PIXAR THEORY: How “Emma Jean” Connects Toy Story, Up, and Inside Out!

[@jenji1120]

...I don't see how people don't like the genetics. That's actually one of my absolute FAVORITE parts. I love when he compares hair, eye color, left/right handedness, etc. I love it SOOOOOOO much c:

[@JuliaNightmare]

Kivuli Malkia same here.

[@yeppepperoni]

Kivuli Malkia agreed

[@jason222shark]

Kivuli Malkia anyone up for some Punnett squares?

[@Frankthegb]

I think it's because most people don't understand it and don't care to understand it, or because they believe that Pixar wouldn't put that much thought into their movies because they're made for children.

[@everestcanyon5647]

I guess you are just interested in things like that. Some are, some aren't.

[@aidanw892]

What if Emma was asked to Bear the child since Ellie cant

[@TheTheorizer]

interesting... Incredibly interesting...

[@SirenUndine]

tankaider 02 I was thinking the same thing!

[@tomaszlosinski875]

That would make more sense than a teenager having a child before marriage in quite a conservative time period.

[@angrypeg8064]

That would make perfect sense!

[@nicolekester9072]

That would add so many more levels to the beginning of up

[@rualker1090]

Andy's dad is obviously Marlin from nemo. HAVE YOU SEEN MY SON

[@redfox5809]

LOL

[@mariagbayeh3592]

lol😂

[@mariagbayeh3592]

lol😂

[@mariagbayeh3592]

lol

[@mel.xnx._]

omg I'm dead

[@lilyjohnson8066]

What if Emma Jean took the kids got full custody and when she said "we" in the letter she was meaning her and the children!

[@reddiamondcat3391]

Lily Johnson Emma’s name isn’t Karen

[@zenvanden991]

@@reddiamondcat3391 you deserve the world

[@bruhsoundeffect2808]

RedDiamondCat oof

[@johnbledsoe1664]

If the letter was very old than that would make sense.

[@iAmMadeOfSoup]

Emma Jean is not my lover, she's just a girl who claims that I am the one, but the kid is not my son

[@thwb4661]

Ahh I see what you did there 😅

[@tylerryan7959]

That move you did there was smoother than a smooth criminal.

[@rubbergamer5092]

nice

[@phayara]

That sound more like a thriller

[@blobtheblobb6653]

Just beat it, Pearl

[@julicastillo118]

Jean is often a middle name instead of a last. what if Emma Jean and Ellie F were sisters. Carl F started a relationship with Emma but then fell for Ellie. With Emma and Ellie being sisters, of course they would eventually forgive each other and make amends. Emma could be mom to Jenn and Jill. Since Carl and Ellie couldn't have children, they probably were pretty close to Jenn and Jill and then loved Molly, Andy, and Riley a lot since they would never have grand kids, and would probably seem like another set of grand parents to them, which is why Riley's family would have a picture of her. And if Emma was Andy, Molly, and Riley's grandmother, it would make sense that she would send a post card while away and why it would have value to Andy. So if Emma's middle name is Jean, what's her last name? It could be Davis. Maybe Jenn had a divorce and took back her maiden name, or was not married when she had Andy, do Andy's dad may have a different last name than Davis. OR, option two is Jenn is on a loveless marriage with a man who's always at work and is busy. Daycare is super expensive. They have a nice house and a nice neighborhood. Andy gets the newest coolest toys (Buzz). Nice birthday parties and Christmas's. That's a lot for a single mom to afford and still have family time. Thoughts?

[@shae8877]

Juli Castillo that wasbthe longest comment I've ever seen

[@shae8877]

* was the

[@castro2338]

Juli Castillo it's a fucking KZbin video not an essay for your English class.

[@julicastillo118]

+Castro and who forced you to read it?

[@SaurianStudios1207]

Juli Castillo has riley ever met andy?(at least outside the events that the movie depicts)

[@SeamusGorman4]

This just blew my mind omg hahaha

[@TheTheorizer]

I try, lol.

[@l.dawson2089]

Seamus Gorman Hi Seamus! I love you and your videos! ♡♡

[@aplam94]

Seamus Gorman ur awesome

[@ryansymons7179]

Hey Theorizer and Seamus, it would be AMAZING if you both did like a combination video.

[@calypso7452]

Seamus Gorman love your channel!

[@catalinamatamala110]

in the incredibles the woman with gray hair has the last name davis

[@awesometheoryalert8846]

Catfix She does and Her and Mr. Incredible don't have a VERY good relationship so maybe one day she went out and cheated? huh? I'm just THEORYING?

[@JustMorganVII]

But she is a woman and weare looking for a man, maybe her father is andys father too and they are related, but the incredibles would have to be in a time after toy story cause it would mean that in toy story 4 Andy being grown up, is when the incredibles is taking place or is about to.

[@laurybonaventure3836]

Awesome Theory Alert she was never with mr.incredible tho

[@luischigne1969]

Archadious GC Well I think it can't be, because The Incredibles takes place in 1962.

[@TheRealJohnStephenson]

Luis Chigne Maybe she's Andy's aunt or grandmother on his father's side?

[@andrewkemp8677]

Bill is the father. Emma Jean is not the full name, Her full name is Emma Jean Davis. Emma Is Elie's SISTER. Carl Falls for the sister after having a kid (or 2) with Emma (Jennifer and Jill). Bill does the EXACT same thing by leaving Andy's mom for HER SISTER after having Andy and Molly. The theme is repeated where the guy falls for the sister and the girl left being keeps the maiden name for her kids, thus the name, Davis, gets passed down. It's like a curse passed down through a family tree. Dark, I know.

[@johannamartinez3393]

Andrew Kemp o..m...g

[@keirabroom5844]

Andrew Kemp that's what I found

[@bristol8460]

That's actually really good

[@cyphansepticpewdieplier492]

so carl and bill are two timers and maybe andy will do the same 😱😱😱

[@kimberlybarger7226]

😱😱😱

[@RandomlyBeautiful13]

If The Incredibles takes place in ...62' I believe...Jack Jack would be 33 in 1995 when the first toy story came out. Andy is 6 years old in the first movie, meaning at the time Andy was born, Jack Jack would be 27. My theory gets a little far fetched when I say that since supers have resurfaced, maybe Jack Jack doesn't want to be associated and changes his name. (Maybe last. Maybe entire.) Like many failing marriages, they had Molly in an attempt to save it, but it didn't work, which is why she's so young. Jack Jack has brown hair and blue eyes. "So what about Molly? She's blonde." Yes. The recessive trait. Jack Jack's father and brother are both blonde. "Wouldn't Andy and Molly have powers then?" As far as I recall from the pixar theory, super kids are only produced if both their parents are supers. So that's my theory as to why Jack Jack is Andy's father.

[@james_birchmore]

WOW! It all make sense!

[@angel_wings3957]

sounds right

[@bensonbbarry2945]

RandomlyBeautiful13 MIND BLOWN!!! WOOOOAAAHHH

[@lakeboat1634]

wow.......good theory

[@chatnoirgirl1317]

RandomlyBeautiful13 U R GOOD!

[@josh.0220]

Andy's dad is the grasshopper from A Bug's Life

[@callumfinlayson-palmer8393]

Joshua Hurd it makes so much more sense now

[@thedarklordmegatron7111]

No, it's Barry the Bee.

[@josh.0220]

Daffa Rabin what if it's Barry the Kramer

[@thedarklordmegatron7111]

Joshua Hurd No, I think it's Barry the Obama

[@josh.0220]

Daffa Rabin that one I like

[@numberoneweezerfan3000]

Andy's Dad died of polio syndrome and those pictures above the stairs are of him DOES ANDY EVEN WEAR GLASSES and have Woody to him duh

[@landonfigueroa8452]

Addison Hodge you saw super Carlin brothers didn't you? I did to

[@numberoneweezerfan3000]

YASSSS THEY GUUUUUUUUUD

[@kayaroberts7100]

that theory was debunked last year

[@beeboy6945]

andy from toy story is atculy andy jr

[@Izix-kd4ce]

That theory was debunked

[@Superlazerninja12]

What if Emma Jean is the old woman from Ratatouille and her husband is dead and that postcard was sent before he died and it was sent after she moved to France.

