Patrick Mahomes not ranked unanimous No. 1 QB, Dak and Rodgers, Purdy a snub? | FIRST THINGS FIRST

Nick Wright, Chris Broussard and Kevin Wildes look at the recent Top 10 NFL QB rankings and react to Patrick Mahomes not being ranked No. 1, Dak Prescott at No. 10 unanimously, Aaron Rodgers ranked eighth and whether Brock Purdy being snubbed out of the rankings.
#FirstThingsFirst #NFL #PatrickMahomes
SUBSCRIBE to get the latest from First Things First: foxs.pt/Subscri...
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: tinyurl.com/y4...
►Watch the latest content from First Things First: foxs.pt/Latest...
▶ The Carton Show's KZbin channel: sprtspod.fox/Su...
▶ The Herd with Colin Cowherd’s KZbin channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
► UNDISPUTED’s KZbin channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
► Speak's KZbin channel: sprtspod.fox/SU...
► The Skip Bayless Show KZbin channel: sprtspod.fox/SU...
► What's Wright? with Nick Wright KZbin channel: sprtspod.fox/wh...
See more from First Things First: foxs.pt/FIRSTTH...
Like First Things First on Facebook: foxs.pt/FIRSTTH...
Follow First Things First on Twitter: foxs.pt/FIRSTTH...
Follow First Things First on Instagram: foxs.pt/FIRSTTH...
Follow Nick Wright on Twitter: foxs.pt/NickWri...
Follow Chris Broussard on Twitter: / chris_broussard
Follow Kevin Wildes on Twitter: foxs.pt/KevinW...
About First Things First:
Nick Wright, Chris Broussard, and Kevin Wildes team up on First Things First. The trio offers their take on a bevy of sports stories alongside special guests from across the sports world.
Patrick Mahomes not ranked unanimous No. 1 QB, Dak and Rodgers, Purdy a snub? | FIRST THINGS FIRST
• Patrick Mahomes not ra...
First Things First
/ firstthingsfirst

[@FirstThingsFirst]

Check out the All Facts No Brakes podcast: link.chtbl.com/AllFactsPodYT

[@brandonjones6622]

1-3

[@Tisoy-xh4ok]

The hate on Brock is incredible. For sure better than Herbert Dak and Stroud. Top 5 IMO ‼️‼️

[@NafisFoster]

Patty mahomboy mvp15 💪🏿🫡 that guy

[@justinczech1489]

"NO! Do NOT show the Purdy graphics!" We are so back folks

[@JayRose619]

😂😂

[@ILLBNSANITY]

My thoughts exactly 💯😂💯

[@DuvalPioneer]

FTF fans unite.

[@paulbrusuelas6706]

I'm here at work, "listening" to this on youtube about to get fired cause I laughed too loud - we are so back🤣

[@williamd1891]

God it's so good to be back. Off season sucks.

[@dw6786]

I’m always reminded how much I love this show by these long breaks 😂😂

[@4evareallive]

I was 🤧 sick

[@antvarner7950]

Seriously!

[@brockaustin1018]

Yeap

[@ramsesflores7904]

I feel like they have had back to back breaks

[@poohbron]

I be sick when I find out they on break.

[@williamallen7984]

It’s funny how Nick always said Purdy is somewhere between 12-15th in the league and Brou calls him a hater…but Brou is fine with him at 11 😂

[@thomasdascombe4939]

It’s because Brou completely agrees (as anyone logically would) but the show needs the argument dynamic

[@judshuttie70]

No it's not ranking it's way they talk about the player, brou says he's 10 but tells truth Brock has been great but needs to do it longer and he's still young and can improve he also says if he does it again then he will move him up nick on other hand diminished everything Brock does and talks about why Brock will regress see the difference ranking might be similar but why and how they talk about him is totally different.

[@robertadams305]

​@@judshuttie70 Nick and his fans are 2D. Their brains work like a light switch: either on or off. Your explanation is good, but it won't help them.

[@justingabriel1765]

Well yeah, ranking where they are before the season Vs when they are playing during the season is different stuff

[@ShadeXH]

@@judshuttie70 Yeah but the substance is still the same. Basically the same ranking and both are saying, in different ways, that they gotta see more before they believe. It really comes back to how they both felt about Jimmy G lol. One thought he was good and one thought he was propped up by the system

[@brody6392]

The fact that this shows is still so entertaining in July is crazy

[@thenoseknows9391]

It's entertaining cause they gel like no other sports show 💯💯👍🏽👍🏽😅😃🤣🤣😁😄

[@carlossaenz7485]

Comedians. It is a good laugh..

[@704jizzle2]

What has Herbert done to get that high

[@Noahdventure]

Ball out

[@erictempleton7703]

​@Noahdventure stop Herbert's 30 - 32 in his career. And that's with top-tier skill players. Justin herbert is the next Phillip Rivers.

[@Noahdventure]

@@erictempleton7703 he’s also scored the most points of any team over his 4 years. Defense sells.

[@Noahdventure]

The people who scout for a living have him at 6

[@alexs3224]

@@erictempleton7703you know it's 11 on 11 not 1 v 11 right? Herbert is way better than he looks cause the chargers are waaaaayyyyyy worse I don't miss a chargers game and he's the only reason the win column is double digits at all

[@donovan4222]

Joe Burrow really still riding off that hype from his team beating the chiefs like 3 years ago

[@fyilando854]

name a QB better on that list besides Mahomes…

[@matthewwilliams4168]

@fyilando854 all 31 other starters are better than burrow if burrow can't stay fit

[@fyilando854]

@@matthewwilliams4168delusional…

[@donovan4222]

@@fyilando854 Lamar and Allen for sure, the rest are arguable

[@matthewwilliams4168]

@fyilando854 the best ability is availability

[@WordsMatter1982]

Brou "Having Purdy at 11 is criminal!" Nick: "So where do you have him?" Brou: "10th!"

[@kenkaneki1522]

I mean realistically he’s top 5

[@soda8736]

Chris don't wan to stand 10 toes on Purdy

[@jeradlarkey390]

@@kenkaneki1522 In what world? Maybe top 10, maybe.

