Palestinians: If Israel apologized for 1948, would you accept them?

[@sprachenwelt]

What I find difficult is, that many Israelis make the claim that they have the right to return to land, they occupied some thousands of years ago from the Kananites, and then question the right of the Palestinians to return who actually have been living there for by far longer than Judaea even exited. A quite strange attitude I must admit.

[@dogbert52]

Keep finding it difficult. I find it difficult that other humans use my highways...... but i cope.

[@adam_1144]

@shani isreal I understand that the subject is very emotional and relevant but maybe calm down a little. Your comments make the rest of us look unreasonable.

[@adam_1144]

@lolo rodriguez No state was even established either. Israeli territory simply was renamed Palestine by the Greeks and then occupied for years. Even if Palestinians were connected to the land, they never created their own governing body or independent state, meaning that Israel acquiring the land while defending was legal according to the rules of a war.

[@starhopper408]

What I find difficult is understanding how any sane person could, for as much as one moment, suggest that any country should allow milz of people who have openly vowed to destroy them into their nation. Quite a strange attitude, I must admit.

[@Channel-ml4qv]

What are you smoking lol, Canaanites are not 1 people, it’s an umbrella term for multiple ethnic groups that lived in the region called Canaan, which included Jews (back then we were called Israelim, or Israelites in English). Arabs are we’re not Canaanites.

[@IDKhowtopickaname]

To apologize means more than saying you're sorry, it means to hold yourself accountable for your actions and make an effort to repair.

[@mariamahmed-ei8js]

I feel it is like US saying sorry after they INVADED iraq

[@monkeyb1820]

@@mariamahmed-ei8js The US made Iraq more devoutly Islamic than it was previously. Muslims should thank the US for doing so.

[@90DeadTimer]

@@monkeyb1820 yeah and we should also thank them for the millions slayed civilians mostly women and children you’re right. Thank you for taking my child and my women.

[@monkeyb1820]

@@90DeadTimer The US freed Iraq from secularism. This is what Muslims want. Ironically though, many Muslims in the US want this, but lack the guts to leave and go live in these other countries. Note that the US hasn't done this for evangelical Christians or Jews, only for Muslims.

[@90DeadTimer]

@@monkeyb1820 the funny thing is USA goes to other countries to stop secularism there, but can’t stop their own secularistic system.

[@kensei_vision]

i can see the pain and sadness deep in their eyes

[@kensei_vision]

Palestine is like my second home in my heart, i love Palestine and palestinians as well

[@moneybenny6522]

Is not pain and sadness..... its hatret and anger although their religion is against it..... its like their regression back to Arab Jahiliah

[@strix-kv3bn]

@@moneybenny6522 What's it like having no empathy?

[@usuitakumi4031]

@@moneybenny6522 you are a monster

[@khalildz1552]

@@moneybenny6522 if the prophet is alive he would fought u untill end

[@barrotem5627]

I came straight to the comments section.

[@Linda43]

You had company

[@trs8696]

fair enough, the video is exactly what you'd expect it to be

[@Whatever4867]

becareful of the brainwashers in the section

[@starhopper408]

@@Whatever4867 Of which you would be an example.

[@mustafajuventino9964]

No, you came gay to the comment section

[@r.blackmore5921]

Palestinians want State not near Israel, but instead of Israel. So there is no need to ask them.

[@krillin876]

Where are these interviews?

[@Linda43]

Correct

[@liron-hazan]

@Vitaliy Markov Their grandparents started a war on jews in a land who wasn't theirs, It was a property of the British empire, The hostiles expelled out of it. They have no rights to the land.

[@marksimons8861]

This is why the international community has given up on the Palestinians.

[@marksimons8861]

@Vitaliy Markov And herein lies the problems. Either you want a Palestinian ethnostate (in WB, Gaza with East Jerusalem as its capital) or you don't.

[@nomad9338]

Would you accept someone stealing your house if they apologised?

[@AverageReplyer]

We accept Palestinians

[@nomad9338]

@@AverageReplyer you only accept them if they allow you to steal their land. If they speak against it, you call them "terrorists" and "anti Semitic"

[@chiakinanami5037]

Don’t worry we don’t need you to accept us we’re totally fine without it❤️

[@pupik1563]

But they never owned the house

[@nomad9338]

​@@chiakinanami5037 I know, but international law doesn't accept what you're doing either, and one day it's coming for you.

[@jettawayadventures1081]

This question doesn't make any sense. If Palestinians feel that they were pushed out what was 'British Mandated Palestine' in 1948 and were not allowed to return, there is no chance they will accept a jewish homeland in what they consider to be their country. Do you think that the average Palestinian would care that 161 countries voted for Jewish independence as a sovereign state of israel?

[@ef2718]

All the people interviewed in this channel are still living on the land that used to be under the British mandate.

[@jettawayadventures1081]

@@ef2718 but not Israel proper.. hence my point. Beit Rima is at least 20 minutes outside of the state of Israel it's affectively heading towards the Jordan rift.

[@obitouchiha8053]

Palestine will not accept jew untill last day in this life if they not leave them country its simple

[@jettawayadventures1081]

@@obitouchiha8053 peaceful lot

[@gershonsavitsky6620]

@@jettawayadventures1081 The absurd is that they feel comfortable to sit in BetRima and to discuss if they will accept Tel Aviv as Jewish city or not. They are not loosing anything to say NO. Once they will be under real danger to loose their comfortable live, they will ask to have their own small country in Bet Rima (areas wherever they are living now). So, as better Israel doing their life as hostil they will be.

[@oolooo]

"We want Israel to apologize for a defensive war where we attacked them with multiple armies with the intent of exterminating them just for existing" Considering the amount of ancestral land Israel was willing to give for peace , maybe it is time Palestine left the area .

[@oolooo]

@Yoav Daniel By this point , Palestine does not want to have a state .They made their bed .

[@Whatever4867]

@Yoav Daniel it was all unfair

[@starhopper408]

@@Whatever4867 Life is unfair.

[@oolooo]

@E Ms Yes , the Pallywood Lies .The idea that Palestine is not only a nation but a victim somehow .

[@Whatever4867]

@@starhopper408 yes, life is unfair under israeli occupation

[@trs8696]

i love this channel but i think its becoming pretty clear that the palestinian answer to any permutation of "would you accept a deal/peace/apologies/negotiations" etc is always a resounding NO

[@solvingpolitics3172]

Thank you!

[@AmericanDreamer]

and for a good reason

[@Nashmi-JO]

of course no when we kill the zionists and kick them to the sea we will ask for forgivness and they will say no for sure use your mind before commenting again

[@Dor7r]

@@Nashmi-JO as Golda Meir said "Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us.” You will keep with the hate and we will keep making peace with other countries.

[@interestingyoutubechannel1]

@@Nashmi-JO 21% of all Israeli people are Arab. How many in "liberal" Ramallah are Jews??? Those Arabs that were kicked out were among militias that were trying to kill us! It was war, you lost. We tried making peace for MINIMUM 6 times to give you a palestine State, and you refuse everything. You will never know peace or progress.

[@apiFerrari]

I really dont understand why should jews apologize for what in 1948??? They were attacked by "palestininans" and their arab neighbours... Israel only defended himself

[@InitialPC]

@Roy Wales Christianity is not anti-semitic..

[@lori8161]

@@InitialPC This is how Jews treat their "fellow" Christians (Not all Jews btw just a few)

[@dogbert52]

@gamboni100 i think israel should apologzie for not finishing the job.

[@azizamrs8547]

The last old man is a wise man.

[@kensei_vision]

his charm and strong personality made that man stutter

[@whitemailprivilege2830]

Palestinians: “We will accept Israelis...if they leave our lands” “We want peace... not with Israel” 🤔 🤷‍♂️🤨

[@solvingpolitics3172]

@tarek jbara Like the world needs another useless Islamic country.

[@digitalhunter834]

@@solvingpolitics3172 another fool

[@patriotsforisrael3610]

@@solvingpolitics3172 Exactly. Palestine is not a state it is an authority. And is also a dictatorial authority. And pays money to terrorists who murder Israeli citizens.

[@presidenterectwhiteycoloni8459]

Would you accept Isralies if they left the planet? Palestinians - "From the solar system to the galaxy Palestine shall be free" gotchya okaaay, in the looney house you go little Nazi

[@avirose194]

Your 1964 Palestinian flag stolen from Jordan minus one Star. The Palestinian flag was created on 28th March 1964, reinforcing the fact that the Arabs were invented by ARAFAT the Egyptian in 1964, yet the 1937 PALESTINIAN FLAG SHOWS A STAR OF DAVID WITH A BLUE AND WHITE BACKGROUND.

