Pixel 5 Detailed Review - What They Aren't Telling You..

Pixel 5 has some killer exclusive features, but it also has 3 key issues that almost no one seems to be talking about..
Most Pixel Fans should buy THIS phone instead! ➡ geni.us/J8ybr
(All links to Amazon)
Pixel 5 ➡ geni.us/WJmcAXN
Pixel 4a ➡ geni.us/J8ybr
Pixel 1, 2, & 3 owners should buy this instead ➡ geni.us/GenuTM
Gamers should buy this Phone ➡ geni.us/JwB8qo
Max Tech Wallpapers ➡ bit.ly/2WNc6Qw
Buy one of our NEW T-Shirts to help support us! ➡ teespring.com/stores/max-tech...
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
In this video, I do an in-depth review of the Pixel 5 talking about things that most reviewers haven't such as the Cameras with older smaller sensors (IMX363) changes to the processor and how that affects you in the real world with Pixel 5 Geekbench and AnTuTu scores, Photo quality and speed without the neural core, Ultrawide HDR and Night Mode shots, Battery life, Speaker Quality, and even 5G Speed with Pixel 5's Snapdragon 765G's X52 Modem instead of X55.
Timestamps ⬇️
Intro to Pixel 5 Review - 00:00
Software & Sensors 01:02
Battery Life - 01:37
Exterior Changes - 02:13
Display Quality - 02:46
Speaker Quality - 03:31
Poor 5G Speed - 05:15
CPU Slowdowns - 07:30
Gaming Performance - 07:48
Daily Usability - 08:04
Photo Quality - 08:34
Old Sensor Issues - 09:34
Zoom Quality - 10:47
Ultra-wide Quality - 11:10
Pixel Advantages - 12:01
"False" Performance - 12:23
Video Improvements - 12:51
Too Expensive? - 13:29
Verdict! - 14:06
~-~~-~~~-~~-~
PRIVACY POLICY and FULL DISCLOSURE:
°Max Tech is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com
°Max Tech is a participant in the B&H Photo Video affiliate program that provides an advertising commission if you purchase through our links.
°If you purchase something from our affiliate links will get a small commission with no extra cost to you. This makes it possible for us to make more videos. Thank you!
°We DO NOT collect, store, use, or share any data about you.
~-~~-~~~-~~-~

[@MaxTechOfficial]

What do YOU think? is the Pixel 5 worth $699 with these 3 issues? If not what should you buy instead? Most Pixel Fans should buy THIS instead! (Amazon) ➡ geni.us/J8ybr Pixel 1, 2, & 3 owners should buy this instead (Amazon) ➡ geni.us/GenuTM Gamers should buy this Phone (Amazon) ➡ geni.us/JwB8qo Max Tech Wallpapers ➡ bit.ly/2WNc6Qw Buy one of our NEW T-Shirts to help support us! ➡ teespring.com/stores/max-tech-store Pixel 5 (Amazon) ➡ geni.us/WJmcAXN Pixel (Amazon) 4a ➡ geni.us/J8ybr

[@johnrobson1309]

Pixel 5 is worth about $489. I could point out better Chinese phones around $350. It's recycled aluminum, cheap underperforming parts and basically feels like the birth of the iPhone all over again happening 13 years too late. I used to rail on my brother about how insanely inconvenient and expensive MacBooks and iPhones are and this Pixel 5 is no different. I got a Pixel 4XL on eBay for $300 and I love it more than any phone I've had so far. Great screen, speakers, face unlock, software, battery life and camera. I don't need my phone to do anything else. The Snapdragon 888 is only a bit cooler and doesn't make any difference in my usage. I'm done wasting money on trivial stuff.

[@pureindian007]

Any heating issues in using pixel 5a 5g on 4k@60fps??

[@isofinal]

Pixel, the forever-love-hate-toxic-relationship phone.

[@rahuldamala7021]

LMAO 😂

[@sipunmeher7046]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😁. True dat

[@zombistank]

This is by far the most accurate description of the Pixel I have ever read. I completely echo this sentiment!

[@isofinal]

@@zombistank hahaha true story, sigh.

[@camyeag]

I feel that with my pixel 3xl

[@agent-rm9eq]

Honestly don’t care about phone speakers. 90% of the time my phone is connected to some Bluetooth device: car, headphones, portable speaker. Speakers are much less important for me on a phone than say a laptop or tablet.

[@thetute59]

Lots of people seem to forget that not everyone has the very same needs. Definetly not happy myself that they 'cut corners' on the speaker department or still cheap out in other areas but no phone has it all, there will always be a compromise.

[@gerard7417]

@@thetute59 he's not talking about everyone tho he's speaking for himself 😂

[@thetute59]

@@gerard7417 Im well aware of that.

[@elionelvega3535]

Same here ...all phone speakers suck anyway in comparison to other devices dedicated for sounds

[@otomicans6580]

The Dude 59 on a date... Girl: I like chocolate peanut butter ice cream. TheDude_59: Not everyone likes chocolate though! And honestly, lots of people out there are lactose intolerant or allergic to peanuts. I'm not happy myself with this poor quality ice cream but I suppose on dates, as in life, you have to compromise.

[@Yodasmith16]

You spent this entire video comparing the Pixel 5 to phones that are %30-%60 more expensive. How tf is that a fair comparison?

[@f2pgamingcastleclashmore119]

But some of the comparisons were with samsung s20 FE. And I think pixel could have put a better processor in the phone for the same price if samsung could do it.

[@janikneil1766]

@@f2pgamingcastleclashmore119 But with a better processor the battery life would be worse, maybe good battery life was Google's primary goal.

[@johnnyloveee]

Everyone does this. I hate it.

[@f2pgamingcastleclashmore119]

@@janikneil1766 better processor means better battery life. Because one of the purpose of newer processors is to increase battery life.

[@janikneil1766]

@@f2pgamingcastleclashmore119 Not necessarily, there are processors that are very efficient and ones that are more powerful, which use more battery.

