Players always kill this NPC & miss the next encounter in Valentine - RDR2

[@Kolo43c]

Arthur “I’m afraid I was a bit too late” Arthur *watching him drown his wife*

[@Taima]

When you're a misogynist but also a bounty hunter

[@wofflecat3011]

​@@Taimait's a video game chill

[@TemplaCon]

@@Taima insecure much?

[@Taima]

@@TemplaCon insecure because…I made a joke that 50 people apparently smarter than you understood to be a joke?

[@Taima]

@@wofflecat3011 it’s a joke chill

[@Claminator]

Arthur: "I got there too late to save her" Sheriff Malloy: "HAAAAAAAA"

[@SlackLifeOutdoors]

Dats my name

[@themurderhornet180]

"got there too late". Literally watched it all happen.

[@Ahrone1586]

Wdym ​@@SlackLifeOutdoors

[@ElectricalExistence]

if you dont know, you can go up the back of the sheriff's office and listen at the door. you will hear the sheriff argue with a woman and then he strangles her, then you can mug the sheriff for a letter, havent gotten past that part yet so ik what happens, trying to keep spoilers low. never played before and on my first run,

[@Claminator]

@@ElectricalExistence oh that's cool, I've heard him arguing with the woman but had no idea but that stuff. I'll have to try it

[@realQuestion]

Sheriff Malloy may not be a very good guy, but the voice actor was totally ready for prime time

[@Taima]

He kinda sounds a lot like Dutch

[@2005portensie]

​@Taima the voice actor is Arthur Gerunda

[@kaybevang536]

@@TaimaSo Sheriff Malloy Is A Man Of PLaNs Too?

[@lamborgini86]

Nothing like dutch but ok ​@@Taima

[@Goldrunner1169]

​@@lamborgini86probably means the way he talks

[@aderek79]

So nice of the game to have a mechanic that works in one specific instance and has the NPCs attack you every other time you try it.

[@Ronuk1996]

Actually it works many tlmes you can turn most NPCs in.

[@aderek79]

@@Ronuk1996 Strange, I tried a few times with NPCs that attacked me on the road. I was accused of a crime (I forget what, Disturbing the Peace?) when taking them into the Office. Bad luck or mod maybe.

[@Deebstertron]

​@aderek79 Exactly, I wiped out a del Lobo hideout, all except one guy which I tied up. I brought him to the very same tumbleweed sheriff who not one day prior publicly executed a del Lobo, and gave me a bounty for another one, and he pulled out his gun and arrested me "for disturbing the peace".

[@70sdude117]

@@Ronuk1996No you can’t. It’s only very specific NPCs

[@Ronuk1996]

@70sdude117 Most random ecounter NPCs can why would they let turn in any random NPC without evidence.

[@Dutch_van_der_linde939]

“ I got there too late to save her “ Sheriff Malloy: HAAA! Good business. Damn good business.

[@Tofi_ytchannel]

Even though it's a lie xD

[@jumbo_pruto]

I'm dead sure Arthur is gonna give you da moneh, Dutch.

[@Brett33]

I never know if it's ok to take someone like that to the jail because most of the time I just end up wanted for kidnapping .

[@coolninjadudeohyeah6833]

Same lol, I tried taking an odriscoll to the strawberry sherrif and got wanted for kidnapping

[@TheDarkPorkins]

@@coolninjadudeohyeah6833 Yes they don't mind if ya kill them when they're threatening someone.

[@EltonElf]

Same i got wanted for kidnapping

[@pandagirl42087]

I just prepare to load the last autosave if a witness pops up, and go for it.

[@johnlucas6869]

Same. I tried to take the hooker to the sheriff and everyone turned hostile.

[@olive9964]

Years later, this game still blows our minds with its level of detail.

[@conformistbastard9842]

WE KNOW.

[@splatninja9447]

It's a genuine masterpiece. Only good thing rockstar has done in a decade

[@michaellego5600]

And yet Rockstar refuses to work on it

[@Simo-dm1zd]

@@splatninja9447bro in this decade that's the only game they made 💀, and the previous one was gta5 (still a masterpiece)

[@yvetteihemesinwa2981]

Ikr?

