Pirates of the Caribbean VERSUS (Disneyland Vs. Disney World)

[@JeffryJohnston]

Glad you're back! And, you're 100% right, the bayou is my favorite part of the entire ride. It's just nice and relaxing and sets up the whole ride.

[@Disneylander]

Thank you!!! The bayou is so perfect and immersive, it's really the best!

[@gregorybuell686]

​@@Disneylanderthe pirate ride at Disneyland is the best hands down and I've been to the one at the magic Kingdom

[@nicoallison9228]

I absolutely love the Magic Kingdom, probably more than Disneyland, so it really pains me to say this, but I completely agree. The only thing I like about the Magic Kingdom’s pirates is the exterior and the queue. I don’t like myself for saying this, but I just think they did a really bad job on the Magic Kingdom one. It just feels rushed and not executed very well. Disneyland wins hands down for Pirates of the Caribbean. And I’d just like to add that this is a great channel and I will definitely continue to watch your videos, especially the versus ones, I really enjoy them. I really loved the video too. Just keep up the good work!

[@Disneylander]

It's definitely a shame! I wish they either went through with the Western River Expedition or they spent more time on Pirates. The Magic Kingdom's Pirates certainly isn't a bad ride, it's just disappointing compared to Disneyland's. But thank you so much, I appreciate that!!!

[@nicoallison9228]

I totally agree, definitely a shame they didn’t follow through with the Western River Expedition, put pirates at Magic Kingdom is still one of my favorite rides at the park.

[@megelizabeth9492]

At the end of the day, Diet Pirates, is still Pirates, I guess.

[@nicoallison9228]

meg elizabeth Very true 😄

[@SteveCarras]

@@megelizabeth9492 LOL! Agree!

[@aurorapalomino7736]

I loved this one! I completely agree with your points.

[@Disneylander]

Thank youuu!

[@SteveCarras]

As a native Souther Cal, i do too.

[@SteveCarras]

Aurora Palomino Hey.Disneylander's girlfriend or wife! (presumed..Sleeping Beauty's name is Aurora,too!)

[@patriciam628]

Personally I live in California and have been going to Disneyland ever since I can remember so maybe I’m a little biased but I definitely agree Disneyland’s pirates is way better my Cusin pointed out that Disney world just “doesn’t have the Walt touch” he belives that Disneyland has a different feel than Disney world what’s your opinion?

[@Disneylander]

I agree! Walt Disney's imagination is all over the original Pirates, while the Magic Kingdom one feels like a rushed copy that misses out on a lot of the best details!

[@Jen-cj2br]

I love both of them for such different reasons. When I’m at DL, I can really feel Walt’s legacy but when I’m at WDW, I feel more immersed in the stories I love. Character interactions are better at DL but I like the park variety at WDW. I would rather be at any Disney park than no Disney park, though haha

[@Jen-cj2br]

But as for Pirates, Disneyland’s wins.

[@highfive2935]

I heavily disagree, Disney World is the park Walt wanted to build, his touch and legacy is definitely apparent there. The reason the pirates ride at World isn't the same is because they had to put it in last minute not because they lacked Walt's "touch". Disneyland is the park he got to see to completion yes, but don't discount the effect he had on World's construction.

[@SteveCarras]

To me, WDW just doesn't have a lot of the same at DL has, like the bayou, the first, real big drop, and most of the scenes.

[@benapsley9552]

I have some comparison video ideas if you want them: - Indiana Jones Adventure vs. Dinosaur - Old Soarin (California version) vs. New Soarin - California Adventure vs. Hollywood Studios - Disneyland Forever vs. Remember Dreams Come True - Pixar Pier vs. Paradise Pier

[@Disneylander]

Those are great ideas! Comparing current things with their older versions is something I haven't considered before! Thanks!

[@ao9688]

Ben Apsley Tower of Terror vs Mission Breakout

[@ryan-tm4mm]

Syndrrin He did that

[@ryan-tm4mm]

Tomorrowland at Disneyland vs Disney World would be cool

[@TheJediKenneth]

@@Disneylander l like the idea of comparing Indiana Jones to Dinosaur, which was one of the suggestions made. Twilight Zone Tower of Terror to Guardians of the Galaxy is a great idea too. Update: How embarrassing. You made those already. I'm new to this channel. Great job by the way.

[@erikhi1321]

Most underrated youtubed!

[@Disneylander]

Aw, thank you fir saying so!

