Wrong Place Wrong Time

[@Germinate16]

As an owner, if you manage to make a Labrador aggressive, that says a lot about you.

[@Possumpat84]

My thoughts exactly.

[@Aceofwolves]

ANY dog can be agressive. That lab should have been killed after the FIRST attack

[@thenatural5268]

Or it could’ve come that way to him or been bred aggressively. So maybe we shouldn’t totally assume

[@keylacmckemp1309]

Mine are the sweetest except if my son is walking them in our yard and a stranger passes near. Then they switch personalities. Once you're in our home and they know you, you will be slobbered to death and stood on. They are protective.

[@richardmayora1289]

I totally agree and I used to have two horrible neighbors whose Lab was vicious, attacked my dog into other dogs, but I prevailed in court against both of them

[@shellymilligan2953]

Leave the damn man alone about his weed!

[@teaingram5942]

Exactlyyyy!

[@katymcginn4644]

💜 ABSOLUTELY! IT HELPS HIS PAIN! GOD BLESS HIM 🤗✝️💜💜💜

[@dougschmidt5132]

smoke your brains out vs . taking oxycodone 6x a day. Go for it brother

[@NellieKAdaba]

😆😆

[@leisurefarm]

that man sure speaks with the feistiness of a new yorker.

[@katymcginn4644]

💜 PLUS HE'S ALSO DEALING WITH CANCER. HE DOESN'T HAVE TIME FOR THIS AGAIN. THE PLAINTIFF NEEDS TO KEEP HER DOG SOMEWHERE ELSE 😒🐕✝️💜

[@loveyoutube2177]

Daughter coached the moms paper too much. Judge made a good ruling.

[@cdickerson8759]

Am I crazy or did literally noone ask why the mom didn't close the gate herself?

[@onasamaya1]

I was wondering myself, why she let her dog out but never checked the fence if it is open or not.

[@lukerinderknecht2982]

That was the judge's point, she couldn't cross examine the mom

[@MusicTennis]

I agree. The mom probably didn't. Too bad there wasn't a lease that stated "all dogs must be on a short leash and in the owners control in all common areas". This might have prevented the tragedy. Very sad they both have cancer and lost a chance to become friends with it in common and walk their dogs on a leash together a few times then the dogs smell each other and become friends. I'd bet a grand that neither one of them ever watched Cesar Millan on TV before.

[@hazelbotedapgonzalez6172]

This was unfortunate but you have to bring proof to court and she lacked a lot of evidence.

[@davidellis5141]

She didn't lack ..

[@tcurry1531]

Because there wasn't any.

[@lgreene7]

It’s a shared yard! Just because it’s a “pit bull” and he smokes “weed” (because of cancer might I add!) doesn’t give her the lead way! She’s entitled. It’s a rental where the yard was shared. Her mother and the defendant both had a responsibility to be careful. Period!

[@kenyettaready]

EXACTLY these are comments are trifling

[@JamieM470]

Yes! Medical marijuana is a huge help to people suffering with cancer. It eases the pain like no pharmaceutical can, & has no harmful side effects like all pharmaceuticals have. There are tens of thousands of cancer patients who have legal prescriptions for medical marijuana for a reason. The state that the defendant lives in is still living in the 50's & denying that help to its citizens, while more & more states across the US are legalizing even recreational use. Citizens of states like his have to either suffer the intense & constant pain or resort to illegal marijuana use. The plaintiff had such a rehearsed speech, using weasel words like "vicious" and "frantic", etc, then she insinuates he's some kind of drughead because he smokes weed for cancer. I don't blame him for being upset.

[@tcurry1531]

I used to be a landlord and all my tenants had to have dog insurance or I would not rent to them as my homeowners insurance would not insure me. This is exactly why, but when you have 3 tenants and a shared yard probably all the insurance companies would say it is the other persons insurance that has to pay then they would all be out of luck.

[@stormy6454]

I'm not sure announcing you get 240 oxxies a month was a smart idea?

[@lauriegross8317]

@@stormy6454 and 6 a day is only 180, they don't usually give out extras

[@ButtonsCasey]

The one thing that pisses me off, is it supposedly happened more than once. It would only take one time for me to put a stop to something like this. Either keep your dog inside, or don't take your dog outside around another dog that will attack it. How hard is it for most to use common sense??