[@kenkaneki1522]

@@jeradlarkey390 his stats literally speak for themselves… you can penalize him for him good players. CJ stroud has 3 Numebr 1 WRs with mixon as his RB and some how he’s better?😂

[@jeradlarkey390]

@@kenkaneki1522 Oh come on...the 49ers, with a worse team than what Brock inherited took Jimmy G to the superbowl. Jimmy is barely a back up now. And yes CJ is better than Purdy. What we saw with CJ is what we would have seen had Mahomes actually played his rookie season. I like Brock don't get me wrong, but he will be playing under the shadow of the talent around him until they start dropping those pieces and give him a true contract.

[@jiggahov2]

If The Prince had the same numbers and record as Purdy, Nick would be glazing so hard

[@jeffsamuels2539]

Lmao I was looking for this. They told me he was Andrew Luck.. I see Mark Brunnell

[@Electric_Croc]

They told me he was supposed to be Peyton Manning 2.0 and i believed them 😂

[@jayceh]

Yes because his team was not good Anyone taking that roster to a Superbowl would be insane. Mahomes-esque maybe even.

[@jeffsamuels2539]

@@jayceh he’s got a roster and he’s part of the problem.

[@jayceh]

@@jeffsamuels2539 so without a QB, he's got the same type of roster as the 9ers? Wow

[@LightningXVI]

If they don't get skips time slot at the end of the summer when he leaves, ima riot fr 🤣

[@Itzyaboijay247]

Ong🤣🤣🤣

[@rakhemseku]

Too early for east coast. They just escaped crazy morning hours.

[@ajseker]

@@rakhemseku9:30 Est is the start, idk if that’s too early

[@futureisaiah96]

@@rakhemsekuthis doesn’t make any sense. The time slot is earlier on the west coast… it would be later on the east coast…

[@shaunsteele4968]

They're getting an extra half hour I read today. I don't think undisputed is leaving. Just skip.

[@matthewwilliams4168]

Mahomes is 100 times ahead of number 2

[@pbrown0829]

Better but not a 100 times

[@matthewwilliams4168]

@@pbrown0829 it's probably more like 500

[@JohnDavis_90]

1000

[@amaeletcheu9702]

As an eagles fan it’s absolutely right

[@cjfrm3658]

​@@matthewwilliams4168 Nobody's arguing that

[@DriftEntry101]

Finally! My routine felt so weird without this trio making me laugh Monday to Friday 😅

[@RandomCitizen014]

These guys could talk about grass growing and I’d happily watch

[@annierushing4796]

Couldn't pay me to watch Brou.

[@SovietAssault69]

​@@annierushing4796seriously. Guy has the annoying tone of Stephen A and the bad takes of Colin Cowherd

[@jsmithers.]

​@@annierushing4796🤡

[@christophercluster728]

Herbert at 6 is crazy.

[@Noahdventure]

Probs too low, he’s top 5

[@vainexp3481]

Exactly

[@mrsaving6285]

@@Noahdventure I want what you're smokling!

[@aidonis98]

I've not seen a more overvalued quarterback in forever. Jesus Christ. The guy had a monster rookie season, and has been above average since.

[@rockjm9876543210]

They're in love with his talent and size

[@BeastMode-zo6yy]

Joe Burrow 2? What??? This guy has been hurt 3 of the last 4 years

[@neromusic138]

If Burrow is healthy he’s the second best in the league

[@vainexp3481]

Exactly

[@Harris-Walz2024]

Because he shouldn't be in the top 10

[@neromusic138]

@@Harris-Walz2024 the only players that are guaranteed top 3 QBs are Mahomes, Allen, and burrow

[@wtfarley95]

Apparently if you take the Bengals to the SB, you're top 3 forever 😂

[@edgybravo4287]

sleeping on hurts and purdy just watch

[@maxsteel32]

Just Purdy

[@travesotom6890]

Purdy only 😂

[@connorsmith6517]

Hurts has had 1 good season in his career, and you could put 15QBs on the 49ers and they’d have similar success. If you put an elite QB on the 49ers they win the Super Bowl. Purdy played pretty average throughout the playoffs. Look up his stats, and watch the game. He was good/okay. He’s in the 12-15 range tops.

[@keitht24]

​@@connorsmith6517Delusion at it's finest. Purdy literally made clutch play after clutch play in the playoffs. As for the Superbowl. Last time I checked, it wasn't Purdy fumbling the Ball twice to takeaway a scoring opportunity & give the Chiefs points. That was McCaffrey & the punt returner.

[@ThisGuyDrives]

@@keitht24 Purdy also didn't march down the field in OT. Purdy got saved on a 3rd down in OT with a corner holding call that gave him free downs to still fail. He was on a superior rostered team, still lost to a Mahomes lead team with subpar WR's and yet he still marched down that field in OT and won the game, clutch.

[@Fhill4801]

Herbert higher than 10 is wild

[@codywirth8190]

Tell me the QB in the history of the NFL that overcame the 25th ranked scoring D and bottom bin coaching. I'll wait.

[@mikellbull]

Facts

[@Klingles]

​@@codywirth8190 If we're building logic around ifs and buts, Brock Purdy should be number two on this list since the only thing holding him back is everyone's ifs and buts about him being bad on any other team.

[@jakejones8032]

@@codywirth8190 Overcame the D and coaching to what end? A playoff loss? Well congrats Herbert, you have accomplished nothing.

[@oocharmin10]

Thank you for telling me you’re a casual

[@davidcobb1379]

Why is Rodgers on this list?

[@virgil7272]

same reason burrow is #2 despite not finishing more seasons than starting

[@Jp-do9ny]

Because he's a 4x MVP

[@dariusewing6962]

HE WHITE

[@fisherfoster6032]

@@Jp-do9nyhow does that help him this season?

[@PhilAndersonOutside]

Same reason Herbert is. Wait, Rodgers has actually won a heap of big games, playoff games, and a Super Bowl.

[@akaBPhife]

Nick always gets me with his Brock Purdy slander!