[@adambruins]

I lost a few brain cells lol

[@DarksladeDiaries]

I am an old Disneylander. Visited both Haunted Mansion and Pirates of the Caribbean in their opening years. Always found fault is young youtubers who try to flesh out attractions and concepts from attractions that predate them by 30 or 40 years. So I decided to watch yours expecting the same. But you are right on the money here and this is an excellently done video. I've always thought that if Disney had utilized the space that is in the queue to the ride instead, they may have been able to make something comparable to the Disneyland version. I was very disappointed in the Disneyworld version for all of the reasons you mentioned. Also, good for you in researching Marc Davis' Western River Expedition saga. If I remember correctly, Card Walker was president of Disney at the time, and succumbed to public pressure to put a Pirates ride in Disney World through no fault of his own. In any case, excellent video from an old coot, and I have subscribed.

[@TaylorStJohn-fp9zs]

I agree with your verdict 100%. I personally even prefer the exterior ambiance of the Anaheim version to Orlando's. I am just a sucker for the New Orleans Square vibe. And you're right...the bayou aspect is a key element for me! Sorry for my endless spree of comments. I am basically going through this entire series as we speak.

[@Disneylander]

I totally agree with you! The New Orleans vibe is PERFECT! And please, comment away! I've been enjoying your commentary 😁

[@davidguthrie6316]

One thing almost nobody mentions is the talking skull. In Disneyland, it looks eerie, the way the mouth moves is disturbing, and the voice gives me goosebumps. In Disneyworld, it looks like plastic, is off to the side, with incredibly poor dialogue, and somehow, the voice is even worse

[@tateevans1767]

Nah, you're right. I can't argue with any of the points you made and I don't want to because it is clear that Disneyland's is better!

[@Disneylander]

Glad you agree! Disneyland definitely takes the cake on this one.

[@tateevans1767]

@@Disneylander with your mention of the difference between the Adventurelands in Disneyland and Disneyworld I would love to see you do versus between respective lands when you have covered all of the duplicate rides, love the videos and I'm glad you're back!

[@Disneylander]

@@tateevans1767 that's actually something I was just considering this morning! You'll definitely be seeing that in the future!

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander Wecdlome back

[@SteveCarras]

I agree. I also prefer California's...Have fun..no mention made, but, of course, COVID 19 has afftected..it happened already in 2018 but took a year to shut it down.

[@ztslovebird]

I like the cave scene a bit more in Florida than in California. Not the undead bits, the spooky cave bits. Florida’s score stays ominous throughout the caves, but California has the goofy Pirates song during the cave bit. It kind of detracts from the ambiance.

[@Jp-yb7rx]

Bro that’s false disneylands is way better it’s longer and has more scenes that were left out in Florida and floridas is way too short

[@coelophysisstudios465]

100% agree! After the ride line the competitions as over!

[@jamesmoore2375]

You are spot on!!! Not everything at Disneyland is the best but it is the best. There are almost as many rides at Disneyland's two parks than there are at four of WDW's. They know how to cram them in, in California. I grew up close to WDW, but Disneyland is my favorite!!!

[@Disneylander]

That's a good point, Disneyland definitely packs a lot of amazing stuff into a very small space!

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander Of course, in the case ofg Pirates and Haunted Mansion, those rides's majority is underground...also, they're right next to each other..

[@sargentsargento3310]

Last time I was at MK pirates me and everyone else in line sung the theme song all together it was great

[@camdroid4936]

I agree 100%! But me saying that doesn’t mean much bc I have never been to Disney World. I hope I get to go soon.

[@Disneylander]

I hope you get to go! It's a blast!

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander COVID 19 has hit, you should do a new video.

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander Covid -`9,safe

[@Natebry]

I agree. Disneyland wins. Magic Kingdom Pirates is a cheap knock off

[@DisneyParksMusic.]

Thanks for the Disneyland vs. Magic Kingdom videos they’re very fun and entertaining to watch I know the video next Saturday will be awesome!!!

[@connorerhart6038]

Let’s be real: We all knew Cali would destroy this competition before the battle even started.

[@nickmartiros4472]

Great video! One of my all time favorite Disney rides. I’ve been to both versions, and while I grew up with the D.W. version I agree that Disneyland’s is better. But I still love the Disney World Pirates too! I can’t wait for more videos! 👍

[@Disneylander]

Yes, they're definitely both still fun rides!!! Thank you so much!

