DEVDAS MOVIE REVIEW! | SRK | Sanjay Leela Bhansali

Here is our review of Devdas!
#Devdas #SRK #SLB
THANKS SO MUCH TO OUR EXTRA JUICY PATREON SUPPORTERS
HANOZ NAVDAR
Be a patron for us and support more videos like this!
/ ourstupidreactions
If you would like to send us something
18960 Ventura Blvd. #76
Tarzana, CA 91356
Korbins Personal KZbin page-
/ korbinmiles
Ricks personal KZbin Page-
kzbin.info/door/BH1...
Korbin Miles - www.imdb.com/name/nm4716836/?...
Rick Segall - www.imdb.com/name/nm0781848/?...
For Business - [e-mail]
Follow OurStupidReactions On FACEBOOK & TWITTER:
FB: / ourstupidpod. .
TWITTER: / stupidreactions

[@OURSTUPIDREACTIONS]

What should we watch and review next?

[@randomdude6862]

Omerta

[@sandeephp2327]

ULIDAVARU KANDANTHE

[@kinfinity]

Dev D

[@stan_1874]

Legend of bhagat singh Rangroot

[@usthambi]

VADA CHENNAI..at least watch the trailer and then try to stop your self from watching the movie😂..you will love it so much! Also will give you an insight into a different style of movie making..!

[@prashantsrivastava5218]

I agree, the acting might look over the top but all the other actors are very experienced and reputed character artists in India so the melodramatic nd stage kinda acting was deliberate choice of the director.

[@Deepakchauhan-ry6hs]

Prashant Srivastava exactly!

[@vihar145]

Yes

[@abhisheksrivastava2688]

All the other characters are probably more experienced than the main 3 leading the film. They will probably understand in time that expression is not a choice for us but is inherent in us. They should probably come and live in India for a month to understand a decimal of it.😂😂🤣😂 Still, the best critics than the one we have in India.

[@dreamerachiever2718]

Actually the supporting cast was more realistic than leads...it's just that westerners are not used to way of Indian way of expressing..

[@rinkapatel5993]

Sanjay the director made it melodramatic. Because in those era, people actually behave like that. People of that era took so much pride of being upper caste. so, Sanjay have to made like it.

[@parthdua3440]

Indian women traditionally put red-colored 'sindoor' in the centre parting of their hair. The husband puts it on her during the wedding ceremony. Its the mark of devotion to the marriage bond.

[@shrutideodhar3838]

Also he wanted to scar her like moon has spots & she was spotless. But bcoz of the blood on her forehead which Devdas runs it up her hair-parting. Its symbolic of Sindoor that he put in her parting. So they got their wish to be "kinda sorta married" she is his 1st. Even if the world won't accept & it be embarrassment if they elope which she had already brought shame by spending late night at His place when her mother was humiliated. So they can't marry each other after that. But he put "Sindoor of blood" in her hair parting so she is his 1st. And then when she is going away she shows him she carry the lamp she always had of faith n wishes n prayer for him

[@mansibharti4665]

There is no mention in the novel about this event.

[@shrutideodhar3838]

@@mansibharti4665 something called creative freedom of director. If u know. I may be wrong. Just like Harry Potter movies. U cant have word 2 word from novel. If u hv to squeeze it in timespan of movie.

[@gaya1604]

@@shrutideodhar3838 however "romantic" that is, its kinda disgusting and shows the guy's entitlement is stamping her even if she "wanted" it

[@shrutideodhar3838]

@@gaya1604 why is it supposed to be my problem? I just explained cultural angle of sindoor to them. "Khoon bhari maang" they don't understand what that means. What the director was showing what Indian masses we're getting. BTW unlike u I quit using logic, sensibility, science, rationality & other components of my brain while watching Bollywood movie like a Decade ago. Sorry for you loss (of ur grey cells*) I really feel sorry for you

[@arshdeepoberoi140]

It was the most expensive Hindi film (unadjusted for inflation) to be released at that time. When other directors would stick to a budget of 5-10 crores, to make his labour of love, Sanjay Leela Bhansali created this masterpiece at a whopping 50 crores. It was nominated for the BAFTA Award for Best Foreign Language Film(one of the only 2 Indian films nominated so far) and was also India's submission for the Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film. It was ranked #74 in Empire magazine's "The 100 Best Films Of World Cinema" in 2010.TIME magazine named Devdas as the best movie of 2002 among all the movies released around the world that year.The film was also included in TIME's top 10 movies of the millennium worldwide.

[@youarein1ov3]

So that intro scene with the over excited "He's coming back" is actually 80% realistic in those days.