[@claro371]

I'm still waiting for a phone reviewer to spend more than 2 seconds on call quality.

[@CoisesFoiledAgain]

And for many of us, that's why speakers matter (the top one, in particular), even if we never use them for music or video. Calls begin and end with the microphone and the speakers. I, too, would like to hear more about call quality. In my humble opinion, to be a good smartphone, a device first has to be a good phone.

[@eladbari]

Exactly. I guess Gen-Z only texts, so they don't care about call+speakerphone quality

[@boakyebb]

I completely agree... Nobody wants to address this properly and accurately ....all we would like to know is what is calling quality like ...

[@Darthus]

Why compare a camera from a 699 phone in the US ($599 in every other country) with a 999 (iphone 11 pro) and a 1399 phone (Note 20 ultra)?

[@thetute59]

We'll one can measure david vs goliath. Ofc im exagerrating, but you get the point. The pixel3a was actually a very strong contender vs even very expensive phones in some areas. But I do agree with him, they're falling more and more behind.

[@hbouyb]

because it's google's flagship irrespective of price and because they claim they got the #1 phone camera in the industry for how many years now? also, the 12 mini which is the same price as the pixel 5 has the exact same main and ultra wide lens as the 12 pro so your point is moot

[@georgemonks4001]

@@hbouyb they don't claim they have the best camera, every tech KZbinr says it's the best

[@n8george]

What kind of question is that? Pixel is known for its camera so why not?

[@Darthus]

@@n8george I just think if you're comparing one product with another when one of them is twice the price that should be contextualized. A Honda Civic that is known for acceleration shouldn't be compared against a Tesla Model S without mentioning the Tesla is twice the price.

[@makhosimayisa5800]

Camera bump looks cheapish?! wtf does that mean😂😂. How does an expensive camera bump look like?

[@payman1023]

Yeah this guy is full of crap

[@rionugroho1403]

More like iPhone probably 😏

[@rf340-s3p]

Can I suggest using a different background for reviews? That one makes the screen look broken at first glance!

[@alexjensen8493]

Lol I thought his screen was defective and it was going to be one of his complaints.

[@GrahamTriggsUK]

Not a single negative there that I care about. The back feels fine to me, and besides which, I always put cases on phones to protect them from drops. The built-in speakers are at least as good if not better than my previous phones for the times that I use it - when I care about having bigger sound, I'll connect it to bluetooth speakers / headphones (or use a hifi, etc.) Every phone I've ever had is good enough in the camera department for basic snaps - when I care about the photo quality, I use a real camera. I do not game on my phone. Ever. I use my phone - *as a phone* - (I know, that's shocking, right) and as a phone the software is significantly better than what other Android handsets provide. The one thing I would agree with is that it doesn't necessarily justify the price premium over the 4a 5G. They should have just released one 5G handset, although I would lean towards the Pixel 5 and pricing it at $100 less (which ought to be achievable when you aren't fragmenting the market). I get that reviews should cover all aspects of phones so that people can make up their own minds about what is important to them, but it's a pity that hardly anyone talks about why these devices are a better *phone* than other handsets that might offer more powerful hardware at a similar price.

[@Redxtc1226]

Thanks for summing it up and saving me some time

[@stevensanchez1192]

@Wurzel Tee Have you noticed that most of these youtube comments seem to be bots? I think I'm going to have to report this to KZbin.

[@rizdog5735]

The best part of this phone, and the main reason why people would buy it is because it is small, and fits well in the hand, that is why I'm going to get it.

[@EricHouserecho1284]

I love my Pixel 5, one of the best phones I've ever had. Amazing camera and I love asthetics and the form factor. It's built strong and lightweight. Wish I'd bought two!

[@Element5x]

Came from the pixel 3xl; I am rather pleased with my pixel 5.

[@21divel]

Already having ordered a pixel 5, leaving the 3 xl, I'm happy to read this.

[@rizdog5735]

How are the speakers and peformance going for you?

[@ytApplecations]

Got the notifications on! Congrats on 400k subscribers, keep up the good work!

[@MaxTechOfficial]

Thank you!!

[@Jahremy]

Never be an early purchaser of a Pixel device (other than the 'a' devices). Just wait 1-3 months for it to drop down to what the price should've been when it was released.

[@hickey85]

Unless your happy to receive bose qc35ii for free which makes it worthwhile of course. But once that offer ends for real wait a bit. 😎👍

[@Andrew-it7fb]

My 2 xl has been fantastic and I pre-ordered it.

[@tudorrose3443]

@@Andrew-it7fb I'm returning my pixel 5 as I feel it's a downgrade on my great 2xl. Will probably keep my 2xl and add security when the upgrades stop in December. Have always had superb photos with my oldie so I'll save my money for now! Disappointed with the 5 screen compared with 2xl, not as rich in colour even in boosted mode and the sound 🤨

[@Andrew-it7fb]

@@tudorrose3443 I've heard about issues with the screen separating from the frame, but everyone seems to be praising the screen and they criticized the 2xls screen. I never had a problem with it though. I just need to decide weather to upgrade or replace my battery. It feels like my phone is draining faster than it should though based on the battery capacity I have. I use a battery app to test that.

[@tudorrose3443]

@@Andrew-it7fb yes, my battery isn't lasting as well as it did since Android 11 but I can still get a day out of it. Think we've been spoiled having a brilliant phone and the size of the 5 seems tiny in comparison. I may take a look at Oppo but do like stock Android...

[@jarjarbinks8954]

Kudos to you guys for pointing out the fact that google uses older sensors. I hope you'll point this out too in your iPhone 12 review too as it also uses the same sensor as the 11

[@MaxTechOfficial]

Yes!

