(Parody) Everything Wrong With The One Where Pinkie Pie Knows in 5 Minutes

Raise your hand if you can keep a secret better than the pony with a promise named after her.
Cinemare Sins is a fan-made series inspired by Cinema Sins. Be sure to check out the original: / cinemasins
Cinemare Sins Playlist:
• ALL Cinemare Sins Videos
Thanks to "casper" for their suggestion!
See channel links for a form to submit your own sins for future episodes!
Consider supporting me on Patreon!
► / littleshyfim
$1 tier includes Discord server perk, patron-only feed, and early access to new videos. Thanks for your support!
Follow me on Twitter!
► / littleshyfim
All third-party content belongs to its respective owners and is used in a nature considered "fair use." I'm not associated with Hasbro nor the makers of Cinema Sins.

[@FlynnMLP]

I love titles like that. "Have you seen the new episode?" "Which one?" "I forgot what it's called, but it's the one where Pinkie Pie knows." Or: "Have you seen the new episode?" "No, not yet, what's it about?" "It's about time."

[@shinygod7310]

Your comment says it was posted one day ago but this was posted 14 mins ago????

[@hotspiceeee]

S H I N Y G O D True, And the Video has only been out for an hour

[@feqbrony8989]

What about that one where it's just a slice of life?

[@nicolaking9932]

HOW IS THIS COMMENT A DAY AGO WHEN THIS WAS 1 HOUR AGO🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@feqbrony8989]

Nicola King Pinkie Pie. Time has no influence on her power

[@Pugzie2000]

"The one where pinkie pie knows" She always knows, why else would she give all the exposition

[@nicolaking9932]

do you know its 2020

[@dotsce]

⁠@@nicolaking9932do you know it’s 2024

[@mikeisforreal6030]

I did the counting, and you won't get to the last episode until June 1, 2029. That's both a sin for you for making us wait and a sin for me for wasting my own time.

[@Black-Swan-007]

This upsets me. 2029 is like 30 years from now! What? No way is it 2020 already. The 90's were only 10 years ago!

[@kabhes9040]

@@Black-Swan-007 you seem to strugle with math a lot.

[@Black-Swan-007]

@@kabhes9040 I mean I do but my comment has nothing to do with maths.

[@kabhes9040]

@@Black-Swan-007 it was a joke because 2020-1990=/=10 years

[@Black-Swan-007]

@@kabhes9040 I know that. That's why *I* made that joke. You don't get to tell me my joke was bad, then tell the same joke.

[@graphitetailgrace3870]

4:11 Cadence's horn is a lie detector, and she was detecting Pinkie's attempts at deception.

[@eebertdeebert]

This is my new headcannon.

[@TheCommenterDragon]

I was really impressed with Pinkie Pie, her ability to keep secrets without the Pinkie Promise was really put to the test in this episode, and even though she almost cracked once or twice, she did a good job of keeping her wits.

[@hudakik2242]

1:12 Why is there no sin for the pixar ball?!!

[@sparklemaggie1584]

Oh i just noticed that

[@CilanSteele]

Let's all have a moment of silence for the last line of dialogue from Mr. Cake for the entirety of the series: *You're a real cake saver!*

[@libra818]

😔

[@EnriqueLaberintico]

No way, I love Mr. Cake. This is awful.

[@royalrebel8380]

Yay! I love how you’re continuing the legacy of the show even after it ended

[@uncleiroh8252]

You mean after it died.

[@Velenturer]

@@uncleiroh8252 what he’s right?

[@MidnightMuffin]

@@uncleiroh8252 What's the difference?

[@akieboygaming]

@@uncleiroh8252 it didn't die Equestria continues with G5 it's in the same universe so you just wronged something correct

[@NH23-m8f]

And after a few episodes been deleted,DELETED

[@kvn8907]

4:50 I completely agree with number 36. She went through all the trouble to avoid telling the secret so as to not ruin Twilight Sparkles surprise and enjoyment, but is completely fine with rushing her through the scavenger hunt, ruining her surprise and enjoyment.