[@prathaypalav5276]

Korbin went From “ I am not a fan of random songs in movies” 😐 To “ I was waiting for the songs to come and I didn’t want it to end” 😍 The Bollywood effect ❤️

[@mikiim5739]

🙌🙌🙌👌👌👌👌

[@aashishri5169]

Plzz Comment which is the song u want OSR to react to... 1)Main Koi Aisa Geet Gaun (Yes Boss-SRK) 2)O O JANEJANA(young shirtless Salman) 3)Hawa Hawaii (1987-Sridevi) 4)Dream girl (1977) 5)Aaj phir jeene ki tamanna (Guide 1965) 6)Chura liya h tumne jo (1973) 7)Ude jab jab zulfein teri (Naya Daur 1957) 8)RAMTA JOGI from Taal(1999) 9)SATRANGI RE from Dil se(1998) 10)Koi Ladki Hai Jab Wo Hasti Hai (1997) 11)HEY K SERA SERA from Pukar (2000) 12)Chamma Chamma from the movie China Gate

[@prathaypalav5276]

aashi Shri each and every song if possible 😅

[@aashishri5169]

@@prathaypalav5276 yeah but they don't react to songs that I suggest

[@boonslang6689]

He said it because he didn't want cringy acting to start. Lol.

[@aanchallal5541]

I am sure that Korbin loves the ending but it destroyed me

[@nikitasharma1508]

Another perspective is, the supporting characters are the triggers for what happens to the leads. Those supporting characters' voices were loud in their heads (hence the loud acting) and the leads were submissive to the pressures and so their expression was also more subdued and grounded.

[@kanwalkoul5859]

Nikita Sharma that’s what I thought too

[@garimakilledar5810]

Yeah.. Exactly! Many directors especially in old films and TV Serials do this, if you notice. They deliberately make the supporting characters loud and caricaturish coz they want to show them just in relation to the lead characters and the effect they have on lead characters just to make the leads the 'highlight' of the show. This has changed in recent times, when every character has an independent character ark and a backstory and hence they look more realistic and believable but this also "distributes" the spotlight from the lead actors.

[@sanairshad8529]

I love this interpretation

[@karebear4957]

Nobody: Rick: *_My Notes_* he's so cute, love ya the most Rick

[@VikasRao516]

How the hell Rick is always right ? Even we Indians learn from him about Indian movies

[@davincecool]

Agree!

[@rahulgautam7476]

Righty said

[@gamesbhaand0078]

Korbin also has valid point. Given their maturity and clarity of thought, they are able to present a dialectical analysis of any movie which is a treat to us.

[@aminmitha1480]

Xactly brother.. I am a stage actor.. I watched lot of movies.. but after I started watching OSR I learnt what to observe and how to judge the creativity and brilliance in movie.. Rick is damn amazing I learnt alot from him.. he is brilliant..

[@boonslang6689]

Yes he is right in analysis but the acting is definitely dumb here. Those theatrics don't serve well for the tv.

[@biswajitbhowmik4687]

Now we want CHAKDE India and SWADES!

[@boonslang6689]

Chakde India is very average. Why you want it to be seen by foreigners? There are tons of better movies.

[@Raider4967]

@@boonslang6689 lol then you must be mad,chak de india is India's best sports film, majority of people have liked this movie and critics even,so better get some life you one from the minority

[@boonslang6689]

@@Raider4967 People have shitty taste here that's why mad bonanzas like Bharat ever today just keep hitting gold while truly great cinema like Black Friday, Ship of Theseus, The Blue Umbrella and Haider perish. I wasn't much shocked while sitting in empty audi of Haider because dumbwits like you were all busy in other Audi drooling mad over Bang Bang. You are way too much indulged in others opinions rather than making your own. I spoke what I thought, but you just keep bringing some critics and some box office shit over n over again. Get a life, dumbo. I am better with basking in my own madness than drooling over lists. Now let me enjoy season 3 of Attack on Titan. You are just spoiling it with your stupid comments turned notifications.

[@00darkknight007]

@@boonslang6689 chal de was a dangal of that time..!!

[@hindimovieadmirer6025]

SWADES?? Wohaa....Ha...ha. It's the most stupid movie made and that's too by the director of "Lagaan", obviously the brain of Aamir was behind that movie which wasn't in this and SRK also didn't had any. I'm not talking about the acting, but the whole story concept was stupid. I'm saying this as a person who knows the subject of 'water' and its nature. When one decides to make a movie on a subject of science / technology or sports, etc. then he must once sit with its expert to finalise a believable script. At least "Chak De India" does justice with it. But "Swades" fails so miserably that it still after so many years, makes me (and many of my friends) laugh. We still sometimes say, "Ye kaisa kaam kiya hai, tumne to is ka Swades hi banaa dala...ha...ha...ha...

[@sanairshad8529]

it's been almost 19 years of Devdas and I'll still cry like a baby whenever I watch it

[@Ramanand7136]

Same thing happened to me and I choose living the life of devdas

[@PS-sd3zv]

Bengali literature eternal and ageless......one of the best storytelling happened 70 years ago in Bengal and evolved a linked cinematic culture......very similar to Russian literature.....ChokerBali......many others

[@rudranisengupta1269]

The way Rick understood every scene and the deeper meaning behind all of them...shows he has become a true Indian...❤...btw i am a Bengali...😁

[@ricksegallactor]

Rudrani Sengupta 😊😘

[@tylorjane4719]

😂😂

[@kushalsehrawat6084]

@Rudresh Dessai 🤣🤣🤣yeh badhiya tha guru

[@priyak7384]

Ur typing in English, watch Hollywood and understand it , probably wear non Indian brands u must be a true western too . U might as well get happy to be called western but do know that everyone does not have the same mentality. Poor leeches.

