Popeye - BBQ For Two Original and Reanimate Comparison

[@TomboTime]

Really drives home how much passionate animators upgraded a . . . pretty cheap popeye cartoon lol

[@jossuecabrera8611]

Now if only we can get the same with Tom and Jerry (Early tv era), Looney tunes (Also early TV era) or the pink panther cartoons. Those are pretty cheap.

[@CrazyChris622]

pretty sure most cartoons were cheap in those times

[@doodledangernoodle2517]

@@jossuecabrera8611 Gene Deitch era Tom and Jerry suuuuuucks

[@jossuecabrera8611]

@@doodledangernoodle2517 I know right? I avoid those episodes like a disease

[@sweets_Cat88]

Didn’t Popeye once had a few episodes animated by Hana Barbara?

[@animegx45]

5:06 That's a classic gag that the classic weirdly failed to do. Not just having Popeye himself leave a perfect hole, but even his hat that was already off his head somehow still left the same impact.

[@shenloken2]

03:35 - The reanimate of this particular gag hits so much harder than the original! The facial expressions sell the dialogue so much better!

[@alexhyatt7541]

5:21 JUNIOR? Don't call me a sissy name like that my name is [unintelligible noise]

[@danielgudinojuarez6729]

3:35 to to 3:42 So dynamic and smooth 🤩🤩🤩

[@LucasFerreira-lr5nj]

And funny lmao😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@sweets_Cat88]

I think I saw a Twitter post with this particular scene in the work in progress stage.

[@LucasFerreira-lr5nj]

And it's of what Twitter account that you saw this?🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@sweets_Cat88]

@@LucasFerreira-lr5nj I can’t remember the name … sorry

[@sweets_Cat88]

I’m not the brightest bulb but I just saw your Twitter feed and now seeing your KZbin name…

[@DarkOverlord96]

02:16-02:23 Wow, whoever did this segment NAILED the look of the old black and white Popeye cartoons! It almost makes me wish the whole short was animated like this!

[@smoage]

Hey, that was me! Thanks! Glad you liked it! Hopefully I can cook up some more of that kinda thing soon!

[@dukkemonterier3429]

@@smoage Outstanding work.

[@smoage]

@@dukkemonterier3429 Thanks!!

[@JustinKatz]

Love it Tom!!! ❤❤❤❤

[@ramskull-goneelectric563]

@@smoage As more stuff goes into the public domain you would be able try it with other stories and other earlier cartoons.

[@CartoonEj203]

5:20 Whoever animated this part did an awesome job

[@robertmillward6153]

5:12 - A nice tribute to Robin Williams

[@nickwerner7983]

The Genie!

[@christianpeligrinocagadas9781]

​@@nickwerner7983and the only Live-action Popeye ever played

[@joselynfigueroa3955]

04:26-04:30 is my favorite! Olive's '50s Famous Studios design is so underrated and I'm glad to see it represented here! The animation's so smooth!

[@deshawnwilliams3358]

4:21 mine too 😁👍

[@Kamina.D.Fierce]

It's also REALLY funny in hindsight how THAT was considered "Rock n Roll" for that time period. When you hear "Rock n Roll" you think things like Van Halen, ACDC, Iron Maiden, Led Zepplin. Then there's what Bluto is... singing/playing. LOL

[@lemonmeat]

the reanimated is stunning compared to the original!!! its so much more lively and pops out more in the best way possible

[@GraveUypo]

well, the old one is super cheap and is done entirely in the same boring side-on perspective all of the time. easy upgrade

[@sridrawings4510]

except for some of that purpousfully badly draw scenes in reanimated

[@sleepydan9818]

5:41 This is the cutest version of Olive Oil I've ever seen.

[@HanssenChin]

I think this reanimated part was made by caddicarus

[@biraptor6205]

3:35 Is so satisfying compared to the original

[@NFGGisCoolXD]

That guy should be hired

[@tonymata8070]

@@NFGGisCoolXDFor real, I would love to see some Popeye shorts from that guy. 😮👏🏼

[@NFGGisCoolXD]

@@tonymata8070 me too

[@blizzardforonline1954]

4:15 - 4:16 has that one framer!