[@tcurry1531]

This is a rental property. The yard is supposed to be for all three tenants. The woman who has the daughter Olivia needs to be protective of Olivia's dog if it is there, not the neighbors responsibility.

[@spacepanda9037]

@@tcurry1531 yes it is he has a vicious dog he has to have control over his dog especially knowing the other tenants have to cross through his property to get into their home

[@ButtonsCasey]

@@tcurry1531 Olivia was the dog, and there is no excuse to continue to let the dog around another dog that attacked it more than once. I have a cat that attacks my other cats and dogs. You think I let him? No. I keep him away from them and if we see him getting agitated or aggressive, we stop it.

[@Channel-JJ]

@@ButtonsCasey Dang, you got Johnny Paw Pads on lockdown. 😾

[@narrowgate4229]

I was thinking the same thing I'm surprised the judge didn't bring that up. Once your dog was attacked once you have the responsibility to do everything in your power so that doesn't happen again. And the caddy smirks through the whole thing that's really terrible what happened to her dog☹

[@ViraIshnia]

I haven't even finished the video and the defendant is annoying me. He can't shut up and the judge is being very lenient. She's tossed people out for less. Oh sure, he's a man of few words AFTER the hearing

[@tcurry1531]

Yes he is annoying but he is not guilty. This girl does not live there, it is not a pet care business, the responsibility is the woman renter or the daughter.

[@ViraIshnia]

@@tcurry1531 never said he was. Said he was rude and annoying

[@AnneOhn123]

@@ViraIshnia Seems you are as well...

[@tcurry1531]

@@ViraIshnia He is that.

[@mexicanspec]

You don't know how you would be acting if you were drug to court over a case like this and was in constant pain. Would you have a sunny disposition?

[@catb800]

After the 1st attack why would you take your dog back knowing the neighbor /owner is irresponsible.

[@Aceofwolves]

The real question is why wasn't the lab put down after the attack. If it was reversed Olivia would have been put down

[@skeetsneufeld6305]

I what way is he irresponsible?!? Seems to me the daughter is the irresponsible one! After the first attack a responsible owner with even a half a teaspoon of common sense would refrain from bringing the dog to a place where it could be attacked!! Also the Defendant lives there and pays rent there. It is his home. You have no business ordering him around! As for you Mr. Defendant, I hope you are doing well. I too use weed for pain relief of severe arthritis.

[@msenglish8382]

That defendant ran the whole courtroom and JM let him! He's used to getting his way for sure.

[@victoriousco]

I think he is in pain of cancer

[@katymcginn4644]

@@victoriousco 😢 DEFINITELY IN PAIN FROM CANCER 🥺✝️💜

[@tiffanyazadsattaur1408]

@Hades access to leave and come she has to pass there it’s how the house was built

[@sandramika6710]

If the mother was watching her dog, it was the mothers responsibility to make sure that gate was closed. That dog shouldn't have been let out without her checking the gate, because that dog doesn't live there. It sounds as if she just forgot to check it or she was just too lazy, or maybe she just wasn't feeling good, maybe the daughter shouldn't have asked her I'll mother to watch her dog.

[@katymcginn4644]

💜 YES, I BELIEVE IF HER MOTHER IS GOING THROUGH CANCER TREATMENT, CHEMO & RADIATION. HER, THE PLAINTIFF NEEDS TO BE RESPONSIBLE & FIND A NEW PLACE TO LEAVE HER DOG. ESPECIALLY KNOWING THAT HER DOG & THE DEFENDANT'S DOG HAVE FOUGHT BEFORE. IT'S JUST TOO MUCH FOR HER MOTHER RIGHT NOW. MAY HER MOM BE HEALED, SENDING LOVE & HUG'S 🤗✝️💜💜💜

[@thina5918]

I loved thw defenant. I also loved how he defended the fact that he smokes weed, like honestly, it doesn't say anything about his mental abilities or his character.

[@ImmortalKingJay]

Period. I was so annoyed by the defendant for bringing it up as to shame him. It's something prescribed to him by a doctor. He shouldn't have been shamed or villainized.