[@kylecrawford4271]

I’ve been going to Disneyland for a while. And I was a Disney cast member at Walt Disney World. Disneyland’s feels more like an adventure and it lasts a very long time. Walt Disney World felt rushed and lacking. I agree 100% with your opinion. I will ever go as far to say the exit to the ride is much better. I like at Disneyland that you walk right into The park and not a shop. I like when you do these videos. Keep up the good work. And sometimes a little Disney Knowledge is always great.

[@Disneylander]

Well that's awesome! I definitely agree that I like the exit for Disneyland's ride a lot as well. Especially that it let's you walk along the bayou a but more before exiting out into New Orleans. Thanks a bunch!

[@ClayLoomis1958]

Disney World was a Walt concept, but he didn't live long enough to fully make it his, like he did at Disneyland. This revealed itself when Disney World started selling alcoholic drinks in 2012, for financial reasons, of course. Disneyland held out, I presume for some corporate sentimental value, until greed made them open Oga's Cantina in 2019. Now everyone can see their uncle drunk on the Teacups.

[@TheJediKenneth]

If any body in the comments feel Magic Kingdom's Pirates is better, then they never rode Pirates of the Caribbean at Disneyland, It was my favorite attraction at Walt Disney World for decades. My must ride. I finally rode the original at Disneyland', I was blown away. Returning to Pirates of the Caribbean at Florida, though still a good ride, I felt a bit disappointed.

[@Jp-yb7rx]

Disney worlds just feels more short and starts and ends way to quickly. Disneyland also has many scenes that were left out in Florida. Disney worlds is still good tho but I live in California and go to Disneyland all the time and really love their pirates.

[@ianizer96]

It is indisputable that DL has HANDS DOWN the better Pirates!! So I will not yell at you hehe. The only thing that MK beats DL at is the queue. And it even pulls on my heart strings cuz I grew up in Puerto Rico, where we have the real life fort that the MK queue is based on!♥️

[@nocrit_9004]

I love the disney land pirates ride, going to disney world in about a week(after posting this) i am now less anticipating the disney world ride.

[@PatThePerson]

It would be like you guys turning down radiator springs racers for a dumbed down test track

[@callmeej8399]

I Agreed once again, though Florida does get the que right

[@justincarasick7824]

Disneyland has a better pirates of the Caribbean then Disney World

[@SteveCarras]

It sue does..see my other replies here and on other channell's Pirate comparions (TPM, Cory meets World, Provost Park Pass, etc.)

[@KINGCHRIS_XI]

I’m from Florida and WDW is my park but there is absolutely no contest between the 2 pirates of the caribbean attractions. Disneyland is the undisputed winner hands down.

[@fatherdeerhands93]

As a lifelong goer of WDW it is my responsibility to stick up for what is right, and that is that POTC in MK is NOTHING in comparison to Disneyland. The swamp, two drops, and a beautiful and full grotto are just the beginning of the long list of reasons why DL POTC is one of the best rides ever made. It was an ambitious project from one of history's most ambitious men. The other one was rushed to meet fan demand and to keep them waiting for the Western River Adventure that used a lot of the elements of POTC in DL, but was ultimately scrapped along with the rest of Thunder Mesa. Florida wound up with POTC lite and it isn't even close folks

[@fatherdeerhands93]

Maybe I'll get to ride it one day 😂

[@SteveCarras]

There's not even a "New Orleans Square", so..no New Orleans Square, no Blue (or other kind) Bayou in WDW's PotC.

[@Eggman4444]

Its so sad that they rushed this when they could have made it so much better!! Even better than Disneyland's!! If you look at the show building of WDW'S on a map program like google maps it is so SMALL! You can see so much room they could have used to make it just as grand if not better than Disneyland's!

[@Disneylander]

Yeah it's a shame they didn't spend a few more years on it! It could have been awesome! Still a good ride though.

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander If there was a New Orleans Square, at WDW, there would have been a Blue Bayou there in Pirates (also if they hadn't RUSHED so much). Also, as you obviously may know, Disneylander, the original at Disneyland wasn't meant to be a ride, it was meant as a partly underground tourist walk-through, yada yada yada, but then I think yoiu mentioned that already Take care.