[@GameKeeper28]

You cannot have a character pummeled into an accordion shape and not have him in any visible pain. The joke just doesn't work that way.

[@nessthecat1]

Original or Reanimated?

[@GameKeeper28]

@@nessthecat1 Original.

[@avosmash2121]

Ok its very silly but that Pikachu-Wimpy surprise gag was hilarious the first time and it still is.

[@punkysnarks]

The lack of music is really eerie, and I can't help but notice skipping audio in some places.

[@sridrawings4510]

1:52 Michael JackSon : and i took that personally

[@TheRealMichaelJackson1958]

Curiosity: Michael have a Popeye Shirt in THIS IS IT Era

[@sridrawings4510]

@@TheRealMichaelJackson1958 what?

[@Fort_Master]

Man... I've only ever really watched the older black and white Popeye cartoons, But this one was hardly animated at all!! No wonder you reanimated it!!

[@robotx9285]

Deadass the vast majority of these new clips have far more animation....They are all fan created.

[@jossuecabrera8611]

​@@robotx9285 just wondering. Is this from some sort of tv episode of Popeye, since thag would probably make the most sense as to why it looks so rushed, like most cartoons during that time of early tv

[@DarkOverlord96]

That's because those old cartoons from the 40s were theatrical shorts so they had more budget. This was an episode of the Popeye TV show that aired in the 60s which was a LOT cheaper.

[@charici]

@@DarkOverlord96 BBQ for two was also a pilot episode. Which further explains the quality.

[@greenmushroom2587]

Early 60's Popeye was a rough era. Not only the budget was small but they pumped out episodes A LOT. There was like 250 made in 2 years from like 5 different animators, each with their own take on the character. The shorts from Jack Kinney were the worsts (he made this one)

[@christianpeligrinocagadas9781]

6:05 All New Popeye safety segment moral lesson: Don't do most of dangerous drugs and stay away from those strangers but feel a good times be more responsible and more awareness for safety reasons.

[@danielgudinojuarez6729]

The Reanimated collab is much better than the original!!!

[@knuclear200x]

No wonder this got reanimated, i've only ever watched the old Fleisher episodes up to the Famous Studio ones.

[@HenriekeG]

I love the reanimated sequences, but the original (PSA aside) isn't that bad, actually! Cheap limited animation, but I like the strong poses and the way the few parts that DO move move.

[@leandrojose3887]

Me too

[@MauDibujaPersonajes]

1:01 Got Me Dead 💀💀💀

[@delvin0965]

This makes the original look like an animatic.

[@apieceoftoast768]

In a way, it is: it's basically the reanimated's animatic

[@hectormanuel8360]

Dave Alvarez did the final shot. Excellent silhouettes as always

[@itzorin600]

Can we all say that one lump line was probably the most funniest part of that cartoon

[@SpiritzPlanet]

That is NOT rock and roll-that’s bluegrass. *Bad* bluegrass. Bluto needs “genre lessons.” The new animation, however, is awesome!

[@gemstonegynoid7475]

olive oyl wouldnt have noticed

[@TylerMcNamer]

Cartoons made for television were never really that good back in the 50's and 60's. Never really cared for Popeye and Felix the Cat during those times. This reanimated project could be seen in the theaters back in the 30's; people would pay their nickels for this special.

[@magicjuulbus7140]

lol just noticed Popeye breaks his neck at 2:28

[@dukkemonterier3429]

Awesome work, guys! And nice Monty Python reference too. Wasn't expecting it. Was 5:12 a reference of Robbie Williams' movie?

[@AmeliaBerdel-xv3wp]

Yes, but what Monty Python part(I'm sorry I never watched Monty Python:()

[@dukkemonterier3429]

@@AmeliaBerdel-xv3wp Well, nevermind. I can't remember now.

[@AmeliaBerdel-xv3wp]

​@@dukkemonterier3429oh,ok

[@jamieimai9328]

Great job on the reanimated King Features Syndicate TV logo and Popeye’s signature spinning star opening beside the original ones @ 0:10-0:21.

[@friedmcfish3134]

I hope in the future there will be more of these. Seeing a reanimated “Popeye vs Sinbad the Sailor” would be AMAZING!