[@shunaam]

You guys are actually very honest on reviews. Genuine understanding of the movie. Not just the good things but the bad ones too. That's a properly well thought review.

[@ricksegallactor]

The Meek Geek Thank you 🙏🏼😊

[@Spjen]

Rick and Korbin, I wish your review and analysis could continue for 3 hours. It could have been as good as watching a movie like Devdas. Your depth of thoughts and passion really so exciting to listen. Your love, interest and appreciations to indian culture is truly much appreciated. And yes India lives and celebrate the deepest expression of life on earth. It's absolutely bliss to watch this video. Cheers !!!

[@souhardhs2273]

*Devdas is indeed a masterpiece*

[@abirdhiman]

Now watch the modern Devdas by Anurag Kashyap (Director: Gangs of Wasseypur) to see a completely different take on this saga!

[@nirbhaysamrat2180]

Dev d

[@Savstein]

I was going to stumble down to the comment section to comment for the first time! Asking them to review DevD Their lack of awareness of Anurag kashyap is criminal!

[@user-wg8gh3be8f]

its boring thou

[@sunbong_rulez]

@@Savstein Agree. For them, Anurag Kashyap doesn't even exist.

[@prateekbhore2264]

@@user-wg8gh3be8f no way, it is more awesome than any of Devdas, It's practical and realistic with good songs by Amit trivedi

[@shrutighosh311]

That thumbnail just killed me man. Korbin giving serious competition to Aishwarya's Paro in terms of eye expressions. 😂😂😂 We all know your hidden talent Korbin miles since pastrami mastani song reaction.😂

[@priaCH1]

I understand from where Korbin's analysis is striking here. Even though me and my cousins used to love Shah Rukh Khan and Bollywood since he really made us dwell in it and enchant us with its nuances, we still would be like oh God, what drama, and wth is this song etc since we were raised in abroad. After moving to India I understood - Korbin, that actually the whole hyperbolic dramatization of the lady is a reflection of how people actually express in India, when a son comes home, the mother actually "jumps", in India emotions are not subtle, few have started applying the subtleties, may be because of the penetration of series from the western world Again, I totally can feel in my skin what you are saying since I still have the memory of me and my cousins being all "doo doo" while these scenes would cover our screens. We were raised in a culture which is not very hyperbolic, however I totally understand Sanjay Leela Bhansali's allowance of the exaggeration, if not his teachings being injected in their acting. I feel it is hard for us to understand movies from different cultures unless we don't understand the roots of the culture. One starts developing understanding once he/she crosses the periphery of a particular culture. It is really important to have a good amount of internalization of the culture before understanding in totality the expression of any movie. N.B : I have become so dramatic myself :p

[@LaVictoireRosee]

Idk... I'm Bengali, and my family is very repressed, except when it comes to anger. All other emotions are pretty tame. When my mom watched it with the first time, she was so annoyed with the melodrama, especially because Bengali cinema is a lot more subtle than Hindi cinema. The original Dilip Kumar version made me cry as a kid, but I didn't feel a thing for SRK's Devdas. I just had a headache. I find South Indians to be the most chill of Indians. India is a big place. So I guess my experience of India is very different from yours since it's about localities.

[@archiem654]

@@LaVictoireRosee i am from haryana and we are over dramatic like that. Loud, passionate and melodramatic. And even violent. I guess its punjabi influence on sanjay because hindi cinema is dominated by them.

[@poojakarle4421]

I love how Rick notices minute details of cultural aspects of indians. Eg: he said wen they culd sense each other's presence. 💕

[@Pinkx07]

Rick is Bang on with all his interpretations about Indians💯👏🏽 Yes we are celebratory people and yes we are a ‘bit extra’. And Korbin Miles we love you with the same melodramatic emotions of ours 😂

[@minibell]

Correct 👍he understand nicely🙏 👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@Mllesoumibagchi]

Half-hour of OSR is great... Do more of these like podcasts and just talk random things about movies your experience etc.. We would love to hear you guys talk even more...

[@burnt-quill]

Yayy.. i also wait for the notification to come

[@Mllesoumibagchi]

@@burnt-quill tui o OSR dekhish???

[@Mllesoumibagchi]

@@burnt-quill well I don't wait for it anymore... Just keep refreshing until the video pops up

[@DarkNorthEmperor]

And now.... Rockstar! P.s Rick had the "Piano" case....Korbin's got the "Devdas acting"

[@RAVIKUMAR-um5jt]

My data balance is draining but I'm still watching.........end of the viedo I lost 70%data but it's ok my boy's are doing great.......love from india.....❤❤❤❤❤🖤🖤🖤🖤🖤

[@anandsarda2091]

To quote OSR, Your acting would have been more believable, had this not been the start of the month. Your data packs renewed. But extra points for some good sarcastic humor!

[@sanyatanwir4050]

OMG! YOU GUYS WATCHED DEVDAS! THANK YOU!!!!!

