Staining A Friendship

The plaintiffs say the defendant is their neighbor. They claims she was supposed to sell some ink cartridges for them and give them a 30 percent cut. When they asked for the money, she claimed the cartridges were a gift. They’re suing for what she owes them. The defendant says one of the plaintiffs said they were gifts and only asked for money when they saw the ink on eBay. She’s countersuing for all she’s out.
case 29-376

[@leanthonysain4476]

That girl thought she was so smart and was using the wrong words multiple times and the judge called her out every time 🤣🤣🤣

[@netpunk5890]

Cases like these get me all agile 😝

[@yesterdayitrained]

That was amusing. If you don’t know how to use a word properly, then don’t use it… it’s much worse than using words you actually know.

[@shalleemornes-joanah5297]

@@netpunk5890 This made me scream🤣!

[@wvrjl]

​@@netpunk5890- LMAO!

[@201950201950]

Drugs

[@melosidhe779]

I'm over the wife repeatedly saying that she's a "nice person". After that text and her snark comments it's obvious how that's a lie

[@NellieKAdaba]

And I'm over her laughing over the nasty texts she sent to her sister that the defendant received by accident.

[@kj2540]

She is a hypocrite

[@kj2540]

@Ms.C she is

[@uacbpa]

She says "I'm a live-and-let-live person", and minutes later the judge reads the email that was meant for her sister. She's full of it.

[@brittanymark9213]

If someone starts with “I’m a nice person…” it’s a guarantee that they aren’t.

[@Keymommy]

The way judge is correcting her on her word choices 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@larrythayer1452]

Yeah people always try to sound smart and end up looking stupid. LMAO

[@keithmccaslyn2527]

I Love and she's right too! Just like "I seen it" totally incorrect !! I SAW IT..simple but nooooo. I Love the way the defendant said " He & I" Love it. I hear so rarely theres day. God I Love Languages and speaking them as properly as possible,. there;s no "X:" in the word Ask either, or the way way over used " whats up? question not a greeting. Whats Up? Air Hellium, English class,grammar and semantic's..... American's and the language.... Im thankful next year ,a move near the artic circle!! Ha!!

[@berryhij1]

That’s the best part.

[@wizardofahhhhhhz]

I was like “agile?” That word makes no sense in that sentence lol 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@arlenemunford8296]

@@keithmccaslyn2527 yes., the word axed instead of asked it so prevalent in most of these cases, I’m always hoping she calls them out on it!

[@adrianprince7266]

The defendant said it perfectly. The plaintiff's husband use to have a good job but now he doesn't. So they obviously need the money now as oppose to before.

[@jehneanyshari1518]

@Shandra Johnson Woowww why didn't I think about this? That actually does make more sense.

[@carolynhorne9863]

But the truth was in the messages.

[@brookelynnkeele6841]

💯💯💯

[@C3yl0]

Thank you for sharing your opinion.🙄

[@wvrjl]

​@@jehneanyshari1518- Not really. First, the defendant had already stated that during the case (at the beginning, I believe). Second, the evidence CLEARLY PROVED the cartridges were NEVER a gift (and I bet money the defendant actually DID sell them). Third, needing money doesn't matter since the text messages already showed they were clearly never a gift. It's VERY common for people who need money to call in their debts when they need them. That doesn't mean they're not debts (especially in this case where the text messages show they were clearly NEVER gifts). Defendant's exit interview: when given a gift, especially something used, that the plaintiff got for free, you wouldn't need to ask if you can sell them. They would be yours. Throw them in the dump if you want!!!

[@dellahicks7231]

Anyone suspect that he lost his job because he obtained those cartridges through nefarious methods? The plaintiff made a comment about him not working, I suspect he didn't sell them himself, Craig's List, a local buy & sell, because he wanted distance between himself and the merchandise. All three of these individuals are shady AF!!

