What If the Clone Commandos Started the Rebel Alliance

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

125k Subscriber Giveaway!! Giveaway Sign Up Form: forms.gle/fo6hWTkRpsCCzfjz7 NSabers Discount Code: PPSW or nsabers.com/?ref=dwpfhhms Padawan Tier & Up to Join Patreon Giveaway: www.patreon.com/ppsw

[@josearojas1220]

What if Anakin Skywalker trained Barriss Offee, would you do it?

[@neofulcrum5013]

This was one of the ideas for the cancelled rebel commando game. I’m looking forward to seeing the change in ground battle tactics for the rebellion here.

[@nekogamer2508]

I hope we can get that game since the og battlefront douolgy is being remastered

[@NickDaGamer1998]

​@@nekogamer2508Hah, fat chance.

[@ChristianGibbons777]

@@NickDaGamer1998Fat?? So there’s a big chance then that they will???

[@alexthedemon2203]

@@ChristianGibbons777 No- it means there isnt

[@RichDXtreme247]

@@ChristianGibbons777Fat chance = No chance

[@socialaccount0000]

"Your tactics confuse and frighten me, sir" - Scorch

[@deathsticks1776]

“Your behavior confuses and frightens me sir.” Is the real quote. But hilarious nonetheless.

[@TaliZorahFangirl666]

@@deathsticks1776no OP is right

[@manuelgrothe608]

We need Boss, Fixer, Gregor and Sev vs Scorch and his Imperial Clone Commando Squad

[@MonzaniaStrike]

have to admit I think the commando armour is my favourite looking clone armour and it's nice to see a story focussed on them, after Republic Commando, we never really go much about them

[@ScP-049-01]

Bro looks like the nicest guy ever and also has the best storytelling voice ong

[@Only1199]

What if during Palpatine and Dooku’s sith ritual, it backfired and unleashed not only abeloth but eldritch horrors as well?

[@HolyknightVader999]

Abeloth would likely kill Palpatine, and Dooku would be calling on the Jedi for help.

[@starkillerjedi5486]

@@HolyknightVader999Do keep in mind, it will been the Jedi and Separatist at the time since this was likely before or during the Clone War Era

[@gabidz-u2s]

What if the rescue party sent to the separatist Jedi prison ended up crashing and found during the Imperial times about 20 years later? Specifically, imagine if during the mission to rescue a Jedi holding vital hyperspace lane codes, the shuttle transporting Obi-Wan, Anakin, Ahsoka, and the 501st troopers who are in carbonite crashed , resulting in R2-D2 being destroyed. Later they were unexpectedly discovered and saved by rebels.

[@gabidz-u2s]

side note. they crash before getting to the planet or after reetreeving the codes.

[@Swedish_ants]

Good idea

[@mad_ozzy]

Yes

[@newstarkiller]

Wasn’t Rex, Echo, Fives, Cody as some random 212th troopers onboard as well?

[@gabidz-u2s]

@@newstarkiller yeah im pretty sure.

[@socialaccount0000]

What if Palpatine *didnt know* he was Darth Sidious? As in, what if Darth Sidious was a split personality that Palpatine was unaware of?

[@wheeeeeeeee3]

Interesting...

[@dragonfell5078]

That would make for such interesting drama! Anakin would probably try to save his friend Palpatine who's in a Jekyll & Hyde situation with Sidious

[@RayMKlll]

That, I gotta see

[@CASA-dy4vs]

Palpatine: there is a Sith Lord in the senate I assure you anakin Anakin reaching into the force and sensing incredible darkness surrounding him: are you absolutely sure it’s not you?

[@Menhtrol]

What if Qui Gon found Ventress after her masters death. What if the Whills send Starkiller back in time to the beginning of the Clone Wars. What if Maul surrendered to Ahsoka on Mandalore and told her to contact the Jedi council so he could warn them of all he knew. What if the Jedi saved the Nightsisters from General Grievous on Dathomir. What if the Mandalorians had evacuated Mandalore before the night of a thousand tears.

[@pimperorpimpatine3199]

The top one you suggested has sort of been done. Check out his video on What If Ventress Trained Anakin Skywalker. One of my favorite Pente videos.

[@bigdogdempsey605]

Wow the commandos really messed the empire up like damn

[@gamergunn7139]

I got an idea. Possibly after the Bad Batch ends. What if Caleb Dume joined the Bad Batch?