[@Stampler15]

Why should they apologize, for a war they didnt start?

[@ahmadabu-rumman2904]

No actually they did start it.

[@Stampler15]

@@ahmadabu-rumman2904 Israel issued their independence, just after British signed the mandate for Palestine.And a miltiary army of the Arab States entered british palestine.

[@dogbert52]

@@ahmadabu-rumman2904 no actually they didnt. Google it.

[@ef2718]

For refuting to drop dead.

[@saeedvazirian]

@@Stampler15 You can't issue independence over someone else's land, lmfao. The British Mandate for Palestine had more legitimacy dumbass.

[@user-si7ig6ul7l]

These people clearly don't want peace

[@5amsaramadanlearnarabic347]

If someone stole your house and threw you and your family in the basement and killed your brothers, and their justification for all of these cimes that this house was for my ancient grandfather 3000 years ago. Would you make peace with that criminal?? Ofcourse not and I admire the true people with dignity and pride in the video because they never surrender ✌

[@mohammedkenz1717]

yeah but they tell that if they apologize and give the rights that are not given by israel government then its okay. and u will not understand the pain of them that losing their home

[@lori8161]

@@5amsaramadanlearnarabic347 Did you like Rabin?

[@KaramKettanie]

@gamboni100 do you think otherwise?

[@5amsaramadanlearnarabic347]

@@mohammedkenz1717 Only an apology is nothing, Millions of Palestinians still live in misery every day inside and outside, humiliating checkpoints , new settlements and the list go on , this plus the people Israel killed and keeps killing. So it is AN OCCUPATION what the occupier should do if they're sorry it's not just words my friend. If it happens and it really becomes a binational country with equality and the right of return is applied then yeah this might heel 100 years of war. But the Zionists will never do that , they will never give back land they steal without war even if it's against the international law, they never did and they'll never do.

[@farahcruz2006]

The old man at the end made me cry 😢. We hope we will come back one day Amo 🙏🏼

[@ttbr7687]

It is sad that there is still so much hurt on both sides that even the concept of a two state solution (regardless of if it is 48 or 67 borders) seems unimaginable. With that mindset from both sides the conflict will only continue to cause more suffering.

[@shachargabbay1496]

totally true. Im an Israeli and I was simply born into this conflict. I don't wanna hurt anyone. But the fact that both sides are reluctant to listen to each other is making me sad.

[@chadchadson3894]

Im from Europe and have no ties to either israel or palestines, but from watching many hours of these videos it seems that the palestinian mindset/education/indoctrination (whatever you want to call it) is to blame for a lot of the current problems. Thet are simply living on cloud cuckoo land if they think 11 million+ israelis, most of them born there, have no citizenship to any other country and israel is all they've ever known for possibly 3 generations or more are just going to leave everything behind and go. At least the likes of the greeks, germans, native americans etc acknowledge their 'catastrophies' which happened generations ago are permanent and adjust to a new reality for them and their children moving forward At least a lot of the israelis being interviewed are fairly rational and want a workable solution based on the current reality. (Although granted theres a few crazies who want egyptian, Jordanian, syrian and lebanese land as well).

[@starhopper408]

Naqkba "We tried to k you. We were not successful. We are the vic tims"

[@yacovezra2924]

Hi dear

[@presidenterectwhiteycoloni8459]

They have the Nazi victim mentality

[@Whatever4867]

i explained that to u

[@Whatever4867]

yom hazmaut: they treid to kill us, the only one who we blamed is the one who didn't

[@Whatever4867]

@Yoav Daniel the authority called palestine?, sorry there is no authority called by the land it is governing

[@TheKopikota]

If someone apologizes for their mistake at first places, I will forgive. Forgiveness is a noble thing on the part of Islam.

[@abdurrahmankhan1145]

If they apologize and undo things what they have done and what they are doing.

[@khalildz1552]

Yea but thy ll hve to leave palestine first our prophet wont forgive children killers

[@pedrokantor3997]

Apologies are empty, make amends.

[@kyakaroonmein7665]

Kaunsi babligand University se padhayi kiye ho.

[@Benfreidkin22]

Try asking them if they'll share a state with Jews with equal rights to all, I bet they will all say yes.

[@shahd4721]

Actually Jews used to live with palestinians peacefully before the whole 1948 thing. Go read about it. They were safer under palestine. Even before that when Germany was killing them many Jews were under palestines protection with no issues😀

[@obitouchiha8053]

@@shahd4721 because palestine help them from hitler not because they have them own land there thats it

[@shahd4721]

@@obitouchiha8053 uh no lmao. There are Arab Jews u know. I personally know a few - 💀 the Jews living in Palestine at the time were palestinian Jews. And some from outside actually came in and well

[@תאירזלצמן]

@@shahd4721 actually no🤣 there were many terror attacts, google it. that why the britis give up and let the UN solve it...

[@helacopter1924]

Ummmm no. Majority will say no because of the horrible scars we have.

[@gershonsavitsky6620]

Can you imagine in 1946 Germans in the occupied Germany will be asked: "if Russia, GB and United States will apologize, will you accept them? Will you accept Poland in 1939 borders?" Those bizarre people claiming that they are occupied but behaving like occupiers - having conditions, claims etc.

[@brickleberryfan2984]

shut up

[@benkennedy3376]

Apologize for what?

[@starhopper408]

For refusing to drop de@d at their request. Duh!

[@zabenaleid2547]

@@starhopper408 What a dumb statement. I feel like this comments are the highlight of your day. We oppose displacement and ethnic cleansing, fools like you are what spread actual hatred. Arabs were a majority at the time. The UN which was a remix of the failed league of nations had no right to give Jewish European immigrants 55 percent majority of land when your ancestors were no more than 20-25 percent of the population.

[@starhopper408]

@@zabenaleid2547 You were dis placed because of your hostility to J self determination and refusal to share, which was a choice. The UN didn't give Israel anything, the members (ie the world community) recognized the Jewish history of that land and supported the creation of a J nation (they did not have the power to "create" anything themselves). It was Israels from thousands of years before that and formally as a reborn modern nation in '48 because of J sacrificed and fought for it, not in '47 as some sort of UN gift. And the pop % is irrelevant. The stated purpose of that nation was to be a homeland for the J nation of people, which means ALL the J nation of people, not just those that were there then. It should have been all made Israel from the start, for that and many other reasons, but the Britz gave 80% of it to Arbz. THAT is the A part of the mandate area. The rest is Israel and should have been from the start, but since it wasn't, the Arbz making another b ad choice of attacking is what made it so. If anyone gave Israel land (albeit unintentionally), it was the Arbz with their foolish choices.

[@dogbert52]

For not finishing the job

[@moshak1455]

Big translation error it's actually embarrassing. In Arabic they are literally asking not about accepting the Israelis. They are asking will they accept their apology if Israel apologizes. Obviously the answer is no. Not without adding to the what comes with the apology.

[@israarayya2358]

Actually no in many instances the translator is saying will you accept Israel and Israelis if they apologize for the Naqba and they stay in the land. Her translation is correct. I'm not sure maybe I misunderstood what you're trying to say?

[@israarayya2358]

The interviewer wants to know if they would accept Israelis should they apologise about the Naqba.

[@solvingpolitics3172]

Anyone who thinks there is such thing as a one state or two state solution has never listened to what Palestinians and their leadership actually say.

[@Linda43]

The world is deaf and blind and mute.

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 No that's you

[@solvingpolitics3172]

@@Linda43 Yes correct. However I think it has more to do with worthless bodies like the United Nations & E.U. who try to justify their pathetic existence at Israel’s expense!

[@Linda43]

@@solvingpolitics3172 Agreed

[@solvingpolitics3172]

@@lori8161 Explain or did this video go in one ear and out the other for you?

[@edalabdali]

Palestinian land is for semitic people. But what people do not know is that Semitic does not mean Jewish. Semitic people is people who lived in that area before Moses or Judaism. Those people became Muslims, Christian, and Jews after. Hence, Palestine land is for all and not just the Jews

[@JeyseeTO]

“The Arab governments told us: Get out so that we can get in. So we got out, but they did not get in.” A 'refugee' quoted in Al Difaa (Jordan) September 6, 1954.