[@undergrounddojokeyboardcag701]

Nah. It sounds to me like he was working for a smaller business that shut down or a franchise with a store shutting down, and someone said he could keep them. This happens all the time. A business stocks up on something like printer carts, does not do the business they expect and close. If you're on good terms with the owner, they will probably give you stuff. Because otherwise its them who has to figure out how to store it, pay to take it to a landfill (ink carts are a diff. story and more expensive) or sell it themselves. In the case of the latter, one has to weigh potential return with time spent and as the lady said, selling on EBay is time consuming. Ive personally known multiple people who have shut down businesses and this happens. One buddy of mine closed down a loan place and gave me all their computers. I just had to go there, remove the HDDs and give them to him. Aside from that, i got 13 quad cores that i cleaned up, stuck HDDs in and sold on EBay. I don't see anything shady here.

[@DavidKen878]

Naw. If he lost his job because he stole them, more than likely they would ask for them back.

[@Elayesee13]

Idk At the end when the defendant said “One min they happy and the next they wanna ransack my house..” Easy answer They BOTH HIGH AS A KITE THE GUY IS DEF ON OPIATES

[@matcuscorpez6452]

@@Elayesee13 why do you assume opiates though?

[@Elayesee13]

@@matcuscorpez6452 one: I’m a recovering addict.. 5 years, 9 mos sober from them. Not counting everything else I was on so I’m hyper aware of people and drugs. It’s a guess. I’m about 90% sure UNLESS he’s on nerve pills, but again, it’s a guess.. def not speed, not weed, his actions/behavior show opiates.

[@pariswright7094]

All three of those people are weird, and the wife’s manic laughing is scary.

[@lauraanne5175]

@Ellie5621 she's not

[@pariswright7094]

@Ellie5621 lol

[@robertlehnhardt2084]

That kawhi leonard laugh

[@lmarteen2778]

@@lauraanne5175 oh yes he is !

[@bradfordloyd7623]

Yeah.... They didn't even try to cover up that Adam's Apple 🤭

[@missandei151]

The free legal advice segment w Harvey is a great switch. They shld keep it & scrap the dumb questions on the street bit, even if/when things open back up

[@fionav3840]

YES! Quit asking people who know nothing about legalities but just want 30 seconds of air time. That part made me not want to watch PC any more

[@valeriepetty5853]

Hell Yes!!!! That is old 🚮and tired/played✡ out. The, court is adjourned.🔨

[@valeriepetty5853]

I think Harvey started off here she helped him out but then he got his own show and Mary comes the money that kind of sort of stick together cuz their friends and they're running in the same Jewish Community but that's three question is really a waste of time we could get more Court time the questions are good questions but the people who are answering them don't know nothing so so wasted time

[@Haruzumakii]

I didnt mind it

[@lenas6479]

@@valeriepetty5853 I think this whole Doug & Harvey thing is unneccessary. The litigants mak ng comments after the verdict is enough.

[@25649sanchez]

i have more of a feeling that the guy took the inks from his job didnt want to risk in selling them because he did not have permission to take them in 1st place

[@edwinholcombe2741]

I has the same thought

[@Brinah]

Aaahhhh yes!

[@silversun3133]

Talking about it on national television where people can see his face isn't such a bright idea if he stole from his job.

[@donnaduncan3762]

I don’t know about that. It is amazing what companies throw away. I have some of those toner cartridges. They are all brand new and they were dumped. Some of these larger companies just can’t be bothered with the stuff so they toss it if they are no longer using the copier that would have held that toner cartridge….very wasteful but true.

[@25649sanchez]

@@donnaduncan3762 yes lots of companies junk inventory nd file as a loss in tax etc. nd most r strict from allowing employees to take product for their own use especially food products either way if he was innocent in acquiring said ink he couldve easily sold it himself but instead passed it on to neighbor some companies do allow certain items to employees but it's few nd rare especially if it can be resold in market

[@netra3089]

It’s the plaintiff trying to sound educated for me😂😂Judge was like Ah Ah wrong word again😭

[@jakozywhitson8529]

Lmao! I knoooow, I was so embarrassed for her.

[@barbarak2836]

Her husband was using words like "gaven." They are quite a pair.

[@ThunderingThighs]

Agile…no, AGITATED 🤦‍♀️🤦🏽!

[@bubblegum1948]

That was like knowing an accident is happening and you don’t want to look but you can’t help but look anyway. Total humiliation and disaster! 😭

[@geea3993]

“They still ask me to hangout, and smoke” thats what she wanted to say 😂😂

[@whyucare24]

😁.....Bay Area!