[@StellarMoo97]

Superlazerninja12 well she had brown eyes I think and white hair very white hair if she had dark hair before I don't think it be so white so she could of had blonde or light down hair

[@LightningScorpion53]

Superlazerninja12 That's good!!

[@Superlazerninja12]

angelica pages I just went and watched Theorizer's ratatouille video, the old lady has blue eyes.Also if Emma and Carl are the parents of Jennifer Davis and Jill Andersen and the old lady is Emma Jean and she and Gusteau are the parents of Anton Ego and Linguini like the theorizer said in that video, that would mean Linguini and Anton are the half brothers of Jennifer and Jill and the uncles of Andy, Molly, and Riley

[@hurricanemeem]

wouldn't that also mean Anton ego and Jennifer and Jill are half siblings?

[@Superlazerninja12]

Shahira Khan I said that in my reply to my first comment

[@darkbowserdofus9978]

Tri state area? Blue ear eyes? Brown hair? Its Phineas and Ferb's dad

[@rockinrich8]

Darkbowserdofus99 maybe... dun dun DUN

[@strawberry9192]

oml

[@healthyham5266]

I thought it had to be a Pixar movie

[@aaaaa4330]

Rose 0804 it was a joke Einstein

[@luxlisbon2727]

YASSS

[@EveIsNotPosh]

You didn't exactly mention this, but what if Emma Jean's 'we' was not in reference to her S.O., but to her and her children. Carl would want an update on them, and it seems remiss to have completely glossed over them. Just something to think about

[@itsthehumor95]

Pen and Key Eve very good point!!

[@adelaidewinters8147]

Pen and Key Eve that's a good point

[@kayleyy9686]

Pen and Key Eve GOOD POINT

[@QueenEra33]

Pen and Key Eve thought the same thing

[@RinSere]

Might be all the above too.

[@toiletpaper6092]

The super carlin brothers revealed in an interview that andys dad died of polio and that woody was his fathers Plz watch the video

[@justsomeotherguy5679]

I LOVED that story! I pray to God that we at least get a Pixar short depicting it!

[@Flowerhays]

What if that was a lie made up by andy's mom to protect her son and daughter?

[@averynored6249]

It was debunked by the head of Pixar

[@donnalynn2]

I love that Super Carlin Bros always get interviews with Pixar. They just get us so much info but I also love how the Theorizer literally spends hours and hours trying to figure everything out.

[@thepowersaw6245]

I think that the father is Nemo's mom because clownfish can become the other gender when necessary.

[@Josh-iu7jr]

Herp Derpington YES WE HAVE A LEAD

[@thepowersaw6245]

the evidence points right to it.

[@flazzorb]

HE IS THE... well... he's both father and mother...

[@hush64]

Herp Derpington didn't everyone know that

[@jamstarr]

but its a fish....

[@andrew602]

Pixar: *clap* ok time to make a new movie to make this theory impossible

[@tharshena9283]

Alien.Stevonnie Haha ikr

[@cerebralcloud92]

Tharshena Reddy They already have. Andy’s Dad is dead, having given Woody to Andy. All the pictures in the original house that “are of Andy” are not entirely of Andy. Some of them are of Mr. Davis when he was a kid. SuperCarlinBrothers already covered that.

[@guess6635]

Alien.Stevonnie this need way more likes

[@renmoore9592]

Emma is Carl's sister. Jennifer is her daughter. Bill is Andy's dad. After a huge fight with Jennifer, they divorced. Carl gave him the post card. Bill married Jill. They adopted Riley. They adopted Riley, because Jill couldn't have children. After finding out, she bumped into Ellie, who became a mother figure to her. That's why she has the photo. Deal with it.

[@kinsey010]

It's been confirmed that Emma was Carl's old love interest. So your theory doesn't add up, sorry.

[@humanbeing7634]

Kawaii Gem Yessss! That's what I was thinking! I made a comment about the sister thing but not the rest of the stuff 😂

[@renmoore9592]

Hope In It's Purest Form I'm sorry, apparently you can't read. My comment says "deal with it". I don't fricken care what you have to say. Oh, and if you try to get back and be salty, guess you should change your username.

[@kinsey010]

I wasn't trying to be rude, calm down. I was just pointing out flaw in your theory and wasn't saying sorry sarcastically but I actually was sorry since you took all that time to think of that theory. There's no need to be rude and attack me like that. You misunderstood.

[@renmoore9592]

Hope In It's Purest Form I'm sorry, that was mean of me. I shouldn't have lashed out like that.

[@AWESOME2715]

10:02 Actually, there are pictures of Andy's father RIGHT THERE. That's not Andy in those pictures. Its his recently deceased father.

[@b.s.6728]

Dominic Gonzales why would there be childhood pictures of him on the wall, but not Andy or his mom? If it was a memorial they wouldn't just be a bunch of childhood photos when everyone in the house only knew him as an adult

[@naima7765]

Bee Stee no she/he’s right I saw that video too it’s true that’s Andy’s father that died but I don’t know why it’s of him in his childhood

[@BungieStudios]

Andy Sr. was not obsessed with his childhood past. Those are pictures of his son.

[@jefrenpinote1689]

Just watch the supercarlinbrothers toy Story 0 you repliers

[@alien.complex]

Actually, they are indeed photos of Andy Sr. It was stated in the movies that the Andy looked a lot like his father, and the SuperCarlinBrothers made a video detailing an interview they had with one of the movie's creators. Andy Sr. had polio as a child, and his family were poor, not to mention the fact that back then the vaccines were harder to get back then. Fortunately, Andy Sr. recovered. Around the same time, however, there was a competition hosted by Cowboy Crunchies cereal for a free Woody doll, right as Sputnik was launched into space. Almost every child that had entered had most likely moved on from Woody and his Roundup gang, is what the producers thought, so the Woody prototype was thrown out. Andy Sr. had made his letter for the Woody doll decorative and detailed about why he couldn't meet the full requirements. One of the producers for Woody's Roundup decided that instead of throwing out the one Woody doll in existence, it would be better to give it away to the child she thought deserved it most. Andy Sr.'s letter caught her eye, so she read it and instantly decided he was the one who deserved the prototype doll. Andy Sr. recieved the Woody doll whilst he still had polio, so the family locked it away for safekeeping whilst they burned all his other possessions, aside from Mr. Potato Head and Slinky to make sure that nobody else got polio. This explains why one of the photos hanging on the wall has a picture of what looks like Andy wearing glasses, when throughout the movies it has been shown that he hasn't actually needed them. Polio makes eyesight worse, and so of course Andy Sr. would need glasses if he was infected with said disease. Jumping into the future to around a year before the first Toy Story, and Andy Sr. has been hit by polio yet again. Due to his lack of schooling from having the disease as a child and the lack of funds his parents would have had to send him off to college, they are still living in Andy's childhood home since they had nowhere else (assuming that Carl and Emma are indeed Jennifer Davis' parents, neither of them may have wanted to take in a family of four, especially during retirement). A ressurgance of polio is essentially a death sentence, as it comes back stronger and way more fierce than originally. Nobody else in the family is affected due to vaccines, and there is basically no way of helping Andy Sr. now. He gives the key to his toybox to his son, Andy. It hasn't been touched in years because of polio, and whilst all of this has been going on, Woody, Slinky and Mr. Potato Head had all been in the dark, not knowing what was going on as they were in a deep sleep, similar to that of the one Jessie, Bullseye and Stinky Pete experienced in storage. Andy goes up to put away the ket in a special place, and when he goes back down to continue his conversation with his father, he finds out that he is dead. The next week, they have a funeral. Andy had forgotten all about the key to the toybox, but when he went home and went back up to his room, there it is. He decides to use it to see what his father had been hiding this whole time, and in there he finds just three things. A Mr. Potato Head, a Slinky Dog and a Woody doll, the only one in existence. Because Andy Sr. was infected by polio around the same age that Andy was at the time his father died, the toys couldn't notice any difference between the father and son, since they'd been in the toybox for so long. Molly is born not knowing who her father was, and Jennifer Davis becomes a widow. That is the story of Andy's father. Please forgive me for any forgotten pieces of information, spelling or grammatical errors I made in this, it is extremely late and I cannot be bothered to look over it all. I hope this covered the basic premises of what happened for anyone who bothered to read all of this.

