released after he passed away and the song and the video itself is such a beautiful masterpiece.

[@maek8934]

There are a lot of MVs I would like to recommend, but next time I want to recommend JONGHYUN's Shinin' to you. His posthumous album's name is .

[@ltm718]

Ring Ding Dong!

[@syedalamiatabassum9123]

Married to the music!!!

[@leeminhyung167]

He’s already reacted to it kzbin.info/www/bejne/jIDbqHh5atd2gZY

[@syedalamiatabassum9123]

@@leeminhyung167 ohhhh...didn't know that. Need to suggest another song then. thanks for informing me 😊

[@ninawilliams9647]

From now on was the boys first concert 2 months after jonghyun passed. The song shows 4 boys, five mics tears and hardship. The song is so beautiful and sad at the same time. The harmonys in this song is like the song ourpage. Watching them cry and struggle was the hardest thing I have ever watched. Thank you so much and I hope to see you react to this.

[@Choimimi100]

Jonghyun - Deja boo 💖

[@MyvIsLove2]

keys 'one of those nights' please!

[@Ree-js9lc]

i absolutely love the look, the aesthetics & the choreography of “Your Number” pls react to this, Ben!

[@theabruun1028]

Please watch the SHINee - Everybody dance practice

[@leeminhyung167]

This reaction shows why Ben is the best reactor on this platform. Cause he cares so deeply and you can just feel that watching his videos.

[@ashdee24]

Key - I Wanna Be. Great song, great MV, also Key makes a mullet work somehow.

[@thekeytomyheart_]

SHINee - Sleepless Nights

[@mich7933]

Everytime I hear this song I start crying.. I love SHINee so much 😔

[@ltm718]

Dream Girl!!

[@PumpkinKoreaSpain]

React to Jonghyun Crazy please. I always cry with our page

[@afihartolo8229]

I always watch Crazy, when i miss jonghyun... *well, it means almost everyday, then... 😍😊😊

[@wuland1825]

Love it ♡ YESS

[@thea.25]

@@afihartolo8229 gosh. Me too. 💚

[@giselacaceres7247]

Yes...!!!

[@tobysmith6196]

Can you react to Diamond Sky?

[@renaissance5301]

RDD is a must! I also submit for the vote, Sherlock or Lucifer dance practices. Both are iconic, your pick! I have no words for Our Page because the meaning it holds can't be expressed through our limited language. To say it's "special" or "meaningful" is a GROSS understatement. If you're a Shawol you understand though.

[@hafyalol673]

How could you not cry

[@mayoannarhimes5315]

Everytime I heard this song I always cry. This song is for Jonghyun.

[@eyla107]

THATS IT IM FINALLY SUBSCRIBING TO UR CHANNEL !! more shinee reactions 🤟🏽🤟🏽

[@bumkeymyeon]

React to 'Your Number' next please!!! I love that video so much and the boys looking hot af as always

[@susanmarie9513]

Oop, theres the tears

[@SeleneLedezma]

The way all of them participated in writing the lyrics makes it even more powerful 💞

[@michellegomilan5596]

Ben, thank u for reacting to this video and i commend you for holding it in thru out the vid. I was crying at the beginning of the video knowing what the song means. Yeah, this song is for our lovely and talented JH. I still can't help but cry everytime I hear this song. I'm looking forward for your reaction to shinee vids. Will drop by everyday to watch it. Always stay safe and take care, Ben 🤗

[@Morgase68]

This song hits me in the feels every time. You can't help but get a little teary eyed.