[@JeremiahLOsborne]

Drugs. It's drugs that brings them together.

[@yesterdayitrained]

That’s the only thing that makes sense, yes.

[@heatherbop2946]

Yeah seems like it

[@NapalmYourMom]

came here to say the same thing

[@Mo-cd7do]

Yes this gives me crackhesd behavior

[@tschandraheinze1680]

You guys are so funny, took thoughts right outta my mind.

[@foxwithtubesox1075]

Defendant: I'm on disability and can't afford living on the bay area. Also defendant: So, anyway, I drive the plaintiff to Costco and buy him a new TV.

[@sarahbrower2453]

🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@hafsahsarham9870]

😂😂😂

[@MorganC.]

Maybe the Ebay money paid for the tv

[@PastorJamesGillespie]

Oh... Tweety Bird's granny needs a lesson in how rid himself of mannish mannerisms... for this 'little olde lady' has several tells as well as a lesson in fashion. I have two brothers that are gay and they would agree that she needs to do something with that hair I'm sorry.. I don't want to seem cruel.... I'm just surprised that he would be allowed by friends or family to appear less than best

[@WonderingHead]

He probably stole them! He can't even tell it straight😒

[@JohnEastmanExAttyAtLaw]

no. she said he does not need money because he has a good job. that is why he did not ask for money.

[@Nothingleftbutthetruth]

The husbands a thief, if it looks like a thief and acts like a thief , its a thief. The plaintiffs have a drug problem.

[@vikasgurung8755]

🤣🤣🤣

[@brandilyn332]

You randomly pulled that one out of your ass

[@denfolo5224]

I would return any "gift" that I have not used if the person who gifted it wanted it back. I have way more dignity than this.

[@ameliapugmomdiamondpaints9015]

With the title why was I thinking this case was gonna be about a bad tattoo? 🤦🏻‍♀️😂

[@camillagoldman8139]

Me too

[@juliewhite917]

I was hoping

[@traci12078]

so was i

[@ryinwhyers365]

Because of the word inked? I mean just a thought….🙄

[@wynstonsmith7194]

@Maria Rajab plus in the thumbnail, the plaintiff's shawl made it look like she had sleeves done on her arms!

[@heathernks8]

The defendant was really disappointed that she had to give back the cartridges that weren't "worth as much as they're saying and were a gift" even though texts proved otherwise.🙄

[@NellieKAdaba]

👍🏾

[@universaldollie]

I agree with Nellie K. Adaba.

[@virginiascheider5205]

She? 😆 I think not 😆

[@maxine3020]

SHE!!! Clearly The Defendant Is A DUDE!!! 😳😳😳

[@jasminechavez6023]

@@maxine3020 when shim spoke it scared me

[@marikboo]

Plantiffs are doing some shady stuff. Companies would rather destroy/trash merchandise that is faulty than give them to their workers for free.

[@KiraylAsia]

Not completely true ! Nike has a giveaway twice a year for their employees for defected products.

[@kd9703]

Some companies will allow employees to take unused, expired or even damaged materials (used or bought by the company) to sell for their personal benefit or even dispose of at their convenience. You’d be surprised how often this type of incentive is used in companies (not all ofc, but some)

[@marcp1180]

My buddy was shortly ago given 5 nearly new (one actually never assembled still in the box) lawnmowers that were Lowes returns. Lowes took them to his small engine shop and they didn't want to service the brand, so Lowes said we don't want them, do you? Boss man gave them to my vuddy instead of the scrap dumpster. We sold 4 so far and have one more for sale. Sometimes companies do give stuff away without the employees stealing.

[@marikboo]

I appreciate these different perspectives. I guess I'm just thinking of my own experiences. One time my uncle and other employees were taking home scrap wood from his job. Their manager specifically said that it was ok to do so, until the manader's boss started to ask questions. Uncle said that his manager said it was ok, manager lied and said he never said that. Uncle then lost his job.

[@eh-i1841]

@@marikboo I haven’t known any employer to give damaged goods to employees.It may encourage deliberate damaging.

[@CleveNative]

The plaintiffs need to focus on moving out of mom's home instead of chasing after these expired and unaccounted for 👀, ink cartridges

[@awkwardpanda75]

Bingo. We seem to be missing the fact that they are seemingly average people, sort of average intelligence, at least in their 30’s, living with their mom.

