P3 | Hijab: My Body, My Choice | Mahsa Amini: Islam, Media,Politics & the Hijab | S.Ammar Nakshawani

----
Click Here to Subscribe & keep updated with our latest videos on our Channel:
/ sayedammarnakshawaniof...
Follow Sayed Ammar on our social media pages:
Facebook - / sanakshawani
Instagram - / sayedammarofficial
-----

[@syedalam8524]

Dr. Nakshwani-you are great. Excellent speech as usual-May Allah Ahlul Bayt kay sadqay mein keep you & your family safe, grant you long, happy, healthy & prosperous life-Aameen

[@spiritualrituals9603]

The problem is neither the veil nor the religion. The problem is that the religion is being used as a CONTEXT in the wrong hands for their own benefits. I believe the hijab has not really been the issue of the Iranians, but the way it is enforced on normal women's but have shut their eyes to their own daughters who are all abroad US or Canada etc.... the double standards is the problem.

[@wafaajamshid14]

May Allah bless and protect Dr Sayed Ammar Nakshwani and his family from anything bad 🙌🏻🙏

[@Billionaires_Muslimmotivation]

God bless you more and more in this life and the afterlife. Ameen

[@sakeenaraza2625]

It’s hard to predict the reality on the ground in Iran and to determine what percentage of women there are pro or anti 'forced hijab’. The western media is obviously biased in its representation of the whole issue. What is clear though, is that there is resistance to it and it is to the point of hatred for the hijab in some factions of Iranian society. It boils down to the fact that forcing anyone to do anything will elicit contempt which like you said, Dr. Nakshawani, will manifest in a way that is outright vulgar, and hurtful/disrespectful to many. You can only foster regard or respect for religion or a religious way of life by inspiring people and not by forcing them. Ultimately, there has to be freedom of choice in adopting a certain way of life. If someone is not religious, to begin with then hijab will likely not appeal to them and forcing them to do it will not sit well with them. This is true for anything in life. Hijab is not discussed very extensively by our scholars or rather it is not discussed in a manner that is convincing. The Quran does not condemn women who don’t wear a hijab/khimaar the way it condemns other ‘sinful’ acts. Certain acts will lead to hellfire or other detestable outcomes in the Quran but not wearing the hijab is not stated to be one of them. It seems to fall in those grey areas where if you do them you’re a 'better' Muslim perhaps? I am not a scholar but would really appreciate more education on this. You are correct in saying that there are many Muslim women who grow up in households where hijab is not done (I can speak for urban Pakistan) but religion is revered and observed in every other way. Covering the head is not considered an absolute necessity or an obligation. It is left as a matter of choice. I would appreciate if you clarify whether not wearing a hijab, is a sin? If yes, then what is the penalty for not wearing the head covering in the hereafter? Are there sayings of the imams that talk about the fate of women who don’t wear a head covering?

[@shaheedaessack6142]

Great question.

[@Billionaires_Muslimmotivation]

I love it. Lets get more inspired about Islam im general. Iam really looking forward to listening more about Dr. Ali Shariati /Ayatollah Motahari /Ayatollah Khomeini❤❤❤

[@mohammedhassanakbari6722]

Why not about Sheikh Yasser-al-Habib & Hassan Allahyaari?

[@AbuJawadH]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/roXHpGiPptt9hqc&ab_channel=IslamicPulse3

[@mohammedhassanakbari6722]

Kant Believe that you take that Sleazy Clown Muzzafar as a Credible Authority!!!.... Speaks Volumes of your Degeneracy!!!...

[@mohammedhassanakbari6722]

@@pathofhussain9811 Be careful with your tongue & this behavior of yours here is actually the degenerate level. So who has made you like this? Obviously your blind devotion to the Iranian Regime.

[@mohammedhassanakbari6722]

Besides Ammar Nakshawani is just a Politically Correct Stunt Man or Joker. Was Never Credible to Start with in the 1st place. Same goes for the Jokers Affiliated with the Iranian Regime.

[@alimoeed2577]

My brother messaging you feels like communicating with you as I know for sure you will read all the comments. Your knowledge and passion is beyond words. May Allah look after you and make people understand your views. Ya Ali Madad

[@a.d.a.8400]

We need these nuances in the shia parts in the world. We’re stuck in this “That person has most Knowledge and therefore I should follow him in every single act I do. I can’t Think myself”.

