'Pakistan's New Nuclear Doctrine Must Be Seen In Nuanced Terms'

[@ashy3640]

India must revise its N doctrine that NFU applies only for who obeys NFU and also for non nuclear power. But for a nuclear power country who not obeyed NFU, India's NFU also not applied on them. India must have right to use nuclear first against such power.

[@drshibank]

Intellectually and startegically very good talk, thanks Strat Global.

[@ShivamSahuIndia]

Thanks 🙏🏼

[@sanathvemireddy3081]

Rouge State Pakistan must be dealt with same.

[@SuperGreatPakistan]

Get a life gow mutter

[@sahibzadasafi1701]

Haaaan to karrrrr naaaaa ! Kaaan pakkk gy hain sun sun k

[@drshibank]

The Pakistani are again back to the game of showing the nuclear weapon as a deterrent to force India to be defensive in the relationship so that our response is highly subdued and defensive rather than balanced and strategically superior. The shaky Strategic command in Pakistan is also a keyway to keep India and Indian strategic camps on the edge. The US and other powers are also taking stock of the scenario and fragile controls of the nuclear arsenal. The fact is Pakistanis are masters at keeping India and Indian strategist always tied down and afraid of the power game from Pakistan.

[@gangadeshmatakimaut4739]

Pakistani command/control and nuclear safety is well ahead of India's by an benchmark.Regards

[@drshibank]

@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739 yes, so long as the US and IAEC are watching and monitoring it, but the problem is even they are jittery and don't trust Pakistani politicians and their deep state. I don't know why you have to compare with India when you have no clue or idea about the kind of CC&C is prevalent in India. Thanks & regards.

[@hdjfjd8]

@@gangadeshmatakimaut4739 lol a country which cant manage rag tag TTP terrorists which they themselves fostered and attacking them left and right should shut up when talking about nuke safety

[@suryavaliveti8355]

Does anyone know who made the phone call that bailed Pakistan out this time?

[@Lets_Be_Real_UK]

My guess is, the US. Who else could have such control over the IMF ?!

[@IndiaTides]

You understand that if they lost control of their country then nuclear tech is in danger. India wants Pakistan unstable enough that they cannot be threat but not unstable enough to become threat to us. Americans did right thing. Who do you think was stopping loan to them till last moment??

[@imperator791]

​@@IndiaTides If the USSR can collapse with so many nukes than certainly our aim should be of dissolution of 🇵🇰 without any nuclear exchange.

[@temp1851]

​@@imperator791you think you can compare the Russian with these cockroaches.

[@MohammedShafiq-id5ov]

​@@imperator791pakistan isn't the USSR, also the Soviet collapse was inevitable as it wasn't viable to control those states that big likewise Bangladesh formation was inevitable as it wasn't viable for pak to sustain that wing with no land border or sea connection and india imbetween, this game the army and ISI played was by design gen Faiz Hameed devised this plan to ensure army stays powerful as imran khan threatened that notion. Pak can fight a hot war with empty pockets and if needed saudis would find then wahabbi ideology still dominant

[@lakshmineuroscience]

Just get rid of usd, imf will disappear and no one can bail out pak.

[@dukhi_aatma372]

Pakistan is no longer in a position to dictate/change the rules of the game. Going ahead, it can only get dragged by India, and try play catch up game. Their current rhetoric are just signs of desperation. There is no way they can fight an active hot war with empty wallets. But let's not forget, elections are around this year in Pakistan (at least appears to be), and given that the current government is the most unpopular government in Pak till date, they'll definitely try and play the India card by flaring up the borders, and attempting some attacks to evoke emotions in Pakistani people. It's the same old trick but got to be watchful.

[@redbaron9029]

This is yer another BJP delusion. 😅

[@c.selvarajhunc.rajhun7021]

​@@redbaron9029😂😂😂😂dis anyone mention BJP this proves how secularism has made them in a transformation towards islamic terror sympathizers

[@salmanmunir765]

War would never be a solution , no matter how strong or weak one country or the other. Neither country is in a position to threaten the other and should be prudent enough not to provide an arena for bigger players. End of the day we shall have to think about devastation war will bring to both neighbours.

[@santhugowda7179]

Pakistan is a small country.

[@mowiththeflow4446]

Why can't India scrap the "no first use" policy to send a befitting message to Pak and China? That will put an end to the nuclear blackmail.

[@shreepanicker]

India's unnecessary restraint is being seen as diffidence by the Pakistanis, who lose no opportunity to wave the nuclear threat before us. In effect nullifying our nuclear capabilities and almost making it a boomerang. While it should be the other way around. From now on we should declare that any mobilisation by Pakistan will make us go nuclear ready, and even so-called 'non state actor' actions like terror attacks will merit a nuclear response. Let them also sweat it out for a while.

[@surendrabarsode8959]

1. India is no threat to Pakistan under normal circumstances. Even the issue of POK and GB will be settled by India through talks. This is our position, whether Pakistan understands this or not. 2. India of course has much superiority in conventional arms against Pakistan and Pakistan ought to rely on nuclear weapons in case its survival is at stake. This is understandable. But redefining the nuclear doctrine in terms of 'full spectrum- vertical and horizontal' deterrence and that too perhaps at the first opportunity, is a matter of worry for India. 3. India should be ready for this and take appropriate steps if the situation so arises. But we must warn Pakistan that India has full right of reprisal in case of any misadventure from Pakistan be it in terms of terror attacks, incursions, subversions, etc. 4. Beyond this plain speaking, it is for the experts like Brigadier to talk on the issue.

[@amittiwary7432]

There is no sticking to no first use..Rajnath Singh..it's not a rule set in stone..