[@VJFranzK]

3:30 wow, they actually animated her toes in the original??

[@deshawnwilliams3358]

They sure did 😁👍

[@tjswanson7577]

I think this is the only time I've seen Brutus as the neighbor/rival in a cartoon instead of Bluto. I'll admit I haven't watched many of the cartoons from the 60s on, but I always thought they had Bluto and the comic made Brutus as an attempt to avoid copyright (Unnecessary as it turned out)

[@gemstonegynoid7475]

i thought bluto looked weird in this. i see, its a kinda lazy redesign of bluto because of copyright.

[@gerlofsdonia4522]

I hope this means you eventually make more of these. I'd love to see the choppier Popeye 60's cartoons redone!

[@Themrock21]

Popeye and the Phantom is planned.

[@HenriekeG]

​@@Themrock21Maybe I could join one of them, for once :o

[@gerlofsdonia4522]

@@Themrock21 Awesome! Since you mentioned the Phantom, I hope that also means you all will do Flash Gordon some day. 😄

[@mikechicago6200]

Looks great and even better then the og....all the animators for thier part did a great job! Man the original Cartoon looked so cheap and not that good looking...man the reanimated one looks even better4

[@WULDORI]

hahaha when popeye eats his spinach he turns into the inimitable Robin Williams!

[@Grumbo_studios]

5:19💀Dont look

[@waynemacfarland1546]

Popeye: (frowns) Wimpy & Swee'Pea: (know this is not the time to argue, walk away without saying a word, except Wimpy, who says "Pardon me." on his way out). Popeye: (beckons Brutus) "Junior!" Brutus: (offended, shouts) "JUNIOR?!! DON'T CALL ME A SISSY NAME LIKE THAT!! MY NAME IS,...!!!" (charges at Popeye like an angry bull with a full throated roar of rage) "RRRRRRROOOOOOAAAAAARRRRRRR!!!" Popeye: (winds up with his fist as Brutus charges him, lets Brutus have it with one punch, sending him sailing over to the other side of the country). "POW!!!"

[@Gittykitty]

I'm impressed how the new one got the hole in wall joke right.

[@GameKeeper28]

3:31 What the hell is Bluto holding? Is it some kind of weird looking cup?

[@damon2636]

It's a shoe

[@GameKeeper28]

@@damon2636 You don't put sugar-cubes in shoes.

[@Meteorite_Shower]

@@GameKeeper28 Yeah, it's a really goddamn bizarre part, but it's... part of the original for some reason. Bruto just... now has Olive's shoe and is putting sugar in it like it's a cup of tea. I feel like something got horrendously cut from the story.

[@GameKeeper28]

@@Meteorite_Shower Oh, he's using her shoe as a cup for tea. Wait, what? Now I'm even more confused.

[@ryshi1299]

Can you please do Popeyes the sailor in safari so good reanimated

[@Don_Matteo]

This is one of my favorite episodes. I still have the one that I recorded from a morning show when I was like 8.

[@Truehero1057]

I can see why this was reanimated. The original version looks like it’s barely holding onto its budget.

[@Tabascofanatikerin]

Thanks for this video!! Makes it much easier for me to show people the differences between original and reanimation 😊👍

[@sethcarlow8363]

i had fun watching this,wow.

[@Rubberman202]

Wait a minute... I recognize the name "Jack Kinney" from a bunch of Donald Duck cartoons I used to watch!

[@Tabascofanatikerin]

Yeah. He also directed a lot of 1940's Disney feature films like "Pinocchio" and "Dumbo". And among his directed shorts are "The Fuehrer's Face" and "The Story of Menstruation". Quite a portfolio!

[@Nick-ty9us]

Jack Kenny directed a lot of goofy cartoons though like to how to series

[@PScoopYT]

Yeah, he was a former Disney animator. After he lefts Disney, he founded his own studio and have done various animation, including the 1960s Popeye TV cartoons.

[@Nick-ty9us]

@@PScoopYT why did he leave Disney was it because Disney was shutting down the cartoon department

[@Nick-ty9us]

Jack Kenny, was mainly the Director of the goofy cartoons made at Disney in the 1940s and 50s

[@Pikazilla]

These tv cartoons did have good writing, but Wimpy provided the animation budget.