[@victorAgain00]

The 12pros use newer larger sensors. They are the real camera beasts apple was taunting

[@jarjarbinks8954]

@@victorAgain00 not really lol. Only and I repeat only the 12 pro max uses a larger sensor and it's not even that large at an approximate 1/1.7 inch sensor. The regular 12 pro uses the same sensor as the 12 which in turn uses the same as the one found in the 11. It'd be interesting to see how much apple has pushed the hardware with their software but if it's any indication from the pixel series, YOU JUST CAN'T BEAT PHYSICS

[@ellenrobbins1807]

@@jarjarbinks8954 you’re saying it’s not that large because you’re comparing it to Samsung and other Sony sensors, but you forget that it’s a 12mp sensor compared to 48, 64, and 108 on other android phones this year, it’s going to be much more well optimized because the hardware doesn’t have to do any binning to get the large photon sizes. The way specs look on paper isn’t everything, the size difference between the 108mp sensor in Samsung phones and the 48mp in the OnePlus 8 pro is very negligible if it makes any difference at all. All are still small sensors when compared to real cameras.

[@azizaja8255]

@@jarjarbinks8954 I searched it up on Google, how big 1/1.7 sensor is. Turns out it's as big as Huawei P30 Pro wide sensor and Samsung 64MP GW1 sensor that usually used in midrange phones like Redmi Note 8 Pro

[@ilianto]

Oh man, everyone wants the slimmest possible bezels and then everyone complains why the speakers are not as good. I wish manufacturers stopped listening to what people want and do some serious R&D instead to give us what is best. What we want is usually not what we need. Thumbs up for the rest of the points! 👍

[@therealcinnimo]

💯

[@kevindsmith10000]

How come other manufacturers are finding a way to balance thin all screen design and good speakers? Google definitely has the resources and talent to put a complete phone together. I just don't think they care. I've seen various tech blogs and reviewers talk about the reason the Pixel exist and one of them is to keep Samsung in line. When Samsung was looking to build out it's own ecosystem and move away from Android and google services. Pixels are an afterthought to Google and year over year it shows in their compromises.

[@ibn-aaam4170]

Google marketing strategies r shit. They r selling over priced products. Even they doesn't have to pay royalty for OS to anyone. If they just had included sd865+ i would have bought it. But this product is trash for that price range. They r the Apple of Android world.

[@timg2727]

This year's Samsung flagships have really, really good speakers (for a phone) while also having tiny bezels. Google just doesn't have the engineering prowess to pull it off, plain and simple.

[@yapolloable]

do you save more battery by limiting CPU clock of SD 865 to 70% or having SD 765G? I love the size of pixel 5, camera and huge battery. Considering between Pixel 5 and Galaxy S21

[@Creli-ph4xb]

Change audio in accessibility settings >mono audio> combine channels when playing audio

[@theskyguy126]

Does this make all sound come out the bottom speaker?

[@afrikaner]

In terms of value, the Pixel 5 is a good deal when you get a nice pair of Bose headphones. I know you get the same with the Pixel 4a 5G, so I’m getting one of those for my wife. The sound doesn’t bother me as I use headphones 95% of the time.

[@stevensanchez1192]

Don't let this review slow you down, the guy is a fake reviewer and I noticed something was up the moment he compared his WIFI to cellular data and called it a 5G comparison.

[@dgaubin]

My Pixel 5 speakers are perfectly adequate for the kinds of things I'd do with phone speaker. For better sound, I use bluetooth headset, bluetooth speaker, or I'm casting to tv.

[@90ravg]

How fo you know which sensor does iphone use? What model is it? Where do they officially state that? Honest doubt

[@NibbledSandwich]

Needs face unlock? In a time when I'm wearing a mask. Lol

[@hythlodaeus9944]

are u planning on buying a new phone when we no longer have to wear masks? or do u wear them home? where many ppl are for the entirety of their day in these times? I agree with him that the option is nice.. i just always hated it. lol.. So Pixel 5 is for me.

[@sparkfx5874]

Never liked face unlock. It's pointless, fingerprint biometric sensor on the back is perfect and faster considering most of the time you pull it out your pocket and the phone is already unlocked due to the perfect placement. BUT THE BIGGEST PROBLEM WITH FACE UNLOCK: Many apps do not support it natively instead of using your password and still only have options for using your fingerprint instead of your password. I couldn't imagine having to input my password all the time because I have a phone with "superior face unlock" but no fingerprint option and am forced to enter a password manually every time. Most overrated feature on modern phones imo.

[@domc9026]

My phone still unlocks even when I'm wearing a masks.

[@domc9026]

@@soundwavesuperior6761 I think its an iris scanner

[@UnkemptBushell]

@@hythlodaeus9944 The phone unlocks instantly when you place your finger on the scanner. The scanner is also in a very natural position. I've never understood the desire for face unlock, masks or no.

[@inrain_bows]

This review is pretty honest, but there is a bias, especially towards the performance and speakers, as for most, these are slighter issues than the video exaggerated.

[@noelmontanez7472]

Exacly he just wanted to bash the phone. You can tell LOL

[@rao27_cs]

Sure it might not 'feel premium' but this phone is built like a tank...

[@lorimauk3353]

You discussed speakers for youtube and music, how are they on the other end of a call?

[@curtiswrigley]

Iphone 12: The only flagship phone in 2020 with the innovation of a 60hz screen and a gigantic notch.

[@nfserapitbull]

Very funny Peter.

[@jamesogorman3847]

And still better than most of the rest, after the iphone the best phones I have ever used are by OnePlus, all recent Samsung's are just way too toyish for my liking, loved the look of the s20, but just hate the skin on it, and what point in a 120hz display with a vertical scrolling app drawer, and most launchers are just a bit glitchy at times, so not particularly fond of them either, iPhone to get stuff done for work on, but otherwise OnePlus is definitely my good to, even though I'm typing this on a pixel 4a😂😂

[@victuringan1429]

And still the best selling phone worldwide. People won’t care even if you put 1000hz on the screen.

[@curtiswrigley]

@@victuringan1429 IOS has something like 35% of phones globally. And they will catch up to everyone elsewith the hz in a couple years and then give it a made up name like they invented it. Its the apple way. Lag behind 2 years then claim they innovated it

[@bruboss2064]

@@curtiswrigley to be more precize only around 17% .. globally.