[@nudel6750]

Andy's dad is shrek Yes I know that's dreamworks

[@uny4781]

Nudel *Sigh* I hate you.

[@mackenziealessandrini2543]

This is my favorite comment

[@mauralawton3260]

Shrek isn't a human

[@greenworksbleach8320]

Maura Lawton screw logic in the butt.

[@kikiguzman3309]

Nudel Shrek is love. Shrek is life.

[@fadedash2644]

Maybe when Emma Jean said "We" she meant her and Jennifer and jill??:p

[@vlogconvos5429]

Wow. That actually makes a lot of sense. After all, Carl would probably be interested in how his kids were doing.

[@evaanciaes5940]

*Qxeen_Ash* good point!

[@jemedra5113]

*Qxeen_Ash* nice point there

[@scottbaker2226]

Good point, he obviously didn't have much custody of them anyway. So maybe he was a deadbeat dad?

[@SoCaitlynANDKelly]

just a theory but what if JakJak from 'The Incredibles' was Andy's father? JakJak has blue eyes and blonde/brown hair. You're probably wondering about the last name. In the movie JakJak's last name was not "Davis", but was "Parr". Maybe when JakJak grew up and gained control of his powers he realised that he didn't want to be part of the whole "superhero" thing and decided to move away and change his last name. Lol just a theory tho.

[@haris4482]

This is such a good theory

[@davesmith6917]

or it is a fake name to blend in and be normal .

[@MindOfSheesh]

Chloe Crinnion weird theory but whatever

[@Vogg26]

wtf..

[@Antasma1]

Chloe Crinnion I hope this was a joke

[@jasminejara1187]

I have a theory too What if Andy and Riley were swichted.What I mean is that Jennifer and Jill had there babies a and somehow they switched there kids that will explain how Rayle looks more like Jennifer and Andy looks more like Jills.

[@tindraholm8907]

Thank you! I thought about it through the whole video! (Sorry for the spelling and grammar)

[@lunalovegood2337]

Project Fun hi

[@Bigback08]

Actually, Stated by The Super Carlin Brothers. Andy and his father have the same features....So this wouldn’t be possible..

[@jpiano6100]

Project Fun lllllll.l.l..l

[@keegancole6083]

Project Fun they have a large age gap though

[@awoken2562]

Solved it. It's Mr. Incredible. They broke up because she realised he had an ability.

[@awoken2562]

Buuut, she had an ability too, and so did Andy, to bring toys to life without him knowing; Andy's sister was adopted so that's why she doesn't have one.

[@awoken2562]

Oh, and in Emmas Wedding, behind the family you mentioned, you think that looks a little like Mrs. Incredible, or maybe her mother?

[@mackenziealessandrini2543]

What if she hasn't discovered her ability yet.

[@drefeddi4942]

Awoken n that y she looks diff

[@im-vx9xc]

Awoken maybe...

[@emmahanley5747]

Jessie was seen on the floor of Boo's room in Monster Inc, could Boo be involved in this??

[@evaanciaes5940]

Emma Hanley the thing is that they have too much easter eggs that don't mean nothing

[@emmahanley5747]

I still dont really understand the whole concept of Easter eggs

[@evaanciaes5940]

Emma Hanley well easter eggs are those "hide messages" that are everywhere in the movies

[@therealbianca5952]

Boo could be Riley's mom and when she gave up Jessie as she got older it would make sense and the timing would add up to how Jessie meets up with Andy years later and it would also make sense that the moms had grown up in the same area since they r sisters so hence why Riley's moms old toy would be in the possession of the crazy toy guy who lives in there home town

[@calicomarker]

Boo could be rileys mom? Do u mean Riley could be boo's mom??

[@honeysuckledudley1950]

I think that Ellie not being able to have children is significant..... Emma and Ellie are sisters. Ellie can't have kids- Emma is carring DNA similar to Ellie- Carl and Emma have a child together, planning on Ellie and Carl to adopt. some big family drama and Emma keeps the child. Emma eventually gets married to someoneDavis and has a son- MrDavis. Making Emma, Andy's grandmother, it would make sense that Andy has a post card from her. to symbolise that people come back after a divorce. Or is it just me?

[@channeycash2609]

I hope y'all notice this. If Emma is really Emma's friend, she would come to her wedding. Emma is not on the front row, since that is ONLY for the family. What I want everyone to do is scan the wedding carefully and if we find a woman there that resembles an exact woman to the other Pixar movies, then that woman truly will be EMMA JEAN! :D

[@ginaaa596]

That would mean that Jennifer and Mr Davis are siblingd

[@lexilillypad5545]

In Andy's house there are pictures of Andy's dad

[@eileenkimble7510]

Where

[@MeepsLovely]

Where???

[@Evancore-u6v]

Randomly Awesome All the pictures you thought were Andy we’re actually Andy’s father. Mike Mozart who was a friend of Joe Raft confirmed this in a interview with the super Carlin brothers

[@Aar0nDavis]

I do not have a wife or son.

[@bellahuffstetler135]

Aaron Davis Well it's not this guy. Thanks for your contribution to the theorizer community :)

[@soccer_1452]

Aaron Davis Lol! 😂

[@miadavis5993]

Aaron Davis Lol me neither + im not a man so well yeah u get the picture lol 😂😂😂

[@jaynesmith249]

Aaron Davis don't deny it... YOUR THE FATHER😂😂

[@miadavis5993]

Jayne Smith 😂😂😂😂😂 im glad im a girl lol

[@c4sper123]

I don't know why but the guy in Toy Story 2, the guy who fixed woody's arm is somehow related, I don't know how nor why but I have a feeling

[@madofdad]

I bet your right

[@devongrant3027]

stephen hewitt What if the reason that Andy never knew his father is cuz his dad is like a god or a Demi god or something

[@devongrant3027]

Or maybe it's just some black guy

[@goblinmaez4742]

I bet you are right

[@devildognick321]

hey thats a good theory

[@gtfrias]

u deserve more subs your great

[@vickd4683]

francisco frias *you’re

[@ashlyndallas2024]

francisco frias SO TRUE!!!

[@lindsaylindsay2453]

Lewis Memeking jeez don’t make a big deal about it

[@noobkiller3567]

Well add me I just subbed

[@josevillaperez5384]

I know dude 😤

[@ADAMan123]

You hyped for toy story 4? I mean not that it will be a good movie, but it might add to this theory.

[@katielynn9909]

Adam Ferry WAIT THERES GONNA BE A TOY STORY 4? WUTTT

[@ADAMan123]

Yeah there is

[@firstlast8720]

It's going to be trash since the other movies are ok and we all know how movies get progressively bad

[@ADAMan123]

Oh no it will be terrible

[@youredoingfineyt]

Toy Story 4 gone be focused on woody and bo’s love story

[@liyahboogie471]

If this make any sence the baby from incredibles 2 which comes out 2018 the baby has blue eyes and brown hair. The pixar theory says the incredibles timelime is 1950-1960 and if the baby is still zero (even if he was like 5 or something) so if the baby is still zero from 1960 to 1997 the baby would be around 37 now to toy story 1 andy is 6 in that movie and if the baby was andys father is the baby the baby would of had him around age 31 I dont know if that makes any sence ITS A THEORY

[@ivanliscelotte]

Aaliyah murray J

[@xealexander241]

Aaliyah murray but wouldn't Andy have superpowers??

[@margaritaflores8114]

Xe Alexander he has the power of friendship

[@bellebradlington5924]

Xe Alexander you only get the powers if both parents are a super

[@ashhtuin]

Maybe the mother wasn't a super?