[@annierushing4796]

nick born wrong

[@ThisGuyDrives]

@@annierushing4796 the SB says otherwise. He failed to lead his team down the OT field after given 3 free plays after a corner holding call. He also had the superior roster on offense. Couldn't get it done. Mahomes got it done with his worst offense ever.

[@annierushing4796]

@@ThisGuyDrives go away

[@breezeyouttahere9801]

@@ThisGuyDrivesshut up clown

[@maesonsims6885]

@@ThisGuyDrivesdude he helped give his team the lead 3 times and walked off the field the last time with the lead. How on earth is it his fault they lost

[@joeymorini7685]

I legit laughed out loud when brou started the purdy segment early😂

[@robertadams305]

Pre-emptive strike. Saw the kaiju (Nick) coming, and George Bushed the button.

[@Fonziggy]

I honestly don’t know how Herbert keeps getting on theses lists

[@jg7102]

Because hes a no doubt top 10 QB. Its not close.

[@unsolicitedditkapics9722]

Name and basically name alone

[@Klingles]

He has done absolutely nothing to prove he's a top 10 QB except get drafted in the first round.

[@KyleMacSkill]

​@Klingles if mahomes had brandon Staley as a coach and that chargers defense no chance he has a SB. Not saying Herbert is as good as Mahomes but he has definitely been held back by his coach and defense

[@PhilAndersonOutside]

He has a lot of potential, and he always will. Even if that's all he's ever shown, and all he ever has.

[@johnchapman7973]

Everyone's trippin, Purdy is easily top 5

[@jikan-tabi-1888]

Mahomes, Burrow, Purdy, Stafford and Goff are the only active starting QBs to play in the last 6 SBs from the top 10 list. No Purdy? A NFCCG and SB. Huh?

[@Reclaimer77]

Goff was overrated even WHEN he went to the SuperBowl, one he didn't show up for. Now? He doesn't belong at #9 that's just crazy.

[@htdubski23]

Brock Purdy isn’t top 15

[@joshprout1726]

Hurts didn’t just play in a Super Bowl?

[@mattthomas1442]

@@Reclaimer77 4 Pro Bowls in his 6 healthy seasons. Took 2 long time losing franchises to division championships within 2 seasons of being a starter, last 2 years the ONLY QB to throw for over 9000 yards, has 60TD passes, thrown the fewest interceptions, is 16-6 against playoff opponents and 2 dropped passes and a ball bouncing off a CB's facemask away from taking yet another franchise to the Super Bowl. If anything he is underrated cause he had 2 bad years in LA where he wasn't seeing eye to eye with his HC.

[@erikdayne5429]

I totally agree. Jimmy G should be top 10 because he’s been to a Super Bowl and an NFCCG. Great point.

[@dwes6447]

These guys take more vacation than Aaron Rodgers

[@tannerarmstrong1496]

I don't see any arguments for Joe Burrow being a top 3 that couldn't be applied to Brock Purdy even more so. I think this means we're probably giving Burrow too much credit and not giving enough credit to Brock Purdy. They should probably be next to eachother at positions 5 and 6.

[@htdubski23]

😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@peterlevis4130]

I thought for the first time ever my kings would get a segment dedicated to them cus they got demar derozan and the boys go on vacation😭

[@Wayfarer17683]

Purdy disrespected and Rodgers given too much respect

[@sketchychoppersociety2448]

Roger's in no way is a top 10 QB .. Purdy is a top 10.. Herbert has done nothing..

[@codywirth8190]

Herbert took over a roster that Rivers got fired with a smashed records meanwhile having no coaching, the 25th ranked scoring D, mangled bodyparts, revolving pieces on offense and cherry on top no actual homefield advantage. He's a phenom and Harbough is gonna show you why this year.

[@lukeoldfield7608]

I’ve been having first things first withdrawals, thank god they’re back🙌

[@blakeharris58]

The 49ers are 4-2 with Purdy. The Cowboys are 2-5 with Dak.

[@annierushing4796]

so. dak insu purdys problem

[@soda8736]

And Purdy didn't even really play one of the losses

[@Bongaveli]

Because the 49ers have a better team, management and ownership. Put Purdy on last year’s Cowboys, with the Cowboys coaching staff, and they probably don’t make the playoffs. What Dak does to cover the cowboys warts has always been grossly downplayed.

[@lagodifuoco313]

Regular season.

[@Dreamwunder]

@@Bongaveliyou don;t know that don’t speak speculation as a fact. Cowboys had the most pro bowlers this year too but ok DAK keeps failing but Purdy literally put up comeback victory in playoff against GB, biggest NFC half time deficit in History of NFL and went to OT against Mahomes and literally left the field after getting the lead EVERY TIME and if defense held once they win. But sure instead of seeing what actually happened, let’s just speculate purdy on most pro bowl team cowboys with Ceedee better WR than anyone on SF he wont even make playoff lmao

[@GameTimeKnox]

Burrows is the most over rated qb ever man quit it

[@Mysterio-Solar]

This list is literal fantasy . Brock Purdy Literally was QBR Champ , was Top 5 in every signicant passing Category , and led in the MVP All last season . He had the Best Passing Completions Percentage over 20 30 40 yard passes . He has led SF to a 15 Point per Game improvement . He went to 2 NFC Title Games , and a SB in the last two seasons . Dak literally had Stats Vs mostly losing Teams compared to Brock beating Winning Teams with Top Defenses . Brock hung 42 points on Philly and Dallas . Here's The REAL List 1 Mahomes 2 Purdy 3 Burrow 4 Hurts 5 Allen 6 Stafford 7 Jackson 8 Stroud 9 Goff 10 Love 11 Cousins 12 Prescott 13 Lawrence 14 Mayfield 15 Rodgers

[@jgould30]

Purdy deserves top 10 by numbers and success. Simple.

[@connorsmith6517]

Jimmy G threw for 4,000 yards, 27TDs to 13INTs and led the Niners to the Super Bowl. Should he have been a top 10 QB? He was top 7-8 when it came to statistics and team success. Highest winning percentage ever. Obviously not. Purdy is a solid QB, but he caps out at 12-15

[@terrythegnome2408]

@@connorsmith6517 Jimmy also had the number 1 defense in the league and a top 10 o line. Purdy had the 13th ranked defense and the 22nd ranked o line. Try again.