[@sseeaahhaawwkkssrule975]

I'm surprised you can take him to the sheriff's office and put him in jail. Usually when you hog tie somebody and ride around town with them. They accuse you of kidnapping lol

[@BubbaYoshi117]

Hell I got a kidnapping bounty from hogtying an O'Driscoll

[@R1PP3R_93]

@@BubbaYoshi117 I lasso dragged an O'Driscoll into town and everyone started shooting at me lmao

[@gamergodeighty1686]

@@R1PP3R_93yeah I think the game should tell you if you can arrest someone

[@morpheusdorpheusorpheus]

@@gamergodeighty1686kind of a nice rare treat for the few people who do it on their own tho

[@obscurity3027]

You need to see someone commit a crime in order to arrest them. You can’t drag an O’Driscoll to jail just because Dutch hates them.

[@madchad4805]

This is a great example of why RDR2 is the greatest game ever. One act with 3 different scenarios it’s like a choose your own adventure book.

[@Delessi]

Not to mention that this is a random event, it's not even a sidequest or mais quest and still have more outcomes that most of today games

[@dsadsa726]

Choose your own adventure in completely linear story where not even character youre roleplaying as is choosing anything for himself lmaooooo

[@maximodiaz802]

What?​@@dsadsa726

[@Stacked3403]

For real, I'm on my third play through and I'm still finding and seeing new things. The greatest game of all time

[@ChuyMJ12]

Totally. I’ve been playing it for a year now and I didn’t know you could tie this npc down and take him to the sheriff. I’ll try it in my thirs playthrough.

[@arkay238]

“Would’a saved her, but I wanted the rare cutscene”

[@markwallace1727]

I encountered the gunsmith trying to drown his wife yesterday. Rescued her and hogtied him, but left him there as I'd previously been arrested for kidnapping when trying to take a crim to the sheriff. As I needed ammo and he was tied up out back, I stole it. On the 3rd box I stole, I was reported and arrested. Went back to his store and he laughed about my arrest and how he was such good friends with the sheriff. 🤷

[@CommentinoCommentoni]

@Player7 we need u

[@tupakkaonhyvaa]

Lol!

[@Kinan_The_G.O.A.T]

What? Can you explain more, I searched it on yt, reddit no one said anything about this encounter. What gunsmith in which town

[@pandagirl42087]

​@@Kinan_The_G.O.A.Tthere's a few wife drowning encounters, none of them are a gunsmith, dude probably got confused because the gunsmith was gone for another reason.

[@Kinan_The_G.O.A.T]

@@pandagirl42087 oh, I was confused too. Thanks

[@fredericksmith7942]

“Ain’t no escape now!” - Man who just got his ass kicked, 1899.

[@terminallumbago6465]

I’ve been playing this game for 6 years, and I’m STILL finding new things. Best game ever made, hands down.

[@ayarlett]

I just said exactly the same thing today to someone playing live on TikTok. My wife said to me, "does this game ever end?" and the answer is....not really! There is always something more to do..lol

[@Joker_JAK]

It's not even close. Lol

[@Edithandle1223]

you forgot to loot the wife

[@spiritbaki108]

minmax

[@Panzerfaust_1939]

Yeah

[@WillHopper-py8jj]

DUDE

[@GazB85]

😂

[@lykezomfg11]

She don't need her stuff

[@Nyruami]

I like RDR2, you can just tie up whoever you want and sell him to the Sheriff, no questions asked.

[@lilithmarleen]

Hmm, nope. Just the NPCs that you witnessed committing a crime. If you tie up any old NPC and deliver them to the sheriff, you’ll be arrested for kidnapping.

[@moonfoxarise]

Not if he doesn’t notice…

[@Ww1whiz1914]

I made the mistake of thinking I could deliver this guy dead. He immediately stood up, the law had been called. So I shot him, called my horse, who at the time was at low bond with, which I think was the reason he didn’t come too close (right next to me, I always hate that), so I made out of there with almost no health.

[@miles2706]

Did you really played RDR2?

[@jayweh]

Idt you've ever actually played the game.

[@fluffyfeetbmf]

This is something I didn’t know, you learn something new about this game all the time. Thanks for the great video.

[@stewhite7751]

This game is absolutely amazing .. but whats more amazing , is the work you put in making these videos for everyone. Well done player7 👍

[@tonyedwards3938]

Never played this game.