[@Orangeyouglad870]

Health inspector Gummy is the greatest headcanon ever but he’d have to be as sanitary as Caesar Zeppeli to get away with swimming in food

[@lunanote-cassettemeower]

Maybe he has some kind of antibacterial coating on his body.

[@amateraceon5202]

2:09 they’ve barely had their cutie marks for any time and they’re already making animation errors

[@alicetheneko7529]

Actually, if you pay very close attention, Sweetie Belle’s head was held back a little, causing her mane to hide her cutie mark until she stopped and put her head forward a little bit

[@legodev4177]

@@alicetheneko7529 This may seem likely, but we should of at least seeb a glimpse of her cutie mark while she was moving instead of it just not existing

[@privateinvestigatorrick7406]

*_"My Little Pony: F•r•i•e•n•d•ship is Magic"_* Stay tuned next month for another Pinkie Pie episode!

[@axezeeplushie2497]

Private Investigator Rick. the song or the show

[@bonnie_moondust7862]

I can't anymore

[@_.SpaghettiMuffins._]

I have found too many people with cartoon characters as their profile

[@privateinvestigatorrick7406]

@@_.SpaghettiMuffins._ Welcome to the internet.

[@illstealyourkneecaps694]

@@privateinvestigatorrick7406 have a look around

[@nicoboiboi8302]

2:09 when your cutie mark is sick of you so it leaves

[@mr.champion7304]

1:16 I mean, we literally have a phrase that tell us to not question Pinkie, "nobody questions Pinkie Pie" 1:31 Honestly, I didn't really believe it before, but now I do 4:00 Wait, hold on, why didn't she just tell her friends that she was keeping a secret? I mean, the rest of the mane 6 know that you can't tell a secret, so if Pinkie had just said that she was keeping a secret, then any pressure that the mane 6 was giving Pinkie would've stopped. There's no reason why she shouldn't tell them that she's keeping a secret. I always hate how unpragmatic characters(as well as people in general) are, especially when they don't think about what the other person doesn't know, and don't think to tell the other person their reasoning. Anyways, rant over. I just don't like how stupid some people can be when it comes to resolving situations. Oh yeah, and headcanon broken, as well. Anyways, I'm willing to bet that Littleshy is going to continue these videos into Pony Life

[@nickr8662]

About the sin with the unicorn still keeping her magic on the cup, have you never set your cup down on the table and kept your hand on it?

[@drawfunpaige9762]

3:08 I know a balloon twister personally, and they have a baby human balloon on their menu. People get it a lot too. It’s kinda like a kid wanting a doll.

[@isadoraalvarez9767]

rarity saying they wont judge pinkie could just be her trying to help ease the strain she knows the secret is putting on her.

[@Sir_Budginton]

5:18 This bit had me cracking up, it was hilarious

[@unoreverse_nou1935]

My own sin: “Wait,Is pinkie pie facepalming or hitting her eyeball with her hoof?” 1:43

[@DiamondKittyCat]

-_-

[@feqbrony8989]

No, she's trying to figure out how she can pick stuff up with hooves, but she doesn't have a microscope

[@fiend-off-the-grid]

that's the last part of a Pinkie promise, "Cross my heart and hope to fly, _stick a cupcake in my eye_ "

[@alicewilloughby4318]

Redhaired Person, "Cross my heart and hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my eye!"

[@fiend-off-the-grid]

@@alicewilloughby4318 hey, just letting you know I also commented something along these lines a little bit earlier

[@jareththegoblinking3191]

Twilight: So you're having a baby, did you cuddle? Cadence: Yes Twilight, and more Twilight: .......There's more?

[@ShadyRK9]

This episode actually cheered me up because it actually aired a week after my grandmother dieing back in October 2015. Thanks Pinkie. You might not be my favorite of The Mane 6 but this episode helped me alot with laughing at the random funniness!

[@user-uo8ny1kj4c]

thats honestly so sweet.

[@efaristi9737]

Honestly, i also found the moment when Twilight&co harrasse Pinkie so she would tell them the secret she's keeping instead of understanding that, since it's a secret, she cannot share it with them quite infuriating, considering just a moment ago, they hammered that ruining the surprises of someone else is a really bad thing to do. Like, are they even listening to themselves?