[@solvingpolitics3172]

Sounds about right for Arab governments. 2.4 million fatalities in last few decades. Arab vs. Arab!

[@bhatfirdous1081]

Typical Zionist propaganda

[@Daughter-of-Palestine]

@@solvingpolitics3172 I wonder what caused those instabilities in arab countries.

[@VIP1G]

man there's a video for the first israeli president saying when he came to Palestine that : we the jews came her to Palestine with peace and we don't want to take their land 😁

[@TheRanaro]

We have nothing to apologise for.

[@abbask56]

Please search more, you may find some tiny things under the bed

[@TheRanaro]

@@abbask56 try Jordan. It's the real Palestine.

[@abbask56]

@@TheRanaro you have found Jordan under the bed? What a biiiig bed!

[@abbask56]

@Yoav Daniel Yes, there are other accomplice involved

[@TheRanaro]

@@basirj8578 Go home to Jordan. I have no connection to Khazaria and, like Palestine, there is no such a place.

[@deleted72636]

Apologizing for returning to their homeland?

[@Linda43]

Crazy, right

[@lanajalal6128]

Biggest lie ever

[@bosniencommie1202]

@Roy Wales dne part is laying most jows are alhenzis whus gean pole mostley coms from europ more spacifictley spein,germany,poland,rusia

[@bosniencommie1202]

Ot wasent there homland in 2000 years and fup religus cleims

[@zabenaleid2547]

@Roy Wales You have DNA evidence that you're Hebrew israelites? Lol. Your DNA evidence shows that majority of Jewish people have some common ancestor. The DNA shows Ashkenazi Jewish Europeans are SLAVIC.

[@ArnoldTeras]

I think there are lots of kind and gentle people among both Arabs and Jews...I don't understand why they view the other side as "monsters" or something. :(

[@liavle12]

Why would we appologize? They started the war even to think that is insane. And i like the hypocracy in this comment section.... when a palestinian says he wants israel to be gone and destroyed you don't even talk against him and on the israel side comment section you say where is the humanity.. you cant be a friend to a guy wants to destroy your county. ISRAEL IS NOT GOING TO DISAPPEAR you need to accept this fact.

[@lenae2049]

Can you imagine how a palestine or the palestine collective feels, if you compare the maps from 1946 for example to 1967 and now? How would you feel?

[@avirose194]

ARABS IN ISRAEL. Palestinians are comprised of several ethnicities made up as follows: Arabs who are the majority: Kurdish, Syriac/Assyrian, Armenian and Afro-Arab. Modern Palestinians are descended from many different Arab peoples from the Levant and Arab/Muslim states who fled and migrated as refugees to the geographical region named Palaestina Syria in 135AD by a ROMAN, Hadrian. The closest Arabs aka 1964 Palestinians ever came to Jerusalem, Judea and Samaria was through the ILLEGAL JORDANIAN occupation in 1948 to 1967. Palestinian claim to an ancient civilization has been refuted by simple and credible facts; starting from their so-claimed Palestinian ethnic foods, national dress and lack of any archeology which is the blueprint proving ancient civilizations - simply because there is NO ANCIENT PALESTINIAN PROOF OF ANCIENT ROOTS. Palestinians state that their ethnic foods are: Kubbeh, Mujaddara, Tahini , Baba ghanoush and a list of other ethnic Palestinian foods; but…. KUBBEH originates from Jordan, Cyprus, Lebanon, Armenia and other ARAB nationalities. MUJADDARA: originated in Iraq. TAHINI- originates from Persia BABA GHANOUSH: place of origin is LEBANON. PITA - is a flatbread eaten in the Middle East and dates back to Natufian (now Jordan) times. Summary: As can be clearly checked, ethnic culinary foods of 1964 Palestinians have been claimed as their cultural foods, but as one can clearly see, were borrowed from ARABS. LANGUAGE: Palestinians speak ARABIC (with an accent) NATIONAL DRESS: Palestinian men wear/wore a “thobe” which originated in Syria, Iraq, Jordan and the Arabian Peninsula. No one has a problem with Arabs calling themselves Palestinians, but there is a problem when Arabs aka 1964 Palestinians “adopt” cuisine, dress, prayer books, shrines and sacred places and claim them as part of their own ancient traditions, even though recorded history documents prove otherwise…… 2,000 years old and showing ancient HEBREW script only one of thousands of ancient artifacts proving JEWISH HISTORY AND ORIGINS IN THIS LAND.

[@DF-pr9iy]

Did you call us Syriacs Arabs? We are not Arabs!

[@MichouThe]

All I just read were facts!💅🏾

[@Supergutter]

There is nothing to apologize, because God has brought them back. Ezekiel 36,24.‘For I will take you out of the nations; I will gather you from all the countries and bring you back into your own land"

[@lanajalal6128]

Why the fuck we should care about what god says

[@Supergutter]

@@lanajalal6128 He is the boss :-) he does not lie....There is only one God, the God of Israel !

[@Channel-ml4qv]

@shani isreal relaxxxxx. They got a point, some fake magical god didn’t bring us back to our homeland, it was us who did that on our own.

[@Channel-ml4qv]

@Yoav Daniel I disagree. We did this on our own because we finally had enough strength to return back to our homeland. You think god was helping us every time we were displaced or slaughtered? He must have been taking a nice long break from work

[@lanajalal6128]

@Yoav דניאל I’m not denying your rights to live as long as you don’t deny my right to live in the land, I know many Israelis believe that us Palestinians are too indigenous and vice versa I believe that they’re indigenous

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

Mind Begs the Question: If a person - Worships only his Creator If another person - Worships only his Creator Both Worshipping - different,same?

[@yigalgurevitch2936]

both delusional

[@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings]

@@yigalgurevitch2936 Mind Begs the Question: Unless you created yourself Surely,you have a Creator No?

[@yigalgurevitch2936]

@@HumanBeingsRThinkingBeings the other possibility, there is no creator at all.

[@nasimagdam2723]

i don't understand your question. there is only one God. you can call Him a different name but He is still the same God. even if he grants you the free will to create your own world, He is still the same God.

[@yourboykaster]

most Arabs didn't understand the question obviously.

[@Герман-ш7щ]

apologized?) what a joke. arabs need to apologize

[@lori8161]

@المهم لاحد يكلمني No I don't want to and btw I'm not a Jew (I'm a Muslim)

[@lori8161]

@tarek jbara I hate Stalin he ki!!ed many Chechens

[@lori8161]

@المهم لاحد يكلمني أنا عربي ٤٨

[@Герман-ш7щ]

@tarek jbara my toiled paper is your face

[@lori8161]

@@Герман-ш7щ Got a question for ya:Do you hate Chechens?

[@Lea_5584]

If it wasn't for the Balfour deceleration, nothing of all this would have happened

[@qwli5460]

If it wasn't for the crusaders Spanish inquisition pogroms blood libels and holocaust nothing of all this would have happen

[@Lea_5584]

@@qwli5460 and is it also because of the holocaust that Israel decided to send its army to Lebanon until may 2000?

[@qwli5460]

@@Lea_5584 I was talking about 1948

[@Lea_5584]

@@qwli5460 So what happened in 1948 justifies everything that happened later, including the attacks on the Lebanese people during the 90s?

[@qwli5460]

@@Lea_5584 I didn't say that

[@salRL-eb3zc]

Israel should not apologize, she was attacked. take responsibility for their actions, meanwhile, terrorists who have murdered innocent Israelis over the years have gained respect and esteem.

[@matthewmann8969]

It goes back way longer then that the animosity between MANY NOT ALL Jews And Arabs began since the times of Prophet Muhammad deny it if you want but I am not fooled

[@texanboiii562]

What about the ones who were Arab Jews? 😂

[@starhopper408]

@@texanboiii562 Mizrahim are Jews who lived in Arab societies, not Arab Jews.

[@user-si7ig6ul7l]

@@texanboiii562 not as if they had much choice, convert or die/convert or be extorted biggest mafia in history Islam is

[@alio6051]

@@starhopper408 but they were still part of the society and our prophet(saw) of course accepted them, he accepted everyone

[@alio6051]

@@user-si7ig6ul7l we have no animosity towards the jews. Its just that what has happened in palestine has really hurt the hearts of the muslims and non muslims all around the world and we are deeply affected by the bloodshed thats happened to the people there.