[@asmitaheer2583]

You reacted to Devdas and youtube notified me.... Is this even real??😅😂

[@98919891989198914]

Chandramukhi played by Madhuri Dixit is considered one of the most iconic characters in Indian cinema. Indian audiences love her dearly. She is to Indians what Julia Roberts is for the American audiences.

[@ecoguy3081]

For more realistic take on the same story, watch DevD by Anurag Kashyap

[@prateekbhore2264]

Yeah bro, especially the climax , when Dev realises that life is precious and moves on with Chanda. Everyone deserves a second chance for themselves. Dev D is awesome

[@makr9233]

SRK hits Paro because she said how proud she was for how beautiful she was. SRK tells her that even beautiful moon is not perfect and has dark spots on it so she should not feel as proud and he gives her imperfection on her forehead.

[@anitak3985]

Hated that part. But that was in character for Devdas and why I believe he didn't deserve those two women. They were too good for him. A 2020 adaptation should have the women falling for each other😉😁

[@afsanaaktar4732]

He also give her that scar to remember him by which she cannot erase as he knows he cannot live without her and going to destroy his life.

[@anitak3985]

@@afsanaaktar4732 uff such a toxic guy.

[@nabszains]

@@anitak3985 UwU pls adopt me senpai

[@r2.b2]

Anita K: ditto. Would really love to watch that ending! Did you watch Ishqiya 2?

[@ladybug5250]

Watch DevD, modern take on Devdas

[@sujanikoya2826]

They didn't seem to take to Anurag Kashyap till now, so it would be interesting...

[@sanjana6572]

@@prateekbhore2264 shhh no spoilers :P

[@anshulgupta86]

@@sanjana6572 yeah please edit and remove the spoilers.

[@Dip94]

Yes

[@shilparyadav]

Yessss !

[@anushreevk2882]

I wish Rick was one of my friends for real.. I'd just love to sit and talk to you forever..would learn SO much.. I absolutely love how you express yourself.

[@ricksegallactor]

Anushree Vk Awwwww 🥰 Thank you 🙏🏼😘

[@arshdeepoberoi140]

Guys u have to watch and review kal ho na ho and veer zaara. It’s time for u to get into the world of king of romance, Srk

[@sanjanajain4548]

You've watched some of SRK's iconic work now (My Name is Khan, Dev Das), same with Ranveer and Deepika (Bajirao, Padmaavat), Shahid (Haider), Ayushmann (Andhadhun). You guys have got to go for Ranbir Kapoor and VIdya Balan's best next. Two fantastic actors, I would recommend Rockstar/Tamasha for Ranbir and Kahaani/The Dirty Picture for Vidya.

[@anniekhan4488]

Even tumhari sulu for vidya

[@syedaamir7147]

Man the acting in the dirty picture was fantabolous

[@alwaysreference07]

YES exactly!!

[@oishipriyaghosh7021]

So he hit her randomly and Rick is so right about the symbolism part! He did it coz colour of blood is red and colour of sindoor or vermillion is red too! So he hit her on the forehead and blood spilled just near the centre parting thus symbolising their love and longing. In many old movies u can see actors cutting their thumb a bit and putting their blood as sindoor on their lady love claiming to be married. Blood is sindoor for them. In Devdas that is what was shown in a symbolic way. That they belong together and to each other despite one getting married.

[@shreyagin8660]

That's abused, so your lover hiting you mean your lover love you.

[@LaVictoireRosee]

The movie glamourised Dev's abuse and petulance. In the novel, he's meant to be impulsive, and abuse. The original scene is that he hits her on the face with a branch or something and actually says "you are beautiful like the moon, but even the moon has scars, and now so do you". Dev was an alcoholic man-child, with anger management issues and the novel was a commentary on Bengal's class based society, and hypocrisy.

[@farzanamahbub2011]

This was amongst your top 3 reviews. I enjoyed every moment of it!

[@Madhumita103]

Best movie review till date...This movie is a masterpiece minus acting...I m totally satisfied with your review..Good job 👍

[@ricksegallactor]

Madhumita Sharma Thank you 🙏🏼😊

[@onewinter9411]

Minus acting? Is u blind?

[@Madhumita103]

@@onewinter9411 first of all "is u blind" is grammatically incorrect, you should ask "are u blind?". Answer is: no, I m not blind.. Rather, I think u r rude and duffer and also you don't know how to accept opinions different than yours..grow up 😄😄

[@abhishekhemnani9735]

@@Madhumita103 First of all "Is you blind" is meme culture (look it up) And second of all before having an opinion it's always best to do some research before hand ( so that you don't look like an illiterate duffer rude person) The "over acting" was a stylistic choice of the director and if you're not familiar all the actors are celebrated for their acting prowess and "over acting" is also a skill

[@Madhumita103]

@@abhishekhemnani9735 Since u have unnecessarily commented here I need to tell u that whether it was a meme or fucked up English, both ways it was offensive..You can't force your opinion and talk rubbish in the name of any meme. Now let's move to the movie review..movie was grand, music was awesome and sets were mind-blowing but I didn't like the acting part..I know overacting was done as per the whims of SLB, everybody knows but still I didn't like it..I have every right to like or not like anything right? U liked the movie many congratulations to u 👍and I m not gonna question that...then what is the problem in accepting my perspective? I may be uneducated (as u said) but I know that it is not much difficult to respect others school of thought even when it differs from yours..I hope u will understand..take care

[@MrinhalGaur]

If you spell Rick Segall in Scrabble, you win. Forever.