[@Emcostanza]

@@awkwardpanda75 mom could be disabled or something. No one knows the situation

[@milly_lily1395]

Love how she keeps trying to use big words and clearly don't know how 🤣

[@wizardofahhhhhhz]

She slipped up and mentioned the warranty scam 😂😂😂😂😂

[@chukwudiilozue9171]

LOL

[@ShanniBananni]

Yup. All 3 are scammers. I have a feeling that this law suit was a scam. Plaintiffs sue for $4000. Defendant puts up weak defense. Judge Milian rules in favor of the plaintiffs. The show pays the judgment and they all split the money.

[@princesshermione001]

@@ShanniBananni i have that feeling too! And plus it's not farfetched for them to think of something like that.

[@araunah1579]

no the judge read it wrong i think what she was saying was that the tv that broke had a warranty so they were going to just go get another on their own and redeem the warranty but the neighbor swooped in and offered to help so she used her costco card (the lady mentioned the mom had her own costco card so therefore they would have to wait until the mom got back in town, can’t go to costco without the card) and bought the tv for them with her own money. there saying she didn’t have to do that because they would of just waited till the mom got home to use to costco card to go redeem the warranty. they were not trying to swap the broken tv to return it. the judge definitely read that wrong.

[@ThomasMalloy23]

BS

[@aangie7881]

This whole episode was weird & I’m here for it lol 😂

[@melli2413]

How the plaintiff can talk mess behind someone’s back even calling them a B and still claim she’s such a nice person

[@CharisToTheWheeler]

Exactly

[@RR-yi8qg]

I felt soooooo bad for her when the Judge began reading it knowing that she literally asked her the night before to come for drinks. They seem like the type of people that will set you up to kill you but pretend to be your friend.

[@AnneOhn123]

Marilyn, Marilyn, Marilyn $5,000 worth of printer ink is not impossible!!!! You obviously don't buy your own printer ink!!!

[@ViVALaKiRAxx]

I was about to say I used to work at Office Max, its not that much product.

[@Wondah007]

Yeah even home printer ink isn’t far off of the price. It’s really expensive

[@RobKMusic]

Seriously, especially if it's company that has like 10-20 printers. I hate it when she just assumes shit she knows nothing about.

[@ItWILLbeWONDERFUL_THERE]

I hear you. The little bitty cartridges for a personal printer is like $40 each. I don't even want to think about the cost of a single BUSINESS-SIZED printer cartridge.

[@emmakai2243]

@@ItWILLbeWONDERFUL_THERE For my home business use, with electronic options these days, it's just easier to just go to the library or commercial printers. A business cartridge is about the same for a consumer printer ($200-$300).

[@a2max280]

Agile=agitated. Recognizance=volition. Good thing I have aTweakers Dictionary. 🤪

[@yesterdayitrained]

You go! I love it!

[@jenniferwang3489]

I'm questioning that the guy didn't ACTUALLY get these for free.

[@Itsroccib]

No, I believe he stole them

[@theuseraccountname]

He so *happens* to not have that job anymore.

[@uacbpa]

I don't. I've worked in IT and in large companies that get rid of expensive things for a number of reasons, not just ink cartridges, but also equipment, furniture, books, supplies. In fact I know of a charity in NYC that all they do is collect things that companies discard. They get all kinds of things, sometimes brand new. IN a place where I worked once, an ED got rid of a brand new expensive chair because she didn't like the color.

[@pnwnewyorker9088]

He stole them from his employer. He was probably told to damage them out of inventory. That doesn’t mean employees can keep them and definitely not profit off them. He’s lucky he wasn’t fired. Maybe he was after they saw this.

[@camarojai6832]

I think you hit the nail on the head with this one

[@ashleyburch2290]

Neighbor did say he lost his job shortly before court hearing.

[@nishae7436]

For some reason the defendant scared the ish out of me when she started talking …

[@hijabibeautiful]

Cause she’s a dude

[@nishae7436]

@@hijabibeautiful oh…smh

[@tjneverdefeated4394]

Yeah

[@k9.p]

Me 2

[@existentialcrisis4884]

@@hijabibeautiful no she isnt

[@lacymacdougall9660]

As a drug addict I see some VERY familiar behavior in this case.