[@Isnapthesky]

I3rael doesn't even care about giving rights to Palestine, let alone apologizing for massacring the Palestinian. Neither does US apologized to the Native Americans for the genocide US committed against them, even to this day. That's enough to acknowledge why both these country support each other.

[@InitialPC]

A) Palestine lost Israel because of a war IT started, not the Israelites. B) The US HAS apologized, a shit ton of times, and there are many legal reparations for natives and those of native descent and has been for almost a century now.

[@Isnapthesky]

@@InitialPC US didn't apologized neither officially nor unofficially. If you have links about the apology then share it

[@InitialPC]

@@Isnapthesky So when the US gave money that after inflation is now worth a TRILLION dollars to just ONE indigenous nation, thats not reparations? When the US decided that native territories are allowed to enforce their own laws outside of federal jurisdiction, thats not reparations? America literally repealed the statehood of Oklahoma FOR natives! and you want to tell me they never did anything for natives?

[@dogbert52]

@@Isnapthesky belgium dosnt give rights to mexico and nigeria dosnt give rights to south africa...... this is how the world works buddy

[@Isnapthesky]

@@InitialPC The least thing the world needs is the involvement of America and their so called freedom. Look at the places where murica touched, it was destroyed and caused diaspora. Look at the Vietnam, Middle-East, South America where they either managed to overthrow democratic government through coup or invaded it. How much you're deluded to think money can make people to forget about the atrocities they faced just because they had different look?

[@kastrama]

I can't get this. They spiking about their lands, Palestine,but their never been Palestinian state...

[@conanf129]

Just because they were not formally a state doesnt mean their lands were up for grabs or didnt own any property. The Kurds, for instance, were never a state. They should by the logic forfeit their independence aspirations

[@edwinlucianofrias1643]

Stateless people still have rights.

[@conanf129]

@Cease AndDesist Egyptians and Yemenis were ottoman subjects. They're still called Egyptians and Yemenis. Same thing here

[@nicbahtin4774]

imagine apologizing for winning a defensive war

[@yurichtube1162]

Palestenians should perhaps suffer another defeat

[@starhopper408]

@@yurichtube1162 They will, but they never learn anything, so unlikely to help with their delusions.

[@nicbahtin4774]

@@yurichtube1162 They can't even work proporly much less fight effectively, "arab work" am i right ? The main problem is the globolists that fund them without it they are nothing.

[@yurichtube1162]

@@starhopper408 that sounds problematic. Perhaps it is best to abolish the PA leadership and make it governed by Israel. The status quo will continue, and they can live where they do now but with the right leaders peace can be achieved.

[@yurichtube1162]

@@nicbahtin4774 they are resisting for the wrong reasons. They need to become enlightened, and understand the meaning of the word coexistince.

[@masmoney5731]

Isrealis killed many Palestinians over decades that’s a fact it’s gonna have to be one hell of an apology if anything. I think an apology is well over due regardless. .... peace ☮️ no pun intended ..lol

[@jason4275]

its not the same

[@masmoney5731]

@@jason4275 either way Isreal must apologize like a really big apology, they still will not be forgiven. But an apology will be The right thing to do. ....also Palestinian pride is not hanging on nobody’s apology.

[@Linda43]

@@masmoney5731 Don't be so serious. This is just a video. The Jewish people will not be apologizing to the Arabs for anything. Least of all for reclaiming our ancient ancestral homeland of Israel, or defending ourselves from their attack on our sovereignty in 1947, 1967, etc. Or building a beautiful country or any other dm thing. This question was the most ridiculous question yet.

[@dogbert52]

"The british have killed many argentinians..... "

[@jason4275]

@@dogbert52 Don't get me started on Argentina, you need to look up what they did to the black population in that country in the late 1800s.

[@libgapper9761]

Thank you for your bravery Corey!!

[@10BaroshGever]

If you're still believe in piece after this you're just naive

[@Nothing-ui7pj]

If you believe in peace in general then you are Naive

[@Nothing-ui7pj]

@Roy Wales 😂😂 yeah tell me WW1 Ww2 French colonization of Algeria French occupation of Vietnam American war on Vietnam Korean wars (which were fed from the west and communists) US invasion of Iraq 2003 This is peace by bloodthirsty criminal “peace-lovers” non-muslims

[@solvingpolitics3172]

Or a another self loathing leftist.

[@Nothing-ui7pj]

@Roy Wales you are either stupid enough to take things literally, or dumb enough to believe that those countries have made “peace” after those conflicts, you think Vietnam could ever forgive for the wars waged on it? Or will the Iraqis do? They wont, France still to this day hold the bodies and skulls of Algerian freedom fighters in museums and refuse to apologize for its crimes in Algeria, is that peace?

[@Nothing-ui7pj]

@Roy Wales what i mean in General is that its all a game of benefits and mutual interests, and don’t take my words literally, your brains should have the necessary flexibility friend because expressing ourselves in languages is flexible, i do not promote ongoing violence and conflicts and i do not urge people to kill each other, and i do not mean by “not believing in peace” is that every two countries who do not have mutual interests should wage wars against each other, what i meant is that politics in General is a dirty game, and humans are greedy bastards.

[@fatifleur-hp6jr]

It’s painful!

[@danielb.k.becman6841]

Mr. Shuster...Thank you for doing this amazing work! I've been watching your videos for a long time, dont miss one! Amuses me so much to hear the answers to the questions you propose ( very firmly, btw, bravo!)....once again, thank you some much. Hope to record something with you in Eretz someday

[@jason4275]

*They declare war, not an independent Palestinian country, but war, they lost, So you don't negotiate with the losing side.*

[@Rabolisk]

And you think the US didn't declare war on Iraq in 2003? Or is it only OK when white people declare war?

[@tFighterPilot]

@@Rabolisk Did anyone say that it was ok for the US to declare war on Iraq or that it wasn't ok for the Arabs to declare war on Israel?

[@tFighterPilot]

@Someoneak17 Somewhere Most of the British who took place in the war were on the Arab side.

[@tFighterPilot]

@Someoneak17 Somewhere They didn't give us anything. They conquered the land from the Ottomans in WW1, aided by both Arabs and Jews, then in 1947 they left, only leaving some officers to train the Arab legion. That's when the war started.

[@tFighterPilot]

@Someoneak17 Somewhere It didn't matter. It was only a declaration of intention. The fact is, when the actual war started, they sided with our enemies.

[@ajg3768]

Palestinians never had official country. As nomads they walked up and down, left and right for thousands of years as STATELESS.

[@franovak2654]

Mh no that's just what the Ottoman empire was, there were no actual states, as there weren't in Europe under the Austrian-Hungarian Empire in Eastern Europe or because of domination of France/Spain on other countries/people. National State and its ideology are is in fact a modern social construct but that's not an excuse for de-nationalize entire people/countries for western imperialist and Israeli colonialist purposes.

[@ajg3768]

@@franovak2654 . Well Israel was legitimate Country during Roman Empire, they have the right to claim what was theirs. Palestinians,again never care or tried to establish their country.

[@starhopper408]

@@franovak2654 They were never sovereign in anyway. ... And Israelis can't colonize their own homeland.

[@syrianatheist817]

@@ajg3768 israelis are nomads they were enslaved by every ancient nations

[@ajg3768]

@@syrianatheist817 . Suggest you stop drinking.

[@schmechmal]

my point of view is that Israel have to apologize for occupied Palestine.The degree of apology must be the same as that which Germany has awarded the Jews. that means giving them land, paying compensation and having human rights in general. Unfortunately this will never happened

[@fredperry9235]

Doomed by their own mindset

[@aminhanini609]

They are right , How can you agree with the thief, even if he is strong and supported by others, would you accept that you ask him to return some stolen belongings to you and then forgive him? First and foremost, he is a thief, a thief and a usurper. He should be punished with imprisonment and a fine.

[@farfiman]

@@aminhanini609 There is "your truth" and "reality". At some point a person has to face reality.

[@avirose194]

I pity the day, Palestinian reality hits them between their ears. 100 years (before the State of Israel was reborn), the ARABS rejected a homeland for the 1964 Palestinians. Read the timeline of "100 years of chronic Arab REJECTIONISM " which relates to 100 years of CHRONIC ARAB REJECTIONISM and their choice of wars, which they lost. Still rejecting and still losing...reality check!!!!