[@Wissle]

+ 1 sin for being the first episode in Cadance's and Shining Armor's descent from two interesting characters with tons of potential to nothing but parenthood. They couldn't even spend a single afternoon away from the demon spawn without a mayor breakdown.

[@clementine4750]

0:38 for the love of God!.. that is messed up o_o

[@FanSeitz]

3:33 Oh god that frame.

[@glorvalmacglorvas6082]

Gummi being the health inspector is such a hilarious idea to me.

[@thatautisticbrony7847]

I like the head cannon that gummy’s the health inspector.

[@sethmoss8671]

Now, Littleshy. Your headcanon is still valid. Rarity might still be playing along for trolling purposes. Another sin is that Rarity's forever is karma for Pinkie's Forever.

[@Deathclaw-lh5tl]

1:46 - New headcanon accepted.

[@novalightfim]

People give Spike episodes crap for dumbing down the characters, but Twilight is fairly oblivious in this one.

[@alicethedemon6551]

2:30 best sin in my opinion

[@Cosmicninja747]

Man, I can really appreciate that YTP edit at 2:38

[@winxxed]

I'm surprised you didn't pick up on how Shining Armor managed to hear pinkie in the room before walking in and finishing her sentence as pinkie initially said "shining armor and cadence are gonna have a-" and shining armor continues "an awesome weekend"

[@InariOkami]

4:09 Hornboner is canon!

[@lanfour4444]

Delete this

[@Wissle]

lmao

[@eteii]

Oh god please no-

[@sparklemaggie1584]

Wuh

[@bonnie_moondust7862]

So nobody is gonna talk about how this episode's name is a reference to F.R.I.E.N.D.S?

[@Death_Stroxke]

1:58 Literally everyone in quarantine

[@timwoods2852]

Twilight is more concerned with *her* new status as an aunt than her brother becoming a father and best babysitter turned sister-in-law becoming a mother. *Clong*

[@tomspiegel5322]

Obligatory Tom Spiegel Sin 4:12 Spike was not invited to join the scavenger hunt _or_ the party.

[@Pseudowolf]

I still wonder if this would have been more entertaining if we, the audience, were also never told what the surprise was until the end. Or if that would have just made Twilight and Co seem too oblivious.

[@sparklemaggie1584]

Hmmm

[@moonlightbabe7918]

5:21 I almost spit out my coffee 😂

[@char418]

I'm good at keeping secrets I usually don't feel any guilt when keeping them or I completely forget what I'm told cuz I have a bad memory

[@thecrapnest6346]

4:02 or maybe she was still in on it and is just doing an act I mean just look at her expression when she says that line

[@FuzzyStripetail]

Mr. Cake probably couldn't deliver those cakes and was therefore forced to rely on Pinkie Pie because Mr. Cake had an emergency cake saver booty call baking which could have explained Cadance's magically growing horn and the absurdly large carrots that were brought to the party.

[@alicewilloughby4318]

0:10 - Maybe Pinkie had already completed a number of cupcake pyramids and put them somewhere that they didn't show in this shot. 4:24 - Is AJ afraid ponies will find out she's older than she pretends?

[@billykaplan9915]

To be fair if Rarity did knew she couldn't be obvious about her knowing so she could have been acting

[@t-1156]

This video has less than 40 sins. As a random viewer, I think that deserves a sin. *Ding* Total sin counter: 40

[@Fictionboy16]

"(takes a bite of an apple) You padding the sin count, bro? I think you're padding the sin count..."

[@TheRealE.B.]