[@anandsarda2091]

Is there a way i can always just get to your comments in one click.. and not search for it.

[@MrinhalGaur]

@@anandsarda2091 😂😂😂😂😂😂👍

[@ricksegallactor]

Mrinhal Gaur 😂😂😂😂That’s fantastic!!!! #mrinhalthelegend

[@MrinhalGaur]

@@ricksegallactor no it's #RickTheLegend only 😉😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇

[@ananyam5335]

Are u a poet or a writer bro..???? I really wanna know😋😋😋😂😂😂😏😏😏😏🤓🤓🤓🤓

[@fallingintofilm]

Aishwarya Rai is literally a goddess in this film 😍. The visuals are incredible. Yes. The overacting is a little bothersome if you aren’t used to it. Korbin has a good point there.

[@abhishektanwar8070]

HIT - It was not a random hit. In Book Devdas is actually a person who also abuse Paro to show his love. In that scene he says Paro is beautiful as a moon but moon has scars on it and then he hit her and says the scar that now she has is by Devdas and it will be there till she lives. It is such a good symbolism .

[@shimahelmi3135]

Abhishek Tanwar hope Korbin read your comment

[@saniya6942]

So he was actually a toxic guy!

[@poojavyas3458]

Hum dil de chuke sanam , one of Sanjay’s great movies as well.

[@MaishaBeg]

Pooja Vyas I love Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam! ❤️

[@KrishanKumar-ec1ch]

And one of salman best works

[@user-os7be5zn7i]

Haven't watched this movie but I've watched Dola Re Dola so many times. One of the most beautiful Bollywood music videos ever.

[@masalahunty]

Hana Watch da damn movie 😩😬 Its goooooooooooooood

[@aashishri5169]

Comment which is the song u want OSR to react to... 1)Main Koi Aisa Geet Gaun (Yes Boss-SRK) 2)O O JANEJANA(young shirtless Salman) 3)Hawa Hawaii (1987-Sridevi) 4)Dream girl (1977) 5)Aaj phir jeene ki tamanna (Guide 1965) 6)Chura liya h tumne jo (1973) 7)Ude jab jab zulfein teri (Naya Daur 1957) 8)RAMTA JOGI from Taal(1999) 9)SATRANGI RE from Dil se(1998) 10)Koi Ladki Hai Jab Wo Hasti Hai (1997) 11)HEY K SERA SERA from Pukar (2000) 12)Chamma Chamma from the movie China Gate

[@vikramsrivastav9854]

Wow! Good to see your comment here!! I checked the other day the movie isn’t available in the stores like Tsutaya in Japan yet.

[@r2.b2]

To me that song will always be associated with Munnabhai MBBS

[@n3mo_17]

Okay, this is going to be interesting... Half an hour of them talking...

[@atproduction5759]

Exactly , because this movie is brilliant

[@dhruvsinghal4194]

Devdas, actually is a very old story. From the 1800s. Then it was first made as a black and white movie. It was a big hit. Sanjay adapted it. Then it was again adapted. It's an eternal story

[@pallavijoshi4549]

For a Sanjay Bhansali movie Ramleela next And then Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam

[@oishipriyaghosh7021]

Yes Jackie shroff is Tiger shroff’s father. And this movie is greatttttttt. Thanks guys. Love u both

[@oishipriyaghosh7021]

Omg my 1st like over here . Thank uuuu guys! Btw korbin had replied to me once on Instagrammmmmmmm and that too had made my day just like this like TOOODAYYYY 🥰

[@tusharrana5256]

Watch Anurag kashyap's version DEV D ! My Favorite from the adaptations.

[@prateekbhore2264]

Yeah bro, especially the climax , when Dev realises that life is precious and moves on with Chanda. Everyone deserves a second chance for themselves. Dev D is awesome

[@tusharrana5256]

@@prateekbhore2264 loved every thing.. Especially Acting , Music & Stylized Cinematography.

[@prateekbhore2264]

@@tusharrana5256 colours , visuals in the song pardesi...

[@neodro4831]

Very true!!!

[@thesilentnightingale2807]

I found Dev D extremely derogatory to the actual novel, especially, Devdas' character

[@nimeshbhandari8470]

I'd love to watch any movie with both of you guys😁 And I wish SLB sees your videos and reactions to his films❤️

[@anikethkattimani6543]

Remember "Swades" guys, don't avoid that movie just because you don't want to bore us by watching Shahrukh khan. We would be happy to review that for us. My name is khan -- Devdas --- Swades or chak de should be his next for sure!!!

[@oishipriyaghosh7021]

The book is a masterpiece! This movie has been made so many times in different languages! It’s an epic love story

[@ruchirpareek]

It is not a love story. It is about a destined darkness of masculinity.