[@arbjful]

@@ImmortalKingJayhe is a pain in the b$tt, as clearly seen by his behavior in the courtroom

[@elvickRULES]

The plaintiff’s spiel about “some people should just not own pets”. Yeah, you lady. You kept taking your dog to a place it gets attacked. Multiple times! What. His story on “if the gate is closed her dog is out there, if it’s open it’s cool to let his dog in.” Makes perfect sense to me. That sounds like the type of agreement people would have. Maybe the mom just wasn’t feeling well and didn’t check. All the more reason not to leave that dog with her. She’s going through a lot. As is he. Yet she had no sympathy for his cancer treatment it seems. I’m no fan of drugs however if pot helps elevate pain from cancer or other disease who cares? I would actually smoke it if it would help any issues I may find myself with in the future and I don’t like drugs. But I’d rather smoke that then take tons of pain killers or something

[@saramichele7366]

Agree with everything you said!

[@tcurry1531]

If I was the woman when I am home and Olivia and her dog are there that gate is closed and locked. Not the mans fault if his dog is allowed to be out there with the mothers dog anytime. He should not be expected to know or remember when Olivia is there.

[@lovemii3kids]

Poor guy is over this mess. I feel bad for him. Hope he is doing well

[@tommyjones6866]

Based on the layout of the house, it definitely appears as if all the yard is "shared" property. Unless the mother can prove the yard in front of her entrance is hers and only hers...the plaintiff was always gonna lose. Also...its kinda bullshit that he cant use the backyard whenever the plaintiff decides she wants her mom to dogsit. That dude....plus is dog...live there. They pay rent. The plaintiff does not.

[@skeetsneufeld6305]

Exactly!!

[@benmartinez1267]

Don’t dump your dog into a shared space then complain when the animals act like animals.

[@jenn_x.]

👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

[@stevo9421]

The plaintiff sounded like a well rehearsed news broadcast. With equal measures of drama and nonsense in an effort to create a case on her mothers behalf. She made it smell a bit like a scam and JM was on it as always

[@odettethompson6221]

That was exactly my thought.

[@fuckyzeit]

Yes. I agree. I was wondering about the filler words she used.

[@amandaz9762]

Nailed it

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

She was also so smug about it. Practice Practice Practice

[@lawfullucyless6715]

As I stated ....

[@cheyennexo5714]

She shouldn’t keep taking her dog to her moms house knowing her dog has been attacked “multiple times”. That’s just irresponsible but wants to blame it on the guy. She could’ve paid for a dog sitter but now she’s paying for vet bills

[@saramichele7366]

EXACTLY!!! 👏👏👏

[@CarrieRay]

Yes, plaintiff seems to busy to have her own dog if “grandma” is always watching her. She has no place to admonish anyone about who should or shouldn’t have a dog.

[@sandwichman100]

its a crazy setup where you have a fenced and gated area but anyone wanting access to the rear 'home' has to travel through another 'home' owners yard

[@marytodd6411]

As a cancer survivor, I hate when they play that card without proof.

[@WhiteMinorityWorld]

Marijuana needs to be legalized everywhere in the USA.

[@heidicrimmings9615]

Amen to that.

[@smfarrie2943]

Too many kids are using it.

[@Smitty46sb]

🎉

[@WhiteMinorityWorld]

@@smfarrie2943 make kids illegal....

[@amjedhatu542]

@@smfarrie2943too many kids use alcohol but it’s legal.

[@southernzen365]

He's in pain, has cancer and is just over this. I didn't find him annoying, I found him to be annoyed. She was very unprepared and the Judge made the right call.

[@nedjborsali4324]

Agree! People need to stop calling him a jerk! He has enough on his plate!!!

[@Vicky-by2hq]

Exactly. I found him like a non-nonsense guy who doesn’t take bullsh*t. Leave the guy in peace and take better care of your dog.

[@elvickRULES]

Once I heard about his chemo I understood why he was so annoying and he ceased being annoying to me. I get it I’ve seen how it affects people. It’s truly sad. My brother in law’s mother is currently dealing with cancer treatment and it’s effects on her and she just seems so over everything. It breaks my heart she’s a nice lady.

[@lee-qz7bd]

He's being straight forward and by the amount of Oxy he takes a day, I can only imagine the pain he's in ( speaking as another person that has to live with constant pain )

[@JoshuaHayden-vw3cd]

He was laughing and smiling on the way out of the court room being a smart ass the whole time and was asked point blank are you in pain laughed and said no

[@dinomite078]

I would hate to have him as a neighbor.