[@corpsefoot758]

What’s strange is that Khamenei never even “had the most knowledge” of his own peers at the time They hastily shoved him into the top seat without him being an ayatullah or mujtahid. Such an embarrassing stunt

[@sulemanhaider1305]

The concept of Marja is a key component in Shi'a theology. You can't just override what you think is correct or not just on a whim, people who are qualified in the field have to do this job. Assuming you are a Shi'a, how would you define jurisprudence? Can I, a lay person, make major decisions in the field and follow that? An expert's opinion is greater and deserves to be followed and respected. It's also a universal constant to look towards an individual who is an authority on the subject instead of making stuff up on your own. Sayyid Ammar also follows this code. He is a Muqalid (student/follower) of Sayyid Sistani and mostly gives verdicts that are believed by him.

[@sulemanhaider1305]

@@corpsefoot758 Khomeini and Khamenei were/are, indeed, Ayatollahs and Marajī. Khamenei is a Marja, and the "requirements" you see online (by ignorant westerners) is nothing but a farce. He has the requirements filled, he is a religious scholar, a Marja-e-Taqlid and he has much legitimacy in that regard. Several Marajī have views that are shared by Khamenei, with those that don't, are often very liberal or hardliners. Khamenei is also very moderate, because Marajī like Sayyid Sistani has issued a fatwa saying all board-games are Haram because they can be used for gambling.

[@corpsefoot758]

@@sulemanhaider1305 There is nothing “moderate” about allowing your supporters to chant “Death to opponents of Wilayat e Faqih” next to Shi’a shrines. Nice try, though

[@corpsefoot758]

@@sulemanhaider1305 If these so-called experts oppose the Imams’ own behavior in many aspects of their lives, then what exactly are they “experts” of in the first place

[@mahmooda561]

Thanks a million Syed Ammar. May Almighty Allah bless you with safety and protection today and Always. Aameen. Indeed all of us need to be more thoughtful. Very very well anaysed and thoroughly discussed the topic. Jazaka Allah khair Brother.

[@Godfinity]

Iran is a country with many enemies.Therefore, when an issue arises whether planned by its enemies or not its enemies hands go full force into action. Lets not forget that when we see hijab burning, vandalism or mosque attacks that Iran has a good amount of Jewish, Christian, Baha’is and etc who would be more than willing to indulge into such activities. Lets not forget the paid under cover informers who are solely there to take advantage and or further such incidents into their favor.

[@mohammedhassanakbari6722]

It is always some paid Agent - like the Government there can do no Wrong?

[@marionmourtada6580]

A government under such outside inhumane pressures is not going to behave the same way not under such pressures

[@mimimiraj7351]

Salaam. Keep on preaching the Truth...make us hunger for knowledge. May Allah, swt, grant you deep deep understanding.

[@mohammedhassanakbari6722]

@@marionmourtada6580 When was the Government Rightly Guided to Xtart With in the 1st Place?

[@claudiotavares9580]

I iranian jew or christian would hardly risk his life or the life of his whole family because of "muslims political issues".

[@taslimkhataw340]

AsSalaam Alaikum Sayed 🤲 JAZAKALLAH Duas for you , your family and team. May ALLAH (SWT) shower HIS blessings, and mercy by leaps and bounds and grant you health, and prosperity. 🤲

[@loldwaboutit]

God bless you sayed ammar .

[@razabadass]

Thanks sayed bro :)

[@arfabutler4391]

A very well rounded and thorough analysis 👏 great job 👍💕👏

[@azmetrafik3548]

Vy intelligently analysed this issue. Stay elevated.

[@Bluecaponly1]

Hui Dr sayed ammar I love your lectures

[@mahera15]

Mashallah subhanallah beautiful words wow I only you stay save in sayyadah s sayyah

[@hassantalat8238]

An excellent speech.

[@moaleali]

Some statistics in Iran say that about eighty percent of Iranian women wear hijab and want it. Those you see on the street who don't wear hijab will be naked if there is no hijab law. Hijab is not only a personal law but a social law, it can be implemented in the society. The state of religiosity and hijab of women in Iran is not what the media say. The problem of the western media with Iran is not the hijab, but the Shia Islamic government.

[@sakeenaraza2625]

Women in Pakistan don’t roam around naked nor do they roam around naked in other Muslim countries where hijab is not mandatory

[@moaleali]

@@sakeenaraza2625 To better understand what I said, you can refer to the photos of Tehran before the Islamic Revolution!