[@T-H-E-WORLD]

@@connorsmith6517Jimmy was ok but nobody in San Fran thought he was top tier. There was no argument to be made for Jimmy. There is def an argument for Purdy. Watch the games…

[@bolo34lx]

I'd replace Herbert for Purdy. He may be talented but he hasn't produced in the regular season or the playoffs.

[@Travolta12e]

Put Herbert in this stacked 49ers roster and they would've won like 3 rings by now

[@codywirth8190]

Takes a defense to win consistently, numb balls. 25th ranked scoring D since he took over. Tell me the QB in history that overcame that consistently I'll wait.

[@av2018]

@Travolta12e try again because Herbert would destroy the team with his selfishness. He and Josh Allen would take away McCaffrey’s touchdowns by throwing and diving in, respectively.

[@aroperdope]

​@@av2018he didn't take away Austin eckler's production

[@aheroictaxidriver3180]

Goff below Rodgers is ludicrous.

[@terrythegnome2408]

Goff had the best o line in the league last year, it’s no coincidence all of a sudden Goff is good, what happened when got pressured in the championship game? HE CANT THROW ON THE RUN.

[@aheroictaxidriver3180]

@@terrythegnome2408 Just compare the numbers from 2022 and 2023. Who won the last time they played each other?

[@terrythegnome2408]

@@aheroictaxidriver3180 Rodgers aint great either at this point. Neither belong in the top ten.

[@kevinragland6307]

Man y'all better put some respect on Purdy. He's a dawg man! 💯

[@914bub]

Most important stat for a QB is playoff wins. Dak lacks tremendously in that category.

[@drdream2095]

So does a lot of QBs

[@b.r3228]

I agree. Sherbert shouldn't be top 10 either.

[@JS-bn4vx]

Ok then Lamar shouldn’t be so high. He’s cheeks in the playoffs every single year

[@914bub]

@@JS-bn4vx agreed

[@oofspoof]

I don’t understand how Dak is ahead of Purdy when he’s had YEARS with a great roster and hasn’t made a title game, while Purdy has done it the first two years of his career and embarrassed the Cowboys in the process

[@RedMage117]

I'm not a Dak fan but to be fair...Purdy is on one of the most loaded rosters in the league

[@oofspoof]

@@RedMage117 Purdy has a better RB and TE while Dak has a better #1 receiving option and offensive line. Although I’m not saying Dak has as good a supporting cast, he’s played with prime zeke, consistently top tier tight ends, and a top three receiver in CeeDee

[@terrythegnome2408]

@@oofspoof also what is most important in terms of qb play on average, and NO ONE mentions is that the 49ers o line ranked 24th in pass protection last year and the cowboys were a top 5-8. I think people assume if you have the best left tackle your o line is good but there are 5 guys there and all of them are mid and washouts from other teams.

[@michaelwallace2487]

Thats 'a false narrative in my opinion. Purdy is on a stacked team with a genius as a head coach. I don't believe in hero ball. It's a team sport and you're only as good as your roster. Dak plays as well as he can with less. The Niners are loaded AT EVERY POSITION; THE COWBOYS ARE LOADED IN A FEW POSITIONS. That is a fact. This false narrative that the Cowboy's have a top 5 roster is a lie spread by the NFL, sports media, the Jones boys, and some fans--especially Dak haters--to increase excitement per game. A Batman movie can only work, if Batman, as a protagonist, is equal to his antagonist, the Joker. If not, the movies don't work. So, being so popular, the Cowboys are hyped up. The Cowboys haven't had a top 5 roster in 7-8 years. They're top 10, but not top 5. Their owners are cheap; they create nothing but drama to increase the worth of the team; they create distractions to maintain popularity; they willfully create headlines to keep the team relevant, and to keep their product in the news. Haven't you figured that out yet? I am absolutely convinced dragging their feet to pay their players this year, is a marketing ploy to keep them in the news. It's a marketing maneuver, and a tool to keep making millions. That's what 10 billion dollar entertainment companies do, and football is an entertainment! Why do the Cowboys play Thanksgiving Day every year? Marketing! Who came up with having the Cowboy Cheerleaders? The Cowboys. Why? Marketing! They’ve forgotten the most important thing: the product itself, and to field the best team possible. The Niners, Lions, Eagles, Packers, Ravens, Chiefs, Bills and Dolphins--all superior rosters--have not.

[@terrythegnome2408]

@@michaelwallace2487 every position? Their o line is bottom third of the league. Turns out there are 5 guys on the line not just left tackle! Weird. Can you name anyone else on their O line? Get Purdy a decent pass pro unit and he will dominate the league. Best accuracy from a clean pocket in nfl history, problem is he gets a clean pocket 6 - 8% of his dropbacks.

[@cpt_vi3w547]

Someone is clearly a Mahomes hater. Salty Buffalo fan

[@av2018]

No doubt PM15 is living rent free in dude’s head.

[@Sirharryflash82]

13 seconds. I remember seeing an old NFL Films video of Gale Sayers saying "give me 16 inches of daylight"... they need one of Mahomes saying "give me 13 seconds and I'll rip your heart out"...

[@Ninjachickenfingers]

Good to have the crew back 😂

[@1995Corey]

Pat Mahomes is still number 1 QB to me

[@andrerandall7873]

@@1995Corey duh

[@jcf4074]

Controversial

[@chuckleezodiac24]

the Earth is still round to me.

[@gregallen5966]

I'm taking Brock Purdy over Aaron Rodgers and Dak Prescott.

[@thekidsavage4511]

Call burrow the big hurt

[@justadude1065]

“Big hurt” yet has more conference championship and SB appearances than every other AFC QB combined not named mahomes since Burrow entered the league. So yes please make a stronger argument to further prove he’s the 2nd best QB in football.

