Pooping Out on a Puppy Payment

The plaintiff and defendant live in the same building. He sold the defendant two puppies, but he says she hasn’t paid him, so he’s suing. He also claims the defendant’s son strangled him. The defendant argues she only got one puppy. She doesn’t think she owes him because he pushed her and caused damage to her apartment. She’s countersuing for property damage and vet bills.
27-007

[@roberthewitt3072]

If your on a fixed income and can't afford a pet...don't have one

[@rckkeller9437]

I have a feeling WE are paying for those dogs. Welfare is to help people get their lives together, not to buy dogs.

[@VladmirPoopN]

​​@@rckkeller9437you do realize most of your taxes go to city developments and maintenance and the military? Edit: just pointing out that any of your tax money hypothetically going to the dog purchase would be fractions of a penny

[@themrs.1200]

@@VladmirPoopNThey really do not understand. There are people who truly believe their taxes cover their children’s K-12 education plus infrastructure, defense, and services on a local, state, and federal level. 🤔

[@tbecker97204]

I am on a fixed income, and I *could afford* a pet but at the same time I understand that, like children, they are a HUGE responsibility.

[@danir6695]

@@VladmirPoopNit doesnt make it any less annoying though. Regardless how much i personally contribute to any welfare fund, i dont like to see it wasted on non-essentials. Just my view.

[@probochronicles3991]

"One son is not working, the other is in rehab." Best time to buy two puppies....🙄

[@oldageisdumb]

Preach

[@RileyCullen1]

Right.. stupid people… I can’t pay bills but I NEED this doggo!

[@amandas2541]

Plaintiff isn't a saint but I believe he got pissed off from being lied to multiple times about his money. Defendant is a liar.

[@StevenDoh]

Doug at the end..."You have other problems" hahahhaahahahaha He is so savage and I low-key have third party awkwardness listening to him put people down

[@bjohnson1149]

He just tells it like it is!

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

We love Doug 😂

[@gratecarma6959]

He’s miserable.

[@scoot8792]

I feel the same way about the 3rd party awkwardness lol

[@rn6710]

He's the best.

[@oldageisdumb]

I can guarantee she isn’t a great dog owner. If you can’t afford a few hundred to buy a puppy the you can’t afford a puppy. And to the plaintiff, thank you for breeding bullies when the shelters are overrun

[@tbecker97204]

I hope the *puppies are all okay and in GOOD, quiet, stable homes.*

[@zacharybohlman4069]

If you had to “finance” $50 you can’t afford a dog. I hope those poor dogs are ok.

[@rezotydnic]

Neither the defendant or the plaintiff should own dogs.

[@WesleyLindsey]

Meth users always have a certain look to them

[@Itsroccib]

It’s a hollow, sunken look. Sad

[@millissentflemmings2216]

😢🤦🏾‍♀️

[@ruthrecord8196]

I thought that as soon as she walked in!

[@daynasafranek7807]

It’s from bone loss of the jaw. A lot have partials, dentures or have missing teeth. Can probably afford drugs… son in rehab. Says it all.

[@aliciacarstensen7904]

She should have got some teeth to replace what the meth rotted out instead of a puppy

[@laurabateman8151]

😂😂😂

[@marilynwillett804]

is that what it is, so many women show up with no teeth, shrunken faces like old women but eye make up on.

[@moonpaints4090]

Missing teeth doesn't mean meth. So people can have bad oral hygiene and lose all their teeth. It's her personal choice to buy fake teeth or not.

[@jayee-vf6eb]

Lmaoooooo

[@marcianicotra]

Really poor fitting dentures!

[@alissonvonderlane862]

If you cannot afford to care for pets, don't get them! 😢

[@tbecker97204]

So many homeless people have pets, I've noticed. Weird.

[@trekgirl65]

Especially the feeding and cleaning up after.

[@calikat8654]

Poor dogs. She wants to "buy" dogs but goes to the shelter for beg for dog food. If you can't afford pet food and care ,DON'T HAVE A PET.

[@sarahbarton4977]

Probably just wants them for breeding and getting money .

[@sarahslate9855]

These are the types of ppl who DON'T NEED dogs! If you CAN'T afford to feed them,,then YOUR NOT going to be able to take them to Vets..

[@rosechardonnay5351]

There is no doubt in my mind that the plaintiff is an aggressive and violent man, you can just tell by his entire demeanor. The defendant and her daughter (and I'm assuming her sons too) are all drug addicts that probably shouldn't be owning pets.....this whole case was a mess....