[@tenchi654321]

I'm still not sure why folks are mad about speakers and the headphone jack when mostly everyone is using earbuds lol

[@matthewwood3000]

Cause reviewers need some negatives to talk about, but I don’t don’t see how they are negatives I mean it’s not like the speakers are so bad you can’t use them and yeah most people have wireless headphones or earbuds

[@Kane317]

I agree, same reason I never understood the complaint about the absent headphone jack. Aren't most ppl are Bluetooth headsets by now?

[@f2pgamingcastleclashmore119]

I always use speakers. Im using my phone's speakers to watch this video right now too. I even use my phone's speakers to listen to music in the car.

[@tylerjohnson1933]

Hey guys great vid 😍❤ Could u please make a video where u edit a full vid n the 2020 ipad pro

[@JoelOman1980]

I've been using the Pixel phones (even though they are not even officially available in my country) for a couple of years now and I love seeing Google progress with their software and usability. This review was a real eye-opener to someone(=me) who's now coming from the Pixel 3a XL and thinking of upgrading. Might go for the 4a instead and save some cash for the next incarnation. Thank you very much, informative, non-biased and well spoken. Subscribed for sure!

[@googleuser7126]

I love my pixel 5! So glad I got rid of my shiny turd note 20 Ultra.

[@Willis2992]

Good on you. Ibe got an S20 5G Exynos which is also a shiny turd. The battery life is abysmal.

[@supertrick4352]

@@Willis2992 did your s20 get really hot? For example when charging or just usual use? Did you change to pixel 5 now? If so, was if worth it?

[@zski1]

Great review. But I’ve watched 15 other popular tech reviewers and their reviews are more positive. Why? They can’t ALL be biased?

[@Beyllion]

Because the phone is going to be good for the vast majority of people. This one is nitpicking for no reason. I used to have a flagship Huawei phone and now I bought a Pixel 5 and I can say it's a no nonsense phone. The only real criticism I can make is the speakers. Both the loudspeaker and the earpiece which isn't really an earpiece. Other than that, this phone will give you most of what an S21 can give you, for a lower price.

[@eladbari]

Because the average youtuber isn't like the one above. They are clones, and they run on the same generic script/Casey Neistat background music/ Cool LED room light. Try to think when was the last youtuber review you saw where product review wasn't all smelling of roses?

[@stevensanchez1192]

@@eladbari As a tech guy you're defending the wrong reviewer, lol, the guy above destroys this reviewer.

[@pranavgautam96]

In short, if you're a Pixel Fanboy, get the 4a. That's value for money right there.

[@AmitKumar-pj6tz]

Really true bro, got one myself yesterday during big billion day sale

[@themeapster5974]

Or wait until black friday to see if it drops price

[@rustylarry7465]

4a 5g seems better than normal 4a, will last longer imo.

[@techsenseionline4567]

Got my 4a today bam

[@The_Calm_Chaos]

I got my 4a when it came out and I'm very happy with it.

[@farzadjahanfard]

Watching on my pixel 5 sold my s20 5g no regrets.

[@Deathbatman]

I would have regrets, I would choose the s20

[@Shahyan008]

😅😅😅 no External memory must be great...ATM IPHONE, GOOGLE AND SAMSUNG phones SUXKS..

[@payman1023]

@@Deathbatman you deserve the s20

[@user-mb4xy2cz3t]

@@Shahyan008 wtf would you need more than 128 gigs anyways?

[@brad5726]

10:57 lmao why are you taking zoomed in photos of your neighbor's houses 😂

[@wilibus]

You pitched the 4A pretty hard in this video, but you didn't even mention what I feel to be the largest difference. Wireless Charging.

[@FXTKITE]

Great video! I'm running a Pixel 4a and you reinforced my decision. So far I love the 4a! Previously had a 2 (was great) and a 4XL (was awesome when it worked, but was not reliable).

[@John-ys4ji]

Where can i find the wallpaper,I dont see it in the Adobe cloud album

[@nng1979]

Pixel 5 just works, is well supported and easy to use. Also the price cant be beat... thats the point. And as far as the camera is concerned it smokes the OnePlus 8, Nubia RedMagic 5S and Iphone SE which I compared.

[@lamustardo]

10:31 Gordon Ramsey after Face App Young!?

[@ZuLuuuuuu]

Thanks for such a detailed review. I don't watch that many videos on my phone but even for me the speakers are important.

[@ssaini5028]

The N20U and iPhone 11 Pro cost twice as much as the Pixel 5. Marc Levoy former head of Google's camera development said there were trade offs for using bigger sensors. Not sure who to believe here, a PHD professor with decades of experience of a KZbinr named Max?

[@MaxTechOfficial]

Yes the Note 20 is a lot more expensive but the cameras in the 11 Pro are the same as the iPhone 11 (other than telephoto, which was just one image in this test). You can buy the 11 right now for $599. There are definitely trade offs for using larger sensors which is mostly the readout speed and needing to use larger higher quality lenses which means big camera bumps and of course price. The readout speed gets improved year over year so now larger sensors can be read out faster than the Pixels 4 year old sensor.

[@efenili]

Other reviews may be soft but the tone of this one feels overly critical just to be different. Parts feel like you think it's the worst Pixel ever but other parts praise it. I don't care about benchmarks and hate that they are showing up in phones reviews now, especially if the only time you see a performance hit is in intense games at full settings. It's like those stupid camera scores everyone used in their marketing and reviews a few years ago. I do agree on $600 being where it should have been. I don't agree that the 4a experience is the same despite the hardware similarities. Samsungs software IMO is the biggest negative of all, and a stopper for me. At least the OnePlus 8t has a cleaner UX but I'd still prefer the smaller size, better battery and camera on the Pixel 5....along with what I think is the best android experience by far still

[@tunepa4418]

Exactly my thought. I don't appreciate a youtuber watching other people's reviews before giving his own honest opinions

[@Sandz_]

100% agree. I’m an Apple fanboy...but IMO he’s just being dishonest. Saying things like “I thought I had a defective phone, the speakers are really that bad!” They aren’t. They’re 100% not that bad. Google, as much as I don’t like them, wouldn’t put their name on if they sucked like he’s describing. Also, talking about 670 nits vs 1200 nits on the screen brightness like that means ANYTHING to 99% of people buying phones. Cool factoid, I guess? I’ve literally never considered how a phone benchmarks. Ever. I don’t even know anyone who has...and a run in a pretty technical crowd. This feels like he’s trying to be edgy or something. It’s weird. Lol.