[@skinnymelo]

@@justadude1065 Carried by a historic defense and choked in the SB. Carr has a SB appearance too, let’s put him top 5. Thinking 1 season of Burrow’s team succeeding with him not even being the most important factor, makes him clear number 2, and that too 3 seasons later is truly hilarious. Inside the mind of a Bengals fan.

[@justadude1065]

@@skinnymelo he’s a top 3 QB. All that cryin yoire doin doesn’t change that at all. You’re a casual mouth breather though so your lack of football IQ doesn’t surprise me. Y’all are always the loudest in the comment section and always want your ignorance to heard because the issue is you’re unable to understand said ignorance when you speak it and type it.

[@AZTUC_520]

Hurts at 4 is crazy. He'll be traded next off season.

[@carterallen8018]

They had a list of 10 quarterbacks in front of them, and they proceeded to spend the whole segment talking about the only 3 qbs they ever talk about. Genuinely glad to have the show back though.

[@Tha_Trigga]

well theres not a lot of disagreement so it makes no sense to discuss.

[@kangaroocourt9507]

I'm watching rn and they are talking about Herbert Dak and Rogers.

[@Waliocoolioflo]

This show has slowly turned into the equivalent of Skip & Shannon's Lebron v Brady everyday argument

[@kivngken]

I’m sorry but can someone tell me what the hype is for Herbert ? For him to be ahead of all these guys with playoff wins and Super Bowl appearances?

[@Shlooboo]

He is a beast. The guy carries the Chargers sorry defense. Just watch a Chargers game and you will see why.

[@jg7102]

Because football is not a 1v1 sport. This should make sense to most but somehow it doesn’t.

[@kivngken]

@@jg7102 if that’s the case then Tom Brady isint the best QB ever in your logic

[@PhilAndersonOutside]

He has a lot of potential. And he always will. Even if that's all he ever shows, and all he ever has.

[@Shadow-vd8ss]

@@kivngkenthis is very valid take. Brady in the playoffs has actually not been very good over his whole career. Ironically, his best performance by far was in a loss to the eagles

[@AnthonyTaylorJr210]

Dak being 10 as a 4th round pick is an awesome accomplishment. I am not giving out participation trophies, I just think sometimes it gets over looked that he was a 4th round pick and not a 1st round pick. I also think he would be considered better if he wasn’t on a team that had championship aspirations every year. Dak takes a hit for being 2-5 in the playoffs for the Cowboys, but the Lamar who has worse numbers in the playoffs, and maybe the same record, is considered wayyy better🤷🏾‍♂️

[@EZR725]

Lol because Lamar has 2 MVPs and only lost to the best QB ever in the AFC Championship last year and not teams like Green Bay 😂. And minus all that he's just clearly the better player

[@gperezniners4949]

Yeah and where was Purdy picked?? And has accomplished more in a year and a half than Dak’s 8 year career

[@AnthonyTaylorJr210]

@@EZR725 I am not saying Dak is better than Lamar. Everyone bases Dak’s ranking on playoff record, and Dak’s stats in the playoffs are better than Lamar, and Dak’s and Lamar record are the same or similar in the playoffs

[@AnthonyTaylorJr210]

@@gperezniners4949 he is number 11 on the list. If you are mad at his placement, remember, I didn’t make the list 😂

[@gperezniners4949]

@@AnthonyTaylorJr210 I know you did not make the list. Just stating the FACTS

[@djshannon16]

All my shows are back and I now have something to listen to for my full 8hr shift mon-fri God is good 💯😭🤣

[@samuelgaona7196]

The thing is, Dak's numbers in the regular season are top 5, and his playoff numbers in the playoffs are top 10, but the 2-5 record ia what makes people say he's 10th or not top 10 at all, doesn't really make sense given Lamar, Love, Stroud, Stffoard, Allen, Burrow, Herbert and Rodgers have losing records or .500 records

[@twiggywiggly]

1.patrick mahomes 2.lamar jackson 3.josh allen 4.joe burrow 5.matt stafford 6.justin herbert 7.aaron rodgers 8.cj stroud 9.jordan love 10.deshawn watson 11.trevor lawrence 12.kirk cousins 13.jared goff 14.dak prescott 15.brock purdy 16.caleb williams

[@Saylin021]

Nick has watched 2 Purdy games and made all of his decisions based on those lol

[@ashishlakhanpal6443]

So why didn’t he make the top ten

[@terrythegnome2408]

​@@ashishlakhanpal6443 cuz execs don't watch football closely. Ask defensive coordinators who Purdy has played against. Spagnola for example. Said Purdy was trashing they zone defense better than anyone he had ever seen. Then CMC fumbled. I assume thats on Purdy. Then Trent Williams had two penalties, also on Purdy probably. Spags said they needed to make up custom plays at halftime, ones they had never practiced before, in order to beat Purdy. Spags probably doesnt know what he's talking about though.

[@user-yq6ly3rb8n]

CJ Stroud may become a top 10 QB but 1 year is not enough. Jordan Love should be in mix, so should Brock Purdy. This list is just an odd list to justify but it's opinion and everyone has one lol.

[@dejntxhee4085]

Watching these guys will turn your head upside down!!

[@danielgalan1920]

The gap between Mahomes & #2 is larger than the gap between #2 & #10.

[@jeffsamuels2539]

👀👀👀👀📠

[@drew5700]

That's a lie

[@donkeyman23]

@@drew5700it’s fkn true mahomes is pretty much considered number one ball all nfl fans meanwhile everyone else fighting for positions 2-10 there is no consensus list after the number one spot

[@drew5700]

@@donkeyman23 nah he's not that much better than those other guys, I would say if this was a drag race mahomes would have a half car lead

[@donkeyman23]

@@drew5700 crazy asf mahomes in that goat convo these dudes are just run of the mill good quarterbacks

[@watcher99999]

As a chiefs fan, Lamar was dissed

[@jdailey01230]

As a Ravens fan, we're used to it.

[@lukeyaple5949]

Chiefs fan as well, and that is absurd. Lamar should be number 2.

[@thomasmicaelcannon7867]

​@@lukeyaple5949facts!

[@jg7102]

Im a die hard ravens fan, as big as it gets. I love Lamar but 2 playoff wins in 6 years. Hes been a no show for us in the post season. I 100% agree with the list.