[@emo-channel]

Lmao you've got a lot of imagination

[@kyoto32001]

FACTS! defendants got what they deserved.

[@aiming4peace254]

It doesn't take imagination to see: He's a really tough guy who doesn't take any excuses from anybody... except he slipped here a bit. (I wouldn't trust he'd give me $5 back from a small loan-- no way would I make a $100-- $400 deal with him.... actually, they all seem "shady," Both sides say one thing, and then there's a 50/50 chance they'll tell the truth, (first they give a version that sounds pretty good--then they can be coaxed into a more accurate story...when it seems there's no other way), The defendants still talk about this case "at the dinner table," and think they told nothing but the truth in court. When they're corrected, they still "plow forward." They aren't embarrassed...I am embarrassed for them. 🙄

[@mercedesbardales2933]

Well said

[@123kymar]

Must be a yt woman...oh my God, God forbids someone gets upset and angry...ooooh they're so violent....They are gonna kill me the only person shooting in American is yt males and they are ALWAYS so calm and non-aggressive and non-violent

[@maryannegunter115]

So her witness couldn't come because she's in a WC. But in the affidavit, she went to work? Really??

[@RealRaeNichole]

Exactly and you can pay for a notary to come to you it’s probably like $30 max.

[@ashleyquam]

lol I love the way this guy tells his story 😂😂

[@carleethe1st]

This whole buying three puppies on a whim is so crazy to me. I’ve really, REALLY wanted a puppy for over a year now, but I still don’t have one. Why? Because in the weekdays I don’t come home for 12 hours. It would be unfair of me to do that to a dog. The question of getting it shouldn’t be “is it cute” or “can I afford to buy it.” It should be am I in a position (financially and other) to give this puppy the life it deserves!

[@Multipass1111]

I love Judge M 💜💜 Even she knew this lady IS a tweeker and so is the daughter.

[@ccrow86]

Just started the case and I can already tell she brings drama

[@mikieanthony777]

You look like the plaintiff

[@michelehemlokhexwhite4310]

They both seem like they bring drama...

[@joeybagodonuts6683]

It's too bad innocent animals have to deal with idiots like this. (Both of them.)

[@projectionv.accountability1010]

I hope the defendants have gotten help for their addiction(s).

[@user-fw8bw3eg7q]

Pets are extremely expensive and you can expect them to live 10 to 15 years, sometimes longer. If you aren't committed to that, don't bother getting them. I get they're adorable when they're little, but they grow up! Don't get a pet on a whim, it's not fair to them.

[@nicoleandry9464]

Bulldogs are even more expensive and more work to take care of

[@user-fw8bw3eg7q]

@@nicoleandry9464 Oh I do know!! I have a Beabull! Quarter beagle 3 quarters bulldog! He is a ham!! He needs special food, he is like a Billy goat he gets on everything and into everything which I can't wrap my head around cause he's short and fat but extremely determined! So I've come home to him on my counters and as you probably know they are so fat with those little stubby arms so I'm scared he's gonna jump down and break one. I chose to have dogs instead of children... I now realize there is no difference! My house is full of baby gates, my cabinets are locked, I own no chairs in my kitchen 😂 and he only listens to my husband! He will turn around when I tell him to come inside but he hears my husband and all of a sudden he is the most well trained dog that listens to all commands 😂

[@mochasoqrimey]

Why was his head leaning like that when he opened the door 😂🤣🤣

[@JRL_06]

Had to rewind that back 😂 😂😂 0:01

[@mochasoqrimey]

@@JRL_06 HaHa

[@Mm2k11]

If you have to set up a payment plan to buy a dog you have NO business being a dog owner when being a dog owner is a LUXURY not a need they have MONTHLY expenses.

[@Mathew2190]

If you cant afford a dog, dont buy a dog

[@scooneil]

Defendant was working in "he was drunk" so often you could turn this case into a drinking game. Anytime someone hammers on an attack like that (particularly when they bring zero evidence to court for their case), it's usually BS.

[@ljfire100]

i was waiting for him to say bada boom bada bing

[@ConfusedinJuly]

I love my free rescue dogs ♡

[@iris-nx1wt]

My local shelter charges almost $300 for a rescue.