[@SomeSuperGiant]

“Why didn’t I just force choke the clones when the fight started. I mean, I was able to pull down an entire spaceship with the force.” -Vader “ When I said, use your anger I didn’t mean use it uncontrollably”- Palp

[@shadics_minecraft8063]

I wish this was a cannon event. yet a first person shooter playing as a rebel clone commando (which you can customize with paint jobs and leather patches and equipment)

[@libertyprime5923]

I believe there is a multiverse within star wars where all these what if videos are canon and that the game Star wars Republic commando takes place in the same universe as this alternate reality

[@irystocrattakodachithatmooms]

What if Anakin secretly commissioned the ARC-170, X-Wing and Stealth-X before the Clone Wars. What if Anakin was a Jedi from the High Republic preserved in Bacta for when the power of the Chosen One was needed the most. What if Cal Kestis joined a mainstream rebel cell instead of the Partisans.

[@ineedanewname.8169]

Oooh, I like the second one, would carbonite be a better method of keeping him in stasis?

[@irystocrattakodachithatmooms]

@@ineedanewname.8169 No, long term storage in that stuff is hazardous. Remember what happened with Han after the length of time he was in it? It would have to be that Anakin would be ready to go right away.

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin looked after Bobba Fett after genosis. Also what if Anakin saved the nightsisters from dooku

[@percyjackson386]

Day eleven 1) what if the republic raised a army of volunteers not a clone army. 2) what if Luke and Mara, post union comics, traved back to the clone wars. 3) what if The Pius Dea returned 4) what if ahsoka raised mara 5) what if the Republic Outland Regions Security Force formed the base of the republic army 6) what if Etain Tur-Mukan survived 7) what if Siri Tachi survived and her and Obi-Wan Kenobi fell in love 8) what if the yousong vong attacked during the clone wars 9) whist if Meetra Surik, Jedi Exile, trained anakian.

[@Salt-Upon-Woundss]

The return of the Pius Dea is the one I really wanna see, Especially if the Order of the Terrible Glare gets their hands on Anakin and turns him into someone that would make the God Emperors Holy Inquisition proud.

[@Aahmpower]

First one could be said that it has already been covered on a past video kzbin.info/www/bejne/jHixZayMpaeGjNE&t

[@TheJmlew11]

I hate how the republic commandos have essentially been relegated to “yes men” who bow before the empire in the Bad Batch.

[@wargamesmaster]

What if the CIS found the remains of HK-47?

[@williamcote4208]

Here’s the thing… they actually did

[@wargamesmaster]

@@williamcote4208 In legends and in the now dead mmo Galaxies.

[@Sigma-gb9yd]

@@wargamesmaster Ehhh, half dead at worst. And becoming more alive every month

[@yesno8473]

I'm not sure if this would work, but I think it would could be interesting if you did a 'what if' between a character you've created from a 'what if episode' and a pre existing StarWars character in a new context. For example: What if Ahsoka had a sister who fell in love with her master, Anakin Skywalker? (referencing Odina here who was only a year younger than Anakin). Obviously this would change the context of the previous story you did about what if Ahsoka had a sister but it could just be a seperate thing. Anyways, love your videos and am wishing you well on making it to 200k subs!

[@cyberinsecuregaming2890]

I hope that the Clone Commandos turn on Hemlock in the finale of the Bad Batch. Like imagine if Scorch 'betrays' Hemlock.

[@Tenebris_Natura]

This aged poorly 😂 RIP Scorch

[@cyberinsecuregaming2890]

@@Tenebris_Natura Yeah, it's clear now that Dave just wanted the commandos to be a higher-tier of bad guy without really considering the lore implications of it. Especially when the commandos had a high defection rate in legends.

[@CenkHebeuy]

l would like you to get these video ideas please: 1. What if Padme saved Anakin from Count Dooku?(I mean when he was traded for General Grievous.) 2. What if Palpatine received the list of force-sensitive children? 3. What if Padme won the vote against Palpatine and became chancellor? 4. What if Padme Amidala was a Sith Descendant? (However, she will not defend Sith and will be force sensitive.) 5. What if Padme Amidala had been discovered and trained by Anakin to be force sensitive during the Clone Wars? 6.What if Darth Momin killed Darth Vader? 7. What if Anakin had not gone to save Palpatine but Palpatine had killed Mace Windu? 8.What if there was Tom and Jerry(Cartoon Characters) in the Star Wars universe? 9.What if Padme Amidala started thinking just like Anakin as a result of the clone wars (good things about the Empire). 10.What if Bugs Bunny and other cute heroes were in the Star Wars universe? 11.What if there were remnant in the Star Wars universe?

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

What if Sokka was a Jedi. (Avatar) What if Rey was trained by everyone's force ghosts. What if PPSW and Star Wars Galaxy did another collab. What if Rey killed Kilo Ren on Starkiller base.