[@syedalam8524]

Well said-I agree with you 100%

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

@@sakeenaraza2625 Women in Pakistan don't have the best hijab neither hardly something to boast about.

[@sakeenaraza2625]

@@Shia.Ahlulbayt I’m not boasting about hijab in Pakistan but thank God we have freedom of choice there!

[@berthabaig4520]

The only One Who has the right to say..do it ...or ... don't do it is ALLAH, HE IS THE ONE, no men has a right to tell anybody what to do

[@samanbayat6912]

Assalam wa aleykum dr. Ammar. Thank you so much for your videos in this caotic period. Interestingly, I see a similarity between the discussion/actions about the hijab in Iran and the interference of the West with what happened in the Jamal war. Some western countries are trying their best to attack Iran while thery are holding "clothes of Uthman" and hiding behind the crowds. They do this while standing behind someone who willingly or unwillingly, for the betterment of society or boredom wants to show disagreement. Much love dr. Ammar.

[@alexxcostello]

Thank you for the lecture. It makes sense to me.

[@slsa915]

Assalaam Aalaikum Dr. Nakshwani. Thank you for the lecture. When are you debating Adnan Rashid? It is long overdue.

[@Immu_VLO]

God bless you ❤

[@berthabaig4520]

I sow a 1900 pics of inglesh working woman in a factory full cover, head and arms and long dresses, and looks it was a low. How come now everybody is against the hijab?

[@dbeatty]

I've been thinking about this issue a lot lately. A few things that have come up for me - I think it is a disservice to hijab and women to look at it as a symbol of anything. It adds a lot of baggage to the issue that sometimes results in harm for women and confusion of the real principles behind the matter of hijab. I think we would be better off if we were to discourage people of taking hijab as a symbol of Islam, as a symbol of backwardness, as a symbol of oppression, as a symbol of whatever. Something else that comes up for me is that while scholars often say the Qur'an is clear that hijab is required, the matter doesn't seem so clear to me. Modesty, yes. Specifically head-veiling, no. Because while a verse does tell women to cover their bosoms with what was a head veil, that verse does not say the head-veil itself is therefore obligatory, too. The point of the verse can be understood as about covering the bosom, and it is not a foregone conclusion from that verse that covering the hair is also absolutely required - especially when we delve further into the fiqh and see that some women were not required to wear hijab in all contexts - slavery, women beyond hope of marriage due to age, etc. What are the modern analogs of those contexts, if any? The large principles of modesty and covering and lowering gaze are all sound and good. The details of how that presents obviously have some contextual variations, as have been mentioned in this talk. I think it is fine to encourage women to cover, but sometimes people take this so far as to the point of true hardship for some women in some contexts. People seem to get far too dogmatic about hijab due to that baggage of symbology and politics, and I think this is a grave disservice to women who would try to wear it.

[@shha1417]

Free my people

[@irwetwater]

Well Sayed Ammar, the lady who burns her vail doesn't look at it as the symbol of a faith but rather looks at it as the symbol of oppression she had faced all her life. BTW; Mz Katayoun Riyahi the lady who you mentioned her outstanding acting as lady Zulaykha was arrested earlier this week for speaking out against mandatory hijab 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@zeldatanit4346]

You always give speeches with substances sayed But I would like for someone to just say what needs to be said in a straight forward manner Women being forced to cover themselves isn’t going to stop sexual corruption or deviance …. I mean… as far as I know .., the Iranian police hasn’t come up the same technology as we have seen in the movie minority report and thank khoda they dont… if so .. they’d be able to predict when a man will decide to rape another female or when a man will decide to lust upon a non mahram female and before you know it, you would have a lot more in prison than expected 😅…. That’s obviously impossible to predict or to prevent. So…. How exactly is hijab a remedy for all the chaos that could happen in a society ? Theft, domestic abuse, corruption , extortion , child abuse ? Rape (that still occurs even among veiled women) , violence in general Like … it’s just utterly ridiculous to have a government put so much weight upon a piece of fabric over a female’s head ! And forgive me please for using cliche phrases that feminists regurgitate, that’s honestly not my intention. But in light of what is happening hijab is no longer seen as a symbol of prudence and piety like how it was majestically worn by the ladies of ahlulbayt. And my mind STILL can not comprehend all those (men and women but mostly men who say they are followers of ahlulbayt a.s. ) who absolutely have no problem watching their own brothers and sisters get tortured and beaten and arrested or even killed in not only the name of Wilayat e Faqih but in the name of our imams and maasumeen such as sayeda Zainab (as) and sayeda Fatima (as) I , as I convert have contemplated leaving Shia islam so many times because of witnessing so much hatred in this topic. But I refuse to give in and I refuse to accept their distorted view of this religion when I know what the Quran and ahadith say in regards to ikrah (coercion). In return I know the kinds of comments I will get back. I’ve been called melodramatic , dramatic , accused of “romanticizing “ Islam while ironically they are romanticizing Hudud and Sharia Law and consequently romanticizing violence in the name of “a moral Islamic society” All I can say to that is… good luck having people joining or respecting this religion with that kind of mentality.