[@uniquelybeautifuljourney7261]

I was just going to say that they are no free rescues in California only for pit bulls what family wants to get a dog that’s unpredictable. And the doodles they changing 500. To adopt them when they are so overwhelmed with overcrowding you think they be doing free adoptions due to the severe overcrowding but nope

[@akairiyahiko2602]

I’m dying laughing at the plaintiff. He had me crying with his statements. 😂😂😂😂😂. That defendant is a liar and look coked out too

[@juliagreen2186]

The plaintiff has known the defendant for seventeen years.

[@bethehype5339]

They some damn thieves

[@ambergraybeal3200]

The real losers here are those poor puppies

[@racheldeborde8237]

I only pity the dogs!

[@Stressless2023]

Mom looked like she used to be pretty before the drugs.

[@rckkeller9437]

I thought the same thing. She is intelligent, speaks well. She could get a decent job and get off of welfare.

[@8thhousealchemist600]

She got the meth-mouth now

[@8thhousealchemist600]

​@rckkeller9437 you give people credit for "could"?

[@VladmirPoopN]

​@@8thhousealchemist600I don't think that's how they meant it

[@danir6695]

@@8thhousealchemist600they were merely pointing out the fact that the defendant has the intelligence to work for a living, not giving her credit what she “could,” do. Reading comprehension is a thing.

[@cathylittleton7361]

This is why u don't do business with neighbors

[@themabukafamilydavis-mabuk8501]

Lol at Doug “ you got other problems I think “ he’s a mess 😅

[@stephenbanks5952]

So is the defendant's plan to beg for free dog food from the shelter every month? She cannot afford the two dogs.

[@deewah1698]

The way this dude tells his story reminds me of when I had hair and would go to the barbershop.

[@mikieanthony777]

ahahahaha lolololol lol😅😂

[@namnack]

It reminded me of every Scorsese movie ever made.

[@nightsky3981]

I swear I must have ADHD. I got lost in the middle of the story.

[@user-on3pt6wc7p]

Get payment UPFRONT!!! Don't trust anyone, EVEN FAMILY MEMBERS!!! Solves disputes like this...

[@angellucas-ranck9594]

I don’t get “buying” a pet when the shelters are over full with pets that need homes or they are put down. Last year my husband wanted a pocket bully(chihuahua & pit bull mix) so he bought it but he paid first before he could get the dog. That was the first time I’ve ever ‘paid’ for a pet, I’ve always rescued my pets before.

[@kittyfan]

no one sells a puppy for $25 anymore....even mutts go for several hundred. (much to my amazement)

[@DonziGT230]

False.

[@kittyfan]

@@DonziGT230 so what do they sell for? You didn't finish your point. (these pups sold for $300)

[@BeccasaurousRex270]

Hundreds? Ha girrrrl. People sell mixed breeds with fancy names for THOUSANDS. Deformed bullies (look more like bullfrogs) sell for even more and these dogs can barely walk

[@DonziGT230]

@@kittyfan Anywhere from free to thousands of dollars. I did finish my point, the only point was that you made a false statement.

[@thatvalensteingirl]

​@@DonziGT230You ever look at the price of a goldendoodle? That's considered a mutt, even with 'designer' parents.

[@jncuttie]

Some people should not have animals. The defendant is one of them.

[@malniehamex5273]

“You got other problems I think” -Doug 😂😂

[@mrshappilymarried1]

The sister told him to call her if they didn't pay. She told him because she knows her family is nuts..He should have called her like she said.

[@themrs.1200]

Only issue with that is the sister doesn’t even have her dog any longer.

[@epickup08]

When I see meth mouth like this, I make sure I take care of my teeth and stay off drugs.

[@nathanderover6929]

I want to listen to this guy talk all day long. His accident is hillarious!

[@barbaraness4507]

The woman doesn’t even have any teeth so how could she afford to pay $800 for the two dogs.

[@Catloudan]

ZERO sympathy for breeders and people who pay for dogs, when thousands die in shelters daily. Especially since this lady CAN'T AFFORD ONE.

[@Tuturu708]

We should ban breeders. Humans bred too many dogs and cats and instead of fixing the issue we’re continuing to enable people like this to make money off of their neglect in spaying and neutering their animal. I work for a rescue. Things are so rough in the US right now. Post Covid so many people dumping their animals. We don’t need more.

[@audiodynamixBagzz]

Lol he got arrested 3x in one night. 1 arrest takes a night lol.