[@BornNoU]

“9/10 dentists do not recommend trying to ransack the house of someone who is microns away from completely losing their sh!t!” 🤣

[@zacharybohlman4069]

That was so cringe 🙄

[@iheartdates]

I love that Harvey’s dog chimed in at the end! 😆 It’s a great reminder that we’re all just humans trying to make it in this world.

[@nothingtoseehere3577]

I feel like those cartridges weren’t legally acquired

[@asabovesobelow7981]

ditto lol

[@sarahstauffer4874]

The defendant is a kindred spirit. Helping buy them a tv so they won't be homeless, letting them work it off. And here they are suing her..

[@Seei8none]

No good deed goes unpunished!

[@donnawatkins4039]

It actually makes her dishonest because she's hiding something from the mom

[@breezluize3282]

For the lady at the end of the episode who asked Harvey the eBay question: eBay has an excellent refund policy for Buyers. If you paid through PayPal you also have Buyer Protection and you can get a refund using that option.

[@ComaLies225]

Yep! I only buy through paypal because of it.

[@ydbetan]

I wasn’t expecting the lady’s voice to be so deep

[@karenoconnor4180]

She’s trans I’m guessing..

[@citygirlingraham]

Yep, trans gender,

[@tjmatt2475]

@@karenoconnor4180 he u cant magically change a gender his dna,testosterone ect still spells MAN lets be REALISTIC

[@tjneverdefeated4394]

The defendant looks and sounds every bit like a man. I was so confused the entire time. 🥴🥴🥴

[@NixScrapolla]

She's a smoker that's why she sounds like that

[@Jeustar]

Was just listening to it and I really thought it was a guy speaking until I watched it

[@2009gradcu]

The defendant is a dude

[@Jeustar]

@@2009gradcu she is? 😳

[@2009gradcu]

@@Jeustar genetically, yes…

[@rain73ful]

@@2009gradcu "Her" voice gives it away.

[@eloahnon4952]

I have an aunt that chain smokes and drinks like she doesn't have a liver... she sounds just like the defendant. Dude or not, it's not a soothing voice.

[@richdlaw]

The Plaintiffs are shady and tried to come off as angels.

[@jroc74gd4l]

The plaintiff’s wife’s laugh is freaky. Yikes.

[@payableondeath9091]

Defendant could be a poster for Aerosmith song dude looks like a lady

[@edwinholcombe2741]

I didn't think the laugh was anything out of the ordinary.

[@cbro2807]

Yeah, first thing the judge asked was how he got the cartridges. And was like "That's wierd..." Lol

[@Alivirgo8.24]

JM cracks me up she said GET OUT! lmaooo she's hilarious when she loses her shit

[@edwinholcombe2741]

It was uncalled for

[@AP-uo7sp]

I think these neighbors are working together to scam the show. Expired ink cartridges that they got for free🙄

[@Geronimo2Fly]

Me too. I'm glad the judge didn't award any money to anyone.

[@CJ-nv9xq]

The "babe, you're done" when he realized she was exposing their warranty fraud plans

[@AshleyMarieMommy]

The judge missed it. The defendant said “they keep talking about them” like she was annoyed. Why would “we be going on about these continually” she stated later. Why would they be coming to her over and over if they were GIVEN to her?!

[@kj2540]

I feel for the lady. I hope she stays away from those people and find better friends because obviously they are using her and could get her into more trouble. Sometimes it is best to stay by yourself than with the wrong crowd/ and they are the wrong crowd for sure.

[@Idontwantafuckinghandle588]

The lady is a shister too

[@abbyavilaVioletVessel]

Idk if that’s a lady tho.

[@GGCanLove409]

The plaintiff said "Can I say something?" 26 times lol

[@apoliticallevi]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@gtsound12]

Cartridges are expensive. I don’t know why the judge keeps acting like 4K for a ton of cartridges is impossible

[@gkdiva6]

agreed

[@D_Parks]

Especially when I never heard a quantity. Without quantity, saying something is expensive is totally dumb.