*Since this was the first episode after Crusaders of the Lost Mark, I was excited because I thought this could be the start of a new "the Cutie Mark Crusaders' cutie marks are mirrored/upside-down/just plain wrong/not even consistent within the same scene" running gag, but it looks like this episode doesn't actually contradict Lost Mark in the two brief appearance that the Crusaders make. I suppose Sweetie Belle's briefly disappearing could count, but that's just a blink-and-you-miss-it animation hiccup.*

[@squippites7356]

The thing I’m more focused on. SHINING AND CADENCE HAD SE-

[@mollysandera991]

But that's normal

[@feyasatos]

OH I AM IMAGINING THAT

[@vernyulkisasszony4708]

@@mollysandera991 They are a couple afterall

[@dookiehonestreaction]

SHINING AND CADENCE HAD SEEN TARTARUS

[@dookiehonestreaction]

HASBRO MAKE THIS SPG

[@Goat81093]

Don't forget about the fact that Pinkie was very good at keeping secrets in the episode "green isin't your color" so this whole episode was out of character

[@Actually_its_Ashely]

Gummy is the health inspector! NEW HEAD CANON

[@SonicJrandSarah]

Twilight: You mean, I'm going to be an ant. Saw that one coming!

[@ezioauditoredafirenze9249]

Wow this is the best episode nice job littleshy

[@kerrygligorovic9758]

I hoped in the end of the episode that Pinkie Pie finally told Twilight and the others the truth that she knew that Shining Armour and Cadance were having a baby in the first place because they could have realise Pinkie Pie's strange behaviour and why she was the one who knew the clues to the scavenger hunt.

[@Luna-Hamster]

2:48 Dinky is a mare instead of a filly and a recolor of Trixie.

[@CyberWarezz05]

2:47 no sin for the mare with Derpy's colors and Trixie's mane?

[@sparklemaggie1584]

She was purple, not grey

[@RebekahSmithChildofGod7]

That mare also looked Trixie.

[@stubbsy008]

Littleshyfm you shoud make these episode's the first and last day of the month

[@angryguy9000]

Littleshy didn't commit to the running joke of sinning the castle as seen during the intro. +1 Sin.

[@LittleshyFiM]

I had the castle sin; I only use the theme when it's not featured prominently in the episode.

[@HandheldGamer1991]

That cadence horn scene....why did you show me that o_O

[@franciscotapia9682]

Hack:you have been hacked 0:14 most of them are on the other side *+1* 0:18 one of the small horses is riding a dangerious reptile *+25* 0:33 in other words, carrying the letter at all times in an enclosed space *+2* 0:37 i thought this was the nightmarish visual *+44* 1:10 i hate that pun, and i'm a walking axe *+3* 1:34 THIS JOKE AGAIN?! *+33* 2:37 that guy is obviously not Fluttershy guy, since he has the exact same character design as Fliterfloosh, except with the face replaced by a shy guy mask *+47* 2:54 and she's a reused skin of rariry *+1* 3:12 THERE ARE NO UMANS IN THIS TERRITORY *+1463* 4:02 phew, now this unfunny joke won't be contaminating other episodes anytime soon *minus1* 4:09 tv tropes thing *+193* and the balloons aren't scary *+7* 4:50 this joke again? *+84* ?:?? And now an extra sin because this filler episode was teasing a major surpirse that by the time season 6 came, it wasn't a surprise *+1* Episode sin tally:1,942 Sentence:arrested for trying to ruin The haltin days

[@CrystalKitty1220]

-Why are you uploading this late at night I- -was about to have a decent night sleep--

[@EnigmaticEntity335]

"Why not let the friends in on the secret?" Yes. You literally have someone who is KIND enough not to share it to Twilight, someone who would GENEROUSly decline sharing it, someone who is LOYAL enough not to, and someone who would be HONEST in keeping the secret.

[@NonAnimusJodendi6190]

"""""""""""""""""LOYAL""""""""""""""""" 😹😹😹😹😹😹😹

[@jennieallen616]

This didn't make it to 40 sins, that's a sin

[@fatalwaffle1715]

Cool Video Bro!

[@voltrici]

Dude... it's pinkie pie... she can even disasemble her entire body...

[@lisaf053]

Ah, this episode. Revealing Shining Armor and Cadance going to have the Princess of Merchindise.

[@camiblack1]

Oh Rarity knew, but she'd been waiting for this chance for four seasons.