[@Endrgamr262]

I wanna see sokka as a Jedi

[@lordgzstg6181]

You'd just get more mary sue complaints with that last one.

[@ExtraSpace62]

What if Admiral Yularin defected from the Empire? Maybe at the beginning of the Navy's rebranding or sometime after that, he might realize he wasn't doing the right thing or have a change of heart. He could be a very valuable asset to the rebel alliance thanks to his experience and possible inside knowledge on the imperal navy

[@edwinsepulveda950]

Or thrawn

[@spawnofragnarok9267]

What if the Galactic empire had invaded middle Earth ? What if the Galactic empire had at the time of the Dinosaurs ? What if the separatists had migrated to Earth during the time of the last ice age ?

[@mentalist7772]

What if Obi-Wan became Grandmaster during the Clone Wars? Palpatine said Obi-Wan was everything a Jedi should be. Also Anakin would have no reason to lose trust in him and wouldn't mind taking orders from Obi-Wan like he would from the Council.

[@noneedtoknow07]

What if Cal Kestis ended up in the High Republic Era. Just a contrast between a Jedi Survivor and a Jedi during a time they wouldn't have all that much to worry about . Not mention he uses blasters which would absolutely trigger some of them

[@matthewmohri9990]

Wow, Pente your vids just keep getting better and better.

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

What if Yaddle was a Sith Lord. What if Tyvokka trained Anakin. What if Satele Shan trained Rey. What if Padme was a Jedi trained by Plo Koon or Yaddle.

[@erikakerblom2900]

Noice as always Pente! Day: 123: What if Talzin raised Maul? Day: 54: What if Darth Plagueis trained Maul?

[@hunterdinoking]

Day 91. What if the outbound flight survived

[@brocktonbishop5874]

It’s absolutely beautiful! If the Clone Commandos started the Rebellion against the Empire, the Galactic War would’ve been no different than the Clone War!

[@daniellevin7163]

Can you do a what if jango fett learned and raised omega with boba i think it will be really cool to see boba and omega raised as siblings but im pretty sure jango will give omega the name of his sister arla. And omega will probably act like boba not really liking or respecting clones in any case if someone knows of a fanfiction about thise let me know.

[@Eloquent440]

What if Iden Versio stayed in the Galactic Empire

[@cartoonzentertainment]

What if Sabine never relinquished the Darksaber?

[@jonathanclark236]

This was AWSOME

[@Maik_Privat]

What if Dooku never changed the Inhibitor Chips?

[@owenscott6159]

What if guardians of the galaxy was in star war prequels

[@Unlucky1776]

Bro what😭😭

[@63TEA]

No, just no bro.

[@nathansheldahl]

Love the way the commandos took out the Emperor and it’s what I would expect from top tier spec op soldiers like them. Don’t engage the top target directly, but trick them to kill themselves thru brilliant sabotage.

[@TheLuconic]

Palpatine laughs: You clones cant touch me in my safe room! Commando Clones: We dont care. blows up the ship and Palpatine has a suprised Pikachu face as he floats in space.

[@Seperatist1206]

Hey can you do a video about clones and the separatist droids joined together after the empire took over please

[@Darth_Nihilus_solos_Vader]

What’s if Anakin rejected the force

[@IkarosVonVoid]

Rejected in plan i don´t want to train and use it or, in the way of i want to destroy the force?

[@Darth_Nihilus_solos_Vader]

@@IkarosVonVoid refusal to use it

[@IkarosVonVoid]

@@Darth_Nihilus_solos_Vader Palp prob just torture him till Anakin breaks and use it

[@Darth_Nihilus_solos_Vader]

@@IkarosVonVoid Anakin: Nah I’d win

[@JEFarmersMarketYT]

1. What if Dooku was captured on Geonosis? 2. What if Anakin and Padme rescued Obi-wan? 3. What if Naboo joined the Separatists? (This one revolves around a deleted scene in AOTC)

[@michaelmckean7543]

What if the Jedi secretly cloned Anakin during the clone wars.

[@bercalziner722]

What if Shmi was still a slave to Watto in Attack of the Clones?

[@alexander.tahtadjian]

This was amazing. I’ve been a fan of your videos for a while and it’s always fun to see your interesting SW what if’s. It was also fun to see the Clone Commandos starting the rebellion getting shown some love. This is definitely an interesting scenario and it should definitely get shown some more love. Plus they’re Clone Commandos…enough said. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s

[@lawriehinchliff]

OMG if Disney ever makes a Star Wars What If Show, this HAS TO BE AN EPISODE/ARK FOR IT!!!!!! Great Work!