[@gtsound12]

@@D_Parks towards the end they said there were 42 cartridges and if you ever worked in an office you know those commercial printer cartridges are really big. If the regular home printer ink cartridges are like 60 a pop they. 4K for 42 professional printer cartridges seems like a steal

[@D_Parks]

@@gtsound12 I heard that but I thought she misspoke. $100 per cartridge does seem like a great deal.

[@nyaj754]

She probably have no knowledge of how much they are worth. She usually does her homework before a case but the fact that she kept acting like 4K was a lot just proved that she didn’t

[@ducknorris233]

How cool would it be to have a female John Goodman as a neighbor?

[@fionav3840]

😂🤣

[@saltslag1287]

Bro

[@ducknorris233]

@@saltslag1287 dude

[@drshreddi7040]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@saltslag1287]

@@ducknorris233 good one tho

[@Cancerblk2]

Dang!!!.. I think she should have gotten the cost of the TV back!!.. I think the judge forgot 🤔

[@Fush1234]

Highly likely the guy stole these from his company… it doesn’t matter.. he & she are nutters as well

[@dankjankings7339]

What’s a nutter?

[@SaturnaliaJones]

This was an all around weird episode, something was definitely off about the whole thing. Surprised she kicked him out, she's let people get away with much more. Camera work was weird with Douglas's head in the way. Parties were just weird, even for this show. Something was just super off and not enjoyable about this case.

[@ShoW-hx3mn]

100% agree!! Such a weird episode. I don’t usually come to the comments but had to come down here today to see if anyone felt the same way!! Lollll

[@nedjborsali4324]

I completely agree with you!!! Although the party of three were weird, she did not need to kick him out like that!!!! Like you said others have done so much more and she let it slide! That was not fair!

[@susannecarolinehoff7847]

Yes .. really weird 🤔

[@rockobill7637]

yeah kicking him out kinda came out of nowhere but I couldn't understand everything he was mumbling so wondered if he got inappropriate or said something that was edited out

[@KikiNasty]

I really think she didn’t give them space to explain anything. I think the plaintiffs were trying to say they wanted to use their warranty and their neighbor bought them a replacement before they could, so they offered their warranty replacement to the neighbor and she denied (I think??). It’s just all sorts of weird

[@nyaj754]

I need to see the defendants birth certificate

[@SaturnaliaJones]

Defendant got them crazy eyes. 👀

[@PHOENIX1699]

I've made thousands selling ink on eBay Judge doesn't know whay she's talking about Especially commercial cartridges - hundreds a piece

[@SaturnaliaJones]

It really irks me when she's over confident about things she knows nothing about.

[@yesterdayitrained]

The value of the ink cartridges had nothing to do with this case, though. It might have been a point of contention between the parties, but the issue was a dispute over who actually owned the cartridges, not how much they were worth. So the Judge’s knowledge (or lack thereof) was not relevant, and did not impact the case or the ruling.

[@camarojai6832]

Yea those cartridges are no joke. When printing plans and things on large commercial printers adds up quick

[@ashleyashley8062]

Where do you get the ink from?

[@christie4044]

Love the legal Q&A with Harvey. Please do that all the time and skip the talking to the group in the street please. 💜

[@zaymathew8203]

Definitely Wasn’t expecting the defendant to have that voice 😳

[@justmissj]

The husband looks like he does the Buffalo Bill dance in his basement.

[@meljavi7453]

Lol wtf

[@jb3702]

😆😆😆can totally see that!

[@nooblette]

Holy shit that’s so funny, I actually thought that for the defendant…

[@gregergreg]

The collective IQ of all involved is about the level of a brick.

[@errongaren]

LOL

[@marknasia5293]

That is offensive to bricks haha 😆

[@brooklynmobley5449]

The brick can build a home lol those three couldn't operate a hammer

[@Lauren-tk1gq]

I would say a brick because that is too big. I would say a koala. They are dumb as hell

[@bluepuppy1139]

My dog was extremely interested in what the dog at the end had to say!🤣🤣🤣

[@jeylohnen]

Thats defendants voice 😳. Was listening as i was driving and i swear i thought that was a male in late 20s or early 30s!

[@karenoconnor4180]

@Truth Betold yes the defendant is clearly trans 🤷‍♀️

[@TabithaKristen]

Confused by the number of people who seem to give a damn about the gender of the defendant. Like, who tf cares?