[@Jp-yb7rx]

Well that had to rush because people were complaining that there was no pirates after they realized

[@Jp-yb7rx]

But Disneyland’s is still better I’m from CA

[@AmaindeJH]

I spent quite a bit of time in Land, and have ridden Pirates there many many times. I’ve been to World three times and ridden Pirates a total of 5 times. Love both for different reasons but I really don’t like how the drop at World is actually really dark and disorienting. The one at Land is bigger and doesn’t feel like falling through pitch black nothing then getting your butt splashed with pee water. Drops at Land are so much better! And I agree about the Bayou scene!! Oh AND the ride at World is dark AF !! Ditto Haunted Mansion!! All are stunning but WDW dark rides are SO DARK!!!!

[@rct3isepic]

Ok, I wish the second drop in Disneyland was placed was placed where the only drop is in Disney World. I like the drop into the battle scene. Also I think a re-imagined Western River Expedition should replace Florida's Splash Mountain instead of Frog Mountain

[@VaultDweller804]

I've only seen ride throughs of Disneyland's Pirates, but despite all the extra scenes I'm still very conflicted. Disneyland's queue I'm sure is nostalgic for Disneylanders, but it looks miserable and almost entirely unthemed. I'm also very confused by the bayou scene. It doesn't make sense to me that a ride set in the Caribbean starts in a bayou in Louisiana. I know it's because of pirates like Jean Lafitte, but it feels really weird to ride past an old man on his porch while banjo music plays and suddenly you're in the caribbean during the age of piracy. Also, the fire flies look really bad even for the time period. You can very obviously see that they're just lights being blown by a fan. The caves and the skeleton pirates are pretty cool in Disneyland, but the soundtrack seems kind of weird and disjointed. In Disney World the scene is short, almost too short, but the tone is set really well by the soundtrack and the small scene that we do have. In Disneyland you see all these scenes... and then you unceremoniously drift into the town scene like nothing happened. In Disney World you see the skull's eyes flash in your face, you're dropped into darkness, and then when you can finally see again the ship is right in front of you! It's an incredible reveal! In Disneyland it's almost disappointing. Not to mention Disney World has smellitizers throughout the ride. The smell of gunpowder, rum, and fire really make everything feel so real. I still wish that Disney World had the scenes after the jail, but if they just got rid of Jack Sparrow and returned to the old show scene it'd still be much better. Maybe seeing Disneyland's Pirates in person would make a difference, but it kind of feels like Disney World was just trimming the fat.

[@ItzAdrian02]

Finally this series is back. Hopefully there more coming soon. Recommending Haunted Mansion, Jungle Cruise, Small World

[@Disneylander]

There's definitely more versus in store!!!

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander He's done a Haunted Mansion one since! (And said he lkiked DIsneylnad better, espeecially what with the HM Hoiday, But I don't care for that "Tim Burton-ized" stuff IMHO, Almost like both, and live in Anaheim, well, 25 min.west i.e. but give Orlanda props for not only NOT having that overrated Burton stuff but being longer.And the newer interactive stuff at the opening of one queue. Haven't been to Orlando since way before that 2011 installation of that interactive area, which, honestly, looks like fun.I went there in 1995.) As for Small World. he doesn 't seen to have one. That would be fun, wouldn't it. I went on that one, but, like, the PotC, underwhelms, no big facade, at least..At last the overlay for Christmas at SM at DL (unlike the weird HM TB stuff here in Calif.with DL is) is a delightful Christmas stuff, and they added the Disney characters from features...

[@philrabe910]

Both MK and Disneyland went outside the berm, so I don't see why MK couldn't have been "Plussed" compared to California, rather than the reverse. We grew up in Florida and so that version. I got to see the original in the 80's and was blown away. Took my sister for a milestone birthday and we had lunch at the Blue Bayou- I had made reservations before she even saw the place.

[@martidodger7106]

The first time I went to Disneyland after years of Disney World’s PotC, I was shocked at how much better Disneyland’s is. Going back to WDW’s after experiencing Disneylands, I spend the entire time on WDW’s wishing I was on DL’s

[@Snowflurry00]

Agreed. The talking skull is better. The drops, the skeletons, the smoke screen images, the burning room, and the ride back up. I even like the gift shop better. Pieces of Eight and New Orleans Square. 💯

[@Pudding175]

In the blue cave intro part of the magic kingdom ride, from a certain perspective. It looks like the rock say "PIRATES." Am I the only one that sees this in the rocks?? Am I too high rn???

[@kevinkevin624]

Hey...the video is good. As someone that has been to world a million times, and never land, it's really interesting to see the comparison. The only suggestion I'd make is maybe to tone down a bit of the unnecessary jokes and such...just my opinion. Not bad, just seems like trying a bit too hard when your information and delivery style stand on their own...no need to interject. Keep up the good work!