[@elilundgreen]

No, this dude's video making work is not more amazing than the years of effort put into this game by a team of developers. Not even close

[@Delpasadoparati23]

Arthur: Got there too late to save her. Also Arthur : Waits patiently for her to get kill.

[@bozapub3507]

It was hard watching that part

[@Delpasadoparati23]

@@bozapub3507 You are right. Someone was saying in another comment section that even though it is a video game, it makes you feel...I cannot remember what the word was 🤔 empathy? I think it was, and feelings as well. When I play and fail to help someone I feel bad. It feels too real.

[@bozapub3507]

@@Delpasadoparati23 yup absolutely. My exact thoughts. Even tho it's a videogame it was hard watch.

[@takahashi2852]

it would be interesting to know all the NPCs outside of bounty hunting that you could arrest like the escaped prisoners such as Black and White

[@moonscar119]

Turning in black or white would be horrible though. Every encounter with this is hilarious

[@ayarlett]

Why arrest Black and White? They carry on like an old married couple. I came across them in a remote place as John and they never changed one bit. God Bless em.

[@altrag3748]

Dude I don’t know if I could just sit there and watch, they made that drowning sequence WAY TOO realistic it’s awful just to watch.

[@Carl_McMelvin]

Gay

[@kattpiss1]

@@Carl_McMelvinfellas, is it gay to have basic empathy?

[@internaut4257]

You clearly have issues you need to work out

[@rileigh5642]

There’s a few other scenes I feel the same way about

[@kazim1700]

​@@Carl_McMelvindude you probably watch gore videos to impress your "boy"friends

[@chrisquarrie]

RDR2 is, without a doubt, the greatest video game ever made. The bar has been set.

[@BlazeInferno360]

This is my second time playing it again. Man what a great game 😌

[@ste1nfo790]

Preach.

[@John-996]

This is amazing crazy how work went into stuff that most people will not see.

[@justanotherboi1212]

The irony of this is that sherrif maloy also choked to death his lover

[@ValiantWrestling]

You forgot to pick up your hat after tying him up...

[@arkay238]

Your horse got it

[@brandonmccoy7006]

I swear this game is the gift that keeps on giving. I didn't know this one

[@Vox_Was_Here666]

The fact that I tied him up and took him to the Sheriff without knowing I could, is quite hilarious

[@guperman8249]

I have more than 1,200 hours in this game and seeing this an encounter I have never even heard of before gives the urge to play it once again. This game is just so re-playable it's insane

[@susanlisson7066]

Damn, I’ve replayed RDR2 and never seen this! So many extra little things in there. Incredible!

[@Driller12]

I like that the sheriff gave less money for when he was a killer than just abusing her, like he did society a favor or something

[@uligallardo8110]

If you're given less money for failing at saving someone, then no matter what morals do you have, you'll want to NOT fail next time.

[@xiyangzang562]

Two lives exchanged for this hanging scene. 😂

[@obscurity3027]

This is a great way to get the bolt action rifle early too. One of the guards on the gallows carries it. Also, cutting Arthur’s hair that short is an absolute travesty.

[@planescaped]

Now that is interesting and a pretty good incentive to let him drown her, lol

[@Star_of_the_Sea1]

In my first playthrough, i came across this encounter and killed the guy via explosive and incendiary rounds to the melon. The woman ran screaming.

[@TowerBuild92]

Acceptable

[@ayarlett]

You could have made 6 dollars.

[@rileigh5642]

When in the story do you unlock this encounter?

[@jasonoverman9679]

With how happy the sheriff was I thought he was going to use the guy as a scapegoat for the lady he was having an affair with

[@Ricksdetrix]

1:14 "Ain't no escape now!" You're god damn right

[@SrNuno-tl5kc]

God this level of detail feel so good and immerse you in the game for sure.

[@stevejames7930]

This game is so detailed it’s crazy

[@ayarlett]

Valentine has the most secrets of all the towns. Good to hang out there for a full week and see what happens at night.

[@zinmas_2568]

This game is ART

[@VeniVidiVici911]

Man this game is incredible, i cant think of any game that has the details that this one does

[@Vman3D8531]

We not gonna talk about the absurd amount of money he just suddenly received from a little wad of money on the table?