[@rajnizamre7717]

SRK's movie review ❣❣❣ perfect start for week ....35min review 😳😳 I know it's going to be honest review

[@yogeshkukreja7958]

My soul requires both Devdas and Rockstar review for redemption. So, for how much time do I have to stay on this cruel world?

[@geekyambi8774]

Jim Carrey can do realistic performances. Ever seen 'Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless mind'?

[@anubhaf39]

I thought the same thing Jim Carrey come on!

[@samudrikasawant773]

I would like to see you react to Kajra re song starring Amitabh Bachhan, Aishwarya Rai and Abhishek Bachhan

[@RavyToor]

HOLY SHIT YES

[@srutik6654]

Yesssss

[@madhuacharya1438]

Yes kajrare song reaction pls

[@galimir]

Im chanting thisone to them since forever... ;)

[@sudeshnapodder5876]

I agree with korbin. I found Jackie Shroff and Kiran khers acting to be over dramatic and loud.

[@pragyakochar]

Sudeshna Podder me too. I don’t blame him. I’m an indian and had been watching indian movies since childhood, i still don’t enjoy melodrama. This is one reason i hate some of the indian daily soaps 😂

[@riswanarahim4347]

I don't think jackie shroff was over acted

[@Fidah]

@Jarita Gupta hahaha

[@sunnydeb6813]

@@riswanarahim4347 ya true,,,he was elligant not overacting

[@adamnotineden]

Hats off to you guys!! Such insight!!! I have read reviews of this film when it came out... no one has reviewed it so well covering every aspect of art and production as you have.

[@10anshul98710]

I LOVE your honest openions... can't wait for more reviews!

[@HarshSingh-qr5lm]

You didn't specifically talk about SRK's brilliant acting. The man deserved at least 5 minutes exclusively for his acting in this review.

[@abhishektanwar8070]

Aish was much better with her expressive eyes and the range of emotions from happiness, anger and sadness at the end.

[@HarshSingh-qr5lm]

@@abhishektanwar8070 Dude, what SRK does in this movie was so damn good for that time. Nobody had done anything like that before. What Aishwarya does not seem very remarkable at all to me.

[@HarshSingh-qr5lm]

@@yaikunta If you're talking about Rick and Korbin, they know a lot about cinema in general than any of us. I just feel that they should have said more about SRK in this. In the Gangs of Wasseypur review, they didn't speak about Manoj Bajpai's jaw-dropping performance either.

[@HarshSingh-qr5lm]

@@yaikunta I don't think so. These guys know what they are talking about. Both are actors themselves and Rick has really good theatrical knowledge. They are unique, and I love their videos

[@samiforlife1392]

@@abhishektanwar8070 whaaaattttttttttty???????? Are u kidding me????

[@zg1132]

I am so glad I follow you guys.... This is the best review of Devdas 🤗🤗🤗🤗

[@ricksegallactor]

Sushmita Goswami Thank you 🙏🏼😘

[@riasha_das]

The story of 'Devdas' is set with the background of Bengali culture. It is India's one of the most richly cultured places in terms of literature, art, theatre and music❤️

[@bambi274]

I get goosebumps every time u guys r mentioning anything of Devdas

[@pgl99]

Now Watch DEV D! The Dark, R-Rated Version of this Movie by Anurag Kashyap. And also do Pataakha by Vishal Bharadwaj.

[@sds5951]

The movie was released in the era where overdramatic soap opera where huge in India (like Kyun ki saas.., kahani ghar..., etc) that's why probably it had some elements of it

[@kesharaikathak]

amazing review as always but would have liked it if there was a segment especially allotted to discussing SRKs acting as well as Madhuri and Aish. Was actually waiting for more on this.

[@shivasai9888]

Love Rick's in depth understanding and explanation of the film and Korbin's increased interest for bollywood music! No doubt Sanjay sir is hell yeah so creative that he is even able to draw out the emotional attachment even from the foreigners with his cinematography😯

[@parthdua3440]

Love The Breakfast Club. That's what is in the background isn't it?

[@tweentycenturyrock]

Deva re deva I can't believe they watch it.

[@munnaabhai-kf4yn]

Masterpiece review by you well done,carry on the good work

[@Hardik.Modi1]

I binge watched your videos for 10 hours today and it was after watching this video I just had to make a comment. I absolutely loved your review. I could really understand the difference in opinion and I was so happy to see your honest opinion (Love ya Korbin). Korbin's reaction on ending of the movie was absolutely hilarious. I felt I was able to know you guys a bit better as well when Rick mentioned that he likes real paintings and Korbin mentioned that he likes abstract. Really tells you from where your opinion is coming from. Back to watching more videos.

[@ashwinraghunath4453]

Now everybody yell SWADES 😂

[@anandsarda2091]

He means Swaydes, Korbin!

[@satishrawani448]

34:09 minutes review and I watched it Whole probably the longest review I have seen. Thanks for the ♥️ love watching you guys debating on reviews.

[@jaygurung4640]

Korbin better be a really really good actor after complaining soooooo much about acting. Can someone please direct me to some of Korbin's work. I still love Korbin, just wanna see his mastery of Acting.