[@jb3702]

"You got other problems i think"😂😂Doug is too damn funny

[@loveandhappiness304]

The lady kinda double talk. She said the lady couldn't come to court because she was in a wheelchair. But she was able to drive to work. Make it make sense when you write up a fake letter 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@crystalshaw8744]

" U got other problems...I think...lmbo

[@lawriesaxton7645]

STOP BREEDING YOUR DOG!

[@lindaburger2695]

I agree, there's plenty of dogs that need a good home

[@BeautyMonster1000]

There's nothing wrong with breeding dogs. It's nature. Also, it's the owner's choice. You don't get to decide for other people. I'm all for adoption but I'm not against breeding and I don't understand why anyone would be.

[@BeccasaurousRex270]

@@BeautyMonster1000because he’s not an ethical breeder. No OFAs done or PenHip either. He’s not breeding dogs to improve the breed or based on breed standard. I will always shit on unethical breeders. Too many dogs are euthanized because of greeders like him

[@thatvalensteingirl]

​@@BeautyMonster1000Irresponsible breeding keeps shelters full; especially full of bully breeds that get euthanized en masse because nobody wants them. Shelters have to clean up the mess those dog breeders make.

[@patrickchubey3127]

Don't buy things that you can't pay for.

[@marcellobalenzano8374]

Why would the plaintiff sell her and her son dogs?! I wouldn’t sell her a package of gum on credit….Much less, a living breathing animal.

[@baller1805]

These people are very rough

[@crimsonxxspawn8613]

"No no i got medical marijuana i smoke all day long......you sound like you got other problems" 💀

[@perfectlyimperfect9129]

If they had Went to their local shelter and adopted Instead of buying from a breeder They would not be having these problems !! Thousands of dogs and cats die every day in shelters !! 😢 14:02 No you cannot judge a book by its cover that's definitely not legal If a judge was to do that.

[@krystalunique2269]

Everybody doesn't want a neutered/spayed animal...

[@danir6695]

I doubt these people would’ve been approved for the adoption

[@danir6695]

@@krystalunique2269unless one intends on breeding, then there shouldnt be any reason not to fix your pet. Just my opinion.

[@amandas2541]

If they went to the shelter their asses wouldn't have got one puppy let alone three because you have to actually pay for them 😂

[@oldageisdumb]

@@krystalunique2269Clearly you are planning to breed your dogs and sell the puppies. I honestly beg you to go to a large shelter and see the hundreds of animals needing homes. It’s not worth a few hundred dollars.

[@joshuazito8240]

She looks like Idina Menzel who would have grown up in a trailer Park.

[@talexander2302]

I mean if you have to get free food from a shelter to feed the dog i really feel like you don't need it..wants and NEEDS are 2 different things

[@AudaciousMarv]

Aw that’s meth’d up

[@gilannev9171]

jM cannot resist puppy photos…

[@stevebutler812]

Her: Meth? Him: Rage? Though it was weed!

[@Audrey-wi1gc]

He said, you got other problems I think 😂

[@vzee8037]

The defendants are delusional. Having a dog is expensive. They need food, shots, etc. Back when my Bichon (he passed away at 18 yrs old) got sick and ended up in the hospital, my bill was $16K. Now I have a new fur baby and he is insured to the hilt. 😆

[@bnellaniyah]

Never understand why people "sell" things without collecting all the money first. Seems like he didn't want to be bothered feeding and taking care of them. Then tried to collect later...

[@thatvalensteingirl]

I sell stuff on marketplace to make space in my home, but I've never handed over an outfit or whatever else and been like, "It's fine, whatever, venmo me when you feel like it," Cash at exchange.

[@GavinA-vf9sg]

METH IS A HELL OF A DRUG

[@loribryant884]

Just because you're poor doesn't mean you can't have pets BTW 😢 There's homeless people that treat them pets better than a lot of rich people 😢

[@z_ed]

It's just irresponsible asf...selfish, too

[@danir6695]

I agree to a certainty point. Like, if you dont have $400 to pay for the animal… don’t get it.

[@mykalaearley6963]

Your not suppose to sell a puppy until it is at least 6-8 weeks old. Each state is different for the minimum age requirement but he shouldnt have been selling any puppies until the legal age

[@whi1870]

This should be common knowledge. What do you even feed a 2 week puppy if the mother isn’t there??

[@supportvawa2213]

You can sell them before they are born. They can't be weaned until after 6 weeks.

[@BeccasaurousRex270]

You can sell at any age, just shouldn’t wean before 8 weeks

[@LaineMann]

8 to 10 weeks actually.