[@MUNDOM316]

damn dude, you mentioned the skeletons but how could you leave out the fun fact that all the skeletons at Disneyland were real skeletons, and there's one real skull still left behind

[@TheJediKenneth]

You may be 100% correct. I once read that actual human skeletons, and the skull that still remains, is an urban legend. Still many still report this as fact. Either way, I find the skeleton section of Disneyland's Pirates of the Caribbean very cool.

[@MUNDOM316]

@@TheJediKenneth why I guess the original skeletons didn't look realistic enough to Walt so they got cadavers from UCLA. all the skeletons have been replaced with fake props now but the skull on the bed's headboard is still very much real

[@TheJediKenneth]

@@MUNDOM316 Kind of creepy. Thanks.

[@mariavillagran1831]

Oh yes.

[@noahmartinez5002]

I think you should read some of the PotC essays on the blog passport2dreams: old and new, she had some great ideas in those essays about how the rides work and how they contextually inform each other, and some strengths of the Florida pirates I had never considered, good video

[@marksommers6764]

At 09:16 "ImporAnt" dropping the T are we ? Alright...no more pronunciation bashing ... DISNEYLANDER , You are spot ON ! The ORIGINAL MAGIC KINGDOM OF PIRATES IN ANAHEIM IS SUPERIOR ! Yes , yes haters , Disneyland Anaheim WAS affectionately called the Magic Kingdom from 1955 (yes , I was there) 'till the '90s . Thanks Disneylander , for the fine research and production . . . And don't be stingy with the "T" , it really is important . 🏰 Have a fan-tastic new year !

[@Disneylander]

Haha, I've certainly made worse pronunciation errors 😋 But thank you! I'm glad you agree!

[@SteveCarras]

He actually DOES pronounce the "T"!

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander I listened, I heard the two Ts.

[@ticketmaster1000]

You’re backkkkk 😱😱😱😱

[@Disneylander]

Yes, finally a real video! Haha

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander Hey, where'd you get the (sotck?) string music, heck, the "Pirate" music between the "parts"(1, 2, ) etc. Neat!

[@happilyeverawkward1948]

Now I gotta go watch the povs before I make any sort of assumption. Granted never been to wdw though sooo biasedly disneyland 😂😂😂

[@jeanettesmith765]

The queue is better in WDW, but I agree that Disneyland POTC is the better one. Florida built their's smaller so had to leave more out.

[@MrDgoodrow]

Well for me I prefer Disneyland exactly I get the point here for the drops I have been to WDW though but I know has one drop how many then one are there other mini drops ? Disneyland I get it have two drops but dose have three or other mini ones I have no ideal I'm just asking a question I hope this is not confusion

[@sunbeamsami]

Disneyland native here! I think Pirates in California is vastly superior. It just has that...feeling. It was built so meticulously and there was so much thought put into it that it just wins. Both parks are so different (like I agree that the exterior and queue in Walt Disney World is better) but the Magic Kingdom lacks the *feeling* that Disneyland has. I'm also so happy you're back and I would love to see a Versus on the Haunted Mansion!

[@Disneylander]

I totally agree!!! The magic in Disneyland is unlike anything else for sure. Thank you so much!

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander Very good Point!

[@felixcortes1685]

I grew up going to Disneyland and the first time I went on disney worlds I was shocked that it ended at the jail scene. I felt ripped off

[@SteveCarras]

Soon after he DID one on that ride! 😎

[@funny.gon-12]

Honestly I feel bad that they even get compared dont get me wrong magic kindom pirates is good but the original Disneyland pirates is my favorite water ride hands down .

[@kristendavis2881]

Disney land version is way better, Its much longer and they have 2 drops I wish Disney world would update there's a bit.

[@davidknee2967]

I respect your opinion a lot but even know disneylands pirates is better I like disneyworlds pirats a lot so I didn't think that you need to bash it but I respect your opinion

[@MCastleberry1980]

I've only been to WDW once, but it seems like more often than not the Disneyland version of an attraction is better for whatever reason.

[@jackieherrera9972]

I love Disneyland’s version best too but one thing I wish it had that is only at WDW is the photo opp that is inside the ride.