[@bwc-chvd]

This is my favorite power fantasy. The commandos are like starkiller in this lol

[@WeazTintHD]

Great story once again. Liked the way it went. Great work.

[@docomega7862]

Here's an idea I don't think I've ever seen. What if R2 told luke everything? We know that R2 didn't get his memory erased. And and he was there for pretty much everything. The clone wars, padme and anakin's relationship, the fall of anakin. He could've also recorded lessons anakin intended for ahsoka. Imagine what would happen if instead of remaining silent he told luke everything

[@matheusdemello2323]

What if Jango Fett freed Shmi Skywalker instead of Cliegg Lars?

[@miscuser5534]

Well to put simply rex would be a clone of his step father and as would the entire 501st, this would lead to some awkward situations on the battlefront where Anakin calls one of the clones dad out of reflex from the voice, also shmi wouldnt die

[@mountain_watcher_8730]

This story was epic! This sounds like a decent premise for a new non-canon Star Wars game.

[@Salt-Upon-Woundss]

What if the Rakata returned during the clone wars with their Star Forge intact too.

[@BK-cu7ce]

Great video, but small continuity error, the ending of republic commando where Sev goes missing takes place just before the events of Revenge of the sith, since the scene is retold in the republic commando book order 66 and its made clear that delta squads mission was to prime Kashyyyk for the republic invasion to help the Wookiees push the CIS off world.

[@oliversherman2414]

What if the Clone Wars reached earth during WW2?

[@lottieparish1715]

I just thought of something. What if you do remakes of some of your older videos because you’ve gotten a lot better with? What? If what if you make better versions of your oldest videos just a thought?

[@criticato8916]

What if Pius Dea regained control of the republic during the Clone Wars?

[@kristianbritton5435]

What if the droid army went full Skynet

[@nachtviking2042]

What if palpatine snuck an inhibitor chip into anakin while he was a Padawan

[@AceOfBlackjack]

Lol literally nothing changes.

[@Grimtrox]

Some sequel trilogy ideas 1.What if Ben Solo met Anakin in the world between worlds while he was training with Luke? 2.What if Kylo Ren met Anakin in the world between worlds between after episode 8? 3. What if both Ben and Luke met Anakin in the world between worlds together 4. What if Luke knew Snoke was Palpatine?

[@timothyschwartz5518]

What if Hondo raised Luke? What if Hondo helped Obi-Wan on Mandalore? What if Hondo joined the rebel alliance before the battle of Chopper base? What if Ezra saved Mace Windu and Depa Billia in the world between worlds?

[@rhydonbeacham]

Could you please do a similar video like this, but instead with ARC troopers? A What If ARC Troopers Joined The Rebel Alliance video?

[@vodkalord6941]

what if the republic used droids and the cis used clones? what if Vader believed Leia when she said they were on a diplomatic mission? what if the younglings killed Anakin? what if Beru and Owen survived?

[@theterribleclaw4285]

If Sev comes back in the future he better have his OG deep voice or I'll be angry.

[@theterribleclaw4285]

I'm sick and tired of Dee Bradley Voicing Delta Squad he sucks at his job they need to hire back the OG Voice actors of Delta Squad, and don't give that excuse saying there Clone's they are suppose to have the same voice don't even try it, they were able to do it in 2005 they can do it now!

[@clarkestomps]

There’s a theory out there that Sev is still alive! Thanks for making this!

[@anthonypyritz2927]

What if R2-D2 started a droid rebellion?

[@constructivecriticism6203]

What is the mutated cordyceps from the last of us broke out during the clone wars

[@theterribleclaw4285]

If Sev did survive he would contact Walon Vau his Mandolin trainer if there's anyone Sev could trust in dark time it's Vau.

[@communismcats2650]

-What if inhibitor chip malfunctioned in the coruscant guard and they executed order 65 against Palpatine -What if humans recruits were used during the clone wars for the Republic instead of clones

[@brocktonbishop5874]

I want to see a video about “What if the New Republic cloned Captain Rex?”.

[@roccocomiskey4715]

What if Captain Rex trained Luke

[@mercfox4387]

Absolutely love this story~! As a side. Would love a what if Kreia trained Anakin Skywalker, knowing how unorthodox and out of the box Kreia was in her teachings, wonder if she'd make Anakin the next Revan.

[@animalhalo5984]

I hope we see Sev free Scorch and perhaps the rest of Delta Squad in TBB. It was heartbreaking to see the jokester of Delta be so broken into a mindless soldier

[@libertyprime5923]

I believe there is a multiverse within the star wars universe where all of these what if video's are canon and the game known as Republic commando takes place within this alternate reality

[@shadowfast541]

What if ahsoka kills anakin back on mortis while she was being controlled by the Son?