[@nemishasharma5737]

Why? I can't act at all and yet I can't stand bad acting either

[@PackOfWolves]

It would be interesting to see your reactions to other adaptations of the same story! Dev D came out 7 years after this version of Devdas, and it's set in the modern era and is much edgier (by Anurag Kashyap). There's also an old arthouse film (Devdas, dir: Bimal Roy, 1955) that was considered the "definitive version" of this story before the 2002 version you just watched. It's known for being restrained, realistic, and intimate. There's a huge list of adaptations on the Devdas wikipedia page (including a genderbent lesbian version which I had never heard of!) but those two are the most notable adaptations that you haven't seen. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devdas It's THE most adapted story to the big screen, with about 20 adaptations till date, since the book came out in 1917.

[@tejas2620]

Please watch “Dil Chahta Hai”.. that film really changed Indian cinema. That film introduced realism in acting in Indian cinema and that’s when melodrama from Indian films started to end.

[@mikiim5739]

Been requesting for months! Karan Johar in fact made Kal ho na ho because he wanted to prove he could make westernized movies like "dil chahta Hai". And then bollywood never looked by. Dil chahta Hai was truly a benchmark for bollywood in a lot of ways

[@mikiim5739]

*back not by

[@adi12637]

The out of the blue smacking thing is not actually sudden. She tries to convince Devdas that she has been insulted by his choices and that he cannot just barge in and proclaim his love because she is indebted to her mother as her mother was insulted so to drive away Devdas she delivers proud and haughty conversation due to which Devdas asks even the moon doesn’t have so much pride..in India a beautiful is often compared to moon..so Paro replies that the moon can’t be proud because she has marks on her and I am untainted. So Devdas hits her to create a mark on her forehead..like the moon now even she has a mark and therefore can’t be proud anymore because their love for Devdas is unique and down to earth, marked by Society and norms and not proud...it is also kind of symbolic because Devdas let’s her go and make her own decision but also gives her the mark so that she remembers that they belong to each other...the third meaning is he tries to console the injury with love by patting it and in the process spreads the blood in her hair parting from between..in our culture applying vermillion there is validation of marriage..so Devdas pats it feeling bad that he hit her but unknowingly spreads the red colour there which for Paro is vermilion on her forehead therefore before she gets married to someone else her and Devdas relationship gets validation with that little red colour and this they are bound for life...if you notice in the song following the incident she holds his hand silently asking her mom to let them be together but her mom doesn’t say anything which depicts that she is strict on her promise to Devdas mom and she hasn’t forgotten her insult yet.

[@syncme6356]

Pride is okay in men, not in women. So hypocritical. There's no excuse for abuse

[@tushartyagi1200]

Watch. Kaagaz ke phool by guru dutt It also has sad ending korbin you would love it

[@r2.b2]

Tushar Tyagi: gah! Too depressing! I think sahib biwi aur ghulam may be a better movie? Or perhaps Pyaasa? Love Baaz, though amongst Guru Dutt's films

[@2001aniket]

I really appreciate how much you guys pay attention to detail in the review. I appreciate that Korbin doesn't shy away from calling out the bad portions of a film. And the fact that you both have such different points of views and debate so well in the review. Also, If you want to get to know India's hinterland better, watch Vishal Bhardwaj's Omkara. It's an adaptation of Shakespeare's Othello. It is a modern masterpiece

[@Itubersays]

Agree with Korbin about bigness vs believability but Jim Carrey can do serious roles - The Eternal Sunshine of a Spotless Mind, The Majestic. I wonder if you guys do exclusively international/bollywood movies.. I would love to hear your thoughts on David Lynch. David Lynch movies are usually love it or hate it affairs. Some think they are overindulgent ego trips, or pretentious, overly symbolic mishmashes that need the cinematic equivalent of a Rosetta stone to decipher. Mulholand Dr is one of my favorite movies...

[@jnyanendrarajbongshi603]

Yes korbin DARKNESS IS FUN

[@smrutibodhi3284]

God that's not bad acting. That's just how that movie was supposed to be.

[@kapzutube]

if you want to see new age devdas, watch DevD directed by great Anurag Kashyap. Another masterpiece

[@pandeysunil2803]

Both of you are right as you see it from 2 different prospective.....I agree India cinema carries song dance and drama from culture but also wish that starting 30 mins of the movie would have been made differently....I get and connect with it but Korbin’s comments are spot on...and Rick your in depth grasp on feelings Indians and India is commendable 😊

[@sanyatanwir4050]

Not Ray it's pronounced Rye

[@davincecool]

You two are becoming good movie reviewers. Just putting it out there. I loved the difference in opinion. This happened in India as well. I was on Rick's side. But I do understand Corbin's side as well. One thing I learnt from you guys is how to differentiate between movies when showing them to foreign audiences in terms of exposure. You're right, this movie should not be shown to people who do not know Indian culture much as they will just find it overwhelming. It is the fancy dish which someone needs time to understand before they eat it.