[@a.r.1611]

@@Sandz_ This is just the nature of a lot of Android "enthusiasts". Spec sheets win you the race, where actual user experience comes second.

[@re6ies_]

I have the Pixel 5, and honestly I wouldn't change this phone for nothing. Stock android, battery will last me from 7 AM till 9 PM, camera is very good, and 90 Hz works perfect. 765 G was the best option for this phone. I would pick this phone over an iphone or Samsung, any day. I recommend the P5.

[@tjmoore0802]

The pixel 5 camera is fantastic and the experience is amazing also the battery life is one of the best I have used for years

[@ArjitDhavale]

Good Review. I have Pixel 5, iPhone 12 Pro Max, and Samsung Galaxy S20 Plus used by individuals in my home. Your review is good except for the 5G speed. I ran tests on all three phones and the 5G download and upload on Pixel 5 were better than iPhone and Samsung. Did this test repeatedly 5 times and same results. This speed may differ by area but in the same area of the three phones, I was surprised to see Pixel getting more download speeds. I am aligned with your review but somehow Pixel's experience is a winner for me out of the three phones.

[@tak3shi788]

It looks like WiFi instead of 5G logo there. 6:30

[@sayansariyev]

Exactly 😁

[@thatsanaurnaur]

He put his sim in the other phones... right after testing the Pixel 5

[@tamahawk175]

6:11 you're on wifi on your pixel... This review is the classic "I don't agree with public opinion, I'm so quirky and relatable" type beat... It's a $700 phone that you're comparing to the $1100 and $1300 flagships, as well as the gaming section, you said it has noticeable dropped frames; no other tech reviewer has noticed an issue while gaming.

[@kobyrosenberg4480]

He could have swapped SIM cards between phones

[@dominics.3730]

Thanks for pointing this out! That 5G would have been a downpoint for me. Later on the second test at 6:34 he's also on wifi. Same with the Samsung... So the hole 5G testing he did is crap.

[@tamahawk175]

Update for this comment: I got my pixel 5 in the mail and have been using it for the past week, its great. Honestly reminds me of an iPhone if it was Android instead of iOS. Perfect phone for someone who wants a daily driver, wants a flagship, but doesn't want to spend $1000 on a phone. Gaming runs great too so everything he said about frame drops is bs.

[@tamahawk175]

@@kobyrosenberg4480 then why is he showing the speed comparison if he's not on 5G

[@mitchtalmadge]

> you're on wifi on your pixel... These speed tests weren't done at the same time that he was holding those phones. Look at the time on the phone: 3:00 PM. The test was done at 5:14 PM on a previous day. You can see at the bottom of the test that it is "T-Mobile - US", not WiFi.

[@danielevitale2029]

Looking forward to the blind camera test 👀

[@RangerRickTV]

What phone has longer lasting battery life? Pixel5 or iphone 11 pro max?

[@psalias2000]

Wow great video, I remember my Google Pixel 2xl has two great loudspeakers, so I have a full stereo sound output, and this smartphone is still working fine in 2020.

[@jna1974]

mine as well

[@niklasheuer5162]

It is still the phone that best fits my needs. Good enough camera for my use, don't need good speakers, stock android without 3rd party apps, minimalistic design, smaller size etc. I get that there are a lot of compromises but for me they are the right ones. I would have just liked the price at 600$.

[@absk601]

I LOVE the thumbnail of this video as to why nobody is talking about this. See, I follow almost all of the best tech channels and when it comes to TRULY IN-DEPTH REVIEWS, it’s either you or DetroitBorg!! Tech channels like MKBHD don’t go thoroughly through the major features as in iPhone Xs case when he was stating the water resistance. Also I have felt it many times that he isn’t carrying all the information! In the race of becoming the first, people forget the true reason of a REVIEW! I really enjoy how you review a product covering all the necessary features that matter!! Nice work you are doing there, KEEP IT UP! 🙂

[@bludangell]

To be fair MKBHD hasn't actually reviewed the Pixel yet, just done a first look.

[@bblair2627]

where did you get that wallpaper as itas nice?

[@CharlesGallagher]

Why is the Pixel 5 on wifi in this video? Or did Google change the graphic for cellular connection? When you did speed tests on wifi....

[@vanderslagmulders]

Impressive review. Thanks for the useful info.

[@kennysa3586]

I've owned the Pixel for a week and I loved it. No downsides that I can speak of. The only reason I returned it is because at $700 I was having extreme buyers remorse. I ended up getting a brand new OnePlus 8 pro for $800. Way more futureproofed. I will get the Pixel 5 again though in one year when it inevitably loses half its value . It is a great 5G spare phone

[@lomuc]

It's at 300 rn :) (i just got one today btw)

[@dy5167]

How is the GPS performance over the older pixels?

[@exiledfrommyself]

I don't know of any reviewer who didn't complain about the under display speaker. Most reviewers were dismissing 5G outright on any phone.

[@ku5587]

The only thing I'd say is I really don't know how you struggled getting pictures of a moving subject. I have no issues with my pixel 4xl. My note 20 ultra had major shutter lag which made crazy. It's probably a software issue.

[@lomarvgc1580]

One thing Even bezels

[@bradleybfb]

Overrated. Thanks to those "even bezels" the top speaker sounds odd.