[@ShiddyKong]

Pixar is a training course designed by the Government to seek out the most professional stalkers in the world.

[@davidhasalastname6423]

seems legit

[@Sarah-jt8fz]

😱😱😱😱

[@myhobbylol]

I did some research and as it turns out RUSSELL from UP'S last name is davis!!!

[@myhobbylol]

livewire jameez man just google

[@saucyboii2669]

Anna Reeves OMG WE HAVE TO DO MORE RESEARCH!!!

[@rosared7464]

yep, that is Jennifer Davis husband, that explains why they have the picture on the shelf.😎

[@rubydeane4758]

Anna Reeves wat if Emma and her new husband had a child (russell) and that's why at the end of the film we see his mum smile at russell and Mr F cuz there still friends and she alows russell to go with him cuz she knows him, she knows he couldnt have kids with ellie so she let's him spend time with Mr F

[@Adam-yumyum]

Ruby Deane you have a point

[@ludwigv928]

This is way too complicated... So let's just say *Woody is Andy's father*

[@ghostghost8806]

*Detective Pikachu has entered the chat*

[@Evancore-u6v]

Did Boo/The Witch have something to do with it 😂 I mean Since many consider boo as the which in brave, she is very capable of magic With this logic Marlin from Finding Nemo could also be a candidate because he could’ve been human before, got turned into a fish by Boo either by mistake or intentionally in Boos part met COARL who could’ve been human before too, had Nemo and got herself and her other kids killed That would mean Nemo would technically be Andy’s step brother and vicevursa Yeah out of context this theory seems stupid but when you think about it it could be possible 🤔😯

[@RafaelRODRIGUEZ-sb5pg]

No he's not Andys dad died when he was really young

[@deleetiusproductions3497]

How did you know?!

[@phrozti188]

Bro check his latest community post😭 how'd bro call it 3 years ago

[@racheldowning5300]

Andys dad is Mater from cars.

[@parceIfish]

what .even .

[@cass3035]

Aesthetic Rodeo obviously yeah! I was screaming it at the screen! It's so obvious! I mean, just look at the rust on Andy's skin!

[@parceIfish]

+CarJar Blobfish um . what r u thinking a car had u no what with a person and made andy u idiot

[@cass3035]

it's kay kay Hey! I will have no car discrimination here!

[@parceIfish]

+CarJar Blobfish what

[@Socksshoesandhats]

WHAT IF ANDY'S FATHER IS THE TOY COLLECTOR? HOW WOULD HE KNOW WERE WOODY WAS?

[@Socksshoesandhats]

He does have brown hair, but sadly has brown eyes.

[@sebastiansanchezchuquimia7734]

Socks, shoes, and hats blue eyes can skip generation

[@electrixassassin2522]

Socks, shoes, and hats I don't think so because if the toy collector was was wouldn't Andy's mom recognize him when they met at the yard sale?

[@theaidenvids]

Electrixassassin 25 true

[@jelko2311]

Chicken man, Andy's father, please

[@dawsonthecreative]

Hey just found something on this theory… I noticed how in toy story 3 and a few shorts after Toy Story 3 Bonnie's Mom look identical to Riley's mom and what's Rileys last name? ANDERSON. What's Bonnie's Mom last name? ANDERSON. Boom there's your link to how there related right there. Emma jeans kid could have been Bonnie's Mom and then have close relatives after that! Hope you can make something of this!

[@emmabelcourt9909]

But the names are spelt different.

[@dawsonthecreative]

Emma Belcourt ok true true but still they changed there names maybe the last names too so it's a little less obvious?…

[@Nekonokitikiti]

It's not impossible that they're related even with the spelling difference... For example, my father's family name is spelled two different ways, because when one of his father's (my grandfather's) brothers went into military service, they misspelled it, and then that entire branch of the family now has the 'misspelled' name, from the fact it was legally changed to that when he enlisted. It would be a bit of an out there detail, but I doubt Pixar would stick to simple details, myself XD

[@HOWLWOLF]

Nekonokitikiti No, it makes sense. My dad's legal name is Montaño, but mine is legally Montano without the accent so we don't have the same last name technically.

[@Nekonokitikiti]

Wolf O'Donnell Haha, I think it's actually more common than people think, then; ours is Green vs. Greene. I can totally see how accented names would have that problem XD

[@livrandomness2233]

I think that andys father is you and your trying to hide it with this theory

[@logicalnonsense4546]

Is this why they're making a Toy Story 4? (Even though they really shouldn't and just keep up with the shorts) Are they just trying to widen the mystery and reveal more about Andy's dad? Will they reveal his face? His name even?

[@sammyhoffman4812]

Logical Nonsense I think they just ran out of ideas and want more money.

[@logicalnonsense4546]

Sammy Hoffman well, it's probably still an opportunity for them to mess with us with even more Easter eggs that will cause more theories like this to fill up the Internet.

[@sammyhoffman4812]

Logical Nonsense true

[@corinnez7778]

Logical Nonsense

[@primalwarriors8526]

Logical Nonsense wait there making a number 4 God dame pixar learn to leave something alone when it should be done also I would prefer a jak and Daxter movie

[@katiestevenson7742]

Or what if: Carl temporarily broke up with Ellie when they in their teenagers year and dated a girl called Emma-Jean who was actually very similar to Ellie. Carl at some point reliese that he broke up with Ellie over something very stupid and he didn't actually love Emma-Jean, only the bits of her than reminded of Ellie, he gets back with Ellie. Emma and Ellie has a difficult time getting along at first because they both want Carl attention but soon enough they become good friends with each other. Emma-Jean has a child called Andy Sr. Emma-Jean during her life best friends with Ellie and Carl Freddickson but wasn't invented to their wedding which was family only. She wrote them the Postcard, but soon after she is told by Carl than Ellie died while she on holiday, Emma-Jean takes the postcard as a memory to never forget Ellie and in while up in Andy Room. Ellie 2nd sister could took the photo of her from the house. Maybe she only had young picture of Ellie and therefore wanted a photo of when she older for sentiment but illogical reasons. The point is all this is Ellie stuff doesn't necessary have to moved to one location. Ellie was probably loved with stuck a cheeky and outgoing humour which she is shown to have. Her younger sister got something else's of Ellie's too. And then may of took more than one thing. Ellie middle Sister and her "husband" are Riley Grandparents as they had Jillian or Jill. Ellie Family are mostly brown eyed, all expect Ellie and maybe her dad as his eyes are closed have brown eyes, so she must be a carrier of a blue eyed gene plus a blonde hair gene. Jillian married a guy who looked simillar to her father who name was Bill Anderson, who was also a carrier of a blue eyed gene and blonde haired. Ellie youngest sister is Jennifer mum, She married a guy who had blue eyes. Jennifer married Andy Sr (Emma Jean) son was Andy Sr. I don't know if all the genics match up?

[@darrylmihalko2838]

WOAH.

[@ginaaa596]

Maybe Dash is Mollys father, as "Incredible" could be a stage name and he has blue eyes (i think).

[@Orto-jj2di]

Quite possible

[@porcelainboy264]

Dash's legal surname is Parr, Incredible is just an inherited title from his dad

[@Orto-jj2di]

@@porcelainboy264 listen how about this? First andys mom Emily was both divorcee and widow. First husband was andys dad who passed away, the other was dash parr who didn't work things out with her abd so they divorced.

[@porcelainboy264]

@@Orto-jj2di that could work

[@tkic3164]

It's so weird coming back to these videos and hearing the Theorizer sound not demented and haunted by 12th dimensional Dreamworks characters.

[@JuliaNightmare]

Have you ever done\thought about doing anything on Labyrinth? I know some people think that Sarah might have been on drugs, dreaming, or hallucinating, possible all a way of coping with the loss of her mother, her dad remarrying (a woman who seems so different from her mom), and having a new brother.

[@JuliaNightmare]

also, I'm looking forward to your Nightmare Before Christmas video(s)

[@RaikouWolf]

I would so be in for a Labyrinth theory from him!