[@krystlebrown417]

Finally a pitbull not in the wrong!

[@ajacobo90]

Meh, a pit bull with painted nails with an owner that seems entitled...I would say the pitt bull probably started growling or something and the defendant's dog was like not in my house! So she got her a** whooped 🤭

[@wcm5636]

The plaintiffs coat button is hanging on for dear life.

[@chuck9380]

The defendant sounds doped up now and he is annoying

[@ramrajeeramnarine9042]

Agree with the Judge's DECISION.

[@sharonjohnson8512]

"NO. You saying something is not evidense.

[@mrs.jessicarocha1241]

I'm curious why Judge Milian couldn't just call the mother? She's done that in other cases, maybe there was a reason and it just got cut from the episode. But that definitely would've helped the plaintiffs case. Also, the defendant is such an obnoxious jerk 🤣

[@jedimasters1462]

Not really if there's no lease or agreement with the landlord to confirm. It also doesn't make any sense for the mom to have the only access to the yard, especially seeing as he didn't get the privacy of what they are claiming is his side.

[@leeroyjenkins97]

Judge most likely didn’t call the plaintiff’s mother because she is recovering from radiation and chemo for her cancer. I get what you’re saying about her calling ppl before, it’s funny when they out the litigants and ruin their chances of winning their cases.😂

[@mrs.jessicarocha1241]

@@leeroyjenkins97 Yeah, her health could have been the reason. I guess I just thought the mother would maybe at least be able to talk on the phone? Maybe not though 😬 And yassss!!! 🤣🤣🤣 I love watching JM catch on to people that are lying, especially during those phone calls! She's so blunt about it 🤣🙌

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

I liked the defendant and couldn't stand the plaintiff.

[@davidswick8571]

When the judge calls it is because there is some ambiguity in what is written down (either the bill or affidavit) and it is to clarify what was meant. This case would have called to cross examine what the mother says, and as Judge Milian said, "when I cross examine for credibility I need to see the whites of their eyes." On the phone somebody can still get away with lying because you don't see the physical nuances when people lie. It is not up to the judge to make or break a plaintiff or defendant's case. Now what she should have done is phoned the landlord regarding the property and who has access to what part of the property.

[@mikeaq210]

I would have thrown the case out right after the picture of the dog with painted nails came up.

[@leddoandroidgirl]

I would have thrown it out as soon as I saw her reading her testimony, if you're telling the truth no need to read directly from a piece of paper.

[@robschmidt6467]

Entitled young lady. Speaks so fast. Thinks her poop don't stink. Great verdict.

[@amjedhatu542]

I don’t think the plaintiff knows how to use the phrase “with that being said” lol

[@kittyfan]

the LAB attacked the PIT BULL?? that's different!!

[@Anglynn74]

I have to wonder if it was a mix

[@kittyfan]

@@Anglynn74 great point! Bet you're right! All the best to you!

[@Aceofwolves]

@@Anglynn74 no way to know for sure. Ive seen MANY agressive labs.

[@happycamperproducts]

Judge gets mad at defendant for interrupting, then interrupts the plaintiff like 3 seconds later. Lol.

[@robertschaaf7192]

the old guy seems unpleasant to deal with.

[@Noneyourdamnbusiness13]

Hold on the defendants math and mathin... He said he gets 240 oxycodone a month. Then says he takes 6 a day🤔🤔... 6 times 30 is 180... 6 times 31(for the months that have 31 days) is 186... If he's getting 240 that's taking 8 a day on 30 day months and taking 7.74 on months with 31 days!

[@alyssakaye9329]

So they are given a certain amount each month and told to take anywhere from x amount to y amount a day depending how they are feeling that day. His max daily is most likely 8 however he doesn't feel he needs to take the max daily amount. They don't have to take the same amount everyday. Most people do. Some days pain is worse than others. I'm a nurse, and worked in pain management for awhile. Hope that helps. ☺️

[@thesundayreset9636]

The marijuana is frying his brain cells.