[@HanssenChin]

1:20 this animation style looks familiar, did eder kfcard make this?

[@dominicanemperor28]

What was that thing that Brutus was putting in Ovile's shoe?

[@AulisA.O.T]

4:52 two NOM!

[@apocaloso]

This was truly amazing

[@jonothanthrace1530]

I was fully expecting there to be a shot replicating the Nintendo game. Didn't see one, but it's still fantastic.

[@nseven1117]

never thought I'd say this but Bluto's voice is smooth as silk

[@gabreleiros9596]

looks super cool, I will like to participate in something similar to this, where I can find projects like this?

[@superstarhailey]

Hi Popeye

[@hectormanuel8360]

I needed this thank you

[@David-yw2lv]

Even though the animation was lackluster,I prefer the original.The reanimated one is grotesque.

[@StephenSternforPresident]

Why is everything trying to mimic gravity falls animation it's like they're spitting out a lot for the streaming services that have very similar animation

[@STP43FAN1]

1:58 nothing can beat the original where Brutus’ hair gets instantly burned off then regrows right away.

[@TaylorZanderFrancis]

I cant understand how the original looked so stiff when it had about 5 animators. It came out in 1960, right? Hanna-Barbera cartoons with a single animator had more movemenr than this.

[@Themrock21]

The budgets were extremly low and Kinney's unit was filled with Ex-Disney animators who had to get used to it. The first Huckleberry Hound cartoons were also very limited.

[@TaylorZanderFrancis]

​@@Themrock21 I'm not knocking their efforts or anything, don't get me wrong. I'm just stunned that, with so many animators, Ex Disney or no, that it just looked as awkward as it did. There's no sense of timing, the dialogue, though well performed, is kinda poor, and the lack of even stock music feels off. The reanimated version, though abstract in places, really gives it life

[@Themrock21]

@@TaylorZanderFrancis Don't worry. I just give blunt answers. They were frustrated and practical and said, no effort for nearly no money. + they had deadline less than a week for one episode. It was tight on all fronts.

[@TaylorZanderFrancis]

​@@Themrock21Yeah I kinda keep forgetting that TV animation was a VERY different animal. Little money, little time, but not necessarily little effort. I gotto remember that

[@sweets_Cat88]

This is a odd thing I noticed but Bluto/Bruno he kinda sounds like Tony jay.

[@gluttonousmaximus9048]

Always love the shots where they added the Jeep for no reason at all

[@Banjoisawesome]

Sweet Pea and Wimpy left because they knew Popeye ate spinach

[@centraloj8664]

Eu me pergunto de onde saiu essa ideia de reanimar um curta tão específico do Popeye, ficou perfeito 🤩

[@moarmosspatoproductions1475]

2:07 "No yummy for you, dummy!"

[@ma3mc3mu-X]

Why was this episode the candidate?

[@Themrock21]

Because it was the very first TV produced episode. The pilot.

[@SupaaGrover]

That was freakin COOL man. Great job 👏🏽👏🏽👍🏽👍🏽.

[@damienchance2622]

@2:24 is that a Pikachu??????

[@NFGGisCoolXD]

It's Wimpy!

[@timbomb374]

4:00 me every day of my life

[@dunlopgreenwood2642]

I rather 🗳 for a original version of Popeye

[@chrisrj9871]

1960 was not a kind time to the theatrical cartoon stars...

[@otaking3582]

The editing and composition in the original really sucked, which I'm not even sure how that's possible in animation.

[@Tabascofanatikerin]

Very small budget

[@otaking3582]

@@Tabascofanatikerin Even the cheapest cartoons out there wouldn't call attention to their cheapness by having audio seem like they were from something else.

[@SonicXtreme99akaCreeperMario]

How come you say that?

[@PScoopYT]

It was the 60s TV production. CHEAP is the norm, not an exception. Heck, you could find *worse* in the same timeframe.

[@louhepton]

@@otaking3582 This was the first completed, and was handled as the pilot film, made to sell the idea. They may not have handled it as an "official" episode, music and all.