[@yggdrasil4986]

Apparently not (probably money cheat)

[@giraffebean]

Where is the "heard it but couldn't find it until it was too late"

[@dddttt7989]

What happens if you stop the hanging? Any other dialogue if you free him?

[@adur6400]

As far as i know, the guy just runs away, while the sheriff and his helpers start shooting at you

[@cartoonraccoon2078]

Thank you for posting a video with insight and showing the optyions, rather than just another cutscene people post like its their content.

[@-yeme-]

at any of the C2 Valentine hangings, if you shoot the lawman who pulls the lever you can pick up his Bolt Action Rifle before its available in the story or gunsmiths

[@KrazyGoodMods]

Good to know. You can also get it from a bounty hunter when you rescue Sean.

[@livewire2759]

I always pick one up during Sean's rescue mission, like the guy above mentioned. You don't have to pay a bounty that way.

[@arvintyree1109]

​@@KrazyGoodModswhich one?

[@jpmitchell1980]

@arvintyree1109 Usually the first guy you see after knifing the two that Trelawny puts on that show for

[@emir3109]

0:42 that happened to me yesterday i walked up to him intervened he pulled a knife and one shotted me since my health was low

[@tysondormer7515]

a good thing to remember is that in random encounters if you lasso someone and nobody reports you for kidnap then you can take them to the sheriff just remember you have to catch them in the act of the crime first

[@Ronuk1996]

I knew about turning him in, but the fact there is also dilague if you turn him in after he kills his wife and the fact he then gets hanged if he kills his wife is insane. when first played this game i thought this was just basic ecounter. Its crazy that i have done 5 playthroughs and still see new things. Just insane, cant wait to see GTA6 ecounters.

[@livewire2759]

What's insane about it? It's not right, but it's historically accurate. That's how things were done back then. If you killed someone, the government killed you. Still done that way in some places...

[@SpaceBaked]

I can confidently say he will never hang in my game.

[@hushamAmeen]

Can you do more of these videos but in New Austin ? Like secrets and encounters with NPCs , treasures and so on

[@Player_7]

Yes. I will

[@andrewlowden322]

@@Player_7 that freaking gold ingot at Ridgewood farm, so inconsistent how to knock it out of the chest

[@Spectreffex]

I have probably 600 or 700 hours in this game, I've never encountered this guy trying to drown her wtf man this game is so massive

[@Bamboozlenoodle]

Thx man, going to replay the game because of your vids.

[@bossaboy9678]

dude you are doing great with the algorithm with these titles

[@HakoTaco1]

And they say the game is too restrictive on what to do.

[@Ronuk1996]

Yeah it's really silly thing to say when you have stuff like this this game has more freedom then many open world games.

[@John-996]

There some missions that are but there lots main story quests that give you lots of freedom then you have ecounters like this that have many outcomes. People are like sheep and just repeat the same criticisms they hear other people say with out really taking the time to see if its really true.

[@JaylukKhan]

Do they?

[@sefin84]

it is restrictive when it comes to certain things. Like mission which have scripted chases you cant avoid etc. Other than that, RDR2 is one of the greatest games ever made. There is no doubt about that.

[@Ronuk1996]

@sefin84 Some missions like with chases like chick Mathew can be skipped by aiming a gun at him. Others like the Kid who robs Arthur you can catch him for an alterative cut Scene

[@lfs147]

This is not a game, this is a work of art

[@Jarpasaurus]

I’m just noticing now is the sheriff voiced by the guy that does Dutch’s voice?

[@youmukonpaku3168]

it's extremely noticable on the "damn good business"

[@lamborgini86]

Played this game since launch and still finding things out, ive never seen this

[@breadfan590]

What happens if you save him from the execution?

[@unablenarwal8863]

I’ve played this game twice my second play through was well over 300 hours and I have never seen any of this not even the guy trying to drown her

[@dante9903]

Best part is, he accused her of cheating or fooling around right? If you kill him and follow her she’ll go meet up with another man lol

[@JackBlack-uk8xc]

So the last scenario is a best scenario then 😂 all parties involved is dead

[@dante9903]

@@JackBlack-uk8xc pretty much 😂

[@lamborgini86]

Tbf hes out drinking not giving her attention

[@rokukou]

​@@JackBlack-uk8xc She probably cheated **because** hes an abuser... lmao death sentence to cheating is crazy

[@anti-ethniccleansing465]

@@rokukou FYI: They do that in the Middle East, and people with those beliefs are moving here.