[@Jp-do9ny]

​@@lukeyaple5949Based on what? He has 1 good playoff performance against a rookie QB. he's the most overrated player of all time

[@vanfisher3613]

Brou: “He’s been hurt two of the last three seasons!” “He has one great year!” …… He was talking about Tua and Hurts….. not Burrow?

[@blkriteouspc]

Purdy should be on the list

[@samsunggamer6661]

Purdy can be on the list when you are ready to pay him 50+ million a year

[@EdTex7643]

😂

[@stackonez7182]

LMFAOOOOOOOOO get lost

[@DennisB-is4mj]

Nawl fr

[@Muzzlecrowe-li9kt]

Lowkey

[@victorcontreras5703]

Herbert, Goff, and Dak ahead of Purdy is laughable

[@annierushing4796]

stafford. and its laughable. this list dont mean squat

[@michaelwallace2487]

Not to me. Purdy's on a stacked team with an offensive guru. Dak's ahead of Purdy and Goff 'cause he's on a less loaded team, yet still played lights out last year. Herbert is the one that laughable.

[@DrTurkMD]

Thank god: my show is back.

[@dioncarter3925]

Why did they come up with the narrative that Joe Burrow is injury prone??? Granted he was hurt last year which was his 4th year, but his first year he was behind the worst o-line in football at the time and got hurt in the pocket.. his 2nd year he made the SB.. & his 3rd year he made the conference championship game…

[@Renegade-kf8fp]

Mahomes is our generation version of Micheal Jordan

[@Truthteller01]

He will and can be beaten like Brady. The psychological factor is strong but can be overcome

[@jg7102]

A gambler who retires early because he couldnt play anymore?

[@dpackerman4203]

Wrong. Mahomes is LeBron. Brady was MJ

[@Dannycuddy]

@@dpackerman4203obviously the opposite. Brady has longevity and counting stats, game is not aesthetic to watch. Mahomes has per game stats i.e. higher peak, game is flashy and aesthetic.

[@dpackerman4203]

@@Dannycuddy true but Brady is still #1 and Mahomes is still #2 just like MJ and LeBron

[@justsaying5633]

Mahomes haters. Mahomes is always getting disrespected because people are mad he’s so good.

[@WWG3802]

True

[@nickpiazza5890]

You're seriously going to argue "Mahomes haters" the man has serious GOAT conversations after less than a decade of football play. Puh-lease dude. Mahomes is NOT disrespected and he's got practically no haters. Come off it.

[@neetrab]

Disrespected?? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Literally at least 99% of ppl have him as #1 on their QB lists. Shut up 🙄🙄🙄

[@dpackerman4203]

@@nickpiazza5890I hate Mahomes 🙋‍♂️

[@neetrab]

@@nickpiazza5890 I can't stand the guy, but that's just me.

[@jacksonklark6119]

We keep forgetting how bad the recievers were for rodgers in 2022

[@troyc7726]

Welcome back !

[@austinking9912]

It’s so nice living in a post Skip world his days of churning troll culture out are over. This show is peak sports talk tv and how it should be.

[@chuckleezodiac24]

lmao. the troll on this show is Skip 2.0.

[@b.r3228]

Haha you serious? Peak sports talk? They literally are the cousin to skip. Nick loves mahomes as skip loves TB. And they both hate Arod which is even funnier. Nick is the next skip. Delusional love and hate towards certain players.

[@GG-wo1yu]

Mahomes needs to be number one by a million miles

[@dariusewing6962]

Taylor swift love helps lol 😂😉

[@deciuswtasby]

Andy Reid and Kelce effect. HOF QB talent with HOF coach and TE

[@Orcwarknoxx]

@@deciuswtasby Delusional. Why didn't they make it to the AFC championship or SB in 2017 and 2016? They had a HoF tight end and HoF coach then. Mahomes elevated the Chiefs when he came to KC.

[@rodneygaston1382]

Mahomes & Jaylen Brown need to open a restaurant called....."EAT THIS"🤣💪🏽

[@RandaPanda.624]

Brou is the only one willing to give Purdy his flowers! Give that man his flowers!!

[@IncogNegroGaming]

How is Burrow ranked above Lamar the MVP when burrow didnt even play the last 7 games AND his backup had comparable stats to when he went down by the end of the season?

[@codywirth8190]

Burrow can go to a SB, Lamar can't. That's why, numb balls.

[@Truthteller01]

He had BETTER stats than Joe

[@codywirth8190]

@@Truthteller01 And Purdy has better stats than both. Guess Purdy is better than them huh?

[@justadude1065]

You really want to debate this? I’d suggest not because you’ll look silly to anyone who isn’t a burrow hater and lamarsexual

[@b.r3228]

That was a lackluster boring mvp season. It wasn't anything special. Had one great game at the end of the season and people gave it to him because they didn't want any of the SF boys to win.

[@andrew9921-]

Burrow is objectively worse than Allen and it isn’t close

[@dariusewing6962]

BOTH TO ME ARE OVERRATED

[@dbmagee21]

Nick is living his best life!

[@Zaknyfein]

I have so missed the look of fear in Nicks eyes whenever someone mentions the "Purdy" word 😂😂😂...17 and 4 seems par excellence at first glance but Purdy just hasn't been around long enough to form a solid opinion, especially as a Hawk's fan...Nick obviously has formed an opinion though! From the first time he needed to evaluate Purdy, the word salad that spewed out of Nick's mouth piqued the curiosity and has been a source of endless amusement ever since! 😂

[@pihermoso11]

Isn't Mahomes gonna be the greatest QB and might surpass Tom Brady? If Purdy is not even top ten, why would Mahomes need to beat him in SB overtime if he was so easy? That would mean Mahomes is not that great because he needed overtime to beat a QB ranked outside of top 10...

[@deebrown9263]

lol because Mahomes isn't going against Purdy he's going against the 49ers defense, a great defense, hope you understand that

[@pihermoso11]

@@deebrown9263 but would Tom Brady need overtime to beat a QB ranked outside top 10 in a Superbowl?

