Cracking Up A Customer

[@leesuh87]

This was the smoothest court case I’ve seen thus far! It could all be so simple.

[@LawsonPatterson]

He seemed like a nice kid who was trying to do the right thing. Glad they found an agreeable resolution.

[@NellieKAdaba]

I agree.

[@NellieKAdaba]

@LONtoLAX Exactly

[@justinnscanlon]

Indeed. I would hire him in a heartbeat. Genuine individual with integrity.

[@stratfordbaby]

He's a man. 4-6 weeks to have a broken window and no security to your house is unreasonable.

[@Jonahch2v9]

My hat goes off to the husband. Obviously dealt with it properly. When she decides she wants it faster and better and is going to sue, his not being there speaks volumes.

[@granitemoss1451]

I think she jumped the gun, but maybe he decided his time as better spent at work for the day instead of just being another body in the room.

[@mymobilebuddy4392]

He is a nice guy. Accidents happen and he agreed to take care of it.

[@stratfordbaby]

But he DIDN'T. And 4-6 weeks to have a broken window and no security to your house is unreasonable.

[@boriqua1222]

"Cousin Cheo's place" LMAO! Judge Milian is the funniest! I like how bashful the defendant was. He tried to rectify the situation as fast and best as he could.

[@Mac-ze4gu]

He has a cute face

[@Ladyerica54]

Smh, that mother thinks she's helping but she's hurting him

[@NellieKAdaba]

True, I hate when the defendant's parents in cases are touching them to help them.

[@donaldbeetlestone3271]

Btw...wat does SMH mean?...

[@NellieKAdaba]

@@donaldbeetlestone3271 SMH means shaking my head, but I don't use that expression, and I had to look it up online a long time ago.

[@tdagbo]

He could have a disorder....

[@NellieKAdaba]

@@tdagbo I also have disorders, but I don't want to be helped all the time, I get tired and useless.

[@drshondagarnerbrooks515]

The plaintiff tried to stick it to the defendant. Just because she polite doesn’t diminish that she was trying to screw him

[@Joeh1154]

My impression of the $2500 amount was the greedy guy who suggested the window can't be replaced. He just wanted to pad the job and run up a bill, IMO.

[@ShugaAnnSpyce]

I think the mom was so protective because he seems a little delayed.

[@Ianisatool]

I think so too.

[@mrshappilymarried1]

Right! I was thinking the exact same thing.

[@lionelluva]

I thought the same thing

[@ShugaAnnSpyce]

@Polish Kiwi I didn't say they don't. She's overly protective because of his condition, this isn't about YOU.

[@jordanleigh8826]

i noticed that as well. im a psychologist and i noticed that immediately

[@SKOjy113]

I like these rare cases where both litigants are clearly not money hungry and just want whatever problem solved fairly.

[@NellieKAdaba]

I do too.

[@07miagirl]

Yeah, both sides were reasonable and behaved so well. Such a refreshing episode.

[@tiendaphillips8738]

I'm dying to know what the mom had to say now. Lol

[@damnnerves24]

This is one of the nicest cases. It’s rare that both parties are descent and wanting to do the right thing! Judge was 100 right. Communication is 🔑

[@sscc587]

Christian is so cute!! Seems like a sweetheart too.

[@stratfordbaby]

In what way???

[@sscc587]

@@stratfordbaby, in every way.

[@ukmedicfrcs]

The defendant is very handsome.

[@shannonnaegele4075]

He's a kid. You look old enough to be his grandma. Gross comment

[@ukmedicfrcs]

@@shannonnaegele4075 The only thing here that is gross is you thinking my comment was anything other than a compliment.

[@virg0_lem0nade]

@@shannonnaegele4075 -- LMFAO Shannon what are you smoking??? "grandma" about this lady who looks like she is in her late 20s??? "kid" about this man who looks like he is almost 40??? 😂

[@ukmedicfrcs]

@Aiyden New Thank you luv. I don't even acknowledge people like her when they make comments about my physical appearance. Let her post her photo so we can critique it. Lol you're gorgeous by the way! ♥️

[@mymobilebuddy4392]

You go girl.