[@rashmisrivastava5763]

Korbin and Rick have so different perspective 😂

[@PackOfWolves]

YESSS I'm so glad you watched this! All the discussion re: overdramatic stage acting and subtle realistic acting and how Indian cinema has evolved at a different pace -- 1000% TRUE!! I'd love to sit with you and have a proper discussion about this because as an Indian brought up in Australia, my parents watched Bollywood films during my childhood in the 90s, and the acting at that time was much much more like stage acting (it was the heyday of romantic musicals and Shah Rukh Khan). In my child brain, I equated Bollywood with melodrama and cringe, and was borderline embarrased that I was even Indian (I lived in a /very/ white area). As I became older, my understanding of acting became more nuanced than just good acting vs bad acting, and I understood that different audiences have different expectations re: how "cartoony" they expect the acting to be. At the same time, Bollywood cinema saw a DRAMATIC shift towards the more subtle and naturalistic kind of acting that was also gaining traction in Hollywood. I say "Bollywood films" because arthouse films (in any language) have always been more in the "sublte realistic low-key" style, and if you look at South Indian cinema, today it is still waaaay more camp and over the top than anything you have ever seen. But it's not necessarily "bad", because hey - look at the numbers! Clearly it is connecting with its audience. By the way - my parents (and I'm sure many older Indians) don't enjoy the current "subtler" trend of acting going on. It's the same reason why they never got into Western cinema - they find the acting wooden, a lot of the subtlety goes over their heads, and as a result they can't even follow the story's character arc. They can't consume it comfortably, because it doesn't line up with their expectations, so even if they are engaged, it's a frustrating experience. I guess Korbin is experiencing this right now! Anyway I have a lot to say on this. If anyone wants to have a discussion about it, PM me!!

[@sourabhmohre7209]

Preparing for UPSC Mains?

[@riswanarahim4347]

I really think you were not watched any malayalam movie... Malayalam movie are also south indian... But those are not like that what your said

[@13jhelum]

@@riswanarahim4347 I grew up malayalam cinema which has a lot of Subtle performances

[@riswanarahim4347]

@@13jhelum I just said Malayalam movies are More realistic not like Bollywood.

[@13jhelum]

@@riswanarahim4347 yeah that's what I meant malayalam movies are more realistic and the performances are mostly subtle there compared to bollywood

[@Al-bp6pj]

Dev Das being an older film really did have some over the top acting at points. Please watch ROCKSTAR next.

[@sunbong_rulez]

Now watch Anurag Kashyap's version of this. It's called "DevD" and since you now know the story, you'll now have the Hamlet-Haider experience. It's dark, modern setting, amazing acting and has Kalki as Chandramukhi (Madhuri Dixit's character).

[@khatirasharifee5899]

Rick I loved your reference to streetcar! it was a great way to explain what you meant

[@jaiprakash-zz1bz]

That was not bad acting His choice I love melodramatic

[@sanjanajain4548]

My god, you guys did it! Thank you for reviewing this a lot. Please watch ROCKSTAR next, been waiting for it since 3 months now.

[@kayasthadhruv]

I was a subscriber, today, I ring the bell icon. You echo my mind on songs.

[@nishthatripathi4615]

I kind of knew that this is gonna happen and was sure that Rick is going to love it.... I loved your review😊 and can understand korbin's issue but that was intentional in the film...

[@zg1132]

Highly recommended, Sanjay Leela Bhansali's interview with Bollywood Hungama after Padmavaat released. His words, his thoughts, will give you new perceptions to life as a whole. Please watch.

[@balgisalkaff8373]

Pls don't. That interviewer guy?Faridoon? Suck.

[@Pinkx07]

Omg. This is my earliest comment ever. I love you guys💯❤️ #NotificationSquad

[@utkarshsharma8826]

Agreed with Rick Agreed with Korbin Let's just end it with this. 😂😂

[@akashsinghal5656]

Firstly, you guys are amazing! I was very happy to see this contrast. My take on 'Devdas' is that it is undoubtedly one of the best Indian movies, a masterpiece, truly put. Three best actors of Bollywood, 2 most beautiful women & one of the best actress in the world and Madhuri Dixit is the SRK among female actresses. But, to be fair to Korbin, this is the contrast to all the movies you guys saw before. Now, most of the previous movies are young and 21st-century vibe, with action, fast music, and Indian yet western-fit storyline. Devdas represents the period of the era of Bollywood when a simple slow story that evolves with time. It was made extraordinary by acting, simple moments & great dialogues. So, having seen all the exciting, modern Indian movies if you delve in the 90s and some early 21st century movies of such genre, it's difficult to get it in one go. Thus, I do understand the Korbin side. But, Rick, spot on man! You really got the gist and deducted things in a great way. This is just my side and I am a 'Stupid'. I love your content guys, keep it coming. Lots of love!

[@rajsalmaniac8189]

What Foreigner Thinks of Bollywood *BOLLYWOOD = SRK*

[@LiyaBB]

Raj Yes we do! SRK is ❤️

[@rajsalmaniac8189]

Well in other countries maybe but in India not really... I'm sorry to say but SRK movies do poorly in India

[@pinkytinky4070]

I love the honesty and believability in your movie reviews. Good job!!!

[@rachit1042]

Bollywood is so different from Hollywood. In older Bollywood films, supporting cast always used to be bad. These days the supporting actors are sometimes better than the main cast.