[@adityamookerjee.]

Are the Pakistani authorities intimating that their armed forces are around to mainly deploy and use nuclear weapons? What do the civilian people of Pakistan say? Do they agree with the Pakistani establishment? Does the Pakistani military have the support of the people for the new nuclear doctrine? They have nuclear weapons now. Do they want to use them?

[@prachetmakwana6011]

uh, why would Pak army even take civilians into consideration?? they run Pakistan!!!

[@vivekpmc1992]

Pakistani ppl since inception wish to concur Hindustan and that’s their final desire. Their creation of Pakistan is not final, they follow Islamic first tactic of moving from macca to Madina Organise there and concur Macca from there. That time too they used to continuously attack from Madina until final battle. That’s why they took Islamic territories on both sides of India ( east & west Pakistan), so that they can attack from both sides . Remember since 1975 ( after Mujeeb & his ppl were eliminated, Pakistan actually ruled Bangladesh till recently and all political parties except Seikh Hasina to some extent are against India), western nations are also hands in gloves in their plans as they wish to control India as well.

[@priyacharichakravarti6868]

And so China's rabid bull terrier howls again but beware its fetid breath!😮

[@navneet8269]

Pakistan ke nuclear threat bahut hi jabardast aur sansani khej conversation. Very critical questions by gangadharan ji and brigada Sahab answered with full cry dhanyvad😊

[@vicky7100]

@21:21 It’s Aamrika which made the phone call to IMF for bailout to fhakistan

[@incastinc]

How can India play the Peace card? 1. Train Afghans in India which is doing now. 2. Allow Pakistani "professors" to visit India and experience it. 3. Don't raise POK. It is a pain in the neck. 4. Allow Pakistan to buy medicines only for cash. They got money now. 5. Let the US diffuse the tensions. They are giving money. Quid pro quo.

[@rakadus]

Is Pakistan anticipating an Indian nuclear test immediately after May 2024 elections? Remember that the thermonuclear test of 1998 did not produce the desired yield.

[@IndiaTides]

That would be the stupidest move from our side. Our relation with America built on our civil nuclear deal and being responsible nuclear power.

[@rakadus]

@@IndiaTides What's irresponsible in protecting ourselves from China's nuclear build up? In 24 months time, the number of nuclear ballistic missile silo has gone up 4 times in China.

[@Edward4Plantagenet]

@@IndiaTides , शस्त्र उठाने से मत डरो, सिर्फ यह ध्यान रखो की कब नही चलाना है। USA created this mess, they could have stopped Pakistan, but they didn't. We have nuclear terrorists & Communist dictatorship against us. We have to protect ourselves by whatever means necessary. Thermonuclear is must against China.

[@sitarampradhan8488]

India hav not only nuclear bomb India have atom and hydrogen bomb. 2 are more powerful than nuclear weapon.

[@MohammedShafiq-id5ov]

Pakistan's nuclear test in 1998 was far more sophisticated than india's moreover india test did not affect the desired yield also pak has secretly been working on atom and hydrogen bomb since decades with the tacit help of chinese and you will soon be surprised that pak already has this capability why do you think the country is always in dire straits economically. Also why do you think pak has control of afghanistan and uses its proxy taliban to sustain it other than rare stones what else does Afghanistan have a myriad of plutonium which pak uses for its tactical nukes

[@futureiitianjee]

​@@MohammedShafiq-id5ovwe too have 200kt and above monsters ohk Keep that in your filthy mind

[@redbaron9029]

Why you are so much obessed with Pakistan? The army there did your bidding of work there and desteoyed the country beyond repair. What more does india wants?

[@pagan-540]

Perhaps Indians want pakarmy to vacate Gilgit Baltistan and their province of kashmir

[@SuperGreatPakistan]

​@@pagan-540but why

[@RahulMishra-ld2bo]

​@@SuperGreatPakistanBecause it's an integral part of India.

[@SuperGreatPakistan]

@@RahulMishra-ld2bo chal jhoutay

[@RahulMishra-ld2bo]

@@SuperGreatPakistan Truth hurts.

[@razahussainshah8173]

India can dream, any stupid idea.

[@RahulMishra-ld2bo]

Truth hurts. Get some burnol and apply it otherwise burnol price will increase in your country.

[@santhugowda7179]

Already pakistani are importing Indian burnol from UAE. 😆😆😆😆😆

[@muhammadusmanwarraich2684]

You are trying to make “phuddu” to your educated people, with respect you told sme truths but more “Phuddus”

[@RahulMishra-ld2bo]

Truth hurts.

[@santhugowda7179]

Tactical nuclear weapons pakistan. Massive retaliation india katam Tata bye bye good bye gaya pakistan.😉😉😉🥴🥴

[@chanakyagan]

Please post documentaries as in airfield in tezpur

[@razahussainshah8173]

Absolute none professional.

[@santhugowda7179]

Kid wai is kid not professional. Pakistani well know who is the prime minister of india.😉😉😉😉

[@himanshusingh0876]

Your expert guy seems to high on something. You must check him believe me even Pakistani establishment will not take his opinion anyway. Nation which is on door of bankruptcy is giving serious nuclear threat to his neighbours without knowing it's repercussions 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@rakadus]

Those who are sinking would like to pull their enemies down along with them.

[@rajveerkanojiya2985]

​@@rakadus😊

[@MuhammadShahid-m9q]

Just wait for two more years and you will see glaring advances in PAF capacity and capability. India would trail behind

[@SunilKasheer]

What exceptional conversation, really enlightening

[@sobant4795]

Indians living in their own reality😂😂