[@ukkomies100]

What if andy slipped trough the monsters inc door when he was young and created a new dimension where he wasnt born yet and then he grew up in the monster world and went back to the past when he was adult and he had sex with his mother unknowingly and he is his own father creating a new timeline paradox where he is his own father.

[@akbruh4265]

you are fucking with my brain

[@DistressedDamsel6]

ukkomies100 u r either a genius or a sick f@ck.....hmmmm? GENIUS!!!

[@Amirokin]

ukkomies100 isn't that the terminator plot?

[@henrykuo5291]

Latrash101

[@DistressedDamsel6]

Henry Kuo wat is it my man?

[@ThistleK77]

I think the possible Emma Jean in the "UP" wedding scene's daughter looks suspiciously like Elastagirl from the "Incredibles"...

[@Sn4ppDr4g0n]

Tori Krauland That is highly true. XD

[@izzy.c1895]

this is like amazing. do a theory pleeease it could even be another sister or something.

[@MoonberryJam93]

Tori Krauland This wouldn't work, because the incredibles pretty clearly takes place in the 21st century, whereas the Up wedding takes place in the early-mid 1900's

[@StWonka]

CactusGuy actually it Incredibles took place on mid 60's

[@asmrigloo]

Jv Ortega but elastic girl could be a descendant of her

[@pacificus66]

Just rewatching all of your Pixar theories because the Nemo one shook me.

[@Charmynox]

I honestly think that Andy's dad is the guy we see in Sid's house watching tv. That could explain why they move because Andy's mom couldn't stand to live next door to a cheater.

[@Alice-mo4vs]

So Sid and Andy are brothers?

[@Charmynox]

Alice 5 It depends on the person and how their theory goes. For me, I say it could go either way because Sid and Andy are the same age or close to it so Andy's dad could've been messing around with Sid's mom so both moms got pregnant around the same time. Which also explains why there's nothing of the dad in the house because he cheated early on in the relationship so Andy's mom had time to get rid of everything that had to do with Andy's dad. Thus making Sid and Andy half brothers. BUT THEN AGAIN It could be that both Andy and Sid have different fathers and Andy's dad ended up messing around with Sid's mom after both Sid and Andy were born. Because Sid does have a little sister. Thus meaning Andy has not only (I assume) half sister Molly, but also half sister Whatever-Sid's-Little-Sister's-Name-Is. BUT THEN AGAIN This is all just a theory and Andy's dad could totally not be the guy in Sid's house.

[@GlaceonStudios]

Phillips. Sid Phillips. And Hannah Phillips.

[@jfecaz]

Larry Trash true all the conflicts could lead to why sid Is so messed up and andy was probably just oblivious or not as affected by the situation

[@jennat1321]

those pictures on the wall that look like him but it's actually his dad because in one of the pictures he has glasses... Andy doesn't ware glasses... Andy's dad probably died because he had some sort of disese... I got this from the super Carlin brothers

[@landonfigueroa8452]

its jenn I just saw that as well I'm and am relieved to know what happened

[@walterkloon3900]

or maybe she is just single or devosed

[@willsafran8855]

Gabriel Clark kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJPQq6ild6hkiNU

[@mrsmith7268]

Post Polio Disorder

[@sloth6053]

They interviewed the creator

[@10dudis]

What if Andy's father is Emma Jean's son? What if they were on a trip together? They sent a postcard to Carl and Ellie and died on an accident. Andy was just a child and he was feeling lost, that's why Carl and Ellie decided to give him the postcard. That may sound like an way more tragic story, but it fits better for me (I can't accept that Andy's father wanted to leave his children and wife forever). Anyway, that doesn't answer any of the questions you left, but is another way to see things

[@sunlightangel87]

I was thinking that he might have died but then I realized there aren't any pictures of him in the house. If the dad died, I would think there would be more of a tribute to him in his memory instead of no photos or mementos of him anywhere. It looks like his mom threw out any and all memories of him, which someone would likely do after a heartbreak but probably not after a death. Sad as it is, some dads do run off and never look back :(

[@10dudis]

sunlightangel87 yeah, that makes sense. It sucks, but is more likely to be true :(

[@dejygopuram6039]

ok you make more sense I think what u said is definitely correct and most important I believe in your concept

[@dankmemecentral8001]

Wouldn't that make Jill and 'Andys Father' siblings? I don't think they would be a huge fan on incest

[@10dudis]

Dank Meme Central hahaha no, I meant that only Jill and Andy's father are Emma Jean's children. Jennifer, Andy's mom, marries Andy's father

[@kaylabounds1201]

I quite enjoy when you speak of genes. I think it's a rather important aspect. These animators do almost everything on purpose. They think it through and do things so thoroughly. They know exactly what they are doing. So thanks for adding this aspect to your theories. Iprefer theories to be through and in depth. You do an amzing job at that.

[@karlyantonette399]

Honestly, I love it when one of my favorite KZbinr mentions another one of my favorite youtubers

[@stacyphillips5565]

I have a theory. What if the couple at Carl's and Ellie's wedding if just Ellie's sister and her husband. Ellie's sister's name could have been Emma Jean and she could have had two daughters ( we saw a brunette girl beside her), The daughters could be Jill Anderson and Jennifer Davis. We know the Ellie & Carl both wanted kids of their own but they could never have any, so it makes sense that they would be doting a Aunt and Uncle and would want to have their nieces over at their house. The postcard could be from when the girls ( Jill & Jenifer) were at they Aunt & Uncle's house, while their parents (Emma Jean & her husband) were on vacation or something of the like. And Andy just happened to find the postcard in his mom's stuff after her divorce and he decided to keep it.

[@sonyaloeraable]

stacy phillips but what about the fact that the creator confirmed Emma Jean is Carl's ex?

[@stacyphillips5565]

She could still be Carl's ex. Carl could have met Emma Jean through being best friends will Ellie and could have have dated/married Emma Jean before he realized he was in love with Ellie.

[@morganevans1772]

I'd love to see the Carlin brothers respond to this

[@TheTheorizer]

I was DM-ing with them as I was making this.

[@kumbi8368]

The Theorizer: Ellie’s picture is framed in Riley’s childhood house. Me: DONE! I’m sold. You don’t even have to say anymore for me.

[@inkheart151]

Ooh ooh ooh!!!! PLEASE READ THIS COMMENT!!!!!! Remember in the Incredibles when the race was going on for Dash? The camera panned to some random guy who was looking at the incredibles funny. Do you think he could be linked to this? The incredibles are in the 50's/ 60's, around the time Andy may have been born. Maybe

[@jenuvian2880]

Jay P. probably

[@gameoholics2694]

Jay P. You smart

[@jailbreaker813]

Jay P. Ooh ooh I 'member!

[@squareboi9247]

i remeber that that makes sense

[@adermaton3277]

Random thing: the girl whom Andy gives his toys to. Her name is Bonnie Anderson. Just thought that was cool

[@anthonyelias01]

Jazi Belle !!!! clues

[@NyNySKZ]

Jazi Belle you might be right about who is connected to the family tree

[@itsthehumor95]

Jazi Belle is this true? 😱

[@katecolvin7531]

yes im going to reply to this multiple times to push it to the top

[@katecolvin7531]

.

[@MeganMeredithHaveFun]

THE BEST VIDEO ON A PIXAR THEORY THAT I HAVE SEEN! PLEESE MAKE MORE YOUR EXPLAINATION ARE SOOOO CLEAR AND SO GOOD THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU I UNDERSTOOD EVERYTHING I LOVE YOU

[@mr.fahrenheit347]

Laaa Wahraniaaa YESSS!!!!

[@nozomiritter5048]

I know that sounds kind of weird, but listening to this, piped that idea into my head. I know Disney is interconnecting their Pixar movies but what if, and just hear me out what if they are connecting the entire Disney verse? It certainly would give you more people to look at. I know that's probably not the case but it's a little Theory I had.