[@Mirko-bi1lv]

3:30

[@7thheaven496]

There both uniquely great.

[@mikechicago6200]

I love a BBQ and i liked the corn and even cooked veggies!

[@Shadoan18]

... Popeye ought to get his butt kicked; Stealing a neighbors plants.

[@SifGreyfang]

I always thought it was insulting with how cheaply made the original version was made. It was so stiff and unlively

[@darrenjob8562]

The popeye boys are better in the original than the reanimated , as well as other things.

[@redddrago5198]

Is the first time i hear Popeye talking in English Does he has a Scottish accent?

[@josiahpurtee1156]

No, he has a New York/Brooklyn accent

[@hanschristianbrando5588]

The difference between a labor of love and a perfunctory low-budget rush job for a less sophisticated audience.

[@pawloto]

Ok, thay was ptetty awesome :)

[@coledakers6127]

This is gonna get more views than the original

[@dobmaster4412]

Lol the original feels bland while reanimated feels like it’s giving more detailed

[@Mirko-bi1lv]

I love when Olive pokes holes in her sock and her toes are green

[@Mirko-bi1lv]

Also, more of her foot is shown

[@ΚλασικάΚινούμεναΣχέδια-ψ5δ]

I can't say that I like the result. It just doesn't fit to the classic Popeye. I don't like the TV-series of the 60s, so it isn't a problem for me to watch an effort to improve it, but all these reactions are exaggerated and several cells doesn't match to the classic appearance of the characters. If someone wants to improve it, he should begin with a research at the theatrical shorts of the hero, especially before 1950.

[@thetribeoffive5675]

C 1982 king features syndicated inc all right reserved

[@gemstonegynoid7475]

this mustve been from one of the lesser popeye years, the original animation is not as lively as usual. i do appreciate popeye shoving the burgers into wimpy's mouth is actually part of the original. and the rather good gag of the final punch really knocking the earth over, causing olive to slide. i thought those were reanimated gags.

[@DBWalks2010]

👍👍👍👍🤩🤩

[@Nelson_Win]

The 50s one is the worst era. It was Gene Deitch who butchered everything as well as Tom and Jerry.

[@JaxRetroGamer]

Please no hate on Gene Deitch he done better stuff.

[@KutayCoskun]

Sooo good!

[@F1492]

Original always The origina , never mind , kkk

[@WilliamT1964]

Can't do it. I couldn't even make it to the 1:30 mark. I love BBQF2 too much to see this done to it.

[@Sahilprakash1999]

5:20 Popeye: junior

[@deshawnwilliams3358]

*Junior?! Don't call me a sissy name like that! My name is... (roaring)*

[@Sahilprakash1999]

@@deshawnwilliams3358 👊

[@sboinkthelegday3892]

If this was done with Felix the Cat, I wonder what it would take to tone down the Sonic references.

[@VJFranzK]

right, the 60's series must have influenced it, and dexters lab

[@GalenNight]

3:35-3:42

[@Stan_man]

Original looks better. More consistent.

[@mlgodzilla4206]

Consistently mediocre and stilted

[@realkekz]

I end up sort of disliking a lot of reanimated projects because they will do something incredibly out of left field that just ruins it for me. I don't want to see a 13 year old's popsicle stick puppets or some bizarre absurdist cgi that has nothing to do with the original art. To me, a reanimation should be just that, a reanimation, it should give the art new life, but still keeping its spirit in tact. I think you guys have done an amazing job with this one, you've revitalized a cartoon that was very probably slapped together by overworked animators in a failing company, but kept their vision in tact, and expanded upon it. This is a great example of what a reanimation project should be! Great job to everyone who took part in it!

[@EbenezerScroogeMcDuck]

Why aren't these people animating for TV? Who said network TV was dead? Why are we stuck with the garbage that's been playing on CN and Disney for the past 20+ years? There hasn't been a good show since 1999... with the exception of Buzz Lightyear in 2000. After that, all we've had for animated sustenance that isn't calarts cancer is Anime.

[@WytZox1]

* I never liked those 1960's Al Brodax Popeye cartoons. Never as good as earlier theatrical ones! 😉