[@hellotweety9174]

TW: from now on/the domes. Ok couple things, to fill in on what some of the other comments I’m seeing are: in reality SHINee had a short time to decide that they wanted to keep being SHINee. There was Dome concerts already scheduled for February 2018 and ticketed for before Jonghyun passed. They have talked about how they went through that time wondering how they could go forward but Jonghyun’s mom had met with them and told them she wanted them to continue and not fall apart. She gave them the boost they needed to feel it was ok and they hand wrote letters to shawols at that time to explain where they were at and what the plans were. You will hear shawols from that time colloquially talk about ‘The Domes’ (this is the ‘From Now On’ concerts, the title having already been set from before and based off their single to be released), it was the first time since the funeral we saw them and it was an incredibly emotional and passionate experience, as much as it was a concert it was truly a memorial for Jjong between us and them- and an incredibly cathartic one, everybody wept from start to finish. From there they have been unstoppable. In May of 2018 was their 10th anniversary and they celebrated by releasing The Story Of Light trilogy. SHINee meaning ‘the ones who receive light’- it’s their story. The MV’s are: Good Evening, I Want You, and Our Page. They all tie together and are well worth the listen/watch in order as they move through grief, unity, and hope. Our Page was written by the boys themselves. 💗 One final thing, the aqua light that is shown in the Our Page MV really happened. As shawols held memorials all over the world at many of them people experienced seeing things like street lights in the park flicker and turn to aqua. It was very comforting for us at that time and it’s so special that they knew about those happenings and included them in this video. Thanks for taking time to review this song today Ben, I know no one warned you about what it was 😬 but I’m glad you did it. I’m super hyped now about what you will be watching from the boys this week!! 💎

[@fernandax6481]

I’m crying already, this song is perfection and art ✨💜

[@florenceuy8062]

No I can’t survive not crying in this song. The lyrics are so beautiful

[@Ree-js9lc]

SHINee is my first & everlasting Kpop love and you are the first YT reactor i ever watched a few months ago.. You both hit me with all the feels 🥺 and because of you both, I have resolved never to stray from listening and loving Kpop ✨

[@girellaleviafront]

You can react to Symptoms from SHINee, it's my favorite ❤

[@farhatdeeba4779]

Ring ding dong💙

[@nisaliavisha4740]

SHINee - I Want You Song

[@daniellewatson3700]

Love this song. That's it. Nothing else needed. Already upvoted the next ones I'm hoping for.

[@replaysoty5560]

shinee week!!!! uhuuuu love that for us

[@applebee39]

The way I interpret this MV is that even when they were grieving, they had to continue living on their life, continue working and continue living. I felt this a lot when he first passed away, especially that one scene where they were still but everything was moving forward around them. Life continues even as you grieve. But eventually you'll move on as well, carrying those who passed with you in your heart and your memories.

[@kiminoseidei]

Thank you for doing this, thank you for loving our shining 5hinee 💎💎💎💎💎

[@nicoleguanio9240]

Ring Ding Dong because it’s a must! But, you made me cry first thing in the morning, Ben! Been waiting for you to react to Our Page. They also helped together to write the lyrics for this song, makes it more personal. Thanks for the love for Shinee!

[@bonikaboo]

React to ‘From now on - SHINee world best of 2018’ The WHOLE video. I cried a pool when I first listened/watched it. 😭

[@ojkmtbae8955]

IM SO EXCITED FOR SHINEE MUSIC VIDEO REACTIONS ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@loretodiazberrios7263]

My SHINee boys , always 5 thanks for everything my SHINee 🥺

[@jadefillion3440]

GOOD EVENINGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG

[@eg7777-z8z]

Ben you made me cry with this....this MV and song is so meaningful to us shawols, for obvious reasons. thanks for reacting to it.

[@gabih023]

this song is so powerfull, I still cry everytime I hear it

[@kkrk7794]

Thank you so much. I really wanted more SHINee videos from you cause i like the way you react and this made my shawol heart so happy.I am super happy for this journey.Thank you so much.

[@tobysmith6196]

Can you react to Replay: Dance Practice

[@keyyys_]

Every time i watch the MV, I can’t help but tear up...

[@rosariovargas2855]

SHINee A-yo (?