[@TheRealBatCave]

U could have got a free bolt action from the sheriff if u start a fight with him before the hanging starts

[@Truffle_Pup]

There's also the one where you can save the wife, hogtie him up, ride him out to the swamps of St Denis and let the Gators do their own justice - Free of Charge.

[@pedinhuh16]

No reward tho

[@Wh173c0c0]

@@pedinhuh16 This is its own reward.

[@youmukonpaku3168]

what's the point of hogties and railroads if you can't do silent film villainy?

[@edwardyoung8575]

This game. Just keeps on giving

[@JaylukKhan]

I had this exact encounter in Rhodes. Couldn't use a weapon, so I just beat him senseless.

[@TsutomuGindi]

Every time I tied someone up for being a criminal I always had someone witness it and call it a kidnapping when I tried to bring then to the sheriff so I assumed i just couldn't do that lol. Sometimes I feel like I miss out on a lot because the game really makes it unclear when you can, can't or shouldn't do something

[@truthhurts3524]

I hogtied him and took him the sheriff after I recused the woman, only I got wanted as soon as I walked into the office. A couple in game days later I found a I think Raider in a prison wagon, killed the Raiders that tried rescuing him. Hogtied the prisoner and took him to the Rhodes sheriff and I got the drowning wife dialog. 🤷🏽‍♂️🤣

[@timetravelingtraveler]

Average RDR2 encounter, pure consistency

[@trillhendrix5551]

Wow still learning new things from RDR2 years later this game is really amazing👌

[@BenSkitzer]

'she a runner, she a trackstar'

[@alexharrington4692]

I saw this encounter in Van Horn and just beat the guy unconscious when he tried to fight me, went on with my day and didn't think any more about it.

[@toReasonWhy]

Whoa, this is a scenario not covered here, I wonder if you encounter them again in any special way later if you do this...

[@Atreas40000]

He is one of the guys that you can use for the bandit and horseman challenges without losing honor.

[@corbinhbucknerjr558]

I managed to lasso one of the Murphree Brood for the horseman challenge and lost no honor. And I enjoyed doing that murdering inbred in. Only one I'd have liked to catch like that better would be one of the Night Folk.

[@Panzerfaust_1939]

One time i was trying to save a dying man near saint denis, when i got to the clinic the doc wasn't there Placed the man down the pavement to go find the doc and got wanted in the city for murder as i put him down Damn doctor wasn't there, i lost more than 150 dollars, still got a bounty to pay, and never got to see that scene where the doc was sawing the man's arm completely conscious

[@crayzmoe]

I wonder what happens when you take him to the sheriff and just realease him there

[@Player_7]

Thank you ♥️Have to try😅

[@Wolfie720]

@@Player_7Same for me we have to try releasing him at the sheriff

[@CasualClobber]

I arrested the pick pocket in saint Denis when you go into the Tailor, hog tied him walked him to the prison walking past several Lawmen, as soon as I stepped into the police station I was a wanted man and akk the lawmen starting shooting at me

[@jamesappleby]

😂

[@WOOOPdoctorFROGhere]

4:52 why is Dutch reading out the crimes that were committed?

[@Terminal57]

Huh?

[@WOOOPdoctorFROGhere]

@@Terminal57 that's Dutch on the platform

[@Terminal57]

@@WOOOPdoctorFROGhere no bro that’s Sherrif Malloy

[@yvetteihemesinwa2981]

That does sound like Dutch.

[@doGInVain]

​@@Terminal57OP is making a reference to the fact they share the same voice actor

[@user-ko7gk7wp5x]

I didn't even know you could catch random criminals and take them to the local sheriff. You learn something new everyday about RDR2.

[@The7Reaper]

Im the 0.1% of players who never came across this encounter lol

[@AlexBrown230]

I'm part of the 0.001% who just let it happen and didn't care, didn't stop him, didn't arrest him, didn't intervene, just walked away.

[@John-996]

​@@AlexBrown230Its crazy they went to this much detail knowing many people such as your self would let it happen or just shoot the guy.