[@rezasadventures1352]

Wilayat faqih is not from Islam, just like sunni sect that has A lot of none Islamic things mixed in as Islamic, there are some mojtaheds in shia Islam that have their own agenda and have huge followers also who mix in Islam what is not Islamic like wilayat AL faqih which is very similar to kufr, what we need to do is to increase our knowledge and choose the right path. Start listening to allahyari lectures so you could have a New perspective on Shia Islam and you could compare it's reasons to the reasons of wilayat al faqih then decide

[@rezasadventures1352]

Or if you just study the ahadith you could see that it's not allowed for shia to start revolution and stuff, we are ordered to wait for the 12th Imam(as) revolution and move with him(as)only,

[@haydaralali8133]

I've noticed a white-washing of what a hijab is. A hijab is covering everything but the face and hands, with no showing of the form or any sort of beautification, light makeup included. A bit of wrist shows and it's not a hijab anymore it's just clothes. A bit of hair and it's just clothes. There is no "hijab slowly coming off" and " half hijab" or whatever. It is so strange how unready people are for punishments for not obeying the law of the creator here in the dunia... a state of being a fetus that argues to those outside that sunlight isn't real... I mean there are more severe punishments after we die... wouldnt we rather avoid those? We are in the Fatimiya nights aswell. Fatima Al Zahraa عليها السلام stayed under the door that broke her rib and killed her unborn son... she couldn't bear staying under the weight of that door. She did it though, to show everyone that there is never any excuse to let go of something mandatory; in this case, hijab. Her legacy, Zainab عليها السلام; felt disgraced when people on the way to Damascus were able to see her height, and temporarily her face. Was what she went through trivial? Is every woman who chooses not to be hijabed, able to live with herself knowing that she is trivializing the pain and discomfort Sayeda Zainab عليها السلام felt when she was at a state a lot of the modern world would call, "too modest". The halal of Mohammad is halal until the day of judgement. The haram of Mohammad is haram until the day of judgement. اللهم صل على محمد و آل محمد و عجل فرجهم و أهلك عدوهم Also imagine having zina with a Bahai Kafir

[@ehteshamali8319]

Protests funded by Saudi, Israel and and USA. Iran is more Moderate than Sunni Countries. Western countries Supported redical Sunni Countries for their interest. As.. Pakistan, Saudi, UAE etc.

[@sulemanhaider1305]

Are you from Iran?

[@ali_irani]

33:25 What about a Muslim woman concludes to become a lesbian? Does she has right to be respected as a Muslim ?

[@MrMineHeads.]

A Muslim can sin. You only stop being a Muslim when you disbelief in the Aqeeda.

[@trutherasitis2109]

Who will know she is a lesbian ? If you keep it private no one will know only your creator! If you are blamed there has to be four witnesses witnessing the act ! How likely is that ?

[@ali_irani]

@@trutherasitis2109 I'm talking about the proud ones who may want to be Muslim and lesbian in the same time!

[@claudiotavares9580]

@@ali_irani No one would do this in his right mind if the threat of being fined in hundreds of US dollars existed. Trust me, education through treating the pocket is WAY more effective that police brutality.

[@sepidehshahmohammad5624]

Dude, speaking as a woman who has lived the last 30 years in Iran, Tehran, we have been sexually assaulted and in some cases raped from the day we stepped out of the house while wearing a complete hijab! What are you talking about only fans and what not!!! Please get your facts from a collection of sources to get closer to the truth!!! Don't repeat whatever you hear!