[@bcoleman7229]

@@thesundayreset9636 ...not the cancer or chemo... just the MJ... -_-

[@thesundayreset9636]

@@bcoleman7229 perhaps all three

[@rachela2299]

He said 6. Oxi lasts at least four hours a day.

[@johnp.2267]

Any dog that attacks other dogs and causes serious injuries leaves its owner liable for damages. The fact it happened twice proves the labrador is a vicious animal. The fact it happened twice also shows the plaintiff's mother did not take proper precautions when dealing with a neighbor who owned a vicious animal. If anything, the vet bills should have been evenly split between the plaintiff and defendant. The fact the plaintiff's mother had no way to show up in person, due to a serious medical condition, could have been mitigated by contacting her via phone, but that was not even entertained. Not impressed.

[@devildoll9929]

The plaintiff isn't a Karen yet, but she's on her way to becoming one.

[@Fleabio]

Plaintiff probably has never been told no in her life. So she's got nothing when confronted

[@user-gl9su8du3w]

Not sure why she didn’t dismiss it without prejudice

[@nicolelugo4187]

Or why couldn’t they do a phone call with the mother ? I’m sorry that pit bull got attacked, but happy it wasn’t vice Versa I was routing for the plaintiff.

[@intrinsicallylast5246]

I feel bad for everyone. I'm sorry her Dog was attacked, I'm sorry he's in so much pain but I'm glad he found something to make the pain go away. I hope she finds peace with what happened at the very least and I'm glad the doggo is ok because in the end that matters the most.

[@wendelorian]

So if the defendant is going to use “chemo brain” as his reasons for his poor memory than we shouldn’t believe most of what he is saying

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

I believed the defendant. If this was true why didn't the b young woman sue after the first attack? She just makes no sense to me.

[@lionelluva]

Plaintiff could have won if she brought some sort of proof. The defendant could not control himself in the courtroom.

[@trekgirl65]

she did, but no mother.

[@DD-d6d3]

I don't think so. The plaintiff claimed there was a dog fight between her dog and the defendants dog a year prior. That means the plaintiff knew the defendant's dog could be a problem, and yet plaintiff brought her dog there again. That's on the plaintiff.

[@skym821]

Why are you having your mom watch the dog? She's going through cancer and breaking up dog fights. She needs to be resting.

[@kyoto32001]

i believe SANTA. plaintiff is a LIAR!!!

[@sullyacuna7859]

The plaintiff should have held off on filing the case until her mom was healthy enough to come to court to testify

[@truthhurts7045]

What are judges going to do when it is legal.. Yall are weird.. Pot literally hurts no one. Yall keep ignoring that it is helping people. What needs to be illegal is the oxy because its highly addictive

[@jawg2392]

lease states no animals, landlord evicted both

[@staffryte951]

why was everyone from that building on chemo?

[@CoolChill]

I wish the mom and landlord both showed up

[@cslworldwide]

Judge seemed a little frustrated at the beginning of this case.

[@natashamichelle8330]

No she's always like that

[@MikeNelli-uq2wl]

All those drugs. Should be in a better mood. Lol

[@ninosimone]

I agree with the verdict , the daughter thought she could finesse the judge and not bring her mother cuz she can lie better lol HA!

[@devianadkar7969]

I think the defendant annoyed them but the yard was shared.

[@mlmichael2791]

Regardless of circumstances, if her pitbull had killed or hurt his dog, the verdict would have been different. Pitbull owners always lose these cases. Also, judge Judy would have called the mother.

[@chrisk6101]

Well she decided to go here it's on her for the outcome ,and plus if her dog was attacked multiple times at the same place why even keep the dog there or find another place if they truly care for the dog

[@CleveNative]

JJ would have NOT called the mother. Both dog owners were neglectful

[@steveomac385]

Judy Judy hates pits for good reason. No way she would have sided with the her, or even called. If they don't show up too bad with JJ. She only calls outside people or people that wouldn't be expected to be there in the first place.

[@r1verman]

I understand why the verdict went for the defendant. Still doesn't change that he was a jerk. Plaintiff and her mother should should have also been more cautious after the first incident.

[@mexicanspec]

What do you mean he was a jerk?

[@r1verman]

@@mexicanspec if I have to explain, it's beyond your comprehension.

[@mexicanspec]

@@r1verman That means you can't tell me why. That's fine.