[@zacharybohlman4069]

Totally agree with Harvey. This guy never should have agreed to do anything. He wasn't *negligent*

[@JamieM470]

Exactly. Unless he was using the equipment like a crazy person, swinging it around his head, he wasn't negligent. Or maybe weed whacking in a rock garden. Was the grass neglected until it was so high that it hid the rock? (the rock that wasn't supposed to be there). How would that be his fault? From what I can find online, he did the ethical, moral thing in offering to pay for repair. Nice guy. Since he made that agreement, he had to pay. But legally, he wasn't responsible. It should have been covered by homeowner's insurance. Edit: It's like rocks on the highway. They're called road hazards. If another vehicle hits a rock on the road and kicks it up into your windshield, they're not responsible. No one can be expected to spot pebbles & swerve around them at high speeds. That would be insane. If a rock falls off the back of a dump truck or is thrown by a person, that's a completely different scenario. They're responsible. Random rocks on the ground? Not anyone's fault. Rocks happen lol.

[@marissawillis2078]

He was genuine

[@back-corner-turnings]

How can the plaintiff walk into court and claim they need a whole new door when their own guy says the door can be repaired, and the process just got delayed! I think they started out doing the right thing then decided they just wanted a new door and figured they could get the kid to spring for it.

[@christiancastillo1556]

Why is that girl making out with her ice cream lol

[@Di_777]

Eww that’s awkward lol

[@coryvittur2581]

I don't think many people know Judge Milian's father & brothers are construction people & Judge Milian knows as much about building stuff, as she knows about the Law. She is a genius on many subjects. I ABSOLUTELY think she & Judge Mathis are the king & queen of the Courtroom.

[@jayburris6252]

She doesn’t. I’ve seen a bunch of cases where she THINKS she knows more because she has family in construction. It’s down right offensive for anyone to think they know construction because their dad is in construction.

[@msteinberg7]

i think Judge Judy is the queen of the courtroom since she has been there before Milian was born,but Milian is #2

[@elizabethhansen6984]

Yes, Lawson, the kid is trying to do it right. His Momma has got to let go LOL

[@jackfisher3906]

I have worked in the Window Industry for decades, NO Window or Sliding Glass Door has Glass that can NOT be replaced. The estimate she had was from a contractor looking for a Bigger Job and BILL.

[@Jean0987654321]

Seems like a pretty cut and dry case and everybody was happy with the verdict

[@joycecourts7403]

That mom is ridiculous

[@notkirill6991]

Great verdict

[@theebonyshow5536]

I just wanted to hug him ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️😩😩😩😩😩😩

[@gwendolenmccloud8771]

His parents raised him well. He's obviously a nice guy who was willing to do the right thing.

[@stratfordbaby]

4-6 weeks to have a broken window and no security to your house is unreasonable.

[@makelifebetterbb]

Very fair ruling

[@firstladypie760]

Thanks judge

[@CrippledEagle]

Unfortunately one can’t always know that there are rocks hiding under the grass or shrubbery. Having run a mowing crew where we also used weed trimmers, I can tell you that it is common for the trimming line to pick up unseen rocks and sticks and throw them with a great force. We required operators to use face shields for that reason. I know of one incident where a face shield was not being used and the operator had his eyeglasses broken. We had glass mirrors broken on the trucks occasionally because of thrown rocks/sand.

[@aaroncarson1770]

No no Harvey, rocks are the responsibility of the landscaper. They're part of the landscape.

[@glenncurley680]

The door looks old.

[@whitechris720]

The glass can be replaced

[@Mary_Lee2395]

If this was JJs court the mom would’ve been kicked out the second time she interrupted which Millian should’ve done the same thing.

[@mdgamble]

Naw!!!! JJ isn’t relatable and too curt sometimes. Judge Marilyn is more relatable, but still stern.