[@nerolaurent2588]

Sherlock (clue + note) SW4 pls

[@susanmarie9513]

Thats a live stage, which he said he doesn't want to risk in the video. Plus he's already seen it on twitch

[@nerolaurent2588]

@@susanmarie9513 so sad :c, thanks for the info

[@milindawilson9175]

Thank you so much for looking up the lyrics for SHINee's "Our Page." I feel like out of all kpop songs in existence this is one of the most important songs to know what the lyrics are about. Every word of the song was wrote by the members and it is all about Jonghyun. The lyrics make reference to things that Jonghyun said to them in the letter he left them when he died. Every word is talking about their relationship as a group and their relationship with Jonghyun.The song and lyrics are a tribute to him and the more than 10 years the members spent together as a group. The song is very powerful and full of meaning. As you can see, the message each of them sings about is very personal to them, it's about their journey as a group and how much impact Jonghyun had in their life. And, as the members have said, it's about all the things they wish they could have told Jonghyun, etc. This album, "The Story of Light" is all about Jonghyun and every song has something to do with what they went through over the past 6 months, etc. "Good Evening" is about SHINee's grieving process and the way the public sees them. "I want you" Is about learning to find happiness again and how they are personally dealing with everything that happened and "Our Page" is the members telling "our story and what we want the world to know about us as a group and what we will remember and miss the most about Jonghyun," etc. "Our Page" is epic because it should be epic. It was the song that made Shawols feel like it was finally OK to start to get back to a little bit of normal again. It was a moment of collective catharsis for everyone within the fandom and it showed us that the members were finally ready to get back to what they loved and they were more dedicated then ever to continue on as a group. I feel like you miss so much of the meaning and story in the MV if you don't know the lyrics. In the MV, in the beginning you see each of the members struggling just to carry on with everyday life. But because they have no other choice they all decide that the only way to honor Jonghyun's memory is to continue on. So you see Onew get back to composing songs (Jonghyun was the songwriter of the group so, this scene also is supposed to invoke memories of him as well), Taemin goes back to the gym (Jonghyun also spent a lot of time in the gym, so this was also Taemin's way of connecting with Jonghyun.) Minho is one of the top actors in Korea and when Jonghyun died he was on set filming for a drama, so we see Minho trying to get back to his normal routine and back to filming. And Key is one of the members, besides Taemin, that is known for his dancing, so you see him getting back to the dance studio and practicing his dance for his first solo debut album. (We didn't know that what we saw in this MV was a secret reveal of his dance for his solo releases, but since then, now that Key's solo album and MVs have come out, we realize that this was the choreography for one of his solos.) The background beat is supposed to be the heartbeat of the group, the heartbeat of the fans, everything that kept the members moving forward and what brings them together as a group, etc. Every part of this song was done very purposefully and deliberately. As you may know, the green/aqua blue light you see all around them is SHINee's fan color, and it represents how Jonghyun is always all around them and how he is calling them back to the stage. The light washes over the members representing how the fans' love, support and solidarity within the fandom gives the members the strength to carry on and to continue as a group. At one point you see each of the members standing still in a room while the world around them continues on. This represents how their world came to a standstill when Jonghyun died and how for a while it felt like their world stopped while everyone else continued on around them. As they climb the stairs to the stage you see the lights come on one by one, I like to think that was each of the fans sending their support to encourage them to keep moving forward. And then once on stage you see the members all standing on stage with the one empty mic stand in the center that represents Jonghyun. In SHINee's concert/fan meeting for their 10th anniversary the members all vowed that SHINee will always be 5 and that Jonghyun will always be involved in everything they do. And during the concert when they performed the choreo for some of their most iconic songs they intentionally left Jonghyun's spot open and only filled in for him when something just wouldn't work without someone in that position. And often during performances where Jonghyun's presence is missed the most, you see them leave an empty mic stand in the center or an open space where Jonghyun would have been, etc. He will never be forgotten and SHINee will always be OT5 forever and ever. :D Fun fact: Just like SHINee's "1 0f 1" MV was 5:25 seconds long because it was supposed to represent how SHINee debuted 5/25/08, "Our Page" was 5:10 long because it was a reference to the fact that SHINee will forever be a group of 5 and this album is celebrating their 10th anniversary.