[@blick5511]

Olympic level mental gymnastics

[@thomasb5810]

Nick foles

[@locustron4268]

@@pihermoso11Tom has lost to non top 10 QBs in the Super Bowl, your take is incredibly misinformed and very idiotic. id encourage you to learn the sport before making comments like this, save yourself some embarrassment 😂

[@toheebomotosho1055]

Burrow gets ranked highly because he is the only one to beat mahomes in the playoff’s, he shouldn’t be anywhere near 2

[@Muzzlecrowe-li9kt]

He’s extremely clutch. Really great playoff record. Most of the QBs beneath him can’t compare to that, except Roger’s but burrow can do everything he can do and Roger’s is just old now.

[@av2018]

Using the word ‘clutch’ is a stretch.

[@thegreenerthemeaner]

​@@av2018 Not really. He clutches the grass often since the line can't protect him.

[@justadude1065]

Shouldn’t be anywhere near two? 4,000+ yards and 30+TDs every season he stays healthy, hasn’t had a worse result than the AFC championship game when healthy, CPOTY, NFL history leader in completion percentage, most 400 yard passing games, 500 yard passing games than any QB in their first 3 NFL seasons, only QB in NFL history to throw multiple 500 yard 4TD performances, 4th most passing yards in a single game in NFL history, 5-2 playoff record only losing to the SB winning teams….list goes on and on. It’s not just for beating mahomes but yes being able to beat mahomes in arrowhead down 18 points and being the only QB not named Brady to show he can beat mahomes in the postseason earns you the two spot…casual. Y’all have no knowledge of ball. Period.

[@justadude1065]

@@av2018he’s the most efficient passer when extending the passing play outside the numbers and has the most clutch 3rd down conversion percentage in the league despite his WRs having the largest percentage of error on 3rd down. He made a SB and right back to the AFC championship being the most sacked QB in the league playing behind the 29th and 31st worst ranked olines in the league. Stop it. Y’all need to learn ball.

[@beastmode3799]

Why only 2 segments? Where is the full episode? Fire the KZbin guy.

[@jeremywhite8871]

1.mahomes 2. Lamar 3. Stroud 4. Allen 5. Purdy 6. Goff 7. Stafford 8. Dak 9. Love 10. Tua

[@thawkereynolds]

Wow, so no Joe Burrow? No Aaron Rodgers? And no Herbert? I feel like there’s a little bit of recency bias considering October of last year people were saying love was a bust

[@ADL21]

Joe Burrow gets sonned by Lamar but he's better than him? LOL

[@justadude1065]

And Lamar is 2-4 in the postseason, with a measly 16ppg, hasnt won a single playoff game where his defense didn’t hold the opposing offense to under 14 points in the playoffs, and couldn’t beat mahomes with home field advantage and his defense shutting out the chiefs offense the entire second half.

[@ADL21]

@@justadude1065 what does that have to with Lamar stomping Joe Burrow into the dirt? Joe Burrow cannot beat Lamar Jackson when his team is not devastated with injuries. Joe Burrow has not even been runner up to MVP and Joe Burrow has "won" playoff games where he did not account for any points. His luck runs out when 8 in purple is on the field.

[@justadude1065]

@@ADL21 because your lack of logic is ignorant. Lamar beating cinci means nothing. He hasn’t played them in the postseason, regular season means nothing, and if you want to go off of QB head to heads mahomes is the guy to beat and Burrow is 3-1 against him and the only QB to beat him in the postseason…yall could sweep us every regular season but most people with a brain are putting their money on cinci over Baltimore in the playoffs especially if Lamar is the starter. the injury excuses are ridiculous as well because all teams have injuries and play games with decimated rosters.

[@ADL21]

@@justadude1065 What were Burrows playoff stats last year compared to Lamars?

[@ADL21]

@@justadude1065 when Burrow has less Surgeries than Lamar has MVPs, talk to me about him being better than Lamar.

[@samuelgainey8336]

Herbert has been in the league for 4 seasons and 0 playoff wins. How in the world is he a top 10 qb?

[@WillAnderson3rd]

Because he's had the worst coaching and defenses and still made Chargers must see tv. Not to mention all the records he's broken.

[@trancebruh3231]

If you unironically think Goff is better than Herbert because Goff has a bunch of playoff wins and Herbert has 0, then you’re literally incapable of evaluating QBs on tape. If the Chargers offered Herbert for Goff outright, the Lions would accept without the slightest hesitation and they would immediately be better.

[@Sir_Robin_of_Camelot]

I mean, I think if you use your eyes, it's pretty clear he's a top 10 QB. Coming from someone with no Chargers ties.

[@ticenits3426]

@@WillAnderson3rdonly record that matters is his 30-32 record as a starter

[@tonythomas2391]

It's not even August yet and the Chiefs bulletin board material is piling up

[@vainexp3481]

How is burrow so high and he did not even play a full season? Lamar won an mvp...and got injuried the following season...and he never ever was top 5 on any qb ranks the following season...make it make sense...

[@WarPigP13]

Cause Lamar is a choker

[@Muzzlecrowe-li9kt]

Yea he’s a terrible choker. Who cares about his mvp. His playoff record is bad. He’s not clutch

[@jonahcomplexx1849]

I’m Burrows first full season as a starter , he was an Aaron Donald away from a chip

[@jaxonschryer5515]

It’s because Lamar sucks in the playoffs

[@nickhewes6860]

MVPs have ALWAYS been a popularity contest. That's why only Green Bay fans think Rodgers is the G.O.A.T.

[@ericktuya6672]

is nobody going to talk about how hurts isn’t even on here at all? bro had one of the best SB performances and last season was affected by injuries

[@jg7102]

Injures are 100% an excuse. Im a die hard Eagles fan and I can admit Jalen was awful last year. If he bounces back he will easily make 7-10. If e has another bad year we will look to trade him.