[@fredperry9235]

@@aminhanini609 Then fuck off back to Arabia

[@avirose194]

Is Jordan Palestine? :: Daniel Pipes www.danielpipes.org/298/is-jordan-palestine The Jordan-is-Palestine argument rests on four main premises: that Palestine historically included Jordan; that the British-governed Mandate of Palestine included the entire territory of today's Israel and Jordan; that the two regions are geographically indistinguishable; and that Palestinian and Jordanian leaders themselves believe Jordan and Palestine identical.

[@guyvisual9210]

Why would we apologize xD ? They attacked us first in 1948

[@honorable_aj7280]

No. The British conquered the land for you to live in. You started it. (Well not exactly cause the British are the ones who conquered it for you not Israelis) but logically Palestinians are the victims and innocents here

[@guyvisual9210]

@@honorable_aj7280 Conquered from who? the palestinians? nah.. The land was belong to the ottoman empire before ww1. It was never belongs to the palestinians. A lot jews was in Palestine (which was the name of the land given by the Roman Empire, and none of the peoples living there was called "palestinian") when the british took the land. The British offered 2 state one for the jews one for the arabs, you decided to attack us, we won, goodbye :)

[@guyvisual9210]

@@honorable_aj7280 Haha victims.. We offered them 5 times an independent state and they keep being ignorant and keeping want all the land of Israel, which will never happen. 2 times after we offered them a state they sent us suicide bombers who exploded in school busses, markets and more and did a lot terror attacks (the 2 intifadahs, which you probably never heard of). And now theres hamas who send thousands of rockets to Israels territory. I think we are the victims here, are'nt we?

[@faizaanwar3662]

@@guyvisual9210 your seriously not the victims that’s what happens when you try to take over land other people were already living on

[@guyvisual9210]

@@ziadalaa6054 XDDDD "killing their men" I bet you're just another 12 year old kid who believe everything in the media but never think if its true. Arabs in Israel have the exact same right as a jew (in Israel territory) and most of us live peacefully and work together. The videos you probably saw us "killing their men" are IDF's reaction because of something palestinians did like throwing rocks or rob.. You can never find what happened before IDF's reaction and if you can send me a link :) And also if an Israeli kill palestinian for no reason he gets 20 years jail

[@Kaeso97]

Hey guys you need to understand lots of Palestinian were kicked out of their house so Ashkenazis could settle in, i would feel the same as them ... Naaqba is a naaqba how are you supposed to accept some kind of "apologizes", and what for ?

[@ef2718]

500,000-700,000 Arabs fled out of Israel and became refugees. 900,000-1,000,000 Jews fled into Israel from Arab countries and became refugees, their descendants make the majority of Israelis.

[@lori8161]

But the Naqba happened a long time ago tho

[@dogbert52]

The ones that declared war on israel in 1947....

[@starhopper408]

They lost what they lost, because they made the poor choices that they made ... just like now. ... Naqkbaa is "We tried to k you. We failed. We are the victims"

[@starhopper408]

@Yoav Daniel No one gives a $hit about that.

[@zoneone3855]

If they apologized, and everyone reached a real peace agreement and all lived side by side without the presence of grudges, why not ????

[@saleemiqbal9346]

The treachery and the oppression . Its much abt. Defence and fear of safety of their families than ego which the other party has! Thats too much pain by just ego

[@misssoso5859]

Can you live peacefully with someone who killed your family and stole your home?

[@zoneone3855]

@@misssoso5859 A real apology is to restore rights to its people and prosecute those involved in murder cases .. After that there is no objection to real peace and sharing life as neighbors :)

[@misssoso5859]

@@zoneone3855 Again; if someone stole your house and lived there against your will and called himself "your neighbor"; would you accept that?

[@zoneone3855]

@@misssoso5859 My words are clear ... Restoring rights first, including homes and lands .. and prosecuting the murderers

[@4clempt]

Dire consequences to the criminal doesn’t turn him into a victim. 👎🏽

[@starhopper408]

@Roy Wales Yep .. and families, societies, countries, freedom, democracy, rights, etc, etc. And now their pushing that crap on little kids ... which is abuse.

[@lori8161]

@@starhopper408 Liberalism is amazing,Democrats are waaaaaaaay better than the Republicans

[@Unnamed7964]

@Roy Wales Why don't you like liberalism? Israel is the most liberal country in the middle east and it's doing fantastically, i definitely wouldn't like a very conservative closed anti freedom non secular patriarchal society version of israel like most nearby countries, liberal is fine, you shouldn't inter-use liberal and leftist the way Americans do like it's the same thing, it's not

[@wheelinthesky300]

Why doesn't Corey create a pretaped question: "48 or 67?"

[@avirose194]

One would think that these Arabs who have rejected their own homeland for over a hundred years and now Biden who is calling for the two state solution to be resurrected would realise that the Arabs aka 1964 Palestinians do not want their own homeland. The plan did not work in 1937, 1947, 1967, 1973, 2000, 2005 all the way through history to 2021.

[@monamie691]

I always ask him why do we have to ask this, he tells me people outside still dont realise what's meant by "all of Palestine".

[@monamie691]

@Roy Wales not at all. There have always been comnents that i dont like, but what's the use of having only the ones i like being here? Someone must have reported it or something.

[@iddopompan1442]

here are some analogies to that question: 1) does the austrian barista that sold me coffee in vienna 4.5 years ago, needs to apologize for my great grandparents being kicked out of their home there and then being sent to death pits in serbia? 2) does the young german woman who once helped me navigate in the metro while touring berlin needs to apologize for the crimes of nazi germany? 3) does that one japanese individual who lives, to say, in osaka today - needs to apologize for the death of hundreds by the japanese empire in ww2? there are many other examples to the above that are not mentioned and i predict most people would find them irrational and immoral. why it needs to be different when regarded to the israeli-palestinian conflict? why do i need to apologize for events that happened before i even existed? it seems humans find it hard to think - that's why many defect to the easy options: blame and judgment

[@solvingpolitics3172]

Great comment! The worst of them has to be the neo n z is online. None of them can even think anymore!

[@avasmith1846]

False equivalency. We can have full rights in germany, can travel anywhere we would want in germany, etc. Palestinians still cant access the places that their families grew up in for generations, and the state which kicked them out still exists today as it did back then Not to mention the *illegal settlements* that keep popping up and continuing to encroach on land that was promised to the palestinians! And every able-bodied isreali citizen is required to uphold this settler colonial atrocity by joining the military for 2 years, meaning every isreali has a hand in it

[@iddopompan1442]

​@@avasmith1846 1) irrelevant equivalency because nothing of what i initially wrote refers to the civil rights that the german citizen or the people living in germany have or don't have - it refers to the accountability of today's generation for events that preceded them. 2) so are you suggesting that the 22 story building that i live in, needs to be taken down completely and have all it's residents sent to other countries, only because a certain palestinian who lives (to say) in a refugee camp in jordan had a grandfather who owned a house in the exact same spot where my home stands today? otherwise, for instance, are you suggesting that can i demand the house that my grandfather owned in vienna until 1938 or take it down entirely, despite the woman living there with 2 children? 3) i'll give you that, i don't see myself as an advocate for israeli settlements and towns in judea and samaria (no offense to fellow israelis and supporters of israel), mainly because it puts our citizens, military and money at risk until a solution is being implemented. that aside, i want to point out that i find none of it as justification for a palestinian being sentenced to death penalty (by the palestinian authority) for the mere action of selling land and/or property to a jew. 4) there are israelis who actually do not get drafted into the mandatory military service for a variety of reasons (mostly for medical and mental reasons). and that goes back the previous points i've made - generalizing israelis in a certain context or holding *some* of them for actions and events that preceded them is just as wrong as saying and doing the same for palestinians or any other country. in another video in this channel, i have argued that past events cannot be a base for the arguments and solutions of the present, merely because they can be traded and recycled back and forth for days and weeks without really leading anywhere. whether we like it or not, whether was right or wrong, the past cannot be reverted - what's done is done. it all comes down to the decision of either stepping in order to find a solution or staying in a pointless vortex of blame and judgement.

[@iamitick6317]

We have 2021 and look and those 2 stories:

[@harald337]

It's not the question if a single citizen should apologizes for a crime done by his ancestors. But a state should apologize for crimes which happened in the past. So your comparison is wrong.