[@Mbheather88]

Anybody else think of 3LW when seeing the title of this case. If you know, you know!

[@reynakharin.est.2000]

No more ! Baby imma do right 💁🏽‍♀️

[@j3ssie2cute]

More like brother promthise

[@hopejones5265]

Broken promithis promithis

[@Misty8097]

@@hopejones5265 not promithis!!! 😩😩😩😂😂😂

[@hopejones5265]

@@Misty8097 🤣🤣🤣

[@Just_us-2]

Judge Millian should have asked the defendant's mom to slide over to the opposite side of her son.

[@kelsg5]

That's what insurance is for. To cover his arse when these things happen

[@annward4149]

Our neighbor was mowing his yard a rock come from lawn mower and cracked our son's bedroom window. We said nothing to the neighbor . It was accident not like he picked up the rock and through it.

[@TheAllAmericanSocialistMTR1000]

The answer to whether you can be held liable is "it depends." If he were on a riding mower, clearly the answer is no, unless it was an area you could see with the naked eye was inundated with rocks. If they were weed whacking a very overgrown area, again, the answer is no. If they were on the edge of an area inundated with rocks, then the answer is yes.

[@bubblegum1948]

Wait…how does she know they’re even responsible for breaking that door? They even admitted that they didn’t know how it happened. It could’ve been from some other phenomenon…what am I missing?

[@osomartinez]

not relevant. the defendant entered into an agreement to fix the glass. he’s decided to take on the responsibility.

[@kamialexz]

The mom needs to stop but he is such a sweet guy

[@sherrys.2259]

That happened to me, and the gardener paid me in cash. I felt sorry for the both of us.

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

Christen seems like a more than fair man. I'm so glad the Judge didn't make him pay more.

[@stratfordbaby]

CHRISTIAN.

[@Thunder-acro]

Looks like somebody needs to put their foot down and tell mommy that he wears big boy pants now.

[@axelfoley20]

I am a landscaper and even I say, the guy is responsible. But this is why you carry insurance and if you don't want to include your insurance, pay the bill. 400 for glass seems reasonable. 2400 is not.

[@cathylittleton7361]

the defendant seems like he was doing the right thing most of them act like they dont want to do it

[@stratfordbaby]

4-6 weeks to have a broken window and no security to your house is unreasonable.

[@princessjagdeeppanesar5283]

​@@stratfordbabywhat are you talking about? No, it's not.

[@Joeh1154]

The Judge got it exactly right, of course. The problem for the guy is now he has a judgement against him which will be reflected on his credit score for years. In most states the judgement will stay on a credit report for 7 years but some states allow for 10 years. That's going to haunt him for years to come.

[@P3rmissionD3ni3d]

What if it’s paid right away ? I think the producers cut checks for verdicts

[@Sunintheam8]

This is one of the court shows that does pay the judgement.

[@judymann6621]

She wants a NEW DOOR that's what not responding does

[@stratfordbaby]

JMM demanded a statement about needing a new door and when she gets it she STILL COMPLAINS. RIDICULOUS. Just be quiet.

[@stratfordbaby]

4-6 weeks to have a broken window and no security to your house is unreasonable. Anyone that thinks he was reasonable is out of their FING MIND.

[@positivelastaction3957]

I think his Mom DID write those reviews

[@socketyellow3]

People don’t seem to know how cutting grass makes looking for rocks is hard

[@stratfordbaby]

He was either there when the glass shattered or NOT. There's really no getting around it. The glass didn't shatter at any other time. It didn't wait.

[@stephaniehowe0973]

The guy giving the estimate wants to pay more money

[@firstladypie760]

People are so stupid. How should a land scaping person to look for stones🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️🤦🏽‍♀️. Person should put in shutter if they have lawns and gardens to cut.

[@stratfordbaby]

Learn English.

[@justinisbell4139]

In lawn maintenance the clean up guy is supposed to go thru the entire yard cleaning up all the debris before the weedeater and mower comes out. So i think the yard crew is to blame.