[@lomarvgc1580]

@@bradleybfb TRUE, BUTT..... even bezels

[@georgemonks4001]

Even bezels

[@karcky]

Let me say something:.....Even bezels

[@ramon475]

That's literally one of the biggest reasons why I like this phone better than any other Android phone atm, asymmetrical bezels are disgusting 🤮

[@chotheamazing]

Wanted to stop by and comment and say I really appreciate your honest review here. I've been considering a Pixel 5 to replace my Razer 5G, and I feel more confident going with the purchase knowing where the shortcomings are. I'm not a mobile gamer, and use headphones - so the slower load times reported and bad speakers aren't a deal breaker for me. Thank you!

[@wanderlust...H]

Same here. Also I don't think pixel 5 will be as slow as something to be worried about. I mean for a power user it might be a turn off but an average user could definitely live with it right ?

[@CB-pe3tk]

Max, thank You for the honest review. actually I'm using N20U and still thinking if I should get the P5. After this review I might reconsider. what I notice on the n20u camera shots is that sometimes it's hard to get a nice shot because of fringing. I did made my comparisons with my P4xl and the noise is really obvious on the pixel. Lastly, how is the Pixel 5's battery compared to N20U? Battery is also what I heavily consider on a phone. Thank You

[@rizdog5735]

I easily pick Pixel 5 over S20 FE and OnePlus 8T just because of its compact form factor and round corners. Now, I understand what you are going to say, I could just get a Pixel 4a because that's compact too. But, here me out, the Pixel 5's advantages over the 4a are so cool to me, that I would happily pay 300 dollars more. My thesis: Need a small phone, and would appreciate 90Hz, Water resistance, Wireless charging, Sage Green colour. And you said wait a year, so here we are, a year later where Google is selling a value Pixel 6 that is big, bulky, top heavy, square corners and buggy.

[@EricHouserecho1284]

Same here. I love the 5. So glad I didn't wait on the 6, hate the heavy, oversized glass design. Long live the Pixel 5, best designed phone I've seen in awhile now.

[@user-mb4xy2cz3t]

He probably meant to wait a year and buy a reduced price Pixel 5, not Pixel 6

[@rupal_hs]

Suddenly every other tech reviewer saying after new pixel launch “ Specs don’t matter to me anymore “ !! Something is fishy 🤨

[@harrydrake4173]

The bags of money from Google changed their mind

[@TherealDjTired]

If they don't praise pixels, no matter how many flows they have, they will not get any review unit...Google will retaliate...but even if all tech youtubers praising while sweating Pixels Google will not be able to sell that many...as for the new Pixel 5...as a techy person...there is literally nothing to talk about...because there is nothing to be imperessed by...simple as that...

[@marco.pereira]

@@harrydrake4173 not sure I agree bc in the past all tech reviewers didn't have a problem being honest and bashing the pixel 2, 3 and 4.

[@hickey85]

I think this is more the case with apple than Google.

[@hickey85]

@NotYouAgain Games no but they blacklist loads who say anything negative about their devices. Not that it matters really. They all are running business so they all do things they think is in the businesses best interests at the end of the day 🤣

[@ChadH2023]

Bad speakers are a deal breaker for me. I use my phone 6 to 8 hours a day for podcast and music in my work van. Clarity and volume are a must. Nice vid!

[@AidosTheMan]

Lmao do u use ur phone speakers in ur van

[@ivak86]

From ex pixel 2 user: You forgot to mention,that pixel stereo speakers works only when gaming and watching videos.For example : If you receive a phone call only the bottom speaker produce sound....and the volume is pretty low :/

[@actionphigures]

Stereo sound is a big thing for me so it's pretty sad to hear that it's not good on the pixel 5 :/

[@tamahawk175]

get some headphones... if you're an audiophile you're not going to be using built in speakers.

[@stevensanchez1192]

@@tamahawk175 Exactly what I'm saying. The sound of the phone is good enough, you really don't need high-quality speakers on it that's just going to mess up the design of the phone when you could just plop on some headphones.

[@thesonofno1]

Still have the Pixel 3. Haven't had a real reason to upgrade yet

[@swololikesolo1625]

Me too, pixel 3 xl. And were still getting another android version.

[@matxzx]

Pixel 2 xl here. I honestly don't know if I should upgrade. Have been waiting for this one, but it kinda seems like a bummer and from all the reviews I've watched, it also seems a bit disappointing. That's just sad

[@swololikesolo1625]

Yeah I can see what you mean. You could always pick up a pixel 4 xl for $400 refurbished on ebay.

[@RichD2024]

Thank you for the honest review. I am in the market for a new phone and was considering the Pixel but had concerns about every issue you brought up and suspected other reviewers weren't being very forthcoming, "the speakers sound okay" they said. No, not okay.

[@SVW1976]

Im running a Pixel 3. Are you telling me to stick with it for another year?

[@maddhatter1206]

Comparing a 600 dollar phone to phones that are 1200.00 is kinda unfair🤣

[@r0sco_1]

I have the Pixel 5 and really like it. The Battery life is fantastic. Wish more manufacturers would focus on 2-3 day batteries. Regularly getting close to two days between charges. The ear speaker is dreadful though. It does encourage me to use any other method for phone calls as I find it really distracting. For watching videos etc then I consider the speakers as Ok.

[@artinbakhan]

Thanks for making this video it absolutely was helpful to me especially the camera portion of this video, therefore keep the great work!

[@kevin_chan]

Can you do the 5g test using the same servers, I noticed the pixel 5 and Samsung had different servers, can't see what the iPhone is targetting, but that can affect the results. Thanks.

[@eliezergutierrez2472]

I think this review is very well made. I like that your taking a level headed approach. Nice review

[@stevensanchez1192]

This guy is the fakest reviewer I've ever seen

[@eliezergutierrez2472]

@@stevensanchez1192 do you mean MaxTech?

[@stevensanchez1192]

@@eliezergutierrez2472 Yes I mean Max Tech, scroll to the second top comment and read the replies. You'll easily find debunks to his review, I almost find it sad that he fooled so many people.