[@Happysecret180]

So most of delta squad died? Damn (scorch was killed after palps died, i assume fixer died on kuwat and idk about boss

[@peterszyszkiewicz5445]

What if Order 150 was transmitted by Rex?

[@cliffdavidson5096]

Question why did no inquisitors cut and run after palpatine’s death? Some would probably get suspicious by getting orders from Amedda and realizes Palps is dead so you think some would run or at try to run? Maybe some would even ask “Why should we listen to you?” And kill him.

[@matheusdemello2323]

What if Anakin Skywalker was born a girl and Padme Amidala a boy? How would *Revenge Of The Sith* change in this scenario?

[@Bigdan678]

Here’s a Halloween video for u. What if the black wing virus escaped during the sequels

[@KutseyKion]

What if ahsoka got sniped instead of kalfia

[@DLCedits15]

Video idea: What if... the Republic found mount tantis before order 66

[@thisisgraham]

What happened to Fixer and Boss then?

[@shenkorte7337]

disney needs to make a what-if show for stuff like this.

[@Impala1709]

What if Rex had encountered Vader after rots and heöped him back to the light and help Wirth the clone rebellion

[@joestargaming47]

Can you do what if the republic didn’t have a clone army during the clone war? But have to recruit people instead. (just like the stormtroopers recruits)

[@darksteel5212]

What if the master chief from the end of halo 3 escaping arc arrived in the star wars galaxy during the clone wars or empire, both sound good

[@gabrielluiz2568]

Interestingly, in canon, this was one of Palpatine's genuine fears.

[@HolyknightVader999]

But they did. You see, Sev was slated to be the first Rebel trooper, blazing a path that Han, Luke, Leia, and Chewie would later follow.

[@Grimtrox]

What if the Jedi Council found Tanalor during the Clone Wars and used it to escape Order 66?

[@Trek001]

What if Sheev and JarJar were lovers?

[@LeviBarnard-ln6fb]

What if omega squad disobeyed order 66

[@dianesinger9729]

Have to hand to the Clones they are very talented

[@markguzsvan1778]

What if ahsoka was on umbara?

[@TheMimiSard]

And in the aftermath of this, Obi-Wan is able to bring Luke up as a Jedi in the new, far smaller, Jedi Order, and talks Bail into having Leia train, which means the twins reunite. Both twins have regular contact with their family - Leia with the Organas, Luke with the Lars'. Ahsoka comes in and becomes a knight of the new Order, and the survivors field a portion of their number out as Seekers, with Order 66 survivors old enough for Padawanships farmed out to all of them, so they can have peaceful field experience (some, like Caleb and Cal, know what war is like, so this would be an easier field-work experience for them). Caleb and his new Master are on Lothal and find a young boy, one Ezra Bridger, who they get permission to bring to the Order. Another mission Caleb and his Master go on is to Ryloth, maybe to work with Cham. While there, Caleb meets Hera Syndulla, starting a teenage romance that carries on for years until she and her whomping cataclysm are space-worthy with their own ship, and can come visit the new Temple. It is because of this one Jacen Syndulla is conceived, with agreements to him being trained, with regular contact with Hera, who ends up acting as a regular contractor for the Jedi. Someone investigating Dathomir finds a survivor, Merrin, and persuades her life amongst living Jedi is better than life on her own with corpse pods of her dead Sisters. She and Cal become friends. Another Nightsister who lands with the Order is the resurrected Ventress. Now rather Grey than Sith, Quinlan finds out she is alive and persuades her that being an ally to the Jedi is worth her time, even if she stays mostly a bounty hunter. Baylan Skoll finds Shin Hati and a Seeker mission. Omega is travelling the Galaxy with the Bad Batch. Maybe she spends time at the Temple on occasion, where she gets some meditation training. Also the 'Batch find Gungi, and eventually are the ones to also bring him to the new Order (this might be after they had got him to Kashyyyk, in which case they also know where he is living). At this point Kelleran is still alive and brings Grogu in with him. No one knows the black creature was Anakin Skywalker, and thus his memory is left mostly clean for all survivors. Only Obi-Wan really knows how Anakin Fell, and he keeps that until Luke and Leia are in their upper teens.

[@colinmack93]

You should do what if anakin was Chancellor

[@lilianemachadostigliano1727]

What if darth vader stop Rampart of destroy kamino

[@theterribleclaw4285]

Vode An, Brothers All.

[@TheAutisticNinja08]

What will you PPSW say the difference between The Clone Troopers personalities differ between the normal clones during the clone wars and the Order 66 clone troopers personalities

[@TenkoBerry]

This is Great 👌