[@JackMontana69]

WTH! GREEDY AF! OF COURSE WHY NOT! SINCE HE IS REPLACING THE ONE THAT HAS BEEN SHATTERED WHY NOT THE WHOLE THING! EASY-PEASY MONEY! DUH! 🙄

[@christiangarrett3403]

U don’t see that often good one for once

[@socketyellow3]

It’s like 400-600 for a replacement online for that kind of door

[@lisasmith1817]

I'm getting really tired of your broken promithes broken promithes

[@goudachad52287]

Lookin at your pager theeing different numberth and numberth...

[@Dougie19xx]

@@goudachad52287 Call you on ya thelly hangin with the fellath the fellath....

[@BriannaTshelle]

@@Dougie19xx hangin wit my girlth you alwayth gettin jealouth jealouth...

[@lisasmith1817]

😂😂😂😂 y'all are awesome

[@branbeelotus]

😂

[@NolaPie]

I think the mom was there because he’s a bit delayed.

[@stratfordbaby]

Very delayed.

[@MM-zg4bc]

I think she just wanted new doors.

[@pickleasaur]

As someone whose jeep has had its windshield broken TWICE by a rock that was kicked up by a driver in front of me... i just write it off as bad luck, one of those things, im not gonna chase the driver and make them pay. Its an accident!!!!

[@sugarshamrock]

The defendant needs to grow up and not take his mommy to court to help defend him. Geez man hope you don't live with her too.

[@looknbakatu]

she was ANNOYING!

[@Ianisatool]

I think he might be a little slow so in that case there might be special circumstances for things like that.

[@Ianisatool]

@ thank you

[@PrettyGirl-zl7th]

@@selinesbeau lol “sit there and be quiet” really has me cracking up

[@RoughJustice2k18]

The mom should have stayed home - she is not a material witness - just an annoyance. Notice that she did not raise her hand when the bailiff was swearing the plaintiff and her son in? Not a party to this case - stay home next time mom!

[@gmar4454]

The person doing the weed eating needs to turn himself so the weed eater head spins so it throws AWAY from the house.

[@CrazyNaturalPrincess]

Defendant's really fidgety

[@BloodNote]

They're probably nervous. Cameras, people, court room. That's a lot to take in.

[@asiyah7714]

Maybe because his mother keeps hitting him!

[@BloodNote]

@@asiyah7714 that too

[@Di_777]

I’d be nervous too

[@theebonyshow5536]

He’s probably anxious and his mom knows that, I just want to hug him 😩😩♥️♥️

[@mycarpounds]

sooooo... if the glass was shattered and hasnt been replaced, do they just have a big hole in the side of their house? Or is the shattered glass still holding together??

[@ninosimone]

The plaintiff last name sounds like a drag queen name lol “ Christine Surh”

[@theconsolekiller7113]

Tanuki Lando Tenichi Wan!

[@Crystal-be9ze]

I don’t know why the judge kept being so damn rude to the defendants mother we are all parents and if our children were being sued we would all be there to support them in the exact same way

[@LWWM]

There has to be business insurance for this kinda thing.

[@stratfordbaby]

Of course there is but they don't want to have business insurance.

[@TommyVinMI]

Judge Judy would have kicked mom out. And those people on the street clearly never cut a lawn.

[@mickm6309]

I was thinking the same thing, who picks up every stone, rock, etc, in their garden before using a mower or a weed whacker.

[@Bread996]

Harvey is dead wrong. If a rock flies through the air off the end of a piece of equipment YOU are operating. YOU are responsible, not me.

[@stratfordbaby]

Just like if you're cutting grass and it throws a rock into a car passing by on the road. Same thing. Harvey is a nutjob.

[@princessjagdeeppanesar5283]

Wrong

[@jennreb5073]

Broken promitheth promitheth 😄

[@MegaSnow121]

The young man has terrible posture, making him look very insecure and in need of his mommy. He is young, so learning.

[@stratfordbaby]

HE IS OLD.