[@freeman8446]

They don't look occupied

[@Linda43]

"Crybullies"

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 I bet you like Lehava you racist

[@Linda43]

@@lori8161 I don't support marriage between Jews and non Jews. That isn't racism. Its cultural and religious survival. Racism is hate. Please Google instead of posting hateful things

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 Lehava hates Muslims and Christians tho

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 And you support them,That's like if I supported Hamas (Which I don't)

[@mikak9105]

I didnt understand how the Jews should apologize for their victory in 48 after the Arab attack, like - "sorry for not let you kill us"?

[@SuperFra2002]

I watched many of his videos and I still can't understand what is his point of view on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Someone knows?

[@Linda43]

🤷‍♀️

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales Like I've said before not all Palestinians are Muslim

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales The Christian ones hate Israel too if you were wondering

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales Are you going to send them to a nursng home?😆😆😆😆😆

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales Not all of Israels enemies are Muslims btw

[@pupik1563]

Can u ask palestinians if palestine was a country when it was founded and by who ?

[@obitouchiha8053]

Kanan who the first ppl live in this land from prophet ibrahim kanan ppl was there before jew religion lol and kanan arabs group

[@matejfele9971]

The simple notion that we have to apologize for something is laughable by itself.

[@abbask56]

Yes! They have to apologize you, because you have occupied their farms and throw them out from there, and killed them when they resist. This land is given by god to you and based on god's command, you can still remain innocent while killing enemied of god.... freak!!!

[@matejfele9971]

@@abbask56 Did you know that when we killed JC, we also gained his superpowers? True story.

[@abbask56]

@@matejfele9971 That’s why I think, the problem is your "god" and that is the real enemy

[@MrZxcvbnm22]

wtf... Well you as an individual dont need to apologize. But Israel as a country?

[@matejfele9971]

@@abbask56 You can blame god, me and every other human being if that makes you feel better. It still won't change reality as it is.

[@yosefshifteh8793]

You know what is interesting, that the palistinian authority was created in 1960's way after isreal

[@faizaanwar3662]

but it was still called palestine before that

[@yosefshifteh8793]

@@faizaanwar3662 who named it Palestine not the Arabs who lived there were also Jews living there at that time the British conquered it from the Ottoman Empire in World War I and they named it Palestine so in 1948 the British chose to make another state called Israel it was their territory they conquered. other nation's obviously could not handle that, so all the surrounding countries attacked the small state, and guess who was miraculously winner, the Jews

[@MishaFlower]

Allpalestine was created in 48. It joined the UAR. Then the UAR collapsed so it came back as the Palestinian authority.

[@yosefshifteh8793]

@@MishaFlower that is that is wrong and not true have you ever learned history it wasn't that long ago don't make up lies only idiots who don't know history might believe that sadly I'm not one of those so I know that's false

[@RISKILNIKIV]

@@faizaanwar3662 gotta thank the romans for that love

[@Zivush420]

What are we to apologize for? Being invaded?

[@jason4275]

History shows that Jews lived there for thousands of years and has always called it there're homeland, the Ancient Egyptians, Greeks, the romans all documented this in there're history books, all this before the A.D era.

[@saeedvazirian]

you literally invaded the region first idiot. You belong in Hungary and Poland, not Palestine.

[@saeedvazirian]

@@jason4275 So did the Palestinians. The zionists aren't jews anyway, most are atheists.

[@Zivush420]

@@saeedvazirian I think you should read some books, or maybe look to what happened to us when we were in Poland or.Hungary, you fucking idiot.

[@saeedvazirian]

@@Zivush420 HOW THE FUCK IS THAT PALESTINIANS' FAULT YOU NUT!

[@blainebossie9519]

Palestinians deserve a lot more than a simple apology. Gaza is an open air prison in the West Bank he’s a honeycomb of destitute Palestinian Territories divided up by illegal Israeli settlements, that conveniently take the resources and infrastructure that would be necessary for a two state solution to be possible, (Israel has stolen so much land from the Palestinians that at this point a two state solution is impossible just as they intended). A secular non-apartheid state should be formed between Israel and the Palestinians territories, but generations of being told to hate each other makes that difficult, especially considering Israel has the same problem the US does, in that both it’s major parties are right wing.

[@meerpirat508]

Actually the settlements aren't illegal. Besides of that, why Egypt dont just open the Gaza border? There's a reason why both countries closed the borders. But it's never the Palestinians fault.

[@SJdC2004]

It's an interesting video... some cooler heads seem to be prevailing slowly among both sides. I have been to Israel and the Palestinian areas. Both peoples were gracious and welcoming. The Palestinians conduct their business in Israeli currency and use Israeli products. Maybe some sort of accommodation can eventually be reached. I really think that both people are exhausted from this endless conflict. I think that Israel's new relationships with the Arab world is a good thing. Countries like Egypt, The UAE, Saudi Arabia, Morocco could serve as a bridge for the two sides to reach out to each other, slowly but surely. The elderly Palestinian gentleman seems sincere. Millions of Palestinians would not be able to flood Israel proper as a practical matter, but several thousand could probably return without it tipping over the apple cart, so to speak. The only real loser in this would be Iran, which has a vested interest in keeping the conflict going.

[@anonnnnnnnnnnnn]

@Roy Wales As a Jew, would you want to co-exist with the same people that tried to exterminate your religion and culture?

[@eldarm1853]

@@anonnnnnnnnnnnn As a Muslim, would you want to co-exist with the same people that tried to exterminate your home and livelihood? Of course you would want to, both sides need to build trust, and give consessions... You prefer war or giving up most settlements? You prefer war or giving up right to return pre-67? The real question is do you want peace?

[@anonnnnnnnnnnnn]

@@eldarm1853 I prefer giving half of the land to Palestinians and half to the Jews. Co-existing is a fairy tail portrayed as a solution. It only causes problems.

[@eldarm1853]

@@anonnnnnnnnnnnn Well, that's okay, my view of co-existence is "not terrorizing or bombing each other". It's simply that to keep the jewish nature of the country, Israel needs to be prepared to abandon a lot of settlements, take maybe a couple hundred thousand refugees, and compensate a bit. Then the Palestinians should waive all sort of right to return, and offer certain Israeli (national) security presence. And maybe in a hundred years socioeconomic differences will be smaller, and imigration/movement and secularism will be more normal.

[@wheelinthesky300]

Corey: Now that you've asked about the Nakba, ask the Palestinians, if, well, they did anything naughty around 1948.

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales A Secularist isn't supposed to care about religion

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales Who said that? Not me

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales Oh you mean Palestine

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales I favor a two state solution,Not a one state solution that will lead to many deaths

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales Wanting peace isn't against Secularism

[@deadlyhuman19]

6:10 Such a cool Grandpa xD :D

[@sladetuner8661]

the British government must say their sorry for the Balfour deceleration

[@artair70]

Well no, they had no vote in it.

[@fatemazohora7655]

will the jews forgive hitler if he apologize???

[@dcrafton3988]

The only difference is that Israel =/ nazi germany

[@MolpPlom]

What i do not understand with Palestinians, that they proclaim their identity as rightfully theirs. I mean... "Palestine" was given by the romans for this region and they just adapted an exonym that is not even derived from their language / culture. This is the same with "Prussia" e.g. .

[@edwinlucianofrias1643]

Ancient Greek historians and geographers had been calling the region “Palestine” for hundreds of years before the Romans came into the picture. It’s part of the reason the Arabs, Ottomans and British all called the region “Palestine” in one form or another. As a Dominican, I find it quite normal to call yourself something that foreigners who colonized you named you. “Santo Domingo” is a name that the Spanish colonizers came up with. The island was called “Haiti” or “Quisqueya” by the natives (depending on who you ask but please don’t) but I don’t reject the label “Dominican” just because my colonizers decided upon it 500 years ago. We did, actually. It wasn’t until the second time we kicked the Spanish out (in 1865) that we started calling ourselves “Dominican.” We just called ourselves Spaniards before that! 😆

[@edwinlucianofrias1643]

By the way, I would venture to say that most Palestinians identify as “Arab” which is a culture that originated somewhere else and belong to one of two religious traditions that also came from outside: in one case the Arabian peninsula and in the other from Jews. A Palestinian can feel Arab and Greek Orthodox without doubts that any of these identities are rightful theirs. I feel Roman Catholic and Hispanic but my connections to Rome and Spain don’t have that much to do with it. Mostly because I really don’t have any.