[@eliezergutierrez2472]

@@stevensanchez1192 you're completely right hopefully they like the pixel 6 that comes out this year because I'm gonna get the pixel 6

[@stevensanchez1192]

@@eliezergutierrez2472 It hasn't been solidified when the Pixel 6 is coming out, but as far as I know Google has always released their phones in October but it's worth mentioning that Google is rumored to be working on their own chips, it's very possible that it will release within early 2022. Perhaps Google is secretly hustling to get the phone out in October since it seems like they're always trying to surprise us. To be honest I'd rather wait for a 7 or 8 and get the 5 because there's a lot of uncertainty but I hope it goes well for you.

[@hamzehdagh3364]

Why is everyone complaining about the speakers? Mine are loud ASF unless I cover them

[@kramshiron]

Nothing to do with volume....it’s the quality, poor compared to previous pixels.

[@kaleok]

thank you for a good review, especially in zeroing in on things others are not fully capturing. Speakers are very important to me as I do not like putting things inside my ear or even a phone up to my ear. I have a Pixel 3 and like the speakers and do not want something even a little bit lower in sound quality while these sound much worse than that. The Pixel 5 is the perfect size for me though, and while I can live with all it's other shortcomings and great comings too, the speakers are a dealbreaker. Wish there were more excellent Android choices in this hand size.

[@SonnOfSam9975]

Question for you... I have a pixel 3 and really like the size and performance... I of course hate the battery life... should I go for the the 12 mini or something else... I'm not a fan of big phones... please share your experience

[@gizmo-addict]

In UK it makes much more sense, pixel5 is priced at £599 with a bose QC II headphone as a free gift..

[@alexkudryk1939]

£599 = $760

[@gizmo-addict]

@@alexkudryk1939 yes..the exchange rate is unfair for UK people but it's same for all brands..s20 FE SD865 version costs £699..if the Bose headphones were not included I believe the £599 for Pixel 5 was also slightly on the higher side..

[@alexkudryk1939]

@@gizmo-addict the Bose headphones deal is sweet. Too bad Americans don't believe in free stuff 😂. We just get to pay the full price.

[@gizmo-addict]

@@alexkudryk1939 every region has its pros and cons..US generally gets better prices and better trade in deals.

[@gizmo-addict]

@SnowBallYT completely agree..especially since in UK oneplus 8T is cheaper and s20fe exynos is at same price as pixel 5

[@michaelmansour8934]

If you want a fair review you should compare it phones with similar price range such as S20 FE and not with the S20 Ultra or Iphone 11 Pro which is double the price. That being daid I agree that the speaker is its weakest point so far. If I go for the Pixel 4a 5G will I notice any difference between 6GB and 8GB? That's the only think making me lean to Pixel 5.

[@dingowalli]

I'd honestly get a regular 4a instead of the larger 4a 5g if you want the best value. I was using regular 4a and sold it as I'm buying the pixel 5 which in Canada is $100 usd cheaper than in USA. In Canada doesn't make sense to buy 4a 5g which is only $130 cad difference from the pixel 5. Also even with the identical sensors of the cameras, it looks like the pictures on the 5 are noticeably better than the 4a 5g (and the 4a), from what I've seen in reviews. Just something to keep in mind if you think they are equal in that area.

[@adamross2256]

I've been so back and forth on the Pixel5. I'm still running a Pixel1 XL. Preordered a P5, then canceled.... then ordered again, and canceled a second time after watching this. I've seen too many "meh" reviews to want to pay $700 for this thing. I'll probably wait until the 4a5G comes out, or go crazy and grab a Note205g or something :P (I'm on Fi, so my selection is limited). If I had my pick of anything, I'd probably grab the LG Wing... I'm not a fan of gimmicks, but that swing screen really does seem useful.

[@DirectorLJ]

As a loyal Pixel user having had all except the 4, this is a huge bummer. Before the Pixel, I was using, and loving, that great series of HTC phones that started the whole front facing, particularly the HTC 1 with 'Boom Sound.' My favorite phone of all time. Google seems (seems) to have been committed to sound through speakers as a distinct advantage in their phone. The Pixel 3 has terrific sound. This is going to keep one dedicated Android lover to head over to that other platform...doh! Thanks for the great video, buddy.

[@anismistry1]

I thought your critical review has flaws. I agree with 5G speeds and speakers not the best cause it shows, you have proofs. But the photos, when you put side by side comparisons with iPhone and the Note, the Pixel still looks better except the closeup of your kid. Then again unnecessary raising a point of how much time Pixel 5 takes to process an image which by way is few secs. I mean pictures are there to look at later after you have shot and few secs processing no problem. The gaming I would say still you don't have enough proofs and didn't show plus this chip is said to be decent with games so don't know where your views are coming for or had a one off bad experience or it will be better with software update. With showing benchmark scores you may garner attention or alarm people but it means nothing when P5 is smooth, layman doesn't know and look for these bench marks. Lastly, do note that you comparing phones like iPhone and note to it which has multiple lens and double the price and quiet bigger in size. My biggest deal breaker is the speaker which I knew before your video as few reviewers have pointed and you are not the only one. Even the sensor which is 4 years old have been covered by another reviewer.

[@HenryLeu]

Hey, this is not a premium phone. This is a mid range phone. You can't complain the missing flagship features on pixel 5.

[@noahfoufoulas4761]

I've never use a pixel but was planing on trying it out as I'm drawn to the stock Android and camera. But that being said I also love trying different phones and haven't used an iPhone in a while. Just waiting for iPhone 12 hands on to decide that device I will be getting. Love the critical review and helped bring some things to my attention

[@jsniderhan]

Thanks for the Review. I was pre-ordered, but the speaker issue changed my mind

[@beast6943]

The single core score of the pixel is similar to the original iPhone se. That’s pretty cool

[@splashmaster2000]

But the 765G is supposedly shit, how dare you?

[@nicholasfu5937]

@@splashmaster2000 It is shit. The original iPhone SE came out in 2016. That's 4 years ago.