[@AlexBrown230]

@@John-996 Yeah i mean it could be worse you could be forced to pick a side or participate, so many games force you to choose and get involved. I honestly just saw it went meh and just went along. I just don't know why i didn't really care enough about either enough to get involved and i like that i get to make that choice.

[@ChrisCrossClash]

@@AlexBrown230That seriously says something about you as a person if you did do nothing, would you seriously do the same thing if this happened in real life?

[@AlexBrown230]

@@ChrisCrossClash You know game =/= real life right? Even if it did happen irl and i did nothing instead and just walked away what's it to you? I'm not obligated to anyone but me and mine, i only care about what benefits me. I have no obligation to help anyone else, especially at the cost to myself if the guy might pull a weapon. Go cry about it.

[@dealler669]

Yeah, most people don´t know about this ending because they´re not bloody psychopaths.

[@Cbart23]

Should have made her the woman the sheriff was cheating with.

[@mutatednut]

The detail in this game is ridiculous. How is there still new stuff I haven't seen before? Crazy

[@bhamdodger]

Killing someone in an uncontrollable rage is the exact opposite of killing them in cold blood.

[@livewire2759]

It's different, but I wouldn't say it's the "exact opposite". Murder is still murder... The exact opposite of cold blooded murder would be ignoring them completely. The exact opposite of uncontrollable rage murder would be hugging them and smothering them in kisses and affection.

[@gsaucegaming6635]

Arthur: he killed his wife, I couldn’t save her. The sheriff for some reason: HA!

[@kwdblade4683]

A murderer is worth less than an attempted murderer I guess 🤣

[@dougboyatt2927]

If he hadn't killed her he'd just be a woman beater. Since he killed her he's a murderer. 1s a misdemeanor the other means you're fucked lol

[@TheNwalters0]

I went through valentine a million times and never knew about it thanks

[@LeonTheGreatOne]

I'll always do 1. Anyways.

[@KJGould]

I kept getting accused of kidnapping. Think the trick is do the Benedict Albright mission as early as possible.

[@BigBrotherBrody]

Dont pin the guy who asked for the pin

[@iwaldipanegara]

bcz his noob

[@datmemecat]

Bruh😂😂😂

[@Player_7]

😂😂

[@Sparks00psn]

Pin this man!

[@TexCen]

lol, took me a sec. Thought this was related to Arthur dialog I hadn't heard before. "Hey feller! Dont pin the feller who asked for the pin."

[@leannecraggs1996]

theres an npc encounter in rhodes almost exactly the same as this

[@teefarox92]

I have played through this game at least 4 times already and have never encountered this scenario.

[@NatjoOfficial]

Genuinely one of those little things that makes sense to do

[@jules-ov9sn]

This game is crasy, I can’t imagine the level of details in gta VI…

[@MrShaktros]

Weird I think I got a notification from the game saying I should tie him up and went to the sheriff.

[@robertrastlos4512]

This game is way more complex than i thought. Now i know why my son loves this!

[@LG.Associates]

Mind boggling how much attention to detail Rockstar put into this game. Most of these outcomes 99% won’t even see

[@evil_resident9]

This encounter always happened to me in Rhodes during that part where the games forbids you for the life of it to use guns in Rhodes so I couldn't lazo him and take him to the sceriff but just defeat him with a few punches and never had a second encounter.

[@jacqulineball2284]

Glad you did so I don't have to. I always go for the kill.

[@rigbone1996]

One of the uncountable reasons I keep playing over and over again

[@matss5864]

I feel that the ending with him just getting the bullet and she lives is the best

[@ConstantinoHaza]

Omg, I can't believe I missed that crucial encounter

[@FreeAimDog]

this reminds me of the time dutch had some of the gang dress as lawmen.

[@unnot5706]

This game is so big, I don't think I'll ever fully know it.

[@sanmarinyo]

I did this before accepting the first bounty job at the Sheriff’s office. Make sure to “officially” become a bounty hunter in the Valentines before you take him in. I did not and I ended up getting hunted for “kidnapping” and when I entered the Sheriff’s office the police thought I was kidnapping him instead of bringing him in so the Sheriff and the rest of the Police department started shooting me. I hope this helps and you don’t do the same mistake as me.