[@KT-pe6zh]

The man at 2:35 was about to give me hope about recognizing the state of Israel, until he said the he would not accept to give up the right for refugees to return to Israel :((. Nothing disappoints me at this point !!

[@nabil5535]

Why? He said they could go to their homeland. And he’s right, call it whatever you will Israel or Palestine, people should be able to RETURN.

[@DD-rv8hi]

@@nabil5535 so Jews who were expelled and their descendants should return to Palestine too, for example not considering Gush Etzion an illegal settlement because their residents were expelled under Jordanian rule and they came back after 67... any Palestinian will agree to let Jews return to their former homes

[@MikeRosoftJH]

@@DD-rv8hi Well, if Israel-Palestine becomes a single secular state, there will be freedom of movement. There will be no Jewish or Palestinian settlements. All citizens will be entitled to settle anywhere throughout the country they want.

[@anshulbhardwaj4038]

@@MikeRosoftJH Islam and secularism can not coexist

[@MikeRosoftJH]

@@anshulbhardwaj4038 If you treat Muslims as a whole as an enemy, chance is that they will be an enemy. What goes around, comes around. It's not Islam as such that is incompatible with secular democracy; rather, it's any kind of religious or political fundamentalism. And let me remind you that Israel is not a secular state; it's an ethnoreligious state. Would you, then, claim that Judaism and secularism cannot coexist?

[@thatoneguy7127]

What kinda question is this...wtf

[@bryeetsonny9458]

A thought provoking perspective question on peace, this is what his whole channel is about

[@johnguslen9315]

Ask for too much and you get nothing. A saying where I live but obviously not in Palestine.

[@da7me22]

Corry, I would really appreciate if you change the title to “the Nakkba or the catastrophe” as 1948 does not reflect what is actually asked in the question. I think most people do not understand the amount of suffering the Nakkba has caused.

[@starhopper408]

The Arbz brought it on themselves with their poor and hostile choices. If they want to get mad at someone, they should kick their own @rses.

[@warpedcomedy]

Yes but you brought it on yourselves

[@monkeyb1820]

Google and read 'British Record on Partition' from the Nation Associates magazine. Apologizing makes about as much sense as apologizing to Germany for polluting their land with our ashes and bodies. Only when everyone is taught the truth--and taught that it is not a 'naqba' that husseini failed to successfully genocide the Jews of Palestine, can there ever be peace.

[@tomasmalin]

It's so sad to see them refusing the existence of Israel completely instead of looking for a solution.

[@Linda43]

The Arabs are not seeking a solution but the end of Israel. There can be no peace with a implacable enemy.

[@lori8161]

Well I'm an Arab and I favor a two state solution

[@starhopper408]

@@lori8161 You're an Israeli A rb. That's not exactly the same.

[@lori8161]

@@starhopper408 But technically I'm not an Arab because my ancestors are Chechen

[@starhopper408]

@@lori8161 You clearly id with them, so that's rather irrelevant. Do you look A rb?

[@roslanyasin2891]

Long Live Palestine.....

[@Linda43]

Fantasies are not real

[@roslanyasin2891]

@@Linda43 One day it will happen for sure.

[@Linda43]

@@roslanyasin2891 Nope

[@roslanyasin2891]

@@Linda43 There are millions of Palestinians in Palestine territory and all over the world. When the Arab nations unite and western countries realised how evil is Zionist Israel then it's over for you and your Israel. Bye2.

[@lori8161]

@@roslanyasin2891 I think most live in Chile

[@starhopper408]

What are they supposed to be apologizing for again? Not dropping de@d at the demand of those who have been trying to destroy them for a century straight? Yeah, that totally makes sense. 🙄

[@5amsaramadanlearnarabic347]

Your comment shows that you're totally clueless about the conflict and you have zero idea of what's going on there .

[@5amsaramadanlearnarabic347]

If someone came to your house and threw you and your family in the tiny basement and killed your brothers when they were trying to defend your house , and those thieves justifying all these crimes that your house was for their grandfather 3000 years ago !! Would you make peace with these criminals? All the respect for the true Patriots appeared in the video, they never surrender and they will take their land back again they will not be weak forever read the history.

[@5amsaramadanlearnarabic347]

@Starhopper True they rented it furnished for 2000 years only lol They should have a God who's a landlord to give it to them as a gift this is your logical analysis right ?

[@starhopper408]

@@5amsaramadanlearnarabic347 No. My analysis is that Israel belongs to Israel aside from anything to do with religion and the history would not have been enough in an of itself to make the establishment of the Jewish nation possible, but there was a lot more to it than that. ... the vast majority of those Arbz have not been there for centuries, much less 2000 y, ... guess who has been there continuously for over 4000?

[@5amsaramadanlearnarabic347]

@@starhopper408 your answer is shuffling everything together, what do you mean by ARABS in your answer? Do you mean Palestinians? Or people speak Arabic? Or arabs from Yemen and Saudi Arabia? Or Muslims? Because each has a different answer. But bottom line and that's the logical thing all over the history, the land belongs to its inhabitants , Palestinians all refer to themselves as PALESTINIANS, not arabs not muslims, it's the inhabitants of this land they can be muslims, Christians, jews whatever, which is the logical thing , but Zionism dosen't say so , it claims if you believe in a certain religion so automatically this mskes other people's land is yours even if you're blond with blue eyes ( Which genetically denies that they're the same race of the jews who were Egyptians and denies the claim that the Jews always say that they kept their race for thousands of years)

[@sarahh5936]

Palestine needs to apologize for their attempted genocide on jews in 1948 fighting back against that isn’t a crime Al Husseini started planning genocide on jews way back in 1941 with hitler’s help and every village that was affected were people who joined in on this attempted genocide. You can’t attempt genocide on people then cry when they defend themselves

[@Linda43]

Absolute truth

[@gabrietaselvena2652]

Yeah. I agree with u

[@OmarAhmed-jo1cf]

British tried to cause civil war between Muslims and Christians in Egypt but failed because of the cultural connection and in 1919 Egyptians raised the cresent with cross flag and became quickly aware of what the British were trying to do .But in Palestine their scheme worked , they first caused civil unrest then divided the land based on what they think and the war started right away .

[@nasimagdam2723]

thank you for the explanation. i always assumed it was the americans who were behind it, but it makes sense that the americans were just continuing what the british started. seems like they did the same things in india with pakistan. the have the same fake war here in the USA between blacks and whites, americans vs native amerians... i'm sure the ottamans did the same, and the persians, and the romans....

[@nasimagdam2723]

@Nick Bointon i see this trick that you keep using where you deflect people from the truth by gaslighting them and countering with an extremist view.....

[@nasimagdam2723]

@Nick Bointon a muslim invented algebra. without algebra there wouldn't be any modern technology....

[@duranduran8361]

They should just evenly split the country in half and call it a day

[@starhopper408]

Arbz already got 80% + Gaza. So done and then some.

[@jettawayadventures1081]

They did that in 1948. Its was known as Trans-Jordan. Arabs got Jordan and Jews got Israel. The arabs are still unhappy

[@MrAverageAmit]

2:24 lol that dude is trippin, historic palastine hehe, as it was a glorified civilization with great kings dynasty before israel

[@marksimons8861]

It's amazing that the borders that France and Britain came up with coincided exactly with historic Palestine. That is because this was the point when historic Palestine was created.

[@bosniencommie1202]

@@marksimons8861 actueli it was made es otoman prowenc

[@_Faisal_]

That’s like saying, oh Muslim should take back Spain, Al andalus was a much more glorified place for Muslims Jews and Christians than modern Spain. This is just as ridiculous as your remark.

[@MrAverageAmit]

@@_Faisal_ i don't get your point tho..

[@saeedvazirian]

There was no israel. He is right. Palestine was the name of the region for millenia, but anyways, it's not the name that matters, but the ethnic group.

[@lonly_meh3087]

I hope that Palestine people have a Their land back.and keep strong. Aamiin.

[@wissamalnajjar8682]

How was Palestine and Israël in 1967 ? Because when I see on internet it looks like the actual territory

[@starhopper408]

Ironically, it was the Arbz that insisted that the armistice agreements clearly note that it was not to be considered a border (because they didn't want to be limited to that in the future).

[@Theouterrim77]

@Masmethetime HuluLoulou Arab nations were lining up to destroy Israel in 1967, and later in the 1973 war. Only in 1979 did Egypt sign a peace deal. The majority of Palestinians have always wanted to dismantle Israel and expell it's people.