[@mojkmtmt3131]

All day all night I love live performances

[@labsliiegail]

Been waiting for you to react to this. *sobs THANK YOU

[@stezzmathew4953]

yesssss! shinee is the reason i got into k-pop

[@Lucidanne717]

SHINee-Good Evening

[@teenprez]

Very mean of shawols to start you off here, so beautiful!

[@dakotapowers311]

Omg!! 1 OF 1 ❤️❤️

[@malenabaquer9530]

RING DING DONGGGGG

[@nanirine]

I cried this whole video, my eternal reaction to hearing this song T_T

[@AmeliePoulain_01]

It's already so emotional and then Onew's says "You did well".....

[@belensaavedra3044]

From now on by Shinee ❤️♥️❤️

[@mrs.lh2486]

This lyrics so emotional. Make you cry everyday

[@redwaterkarneval]

Shinee- from now on

[@mhay519]

thanks so much Ben 💖💖💖💖💖

[@amythompson931]

Thank you for this reaction, please let your next one be Ring Ding Dong!

[@pixiyzduss2877]

here again, re-watch all your SHINee reaction videos just because I love it and well yeah 2021 SHINee is back 😌

[@pandakholin]

Ben do we need to ask for TAEMIN - 2 KIDS (new prerelease single coming out tomorrow) or will you do it as usual with the new releases? 😖

[@shinee5hinee99]

Key“ one Of Those nights”

[@dionysiarobinsin7052]

when i first listening this song ..i got so emotianal..i almost cry😢😭

[@ojkmt100]

even when I was not a shawol,when they came back in 2018 I didn't expect them to literally snap with their 6th album. Please remember Jjong for his character,his talent and the beautiful words he left behind and for no other reason.

[@stephanieroseatienza5117]

Our Page holds a special space in our shawol hearts. He will always be remember as a beautiful poem and song. Thank you for reacting to this.

[@zeeeeenuh732]

thank u soooooo much for SHINee. Love you ♥️

[@joanadomingues5524]

I would like to see a reaction for minho's solo mv '"i' m home", because it's the only solo release that Min ho has. It's up to to you, whatever you react it's fine because it's shinee

[@randomapple64]

At approx 13:08, onew in the background quietly says "you did well". Its often not put in lyric videos, but it's always there ❤

[@timashaviswakula412]

I just scrolled down the comments to see which MV reaction has topped. Everyone has commented one MV and no one repeats the name. Basically it means that all SHINee songs are amazing, lol. I won’t dive deep into Our Page because everytime I watch it I cry. So it’s better not to go in deep. I would personally recommend “Ring Ding Dong” because it’s an ageless song. It’s us Shawols’ theme song after all. But since you’re into vocals a lot I suggest you watch some ballads. Ballads with SHINee is the best thing anyone could come across. Once you get into SHINee ballads you obviously can’t get out.

[@kieramacmillan3273]

Even without the lyrics I could tell how much emotion and love for Jonghyun was put into the song and I definitely cried a bit. I haven’t been a long Shinee fan but I feel so proud of all 5 of them. Edit: now sobbing - Taemins first line, “I talk to the sky” made me think immediately of what I do when I talk to my Gran who passed away a few months ago..

[@GleiceCouto]

Your video reactions are the most genuine on YT. Thank u

[@MyvIsLove2]

ben you have no idea how happy u are making me as a shawol and im sure im not the only one. cant wait for a ton of shinee!! ps: you look stunning with that headband!

[@최단비-j3u]

SHINee-An Encore a is realllyyy good song!!!

[@lauralovesmusic22]

Ring ding Dong 🙏🏻💎

[@aloMC]

Well... Now I can't stop crying

[@MkzMary]

I really needed to cry my heart out and you gave me the chance by this reaction video

[@wxsnewhwan_]

And I cry again and almost can not breath 😭😭😭

[@TheAvastra]

You are me everytime i watch and hear this song

[@angellee9008]

Jonghyun's End Of A Day