[@stiancarl3686]

I just thought of somethin' When a couple gets divorced, it is fairly common for the woman to change her last name back to her maiden name. Sometimes, the kids are given the choice of which parent's name they take. Because the Davis' home has literally been striped of any and all evidence of Andy's father, I think its safe to say that the break-up was messy (maybe they never got married). Either way, we know that Jennifer has custody of the kids. I recommend looking for some blonde haired, blue eyed men as Andy's father. As for the connection between the Fredricksens and the Davis family, what if Ellie had a sister? Remember that Ellie also had brownish hair and blue eyes, so maybe her sister would as well. I think that's a little more likely than Carl having kids with someone else. This means that the Andersons probably had a picture of Ellie because she was Jill's aunt. As for the postcard from Emma Jean, is it possible that she was Andy's father's mother? His GRANDMA?? Wow. This just turned into a Dickens novel. :)

[@savageishbu]

"Irregardless" is not a real word; it's just "regardless".

[@TheTheorizer]

Irregardless is a word

[@JerwynJayCatolico]

savageishbu you are right, irregardless is not a word

[@TheTheorizer]

jerwyn catolico It is, it is.

[@inspgonzalez]

The Theorizer hi theorizer! I love your vids!

[@atallus_]

irregardless ˌɪrɪˈɡɑːdləs/ adjective & adverbinformal regardless. "the photographer always says, irregardless of how his subjects are feeling, ‘Smile!’" There ya go. The dictionary has spoken. IT IS A WORD.

[@sphericalcobalt4857]

Everyone I found with blue eyes: Flint from Bugs Life Joy Sadness The main character from Brave, don't remember name Lightning McQueen Eve from Wall-e The old man who fixed woody, but his eyes changed colors multiple times, in the movie they were green, but in some pics blue Buzz Lightyear Mr. Incredible (keep in mind he's alive when carl/ Ellie married) The rest of the Incredibles (including jack- jack) But Davis? Nothing. But to fit in with the genes and timeline? The only character who has brown hair, blue eyes, and was around in the fifties was Jack-Jack Parr. The only thing is, he doesn't fit in the family tree as he is the child of the Incredibles, despite not having blonde hair

[@deserttortoise21]

based on the evidence you provided in the beginning, what stops Ellie from being a great aunt or something? She couldn't conceive, and iit didn't look like they had any time to adopt. Heck, they probably didn't have the income for a child either! The only contingency money they had was the "Paradise Falls" jar, and they used that thing several times during that montage!

[@safarixd9163]

she saying "we" as in her and her daughter(s) because the kids don't leave with him

[@bllkch]

Safari XD PIN THIS! +The Theorizer

[@brooklego2367]

this may sound crazy, but maybe stinky pete may be his father.........i know that he is old, and he doesn't have the blue eye gene........but it can still fit in. stinky pete is probably not his real name (who would name their child stinky) so he could have any last name, including davis. he was obsessed with owning everything that had to do with woody's roundup, including the woody doll that andy had, so it make sense that he really wanted that doll to be PERFECT besides for the money. this could be a theory to add on to later, but as i said, it may be crazy (including everything else) but this is just a theory "A GAME THEORY" i'll get out now. p.s hi random person scrolling through the comments! have a nice day! and i don't care what u think with this yay XD

[@brooklego2367]

okay not stinky pete i meant by Al my bad

[@handsomemadmario]

brook ellis still an amazing theory dude!

[@brooklego2367]

HandsomeMadMario yay thanks i just saw the character wrong so i corrected myself

[@samthewitch9045]

brook ellis nice day to you to. I saw another theory that says this and sorta believe it. nice work!

[@brooklego2367]

Kit Lania thanks! also sry it took me a while to reply also nice day/night to you too!

[@cvvzdesigns]

I... I think I just felt a few brain cells explode and die. For someone who's so into genetics (blue eyes are highly common now, by the way) you seem to have forgotten such a thing as aunts and uncles. This video could have been over in 5 minutes, or a little more, if you'd actually looked at it from that view point. But then, if you had an actual SIMPLISTIC solution to your questions you wouldn't have been able to stretch this bad idea out for 13 minutes. Most probable situation to them all being related is this: Emma Jean is Ellie's sister. The man at the wedding is her husband. They are Andy's grandparents (the child at the wedding would have been Andy's mom, who is a little older than Riley's mom). The reason he has the post card is because he had a close connection to his great-aunt and when she died it went to him as a keepsake. Andy's mom and Riley's mom are sisters. Riley's mom has the picture on her mantle because she, too, loved her aunt. Molly's dad would be a blond, not brunet, to explain the source of blond hair in her family tree. The eye colour could be anything because blue is the dominant colour (I am the only one with brown eyes out of 5 children with one blue eyed parent (mom) and one brown eyes (dad, and both of his have brown eyes, too)). Andy's dad is most likely a deadbeat who couldn't handle having 2 kids which is why he bailed either just after he learned the mom was pregnant, or just after Molly was born. Which is also why there's no trace of him in any memorabilia or photographs. If he had died there would be something around to remember him by. They also ended up having to move in to a smaller house now that his income wasn't there, which is why they move in the 1st movie. So there you go. Riley, Andy, and Molly are cousins. Jennifer and Jill are sisters. Emma Jean and Ellie are sisters. There's you working theory that doesn't involve going through 13 minutes of twists, turns, and desperate grasping at straws to make it work.

[@TheTheorizer]

Emma Jean and Ellie aren't sisters; Are you forgetting what Pete Doctor said? This is why I had to bend over backwards to make it work, and it does.

[@cvvzdesigns]

Actually, I don't even know who Pete Doctor is. Why couldn't Emma Jean be Carl's sister, then? Is that also mentioned by him? I truly don't know.

[@TheTheorizer]

CVVZ Designs Pete Doctor is the creator of all of those movies, and he said one, and only one thing. Carl left Emma for Ellie.

[@nnyrb1]

CVVZ Designs Emma Jean couldn't be Carl's sister because the animator of the love said she was a previous love interest of his. Unless you're into incest, that's not the case. That's also a thing that this original commenter forgot, because they were so caught up in trying to be right about everything. It's highly unlikely that the producers would have Carl date on sister and move onto the other sister and have both of them be fine with it and the first sister even show up at the wedding.

[@annagamer1751]

CVVZ Designs if I may weigh in... maybe Carl had been in a relationship with Emma first? since that relationship had been conformed as well as the relationship we see in the movie?

[@warrentheeagle7456]

I literally cannot stop imaging a dude dressed up as like Sherlock Homes and looking at the screen of their TV watching Inside Out with a magnifying glass 😭

[@Thkaal]

Syndrome is Andy's father. Mind blown!

[@trialbyfire9945]

Th'kaal I think he is too young just my opinion

[@cateteercatvlogs7568]

Th'kaal that would be interesting. given the movie incredibles happened between 60s and 70s. but i think it might but the Incredibles making Dash more likely to be his father given the timeline

[@Thkaal]

Um...Syndrome. Supergenius, egotistical, has a series fo clones. One of those clones is Andy's father.

[@naazirs]

It actually makes sense tho. After the fight and his "death" Syndrome changed his last name from Pine to Davis, went into hiding for 10-15 years met a Women, had and Andy and His Sister. Eventually his wife found out and brutally kicked him out of the house, stripping all proof of her criminal husband from the home. That and it explains why Andys mom never has to really work as far as we know, as Syndrome owned a serious of successful businesses. Also Syndrome and Andy have brown/auburn hair and blue eyes.

[@Sn4ppDr4g0n]

Th'kaal Who is Syndrome? >.>

[@someone-kd7fu]

who else is confused af

[@urmommy5]

Me

[@MC_Madness]

What if the Fredrickson's used Emma Jean as a surrogate mother to have children?

[@ryanbeattie9591]

_MC_Madness_ interesting

[@ryanbeattie9591]

_MC_Madness_ but wouldn't the children be seen in photos around the Fredrickson's house

[@MC_Madness]

What if, because in up the Fredrickson's seem to have a money problem, they could not afford to keep the children so Emma took them and they didn't want to deal with the memories of their failure so they did not keep any photos.