[@kratz57x]

But what about Mom!

[@stephaniehowe0973]

If this is from 2020 thousands of products are hard to get.

[@jasonharris1636]

mommy's boy!

[@stratfordbaby]

He does NOT look like bloody Jeremy Renner. Only if you're blind.

[@juanitaschumacher782]

He’s a slumper his momma did a job on him

[@steveeleigh3731]

The announce is becoming over the top.

[@humanoidmale7567]

Harvey's wrong. If the landscaper golfs a rock thru your glass the landscaper was negligent.

[@t4705mb6]

*Can you even imagine a judge telling a MAN too "Keep whacking away sweetheart!!"??????* *She'd have him arrested for being controlling and abusive!*

[@alexiaanya6733]

Are you referencing to when the judge was talking to his mother? You believe the judge would send a father to jail for that?

[@hallobthynameuwuclan4208]

ANGELE

[@stratfordbaby]

Send the mother out of the court.

[@terrisparta4532]

This woman eyes looks weird.

[@Degorff]

The homeowner should keep rocks and debris off their own lawns. In this case the damage may have been done previously.

[@michellehawkins1027]

Soo do landscaping before the person you hire to landscape comes??

[@stratfordbaby]

EAT IT.

[@jaysteph3167]

I’m glad the judge is a handy man however not everyone is and she needs to stop thinking every lady is as savy in construction as she is. She goes way too hard on women even men about stuff that she’s knows. Construction prices isn’t common knowledge

[@princessjagdeeppanesar5283]

Her father and family are in construction. She knows a lot about construction work. She has seen her father do it. She has never said or mentioned what you said and wrote.

[@numberone5680]

Harvey is wrong. Whenever anyone does yard work, especially mowing, all loose sticks, branches, stones and miscellaneous objects should be removed from the area. It’s primarily a safety reason. Guess he doesn’t take care of his lawn himself!

[@bubgum00]

I don’t think he should have to pay a thing, her rock hit the window. Pick up you rocks before you have someone work in your yard.

[@stratfordbaby]

You would be wrong.

[@Purpleloveme]

Judge your expertise is a judge you're not an expert in double pane sliding doors ma'am. How you gone tell an expertise who looked at the job.

[@princessjagdeeppanesar5283]

Her father is in construction and her family too. She knows.

[@AnneOhn123]

He shouldn't be in the landscaping business if he has no clue how to do the work without damaging people's properties... they should publish his company name so NO ONE uses him! Reckless!!!

[@princessjagdeeppanesar5283]

It' was a accident. It happens. Calm down.

[@Wendypretty1]

Seems like he's a lil off, I guess.

[@BostonPower]

HARVEY'S BOBBING FOR BOYFRIENDS AGAIN OUT THERE....

[@newyorknewyork9790]

Hardly made any money during summer time, I wish he didn't have to pay for it. Mommy please cut umbilical cord. You already did a great job.

[@stratfordbaby]

Harvey doesn't have a clue.

[@princessjagdeeppanesar5283]

And neither do you.

[@vicO1323]

When the defendants walked in and she had all the papers in her hand. Judge Milian was right to tell her to let him be a man. I bet the mom tries to control everything he does.

[@bullydog-q8h]

Plaintiff wanted to reign in cash, what a greedy troll

[@stratfordbaby]

They should have paid the $400 already. They were being pigs.

[@briblo]

Her teeth tho.....

[@victoriamask2200]

So judge saying the lady suppose to get more details from a company!! 🤔🤔🤔 These judges think ppl Jesus 😂🤭🤭

[@stratfordbaby]

He's in his 30s. Obviously doesn't work a real job. A bit slow, not all cylinders are firing. Mom is like his 'handler'. They needed to pay the $400 already. It was WRONG to pay nothing all these months later.

[@princessjagdeeppanesar5283]

How do you know that? Stop hating . You don't know him.

[@marshasteeds]

No house insurance?

[@stratfordbaby]

Not HER fault.