[@srayj]

I’ve been to both parks and been on both rides and as soon as I saw the title of this video, I said Disneyland wins. It’s not really even a contest, the one in Disneyland is so much better. I am curious, if the Disneyland version were put up against the one in Shanghai, how would it fair? I’ve never had the opportunity to go to Shanghai and ride it, but just based on videos that I’ve seen, it looks pretty incredible! So, that might be an interesting “vs” to visit in the future.

[@Disneylander]

I totally agree, this one was an easy choice! As far as the Shanghai one goes, though, I'd have to ride it in person to say for sure! It looks absolutely spectacular, but at the same time it's different enough to make it hard to compare. Shanghai has some incredible new technology, but California's Pirates has the classic nostolgia and simplicity. A tough call for sure!

[@srayj]

Disneylander You make a really good point, the Shanghai version is actually based almost solely on the movies, which were inspired by the original Pirates of the Caribbean ride in Disneyland, so, in a way, it’s not really fair to compare them. Also, I am not a fan of the abundance of screen technology now being used on rides, but it looks like it has been pretty well integrated into the practical sets and effects, which I appreciate, but the animatronics in the original are truly an engineering marvel! To think that they created that many is impressive and that they are still around and hold up to modern audiences over 40 years later! Nothing can probably beat the original.

[@powerlinepowerlineentertai1712]

Star Tours at Disneyland & Disney World Vs video. Please.

[@AEWFans]

Im a little biassed but DISNEYLANDS IS WAYYYY BETTTTTEERRR

[@derekpangelinan4229]

New format and style was great! Also - Disneyland’s is way better!

[@Disneylander]

Good to hear, I had fun with it!

[@chandlerjackson3412]

Loved it! Excited to see more videos!

[@Disneylander]

I'm glad you enjoyed it! More videos will be out soon 😁

[@mermaidciara6609]

Disneyland HMP Why ?!

[@williamvannucci]

You did it again!!!! Thank you so much for doing these videos!!!!! They are really fun and entertaining!!!

[@Disneylander]

Thanks for watching!!! I enjoy making them so it's great to have people enjoy watching. Thanks!

[@williamvannucci]

@@Disneylander it actually reminds me. Recently I created an Instagram account and me and a friend name the account DisneylandersA113. Sorry I didn't think about this when we created the account, only that we wanted to base it off but we were doing because we thought what you were trying to do is so amazing and we wanted to do the same on Instagram. We are more than happy to change the title of the accounts that way you can have an official Disneylander account with out people following the wrong perosn. If you want to talk about more, I guess you can either reply to this comment, or message me at will_v_disney . Again, you're probably my favorite KZbinr!

[@Disneylander]

@@williamvannucci no worries dude, the username is totally fine! Thanks for being a great fan!!!

[@DisneyParksMusic.]

I agree with you 💯 percent that Disneyland’s Pirates of the Caribbean should win because even though I have never been to Disney World the ride time for Pirates of the Caribbean is way to short and the ride itself feels to rushed it feels like it begins with a off start and ends in about 5 minutes after that. Disneyland’s Pirates of the Caribbean has a nice, beautiful beginning in the blue bayou and then you go down to sizable drops and has an amazing middle and climax to the story and ends nice with seeing the people standing at the entrance and looking at the parrot scene at the end. Overall the Disneyland version is better!!! 😉🎉🥇

[@Disneylander]

Yes, great points! Disneyland's Pirates has much more to it. The Magic Kingdom's Pirates is good and fun, but it can't compare!

[@DisneyParksMusic.]

Disneylander True! 😂

[@Jp-yb7rx]

Agreed

[@sanikthehedgechalk6543]

did you kow that im actually chimbey bird?

[@docgravenshmit6692]

I agree. I live on the east coast and so I've been to Disney World many times. I finally got to Disneyland and was looking forward to going on Pirates. The ride was great but I was in a boat with people who wouldn't shut up. kind of ruined the experience.

[@Jp-yb7rx]

Oof that sucks

[@BetoElVago2588]

Yeah Disneyland's much better.

[@thedadalorian6048]

I’m going to DisneyLand in 2 weeks!!

[@tomfrigon3840]

The cue in Florida is the only thing that is better

[@TheSkellingtonGhost]

I love that Mark Davis's passion project idea got fit into Phantom Manor's Ghost Town scene.

[@davidknee2967]

nobody cares

[@SteveCarras]

@@davidknee2967 f u.

[@camdroid4936]

WELCOME BACK!! Again! 😂😂

[@Disneylander]

Thank you! Again!!!