[@zetmu01]

You fools should stop being carried away by bloody benchmarks and spec sheets. I don't know why y'all are so dumb. Watch reviews, "pixel 5 vs iPhone 11 pro max speed test" or other Android phones using SD865 then you'll know why I called you dumb.

[@BillUtah]

@@nicholasfu5937 and if you look at the current SE it looks like a 4 year old phone. That display is horrible when compared to pretty any other 2020 display. 👎

[@nicholasfu5937]

@@BillUtah Well yeah, it's a 4 year old budget phone that was $399 when new. So obviously it's going to look like shit compared to any 2020 phone.

[@DarthVader964]

Me watching on my pixel 4a feeling validated

[@paulgrewal587]

To address your concerns 1) in terms of pricing, this phone is only $699 in the US as it has mm wave 5g. Everywhere else in the world, it’s cheaper .. it’s only $799 in Canada. That actually makes it $150 cheaper than the FE and One + 8T. 2) The 5G speeds you’re getting are wack. I’ve seen numerous channels showing speeds north of 300 mps. You said your local provider provides Sub 6 5G and that maybe be why you’re not able to utilize as your phone supports mm wave. Not entirely sure but give it some time. 3) Stop comparing its processor to phones that are so much more expensive. Again, taking into consideration law of one price, which isn’t accurately reflected in the US, how are you comparing this to a note 20 Ultra or IPhone 11. To put that in proper perspective, that’s comparing a phone that’s $799 versus two phones beginning at $1,550. Canadian prices in the aforementioned. If you pay twice as much, you deserve more performance. 4) Shitty stereo speakers I agree with you. Have yet to get mine but will agree from your review 5) Long picture processing times is BS. That’s annoying to me too. Hopefully they can have some software updates that address this, especially since they’re offering 3-years of them.. Thanks

[@rossrobson91]

Most people, especially KZbinrs forget that Google are very young in the phone game and they get bashed so hard for it, swapped my S20 ultra for a pixel 5 a few days ago mainly for a smaller phone and of course there's some other that I'm sacrificing but I don't regret it because I'm loving it, the speakers really aren't bad at all, if your thinking about getting a pixel 5 don't be fooled and put off by this video because as we all know KZbinrs will put out any video for clicks regardless of whether things are true or false.

[@kramshiron]

The 4xl had decent battery life, mine around 6/7 screen on time with soli and motion sense turned off...I kept the AOD on tho. It was the smaller pixel 4 that had poor battery life.

[@butterz5876]

I appreciate Max's honest and critical reviews and analyses of tech. The other bigger channels aren't as critical on the big companies like Google and Apple so they stay in their good books and get review units.

[@johng9361]

Google is 100% on the right track now with this new pixel line the 4A the 4a5g and the 5. They finally realized it's not their marketing niche or sales niche to compete with Samsung or Apple. Google is totally relying on the strength of its camera it's minimal pixel experience pure Android and just the ease of use.

[@blueglitch8060]

Super awesome review, please keep your videos that way, Honesty in everything👍👏🥰

[@o.j7408]

Never thought a phone review would make me laugh out loud multiple times

[@surtmcgert5087]

The only thing wrong here is... if google fixed all of these "issues" you would still find stuff to complain about

[@hmilles]

the 1200 nits brightness you're refering on the iPhone and Samsungs is not the typical brightness of the screen. its the brightness one small white spot can achieve for a short amount of time, while the other parts of the screen are dark. typical brightness on iPhone 12 is lower than on the pixel, iPhone 12 Pro and S20 beat it by about 130 nits, but those cost 200-300$ more

[@dcuk893]

You're the only tech reviewer to cover the issue with noisy shots indoors in less than perfect lighting. My Pixel 4A has this exact issue and it's so frustrating. My wife's iPhone SE gets way better photos indoors of the kids/pets when they are moving.

[@Photo0021]

The Pixel 5 would have been an amazing $300-$400 phone, maybe $500. The price is just way too high. You're better off getting the 4a or 4a 5G.

[@itskweegee]

The funny thing is the phone is only a bad deal in the US, UK buyers get a free Bose headphone and it is $649 in Taiwan. Just because some 5G bullshit in the US so it is expensive over there.

[@bracitos]

I'm from France, I bought a Pixel 5 (629€), and Google send the Bose QC 35 . I'll sell it for 220€, so the final cost is going to be 409€. For this price, it's the beast deal you can find. Pay 699$ for the Pixel 5, it doesn't woth it but, for 409€, it's great value 😍

[@benjamin7114]

Even at that price you'll be disappointed after a while, Google products are just horrible, American reviewers bias propaganda keeps them alive.

[@itskweegee]

@@benjamin7114 Disagree. They could be horrible in spec numbers but definitely not horrible in user experience. As long as pure android experience is what some group of people want, which I'm into as well, Pixel devices will always have their market. There is no other competitor in my mind can compare with Pixels in pure Android experience. The closest one may be OnePlus but I personally avoid all Chinese phones due to security issues.

[@algol6ful]

@@itskweegee I'm in Taiwan and the price of the 5 makes the 4a 5g not a great deal.

[@incarnateTheGreat]

Why is this guy the only one (who I've seen so far) who basically found a bunch of faults in over half of this phone's features? The Speakers are the only glaring issue.

[@splashmaster2000]

The speakers are fine. He is exaggerating. There's not much of a difference between those of the Pixel 5 and the Pixel 3a.

[@incarnateTheGreat]

@@splashmaster2000 Do you have the phone? If so, what's your thoughts so far? Just for context, I would much rather play games on a console or PC rather than a Phone, so I primarily use my phone for reading, streaming, other stuff.

[@kerryrwac]

Telus Canada has the S20 FE priced 5.00/month less than the Pixel5 and the S20 is 5.00/month more on a 2 year plan. Curiously the 4A 5G is 1.00 less per month. Do i keep my Pixel 2 for another year, or go with Samsung?

[@rao27_cs]

Ok so it's not as loud. That means it's quiet, not that it sounds 'bad' necessarily. Is the sounds quality good or tinny like less expensive phones because that would be inexcusable for a google flagship.