[@sulemanhaider1305]

Neither did you hear what he said nor are you willing to do so. And the statement itself is ironic, "We have been sexually assaulted and in some cases raped from the day we stepped out of the house while wearing a complete hijab.." what a joke lol He is someone who is learned in this field, he's giving a clear statement on what the official meaning inside all of this really is. It appears you people can't handle the term 'nuance'.

[@zeldatanit4346]

@@sulemanhaider1305 I don’t understand where is the joke ? lol you sound like someone in his early 20s who has lived in the west all your life and has no effing idea what it’s like to be Muslim female ? Veiled pious god fearing women in Morocco Algeria Tunisia Libya Egypt Lebanon Syria Pakistan Afghanistan and Iran and so on … have indeed gotten rape and sexually harassed or assaulted despite yes… wearing “proper hijab” A society forcing or encouraging hijab at any political level is not going to stop rape lol You do realize your kind of Islamic idealistic philosophy is the kind of ideology that inspires books like 1984 and the Handmaids Tale ? 😅 Wake up brother .., just a little bit.

[@zeldatanit4346]

@@sulemanhaider1305 that being said above no I’m not a feminist and no I do not promote leftist hedonistic western values upon Islamic societies…. But what frustrates me is Muslim men like you , especially all the Shia men I have known on social media who take the liberty to comment on such topics while reacting so insensitively to the plight of Iranian women or Muslim women in general who have been oppressed in the name of the religion that you follow as well.

[@marionmourtada6580]

Interesting how an Iranian women who has lived in Iran for 30 years speaks so western slang like ..

[@sulemanhaider1305]

@@zeldatanit4346 making claims about me, my life and who I am and what my experience is childish and immature. I, for a fact, am Iranian, I have relatives in Iran and know first hand account of what happens in Iran. And I'm in my late 20s, so don't get excited. It's a joke because it is. Iran has been publicly bashed by international governments for how strictly it deals with rape and harassment. It's also funny that you changed the wording of everything you said in an instance. First saying how you and your family got raped because of the proper hijab and now you are saying you got raped inspite of it. Pick a lane. Finally, this isn't communism. The simple fact that wearing a proper hijab is not sexual isn't an idealistic worldview, it's just fact. There are those who find that attractive, and they are non-negotiable, they exist everywhere; but, the fact that modest dressing strictly limits such actions, isn't sexually attractive and the likes is a fact. There is also the whole thing that women have to be with a male partner when moving outside should also be brought up. I also find it hilarious how you mention rape and the likes and don't mention how rapists, when found, are always sentenced to death! Don't forget that.

[@fahadalam8322]

Ya zuljana madad..ya abooo loooloo maddaddddd

[@avrilfatima160]

Don't try to prove your part...you know very well God didn't instruct any thing like this....if he did then he would not have Adam and Eve naked in the garden of Eden....and it is one's own will to wear what they want not force anyone....

[@sulemanhaider1305]

1) that's not really true, we have several evidences in the Qur'ān and Hadith that wearing a hijab is an obligation, whether someone likes it or not. 2) I doubt that Islam follows the same view as the Christians, in that Adam and Eve were naked in Eden. The Qur'ān even alludes to it. 3) Even if they were, they were literally married so they could do that. 4) By your logic, I can go out in the streets of Berlin, strip naked and should be fine? If that's your ideal, then there's plenty wrong with it.

[@sepidehshahmohammad5624]

You are not eligible to give such strong comment on something you have not experienced. A forced hijab is not modesty. You cannot force a religious symbol on a person for years and still expect them to respect it. They are burning their own forced hijab not the hijab of poeple who have chosen to wear it!!!!!

[@Shia.Ahlulbayt]

Are you muslim? Yes you can according to lslamic beliefs you can comment on something you have experienced. Even rational logic allows it. Hijab is modesty according to the Quran

[@zeldatanit4346]

If you actually knew his lectures starting with part 1 of this particular topic … with all due respect … you would know he is not a proponent of forced hijab But I do understand your frustration and there’s nothing we can do about those religious fanatics online who refuse to understand the pain Iranian women endure on a daily basis other than ignore their comments

[@JeremyDavidsonTheMuslimRevert]

I agree that something forced doesn't force modesty, but being an advocate against something doesn't make it any more correct simply because it was forced in the first place. A thing may be forced on people in any country that is good for you , yet it will always create opposition despite how good it is for the society.