[@ericktuya6672]

@@jg7102 i didn’t say he wasn’t mid last year im just saying that injuries were causing him to have uncomfortable timing with his hand injury and his legs weren’t as strong and explosive as they were in his other year. ik he can bounce back

[@tyler3050]

they literally did address hurts? you might disagree, but he was literally brought up in the dak comparison and they expressed that only one great year can be held against him and could keep him out of top 10 until he rallies

[@ticenits3426]

What did I he do in the superbowl other than lose?

[@janaedavis2581]

I missed these 3 so badly 😮‍💨. Also, I see you Wildes with the just for men lol!

[@timmartin2417]

Y’all still don’t got the full show uploaded lol

[@changes6901]

Burrow has a losing record against Lamar but they blame the whole Bengals team. Lamar has a losing record vs Mahomes and they blame… Lamar. Make it make sense

[@justadude1065]

Burrow is an afc conference champion with a 5-2 postseason record and the only QB to beat mahomes in the postseason and that was down 18 in arrowhead. Lamar is 2-4 in the postseason commanding his offense to a measly 16ppg in the postseason, hasn’t won a single playoff game where his defense doesn’t hold the opposing team to under 14 points and lost to mahomes with home field advantage and his defense shutting out the chiefs the entire second half. There is your answer. By your logic…mahomes is the guy to beat so by default still Burrow>Lamar. His 2 MVPs and his charity one he won last year doesn’t mean a thing. No one cares. He will always choke in the postseason.

[@jg7102]

Wtf are you on? Burrow has been heavily criticized. Lamar has 2 playoff wins in 6 years. Make it make sense.

[@Finnissee0122]

@@justadude1065Tom Brady voted for Lamar to win mvp. Glad he doesn’t think like you lol.

[@bradleygeiriseb2701]

The Herbert hype is insane 😂😂😂 dude doesn't win at all... Dak is way better than Herbert.

[@SenatorSimon02]

What you talking bout CJ literally is a rookie who got #7

[@ericharden6832]

The board going crazy

[@zacht7135]

Dak ranked 9th after 2022 *Leads #1 Offense, leads the league in Pass TDs, 2nd team all pro* Drops to #10. Lmao

[@dtowns]

You cannot rank Dak higher when he is choking in the playoffs as consistently as he does.

[@Mericaa47]

The list was good at the top, but progressively got worse, lol. I don't think Dak is top 10, but Rodgers and Stafford ahead of his is crazy.

[@themightymississippi3703]

​@@dtownsSo Justin Herbert with a losing record in the regular season and the post season should be ranked ahead of Dak?

[@dtowns]

@@themightymississippi3703 nah I think that Herbert being that high is absolutely wild too, bro.

[@travesotom6890]

That’s because he’s a choker in the playoffs 🤣

[@ngtowjavon2103]

Mahomes will have to 4-peat for everyone to acknowledge that he's the best ever 😠

[@EdTex7643]

He'll still need at least 3 more chips

[@ngtowjavon2103]

​@EdTex7643 why

[@ducksgo2375]

@@ngtowjavon2103 Brady needed 5 to be considered the GOAT even though he had already broken most of Montana's passing statistics, so it only seems right that the same criteria is given to Mahomes.

[@howarddickersonjr.6994]

Naw he has to win 8 rings for me to consider him the 🐐! Brady has a 2-1 record against Mahomes including a Super Bowl win and MVP against him head to head. That has to mean something. If Mahomes gets to 8 rings then it’s undeniable!

[@rally1461]

​@@howarddickersonjr.6994 Rings are a team accomplishment😂. And head to head doesn't work either. Brady and Mahomes do not play each other on the field as if they were on the court. It seems you only understand the idea of silly head to head matchups and ring counting culture

[@dinorosga9147]

The smugness on that guy in the middle

[@xouchxy2827]

I’m sorry but I have to get this off my chest. Justin Herbert has to be the most overrated qb as of right now. This dude has 0 playoff wins in 4 years, has lost more games than won and has not been a game changer but more like a game manager. Don’t get me wrong he’s still good but he should be ranked around where Deshaun Watson is at.

[@justinrees2400]

Mahomes>Lamar>Everybody else

[@Truthteller01]

Thank you

[@codywirth8190]

Lamar is a RB.

[@abdihassan328]

Yes bro

[@abdihassan328]

@@codywirth8190 Josh Allen too, bro 🤣😂🤣

[@dadillonful]

Purdy clears

[@bsmith8943]

Purdy is definitely top 10. I think top 5 with the weapons he has.

[@deebrown9263]

That's the point you can have his weapons move him up , it's him by himself, him if u put him on any team in the league, him if they did a fantasy draft of QBs, who would you pick

[@CashCa1_3NINE2Baby]

I think Knick wakes up thinking about Pat 😂😂😂

[@blazinpyromaniac]

Stafford at 5 is CRAAAAZY. He hasn't been top 10 since 2021

[@travesotom6890]

No it’s he’s the best quarterback in the NFC and the only quarterback on the list from the NFC that has won a Superbowl 😂

[@annierushing4796]

never has been. he sucks

[@user-gr6ux9ze9s]

Why the hat on Matt Stafford. Dude is so underrated

[@Travolta12e]

Yeah that was weird

[@theBrendanONeill]

Purdy is the second-best QB in the NFC.

[@EdTex7643]

😂 He's not

[@samsunggamer6661]

Williams, love, Goff, Stafford, Murry (he's my sleeper pick for MVP), Cousins, Dak, and Hurts are all better than him and have higher ceilings.

[@Travolta12e]

He's not even the second-best QB in his own division.

[@PeterDahu]

​@@samsunggamer6661Murry is trash, Williams has played a snap, and Goff failed with a lead.

[@neetrab]

​​@@samsunggamer6661 45 year olds Stafford and Dak does not have a higher ceiling. stop 😂

[@fikrialfathoni]

The gap between Mahomes and 2nd Qb is bigger than 2-5

[@austenfalk6018]

The gap between mahomes and no.2 is bigger than the gap between 2 and 5

[@FuriousTheGeorge]

1. Mahomes 2. Burrow 3. Lamar 4. Allen 5. Dak

[@jdailey01230]

Lamar owns Burrow.

[@FuriousTheGeorge]

​@@jdailey01230who got to the super bowl?