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander Are you coming back? No mention is made that the parks were all closed due to the coronavirus, yet that would be outta datge as this week and next all are reopening! DO one on the Haunted Mansion and Small World!

[@autumnchung5758]

I always wonder why this channel doesn’t have as much subscribers as it should. It’s really amazing!🤩

[@Disneylander]

Thank you so much for saying so!!!~ I'm glad you're enjoying it!

[@SoCalGuy20]

Disneyland's is beyond better than Magic Kingdom's. You got this one right.

[@davidknee2967]

I like Disney Worlds pirates a lot and I think it’s underrated.But Disneyland’s pirates is better but you didn’t need to bash Disney Worlds so much it’s a great ride even know the California one is better. But I respect your opinion

[@MrDgoodrow]

I like the versus a lot by the way I Subscrib to this video the details is very outstanding and the whole this is very spot on I'm sticking to channel I agree with your thoughts and my opining is nothing I trust your opining

[@Disneylander]

Thank you so much! I'm glad you enjoyed the video!

[@rocketgroot4311]

The first time I went to Disneyland I was a toddler apparently so I never remembered that time But the second time I went I was 12 or 13 But I remember when l entered Pirates of the Caribbean & the queue was so beautiful and so immersive when I was inside that queue i felt like it was nighttime Despite it being sunny outside And getting on the boat and overlooking the Bayou My God was I in Awe..

[@sanikthehedgechalk6543]

im just on my laptop

[@thatboicarter7419]

I completely agree. I still really like Disney world’s version, though I believe they could add more scenes. I think they could add the skeletons at the end of the ride.

[@ericaburto242]

One of the world’s best you tube channels I know

[@Disneylander]

Thank you so much, Erick!

[@justimagine2403]

The definitive Disney ride and only Disneyland gets it right. The capacity of this ride is giant, 40,000 riders a day. It can handle people! But the ride up the waterfall at the end, totally awesome and unexpected!

[@N8R_Quizzie]

I agree with this fully. I've only been to Florida, but I love the tropical aesthetic and pirates anyways. I just went to Disneyland for the first time and it's not even close. The queue is easily better in Florida, but it wouldn't make sense to put it in Disney Land.

[@toptobottom247]

Well...I have experienced them all. Admittedly the Disneyland version in this comparison wins over Disney Worlds version. I want to add no holds barred Tokyo Disney' s version was way more entertaining even though it was centered around Davey Jones and Jack Sparrow. It is ultimately my favorite.

[@ao9688]

Glad to see you back! Can’t wait to see what you have for us

[@Disneylander]

Thank you! It's good to be back!

[@SteveCarras]

Hadn't realy noticed how long he was away, just really got accquainted with this earlier last nite.

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander Good.

[@KINGCHRIS_XI]

You either do it right or not at all, I wish we got Marks original attraction at WDW instead and maybe later worked in pirates if there was space and with extra allotted time.

[@joieohanesian2020]

I think Disneyland California one is better because I grew up in California so ya Disneyland wins in my opinion

[@davidthomas283]

the Utilidors' in Magic Kingdom is probably why Pirates drop is small.

[@MrDgoodrow]

The question is how is the theme song Yo Ho a life for me how is it different then in Magic Kingdom to Disneyland ?

[@justincarasick7824]

1:22

[@boomer9518]

JEAN LAFFITE

[@matthewaguilar4249]

I’m so sad they removed the waterfall and the other part

[@tenchi586]

Fantastic video! I'm glad I subscribed to your channel. I'll agree with you that the Disneyland Pirates is better. I've been on both versions too. I especially love the longer cave sequences on the Disneyland version. As a Floridian, I wish we had the treasure rooms and the extra caves as well as two waterfall drops, though I understand they couldn't put a second drop in because of the high water table in this state. That said, I give the Disneyland version a 10/10 and the Magic Kingdom an 8/10. I still very much enjoy the Magic Kingdom one, even if I like the Disneyland one more. However, I will say I don't miss the blue bayou and here's why. I live in northern Florida, and there are tons of areas like the blue bayou in my location in which I see trees sticking out of the water and Spanish moss draped on the branches. The blue bayou scene to me isn't very foreign where I live. I feel the Magic Kingdom queue of Pirates does a great job in slowly immersing the rider into the experience. Anyway, thanks for your thoughts. I can't wait to watch more of your videos.