[@ryanbeattie9591]

_MC_Madness_ that's a stretch I think

[@adanlopezamezcua3365]

Ryan Beattie i agree because in the movie the Fredericksons' were not able to have children

[@inwalters]

First - I don't care what Pete Doctor said - unless it's in the films it's just ex post facto fan fiction Second - here's how it all actually ties together and explains everything: Ellie had a younger sister named Emma Jean (you can see her sitting on the front pew at Ellie and Carl's wedding) Emma Jean was the mother of two daughters - one married Mr. Davis and became the mother of Andy. The other married Mr. Anderson and became the mother of Riley. After Carl died his nieces inherited his effects, including a postcard to them from his grandmother, which is why Andy kept it. Carl and Ellie are Riley's great aunt and uncle which is why she has memories and a photo of them. Riley's dad is the brother of Bonnie's dad (they're both named Anderson). This shows why Andy attended Sunnyside. Bonnie's mom is the sister-in-law of Riley's mom, who is Andy's mom sister.

[@maddygman]

could you do a do a revised theory based on the super carlins brothers interview telling us who andy's dad is maybe that could help you with your other questions (if you haven't seen it, it's not a theory it comes from the actually story writer for toy story)

[@mamaluigi9988]

Ok I have a theory about who Andy's dad COULD be. Remember Toy Story 3, when the clown toy (Sorry I forgot his name ;-;) tells Lotso, Baby, and his backstory? As seen, when the man picks up his sleeping child, Daisy, he has brown hair. And what color eyes does Daisy have? (Taps chin) Blue. Genetics. And Lotso may have known about the man and previous breakups and such, therefore having a grudge with the name Andy, probably hearing it before. The man, Daisy's dad, was with Jennifer before he had Daisy. At the time when Toy Story 3 was made, Daisy was about 4 or 5. Molly was probably just born, and the flashback was probably 7 years after Mr. and Mrs. Davis split up. Now, I may be wrong, ...But hey, that's just a theory. A FILM theory! (Sorry not sorry)

[@alexnwoko1225]

andys father died from polio i just watched the video. those pictures on the wall are actually of andys dad not andy himself.

[@Quackervoltz]

Alex Nwoko Where is your evidence?

[@billybobby122]

Just go watch super Carlin brothers and you’ll get your evidence

[@kayaroberts7100]

Billy Bobby that theory was debunked awhile ago. I think it was debunked last year.

[@randovlogsfromsenioryear]

I recently watched a KZbin video about someone interviewing someone who had been told by one of the creators that Andy's dad died and the pictures on the wall are of Andy's dad as a child and Andy's dads name was ANDY!!!

[@aeoxnian9482]

Please do the nightmare before Christmas soon! It's my all time favourite movie!

[@sarahpepper6206]

+Josip Tito it's the British spelling

[@SuperRedRobin]

but what is there to make a theory about (PS please make one if possible for a halloween / christmas / november special)

[@mixedgenrecat]

In Europe a lot of words like favorite is spells with a u like color=colour flavor=flavour favorite=favourite

[@SuperRedRobin]

Josip Tito thats the american dictionary. we are talking about british people talk

[@SuperRedRobin]

in britain we use the Oxford dictionary you used an AMERICAN DICTIONARY it is simple!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@katym8905]

Oh Jesus, this is complicated... but completely genius!!!

[@joahchewbhaka5679]

06:19 I like the genetics!

[@strwb1es]

Joah Chewbhaka sane

[@jaywatts2780]

Cool

[@endernanismles1174]

I just imagined someone from inside out seeing toys walking around and then they freeze and the emotions go crazy because they don't know how to react

[@carashiri327]

I personally think that Andy's mom had an affair with Sid's dad (toy story) I think she wanted to keep the baby so Andy's dad left....I think this, because to me molly looks similar to Sid and I'm guessing that they probably look like their dad-this is just my opinion we haven't seen Sid's father I'm just thinking thank you 😊 please comment what you think about this theory

[@mysticwolf1358]

Cara shiri this is interesting. but we haven't seen sid's father or andy's father. they are both around the same age and they both have a younger sister. maybe andy's mom had multiple affairs with sid's dad. and shortly after molly was born, sid's dad died. this could explain why sid is very destructive and "troubled" because he lost his father at a young age. and andy isn't like that bc he had a nice mother and had lots of good things to distract him from his pain. which could also show why andy would get lost in his imagination bc wanted to forget about his life. also why he had such a connection to his favorite male toy (that his father probably gave him) and (might've been sid's which is why sid was so excited to have woody) and (wanted to blow up buzz, since he didn't have anyone like andy to get him nice toys). omg i wasn't even thinking when i wrote this, it all just started popping into my head

[@amandabogle7641]

love this theory

[@bellebradlington5924]

mystic wolf but don't we see sids dad sitting on a chair watching tv? we don't see his face but still

[@m4ra996]

What if Andy is related to Riley because her father is Andy's father who divorced Andy's mother? And he married a new woman.

[@ryanbeattie9591]

Frunchie __ Timing that's why. The timing would be off for that

[@sofiasalmoiraghi3233]

Frunchie __ thats what i thought i mean Rileys and Mollys genes are practically the same

[@superphantom100]

Ryan Beattie and why would William change his last name to Fredrickson this theory doesn't make sense but the challenge is to look through the Pixar movies and try to find Andys father.

[@remi5309]

Frunchie __ his last name don't match

[@anthonyelias01]

Ryan Beattie BUTTT!!! Riley might be adopted!?

[@scarlettvlogs3260]

You deserve so many more subs 👍🏻Ur amazing

[@anna-ln5qf]

Weird but interesting

[@eveyoung8604]

What about Bonnie ANDERSON from toy story 3. Is she part of the anderson family? They have the same last name, and that is not very common in the pixar films. In one of the ball things in inside out, riley sees sunny side daycare, which Bonnie went to as a child. Inside Out and Toy Story are pretty close on the pixar theory timeline: 2004 and 1998. That would mean that Bonnie COULD be the about the same age as riley when she was born. Bonnie is about 10 years younger than Andy, so that would mean she was born about 2008, four years younger than Riley. The places that they originally lived look pretty alike. I think that Bonnie and Riley are sisters. I think that Riley was the older child, coming in 2004. Then, Bonnie came around 2008, four years younger. The parents had originally not wanted a second child, but there was a "mishap", and whoops! A child they never wanted. Bonnie looks like Riley's parents alot, with dark brown hair. The only thing that is missing is the blue eyes, but she could have gotten the dark brown eyes from her dad. After they had bonnie, that quickly gave her away to the nice family a few blocks down. They IMMEDIATLEY did this, and that is why you never see Bonnie in Riley's memories. Bonnie was always there with her sister, but Riley never knew this nor Bonnie. Then, because of the dad's "work" (or the mom's credit card fraud. Watch the super carlin brothers' video) they had to move, leaving Bonnie at the town. That is the second child that the anderson's craddled, but then kicked away.

[@emmalinsofie5300]

I finally realized, that's why mr Fredrickson is so close to Russell. His situation reminds him of what he did , being that he divorced Emma jean and Russell dad left/divorced his mom too ? Idk haha

[@michaelcasale5411]

I think Riley was in the pre-school in Toy Story 3

[@jordanjudek]

Mr. Savage and boo

[@alvenher7844]

Mr. Savage I do to because I saw a red headed girl at the preschool seen where she is seen playing with Mrs potato head on a train. crashing it into blocks which looks like Riley's friend and in the movie it shows that Riley's red headed friend and her were playing at a really young age

[@oldunclejoe4777]

I appreciate how much effort this guy puts into his videos, it's the coolest channel I've ever seen and he puts so many cool videos and theories I LOVE IT

[@ZHBG-ll7fy]

Maybe Emma was with Mr. Davis when she sent the postcard. It makes sense a bit--Jennifer, thinking her husband was cheating her, got rid of his evidence of existence. Andy, now without a father, looks up to masculine action figures like Woody and Buzz. Emma wanted to get to know her son-in-law better and decided to spend time with him. Plus, no one else is missing in the family other than Mr. Davis and Emma.