[@RISKILNIKIV]

amazing video

[@talink6867]

6:28 I'm so sorry we beat your asses in a war that you started, I feel terrible right now😔

[@lori8161]

Civilians should never be involved in war

[@Linda43]

😆

[@jontron3freepalestine494]

No we haven't lost

[@talink6867]

@@lori8161 I was talking about those who invaded us

[@starhopper408]

@@jontron3freepalestine494 Yes, you have. And you did it to yourselves.

[@SalveteOmnes1]

Guys I’m from Mexico, here we got the Spaniards, the resistance between natives and Europeans lasted hundreds of years and look at us now, 600 years later we’re all mixed!! 😂 Oops!! Have a glance of your future Israelinians!! 🤭

[@realpatriothawaii5653]

It's against the law for a jew to marry a palestinian in isreal.

[@fayyadabdullah5232]

@@realpatriothawaii5653 Damn this is what u call non human acts

[@Sahajayana-Nirvanasara]

Thank you, What a clear window In---the comments, also. We are Always Communicating Our State whether we want to or not---after listening-quietly, I am on Team Palestine.

[@starhopper408]

You should try team Narnia instead.

[@khabibnurmagomedov8581]

Me too

[@rankirshenboim87]

Notice that palestiniens with some knowlage in English are much more liberal in their responses. If you want peace, start with EDUCATION

[@Linda43]

First we would have to undo their present educational experiences. Look at PALWATCH

[@starhopper408]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/m2Owfp2Zbb-Loqs

[@interestingyoutubechannel1]

If you ever seen their school textbook materials in the PA territory, its vomit-inducing. Bloodthirsty antisemitic indoctrination, they fill children with hate and rage toward us. So yes, I agree education is key. But we cannot enforce an education system on them, it has to be an internal change within themselves, which will not happen any time soon.

[@lori8161]

@@interestingyoutubechannel1 That's true

[@lori8161]

@@interestingyoutubechannel1 I went to one before

[@sugarrayrobinson7394]

What a stupid question

[@lori8161]

No not really,It's an interesting question

[@lori8161]

The answers were "concerning" to say the least

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales Not all Palestinians want to ki!! all Israelis that's a fact and you advocate for genocide against them which is insane

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales Some said yes and some said no

[@lori8161]

@Roy Wales But the ones that said no were concerning

[@obaidabs3944]

I am Palestinian born in refuges camp in Jordan my father told me 1948 the hagana by moshea dyan destroyed the village they killed 1000 from total 4200 people were lived their the village still there and we have papers for our lands and you want us to forgive ?

[@dogbert52]

My grandpa told me in old scotland , dragons fought nessi and lost. And now she is in the loch digesting them.

[@obaidabs3944]

@Ant B you can read about The Dowayma village its easy

[@soiaisreal8444]

@Ant B Abu Gosh hates Israel. They are selfish

[@lori8161]

@@soiaisreal8444 No we don't hate Israel and we aren't selfish,We just want to live in peace if you don't like that you can keep your opinions to yourself

[@soiaisreal8444]

@@lori8161 Shut up Arab we Jews hate you so leave Israel at once

[@rumamarciano4974]

☆☆עם ישראל חי לנצח ☆☆

[@الاهلي-م7ي]

Bruh 😑Whatever you say.

[@الاهلي-م7ي]

@Yoav Daniel i dont think so

[@khalildz1552]

🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@DogesBasement]

@@khalildz1552 Nice Jordan flag

[@mirabrown2271]

What! To say sorry for winning a war? Stupid question.

[@Linda43]

👍

[@bosniencommie1202]

Fore not making a pupit state instade anexing it

[@ramadarayyad3842]

No, to say sorry for killing innocent palestinians and occupying their land. do your research.

[@shaniisreal8363]

@@ramadarayyad3842 you killing us islamnazim

[@mirabrown2271]

@@ramadarayyad3842 that's what happens in war or do you think you played with toy guns. People die and land is conquered.

[@retrogamer3907]

Salute to the dude with the shades

[@dru4670]

What is Naqba ?

[@crmiller1395]

It means disgrace

[@arnold241]

1948 war after cleansing & displacing palastanian from their land

[@BenBorisenko]

Palestinian exodus during Arab Israeli war

[@davidnord2858]

the failure of many Arab states to destroy Israel and kill the Jews

[@Linda43]

No land for peace. Just peace for peace. עם ישראל חי לנצח

[@Linda43]

@Mohamed Mostafa It sets a precedent. I have no doubt it will take time. Meanwhile, Israel is busy with other concerns, like the pandemic and securing its borders. More important than the persistent kvetching of the Arabs in Israel.

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 How is it do we "kvetch" exactly?

[@Linda43]

We have gained another approach to this conflict. One that suits our needs. It's no longer our responsibility to make the concessions or understand their side of things. The Arabs in Israel must accept our stance and approach us.

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 We will never favor a One State Solution,A Two State Solution is best

[@Linda43]

@@lori8161 A one state solution already exists. It is called the nation state of the Jewish people, Israel.

[@calich33sehead]

The first few answers bummed me out but it got more hopeful as the video went on.

[@starhopper408]

One said maybe, the rest all said f no. The surprising part was the one, not the others.

[@zabenaleid2547]

Eli we would accept Israel if they stopped occupying Palestinian lands in the West Bank and allowed the Palestinians to have their own state. This can be a win win scenario. Real peace, not this status quo endless conflict and suffering for people.

[@zabenaleid2547]

Vast majority of Arabs think exactly like the man at 2:50

[@starhopper408]

@@zabenaleid2547 Lies

[@starhopper408]

@@zabenaleid2547 The guy at 2: 50 said "no peace without right of return" .. which would mean the destruction of Israel as a Jewish nation. .... and they know that and so do you (iow, hellloooo true colors)

[@tamerlane7]

Plaease ask the question to the Israelis, “Who is Allah to you”? Thanks and kind regards. Timur from U.K

[@tamerlane7]

@shani isreal Oh Gosh...please repent and seek forgiveness. You have just blasphemed against the 1 true GOD of the universe, who created the heaven and earth and everything that's in it. Regardless of what name by which one may call him. He is still the same 1 GOD. It's not about me believe me, I honestly could care less about it. But sister...please repent for your own sake. May the 1 true GOD forgive us all. kzbin.info/www/bejne/l6K5mYN4gLqnacU

[@lori8161]

@shani isreal There will be no forced conversions on my watch

[@tamerlane7]

@shani isreal Please ask a Jewish scholar, a man of knowledge and he will confirm that it is the same 1 true GOD believe me. I don't mean to sound disrespectful at all in any shape or form, but you have been misinformed honestly. The Rabbis will tell you if you were to ask them. That it is the same GOD. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bF6UZH-gidp4r80

[@dogbert52]

@shani isreal please help yourself.

[@lori8161]

@shani isreal Who is liking your comments exactly?

[@megaswe]

Question: Alot of israelis and palestinians say "of course" as answers even though it not obvious to me as swede. Is it something you say in english, is it correct? or is it just a misunderstanding of how you can use the language? To initiate the answer by stating the basic of your foundation (your view)?

[@ashley1570]

Im not sure if I understand your question. Are you asking what is the meaning of "of course" or if they actually mean it when they say it? If you are asking the meaning, it means "yes". Or a more "powerful" yes like "absolutely!". Exemple : (Question)do you want to play baseball with me? (Answer) "Of course!". "Of course" is part of the english language (so no its not an expression only used by israelis or palestinians). If you ask if they actually mean it...well there is no way to know their true intentions...

[@solvingpolitics3172]

@@ashley1570 I think he is asking wether they mean it when they say it.

[@solvingpolitics3172]

How is Sweden holding up with its Islamic immigration?

[@marksimons8861]

There is a reluctance to say yes or no without some sort of conditionality. I expect that does indeed have something to do with the way a language is used.

[@ashley1570]

​@@solvingpolitics3172 yeah i dont understand the question at all.

[@coletrain411]

If there was a threat from outside (china, russia, whatever) would you (Palestinians) be willing to ally yourselves with jews to fight it, at least temporarily?

[@Linda43]

There are Arabs who serve in the IDF. As well as other ethnicities.

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 No real Arab would serve in the IDF

[@Linda43]

@@lori8161 More bias and stereotyping

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 Nope

[@lori8161]

@@Linda43 I'm saying the truth