[@Disneylander]

Thank you so much! I definitely agree that wine great scenes are missing in Disney World. Even without the bayou, though, I think they should have added something like it, though. Maybe nighttime on a Caribbean beach or something! The dark slow start of the ride in California sets the mood for the rest in my opinion. Thanks again, though!!!

[@mermaidciara6609]

I think your a good youtuber 😁😁😁🤗

[@Disneylander]

Thank you so much!!!

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander :D you ARE!

[@nicolesaid8668]

tonight while looking up food reviews for disneyland I came upon the best and worst restaurant picks that you and Aurora did.. I love the two of you together. So I just subscribed and am now looking through the other videos you have. I am hoping to get tips on how to save time, find short lines, interesting things to see, do and eat in downtown disney, tips on how to save money in disneyland and DCA. Please keep putting up the videos, this information is so valuable. Myself, as well as millions of other people are spending a lot of money to fly in from out of country for an amazing experience and want to be well informed ahead of time to get the most bang for our buck. .

[@Disneylander]

Thank you so much, I'm so glad the videos have been helpful and entertaining for you!!! I should definitely make some more videos with visiting tips like the cheap foods one, I haven't done that in awhile!

[@maximiliandelfino4017]

Dude, you deserve SO many more subscribers! The quality of your videos is amazing! 😄

[@Disneylander]

Wow, thank you so much! That means a lot to me! 😁

[@kitchensinkchronicles3272]

even though the anehiem park is my home park (i live in california), i ended up riding pirates in florida first. i was actually kinda underwhelmed. i had fun and enjoyed my time there, but it wasn’t as amazing as people made it out to be. when i finally got to ride it here in disneyland i was absolutely blown away. it’s a genuine feat of imagineering that i’m glad i got to experience second, since i’m sure if i had ridden the two pirates in the other order i would e been disappointed. disneyland wins for sure!

[@SteveCarras]

It's FAR longer in California, isn't it? :-)

[@Jp-yb7rx]

Yes it is way longer and better cuz it has many scenes in Disneyland that were left out in Florida

[@misplacedmtnman]

I have a question I was hoping you might be able to answer. Living on the east coast I have only ever enjoyed the WDW version of Pirates. When KZbin came along, I was finally able to see just how much more awesome the Disneyland version is, and there is one section of that ride I am curious about. Right after you pass through the jail scene where the imprisoned pirates are whistling at the dog, you cruise through an area (before you get to the armory scene) where there are a bunch of broken beams and wooden slats above, and you can hear creaking noises. I believe at one time there was an effect that made it appear the ceiling was about to collapse and cave in but I cannot find a good video of this particular area. Most of the time everything is stationary and there doesn't seem to be a point to this scene. There is a chair and a bottle (and perhaps some other stuff) up in the rafters, but I never can tell what is supposed to be happening, or what used to happen when the effect was in operation. No one ever comments on this part of the ride so I was hoping you could shed some light on it. Thanks!

[@Disneylander]

That whole area of the ride is designed to look like it's about to fall in on itself, though there's not really an "effect", rather a stationary set. You pass under a wooden pier of some sort that is falling apart and smouldering in parts as if it was recently in fire. There's beams and chairs and things that look like they should fall in on themselves and crash onto the riders, but they're held up by wires 😉

[@SteveCarras]

@@Disneylander Hope you didn't get that copyright strike!

[@snowykitten6860]

Magic kingdom = Disney world in Florida?

[@Disneylander]

Yes! The Magic Kingdom is one of Disney World's 4 parks!

[@neoserenityangel]

I have to say while reviewing the video of both the parks POC in DL wins hands down for authenticity and the longer ride time and bayou etc that said... but probably in my biased opinion that the POC in the Magic Kingdom is underrated yes while the ride time is shorter and not much to it decor wise and shorter scenes it still had an authentic real feel to it IE the cannonballs shooting over your head etc it didn't lack charm and the overall experience was fun the queue was the most detailed it really isn't a bad ride I do agree with you on that the Magic Kingdom should have worked on POC for a few more years the ride could have been epic or had worked on their river adventure

[@mermaidciara6609]

I live in Florida so I ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🤗❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ Disney world 🌍

[@Disneylander]

Disney World is awesome!

[@ItzAdrian02]

Mermaid Ciara WDW version may not be the best version, it's still a fantastic ride, as long as it has a drop plunge.

[@Disneylander]

@@ItzAdrian02 it's true, it's still a ton of fun!

[@nicolaszambrano1208]

I agree with you the original is always the best