[@avic2697]

It is natural to look at any person and identify his or her characteristics (tall, short, black, white, blonde, redhead, attractive, unattractive, polite, rude, male, female, etc.). When someone's characteristics are unexpected or don't seem to align, people notice. Acknowledging this doesn't mean there's a hang-up or an issue with it. It's just being honest. By far, most comments regarding the defendant are about her assertions and demeanor, not her gender identity or sex, which I think is really good.

[@k9.p]

@@avic2697 well said

[@shelocsher2396]

Ppl who want the world to pretend that physical characteristics, and distinctions don’t exist are even more confusing.

[@TabithaKristen]

@@shelocsher2396 😂

[@ThatColtGuy]

This dude probably gave them to her then realized they might be worth something. Either way though the neighbor should just give them back and to hell with the bs…

[@Seei8none]

Right, because it’s most likely stolen property anyway.

[@darleneadams1935]

The way plaintiff is talking, those cartridges are gone!!! She's in panic mode leaving the courtroom cause now she's gotta find 42 to return. 😂

[@MoFe12345]

Whoa. That defendant has a deep voice

[@patrick1587]

No one else can say “all parties, please raise your right hand” as clearly and as fast as Douglas says it.

[@coffeeaddictexpress5038]

I think the defendant was so hurt about getting sued that she went “overboard” on counterclaim. They were free cartridges, this was all for nothing.

[@elizabethhill7901]

That poor girl just uses big words to make herself sound more photosynthesis

[@thelizardking4698]

Dude stole the ink lol no company is gonna give away 4k in product

[@foxwithtubesox1075]

Man! This case was so surreptitious! I be the plaintiffs and defendant all engaged in hydroponic activities together, while simultaneously attempting to submerge the plaintiff's mother. INCONCEIVABLE!!

[@tomoconnor9502]

judge milian, sorry you had such a bad fall in your courtroom a few years ago. Your Cuban heritage, and the way you handle your cases I think is awesome. Your experience as a lawyer comes through loud and clear. thank you for serving justice. tom o'connor, janesville wis :)

[@CharisToTheWheeler]

Wait when did she fall?

[@chrisloraine2735]

They are all nuts!!🤣

[@jla256]

Woooosh. The voice! I didn't expect that!

[@susual8285]

I'm so invested in those episodes 😂🤷‍♀️

[@michellegonzales1128]

The husband gonna give it to her on the way home for mentioning the warranty scam

[@SlashTheWeasel]

I agree with the judge's ruling but I feel like the plaintiffs needed to take responsibility on so much of this. Also I must say why were they whispering in court? Not something that should happen. Defendent helped them out with new TV which they have never paid back on and gave the worst excuse about why not pay it back with the insurance. Plaintiffs never paid anything for the ink cartridges so its not like they are out any money. They were not clear up front with the Def on what to do with it I bet. Especially expired ink cartridges which don't sound easy to sell even for cheap. Once you give something like this to someone else, is it worth making big deal out of? Especially expired stuff that may cost more to dispose of than its worth. So many people out there have inflated sense of what something is worth.

[@pat22nasty]

Lawyers whisper in court all the time 😂😂😂😂…

[@SlashTheWeasel]

@@pat22nasty Lawyers make salary, win or lose. These are litigants who know nothing about the law. Judge Milean has ripped kid apart for throwing her hands up once.

[@bubgum00]

Why would you go on tv and use words that you don’t understand the meaning of?

[@preyg.9686]

😂😭😂

[@CarlosGonzalez-mr5qz]

I know..

[@av8tor261]

I'll bet the ink cartages were stolen in the first place. He is as shady as an old oak tree.

[@lilo4399]

Interesting love triangle dynamic. D said - We're still friends. We still hang out.....

[@breesbonnets6798]

The defendants VOICE?...... Wow Sir, it's deep!!!

[@loveyoutube2177]

The husband definitely didn’t get the ink an honest way and the wife of a back stabber. What a terrible couple doing so much ha to a nice neighbor.

