Patek Philippe Nautilus vs Nautilus 5712/1A-001 Moonphase vs Annual Calendar 5726/1A-001

[@AbdulRWatches]

Two unobtainable grail watches right now, but the 5712 is my choice from the both.

[@scotts1409]

I chose the 5726 because of the beautiful symmetry, and the classic Patel annual calendar.

[@rodneydanger543]

Holy crap. It’s hard to fathom just how impressive these Patek’s are until you see them on the wrist. Gorgeous!

[@zetoch]

Great idea to compare those two pieces. On paper they look very similar, but in the metal it’s a different story. Excellent job Tim, as always.

[@damachine3]

3:59 Not just a blue dial with the new 5726/1A-014, but a very cool blue to black gradient dial. It fades to black as you approach the periphery of the dial. VERY cool. I just bought the 5726A-001 (black dial with leather and polymer straps) from my dealer and he's on the case to get me the 5726/1A-014 (I love the blue to black gradient dial and the steel bracelet). Can't go wrong with any of the 5726 pieces--especially if you are getting them at retail price from an AD!

[@polo32892]

I have both; but I like the thinness and elegance of the 5712.

[@robertosanchez4021]

I'm fortunate enough to have both and both are great everyday watches... by far more comfortable than the AP Royal Oak

[@graemescott470]

Love them both but I slightly prefer the 5726 . But more sporty but still sophisticated

[@fozzyarb]

Love both...have both but the white dial version of the 5726. Both are simply amazing! Great review.

[@stevelee8437]

I was just lucky enough to get the 5726. Love it! I didn’t get a choice, but I would have chosen the same anyway. Great reviews! Keep up the good work.

[@ashkanentesari2254]

Steve Lee nice! Were you able to get it new or preowned?

[@alexandresmirnov9153]

Great video and explanation. My favourite is a 5712. Hope to see pro video like yours. Good good job. Thank you

[@ayoolaonajide5094]

I am fortunate to have the 5712 and it’s a fantastic watch. The jury is still out for me as I think I prefer the micro rotor . I also have the 5205G with the larger rotor with the same movement as the 5726 and I had problems of misalignment within the window just within 2 years of ownership.

[@brokebikemtb4448]

As I just purchased the 5726 .......I'll say not even a competition....5726 for the win....higher beat rate ...newer complication annual calendar....edit 110k boys 5726 for the win

[@pete6705]

Tough call, but I think I give the edge to 5726

[@Stevah00]

I was so disappointed when my brother told me that the 5726 -014 had a waiting list, of several years. It is not holy but a true grail watch.

[@tonya5389]

5712 has the edge 👌

[@ratdammooo]

5712 for its thinness

[@MrLSB4ever]

5726 on bracelet best nautilus combo.

[@bossdefender8037]

Great comparison, Tim! 🙂 But is there any logical reason for Patek to use pins instead of screws?

[@MC-dh3my]

Nice idea to put the two watches one on the other and let them feel the steel

[@BossHugo84]

5726 THE MOST PERFECT WATCH EVER MADE TO ME !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@DavidDatura]

Those pre-owned price premiums (a triple P rhyme! 😁) are absolutely crazy! And it’s odd that the lume on one is so much brighter than the other. As for which to choose? That’s so difficult I can’t actually decide. Mind you, if I had the means to purchase the one, I’d likely have the means to purchase the two! Which is what I’d do (another little rhyme).

[@andrei2023]

My winner is 5712🥇

[@MARKO2465]

5726 for me....5712 too much happening on that small dial.

[@iZacq]

Very nice review 👌🏻 Are they just Full Steel or are the screws in white gold, like in AP watch I like design of Patek Philippe 👍🏻

[@jman600lt]

I love my 5712 but I dont mind the 5726

[@highnrising]

The 5726, no contest. It's a great watch. The 5712 is missing the hour indicators for 4, 5 and 7 o'clock--due to the two sub-dials. Sorry, that's a design defect. It never should have been made like that.

[@tygaz3061]

so happy just received my 5712/1a with a beautiful blue dial. i ordered it and got it in 3 months... when i got the call i was like holy shit!! anyway.... i coulda gotten the 5711 but i think its to plain... compared to 5726 i like the 12 cause of thin case and light weight.. imho

[@para_bellum_1984]

God I wish I could put that 5726 on my grail list. It is the summary of everything I love about Patek. But then you notice the grey market prices. I don't even want to know the AD wait list for first time Patek customers.

[@danny77670000]

5726 for me 👍🏻👏🏻

[@mlamesq8]

The one the AD puts you on the list for is the one to choose.

[@DanteMiami]

I prefer the 5726 (especially with the new blue dial) for the same reasons, though the 5712 would fit me better and has that micro-rotor!

[@williamstalvey6920]

Must be an incredible watch, I am a huge fan of divers watches with a bezel but certainly would love to become more knowledgeable about this fine product.

[@carljosephbuca2070]

Why are the pre-owned more expensive than brand new??

[@timeisahumanconstruct9251]

it's a supply issue. patek has selective allocation practices.

[@kevorknourian5442]

Awesome show and watch

[@tygaz3061]

definitely 5712... i think its the best of the nautilus line... even the 5711... yeah i know... 5711 bec of the simplicity and symmetry.... yadda yadda yadda.... BORING...

[@tucordes]

I own the 5726

[@craig2100]

Simple....buy both

[@bekind1784]

5726 me...not even close

[@محمدحسين-ر2ي1ب]

5712

[@Diirk]

5712 is too thin, it looks unimpressively flat, just like a jumbo, so I take the 5726

[@giovannipasa8264]

sicuramente 5726.....più armonico, più presente al polso e più moderno....il 5712 acciaio quadrante troppo affollato e troppo leggero (lo preferisco in oro bianco o rosa...)

[@yuribonalumi8053]

Non mi piace ne uno ne l' altro. Con quei soldi do l' acconto per una casa porca eva!!😁😄😄👍

[@SLSAMG]

I will never understand the appeal of a posh watch. Incredibly superficial people will delude themselves into calling it "an art".

[@ChrisBoulas]

Explain what's not artistic about it?