[@tracylangsley4064]

Ooooh I wonder if I ask the plaintiff to lend me ten grand on Dec 30th he'll let me off from paying him back on the 31st😂😂

[@erikromero1433]

Yeah, if you’re on a fixed income you probably can’t afford a dog. What trash.

[@myaominky]

JMM looks pretty disgusted with all of these lowlifes 😂

[@Rocket5150]

Drunk Vs. Addicts. All the neighbors lose.

[@wadilotus]

These people are an embarrassment.

[@Ariarosesmommy]

Doug is a savage

[@pamelajordan2890]

Yeah I love it😂

[@ElizabethaSara]

Love him!

[@kenmattel7292]

They clearly use drugs on the defendant side

[@Pinkdiamond12]

Don't give anyone anything until they pay.

[@kyoto32001]

plaintiff has the moral high ground. defendants got what they deserved.

[@arneshareives6825]

I would've argued for her to be responsible for the amount of the sons dog, because she said she'd pay for both in her testimony.

[@allye8872]

Drugs are bad.

[@williammartin5569]

Once again. Doug rubbing it in. 😂

[@themermaidstale5008]

If you sell dogs on a payment plan, get a down payment before you let them go to the new home. You could get the purchaser to sign a paper that show the sale price minus the down payment and the balance owed. Include the payment plan - $50.00 to be paid monthly. The it’s on the buyer to ask for a receipt if paying by cash.

[@brandyhollingsworth6816]

The case hasn’t even started and all I can hear in my head is “I know a crackhead when I see one…” 😅

[@anarahmafe]

😂😂 dug stays undefeated

[@nancyhowell4505]

@anarahmafe *Doug? 🙂

[@anarahmafe]

@@nancyhowell4505 yes, dug

[@MeganB-wp3jr]

The plaintiff is my type of man

[@djaliyashea]

At the end Doug throwing mega shade, you got other problems too i think.. 😂😂😂😂😂

[@mclaybry]

I was smiling to hear the Defendant say the dogs are doing well- and she loves them... but then I started thinking, maybe she screwed her kids up, so she's compensating by taking really good care of the dogs? And the Plaintiff- Jesus- DOGS ARE NOT A WAY TO MAKE A LIVING (unless of course you are a recognized breeder). Living in a basement and breeding dogs is shady AF.

[@AC081361]

I feel bad for the puppies. Some people should not have animals. Both of them are 🫣

[@NovemberRain007]

The nasty plaintiff couldn’t stop smirking when the issue of the punctured tires came up; I think he slashed the defendant’s tires🧐

[@themrs.1200]

If he actually slashed/punctured the tires, why didn’t she report it to the police? 15:10

[@SarahNotSara]

I agree. He kept smirking, diverting his eyes/blinking when asked questions. That is body language indicative of deceit.

[@Tyson2394]

@@SarahNotSarayou watch too much Jim Can’t Swim lady. That’s not a proven science despite what the show Lie to Me says.

[@ChocoBeauty8]

The defendant looks like she is on that "stuff"

[@buck9739]

A judge and lawyer are there for money……

[@shannonbrophy3687]

I think he slashed her tires, hes not a good liar.

[@JC-cm9bn]

And yet there are those who still believe that man didn't evolve from apes 🙄 Watching litigants on People's Court is all the proof you need! 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@lynnwright6054]

I love people in life who don't want to do anything and they get all this money handed to them to have their bills paid and meanwhile people like us are working ourselves to the ground and barely get time to eat to pay for them to sit at home and buy expensive dogs when I can't even buy a dog myself the system is screwed up

[@theburntoutlighter1084]

I know what is like being strangled. Its absolutely terrifying. The person involved thankfully quit drinking and doing well, whixh i repect, but the fear that night and no one came to check on the screaming. ..... Im glad he stopped drinking but it sure keeps me at it.

[@marcdennis4698]

This is why I don't lend money or sell anything to friends THEY WILL NEVER PAY YOU ANYTHING

[@shellymilligan2953]

Nah when someone drinks they show their true character and feelings

[@nbd6213]

These broke junkies know they didn’t pay for those dogs, ridiculous

[@evelynperez7576]

Selling animals are ilegal in nee york. And it should be in entire world...animal has rights too. I here. To defend them. They are not alone

[@glenngatlin8475]

Yeah this guy came at 1130 with a bat wanting his money...