[@carlah6234]

Damn these people are all sorts of messed up :/ I feel bad for them. I suspect drugs and more. Who knows. Definitely feels like there's more backstory here. Weirdest case I've seen to date

[@shayna2562]

an actual nice person doesn’t have to tell people they’re a nice person lol

[@Unavitasempliceebella]

I love this judge she is impartial.

[@Black0bsidian]

Omg that text to the wrong personnnnn ugh! The horror she must have felt when she realized. I’ve done that before and was MORTIFIED!!! It felt like the blood drained from my body!!!

[@brittanyn5415]

Me too 😂

[@pjaypender1009]

Where did the judge ever work? The printer in my office takes 4 cartridges--magenta, cyan, yellow and black--each of which costs $160. That's not unusual for businesses that need high quality prints.

[@glados9386]

He def stole those cartridges and was having her sell them so he wouldn't get in trouble by listing them.

[@coderider3022]

100% yes.

[@javis88h]

These people would be great characters for a bumbling heist comedy

[@jokerkid527]

This is why I don’t use words I don’t know in any conversation 😂

[@merlin333]

She has a very deep voice.

[@pat22nasty]

Those cigarettes will do it

[@virginiascheider5205]

That's definitely a he lol

[@the_lonely_nerd5623]

She's transgender, the effect on her voice is because of the Estrogen shots.

[@virginiascheider5205]

@@the_lonely_nerd5623sorry it's a he, not she, the DNA will prove me right

[@tiddlesa.6125]

If it’s real, that handbag the plaintiff came in with is a Hermes Birkin bag and is freakin’ expensive.

[@zacharybohlman4069]

94% chance it's fake from alibaba

[@bombadomdom]

I think judge got annoyed & forgot about the tv. 🤣 She was totally entitled to that by both of their testimonies!! Strange couple.

[@aliandmama2073]

Plaintiffs are giving me crackhead vibes…….. The defendant looked like she snorted up before the show😂😂😂

[@yesterdayitrained]

All of them are!

[@4everThoughtful]

What's wrong with a neighbor just HELPING another neighbor without expecting a bottle of wine, money or anything else in return? What about doing a good deed just for the great feeling that you obtain by helping someone that can't do it themselves? In this case, the trimming of hedges. Such selfish people; the day will come when they need someone and won't have money to pay.

[@kimholmes8461]

The husband is extremely sketchy. He stole the cartridges. (Judge volunteer to call the employer to see why they gave em to him). The other man is telling all the business he knows lol

[@saint9961]

what other man?

[@kimholmes8461]

@@saint9961 the defendant and plantiff are both men

[@freshtodeath561]

Call the company about some ink cartridges from a year ago? Are you okay?

[@kimholmes8461]

@@freshtodeath561 apparently you're late watching the episode!!!!!! The episode aired 1 year ago & MY COMMENT WAS POSTED AS SOON AS IT AIRED!!!!! Check dates prior to replying to MY (TIMELY) comments. ARE YOU OK????

[@kathleenpoole1372]

Lol he stole those cartridges and a “$1200” bike frame!

[@samuelwilburn5879]

Who needs enemy’s when you have friends like that.

[@jamesmyers6739]

How many times she told that lady that’s the wrong word lol… when trying to sound smart goes wrong

[@undergrounddojokeyboardcag701]

30%? I mean.... if he's doing the labeling, packaging and shipping, cool. If she is doing the EBaying + all the above, it needs to be 50%.

[@ayyboii8108]

I don't think she has the cartridges 😂😂😂

[@CarlosGonzalez-mr5qz]

Yup. I thought so too.

[@johnwelch9661]

The husbands “can I say something” “can I say something tho?”

[@leeharris1320]

Very shady case. I don't know of any company just to give away that amount of cartridges

[@KPbouj]

I feel like the company went out of business and this was leftover and damaged. Or they upgraded/replaced equipment.

[@palopinto4065]

Cant the company return them to the manufacturer for a tax write off?

[@smarttrout5562]

@@palopinto4065 There would be no tax write off by returning them. They would get a deduction when purchased but if returned for a refund that wipes out the deduction. However if they prove that the cartridges were destroyed or donated to a legal charity then it could be deducted.

[@yesterdayitrained]

I don’t see a company having THAT much ink inventory- no matter how big they are (yeah, I know ink goes fast, but still… )