[@littleartfloof]

I need more of these episodes, they're too great 😅

[@desmolboi4049]

1:11 did nobody notice that pinkie's right eye lost its color when she pops out of the chest?

[@glaceongirlakasusie4961]

Book horse(twilight sparkle): I’m going to be an aunt! Editor: proceed to turn twilight into an ANT.

[@izrosegold]

1:47 Headcanon accepted

[@Edward256]

Raises hand! Also, remember when Pinkie was at Twilight for keeping secrets? Tables have turned. Not so easy, is it? ;)

[@skypeters3034]

Imagine how funny it would be if Featherweight the mayor and pinkie freaked out together idk

[@jesse4658]

2:47 is a trixie recolour

[@maggie_knolastname]

Could someone explain the headcanon they were referring to?

[@rosanafalcao4038]

"You won’t even find this level of pointless randomness in a KZbin Poop" "YoUtUbE pOoP, yOuTuBe IS pOop" *Ding!*

[@xxevilcottonxx6601]

1:42 I like the second option more

[@MunchKING]

1:30 Man Rarity can hold a grudge from all the way back in Green is Not Your Color. :p Pinkie Pie did that exact thing back then.

[@Izzy_editzzROBLOX]

Maybe the reason it did that to applejack size on the birth certificate photo is because photos do something too baby ponies eyes which makes them look more…. Oh you know what I mean

[@Dumpling_On_Pawz7096]

Applejack: I don’t like where this is going Me: the heck is wrong with that eye

[@humanfromthesolarsystempla3143]

SHE KNOWS

[@_.SpaghettiMuffins._]

39 sins *insert spitfires catchphrase*

[@shadowunikat849]

0:14 there might be more platters...

[@Luxxorella]

39 sins is a sin itself

[@mythicalcane7935]

And at sin 22, a recolored trixie

[@CorynWarriorKitty]

2:47 this pony reminds me of Rapunzel from Tangled. Even more so because her cutie mark is a flower

[@batzdites]

2:59 Sin: Why does she have a random apple just stored in her mane? Wouldn't she just store a cupcake? Did she really go to Sweet Apple Acres and snag a random apple and think " Eh, I'll eat this later. "??

[@Oggie_rumperoo]

2:39 *why did I keep replaying this and laughing?*

[@cishthefishcat]

Im so surprised cuz I didnt even get the notification!

[@kai_lopez9855]

Who else still watching the mlp series even tho it ended ill show my kids this show tell them how legendary this show is.

[@SleepyWhistles]

Well they all are ponies. So yeah they don't need a health inspector.

[@pen_cap4967]

4:40 yes finally

[@divedweller4295]

That's not Rarity shattering headcannon. That's cold, calculating mockery.

[@wahwahwahhhhh]

Glad to know that you’ll be making sins videos -f̶o̶r̶e̶v̶e̶r̶- until June 2029 :)

[@Pony-Potential]

Love it as always, really helped out my stressful day. But it's always bugged me since this ep aired that...in MY opinion, it started to get a little too close to a sexual undertone. Maybe it's just me but, with all the baby references plus other things I thought "someones only a few words away from a TV PG rating".

[@travissmith2848]

Anybody else found themselves trying to calculate how many cupcakes there really were? I gave up, but with 7 on the first tier, 12 on the next, seven total tires, and each larger than the last I think 100 would be kind of lowball, but nowhere near 567.

[@akishalexiedelossantos2258]

This was posted on my birthday😄😄😄🎊🎊🎊🎉🎉🎉🍰🍰🍰

[@fromthethirdplanet]

Nothing about the Derpy baby?

[@blobbertmcblob4888]

These horses keep referring to their young as "babies" when the only word for what to call their young should be "foal" *Ding*

[@Wissle]

When I first saw the episode I REALLY hoped the remane5 would think from Pinkie's odd behavior that SHE got pregnant. Imagine the hilarity that could ensue from that, like WHO'S THE FATHER etc. But I guess that obvious sideplot was too mature for the show, unfortunately.

[@sparklemaggie1584]

Ya..

[@dookiehonestreaction]

What are u talking about