[@lauraanne5175]

@@mexicanspec I'll help Jeffery out. He was rude, had constant outburst and was an all around bully. He had no control over his own emotions. And before you go saying it was bc of cancer, my mother and best friend have died due to cancer, so YES, I understand the pain, but that is NOT an excuse for being a jerk. He was a typical entitled man who felt the world revolved around him.

[@mexicanspec]

@@lauraanne5175 I see it differently. I see a man who is in constant pain and he had to go out of his house to answer this in a very uncomfortable standing position. I can understand a little of the outburst if he thought it would move it along. You saw how they had to bring him a chair. How much pain was he in before he asked for that chair.

[@Lenzo8449]

She should take her dog someplace where it is safe.

[@Channel-JJ]

Yes, Dogtopia

[@msteinberg7]

she painted that dog's nails red= a 'paw-dicure'?

[@MountainOrbs]

Just because you don’t smoke weed doesn’t make you a great person… i like how she slipped that in.

[@cool92379]

Why did he say “ I’m not raping children or anything “ who said anything about you hurting people on weed🙄 that statement seems suspicious

[@Blueeyedjenn14]

Yet the defendant’s dog never once attacked her mother’s dog or any other known dog? We know of two incidents and the only common denominator is her pitbull. I have no dog in this fight so to speak and I’m not a pitbull hater, everyone I know who owns one they are loyal and loving with their people BUT are true to their reputations. I just find it odd, the entire time the mother and this fella lived nextdoor to one another their dogs got along great and played together daily and the only time their was an issue was with the daughter’s aka plaintiff’s dog….

[@ultimatecouponlady]

Here's a thought plaintiff, don't keep sending your dog over there. Simple.

[@keithkemp3008]

My only problem with this case is the girl already knew there was a problem with the 2 dogs not liking each other so why would you take your dog there and leave him there !! and your mother should have been keeping a better eye on thing than !!! Don't get me wrong the guy was a real jerk but it really was her fault !!

[@odettethompson6221]

I agree. I think it was their responsibility to protect their own pet, knowing their dog is not normally there, and doesn't get along with the defendant's dog.

[@MusicTennis]

I agree. The whole tragedy could have been prevented if there was a lease that stated "dogs must be on a leash in the common areas and the dog owner is responsible for an off leash violation (fine) and/or damages from a dog bite to people or pets". An even better solution is to socialize the dogs together via the Cesar Millan Dog Whisperer methods.

[@nettyspeaks]

The way he speaks says so much about him

[@miriamkivlehan3498]

Who let the dogs out? Who, who, who who, who?

[@daddyharry6065]

The pit bull has painted toe nails 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@celiakusmus]

No lease, no proof, no witness. How did she think she could win?

[@Channel-JJ]

with the Jedi mind control, obviously she's not a Jedi

[@scotthewitt258]

If he can't control himself in a courtroom, why believe he can control a dangerous, aggressive dog?!?!?

[@christopherbako]

The landlord should have figured this mess out. An extra fence should've been added.

[@pamelaclary3801]

Wrong place at the wrong time, there's no right time to be at the wrong place.

[@darnellrandall6442]

Plantiff is stunning!

[@frankgiuliano380]

the spoiled woman is of the mind set that other people should pay her bills.

[@kathyhansen9546]

Everyone says “due to the fact”. Do people know English anymore?

[@dennisstrope8912]

What does cancer have to do with anything? Get to the point!

[@ajacobo90]

Well the plaintiff brought it up as a defense to her mom so why cant the defendant also use it to defend why he smokes pot?

[@ButtonsCasey]

A pit being attacked by a Labrador? Let me watch this.

[@spacepanda9037]

We have a 4 year old Pitt shes never attacked anything we have cats n my nephew my neighbor has a golden retriever lab mix who bit my 8 year old nephew on his calf

[@ButtonsCasey]

@@spacepanda9037 Oh don't get me wrong, I do not think pits are bad dogs at all. It's just weird seeing a case like this.

[@nBasedAce]

I thought people who wore Hawaiian shirts were chill! He needs some Maui Wowie!