[@ZHBG-ll7fy]

Please help me out here. I wasted so much time trying to prove this right.

[@pufflefun6564]

The captain from "wall-e" is Andy's dad

[@spaghettimkay5795]

Puffle Fun How would that even work

[@hk8864]

spaghetti mkay maybe a wizard of oz theory everyone has a look a like wall-e could be called wally in a new movie and andys dad wally moves in with eve his new wife then there could be another whole family

[@portalmasteroverlordelite4697]

that's not possible cause considering the Pixar theory that makes no sense because the people in wall-e have been away from earth for multiple centurie's therefore the most basic way of justifying it.

[@DanMan91693]

But what if the current captain is the descendent of the original captain who is Andy's dad?

[@LPSLivingLife]

That isn't possible because Wall-E takes place way in the future when the Earth is ruined by humans

[@zoegrace1408]

maybe in an upcoming film, andys dad will be revealed?

[@alexpritchett3924]

ASMR_Zozers yes because t story 4 is coming out soon

[@winterkitten1620]

Alexander Pritchett really!!!yay

[@mstr.comedy]

winter Kitten actually no ones rooting for toy story 4...

[@amaryllisbrooke8098]

ASMR_Zozers or its just something pixar mixed up?

[@Antasma1]

ASMR_Zozers I love Toy Story, but I'm done with it

[@NoahhhsArkk]

Okay. So I have gathered some information about one thing. I know that you published this 4 years ago but your channel has had some interest in my recently. One of the Super Carlins brothers video stated that Andy'd dad died. He had died from post polio. He had to get rid of all of his stuff yet he saved Woody, therefore passing it down to Andy. At 10:02 you showed an image of Woody sliding down the stair banister. Also in that image were pictures on the wall. The person in those pictures don't exactly look like Andy, therefore, they could be pictures of his dad. This might not explain fully about who Andy's dad is but it might add something valuable and significant to the story. Also, at the end you had asked us to find a couple who were elderly and from my memory (I think I have this all wrong, time wise and everything wise) but in Ratatouille, Remmy is in the pipes above the French houses looking for food, he comes across a French couple having a fight, one holding a gun and then the couple make up. What if these people are and elderly couple, EmmaJean could have moved to France with this other significant other. Even though they are not elderly, this doesn't state they could have sent this at another time, for example earlier. If it was too early, then Andy's mum could have given it to Andy when he was older. I really don't know if this makes any sense but it might help add to this theory.

[@lordthanatos3564]

Woah woah woah woah woah hold on... Andy as an adult has long brown hair and blue eyes, and is owned by Disney... hmmm... Annakin Skywalker has long brown hair is an adult has blue eyes and is ALSO owned by Disney... hmmm... Andy... hmmm... Annie... hmmm... Andy never knew his father... Anakin didn't have a father... hmmm.... OMG ANDY=ANAKIN CONFIRMED

[@bucktoothbeaverman1087]

TheEdgyOnion bruh when toy story was made anikan skywalker was owned by lucasfilm

[@thewethand390]

found it, in The Incredibles at the end where the fast child is racing right before the mole rat comes there is a man WITH BLUE EYES wearing a business suit and has a "My Name Is" sticker saying davis

[@angelescalera5931]

Kurt Jensen really

[@angelescalera5931]

Kurt Jensen no way

[@celesterobles448]

Kurt Jensen OMG IT COULD BE ( theiroizer needs to pin this) * sorry if i spelled the you5ube name wrong*

[@sherwellecutie9975]

SOMEONE NEEDS TO PIN THIS

[@Adam-yumyum]

Kurt Jensen holy moley I think you got it!

[@melanystuffidk3047]

Tony from The Incredibles maybe? he has blonde hair and blue eyes and maybe he and violet didn't work out ??

[@MonoEnta]

Melany stuff idk OH MY KAULITS thats a good observation

[@melanystuffidk3047]

Reminiscent Of A Daydream I THINK HIS LAST NAME WAS RIDINGDGER OR SOMETHING THO SMH

[@tyrooster5176]

Melany stuff idk you are surprisingly on to something

[@stevie9361]

Melany stuff idk last name does not match criteria he's looking for..... didn't you pay attention to the video?

[@doctorpig5617]

So Jill Anderson was born within the 50's, which makes her at least 53 when she's supposed to have 11 year old Riley, then 64 when the movie takes place, this is preposterous as she looks to be no older than 40. More possible in my opinion, Bill has a child in the 50's, that child has a child in the 80's at age 30 or so, then they have Jill who has Riley around age 24, making her now 35. Jill's grandmother would then be Emma Jean and stepgrandmother Ellie, I think it's more likely to be closer with a lifelong step grandparent than a step parent and therefore she is in the frame.

[@madiblair5208]

I think emma jean is now with andys dad!

[@walter3075]

Rosey100 nah tht would be weird

[@madiblair5208]

DERRIK CORY its ok

[@emmaminiaci96]

I was thinking that two but I don't think emma jean was one of Carl's love interest seeing how carl has been with Ellie almost his whole life, maybe emma was one of Carl's adopted children that left early because she was already a teenager when she was adopted and she would always fight with Ellie, and it was a postcard from his daughter and the we could be when all of the sisters were together wishing there father was there it could also have been andys father

[@bucktoothbeaverman1087]

Rosey100 emma jean would be like 70 by the time andys dad and his mom divorced

[@satisfiedjelly]

they don't have to be together because they are love interests

[@reviewsofthebrick6946]

Ive had a look, but its hard to crack who andys father is but ill try first lets exclude the following. Both car films, a bugs life, both monster Inc films, Wall e as its too far in the future. Also brave because it was to long ago and the good dinosaur as this was even further back. So from finding dory and nemo we have four charactsrs, only Dr phillip sherman is male. Firstly he does have blue eyes. And just because he is Australian dosent mean anything, he could have moved there after his split from mrs Davis, became a dentist and settled down again. Next to toy story and all mcwiggon, he has Brown eyes which may mean im wrong, but is it possible mrs Davis left him because she found him ridiculous, and maybe there is more than one reason he wants woody back Then to the incredibles and Bob parr who could fit the bill, but I think timelines might be wrong Next to inside out and Bill underson sounds plausible lastly to ratatouie And alfredo linguinia who I done think But then could the answer be in the short films Ill exclude tin toy, luxo Jr and knickknack. As well as the toy story shorts, partly cloudy, for the birds, Buzz lightyear, small fry, boundie, la Luna, one man band, day and night, and the rest that done include people. This leVel US with. Rileys first date, lifted, gerries game, and presto. Now ill get rid of rileys first date. And gerries game since he is the guy from toy story. Prestos main guy maybe possible but would be a stretch with the guy from lifted aswell. That leaves me with 7 possibilities Dr Phillip Sherman Ale mcwiggion Bob parr Bill anderson Alfredo Presto And the guy from lifted- lets get rid of these last 2 Ale mcwiggion- he was at the garage sale, so wouldn't have mrs Davis noticed and told him to leave Bill anderson- seems to obvious so it probably isent him Leaving two Bob parr, but wouldn't helen find out about this So i think its Dr Phillip sherman

[@PM-ey9ti]

breaking brick news wow...

[@sanyalewis1296]

breaking brick news d

[@reviewsofthebrick6946]

+ChronicGaming I know I did go on a bit, but I know im probably wrong

[@indib4837]

i think this is a great possibility!

[@reviewsofthebrick6946]

Indi de inktvis thankyou

[@evaanciaes5940]

well, maybe carl and emma jean had a daughter (Jill) and a son (Andy's father) and that could be the reason why she's telling him that they are ok, because they are both "missing"/somewhere else. I mean.. they got divorced and Jill was already in college or in university but Andy's father was still young in the 50's (the toys he had right?). So imagine he has stayed with his mother Emma. then he married or had two kids (Andy and Molly) things went wrong (or not they could be still marry or something) and he's now with his mother

[@evaanciaes5940]

please check up on my lil theory