[@markmalander9521]

I have a different take on it. I think the aggressive dog owner should be liable. How long until that dog attacks a human? Different States Different Laws. My state the dog would be put down by Animal Control. This mans dog is a very aggressive dog we need the dog whisper Cesar to get this aggressive behavior out of this dog. lol... In the mean time I'll wait until we see him back in court for the next attack.. because nothing has changed except now he feels more untitled to let his dog be aggressive.

[@yahdygirl]

He is obnoxious.

[@c.t.1413]

So I smoke weed so what.....it's almost legal hahaha that got me

[@WaltT-q4n]

The judge making an absurd statement after defendant telling her about his cancer.

[@wvrjl]

The plaintiff did NOT "provide more than enough evidence". It was all dependent on the rules of the house. The plaintiff's mother said her lease stated the back lawn was all hers, but they provided no lease. The defendant said there were no leases for the house. What she needed was an affidavit from the landlord confirming that what she said was true. This case was all she said he said because there was no proof..

[@Anglynn74]

this guy is a jerk BUT I also take pain meds, have taken them for over 15 years for my back. Unfortunately we're still in opioid hysteria even after the CDC had to amend their guidelines because it was being misconstrued & abused. My husband has cancer, it's a pain unlike any other, THAT is the only thing I'm on his side about.

[@grneys45]

I take pain meds too and that doesn't mean you have to be a jerk because of it..But that's just my opinion.

[@Anglynn74]

@@grneys45 okay???

[@lauraanne5175]

Is your husband a jerk? Meds or not, he is a jerk. I've lived with and had people in my family die of cancer, guess what, they were still the same person all through their treatments. Sure they were in pain and had bad days, but their personalities stayed the same. A jerk is a jerk, no matter what...Also I am truly sorry for what you are having to go through with your husband. I understand how hard it is being a caregiver for someone with cancer.

[@Anglynn74]

@@lauraanne5175 your post has me confused. is my husband a jerk? he is a jerk? who is a jerk? totally unsure of what you're trying to convey here

[@mickm6309]

5 minutes in and this defendant is very aggressive, no wonder the dog is aggressive.

[@7Maz77]

Good decision Judge Milian.

[@leenie6393]

Don't like this verdict. Sounds like his dog is as mean as he is.

[@Kat-bu3bn]

Omg isn’t he nasty??

[@k0chana6]

She should've had her get her mother on the phone, and the landlord. This was such a miscarriage of justice. Had it been her "pitbull" that did the attack , everyone would be blaming her and her dog. But lo and fucking behold, because it's a "sweet" BLACK LAB, no one bats an eyelash. This is disgusting. She should've won the case.

[@pinkyshoes22]

240 oxys a month and pot…wow

[@oregontrailpickers3553]

That man was quite grumpy.

[@shanna1534]

The plaintiff needs to stop blaming others. One attack you can stand by "I didn't know" but after that it's owner negligence. It's simple... stop taking your dog to a house where it has been attacked! Poor dog

[@cypherknot]

Without a DNA test and/or established breed provenance, you don't know if a dog is of the bully breed. Appearance is not ID.

[@mollylolzzz6527]

Smoking pot is not a crime! Let’s be real.

[@LiveGrowRescue]

No way was that dogs vet bills 2k.

[@glenncurley680]

There is nothing wrong with smoking pot. It's far less harmful than alcohol. By far!

[@heidicrimmings9615]

Indeed!!! P. P. P.

[@kensauer7968]

Judge made the right decision

[@ChrisBX89]

She’s gorgeous🥰

[@annereidy7981]

Her dog wasn't part of the household, if it were attacked once, then find someone else to look after it while your away, and not leave it to a very ill person who cannot be held responsible for events. In other words, pay to protect your pet from injury rather having to pay huge vet bills after the fact.

[@bellasamantha237]

Anne Reidy ohh get out with your common sense nonsense. LOL! 🤣 She has zero common sense n felt entitled but she messed up n JM saw through it. 👍 I don't understand why she put the burden on her Mum as she did n let's hope she doesn't keep doing it. 😔

[@cynthiaprice3528]

Judges him for smoking pot but says nothing about him taking 6 Oxycodone a day. The legal method is wreaking havoc on his liver, kidneys, and heart but the method that is better for his health is illegal. At least his pot isn't killing him while giving him a natural pain relief. That's why I smoke pot and live my life unapologetically. Human beings are a trip!